June 2020 MS - Paper 1 AQA Psychology GCSE
June 2020 MS - Paper 1 AQA Psychology GCSE
June 2020 MS - Paper 1 AQA Psychology GCSE
PSYCHOLOGY
8182/1
Paper 1 Cognition and Behaviour
Mark scheme
June 2020
Version: 1.0 Final Mark Scheme
*206g8182/1/MS*
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Mark schemes are prepared by the Lead Assessment Writer and considered, together with the relevant
questions, by a panel of subject teachers. This mark scheme includes any amendments made at the
standardisation events which all associates participate in and is the scheme which was used by them in
this examination. The standardisation process ensures that the mark scheme covers the students’
responses to questions and that every associate understands and applies it in the same correct way.
As preparation for standardisation each associate analyses a number of students’ scripts. Alternative
answers not already covered by the mark scheme are discussed and legislated for. If, after the
standardisation process, associates encounter unusual answers which have not been raised they are
required to refer these to the Lead Examiner.
It must be stressed that a mark scheme is a working document, in many cases further developed and
expanded on the basis of students’ reactions to a particular paper. Assumptions about future mark
schemes on the basis of one year’s document should be avoided; whilst the guiding principles of
assessment remain constant, details will change, depending on the content of a particular examination
paper.
Copyright information
AQA retains the copyright on all its publications. However, registered schools/colleges for AQA are permitted to copy material from this booklet for their own
internal use, with the following important exception: AQA cannot give permission to schools/colleges to photocopy any material that is acknowledged to a third
party even for internal use within the centre.
2
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Before you apply the mark scheme to a student’s answer read through the answer and annotate it (as
instructed) to show the qualities that are being looked for. You can then apply the mark scheme.
When assigning a level you should look at the overall quality of the answer and not look to pick holes in
small and specific parts of the answer where the student has not performed quite as well as the rest. If
the answer covers different aspects of different levels of the mark scheme you should use a best fit
approach for defining the level and then use the variability of the response to help decide the mark within
the level, ie if the response is predominantly level 3 with a small amount of level 4 material it would be
placed in level 3 but be awarded a mark near the top of the level because of the level 4 content.
You may well need to read back through the answer as you apply the mark scheme to clarify points and
assure yourself that the level and the mark are appropriate.
Indicative content in the mark scheme is provided as a guide for examiners. It is not intended to be
exhaustive and you must credit other valid points. Students do not have to cover all of the points
mentioned in the Indicative content to reach the highest level of the mark scheme.
An answer which contains nothing of relevance to the question must be awarded no marks.
Examiners are reminded that AO1 and AO2 are regarded as interdependent. When deciding on a mark
in instances where there is an attempt at more than one assessment objective all attempts should be
considered together using the best fit approach. In doing so, examiners should bear in mind the relative
weightings of the assessment objectives.
When an answer only contains content related to one of the skills (AO1/AO2), then the levels descriptors
for the award of marks for the skill attempted should be applied to the answer, up to the maximum mark
available.
3
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Section A
Memory
01 Which is the best example of information that would be stored as procedural memory?
Answer – B
Answer – A
4
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
3 Detailed 4–5 Analysis and evaluation of the multi-store model of memory is effective.
Any conclusions drawn are sound and fully expressed.
2 Clear 2–3 There may be some effective analysis and evaluation of the multi-store
model of memory. There may be an attempt to draw conclusions.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
• The multi-store model of memory does not explain how you can remember some information even
though you have not rehearsed it and also struggles to explain why we can forget information that we
have practised and rehearsed.
• There is research evidence to support the idea that there are distinct sensory, short-term and long-
term memory stores. Research shows that sensory, short-term and long-term memory are usually
encoded in different forms and also differ in their duration and capacity.
• It can provide practical ideas for how to remember things more effectively. For example, we need to
pay attention when our teacher is talking to us because information is only passed from sensory to
short-term memory if we pay attention to it.
• The multi-store model has been criticised for being oversimplified. For example, it states we have one
single long-term memory store. However, other research evidence has shown that there are several
types of long-term memory; procedural, episodic and semantic.
5
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
2 Clear 3–4 Clear and accurate knowledge and understanding of Bartlett’s War of the
Ghosts study with some detail.
1 Basic 1–2 Limited or muddled knowledge and understanding of Bartlett’s War of the
Ghosts study is present.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO1
• To investigate how memory for an unfamiliar story is affected by cultural expectations or to see how
memory is reconstructed.
• British participants were given a Native American Indian story called ‘The War of the Ghosts’.
• After a short period of time, they were asked to retell the story. This took place several times.
• Bartlett found that participants remembered the key themes in the story. However, the story was
shortened when it was retold and some parts were omitted.
