Prof Ethics Journal 08-Feb-2022 11-40
Prof Ethics Journal 08-Feb-2022 11-40
Prof Ethics Journal 08-Feb-2022 11-40
B ESSAY
CEsscuy ms
on N elPauolesipuak ELLies ound Duies o
pudies
Adsscotes siticae lauss.
Puukicieud usaials incGLpoctes a msa Csdo
OVesseeiino the disoct peple ocupied
uait act jt Jospe aolaau
Cupied Lausu d indiuiduaJa
us looal pauaesioh Jhawea oaAQLnstt
dleliqatian ko ttaicoLt ound dtoisaods
9quiky Jand sAuninis icodis
o stica Tui olollaadian ipeoley
aaingoleiaatuoM Aaauticulaou condutiu
uolsuatthauewit
ololigatans Leqal
e coudesntiou o
paacticmesactuo sould
maintain Jusuestt qiuo apaLapaiade Lhalp
cOL ond aduanco puualic tust
intg CUeualsA Jauos
ut uai dutieg
peccd do dacliluitt
pusesio uaitt Couge cuno
inteouitu hduocode asido us (oeiua
2peds, cu ükausR ticials e auat
iupeAsttve ol i tt
odiwauittadtan A
cAdi nae tu
aeAeLLn i pisaAsimal
H dhi e taod H4 Le
o HA CGuH.cliad, giotoppaluas_ aud
gttha addsocadt Rulas0 puss) al
standods aod o Oducode haodsto maudaia
YAee
towaod
H COuDd He lshe hoLsto kaap in wiud
diqi Ha
and dspeotHouoads
ound e udicial
5
Tuaduocadu suadd hotbact on looal
Alea Mduwich he ho3 Ouhcda
indeuost He
udwko 9n ehalk
Copanui i iuolidnhe u a olusuictas
9) Tue oduccatt suuddwetteud as auty
Ai ciaud, (0 cetiy t soLuduass
atLa tat Lgeliaud àq uLag ka u
d galpius.coooluuag
Twe
Staei Bo COuncil,akeoadHob Hu
a
Hppeot hoeAain has ild dh2 pus Oppeal
appeal
sesleiuq LuLVeLLe tt udau aed l
Bao Couuncil ldio an d e Raspodaudt
e Diuciplinasup UQWuttee ot Poo Council Lold
Counil L
lssuos
D setnas p.3LOAecukd pdoAkitiauasus auue
quilky
pauskeional ww.conduc 1
9
2 Esa n 0tuupt oCoutin dia
Codenupt Cut a qoictu
desciptiue eduel wdacttaA do paticuda
pBceRdungsin a ud oJauw uolich ends to
wwolssuine dtad skenn to unhibit dtgns
aLagtaasehvas o it ko thL settunand o taiu
diupukts
Tui tsum adenupt o Ld can l Wasil wndsutad
a aA
duuApetkul disolaedi onct ound
cousd oJau ualicla w Hhod
olac t CLd da 4 disuespect dhe legal
buudheities Than he dg as tthe wuiahd to Upoje
Sancto ucd as M 0 con ARnd eCndeng
do ail CRSlLaun pessd
i Js i aLd
qi Cadepi Csud
Tuistum n alD wndastocol n kums o t
uLLdoo oiwik He judi cial pauocendinq. ds wa
kuswlhat a judae Un LOuds can gaue udi cial
udicial
puocendunoys ualaica houe
oCdauin Jiwut in uúeh
i4 hau HAAadsGm to Maka CUAA
an athia adhCle,
udicial pvacaedin
0 stapsit i
lu wmakina
makiina
L judicoal pvacoodiug uo u o ecessltq-
ca onud o uteupt
hdiolhdio, Haa CoMcapi nde.uupt o cuat i oai uad
in ecian 2(oa) o ta odempt
ix oala
uais Ht ,1411
11us suich ch
