Topic 6 June 2016 V3
Topic 6 June 2016 V3
Topic 6 June 2016 V3
Topic 6
Geological techniques
Contents
Prerequisite knowledge
• Topics 2-5
• Geometry and spatial vision
Learning objectives
• Define the concept of correlation and explain its importance and its
basic principles
• Apply the concept of correlation by carrying out simple correlations
using lithostratigraphic and biostratigraphic data
• Describe what a geological and a structural contour map represent
• List and illustrate the different steps needed to draw a simple cross
section and apply them to create a cross section from a given map
In the present topic we will discuss two main geological techniques: correlation
and geological mapping, and their crucial role in petroleum engineering.
Figure 6.1. Changes in the correlation between the two wells in the first image
(superior corner, left) towards a more complex correlation when we start introducing
more and more new data (more wells in this case). (Figure by H. Lever).
If we want to find out the real dimensions of the bodies forming our reservoir,
we will draw a realistic correlation scheme, that we will call from now on “real-
distance correlation panel”. This type of correlation panel will represent (at a
certain scale) the real distance between our wells and therefore orientations
similar to reality (depending on the vertical scale) of the beds that we correlate
(Figure 6.2a).
On the other hand, if we are more interested in the continuity of a certain bed,
or in its age, we may correlate using an “even-distance correlation panel”
(Figure 6.2b). An even-distance correlation panel will be a schematic
representation that will not respect the real distance between wells. Therefore,
the orientations of our beds will be different to reality, and may appear to
change between wells whereas in reality they are consistent.
Figure 6.2.a. Real-distance correlation panel showing the correlation among three
sandy beds in three wells. In this case, we are using the true depth of the wells, so in
this correlation panel, neither the distance among wells nor the dip of the beds has
been modified. 6.2b. Even-distance correlation panel among the same three wells
(Figure by S. Pla-Pueyo). Note how in this case the wells are evenly spaced, or
equidistant. In this case, instead of using the true depth, we are using a reference
horizontal surface (the top of the conglomerate) to determine the depth of our wells in
the correlation panel, so no real distance between wells nor real dip of beds in shown
in this case.
In either of these types of correlation panel, we can decide to use the true
depth of the wells (“true-depth correlation panels”) or we can modify the
vertical position of our wells to make a certain depth coincide with a horizontal
surface (“hung correlation panels”). This horizontal surface is usually given by
a stratigraphic marker or datum, that will be the reference level for the whole
correlation. In Figure 6.2b, the chosen stratigraphic datum is the top of the
conglomerate, so the vertical position of the wells will depend on that surface.
The most commonly used and the most useful in considering the reservoir
characteristics is lithostratigraphy. As it has been mentioned in Topic 4, it
deals with the lithology or physical characteristics of the rock (i.e. sandstone,
mudstone etc). Correlation of lithology gives the arrangement of beds, porosity
and permeability zones, flow units and potential barriers in a reservoir, as well
as volume and extent of the reservoir.
In the lithostratigraphic correlation we care more about the lithology than about
the age of the rocks. Therefore, we may be correlating two bodies of the same
lithology that are totally different in age (Figure 6.3). This type of correlation
can be useful if we are looking for sedimentary bodies that are connected
among them because they are part of the same reservoir. It is possible in this
case to have connected bodies of lithologically similar rock in the subsurface
that are millions of years different in age between two places. This is because
lithological units are time transgressive (the correlation lines may cross time
lines).
Figure 6.3. Correlation among three sandy beds in three wells. The bed has different
ages in each well, because the sedimentary environment in which the sandstone
formed (a sandy beach) remained the same during a long period of time, although it
was changing its location in the landscape (the sea level changed, and therefore the
coastline and the sand formed in the beach changed locations as well).You can see
how this movement through time resulted in beds of the same sandstone having
different ages (Figure by S. Pla-Pueyo).
The next important type is biostratigraphy, for which fossil assemblages and
ranges are identified and used to correlate wells to each other and to a global
chart of fossil ranges for the purposes of dating the rocks.
There are several types of biozones that we can use to correlate, depending
on the criteria we use to define the time interval of the biozone (Figure 6.4):
There are other criteria, but for the moment we will use these four in our
correlations.
Figure 6.5. Relation between fossil appearance and disappearance in logs and in
wells. Figure by S. Pla-Pueyo).
