Valuation of Shares
Valuation of Shares
Valuation of Shares
Intrinsic Value of each Equity Share computed afier making assumption regarding goodwill
The following particulars are available in relation to A Ltd. :
518
Equity Shares of ? 20 cach each
Capital : 5,000 Shares of ? 100
1. Equity Share 8% Prceference
Share Capitanl: 1,000, 730,000
2. Preference ?18,000
3. Reserves
4. Current Liabilities Z12,000
of Fixed Assets
$S.Loss on Revaluation ?30,000
6. Average
Trading Profits (afler tax) 10%
Employcd
Nomal Rate of Return on Capital IC.U. B.Com. (Hons.) Part-ll, 2005)
7. Equity Share.
Calculate Intrinsic Value per
Please note that illustrated.
the preceding problem
Apparently this problem is similar in all respects to
1.
in both the problems. In the preceding problem such profits are
2. The average trading profits are given value has
out the Eaming Capacity Value of Shares. Here, only computation of intrinsic
utilised to find this problem.
average profits seems to be useless in
been asked for. So, the mention of
Super Profits and goodwill.
3. Such profits may also be used to find outline.
that
The following solution is being made on
Solution :
Computation of Intrinsic Value of each Equity Share of A Ltd.
Amount Amount
Particulars
4,500
2. Calculation of value of each Equity Share on Dividend Yield Basis
Particulars Amount
1e x*10=1222
9%
VALUATION OF SHARES 521
Illustration 7.
Valuation on Price-Earning Ratio basis
The Capital structure of a company is as follows :
5,00,000
12% Preference Shares of 10 each
Equity Shares of 100 each 9,00,000
3,50,000
Reserves & Surplus
10% Debentures 6,50,000
13% Term Loan 12,00,000
The average annual profit of the company before payment of interest and income-tax is 7.22.000.
The income-taX rate is 34%.
Calculate the value of Equity Share of the Company assuming that the Price-Earnings Ratio is 12.
IC.U. B.Com. (Hons.) Part-II, 2003/
Solution:
Valuation of Equity Shares of .. Co. Ltd.
Amount Amount
Particulars
4,72,500 4.72,500
The debenture interest is outstanding for 6 months and Preference Dividend is due for I year ano
none of these have been provided for. Depreciation Fund has been excess created to the tune of ? 1,0
Out of Book Debts 3,750 should be considered unrealisable. A claim for compensation to an employe
has been admitted at ? 1,875.
Calculate the intrinsic value of each equity share. /Bombay University, B. Com. Modificdl
VALUATION OF SHARES
527
Solution:
1. Computation of Intrinsic Value of Equity Shares
Particulars Amount Amount
Total Assets :
Fixed Assets at Cost
1,50,000
Investments (Revalued at Market Value) 84,000
Stock 1,35,000
Sundry Detbtors (90,000 - 3,750) 86,250
Cash at Bank 7,500 4,62,750
Less: Depreciation Fund (30,000- 7,500] 22,500
4,40,250
Less: Liabilities :
(a) External Sundry Creditors 60,000
Debentures 37,500
Intereest Outstanding on Debentures
6
for months 6% of 37,400 x 12 1,125
Empolyees' Providend Fund 18,750
Workmen's Savings Fund 30,000
Compensation to workman [actual amount payable] 1,875 1,49,250
Net Assets 2,91,000
Less: (b) Other Owners Preference Share Capital 37,500
Arrear Preference Dividend @8% [Payable on Liquidation) 3,000 40,500
Net Assets available for Equity Shareholders 2,50,500
Net Assets available for Equity Shareholders
. Intrinsic Value of Each Equity Share No. of Equity Shares
2,50,500 -716.70
15,000
Note: Students are expected to note which assets have been included and which liabilities have not been
deducted for the valuation. They should also note the values considered or ignored.
Illustration 12.
Only yield value- weights imputed considering trend of profits valuations for Minority &
Majority Shareholding
Following information is furnished in respect of Sahana Fibres Ltd.
1. Share Capital : 2,00,000 Equity Shares of 10 each fully paid.
2. Profits after tax, dividends decleared and retained earnings
Year Profits after Tax Dividends Declared Retained Earnings
1996 7,10,000 3,40,000 3,70,000
1995 6,00,000 3,00,000 3,00,000
1994 4,00,000 2,60,000 1,40,000
3. Normal rate of return expected by shareholders in the market is 12%.
4. The normal earnings of similar companies in the fibre industry is 15%.
You are required to calculate the value of shares if (a) Only a few shares are to be sold and
(b) Majority Shares are to sold. |.CWA. (Final))/
528 CORPORATE ACCOUNTINC
Point to be noted:
the valuation under yield basis is based
1. Whenre only a few shares are to be transferred or sold, on
dividend declared /paid in lieu of expected rate of dividend. aclual
For majority shareholders, the expected rate of dividend is considered. Students should remember he
such demarcation is not made under Asset Backing Method.