has lcod.lyuoo tapes C
0A nuual uadept
ulempt
2 Aetc 129 i
Aedticlo129129says od He Swwpaawma Cad shall
loeHa Cood Rocod ad i4lau allHe p ouoQy
uc couds induudi uate pouQe epu a
Codcnupt ite i a
IheCound dRa.coudwmas acOL housi uq l
oc and uecoodi ugs uuaoiyiced O Gvelosti iuo
VWARALDRLLi
uot avu aluch hou wo0nd avd
as idanct au T tuutt o4 h Jwocauols
Como oe qussitoud and alo Hese .cods aue
kueakeol aus a iqln auttugui Audl cuuutai a staed
opaiuat Hhokutt o Haase scudscuupois ed
L Codeupto ouu
Atice142(2)
Tus 0icla i also tales culsout Cieuupt Couu
Ihi Biclokaus ha ualon Law i wad la
Hha Paauaad CO
the pLDaisÍ A me uti ood in olouel
o aaticls, SupreeCod Las al e
pauo@ o maka an daa tas secuug au pesohA
adendanto paductie u digcua ioLos te
poseu Ho a ive ws h ut toanua 0L H
COneuupt
Tuisalse oluaes AO Mao Ott Suplane
CQuOAtCaun dug autu na againstt ugds puoual
CiilConHeupt
Seoin2La) o DCoudeMustieCousat ct, 1971
19
state Ci1sal
Cudeiu Cu usilkul disalseoliance to Ha
GAAdololcd duton, judquut
wun
aaCousd cAupausC c8AUilLully pac
ndautakiug Opezon qu toaCOatt
CinccilCotAAPt apA0Lu08..apad-qial HA
A li ch ae da as
aLAnce3 tia pa/oue actuo lw ttuasL
2
apeSOALuguo Outied et+ Uauat
o-he CQLat udo Huisuosua anually
doue tetis pousM. a
Dejehceso Cul udeupdt
Guil Cottpt
couse can bko tua toLsusi uadasce
Lack a kLsdadoRat odin
poon can uat l uald ialsls A CLutuup fE
Co dlse uat kuaw ts uola qius
ue udsut u clou uuusto l mawcA
o ddu Tusos isdudt iuoluua u
ucces ul pdayl the cousHAat uda
Hoat Aspcuys ed n suld l AVod to tua
lsdisidual u
epostG pOsauaiy
tus h t ctiHedicopy t caun g
scce8u pllada d
J
Ha caadiied opy t csud was ust
wol sAAvao fewwM
Tua dJs ouediuco gaLAe lasoal dus
sauld0 ln 4 H Guds pasod ( H
COA aAuliquoug
U wst pec He 198ACSpleia Hsd tal a
pusOA ceA tttg dakeuc a udtuupt i
Ae sas 0attiq aqaidsHask cds
3
idepLodedticS
CeLOu and ue udoo
fhau uoaoAolole oud Joli oa
ale indeepvotertin
ondttue uag paLrdaut adlopls tsLe
tAdepatedi cuu oLLd stks in oc8dlouhc
ECanknptto
2Uausle
C0At
acriwinal Contept
dccudiua toSecion 2) o HeCode npl
CouC Act 81, CouuiualCukeupt au
i)t
Dakad
pulelicatian o O waeo uDORdg,Apoks
00 UauHe 0u esstuQ 0 qus u
lu
uGlid iueluudos
a) scudalia o cudls t &CaMeldiluise louoel
OLDOL
CO
Biosness (eews endg to luteu Hag t
ueduuecou sCu tpo
uolicial
pocegouUgs
c) lsdeuues o
teds ooloyttu juteuALL
sC eLAD to ueoOLuR DlHa e
o odwi uis teioutt
u2ico in auy uotteu a
Punisuwad tpn Cateupt oCouset
Secti on 12 tte Lote.wot qLoud Ak, 1a1
daals uaittHLaa puwishiudd La Coudept oCotA
