1.CFA二级基础段固收 Cherie 标准版
1.CFA二级基础段固收 Cherie 标准版
1.CFA二级基础段固收 Cherie 标准版
:
育
CFA二级培训项目
教
程
金
讲师:Cherie
1/248
Cherie
➢ 工作职称:金程教育资深培训师,CFA FRM
➢ 教育背景:新南威尔士大学金融学硕士
➢ 工作背景:单晨玮老师毕业于新南威尔士大学金融学专业,学术功底深厚。单老
师曾亲自参与中国工商银行总行、中国银行总行、中国建设银行、民生银行总行、
杭州银行、杭州联合银行、国泰君安、南京审计学院、西安工业大学、西安外国
语大学等CFA培训项目。在金程讲授CFA培训课程,累计课时达6000小时,课程
清晰易懂,深受学员欢迎。
:
育
➢ 讲授课程:CFA一、二、三级
教
➢ 参与出版:曾参与出版了注册金融分析师系列丛书、金程教育CFA课堂笔记、CF
程
金
A冲刺宝典、CFA中文NOTES等公开出版物及内部出版物。并参与翻译CFA协会
官方参考书《企业理财》,《国际财务报告分析》等书籍。
2/248
Topic Weightings in CFA Level II
Content Weightings
Quantitative Methods 5-10
Economics 5-10
Derivatives 5-10
程
4/248
Learning
Module
1
:
育
教
程
5/248
1. Benchmark curve
Framework 2. Yield Spread
6/248
1.1 Spot Rates
➢ Spot rate: the yield to maturity of the single payment.
➢ Discount factor :the price today of 1 dollar face value, zero coupon bond
is known as the discount factor, DFN.
1
𝐷𝐹𝑁 = 𝑁
1 + 𝑍𝑁
➢ Spot yield curve (spot curve): the term structure of spot rates – the graph
of the spot rate 𝑆𝑇 versus the maturity T.
:
育
⚫ The shape and level of the spot yield curve are dynamic.
教
⚫ Each point on the spot yield curve reflects the spot interest rate with
程
金
7/248
1.2 Forward Rates
➢ A Forward rate is an interest rate that is determined today for a loan that
will be initiated in a future time period.
➢ The term structure of forward rates is called the forwards curve.
➢ Discount Factor: DF(A,B-A)
1
𝐷𝐹𝐴,𝐵−𝐴 = 𝐵 _𝐴
1 + 𝑓𝐴,𝐵−𝐴
⚫ 𝑓𝐴,𝐵−𝐴 = the discount rate of a unit principal payment initiated A years
:
⚫ 𝐷𝐹𝐴,𝐵−𝐴 : a forward price at time A from today for a 1 dollar par zero-
程
➢ Forward rates model (the relationship between spot rate and forward rate):
𝐵 𝐴 𝐵−𝐴
1 + 𝑍𝐵 = 1 + 𝑍𝐴 1 + 𝑓𝐴 ,𝐵−𝐴
8/248
Example
➢ The spot rates for three hypothetical zero-coupon bonds (zeros) with
maturities of one, two, and three years are given in the following table.
Maturity(T) 1 2 3
Spot rate r(1)=9% r(2)=10% r(3)=11%
⚫ Calculate the forward rate for a one-year zero issued one year from
today, f(1,1)
⚫ Calculate the forward rate for a one-year zero issued two years
:
⚫ Calculate the forward rate for a two-year zero issued one year from
程
today, f(1,2).
金
9/248
Example
⚫ f(1,1) is calculated as follows
(1.10)2
f (1,1) = − 1 = 11.01%
1.09
⚫ f(2,1) is calculated as follows
(1.11)3
f (2,1) = − 1 = 13.03%
(1.10) 2
:
育
(1.11)3
f (1, 2) = − 1 = 12.01%
1.09
10/248
Spot Rates and Forward Rates
➢ Relationship between spot rate and forward rate:
⚫ When the spot curve is upward sloping, the forward curve will lie
above the spot curve.
