The Empire's Influence On Barbarian Elites
The Empire's Influence On Barbarian Elites
The Empire's Influence On Barbarian Elites
MONOGRAPHIES 36
edited by
Paris – Beograd
2012
Published with a support of the
Ministry of Education and Science of Republic of Serbia
(Project n° 177021)
II. he Occident
Damien Glad
Vujadin Ivanišević and Michel Kazanski eds, The Pontic-Danubian Realm in the Period of the Great
Migration (Centre de recherche d’Histoire et Civilisation de Byzance, Monographies 36 / Arheološki
institut, Posebna izdanja, Knjiga 51), Paris-Beograd 2012.
350 DAMIEN GLAD
Fig. 1: Segmental helmet on a fresco from Kerch (Rostovtsef 1913-1914/2003, plate LXXIX).
earliest specimen dating from the 6th century B C was excavated in Sardis in western
Turkey, the capital of ancient Lydia (Fig. 2) (Greenewalt, Heywood 1992). he main
features of a segmental helmet are already present: a conical helmet-bowl reinforced by
riveted metal strips which come together under a circular plate riveted to the apex, and a
T-shaped nasal plate. Only an oblong neck-guard distinguishes this Lydian helmet from
its early Byzantine descendants. A segmental helmet appears on coins of the Parthian
king Arsaces I (238-211 B C) (Overlaet 1982, 191). From Parthia, it reaches the steppe
and the Kuban region where conical helmets, similar to those represented on Kerch
frescos and on Trajan’s Column, were discovered at Gorodskoj in privileged graves dating
from the 2nd century A D (Goroncharovski 2006, 446-450). he type of helmet worn
by Syrian archers on Trajan’s column and some other eastern auxiliaries of the Roman
army from the 2nd century A D is still found by archaeologists in the second half of the
5th century, at a time when the bulk of the Byzantine army was of oriental origin. his
is also the time when a new type of segmental helmet, the Baldenheim type, makes its
appearance, as we will discuss below.
As for lamellar weapons, many scholars attribute their introduction to the Avars,
a Nomadic people of Central Asia who came into contact with the Byzantine Empire
in the mid-6th century. Once settled on the Danube, the Avars supposedly spread this
type of arms to the Germanic tribes of Central and Western Europe, especially to the
Lombards who left lamellar specimens at Castel Trosino and Val di Nievole in Italy, and
then to the Alamanni beyond the Alps. P. Paulsen (1967) considers the helmet found
in Niederstötzingen (Germany) not as Avar but as Lombard or Byzantine, possibly
produced in a Pontic workshop. According to G. Arwidsson, the lamellar helmet
0 5 cm
Fig. 2: Parthian or Lydian segmental helmet from Sardis (Greenewalt, Heywood 1992, ig.21)
352 DAMIEN GLAD
1 2
3 4
0 5 cm
excavated in Kerch (Fig. 3 : 1), together with lamellar armour, could suggest a Pontic-
Scythian origin for lamellar armament.
Regarding the origin of the lamellar weapons, O. Gamber (1964, 14-18; 1966, 17; 1968,
7-44) has shown that lamellar helmets were known to the Egyptians in the 15th century B C,
to the Hittites in the 13th century B C and to the Romans in the 2nd century A D. According
to H. Von Gall (1990, 64), such weapons were known in the Middle East as early as the
Assyrian period. While the lamellar helmet is not attested in 3rd-4th-century Sassanian Iran
(Kazanski 1995, 193), it is worn by eastern auxiliaries of the Roman army on the Arch
of Galerius in hessaloniki (Greece), built between 298 and 305 A D (Laubscher 1975).
Horsemen depicted on the Arch wear lamellar helmets with a T-shaped nasal plate very
similar to those found in the Eastern Pontus.
THE EMPIRE’S INFLUENCE ON THE BARBARIAN ELITES 353
he earliest lamellar helmet from this region was found in a 2nd-century A D Sar-
matian grave by the stanica Tbilisskaja on the Kuban; it has a hemispherical bowl re-
sembling the Roman helmets (Simonenko 2001, 263-265). Another Sarmatian burial,
from Kišpek in Kabardino-Balkaria, dated between the late 3rd and the irst half of the
4th century, contained glass-paste gems and a lamellar helmet with a T-shaped nasal
plate (Fig. 3 : 2). Likewise, the early Byzantine fortress Il’ičevka on the Taman Peninsula
delivered a helmet dated to the 5th-6th century (Nikolaeva 1986), with a hemispherical
bowl and a T-shaped nasal plate (Fig. 3 : 3). he igurative ears of the 5th-century lamellar
helmet with a conical bowl found in Kalkhni in Dagestan (Fig. 3 : 4) are clearly indicative
of a Roman inluence (Salihov 1985). his feature is also present on a helmet from Iatrus
(Bulgaria), dated to the early 5th century (Gomolka-Fuchs 2007, ig.13/1629). Helmets
from Kalkhni and Iatrus could be contemporary. hese igurative ears are reminiscent of
Weiler-Guisborough type helmets and face helmets of the early Empire (Feugère 1994).