High eudound Haa Supuem Cou hawe i von
odiied at theCotehpt
l wlw
cha
nauoe nad it suostaidi allu iwteu S Hend t
Suesteniallyiudesuuuite e duo uG siua
cluwme Cb)
etion otuisHetActseutes Haod He
13
couetma ouethe doence te'uicoH n d
ds tthod theOt dou in ta
uGU G ideuest_ and ei Juaquast s4 uai uq hat
cdaenc@ úGea ds
Case a kCeuteupt o CD
t
Nowe C R Dapldeauu V
O. P.Gupta, HR 1911SC1182
Ctatim 131 AIR 132 1911 5CR 16
Petithan C.k.Daphdteu alnd s
RaspCvdad-0. P upta aa
and
Bench Sikoi S.M. CGJ,Shalat
C.A GAVOVeLAN J. M,Vaidyialiuga
Rou, A.N
Case
Tue
Aspandand Co. P. Giupta) pulaliskao and
ciuculated a GookAkin plalid pusposding
a0 9-ia y DJuti coshan Lglule
addislus
octigi us
jud icdo Lpae tyH C baphdoL
alugug tthsa Jada pettion allaqina at
looklot lhasa2acanoouned the iudquiiudlus
powdicipaded n
he dacisi and loLCLLAlt iute
e laund and Hus uweakanad ha ciclavne
penplein iH A LA
uouelta e ad dsa
q
ousumdg to codept Cous
2 hetoe he dsuQ tojudgtipeukaly
doeohepulaic!
2-001 liaala i
JudgewMQnd aiven g. augd i
hesCIspe
couknpt o
Couad oid doon ttad {heeat 1n eadh
cae iAualueRGeLha lmpuanad puelicddi s a masL
dakawdtlouuadase nH jLdak os4alotaa t ilk
G H
iveoiusit tuo dua caoL judic
pApo odiwsegkon
s uJk i ald as P,
nd
Gtupla. deSpodnd
seudecod
is
ouil Cewtcouo toSmde
Case Comnds besed a Medul 7 nt
A NIJAY SINGIHV.MURARILAL
18
Rule 1O Clhapte T Poat 6 te Ruos ouad
ge Bo Cpanc ludia oa eessiuval
ucodue tpausuioos uo d ad 190cokekaall uat
Ketoandósuu0Coutiuytuessuduess o
a Ay40 Lwig ouen JA0quoo.d Puspobs
lageul peioceeoli wos iiai
ssu
aiea susp.esionlt uostit uke civoupriwo
toaet ud utice.
iDecisiono Bao -
Coundl ldta
dppellot Adocadeuas uspendaa 0et
lsy Hha Dücipivaouui Toilouadott Ba Counc
ia cnu eyLend in oiclation tat lis, te
ha hadcOchtiedthe sclsanoyo
oailglaleoncin uslich t
uuetu na
accugedsas is
dieutThe appollote lacdu disuiuseduisappeal
Decision al Supue Cout
Held -0 sectiain35o dtu Adancactes Act pesnà
Juepimand paogidadtaa nds opuualuc utics d
wat leiy ts Janiencu edinasilu isiCouut dog
iwa iveonuoA t apuoiswmant inuposed the
bigcipuva Tuulbunal ept usl sttusua
cia mstamces inuoluus pLundipu cuepekad
CMSUu hau otleRA daescntvalue Gu Ag
ROA9AOMd ARHA0 in e pAG8i Gn in &auL Htatan
Haln uspeusla aALOLAta uaM Loeäia
pAat
pgedrcas ousye usols ysun
Mco Lsasnati Aainled uit HupitudILdHa
avd dis
Oud ced to pve cood vatcledtthe wnouhe
disw ced asoussut
cLiusous om i ihcaptian to is iih
15suos
uOLho dos Aeslau Coud Petitit-
pelt pOcood
ond
Lsm doto-dauy haa
L p ope coaAa.ct and
ds o usdu
O uo du icakisla.