⚫ When the spot curve is downward sloping, the forward curve will lie
below the spot curve.
above (below) the average. In this case, the spot curve represents an
教
average over a whole time period and the forward rates represent the
程
金
11/248
Forward Rates
➢ Forward curve: The term structure of forward rates for a loan made on a
specific initiation date.
:
育
教
程
金
12/248
Spot Rates and Forward Rates
➢ Reinvestment rate that would make an investor indifferent between buying
an eight-year zero-coupon bond or investing in a seven-year zero-coupon
bond and at maturity reinvesting the proceeds for one year. In this sense,
the forward rate can be viewed as a type of breakeven interest rate.
matures in one year. In this sense, the forward rate can be viewed as a rate
育
教
13/248
Spot Rates and Forward Rates
➢ Yield curve shapes:
✓ The existence of risk premiums (e.g., for the greater interest rate
risk of longer-maturity bonds) also contributes to a positive slope.
14/248
Spot Rates and Forward Rates
⚫ An inverted yield curve is somewhat uncommon. Such a term structure
may reflect a market expectation of declining future inflation rates
(because a nominal yield incorporates a premium for expected inflation)
from a relatively high current level.
✓ Expectations of declining economic activity may be one reason
that inflation might be anticipated to decline. A downward-sloping
yield curve has frequently been observed before recessions.
⚫ A flat yield curve typically occurs briefly in the transition from an
:
育
15/248
Forward Pricing Model
➢ Forward pricing model:
✓ Tradable securities with identical cash flow payments must have the
same price. Otherwise, traders would be able to generate risk-free
arbitrage profits;
𝐷𝐹𝐵
𝐹𝐴,𝐵−𝐴 =
金
𝐷𝐹𝐴
16/248
Example
➢ Consider a two-year loan (T = 2) beginning in one year (T* = 1). The
one-year spot rate = 7%. The three-year spot rate = 9%.
➢ Correct Answer:
:
1
⚫ Answer1: 𝐷𝐹3 = = 0.7722
育
1+0.09 3
教
程
1
⚫ Answer2: 𝐷𝐹1 = = 0.9346
金
1+0.07
0.7722
𝐹(1,2) = = 0.8262
0.9346
17/248
Active Bond Portfolio Management
➢ 1. Yield curve movement and the forward curve
⚫ An active portfolio manager will try to outperform the overall bond market by
predicting how the future spot rates will differ from those predicted by current
forward curve.
⚫ Forward contract price remains unchanged as long as future spot rates evolve
as predicted by today's forward curve.
⚫ a change in the forward price reflects a deviation of the spot curve from that
predicted by today's forward curve.
:
✓ if a trader expects that the future spot rate will be lower than what is
育
✓ if the trader expects the future spot rate to be higher than what is
predicted by the existing forward rate, then the forward contract value
is expected to decrease. The trader would sell the forward contract.
18/248
Active Bond Portfolio Management
➢ If a portfolio manager’s projected spot curve is above (below) the forward
curve and his or her expectation turns out to be true, the return will be less
(more) than the one-period risk-free interest rate.
8 108
8+ +
金
1 + 0.08 (1 + 0.08) 2
− 1 = 8%
100
19/248
Active Bond Portfolio Management
➢ 2. If the trader projects that the spot curve one year from today is
above today’s forward curve – for example, a flat yield curve of 9% -
the trader’s expected rate of return is 6.24%, which is less than 8%:
8 108
8+ +
1 + 0.09 (1 + 0.09) 2
− 1 = 6.24%
100
➢ 3. If the trader predicts a flat yield curve of 7%, the trader’s expected
:
育
8 108
金
8+ +
1 + 0.07 (1 + 0.07) 2
− 1 = 9.81%
100
20/248
Active Bond Portfolio Management
➢ 2. Riding the yield curve or rolling down the yield curve
⚫ If the trader does not believe that the yield curve will change its level
and shape over an investment horizon, then buying bonds with a
maturity longer than the investment horizon would provide a total
return greater than the return on a maturity-matching strategy.
:
育
教
程
金
21/248
Example
➢ The following figure shows a hypothetical upward-sloping yield curve and
the price of a 5% annual-pay coupon bond.