Archaeological evidences seems to suggest that the lamellar helmet was worn between
the late 3rd and the 6th century between the Black Sea coast and the Caspian Sea in
garrisons under Roman Byzantine inluence long before the arrival of the Avars.
Likewise, lamellar armour is attested on the Black Sea from the 4th century B C: in
Čirgirin, in Kerch and in Volkovicy-Romny. Since the 2nd century B C, it is present in
Sarmatian graves, including the Tbilisskaja. he lamellae have the same dimensions and
disposition of holes as the early Byzantine specimens from the Balkans (Simonenko
2001, 275-277). he armour of the heavy horsemen on the wall painting from Panjikent
is composed of vertical splints attached to a skirt of mail (Fig. 4). his technique is
0 5 cm
0 5 cm
0 5 cm
from Batajnica (Serbia), the only one deposited in a grave (Vinski 1954), testiies to
the Empire’s inluence on the Germanic elites. Others come from the last occupation
layer of Iustinian Prima (Caričin Grad, Serbia), dated between the reign of Justin II and
the abandonment of the city in 615. Novae (Svištov, Bulgaria), Selenca (Serbia) and
Vodno (Markovi Kuli, Makedonia) have produced several more fragments (a complete
bibliography can be found in Bavant 2008).
Since the publication of the Lepcis Magna (Libya) (Pirling 1974) and the Heraklea
Lyncestis inds, the Byzantine origin of the Baldenheim type is widely admitted. he
distribution map produced by Z. Vinski (1982, cf. 1984) shows a concentration of
Baldenheim-type helmets in the western part of the Empire around Italy, but also their
occurrence on sites with no known Germanic presence in the 5th-6th centuries. Recent
studies focus on the identiication and localization of arm factories. M. Vogt (after Böhner
1993; 1994) argued for the existence of a western workshop, presumably in Ostrogothic
Italy, but the publication of several fragments from Iustiniana Prima (Caričin Grad,
Serbia) has invalidated this hypothesis. B. Bavant has demonstrated that all four arm
factories identiied by M. Vogt are Byzantine. hree of them could have been located in
Constantinople or in area around the Sea of Marmara, in Nicomedia or Cyzicus. As for
the fourth fabrica, the western group of M. Vogt, B. Bavant has suggested localizing it
in hessaloniki. he author explains the stability of the Baldenheim type by the central-
ized control of production exercised by the comes sacrarum largitionum.
he question of the production of the lamellar weapons is more complex. heir
appearance in the Empire has traditionally been dated to the second half of the
6th century. Placed in the context of the confrontation with the Avars, lamellar armour
was considered as a means of resisting the penetrating power of their three-winged
arrowheads. However, the earliest lamellae discovered at the site of a military warehouse
in Topraichioi (near Babadag, Romania; not yet published) come from an occupation
layer dating from the second half of the 5th century, before the Avars’ arrival. What is
more, the discovery of a large number of lamellae in fortiications far from the conlict
zone indicates the production of this type of armour by Byzantine arms factories
(Bavant, Ivanišević 2003; Bugarski 2006; Ivanišević, Špehar 2006; Milinković 1995
and 2002). Several lamellar armours found in Viminacium show that they were supplied
to the Gepids, positioned in the front line against the Avars. However, a recent ind of
lamellar armour in Spartaria Carthago (Cartagena, Spain) along with early Byzantine
pottery conirms its wide availability in the Byzantine army (Vizcaíno Sanchez 2008).
Likewise, 7th-century lamellar armour was excavated in a Byzantine context in Crypta
Balbi in Rome (Ricci 2001, 400). None of these inds can be related to the Avars.
THE EMPIRE’S INFLUENCE ON THE BARBARIAN ELITES 357
1. These specimens of lamellar armour and lamellar helmet have not yet been published. I would
like to express my gratitude to Dr. Dieter Quast for having informed me of this discovery. Publication
is imminent.
358 DAMIEN GLAD
A critical analysis of theories on the origin and spread of early Byzantine segmental
helmets and lamellar weapons reveals the important part played by the Ponto-Danubian
area. It is the barbarian tribes who provided soldiers for the imperial army that became
the main vectors in the spread of early Byzantine weapons in the Barbaricum from the
Steppes to the Rhine. hese weapons, produced by the imperial fabricae for the use
of the imperial army, were considered as prestige goods by barbarian elites. hey were
difused by the same trans-continental routes, including the Silk Road, the Rhine and
the Danube, which promoted cultural transfers from East to West. It would only be fair,
however, to recall a movement in the opposite direction: the study of shield bosses shows
the spread of western Germanic weaponry into the Empire.