• Participants altered some details of the story to fit in with their own cultural experiences. For example,
they changed ‘canoes’ to ‘boats’.
• Bartlett concluded that how stories are remembered depends on existing cultural knowledge or
schemas.
6
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
05 Use your knowledge of the theory of reconstructive memory to explain why each
eyewitness gave different descriptions of the same robber.
[6 marks]
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO1
• Memory is not like a video recording. This means that memories may not be an accurate version of
events.
• Memory is an active process in which we try to make sense of events and information using our
previous knowledge and experience (effort after meaning).
• We can alter our memories so that they fit in with our social and cultural expectations/schemas.
7
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
AO2
• The two eyewitnesses gave different descriptions of the same robber because they made sense of the
events they saw in different ways.
• Their own experiences and expectations such as what they have heard in the news or seen in films
will shape how they remember the robber.
• One eyewitness may have expected robbers to carry a weapon which explains why they remember
him as carrying a knife.
• The other eyewitness may have a stereotype that people who commit crimes often wear hoodies
which explains why they remember him as wearing a hoodie.
Possible content:
• It does not help us to understand why some memories are not actively reconstructed and are
remembered accurately.
• Some research has found that recall of familiar / personal and unambiguous stories can be accurate
and detailed. This suggests that not all events are changed and reconstructed when they are recalled.
Note: Evaluation of the ‘War of the Ghosts’ study alone, without reference to how that impacts on the
theory, can get a maximum of 1 mark.
8
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
07 You have been asked to investigate the effect of context on the accuracy of memory.
• what you would ask participants to do and what data you would collect
• one extraneous variable that could affect your results and how you could control it
• the results you would expect to find from your experiment.
[6 marks]
AO2
PLUS
PLUS
Up to 2 marks for one relevant extraneous variable and how it would be controlled.
AO3
2 marks: a clear and accurate description of the expected results with both conditions of the IV.
NOTE: if a student only describes a known study rather than basing their design on a known study (max
1 mark).
NOTE: The extraneous variable and control may be creditworthy even if the study is not.
9
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Section B
Perception
A. Convergence
B. Height in plane
C. Linear perspective
D. Relative size
E. Retinal disparity
[2 marks]
A, E
09 Which is the best explanation for the visual illusion known as the Ames room?
A. Ambiguity
B. Fiction
C. Occlusion
D. Size constancy
[1 mark]
10
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
2 Clear 3–4 Analysis and evaluation of Gibson’s direct theory of perception is effective.
Any conclusions drawn are sound and fully expressed.
1 Basic 1–2 Analysis and evaluation of Gibson’s direct theory of perception is of limited
effectiveness or muddled. Any attempts to draw conclusions are not always
successful.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
• Gibson’s theory cannot explain why perception is sometimes inaccurate, for example when our brain
is tricked by visual illusions.
• Gibson’s theory provides a good explanation for how we are usually able to perceive quickly and
accurately in everyday life using information from the optic array.
• Gibson’s theory has helped us to understand the richness of the optical information our eyes receive,
such as texture and colour gradient.
• Gibson developed his theory using evidence collected in real life settings such as using pilots rather
than through laboratory experiments. This increases the validity of his theory.
• Evidence shows that factors such as expectation and culture affect perception. This challenges
Gibson’s theory and suggests that nurture (knowledge and past experience) also play an important
role in perception.
• There is research evidence to support the idea that depth perception is innate. Gibson and Walk
found that infants have abilities for perceiving depth even at a very young age. This supports the idea
that perception may be due to nature.
11
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
NOTE: The two longer lines need to be similar in length, but not necessarily identical, to be creditworthy.
Possible content:
• The illusion occurs because of misinterpreted depth cues caused by the arrows at the end of each
line.
• The arrow heads with outward fins make the line look like the near edge of a building/close to us.
• The arrow heads with inward fins make the line look like the far corner of a room/far away from us.
• We unconsciously scale up the line with inward fins thinking that as it is farther away than the line with
outward fins it must be longer.
12
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
12.1 Calculate the percentage of students in Group B who saw Figure 1 as a rabbit.
State your answer using two significant figures and show your workings.
[3 marks]
13
2 marks for the correct percentage but not rounded to two significant figures.
2/15 x 100
12.2 Which of the following is the correct fraction of Group A who saw Figure 1 as a duck?
13
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
12.3 Use your knowledge of one factor that affects perception to explain the results shown in
Table 1.
[4 marks]
2 Clear 3–4 AO1: Clear and accurate knowledge of the effect of expectation on
perception with some detail.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO1
• One factor affecting perception is expectation. We often perceive what we expect or anticipate
seeing.
• Our past experiences shape what we expect to see (create a perceptual set) so that we are more
ready to perceive some objects than others.