Maturity Yield Price
5 5% 100
10 5.5% 96.23
15 6% 90.29
20 6.5% 83.47
25 7% 76.69
30 7.5% 70.47
:
➢ Solution:
育
purchase a bond maturing in five years and earn the 5% coupon but
程
no capital gains.
金
➢ By choosing to buy Bond Z, Nguyen is most likely making which of the following
教
assumption?
程
⚫ recently issued ("on the run") bonds are typically used to create the par
curve because new issues are typically priced at or close to par.
⚫ The zero-coupon rates are determined by using the par yields and
solving for the zero-coupon rates one by one, in order from earliest to
latest maturities, via a process of forward substitution known as
:
bootstrapping.
育
教
程
金
25/248
Example
➢ One-year par rate = 5%, Two-year par rate = 5.97%, Three-year par
rate= 6.91%, Four-year par rate = 7.81%. From these we can bootstrap
zero-coupon rates.
⚫ Zero-Coupon Rates:
Two year zero coupon rate:
0.0597 1 + 0.0597
1= + , r (2) = 6%
(1.05) 1 + r (2)2
26/248
1.4 YTM, Spot Rate and Return on Bonds
➢ Relationship between YTM and Spot rate
⚫ The YTM of these bonds with maturity T would not be the same as the
spot rate at T.
⚫ The YTM of the bond should be some weighted average of spot rates
used in the valuation of the bond.
:
育
27/248
YTM, Spot Rate and Return on Bonds
➢ YTM and the expected return on a bond
⚫ The YTM is
✓ (1) the expected rate of return for a bond that is held until its
maturity
✓ (2) assuming that all coupon and principal payments are made in
:
育
28/248
YTM, Spot Rate and Return on Bonds
➢ YTM is not the expected return on a bond in general.
✓ (4) the bond has one or more embedded options (e.g., put, call, or
教
程
conversion).
金
29/248
1.5 Swap Rate Curve in Valuation
➢ Swap rate: the interest rate for the fixed-rate leg of an interest rate swap.
⚫ Swap floating rates historically referenced short-term survey-based
interest rates, such as three- or six-month US dollar Libor and are slated
to transition to transaction-based market reference rates (MRR) based
on secured overnight funding transactions.
⚫ The level of the swap rate is such that the swap has zero value at the
initiation of the swap agreement.
➢ Determining swap rate
:
育
T
s(T ) 1
1 + r (t ) + =1
教
1 + r (T )
t T
t =1
程
金
⚫ The right side: the value of the floating leg, which is 1 at origination
⚫ The swap rate is determined by equating the value of the fixed leg, on
the left-hand side to the value of the floating rate.
30/248
Example
➢ Suppose a government spot curve implies the following discount
factors: P(1)=0.9524, P(2)=0.8900, P(3)=0.8163, P(4)=0.7350
➢ Determine the swap rate curve based on this information
➢ Correct Answer:
1/2
1
1/1
1 r (2) = − 1 = 6.00%
r (1) = − 1 = 5.00%
0.9524 0.8900
1/3 1/4
1 1
r (3) = − 1 = 7.00% r (4) = − 1 = 8.00%
0.8163 0.7350
s(1) 1 s(1) 1
+ = + =1
1 + r (1) 1 + r (1) + +
1 1 1 1
(1 0.05) (1 0.05)
:
育
⚫ Therefore, s(1)=5%
教
程
1 2 2 1 2 2
⚫ Therefore, s(2)=5.97%
⚫ Similarly, For T=3, s(3)=6.91%; For T=4, s(4)=7.81%
31/248
The Swap Rate Curve
➢ The yield curve of swap rates is called the swap rate curve (swap curve)
⚫ Because it is based on so-called par swaps, in which the fixed rates are
set so that no money is exchanged at contract initiation—the present
values of the fixed-rate and benchmark floating-rate legs being equal—
the swap curve is a type of par curve.
:
育
教
程
金
32/248
The Swap Rate Curve
➢ The swap market is a highly liquid market for two reasons. (liquidity)
⚫ First, unlike bonds, a swap does not have multiple borrowers or lenders, only
counterparties who exchange cash flows.