If the Eastern Empire was fairly susceptible to the Caucasian and Oriental inluences,
the western Germanic peoples showed little receptiveness to a direct impact of a foreign
culture. Only the elite and the foederati showed attachment to imperial prestige goods,
to which they attributed a particular symbolic value in funeral oferings.
THE EMPIRE’S INFLUENCE ON THE BARBARIAN ELITES 359
Bibliography
Arendt W. 1932: Beiträge zur Entstehung des Spangenharnisches. Ein alttürkischer Wafen-
fund aus Kertsch, Zeitschrift für Historische Wafen- und Kostümkunde 4, 1932, 49-55.
Arwidsson G. 1939: Armour of the Vendel Period, Acta Archaeologica 10, 1939, 31-59.
Atanasov G. 2001: Das römische Wegengrab von Silistra (Bulgarien) in Stein&Sinn,
Burg&Mensch, Wien, 2001, 130-136.
Bavant B., Ivanišević V. 2003: Iustiniana Prima – Caričin Grad, Belgrade 2003.
Bavant B. 2008: Fragments de casques de type Baldenheim trouvés à Caričin Grad,
Mélanges de l'École Française de Rome 120/2, 2008, 327-353.
Böhner K. 1959: Das Grab eines fränkischen Herren aus Morken im Rheinland (Kunst
und Altertum am Rhein 4), Köln 1959.
Böhner K. 1993: Zur Herkunft der frühmittelalterlichen Spangenhelme, in J. Pavuk,
dir., Actes du XIIe Congrès international des sciences préhistoriques et protohistoriques
(Bratislava 1991), IV, Bratislava 1993, 199-207.
Böhner K. 1994: Die frühmittelalterlichen Spangenhelme und die nordlichen Helme
der Vendelzeit, Jahrbuch des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums Mainz 41, 1994,
471-549.
Bona I. 1979: A Szegvár-sápoldali lovassír, adatok a korai avar temetkezési szokásokhoz
(Das Reitergrab von Szegvár-Sápoldal. Beiträge zu den frühawarischen Bestattungs-
sitten), Archaeologiai értesitő 106, 1979, 3-32.
Bona I. 1980: Studien zum frühawarischen Reitergrab von Szegvár, Acta Archaeologica 32,
1980, 31-95.
Bugarski I. 2006: A Contibution to the Study of Lamellar Armours, Starinar 55, 2006,
161-177.
Greenewalt C. H., Heywood A. M. 1992: A Helmet of the Sixth Century B.C. from
Sardis, Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 285, 1992, 1-31.
Csallány D. 1961: Archäologische Denkmäler der Gepiden in Mitteldonaubecken (454-
568 u. Z.), Budapest 1961.
Dörner E. 1960: Mormînt din epoca avara la Sînpetru-German, Studii și cercetări de
istorie veche și arheologie 11, 1960, 423-434.
Ebert M. 1909: Die frühmittelalterlichen Spangenhelmen von Baldenheimer Typus,
Praehistorische Zeitschrift 1, 1909, 65-77.
Engelhardt C. 1863: horsbjerg Mosefund, Copenhagen 1863.
Engelhardt C. 1865: Nydam Mosefund, Copenhagen 1865.
Engelhardt C. 1867: Kragehul Mosefund, Copenhagen 1867.
360 DAMIEN GLAD
Kazanski M. 1993: Les armes du Wādī Dura’, dans J.-F. Breton, M. Bafaqih, Trésors
du Wādī Dura’, Beyrouth 1993, 51-61.
Kazanski M. 1995: Les tombes des chefs alano-sarmates au ive siècle dans les steppes
pontiques, in: F. Vallet, M. Kazanski (dir.), La noblesse romaine et les chefs barbares
du IIIe au VIIe siècle, Paris 1995, 189-205.
Kazanski M., Mastykova A., Perin P. 2002: Byzance et les royaumes barbares d’Oc-
cident au début de l’époque mérovingienne, in: J. Tejral (Hrsg.), Probleme des
frühen Merowingerzeit im Mitteldonauraum, Brno 2002, 159-194.
Kessler P. 1940: Das merowingerzeitliche Fürstengrab von Planig in Rheinhessen,
Mainzer Zeitschrift 35, 1940, 4-10.
Kiss A. 2001: Das awarenzeitliche Gräberfeld in Kölked-Feketekapu B, Budapest 2001.
Kovačević J. 1977: Avarski kaganat, Beograd 1977.
