Treating Dementia With Vitamin B3 and NADH 26.4
Treating Dementia With Vitamin B3 and NADH 26.4
Treating Dementia With Vitamin B3 and NADH 26.4
Abstract Dementia affects approximately 5 million people in the United States, and about 475,000
elderly Canadians. Dementia is a debilitating and often progressive illness. The most common type
of dementia is Alzheimer’s disease, followed by vascular types. There is a need to investigate novel
treatments because the current crop of medications have limited value. Niacin might be a worthwhile
treatment to consider. Research has shown that the risks of incident AD increase when patients have
insufficient intakes of niacin from diet or medical conditions that precipitate niacin deficiency. Clini-
cal reports have documented therapeutic benefits when patients receive optimum daily doses of niacin.
Preliminary trials evaluating the reduced form of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) found
it a safe and effective treatment for AD. At present, research evaluating the therapeutic applications of
niacin and/or NADH for dementia is at a standstill. However, niacinamide is being evaluated in a
clinical trial to determine if it is safe and beneficial for patients with AD. Hopefully, the forthcoming
results will encourage researchers and clinicians to study niacinamide further, and revisit the therapeu-
tic potential of vitamin B3 as a safe and an effective treatment for dementia.
with the former treatment having only weak participants were reported to have pellagra
evidence of benefit on cognitive function.4 (i.e., diarrhoea, dermatitis, dementia, and
Clearly there is a need to investigate other shortly thereafter, death), some participants
treatments because the current crop of med- who demonstrated mental and cognitive de-
ications have limited value in mitigating the clines may not have met the recommended
progression and symptoms of dementia, most dietary allowance for niacin (14 mg for adult
notably, AD. In this article, I will summarize females and 16 mg for adult males6). Some
and comment on: (1) research linking a re- of the study participants may have had sub-
duction in the incidence of AD with high clinical pellagra.
dietary intakes of vitamin B3; (2) the merits The mental signs of mild niacin deficien-
of using niacin or the reduced form of nico- cy (a.k.a., pellagra sine pellagra) often occur
tinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) as in the absence of any dermatologic, mucous
treatments for dementia; and (3) current re- membrane, or gastrointestinal symptoms.7,8
search investigating the safety and efficacy of The researchers did not acknowledge that
niacinamide as a treatment for AD. niacin deficiency can lead to symptoms of
AD, and thereby play a role in the patho-
Preventing AD with Vitamin B3 genesis of AD. Decades ago Aring and Spies
Research has shown a relationship be- reported that neurasthenic symptoms in 225
tween dietary niacin and the development of mild pellagrins were ameliorated by taking
AD.5 A total of 3,718 participants aged 65 300 to 600 mg of niacin every day for 1-12
years and older underwent at least two clini- days (3-6 pills, with each pill providing 100
cal assessments and provided dietary data for mg of niacin).8 The neurasthenic symptoms
analyses over a median of 5.5 years. In this reversed by niacin appeared long before any
large, prospective study, dietary niacin defi- other manifestations of the disease. These
ciencies were associated with incident AD included fatigue, insomnia, anorexia, vertigo,
and cognitive decline. Niacin intake from burning sensations in various parts of the
foods was inversely associated with AD body, numbness, palpitation, nervousness, a
(p for trend = 0.002). A higher food intake feeling of unrest and anxiety, headache, for-
of niacin was associated with a slower annual getfulness, apprehension, and distractibil-
rate of cognitive decline. Specifically, an in- ity. These niacin-deficiency manifestations
creased food intake of niacin slowed the an- could easily be confused with prodromal
nual cognitive decline by 0.019 standardized symptoms of AD, and, if left untreated, they
units per natural log increase in intake (mg), could become severe enough for a diagnosis
which was statistically significant (p=0.05). of AD. The dementia of pellagra looks much
The participants in intake quintiles 2-4 had a like AD since its clinical presentation, while
statistically significant 70% reduction in risk varied, includes aggression, apathy, confu-
compared to participants in the lowest quin- sion, depression, disorientation, hallucina-