Moreover, when we are correlating wells, we have to take into account two
different issues:
Therefore, it could happen that we get a species in the cuttings from younger
sediments that do not belong there, and we may interpret it wrongly, and
locate the first appearance of a species stratigraphically lower than it really is.
Therefore, when drilling, the safest criterion to use is the First Downhole
Occurrence of a species, as we can be sure that it is the first time we are really
drilling that biozone (see Fig. 6.6)
Figure 6.6. Potential issues when using core cuttings data for biostratigraphic
correlations (Figure by S. Pla-Pueyo).
The best fossils to correlate are called biostratigraphic markers, and are those
that have an almost worldwide distribution, and are likely to be deposited in
sediments from many different environments. Examples include the skeletons
of planktonic animals (those that live floating in the ocean, such as
foraminifera, dinoflagellates, radiolaria), and pollen or spores.
The worst fossils or combinations of fossils are those that are restricted to a
single environment, as they will only ever be found in that environment, and
therefore only indicate the presence of that environment and not the age of the
rock.
The main rule to keep in mind with biostratigraphic interpretations is that the
time lines should never cross (see Figure 6.7).
Figure 6.7. Correlation among sandy beds in three wells using biostratigraphic data.
Notice how the correlation lines do not cross the time line (Figure by S. Pla-Pueyo).
The data sets used in correlation tend to vary with the purpose of the
correlation. For example, biostratigraphic data or chronostratigraphic data can
be used, or information from seismic sections can be integrated into a
correlation. Seismic data is the only laterally continuous data available from
the subsurface (Figure 3).
Before the data from two different wells can be compared or correlated, it is
imperative that the data (usually a suite of wireline logs) are displayed at
comparable vertical scales and logging scales. There is no standard suite of
data for correlation: any data can be correlated, but the widest possible range
of data will give the best opportunity to check, verify, compare and validate
correlation interpretations.
Wireline logs are acquired and logged using Measured Depth (MD) in the well
bore. If the well is vertical, then this can be used as a True Vertical Depth
(TVD). However, in the (usual) situation where the well is deviated, then the
logs must be converted to allow for the deviation.
In order to then compare the logs, the vertical depth must be corrected to
some datum to align the logs. Usually, depths are calculated below sea level,
or subsea, giving True Vertical Depth Subsea (TVDSS). Different logs are
used for different purposes:
• Dipmeter: Identifies the dip of the rock units crossed, including faulted
contacts. 'Rock units' in this context includes beds and features such
as cross-bedding within beds (so that current direction can sometimes
be obtained from dipmeter information). Changes in dip can indicate
deformation, faulted contacts or stratigraphic changes.
• Other useful information is given by resistivity and sonic and caliper
logs.
There are a few guidelines that you should always take into account when
correlating logs:
1) Always correlate from the base upwards, this is how the rocks were
deposited
2) Always correlate from the large scale changes to the small scale. Worry
about the formation tops and markers first, before correlating minor changes
and beds
5) Units that pinch out (the natural ending of a bed due to lateral changes in
lithology) between wells are indicated by merging correlation lines (> or <)
The previous guidelines work for correlating wells too, and we can add an
extra line just for the correlation between wells: Never correlate the top or
bottom of a well, as these are artificial boundaries
created during drilling.
A map is a 2D plan view of an area. The map can show numerous different
types of data. For example, topographic maps show height of the land surface
above sea level (Figure 6.9). Other data can be represented on the map, such
as temperature, infrastructure, depth, thickness, geology and any other
quantity that varies with space. All maps represent an area, and usually show
their location by reference to some kind of grid system, either a regional or
worldwide grid (such as latitude and longitude), or a local established grid over
a field.
In an oil and gas field context, the area covered by a map is usually the limits
of the field. In all contexts, a map will cover a given area and contours will stop
at the boundary of that area. This boundary is artificial as the surfaces or
trends of data will obviously continue beyond the designated boundary of the
map.
Maps are the primary tool used to summarise, interpret and communicate
spatial data. Because a map is a two dimensional representation of what is
usually a three dimensional set of data, some imagination is required to both
interpret drawn maps, and to draw your own. Geologists and geophysicists are
usually adept map makers because they are very good at picturing in their own
minds the 3D relationships that are expressed by the 2D map representation.
