Walidad 6492
Walidad 6492
Walidad 6492
User ID : 0000462920
Answer:
Introduction: The Kashmir issue has been a longstanding and contentious matter
between Pakistan and India since their partition in 1947. The dispute revolves
around the region of Jammu and Kashmir, and it has remained a focal point in
their bilateral relations. This comprehensive analysis delves into the mutual
relations between Pakistan and India with a focus on the Kashmir issue, exploring
historical context, Pakistan's perspective, recent developments, and the potential
for resolution.
1. Historical Context and Root of the Issue:
A. Partition and Accession:
Partition Legacy: The partition of British India led to the creation of India
and Pakistan in 1947. The princely state of Jammu and Kashmir was given
the choice to accede to either country or remain independent.
Kashmir's Accession: Kashmir's Maharaja Hari Singh chose to accede to
India, leading to the first India-Pakistan war in 1947-48.
B. Unresolved Status:
UN Resolution: The UN passed resolutions calling for a plebiscite to
determine the region's future. Both Pakistan and India agreed to this
proposal, but the plebiscite was never conducted.
2. Pakistan's Perspective on the Kashmir Issue:
A. Right to Self-Determination:
Kashmiri Aspirations: Pakistan supports the right to self-determination for
the people of Kashmir, allowing them to decide their political future.
UN Resolutions: Pakistan maintains that the UN resolutions on Kashmir
remain valid and should be implemented to resolve the dispute.
B. Human Rights Concerns:
Human Rights Violations: Pakistan consistently highlights alleged human
rights abuses in Indian-administered Kashmir, including excessive use of
force and curbs on freedom of expression.
3. Recent Developments and Escalation:
A. Pulwama Attack and Balakot Incident:
Pulwama Attack: In 2019, a suicide bombing in Indian-administered
Kashmir led to a spike in tensions between Pakistan and India.
Balakot Airstrikes: India conducted airstrikes in Pakistan's Balakot region,
leading to further escalation and military clashes.
B. Abrogation of Article 370:
Article 370: In 2019, India abrogated Article 370 of its constitution, which
granted special autonomous status to Jammu and Kashmir.
Pakistan's Reaction: Pakistan strongly condemned the move, considering it
a violation of UN resolutions and a breach of the region's historical status.
4. Potential for Resolution and International Intervention:
A. Diplomatic Dialogue:
Resumption of Dialogue: Pakistan consistently advocates for resuming
diplomatic dialogue to resolve the Kashmir issue through peaceful means.
Track II Diplomacy: Track II dialogues involving scholars and experts from
both countries have explored potential solutions.
B. International Involvement:
Third-Party Mediation: Pakistan has at times suggested third-party
mediation, believing it could help facilitate a neutral and unbiased solution.
5. Conclusion:
The Kashmir issue remains a complex and sensitive matter in Pakistan-India
relations. From Pakistan's perspective, it symbolizes the right to self-
determination for the people of Kashmir and raises concerns about human rights
violations. The historical context, UN resolutions, and recent developments
underscore the depth of the issue. While tensions have escalated at times,
diplomatic dialogue and international intervention hold the potential to pave the
way for a peaceful resolution. Both Pakistan and India must recognize the
importance of addressing the Kashmir issue to foster stability, enhance regional
cooperation, and promote lasting peace in the subcontinent.
Q.5 Discuss the reasons of cold relations between Pakistan and USSR
since 1947 to 1971.
Answer:
Introduction: The relationship between Pakistan and the Soviet Union (USSR)
during the formative years of both nations was marked by complexities and
fluctuations. Pakistan's perspective on the bilateral dynamics underscores several
key factors that contributed to cold relations between the two countries from
1947 to 1971. This comprehensive analysis explores these factors, delves into
Pakistan's narrative, examines historical events, and considers the implications for
bilateral relations.
**1. Divergent Ideological and Strategic Interests:
A. Ideological Alignment:
Cold War Ideological Divide: The ideological rivalry between capitalism
(USSR) and democracy (Pakistan) during the Cold War era inherently
created a divide between the two nations.
Pakistani Alignment: Pakistan's alignment with the Western bloc under the
SEATO and CENTO alliances further distanced it from the Soviet sphere of
influence.
B. Strategic Considerations:
Geopolitical Alignments: The USSR's close relationship with India due to
their shared non-aligned status and economic cooperation led to suspicions
in Pakistan.
Pakistani Alliances: Pakistan's alliances with the United States and its role
in regional security dynamics, particularly during the Afghan conflict,
heightened tensions with the USSR.
**2. Kashmir Conflict and Alignment with India:
A. Kashmir Dispute:
Soviet Support for India: The USSR consistently supported India's stance on
the Kashmir issue, considering it a territorial dispute.
Pakistan's Perspective: Pakistan viewed the Soviet support for India as a
diplomatic challenge and a factor contributing to strained relations.
B. Non-Aligned Movement (NAM):
Soviet-Indian NAM Alignment: The USSR's alignment with India in the Non-
Aligned Movement raised concerns in Pakistan about the neutrality of the
NAM platform.
Pakistani Expectations: Pakistan hoped for more balanced Soviet policies
within NAM and stronger support for its own territorial claims.
**3. Afghan Conflict and Regional Dynamics:
A. Afghan Conflict:
Soviet-Afghan Relationship: The Soviet intervention in Afghanistan in the
1980s further strained Pakistan-USSR relations.
Pakistani Involvement: Pakistan's role in supporting Afghan resistance
groups aligned with the US exacerbated tensions with the USSR.
B. Regional Instability:
Proxy Conflict: The Afghan conflict created a proxy battleground where
Pakistan and the USSR supported opposing sides, leading to a deepening of
the rift.
Impact on Relations: The conflict reinforced the divergence of interests and
priorities between Pakistan and the USSR.
**4. Conclusion:
Cold relations between Pakistan and the USSR from 1947 to 1971 were driven by
a complex interplay of ideological differences, strategic considerations, and
regional dynamics. Pakistan's narrative emphasizes the challenges posed by the
ideological divide, the Kashmir conflict, and the evolving regional landscape. The
alignment of the USSR with India, combined with Pakistan's alliances with
Western powers and involvement in regional conflicts, contributed to the cold
nature of the relationship. While the geopolitical dynamics of the Cold War era
played a significant role, the complexities of these early years laid the groundwork
for subsequent diplomatic realignments and changing priorities in the region