picakisu
Decisio o High sst
sdaaieuea l
PekitisA sas
a cdao oSelsaCusd
iled in t Delli Hi CodThe
DeuhiHial Couddisnu8 te peltiaunuauia o
dloai, t e petitha and aonba diHn Ho
iecaad us
do edau
Deisian e Supua Couad
dapil he daisioi o Delli High cousd t
special lcoue o appeal led in HeSuupaisma
Loust foaiAdicodtran o udoo tae uial couat
lgtu daluH ab diucti o tad uial suaulol
ota
coeducldauyto- da Sup.auume CoLait ald
Hhad it wosk anpediond aat iad loisua t
Cou _a o OgI On ould puueaned aud l daalt
uHn cAndiuusl U iK inceptn to i uiah
Not oduyuau 14 Ault in peditH c it
odsouuudt in Hialiuuatí uno iuievvve a
pusosacuic asnd te ce
dal od theuiu pro.saed
u dlaydo-da g @cassa to saAalise
Hua Sessioucaes usiMed ue ttied piecainna.al
Bekao uouununei gaHiol, Aesio a iuka ust
eduy unnsel AAod allncoaL Oioleuc
oNailaale At
Co Luut oulu a
uthmaHaa
postpiaua
ucskpassilla
sq
nd o rdusadetipoilla pasicd. Ona ave
ual cGnran cas
s haguld oLcopt LO
23
Ovn ooauSLAAAALt
PaLss A JAQasa uslkich akes
ueuitedalo quuocaad duoue ivn tusa wwi He tuictl
cOidudad
Supua Couott. unalale e appuuaci oleitu diLt
expeüonud lo to petitiaOu,
kced uokhig adisped 4indunaiit dikicult
atend e CouGd Lst da to-day H H du
eu adaOcale ualuo aceaptstsoalu al iu
to- da
crinuual Case teo atend Hatial uidauy
Supawail Coiuod Lald thod caiustoicALAtuay
Hedudt dAdioocosedaited toita eieul
i dou4o-da Hai a 0ceped Hhe
he ualll' i couu t al lasuaoek iio psuia
du wso a
to adtund uaCu uua
uiieUaue aus Pot-ttsv i tuuoana diauuisseo
dainad
und a Aqu
e
codeupt
o in S. 2C6) Cndewpl Gsut
ele
Supue
in peAgAd 12a) d .
Causd ald that the paAsad coua2 AUauolp
Apnknce
aloe uould have a qj99 ley Ha iclea
Henca olas ed Oppeal eoneut thed sudenca
wpaiLaoMLuk powed u ia CSug G
ad ad jwrad ne appallouty au dnnd
o po ka 106o eaeh ln co odalsudtt 15
A coueupt ue
on etapkiouoi
Aa
eauna udendcdAnod
spaigaAe u
o Adhed d
sl3Ana uld ue iperd in ugal aoio toncey
i al
iwupoiscgand 1 ds Aod nds 1utice
L
BCHARAN AL SAHy VUNION OF INDIA
i
Noue chooasiLalsau. iga dndioa
Cteetotn 13g0 AR Jugo,1sg9 SCRSuel-a) 531
Ben HuklosAii Sapyasarlui (C), sIgla K.N. T),
Raunaaattou S
Awnadi AM (T $aikia
KN(3)i
Petti aisexCliauou loal Saluu
y toUul
oPIL
Te
peeat episigu
13 C) t Cc)e s
Coutikutioniupesg coste
uait
Juosomald uickh oi OMd coept
n
naM Puddic oougt u e
iudeat
ha tuteas
iqadi G
pulollieG
otoia u at
36
3. Repot itCoacciwe essiau oniropicsPupksiMa
EHicsQLdCoudehupt Louk Low'eld on 29 t
JanuOL 2.022bkPo ela aa
uha
-7 FuaLpoee iutestoctian
Tbaudameustalam lagaletaies neabeie
a SesiouuSas o uplsld teonou oligudeyote ap
splaaa ensulagtespunito uendluoopeat ion,
uukualaundaei.deali uo CoLAuel Luoitt clients t
to secuoa launeisJuosilorliliea in Hoiscet.