2. Here the profits exhibit a constant increasing trend. Weights may be assigned giving maximum
to 1996 when the profits are maximum. weightage
Solution:
1. Valuation for Minority Shareholders
Dividends Declared
(a) Calculation of Rates of Dividends Declared = Paid up share capital 100
(b) Expected Rate of Equity Dividend Weighted Average Profits for Equity Shareholders x
-
31.08
15 720.72
Illustration 13.
Valuation of Fully paid and Partly paid shares
December, 2015 was as follows :
The Balance Sheet of A Ltd. as on 31st Note As at
Partieulars No.
Amount Amount
1. Share Capital
Subscribed & Fully Paid
(a) 9% Preference Shares of 100 each 1,00,000
(b) 30,000 Equity Shares of R 10 each 3,00,000 4,00,000
Subscribed but Partly Paid
(a) 40,000 Equity Shares of 10 each, 5 paid 2,00,000
6,00,000
2. Fixed Assets Tangible Assets
(a) Buildings 2,00,000
(b) Plant and Machinery 4,00,000
6,00,000
Profits and dividends in last several years were as under:
Year Profits Equity Dividend
?.
2012 4 3,20,000 18%
2013 2,50,000 15%
2014 2,20,000 12%
530 CORPORATE ACcoUNTING
4,00,000. Managerial remuneration is ikely to go up by20 000 Per
Land and Buildings are worth in the same induste
annum. Income Tax may be provided at 50%. Equity Shares o1 companies
dividend rate of 109% are quoted at par.
that :
Find the most appropriate value of acquity share assuming
I Controlling interest is to be transferred.
2. Only a few shares are to be transferred.
lgnore goodwill value, depreciation adjustment for revaluation and need of transfer to Gens.
Reserve
ICA. (Final)j
Solution :
1. Valuation of Shares under Asset Backing Method
Particulars Amount
Amount
Sundry Assets (as per Books) 11,00,000
Add Increase in value of Land &Buildings [4,00,000 - 2,00,000) 2,00,000
Add Notional Calls on Partly paid shares (40,000 Sh. x ?5 each) 2,00,000
Less: Sundry Creditors 15,00,000
2,00,000
9% Preference Share Capital 1,00,000
Net Assets available for Equity Shareholders 3,00,000
(If all the Equity Shares are fully paid) 12,00,000
No. of Fully Paid Shares (30,000 + 40,000 (after Notional Calls)] = 70,000
.. Intrinsic Value of each fully paid share Net Assets available 12,00,000
No. of Shares
-
=17.14
70,000
And same value of a partly paid share =17.14 Call assumed per share ? 5=
Whether a few shares (mínority) are transferred or 12.14
the intrinsic values would be the same. controlling interest (majority shareholding) is transferred,
2. Valuation of Shares by Capitalisation of Profits
(a) If Controlling interest is to be transferred
() Calculation of Average Maintainable Profits (using weights as
theprofits show a constant increasing trend):
Year Profits
Weights Weighted Profits
2012 3,20,000
2913 2,50,000 9,60,000
2
2014 2,20,000 5,00,000
2,20,000
6
16,80,000
Particulars Amount
=[15%
,X*5=?7.50
and the same value of each partly paid share
Illustration 14.
denominations
Valuation of fully paid shares of different following balances as on 31.03.2016 :
contained the
The Balance Sheet of La La Ltd. Note As at 31.3.16
Particulars
No.
LIABILITIES
I. EQUITY AND
1. Shareholders' Funds 1 4,12,500
(a) Share Capital 2 92,500
(b) Reserves & Surplus
2. Current Liabilities 50,000
(a) Trade Payables Creditors 5,55,000
Total
II. ASSETS
1. Non-Current Assets
4,00,000
(a) Fixed Assets
1,55,000
2. Current Assets
Total S,55,000
Notes to Accounts :
Amount Amount
I. Share Capital
Subscribed & Fully Paid
(a) 25,000 Equity Shares of 10 each 2,50,000
(b) 15,000 Equity Shares of 7.50 each 1,12,500
50,000 4,12,500
(c) 10,000 Equity Shares of 5 each
2. Reserves and Surplus
(a) Balance in Statement of Profit and Loss Account 97,500
($,000) 92,500
(b) Less : Preliminary Expenses
532 CoRPORATE AccouNTINE
The avverage profits for the tax or reserve) amounted.
last three years (before transfer for
? 1,50,000, 40% and T0% respectively. Fair
Transfer to Reserve may be assumed at
Income Tax andbreak-u) value and vield value of cach kind of Snare.