⚫ Swaps provide one of the most efficient ways to hedge interest rate risk.
➢ Many countries do not have a liquid government bond market with maturities
longer than one year. The swap market has more maturities with which to
construct a yield curve than do government bond markets. (different
maturities)
➢ In countries in which the private sector is much bigger than the public sector,
:
育
swap curve is a far more relevant measure of the time value of money than is the
教
程
⚫ A Libor/swap curve is probably the most widely used interest rate curve
because it is often viewed as reflecting the default risk of private entities at a
rating of about A1/A+, roughly the equivalent of most commercial banks.
33/248
The Swap Rate Curve
➢ Another reason for the popularity of the swap market is that is unregulated
(not controlled by governments), so swap rates are more comparable across
different countries. (unregulated)
➢ Swap rate curves VS government spot curves
⚫ The choice of a benchmark for the time value of money often depends
on the business operations of the institution using the benchmark in the
United States where there is both an active Treasury security market and
a swap market.
:
育
✓ Wholesale banks frequently use the swap curve to value assets and
教
✓ Retail banks with little exposure to the swap market are more likely
to use the government spot curve as their benchmark.
34/248
2.1 Swap Spread
➢ Swap spread: spread paid by the fixed-rate payer of an interest rate swap
over the rate of the “on-the-run” (most recently issued) government
security with the same maturity as the swap.
35/248
Swap Spread
⚫ The Treasury rate can differ from the swap rate for the same term for
several reasons.
✓ Unlike the cash flows from US Treasury bonds, the cash flows from
swaps are subject to much higher default risk.
bonds.
教
程
金
36/248
2.2 I-Spread
➢ I-spreads: bond rates net of the swap rates of the same maturities.
37/248
Example
➢ Bond A has a coupon rate of 5%, and matures in 3.2 years. Its current
yield is 2.85%. Compute the I-spread from the swap rate provided in
the following chart.
Tenor Swap rate
1 1.15%
2 1.59%
3 1.95%
4 2.40%
:
育
教
➢ Correct Answer:
程
0.20(2.4 - 1.95)
3.2 year swap rate = 3 year swap rate + = 2.04%
1.0
I - spread = yield on the bond − swap rate = 2.85 − 2.04 = 0.81%
38/248
2.3 Z-Spread
➢ Z-spread: is the constant basis point spread that would need to be added
to the implied spot yield curve so that the discounted cash flows of a bond
are equal to its current market price.
➢ Correct Answer:
$5 $105
$101.55 = +
(1 + 0.03 + Z ) (1 + 0.04 + Z ) 2
⚫ Z-spread = 20 bps
:
育
教
程
金
40/248
2.4 TED Spread
➢ Market participants often use interest rate spreads between short-term
government and risky rates as a barometer to evaluate relative credit
and liquidity risk.
⚫ For example, the difference between Libor and the yield on a
Treasury bill of the same maturity, or TED spread, has historically
been a key indicator of perceived credit and liquidity risk.
✓ TED = LIBOR – T-bill rate
⚫ It is an indicator of perceived credit and liquidity risk.
:
育
benchmark for the lowest default risk instruments in a given market, and
金
loans between banks (often at Libor) have some counterparty risk, the
TED spread is considered to at least in part reflect default (or
counterparty) risk in the banking sector.
41/248
2.5 Libor–OIS Spread
➢ Another popular measure of such risk is the Libor–OIS spread, which is the
difference between Libor and the overnight indexed swap (OIS) rate.
⚫ An OIS is an interest rate swap in which the periodic floating rate of the
swap equals the geometric average of a daily unsecured overnight
rate (or overnight index rate).
✓ The index rate is typically the rate for overnight unsecured lending
between banks, such as the federal funds rate for US dollars.
⚫ As market participants transition away from survey-based Libor to
alternative benchmarks based on actual transaction data, the secured
:
43/248
Term Structure of Interest Rates
➢ The implications for the shape of the yield curve under the
expectations theory are:
⚫ For a upward sloping yield curve, it implies that the short-term rate
are expected to rise.