Jo
b Qloseeaoatious utoeuinatiam collocked u HaAtudeds -
Lawyeus acitakeuuftco Lawus at ous
uoluo help GLnalucuth jtusti ca
Laouts
Dciete
aue aseodalol oe clieudi jtudopts
sd itbns
Lawyeus' iunceimeashis iydoui
lnttpuuatation int coL y adDoe kuould
inajusk and ottuical anMs lli
n ad ia.acatusoudal avecOnanit Ho uikiclied t bat
w U einte coe Be.couus ca utic 1tse
veuu uileoun anda iq
haduoca cnwau onie sliould nt
xdtoad ohat Shhis cied
i Tudotsdeda ma nsdundtt nuouctspie.ce
lteuatcti.onqallptud
ekssiseal ltuies ya e diiwed os ateda
coAAduct
s wweuitte 0 OLULotug
loelaoLniaLDA
wis diet a paLaAkuiuna Laur Houosds i
hs adu2eRaL euoandodoaindd
teccustEtics
tesaudpaxactice bi ch olekeuutnnaans
lanal paualesai0d
th us
LGduckoMAalaaa o e
Mai oletet u opsokect
DLOAaJdain iandll ualotistdllgit apreku
lactwean u enh
Bendhaa
auuoyee
o e tha
H sa abat
ugugldtle.
lieve daoHei
Coda
attics3L g Hae
aad alsoue. Huqh etud
eoe ment to
shondoodsatA eco%au to ethica
t kacpaduuislerodiu
kacp
Jus iaipu12.kudusavdcods aduuwiseatin
Liuto wzitleinccdo
coAopuuolyesisial auscouxtalyua
ocsple guut atics
bceie eLDpst o Mokus o
DiHeioueus otplaaity louuo
alspquoub aud uts
oud eupaia
lat
a louis e ppGt
pou
o has to dopasd
ugdcoductdbaAohi uLS
tok im uis wa
LOLADLct Taua
adtcoiodd dudog uicl
puuoi Sn Ound Lmlaaus
dis uoced p.ARLRLdttd
ttARA
3
O
Puless0 Lell Juota oliscuwsed teduties
ada0ccde alich a0dhoided3calecunues a
4olleco4
a) Dutu sesands the dle
BouLnd to accopt lpeieks
2 Net usitlhdaaw kugw seoLGiLA
5Notappeos in matdeses uolhaLLeha wwsel & uits
ull disdosua to ciet
ound kak
Uphold inkuor d tha clieut
Net Not upres macaial oL eudancA
1) Nct
disde2 LOwuucai aus loetucco cu edk q msel
Should uot stu up insiqale ttgadian
4 suauld nt a on iueuctian ote than uat o dieid
1o) Ne aLpi utcnst in astioalalu cdainu
Not lidid O puucLage puopeuty aiuisidooaal
procaedaa
Not daR dependiua s
success o aseus
1 Nct odjustKas 0qaiust pes ounall ualüty
úaluty
kap puope arcusuuts
15 lvdiwod to cliaut amouLda
1e)Adiust as ko nnatiou oacanalias
Pup wida.copy oaccund
13)
Not lmd wgo owsdiants
a N appeo pposle pautes
20 shall wt edeo ldo acALOnounauts usaug la ds
in wis handsao 00LGMetcd oas
iuto Loans
should wisL GLtake aduantag Ha
CM idancouapod hkim ls clicut
33
Duku osoods Cusd
Act iv diuiled mauas
Respec Ht cougd
3)Ne_cOmuica.ke ln priale
4Raap to act in an iUsgal mOu Heugand3oppasetia
5) Rapug to 2presest dieg uu s
o uair mau
)ppea inprr.cp daaesLsda
Rekuu o
app.ea in kugud
latton
8)Net usea ands u
uGs in apulslic plaeg
3)
N
1o) Not
apsasant stalaisnans
o
o
uch he u a
ecuua uteas
ma
Cppeau watcas
Not tand os te 4 olue
34
dRaasgou
eGandusion
Puciekisol ctic can alsa l stoied as duses
Hat houe o jolloustd uyan aduccale dusii pvde
dn ddoncobe ud dos ugo usit sinity ad deait
als a uSduct said o have sialoded
d ei p Ais TA 0E
wovolduhesad veu
icsdeu lud
Ue pesnn in jeld ld is
35