Kubarev G. V. 2006: Die Schutzwafen mit igürlichen Lamellen als indikator der
Nomadenmigration in Eurasiens Steppenzone im 6.-8. Jh,, in: Mode, Tubach
2006, 453-484.
Laubscher H.-P. 1975: Der Reliefschmuck des Galeriusbogens in hessaloniki, Berlin 1975.
Maneva E. 1987: Casque à fermoir d’Héraclée, Archaeologia lugoslavica 24, 1987, 101-111.
Matzulewitsch L. 1929: Der Grabfund von Concesti in der Moldau, in: Id., Byzantinische
Antike. Studien auf Grund der Silbergefäße der Ermitage, Berlin/Leipzig 1929, 123-137.
Milinković M. 1995: Die Gradina auf dem Jelica Gebirge und die frühbyzantinischen
Befestigungen in der Umgebung von Čačak, Westserbien, Antiquité tardive 3, 1995,
227-250.
Milinković M. 2002: Die byzantinische Höhenanlage auf der Jelica in Serbien – ein
Beispiel aus dem nördlichen Illyricum des 6. Jh., Starinar 51, 2001 (2002), 71-133.
Mode M., Tubach J. (eds.) 2006: Arms and Armour as Indicators of Cultural Transfer,
Wiesbaden 2006.
Nefedkin A. K. 2006: Sarmatian Armour According to Narrative and Archaeological
Data, in Mode, Tubach, 2006, 433-444.
Nikolaeva 1986: николАевА. Э. А., Находки оружия на Ильичевском городище,
in: Проблемы античной культуры, Москва 1986, 183-188.
Overlaet B. J. 1982: Contribution to Sassanian armament in connection with a
decorated helmet, Iranica Antiqua 17, 1982, 189-206.
Paulsen P. 1967: Alamannische Adelsgräber von Niederstotzingen, Kreis Heidenheim,
Stuttgart 1967.
Pirling R. 1964: Ein fränkisches Fürstengrab aus Krefeld-Gellep, Germania 42, 1964,
188-216.
Pirling R. 1974: Ein Spangenhelm des Typus Baldenheim aus Leptis Magna in Libyen,
in: G. Kossack, G. Ulbert, Studien zur vor- und frühgeschichtlichen Archäologie.
Festschrift für J.Werner zum 65. Geburtstag, II, München 1974, 471-482.
362 DAMIEN GLAD
Raspopova V. I., Sogdian Arms and Armour in the Period of the Great Migrations, in:
Mode, Tubach 2006, 79-95.
Ricci M. 2001: Armi, in: M. S. Arena et al. (a cura di), Roma dall’antichità al medioevo.
Archeologia e storia nel Muzeo nazionale romano Crypta Balbi, Milan 2001, 395-402.
Rosner G. 1999: Das awarenzeitliche Gräberfeld in Szekszárd-Bogyiszló Strasse, Budapest
1999.
Rostovtseff M. I. 1913- 1914/2003: La peinture décorative antique en Russie méridionale
(Mémoires de l’Académie des Inscriptions et Belles Lettres), 2 vol., Paris 2003 (titre
original: М. И. Ростовцев, Античная декоративная живопись на юге России,
СПб 1913- 1914).
Salihov 1985: сАлиХов Б. М. Калхинский могильник, in Древние культуры Северо
Восточного Кавказа, Махачкала 1985, 167-187.
Simonenko A. V. 2001: Bewafnung und Kriegswesen der Sarmaten und der späten
Skythen im nördlichen Schwarzmeergebiet, Eurasia Antiqua 7 2001, 251-327.
Vagalinski L. 1998: Ein neuer spätantiker Segmenthelm aus Voivoda, Schumen Gebiet
(Nordostbulgarien), Archaeologia Bulgarica 2, 1998, 96-106.
Vǎzarova Z. N. 1976: Slavjani i Prabǎlgari (po danni na nekropolite ot VI-XI v. na
teritorijata na Bǎlgarija, Soia 1976.
Vinski Z. 1954: Ein Spangenhelmfund aus dem östlichen Syrmien, Germania 32, 1954,
176-182.
Vinski Z. 1982: Šljem epohe seobe naroda naden u Sinju, Starohrvatska prosvjeta 12,
1982, 7-36.
Vinski Z. 1984: Dodatna zapažanja o šljemovima tipa Narona/Baldenheim, Staro-
hrvatska prosvjeta 14, 1984, 95-106.
Vizcaíno Sánchez J. 2008: Early byzantine lamellar armour from Carthago Spartaria
(Cartagena, Spain), Gladius 28, 2008, 195-210.
Vogt M. 2006: Spangenhelme: Baldenheim und verwandte Typen, Mainz 2006.
Winlock H. E., Hauser W., Upton J. M. 1934: he Persian expedition 1933-1934,
Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 29 (12/2), 1934, 3-22.