6.2.2. Coordinates
Both z data and also the grid coordinates used refer to some kind of datum. A
datum is any fixed location or line from which measurements can be taken. In
the case of the map coordinates, the datum may be a fixed point (such as the
platform) or it may be a fixed line such as a latitude or longitude of one global
coordinate system. In the case of data, the datum is the agreed reference
level, for example for elevation (height and depth) data, the datum is usually
taken as sea level. Other types of z data use units of measurement that refer
to a datum and do not need to be explicitly stated.
Contours are lines of equal values, that is, each contour line has a single data
value. Contour lines separate areas of higher value data on one side and
lower value data on the other side. Contouring is the art of drawing these lines
of equal value through a scattered set of discrete data points, to create an
interpretation of the gradient of the data in the area mapped.
Elevation is the height above sea level, or the depth below sea level. Mean
sea level is the datum usually used to express elevation data. Elevation is
always positive above sea level, and negative below sea level. Elevation can
be expressed in feet or in metres. In a topographical map, each line will be
joining points with the same elevation.
Follow the contours around the map and notice how they curve around hills
(Figure 6.9A), and follow rivers up valleys.
Note that steep slopes are shown by closely spaced contours, and gentle
slopes are indicated by widely spaced contours.
Note how if you trace a route down a hillside, across a valley and back up the
next hill, you cross the same contour twice in the bottom of the valley.
Look back and forwards from the 3D visualization in Figure 6.9B to the 2D
map in Figure 6.9A to accustom yourself to working out where the high and
low points are on a contour map.
Ordinance Survey maps contain a great deal of other data as well, discrete
data like houses, tracks, lakes, vegetation and archaeological sites.
Figure 6.9. Topographical (height above sea level) contour map and 3D
representation of the same area. A: Ordnance Survey topographic map of part of the
Pentlands Hills near the Riccarton Campus of Heriot-Watt University. The contour
lines are spaced at 5 m intervals, with every 25m contour in bold to help distinguish
the complex topography.
Figure 6.9. continued. Topographical (height above sea level) contour map and 3D
representation of the same area. B: 3D visualisation of the same map, to help
illustrate where hills and valleys are located, and the relative slope steepness as
indicated by the contour spacing on the 2D map. Reproduced by kind permission of
Ordnance Survey. © Crown Copyright. NC/00/542
Geological maps produced for the land show the surface geology, which are
the rocks that outcrop at the surface of the earth (Figure 6.10).
These types of maps are called subcrop maps, and can be useful in
determining local highs (hard rocks) and lows (soft, easily eroded rocks) of the
unconformity surface, as well as likely source rocks for local sediment
deposition above the unconformity.
125 119
120
124 13
00 130
130
140
142
130 128
98
110
100
123
141 120
108
130
140
130 141
126
Google Earth is another tool that can help with the mapping, but it has to be
used carefully. It is easy to forget that although it shows the changes in colour
of the landscape from above, that are not necessarily related to changes in
lithology. Moreover, we still need a topographical map to give us the elevation
reference, and therefore, the 3D information, as Google Earth images are just
2D photographs.
Figure 6.12A shows a dipping bedding plane and its elevation above sea level.
The next figure (6.12B) shows the structure contours for the dipping surface
projected onto the bedding plane. Figure 6.12C shows how these structure
contours are projected on to the map view and Figure 6.12D shows the map
view of the structure contours. As you can see, a plane with a constant strike
and dip has evenly spaced straight structure contours. A folded plane or a
plane with an irregular dip will have folded or varyingly spaced structure
contours.
Although there are some geological maps that focus only in a specific feature,
most of the geological maps you will encounter will have a topographical base,
and will be showing the lithostratigraphy and the structural features of an area.
Figure 6.13. This is the Geological map for Snowdon Area, Wales, UK (© British
Geological Survey). The map includes a cross section, correlation, stratigraphic
column and key.
The location of the contacts between lithostratraphic units are found through
observations of the change in rock type in different spots, marking them in the
map, and then joining the different spots with a line. The line will give us the
contact between two lithostratigraphic units. Where the geologist is certain of
the contact between lithostratigraphic units, the boundary will be marked with a
solid line. When there is some uncertainty of the boundary, a dashed line will
be used to represent the boundary. See figure 6.14 for the map symbols used
for lithostratigraphic boundaries.
The orientation of a bed in a geological map will be deduced from the shape of
the lower and upper contact of the bed when intersecting the topographical
lines.