tile (median niacin intake 12.6 mg/day). The tions, insomnia, psychosis, and seizures.9
participants in the highest quintile (median Low dietary intakes of niacin would not
niacin intake 22.4 mg/day) had an 80% sta- entirely account for the increased incidence
tistically significant reduction in risk. of AD among the study participants. Many
These researchers did not provide any participants had varying intakes of alcohol
robust explanations as to why diagnoses of and cigarette consumption, as well as the
AD increased among participants with low presence of diabetes and/or cardiovascu-
dietary intakes of niacin but they did note lar disease. These and other possible factors
that the level of dietary niacin associated could have increased the participants’ vulner-
with pellagra (8.8 mg of niacin equivalents ability to niacin deficiency during the study
per 2000 kilocalories) was lower than the period (Table 1, opposite).7
range of intake for the lowest quintile (13.2- Above all, this study demonstrates that
27 mg per day). While none of the study insufficient intake of niacin from diet or
Interference with storage Any condition causing impairment of liver function would
interfere with the amount of niacin retained in the body
Increased nutritive requirements Urinary loss (e.g., renal disease, and diabetes), or
other routes (e.g., lactation, serous exudates due to
burns, and severe blood loss)
conditions that can precipitate vitamin defi- if a patient’s psychiatric condition was due to
ciency can increase the risks of incident AD. a deficiency of niacin (i.e., an “avitaminosis”)
As more data emerges linking niacin insuf- even though the aetiology was uncertain. In a
ficiency to AD, it might be prudent to create discussion following their paper, other clini-
public health programmes to promote niacin cians remarked that the therapeutic value of
consumption from foods or increase niacin niacin could not necessarily be attributed to
fortification. Such measures could protect the correction of a vitamin deficiency. They
more of the population from mental and reported that niacin might have helped some
cognitive decline, and reduce the incidence patients as a result of its physiological effects
of dementia. upon cerebral circulation, and/or as a result of
its ability to facilitate carbohydrate metabo-
Treating Dementia with Niacin lism within the brain.
Subsets of patients with early or even In 1952, Gregory administered large
established dementia appear to require large doses of niacin orally (300 mg three times
daily doses of niacin to reverse and/or slow daily) and intravenously (100 mg/day) to 54
the progress of their disease. In 1941, Syden- patients having organic psychoses of senil-
stricker and Cleckley were two of the first ity immediately following their admission
clinicians to report impressive benefits from to a private mental hospital.11 During their
oral and intravenous niacin administration in hospital stays, patients were also given a nu-
29 patients with stuporous or active psycho- tritious diet and liberal amounts of other
ses of unknown origin.10 Two-thirds of their vitamins. All patients were evaluated before
patients were in the presenile or senile age treatment and immediately following any
range with severe psychiatric symptoms of degree of improvement. The evaluations in-
a confusional nature, but none had physical cluded thorough psychiatric examinations
signs of malnutrition or pellagra. Twenty- (with particular reference to orientation,
eight patients recovered after niacin treat- memory, and secondary symptoms), as well
ment. Eight patients received oral niacin as intelligence tests. The duration of niacin
treatment, while the remaining 21 patients treatment was approximately 3-12 weeks.
received intravenous niacin or a combination Once patients became maximally improved,
of oral and intravenous niacin. The oral niacin they were placed on a maintenance dose of
prescribed to patients ranged from 75-4500 niacin (100 mg orally/day). In the group
mg daily until discharge. The intravenous of 14 patients 65 years of age and under, 8
doses of niacin ranged from 100-900 mg. patients improved dramatically following
For most patients, the intravenous admin- niacin treatment. They were able to leave the
istration continued until discharge, but for hospital, whereas the remaining 6 patients
some patients, intravenous treatments were improved symptomatically or not at all. In
stopped and replaced by oral niacin until dis- the group of 40 patients over the age of 65,
charge. Within 4 days of niacin treatment, 31 completed the course of niacin treatment.