S T0%, Find out the
Solution :
1. Calculatlon of Break-up Value
Particulars Amount
Fixed Assets 4,1,55,000
00,000
Current Assets
5,550,000
5,000
Less : Extemal Liabilities Shareholders
Net Assets avallable for Equity 5,05,000
Paid-up Equity Share Capital 2,50,000 + 1,12,500 +50,000 =4,12,500
R5,05,000
Net Assset Value per rupee of Paid-up Capital = 74,12,500 =1.23
.
.. Values of different shares are :
12.30
10paid share =10 x 1.23
R7.50 paid share = 77.50 x 1.23 =9.23
= 75 x 1.23 =6.15
75 paid share
2. Calculation of Yield Values
Particulars Amount
81,000
.. Expected Rate of Dividend = Profit Available for Dividends 4,12,500
100 = 19.64%
Paid up Equity Share Capital
.:. The values are :
I 10.000Equity Shares of? 10 ench, fully paid,S,000 Equity Shares of 10 ench, 7paid-up.
) Preference Share Capital: 1,000, 10% Preference Shares of? 100 cach fully paid-up.
3. Reserves 45,000.
4, Creditors 20,000, Bills Payable R 3,000.
further
Besides the above extracts from the Balance Sheet of Titco Ltd. as on 31.12.99, the following
infomation are given to you
to be reduced by 7,000.
L Valuc of fixed asscts to be raiscd by 25,000 whercas stock value is
the books of account.
2, Liability for expenses 6,000 is yet to be recorded in
Titco Ltd.
Calculate value per equity and preference share of
participating and ratio of
When (A) Preterence Shares are non-participating: (B) Preference Shares are
preference is 3 : 2.
participatian in surplus assets between equity and JC.U. B. Com. (Hons.))
Workings Notes :
Rough Balance Sheet of Titco Ltd. as on 31.12.99
Amount Amount
Liabilities Assets
Solution :
1. Valuation of Shares of Titco Ltd.
Amount Amount
Particulars
34,200
Equity Shareholders s700 22,800
Preference Shareholders (Paricipating) o1 57,000| 57,000
=?1,69,200
Equity Capital Employed =?1,35,000 +34,200
1,22,800
Preference Capital Employed =?1,00,000 + 22,800 = Capital Employed
Pald-up Capital
For Equity Shares
1,69,200
1,35,000
10
1,69,200
135, 000 <*10-*1259
1,69,200 x7=877
7 1,35,000
1,35,000 1,92,000
[1,92,000
10 L1,35,000 x*10=*142
7 1,92,000 x*7=996
1,35,000
For Preference Shares the value should be ? 100 each as such shares cannot share any surplus asS
535
VALUATION OF SHARES
denominations
the above illustration, the equity shares have been valued as if they are of different
Note : In based on
to the reason that the valuations have been
Notional Calls have not been added. This is mainly due
which might give a different picture it all the shares were fully paid.
surplus of assets
cosidering notional calls, the valuations may also be shown as follows :
However,
For Equity Shares
participating shares
A. I Preference Shares are
Shares 1,69,200
Net Assets available for Equity 15,000
equity shares (5000 x?3]
Add : Notional calls on partly paid 1,84,200
1,84,200 12.28
Value of each fully paid share = 15,000
12.28 - 3 = 9.28
Value of each partly paid share =
non-participating shares
B. I Preference Shares are
Shares 1,92,000
Net Assets available for Equity 15,000
Add: Notional calls
2,07,000
72,07,200 x 13.80
Value of each fully paid share = 15,000
13.80 73 = 10.80
Value of each patly paid share = same in each case as already shown, because
these
of each Proference Share would remain the
The value
shares are fully paid.
Illustration 16.
participating shares
Valuation of shares where Preference Shares are 10 each
20,000, 6% Participating Preference Shares of ?
The Share Capital of a company consists of shares are issued and fully paid.
and 30,000 Equity Shares of 10 each. AIl these
participate in a share of the profits to the extent of a
The Preference Shareholders enjoy the right to Equity Shareholders. Any further excess, if left,
further 6% after payment of a dividend of 12% to the
should go to the equity shareholders. 1,00,000. The rates of normal return
is
The normal average profit (after tax) of the company
nominal value of Equity Shares and 99% on
applicable to this type of company is 12% on the classes of shares.
the
participating Preference Shares. Find out the value of each of
Solution :
1. Distrilbution of Profits
Total Pref. Sh. holdersEquity Sh. holders
Amount Amount
1. Share Capital
Subscribed & Fully Paid
(a) 6,000 Equity Shares of 100 each
(b) 10% Preference Shares of ? 100
each 6,00,000
60,000 6,60,000
Amount Amount