AO2
• In this experiment, Group A were shown pictures of rabbits before they were shown Figure 1, which is
an ambiguous image. They were ready to perceive another rabbit due to this recent experience
(perceptual set). This is why 11 out of 15 participants in Group A saw Figure 1 as a rabbit and only 3
out of 15 saw a duck.
• In this experiment, 13 out of 15 participants in Group B saw a duck compared with 3 out of 15 in
Group A. This was because only Group B were shown pictures of ducks before they were shown
Figure 1, which is an ambiguous image.
14
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
13 Outline how culture can affect perception. Refer to both Marc and José’s comments in
your answer.
[4 marks]
2 Clear 3–4 AO1: Clear and accurate knowledge and understanding of how culture can
affect perception with some detail.
1 Basic 1–2 AO1: Limited or muddled knowledge and understanding of how culture can
affect perception is present.
OR
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO1
• The culture in which we live influences our upbringing, experiences and how we make sense of the
world around us.
• Gregory’s constructivist theory of perception says we use our stored knowledge and experiences
when we perceive things.
• This leads us to have cultural expectations which shape the way we perceive the world around us.
AO2
• Marc has grown up on a farm so is more likely to know what farm animals eat. This is why he thinks
the cat is the odd one out as the sheep eats grass.
• José has grown up in a city so he is more likely to think of animals as pets. This is why he thinks the
grass is the odd one out.
15
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Possible content:
• One strength is it gives researchers a high level of control over extraneous variables.
• This makes it easier to measure how the independent variable affects the dependent variable.
• One strength is it is easier to standardise procedures.
• This makes it easier for other researchers to replicate research using different samples.
16
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Section C
Development
15 Sienna is planning her holiday. Which part of the brain plays a key role in this activity?
A. Brain stem
B. Cerebellum
C. Cortex
D. Thalamus
[1 mark]
16 Matt is looking at a drawing of how castles were designed. Which one of the following
learning styles is he using?
A. Fixed
B. Growth
C. Verbaliser
D. Visualiser
[1 mark]
17 According to Piaget’s theory of cognitive development, during which stage will a child first
start to look for something that has been hidden from view?
A. Concrete operational
B. Formal operational
C. Pre-operational
D. Sensorimotor
[1 mark]
17
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
18.1 Outline one example of how Mr Taylor can use praise to improve Jana’s learning.
[2 marks]
Examples:
• he can send email home when she completes a good piece of work
• he can say well done when she puts good effort into a task
• he can give her a merit for answering a question in class.
NOTE: Answers that give an example, and an explanation of how the example can increase learning can
be considered fair and accurate.
18.2 Outline one example of how Mr Taylor can increase Jana’s self-efficacy.
[2 marks]
Examples:
• he can set her easier questions so that she can complete them successfully
• he can break down tasks into steps and help her to complete one step at a time
• he can point out to Jana that other students get stuck then work to overcome problems
• he can praise Jana when she successfully completes tasks, plus an explanation of how this can
increase Jana’s self-efficacy.
18
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
19 Use your knowledge of both negative schemas as an explanation for depression and
Dweck’s Mindset theory of learning to explain why these two students responded in
different ways.
Briefly evaluate both negative schemas as an explanation for depression and Dweck’s
Mindset theory.
[9 marks]
3 Detailed 7–9 AO1: Relevant knowledge and understanding of Dweck’s Mindset theory
of learning and negative schemas as an explanation for depression is
accurate with detail.
2 Clear 4–6 AO1: Relevant knowledge and understanding of Dweck’s Mindset theory
of learning and/or negative schemas as an explanation for depression is
present but there are occasional inaccuracies/omissions.
1 Basic 1–3 AO1: Knowledge and understanding of Dweck’s Mindset theory of learning
and/or negative schemas as an explanation for depression is present but
limited.
19
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO1
• People with a fixed mindset believe that success is due to innate factors like genes. This means there
is nothing you can do to change your ability or talent.
• People with a growth mindset believe that ability and success is due to hard work and perseverance.
• Negative schemas lead people to interpret events in a biased way. They tend to interpret things in
pessimistic ways and often ignore more positive ways of viewing events.
AO2
• Mason’s comments suggest he has a fixed mindset. He thinks there will always be other people more
talented than him and that here is nothing he can do to change this.
• Kyle’s comments suggest he has a growth mindset. He is using feedback from the coach to improve
his fitness and increase the likelihood of being chosen in the future.
• Mason’s comments suggest he may have negative schemas because he only sees the bad things
about this situation. For example, he has decided the coach does not like him even though there is no
evidence that this is the case.
AO3
• One strength of mindset theory is that people can change their mindset and this can be used to
improve performance in different contexts such as at school, in sports or in the workplace.