the majority of these patients experienced Only 4 patients from the over-65 group
rapid and usually impressive improvements. improved enough to re-socialize. The au-
While the duration of niacin treatment was thor concluded that “nicotinic acid is most
unclear, estimates from the cited case reports effective in those psychoses of senility that
suggest 7-30 days or longer since some pa- are of recent, and fairly rapid, onset,” which
tients continued with the niacin treatment was reported to be of a duration less than 6
following their hospital stay. The authors months. The findings showed that the earlier
concluded that the majority of patients with niacin treatment was started, the better the
toxic psychosis or exhaustion delirium, as well prognosis, especially among patients 65 years
as those with unexplained clouding of con- of age and under. With respect to mecha-
sciousness, should be given a therapeutic trial nism of action, the author discussed several
of niacin. This was the only way to determine possibilities including: (1) the correction of
a niacin deficiency; (2) a “saturation” effect leagues discovered that 3,000 mg/day of
in the absence of any deficiency; and/or (3) niacin improved and sometimes reversed
cerebral vasodilatation. The author also sug- dementia.12 Hoffer’s patients required large
gested that lesser amounts of niacin might daily doses of niacin to remain well (Table
delay or prevent the psychoses of senility if 2, below).
given to individuals in the presenile and se- In total, 12 of 15 elderly patients re-
nile age groups. sponded favourably to large doses of niacin.
In 1962, Dr. Abram Hoffer and his col- Table 3 (p. 168) describes the type of clinical
Table 2. Treatment response from large (3000 mg/day) doses of niacin in 15 elderly patients
fast becoming senile or with clear evidence of senile mental changes
Patient Age Diagnosis Clinical response Duration
Initials (years)
OR 62 Psychosis Recovered 4
with arteriosclerosis
Table 3. Brief clinical descriptions of the therapeutic effects of niacin in elderly patients
Case JC (Age 80): In February, 1959, this woman had a mild coronary occlusion. She
developed generalized weakness, weakness grasping with one hand, anorexia, and ataxia.
She was also nervous and had feelings of confusion and hopelessness. During April, 1959,
she began to take three grams of nicotinic acid daily. Within a few weeks, her appetite
improved and she felt stronger. By June, she was able to walk slowly but well. Mentally, she
was much improved. She still had a few episodes of nervousness preceding social events.
There was no more confusion and her memory was good. For the next year, she continued
to improve and in April, 1960, she was quite well. In May, 1960, she had influenza and later
that month she died from a coronary occlusion and secondary metastasis of a bowel carci-
noma. She had been mentally alert up to three days before dying, when she sank quietly
into her fatal coma.
Case GC (Age 75): For several months Mr. G.C. complained of violent dizzy spells, with
headaches, vomiting and general deterioration. Physically he was normal. In November,
1959, he was given nicotinic acid, three grams daily. Two months later he was much im-
proved. He had no more dizzy spells and regained his normal vigour. April 13, 1960, he ran
out of tablets. There was a rapid relapse and again he complained of headaches and dizzy
spells. Nicotinic acid tablets were sent to him and again he improved.
responses that were observed by Hoffer and cursor), other amino acids and thiamine, and
his colleagues.12 In many of these cases, pa- found them reduced in patients with AD.16
tients who responded to niacin remained im- In these three studies, dietary intakes did not
proved as long as they did not stop the vita- satisfactorily explain the findings.
