Sciencedirect
Sciencedirect
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 61 (2017) 22 – 27
Abstract
International business competition is becoming intense along with economic growth among emerging countries. One of the most significant
issues in the expansion of global production involves the localization of parts. Parts processing requires sophisticated techniques, and its
localization requires a certain level of production volume and investment. These needs have caused delays in localization, now among the most
significant hindrances to competitiveness. We developed 1/N machines in order to solve these issues and build a new lean production system
with high cost competitiveness. This system is expected to reduce environmental footprints and generate steady competitiveness throughout the
entire product life cycle.
© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review
Peer-review under
under responsibility
responsibility of the cscientific
of the scientifi committeecommittee of the
of the 24th CIRP 24th CIRP
Conference Conference
on Life on Life Cycle Engineering.
Cycle Engineering
Keywords: Lean production system; 1/N machine; Die casting; Forging; Parts localization; Global manufacturing
2212-8271 © 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 24th CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2016.12.002
Yasuhiko Yamazaki / Procedia CIRP 61 (2017) 22 – 27 23
Customer
100 100 100
Fig.3 Waste in traditional parts production system Fig. 5 Effect of optimal output level investment
Investment
production. Cost can NOT be reduced
Because of its high optimal output level, each parts factory proportionaly by capability
100k
has operated as a dedicated factory engaging in large-lot Cost can be reduced
production, generating much waste in many areas. This waste 25k proportionaly by capability
has always been recognized as a problem, but it has become Traditional Small capability
far more serious in recent years because of its huge negative Machine Machine(1/N)
impact as manufacturing has become more complex due to the Fig. 6 Problem of small capability machine
growing sophistication of parts. The increased sophistication
of products has resulted in diversification, reducing the Investments designed to lower the optimal output level of
production volume per model. At the same time, advances in parts processing can significantly eliminate waste not only
product functionality and high precision mean that parts are from the target production system but also from the
no longer completed in a single manufacturing process but investment itself. As Fig. 5 indicates, a reduced investment
now undergo several steps—such as molding, cutting, and unit improves the company ÿ s cash flow and allows the
heat treatment—before completion, as Fig. 4 shows. These company to avoid the risk of excess capacity. It also makes it
changes have generated substantial costs related to possible to divert assets for other uses in smaller units. Small
transportation and stock between manufacturing processes, as unit investment can also realize a lean production system
well as tasks relating to their management, representing waste through the synchronization of processes throughout the
that does not produce added value. Minimizing or eliminating product life cycle. The production of the desired quantity at
such waste has become a major key to enhancing the desired time also minimizes energy consumption.
manufacturing competitiveness.
Under these circumstances, our goal is to minimize the 3.3. Key point of the development of 1/N machines
optimal output level of parts processing through technological
and equipment development and to create a seamlessly The average capital and depreciation cost of processing can
synchronized flow throughout the production system, thereby be obtained by dividing the equipment cost by the number of
minimizing waste. pieces processed. A conventional approach to minimizing the
㼑㼤㻚㻕㻌㻮㼛㼐㼥㻌㼒㼛㼞㻌㻲㼡㼑㼘㻌㻵㼚㼖㼑㼏㼠㼕㼛㼚㻌㻼㼡㼙㼜㻌㼛㼒㻌㼐㼕㼑㼟㼑㼘㻌㼑㼚㼓㼕㼚㼑
Conventional Parts Fuel efficient/safety product
→simple function, simple shape →Multi function, complicate shape
Cost
㻴㼛㼡㼟㼕㼚㼓 㻮㼛㼐㼥
Waste
Value
Value
Cost
Waste Waste
Waste Net
Cost
Net Cost
Heat treatment
Conveyance
Conveyance
Conveyance
Conveyance
Conveyance
Conveyance
Plating
Electropolishing
Conveyance
Machining
Machining
Die-casting
Warm Forging
Repacking
Repacking
Repacking
Repacking
Repacking
Repacking
Assembly
Assembly
Process㸦э㸧 Process㸦э㸧
optimal output level—reducing equipment capacity— valve parts in an integrated and synchronized line. The overall
encounters the fundamental problem of continued cost line is composed of material (aluminum alloy) injection, die
increases, as shown in Fig. 6: dividing the existing functions casting, heat treatment, cutting, washing, alumite treatment,
is no longer a valid solution. Research must therefore be and inspection in order to solve the problem of a small-
pursued from a totally new angle. For effective problem capability machine, as Fig. 6 shows. Previously, each of these
solving, target processes must be fundamentally reviewed and processes was located in a separate building. Due to the large
transformed in light of the ultimate purpose, and work steps production capacity of each equipment component, large
and equipment composed of small units must be realigned at quantities of stock existed between the processes, which
low cost. The cases presented in the following section required wasteful transportation, loading, and unloading. In
describe how we have achieved these objectives. the new integrated and synchronized line including the small-
scale 1/N die-casting system, the equipment was made smaller
4. Practical cases for each process, with output and setup time equally reduced
[8]. The surface area occupied by equipment was reduced by
4.1. 1/N Machine development for die casting 1/5, energy consumption by 1/2, and production cost by 33%
over the previous line (see Fig. 8).