• Knowledge and understanding of negative schemas has led to effective treatments for mental health
disorders like depression through helping people to identify and challenge their negative patterns of
thinking.
20
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
20 Hughes investigated egocentrism in his ‘policeman doll study’. Describe this study.
[4 marks]
2 Clear 3–4 Clear and accurate knowledge and understanding of Hughes’ policeman
doll study with some detail.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
• Thirty children aged from 3.5 to 5 years old took part in the laboratory study.
• Hughes tested egocentrism using a model of two intersecting walls, a boy doll and two policeman
dolls.
• To introduce the task, a policeman doll was placed on the model. Each child was asked to hide the
boy doll from the policeman doll.
• The child was told if they made a mistake, and was allowed to try the task again.
• In the actual experiment, a second policeman doll was placed on the model and the child was asked
to hide the boy doll so that neither of the policeman dolls could see him.
• Ninety percent of the children were able to hide the boy doll from the policeman dolls.
• Hughes concluded that most children between 3.5 and 5 years old can see things from another
person’s point of view so are not egocentric in their thinking.
21
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
3 Detailed 4–5 Evaluation of Hughes’ ‘Policeman doll study’ is effective. Any conclusions
drawn are sound and fully expressed.
2 Clear 2–3 There may be some effective evaluation of Hughes’ ‘Policeman doll study’.
There may be an attempt to draw conclusions.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO3
• One strength of the study is that asking children to hide a doll made the task engaging and meaningful
to children. It can be argued that this meant children were better able to show their cognitive ability
than in Piaget’s original research.
• A limited sample of children was used as all of the participants came from Edinburgh. This means it
may be problematic to generalise these findings to explain when children from other cultures can see
things from another person’s point of view.
• Other research studies support the findings that some children under seven-years-old can see things
from other person’s point of view.
• One strength of this study is that it challenged Piaget’s conclusion that children are egocentric in their
thinking until the age of about seven-years-old. It suggested that some children can see the world
from different viewpoints at a significantly younger age than was previously thought.
NOTE: Answers that only give generic evaluations are considered to be Basic.
22
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Section D
Research Methods
22 Which two of the following are commonly understood to be advantages of case studies?
D, E
23 Which one of the following statistics is calculated by finding the difference between the
smallest and largest values in a set of data?
A. Mean
B. Median
C. Mode
D. Range
[1 mark]
23
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of both of these types of experimental design.
[9 marks]
2 Clear 4–6 AO1: Relevant knowledge and understanding of independent groups and
repeated measures is present but there are occasional
inaccuracies/omissions.
1 Basic 1–3 AO1: Knowledge and understanding of independent groups and repeated
measures is present but limited.
0 0 No relevant content.
Possible content:
AO1
• In an independent groups design, different participants are used for each condition of the independent
variable.
• This usually means that one group of participants completes the control condition and a different
group of participants completes the experimental condition.
24
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
AO3
• With an independent groups design, participant variables such as intelligence may influence the
results for each group. This means it can be problematic to compare the results of the experimental
group to the control group.
• A repeated measures design has no participant variables as the same participants take parts in both
conditions. This means the results for each participant for both conditions can be directly compared.
• More participants are needed with an independent groups design as you need a different group of
participants for each condition.
• Less participants are needed in a repeated measures design as only one group of participants is used
so this can be less expensive and quicker.
• With an independent groups design there are no order effects as participants only complete one
condition.
25.1 Outline one strength of using a stratified sample when conducting research.
[2 marks]
Possible content:
AO3
• Stratified samples are representative because they ensure each subgroup of the target population is
included in the sample. This increases generalisability.
• Participants are selected randomly from subgroups, this decreases the possibility of investigator bias.
25
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
PLUS
25.3 When collecting information about mental well-being, explain why collecting qualitative
data rather than quantitative data may increase the validity of the data collected by the
researcher?
[2 marks]
Possible content:
• When qualitative data is collected people are not limited by a list of fixed responses, because they
express their mental well-being in their own words.
• This increases the validity of the data collected as these responses will better represent their actual
mental well-being.
25.4 Identify the mode for the average daily exercise scores shown in Table 3.
[1 mark]
Mode = 30
Accept 30 (minutes)
26
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
25.5 Calculate the median for the average mental well-being scores shown in Table 3.
[1 mark]
Median = 11
25.6 Use the graph paper to sketch a scatter diagram to show the results shown in Table 3.
A graph to show the relationship between mean mental well-being scores and mean daily exercise
27
MARK SCHEME – GCSE PSYCHOLOGY PAPER 1 – 8182/1 – JUNE 2020
25.7 Identify the type of correlation the researcher has found between exercise and mental
well-being.
A. Negative correlation
B. No correlation
C. Perfect correlation
D. Positive correlation
[1 mark]
28