min. Once they discontinued it, they relapsed Niacin might also aid dementia as a
fairly quickly, but they improved again when result of its well-established cholesterol-
they resumed the vitamin. Hoffer reasoned modifying properties (i.e., lowers low den-
that these patients had metabolic conditions; sity lipoprotein-cholesterol, increases high-
vitamin dependencies which required more density lipoprotein-cholesterol, and lowers
niacin than they obtained from their diets. triglycerides).17 Research has shown choles-
Another case reported by Hoffer in 1974 terol reduction to possibly aid in the treat-
(and mentioned in his book, Smart Nutrients) ment of dementia.18,19 While data regarding
involved his mother who was 86 years old at this relationship is emerging, some published
the time of publication (Table 4, opposite).13 reviews have shown contradictory results
From the cited clinical reports, it is ap- and even negative outcomes from cholester-
parent that niacin administration offers clin- ol-modifying medication.20,21 More studies
ical benefits irrespective of dietary intakes. are needed to determine whether cholesterol
There is likely some metabolic need for ad- modification is a reasonable and effective in-
ditional amounts of niacin among a subset of tervention for dementia.
patients who show early signs of dementia Another possibility for niacin’s effective-
or have established dementia. Two case-con- ness might involve its ability to increase cere-
trolled studies reported lower blood levels of bral blood flow due to its presumed ability to
a nicotinic acid metabolite among patients increase cerebral vasodilatation. When niacin
with dementia compared to similarly aged is administered orally in amounts of 500 mg
controls.14,15 Another study assessed plasma or topically via a 6-inch patch of 10-1 M aque-
concentrations of tryptophan (a niacin pre- ous methylnicotinate on the forearm, prosta-
Table 4. Hoffer’s clinical description of his mother’s response to a daily dose of 3000 mg of niacin
Case CH (Age 86): In 1954…my mother, then 67 years old, was very nervous and de-
pressed and complained of severe pain in her joints, failing vision in one eye, generalized
weakness and fatigue, and severe arthritis of her hands…Her memory was beginning to
fail. It was clear that she was aging very quickly. I knew no treatment was effective but
I was by then familiar with nicotinic acid used in megadoses. I decided to start her on 3
grams per day, more or less as a placebo…To my amazement, mother was nearly well six
weeks later. Her arthritis had cleared, her fingers were straight, and Heberden’s nodes be-
gan to soften and regress. Her vision in both eyes was normal, and her tension, anxiety, and
depression were gone…Today (1974) at 86 she is physically weaker, does not hear as well,
but is mentally well…She has been taking 3 grams each day of nicotinic acid for 18 years. I
have not seen any evidence of toxicity, and there has been no progression of mental senil-
ity which was so apparent 18 years ago.
glandin D2 (PGD2) is markedly released in rebral blood flow and in arterial blood pres-
the skin and high amounts of its metabolite sure in venous vessels of the head, but this
appear in the plasma.22,23 It is not known if was followed by a lowering of these parame-
PGD2 causes vasodilatation of the intracra- ters.27 In a study assessing cerebral blood flow
nial blood vessels, but niacin’s ability to abort in baboons under anaesthesia using single
acute migraine headaches suggests that this photon emission computed tomography of
might be occurring.24 the brain, a combination of niacin and pen-
Old reports cited by Bicknell and tifylline increased cerebral blood flow com-
Prescott,25 indicated that niacin causes vaso- pared to the control baseline (p<0.01).28 In
dilatation of the cerebral and spinal vessels. another study of similar design, the cerebral
They also noted that intravenous niacin ad- blood flow was increased above that of the
ministration increases the rate of intracranial control when a combination of pentyifylline
blood flow in human beings for 20-60 min- and niacin were administered to baboons.29
utes without any significant change in blood The increase in cerebral perfusion (denoted
pressure. Other published data pertaining to as an increase in R-value) was +29 % from
niacin’s effects on cerebral vasodilatation has the pentyifylline-niacin combination (2.31 ±
been equivocal. In one study, subjects hav- 0.19) compared to the control (1.79 ± 0.13).