Die casting is a process that involves injecting molten
metal under high pressure into a die to mold it. Its industrial 4.2. 1/N Machine development for forging
advantage is the ability to mold complex forms in a short
period of time. The melting furnace must retain a large A forging machine is large due to its great processing load,
quantity of molten metal inside to maintain a fixed interior which requires a dedicated factory in a tall building, as well as
temperature, which requires large-scale equipment. A die- ground reinforcement work, hoist cranes, the transportation of
casting machine requires high pressure to eliminate defects large dies and materials, and anti-noise measures. It is also
(blow holes) that would otherwise form inside the molded necessary to manufacture large lots and keep stock so as to
pieces[6]. Therefore, die-casting equipment is high-output, minimize the number of setups, which are time-consuming
highly rigid, and large-scale. Heat treatment furnaces, which and during which operation must be suspended.
are often operated on a batch system, have the disadvantages An integrated and synchronized forging process requires
of being large in scale and generating intermediate stock. reducing equipment size to a level small enough to be housed
In our development project, we set the goal of in an ordinary factory and realizing quick changeover (with
transforming the respective components of the existing die- each setup time taking 10 minutes or less) through 1/N
casting equipment and creating a small, manageable, and processing load reduction and machine downsizing. Since the
continually operative system with an investment-friendly processing load is determined by adding up material
optimal output level (production capacity) in anticipation of deformation resistance and surface area, it is most effective to
global development in order to realize integrated and reduce deformation resistance by overlaying heat or to adopt
synchronized manufacturing free of waste within and between incremental forging, thereby reducing the surface area
the processes. We focused on the die-casting process, which processed per work step and dispersing load[9]. The
would be the heart of the new system, departing from the techniques used to achieve these results vary from one
conventional high pressure-dependent method by developing machine to another and one parts type to another, and also
a technology to maintain die-casting quality even under low depend on line lot size. Therefore, the know-how required for
pressure [7]. We also developed a technology for stabilizing
the temperature inside the furnace even with a small amount Traditional Line Machining&
Almite Inspection
of molten metal and an online heat treatment furnace. By washing
Die casting
setting up these processes as cells, thus completely Material
eliminating the need for transportation between the processes,
we realized a new integrated and synchronized system. Melting Heat treatment
Fig. 7 shows an example of the application of our small- 1/N system Machine Area :1/5 Valve
scale 1/N die-casting system to the processing of hydraulic Energy
Consumption:1/2
Cost ▲33%
Machining
1/N Die casting 1/N Almite
&washing
Fig. 8 Synchronization consistency line with the 1/N die casting system
(NQQT#TGCᲴO
#TGC ᲫᲩᲰ
(NQQT#TGCᲴO /CEJKPGEQUV ᲫᲩᲭ
2TQEGUUEQUV ŢᲭᲪᲟ
Fig. 7 1/N Compact die casting system Fig. 9 Comparison between traditional machine and 1/N machine
26 Yasuhiko Yamazaki / Procedia CIRP 61 (2017) 22 – 27
cutting by specifying sections of pieces to be cut by the 1/N At the case of At the case of Including next
100% OEE ͤ Real OEE ͤ generation at
cutting machine, constitutes know-how. The reduced (full capacity) Real OEEͤ
processing load in turn decreased equipment rigidity, and ͤOEE=Overall equipment efficiency
setup time was cut to several minutes because smaller dies,
Fig. 11 Cost comparison between traditional machine and 1/N
placed next to the machine, could be lifted without a hoist.