If the line is parallel to the topographical lines, we can infer that the bed is
horizontal (all of the points will be approximately at the same elevation)
whereas if the line crosses topographical lines (lines of same elevation), the
bed is dipping.
The best way of knowing if the bed is dipping to one way or the other is looking
at valleys, ravines or gullies, as they are eroding the surface and exposing the
beds. Dipping beds cross a valley in a “V” shape, which will be more or less
steep (exaggerated) depending on whether the bed is dipping down or up
valley (Figure 6.15).
A B
Figure 6.15. Illustration of dipping beds in valleys. A) Beds dipping down valley
producing a “V”’ shape. B) Beds “V” up valley.
This information will be useful for us to determine the lateral extension and the
boundaries of the bed.
In general, the geologists will indicate the orientation of the beds in the map
using the symbols indicated in Figure 6.14, so we will not need to find out by
ourselves.
6.3.3. Conformity-unconformity
Folds and faults are the main structural features that will be represented in a
geological map.
In the case of the folds, there are symbols to express whether the fold is a
syncline or an anticline (see Figure 6.14), while the faults will be drawn
differently if they are normal or reverse. Please see Figure 6.14 for a complete
list of symbols used in geological mapping.
Sometimes maps have limited data, and therefore outcrop patterns can be a
useful way of determining the structure present. Folds on maps can be
recognised by the repeated outcrop patterns that they create on a geological
map.
An anticline will have repeated rock sequences that are dipping away from
each other, whilst for a syncline the repeated rock sequences will dip towards
each other.
Plunging folds also produced repeated rock sequences similar to upright folds
however they are slightly different due to the limbs of a plunging fold closing
around the axial trace. The limbs of the anticline close in the direction they
plunge whereas for a syncline the limbs open in the direction which they
plunge. Figure 6.17 shows the outcrop patterns on a geological map which
represent folded sequences.
Figure 6.17. Block models and their map view for a) syncline B) anticline C) plunging
anticline D) plunging syncline. Little arrows in the axial plane show the plunging
direction in C and D.
6.4. Computer generated maps
The use of digital maps for geological and engineering purposes is extensive
in the present, but it is crucial to bear in mind that the maps require real data,
that sometimes need to be collected in person, as in the case of the geological
maps.
However, because the computer is limited by the data that we provide, and the
data distribution is not even, computer mapping techniques have the tendency
to produce features that are not actually present, but are an artefact of the
technique used to generate the surface.
Computer mapping can be biased by user input data. For example, we can
generate a computer map that contains trends in a particular orientation, if we
know that all the structures or sedimentary bodies are orientated in this
direction.
Figure 6.18. Demonstration of how vertical exaggeration can distort the shape of a
structural feature such as a fold.
A) You want the best place to illustrate the structures present. You may
wish to draw several intersecting cross-sections to illustrate the
changes in each direction. True dips will only be seen on cross-
sections drawn perpendicular to strike or parallel to the dip direction.
C) Draw the cross-section line on your map, labelling the end points
clearly.
Labels are usually A-A', B-B' etc.
A) Place a strip of paper against the cross-section line, and mark the
locations of the end points on the strip. Then mark (and label) the
locations along the strip where a structure contour crosses the cross-
section line.
B) Place the strip on your framework, lining up the end points. For each
point marked on the strip where a structure contour crosses the cross-
section line, place a dot at the correct elevation according to your
scales within your framework.
A) Join the dots to create a smoothed surface for the structure. Note
that when creating the top or base of an anticline or syncline, the
surface will gently curve over, but not go higher or lower than the next
contour value (or that contour would be seen on the map).
B) Without actual dips for fault surfaces, faults can be drawn vertical, or
given an interpretive dip depending on what kind of fault is inferred, or
if there is a gap marked in the surface, a dip angle can be suggested
from that.
7) Consistency
Make sure that your cross-section is consistent with your map – that
the faults show similar offsets, the dips are the same, and also that the
geological setting you envisaged while drawing the map or interpreting
the map is the same as the setting illustrated by your cross-section.
6.6. Bibliography
Allaby, M. A. 2013. Dictionary of Geology and Earth Sciences. Oxford
University Press.
Mathews, M., Simons, N, Menzies, B. 2009. Short course in geology for civil
engineers. London: ICE Publishing (ICE virtual library)
Rogers, N. (Ed.). 2008. Our Dynamic Planet. 1st ed. Cambridge University
Press.