ing various diseases (e.g., pernicious anemia, Based on these reports, it appears that
congestive heart failure, hysteria, diabetes, intravenously-administered niacin might
and hypertensive vascular disease) were giv- increase cerebral blood flow. More intra-
en intravenous niacin (300-800 mg in 200- venous niacin studies are warranted. Al-
300 mL of saline over 20-25 minutes). Nu- though no reports examine the effects of
merous measurements were obtained, such orally-administered niacin upon cerebral
as arterial pressures, blood oxygen contents, blood flow in human or animal subjects, nia-
glucose, cerebral oxygen utilization, cerebral cin could be increasing cerebral blood flow
glucose utilization, and cerebrovascular re- since it has been shown to abort acute mi-
sistance.26 The results of this study failed to graine headaches presumably by vasodilata-
find any effect upon cerebral vasodilatation tion of the intracranial blood vessels.24 This
by the intravenous administration of niacin. potential mechanism of action is important.
In an animal study using anesthetized Data demonstrate that as dementias of the
cats, intravenous injection of niacin (0.5 mL/ Alzheimer and vascular types progress, ce-
kg) caused a short-term increase in both ce- rebral blood flow and metabolism become
Table 5. Niacin’s purported mechanisms of action in the treatment of AD and vascular types
of dementia
t3FTPMWFTNFUBCPMJDEFQFOEFODZCZSFQMFUJOHFO[ZNFDPGBDUPST
t*ODSFBTFTDFSFCSBMCMPPEnPXWJBWBTPEJMBUBUJPO
t4UJNVMBUFTDFMMVMBSNFUBCPMJTNCZJODSFBTJOHUIFQSPEVDUJPOPGOJDPUJOBNJEFBEFOJOF
dinucleotide
t3FEVDFTBYPOBMEBNBHFBOEJODSFBTFTBYPOBMEFOTJUZCZEFDSFBTJOHUIFFYQSFTTJPOPG
amyloid precursor protein
39. Demarin V, Podobnik SS, Storga-Tomic D, et al: PGC-1 and BDNF gene expression in a mouse
Treatment of Alzheimer’s disease with stabilized model of Huntington’s disease. Neurobiol Dis,
oral nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide: a ran- 2011; 41: 43-50.
domized, double-blind study. Drugs Exp Clin Res, 44. Anderson DW, Bradbury KA, Schneider JS:
2004; 30: 27-33. Broad neuroprotective profile of nicotinamide in
40. Demarin V, Sarkanji SP, Storga-Tomic D, et al: different mouse models of MPTP-induced par-
ENADA/NADH improves cognitive impair- kinsonism. Eur J Neurosci, 2008; 28: 610-617.
ment of Alzheimer patients. International Confer- 45. Green KN, Steffan JS, Martinez-Coria H, et al:
ence on Mechanisms and Actions of Neutraceuticals, Nicotinamide restores cognition in Alzheimer’s
2002 (October 6-9), Kerms, Danube. disease transgenic mice via a mechanism involv-
41. Schreiber SS: Safety study of nicotinamide to ing sirtuin inhibition and selective reduction of
treat Alzheimer’s disease. Retrieved from:[www. Thr231-phosphotau. J Neurosci, 2008; 28: 11500-
clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT00580931?term=N 11510.
iacin+and+alzheimer%27s&rank=1]. 46. Foster TL: Liver function and nutrition in rela-
42. Hivert B, Cerruti C, Camu W: Hydrogen perox- tion to toxic psychoses. J Nerv Ment Dis, 1949;
ide-induced motoneuron apoptosis is prevented 110: 1-25.
by poly ADP ribosyl synthetase inhibitors. Neu- 47. Lin S-H, Chong ZZ, Maiese K: Nicotinamide:
roreport, 1998; 9: 1835-1838. a nutritional supplement that provides protection
43. Hathorn T, Snyder-Keller A, Messer A: Nicoti- against neuronal and vascular injury. J Med Food,
namide improves motor deficits and upregulates 2001; 4: 27-38.