Smaller carts could now be used to change materials, which
was completed within a few minutes. It became possible to 5.2. Significance of 1/N machine development
run several work steps together, synchronizing forging with
cutting and subsequent treatment and enabling the processing Manufacturing technology faces many challenges; in all
of parts with high added-value at 30% lower cost [10]. We cases, the primary concerns are cost and quality (including
intend to export this integrated and synchronized line outside environmental conservation). While manufacturers cite
Japan in order to enhance our global competitiveness. numerous goals such as process synchronization, inventory
reduction, and overseas localization, they are all premised on
5. Significance of 1/N machine development the fulfillment of cost and quality requirements. It has been
believed almost as an absolute truth that increased output
5.1. Life cycle cost in a model case equals cost reduction. Indeed, technological advances in
manufacturing have been founded on this belief, and it is no
These processing methods and equipment have already exaggeration to say that cost reduction has been achieved
achieved substantial cost reductions with regard to the through capacity augmentation by way of accelerating
respective parts. Even greater efficiencies can be expected production and increasing the number of pieces processed per
from these technologies throughout the product life cycle, as unit equipment . This approach is valid as long as output
described in Fig.11 for the example of die casting. volume and product types remain stable on the simple premise
Conventional processing using large-scale equipment can of continued economic growth. Today, as product types and
be cost-competitive if operated at full capacity. However, output volume inevitably vary, manufacturing processes with
high-capacity processing is difficult to maintain if equipment a high optimal output level, which have promoted higher-
flexibility is low. With melting furnaces, it is next to speed and multiple-piece processing, generate significant
impossible to switch materials. This means that a change of waste and increased costs. As the preconditions for
material entails the addition of a new machine. Requiring as manufacturing are changing from the medium- to long-term
many machines as materials implies extremely low-capacity perspective, a completely new approach is being called for in
utilization. The setup of dies for die-casting machines that order to adapt to the changes .
handle an increasing number of product types seriously In such a situation, production capacity (i.e., optimal
compromises the operating rate. The new system enables output level) reduction by 1/N goes against the conventional
operation that produces only the necessary quantity and only concept of cost reduction. It has never before been placed at
when necessary, thereby constantly maintaining a high the heart of development. The keys to achieving it cannot be
operating rate. For a product switch, the system can be easily found in an extension from the conventional principle of
converted for a new product type thanks to the low optimal processing. Achieving a lower optimal output level requires
output level, without waste of investment. The constant reducing equipment cost rather than slowing down the
maintenance of a high overall operating rate means lower processing cycle and, most importantly, by first lowering the
labor and energy costs. mechanical processing capacity. In the case of die casting
presented above, we initially attempted to lower the optimal
output level by slowing down the processing cycle, but this
was not economically viable unless the equipment cost was
Yasuhiko Yamazaki / Procedia CIRP 61 (2017) 22 – 27 27
reduced. After examining the case from several angles, we and surface finishing, which have traditionally been processed
found a concrete key to reducing the equipment cost: lower in large batches. Our approach of minimizing the optimal
pressure. Reducing the equipment cost required simplifying output level in pursuit of the ultimate goal of one-by-one
the equipment, which we achieved by using lower pressure processing resonates with the concept of lean production as
for injection. This goes against the development of die casting well as environmentally benign manufacturing. One-by-one
thus far, which has evolved with the use of increasingly processing, through its remarkable process controllability,
higher pressure, in turn necessitating larger equipment. Higher promotes upgrading and facilitates the observation of
pressure has been employed to increase processing speed and traceability and first-in-first-out rules as part of process
the number of pieces processed per die, as well as to apply management, greatly contributing to quality improvement.
pressure before material solidification in order to reduce Given the rapid advances in information technology, one-by-
internal defects from the squeeze casting method. This one processing suggests the possibility of data collection in
evolution has proceeded in the right direction in accordance single-piece units; such data could then be utilized for further
with the conventional principles of processing. However, process development. We intend to pursue 1/N equipment
development is reoriented when processing methods change development to perfect a flexible and compact production
as preconditions, leading to new discoveries. A development system that realizes a one-piece manufacturing flow stretching
that lowers the optimal output level with 1/N equipment has from the factory’s entrance to its exit.
the potential to create new value by abandoning conventional
processing methods. References
Goal-setting by fundamentally reexamining processing
principles can lead to novel equipment development. The [1] Yamazaki, Y., Sugito, K., Tsuchiya, S., Development of flexible
causal relationship between goal-setting as the starting point manufacturing system, Journal of robotics and mechatronics 26(4), 426-
433, 2014-08
of this development and results can be likened to that of [2] Koren y., Heisel U., Jovane F., Moriwaki T., Pritschow G., Ulsoy G. and
inventory and production in terms of competitiveness. Van Brussel H.: Reconfigurable Manufacturing Systems, Annuals of the
Processing stabilized with a large lot temporarily reduces CIRP, 48,2(1999)527-540.
costs; however, the resultant inventory generates waste and [3] Feldmann, K., Slama, S., 2001, Highly flexible Assembly – Scope and
compromises competitiveness. Reducing the lot size, the Justification, In CIRP Annals, Vol. 50, 489-498.
[4]Kawahara, N., Suto, T., Hirano, T., Ishikawa, Y., T. Kitahara, Ooyama,
source of the problem, is the best solution; as a driver for N., Ataka, T., Microfactories;new applications of micromachine
action, however, focusing on the visible inventory is easiest to technology to the manufacture of small profducts, Microsystem
pursue. Therefore, inventory reduction is a general approach technologies, Feb. 1997, Volume3, issue 2, pp37-41
[5] Morita, H., Furutani, K., 1995, Electrical Discharge Device with Direct
to realizing lean production. Likewise, in equipment
Drive Method for Thin Wire Electrode, IEEE International Conference
development, efforts to detect and remove causes of waste in on Robotics and Automation:73-78
the processing method can focus on equipment capacity or [6] Edgar, J., 1999, Improving the Quality of Castings Produced on Air
size, to find new improvement approaches, which can Driven Minature Diecast Machines, Transactions of the 1999
International Die Casting Congress, T99:127-131
eventually lead to lean production. Realizing lean production [7] Nakatsuka, Y., Taniguchi, Y., Hongou, E., 2000, Development of
involves eliminating all kinds of waste; this can reduce not Diecasting Machine for Saving Energy and Dealing with Environment,
only temporary costs but also the environmental load, Transactions of the Japan Die Casting Congress, JD06:117-120 (in
including energy consumption, materials used, and waste Japanese)
material, thereby reducing life cycle costs. The optimal output [8] Morooka, M, 2014, Small Sized Diecasting System Realizes
Synchronized and Integrated Production, Journal of the Japan Institute of
level represents an important approach to promoting the Metals and Materials, Vol. 64/12:649-653 (in Japanese)
evolution of equipment and processing methods, an important [9] Miyake, M., Yazaki, T., Sodani, Y., Development of load reduction
key performance indicator (KPI) that can reduce costs and technology by swing-type forging and lubrication for large-deformation
environmental load at the same time, leading to new value. forging by high-speed large-reduction forging, materials Transactions,
Vol. 54, No. 10(2013) pp.1951-1956
[10] Kuroda, Y., Fujii, H., Yamada, K., Hashimoto, H., Mori, T., 2014,
6. Future prospects Development of Synchronized and Rectified Flow Production System by
1/N Machine, Journal of the JSTP, Vol. 55, No. 647:1053-1057 (in
We have expanded the scope of 1/N equipment Japanese)
development, going beyond molding to cover heat treatment