⚫ For a downward sloping yield curve, it implies that the short-term rate
are expected to decline.
⚫ A flat yield curve implies that the market expects short-term rates to
remain constant
:
育
教
程
金
44/248
Term Structure of Interest Rates
➢ Local Expectation Theory
⚫ A theory that is similar but more rigorous than the unbiased
expectations theory is the local expectations theory. This theory
instead contends that the expected return for every bond over short
time periods is the risk-free rate.
✓ Although the theory requires that risk premiums be nonexistent for
very short holding periods, no such restrictions are placed on
longer-term investments.
:
育
教
程
金
45/248
3.2 Term Structure of Interest Rates
➢ Liquidity preference theory
⚫ Description:
✓ Liquidity preference theory asserts that liquidity premium exist to
compensate investors for the added interest rate risk they face when
lending long term and that these premiums increase with maturity.
✓ The theory suggests that this liquidity premium is positively related
to maturity. Thus, given an expectation of unchanging short-term spot
rates, liquidity preference theory predicts an upward-sloping yield curve.
✓ The forward rate provides an estimate of the expected spot rate that
:
育
◆ f= E(s)+liquidity premium
程
✓ For example, because the liabilities of pension plans are long term,
they typically invest in long-term securities.
47/248
3.4 Term Structure of Interest Rates
➢ Preferred habitat theory
⚫ The preferred habitat theory is similar to segmented market theory in
proposing that many borrowers and lenders have strong preferences for
particular maturities but it does not assert that yields at different
maturities are determined independently of each other.
✓ If the expected additional returns to be gained become large
enough, institutions will be willing to deviate from their preferred
maturities or habitats.
✓ For example, if the excess returns expected from buying short-term
:
育
49/248
Example
1. In 2010, the Committee of European Securities Regulators created
guidelines that restricted weighted life (WAL) to 120 days for short-term
money market funds. The purpose of this restriction was to limit the ability
of money market funds to invest in long-term, floating-rate securities. This
action is most consistent with a belief in:
A. The preferred habitat theory.
B. The segment markets theory.
C. The local expectations theory.
➢ Correct answer: A
2. The term structure theory that asserts that investors cannot be induced to
:
育
of the yield curve: the short-term and long-term segments rise while
教
51/248
Factors Affecting the Shape of the Yield Curve
➢ Three factors explain historical treasury security returns.
⚫ The level movement factor explains most of the total changes in swap
and bond market yields. This factor may be interpreted as a reflection of
parallel yield curve moves in which rates move in the same direction and
by a similar order of magnitude.
⚫ The steepness factor addresses the shape of the curve, with short-term
yields typically moving more than long-term yields. These changes take
place over time and therefore explain less of the total variance in rates
:
育
A. Level
B. Curvature
C. Steepness
➢ Correct Answer: A
:
育
教
程
金
53/248
Example
2. A movement of the yield curve in which the short rate decreases by
150 bps and the long rate decreases by 50 bps would best be
described as a:
and curvature.
程
金
➢ Correct Answer: B
54/248
Example
3. A movement of the yield curve in which the short- and long-maturity
sectors increase by 100 bps and 75 bps, respectively, but the
intermediate-maturity sector increases by 10 bps, is best described as
involving a change in:
A. Level only
B. Curvature only
➢ Correct Answer: C
教
程
金
55/248
4.2 Managing Yield Curve Risks
➢ Yield curve risk (Shaping risk): risk to portfolio value arising from
unanticipated changes in the yield curve, can be managed on the basis of
several measures of sensitivity to yield curve movements
56/248
Key Rate Duration
➢ Key rate duration
✓ 𝐷𝑃 = σ 𝑊𝑖 𝐷𝑖
:
育
✓ 𝐾𝑅𝐷𝑖 = 𝐷𝑖 × 𝑊𝑖
教
程
✓ 𝐷𝑃 = σ 𝐾𝑅𝐷𝑖
金
57/248
Example
Bond Key Rate
Weight D1 D2 D3 D4
(zero coupon) Duration
2 year 10 2 0.2
10 year 20 10 2.0
20 year 40 20 8.0
25 year 30 25 7.5
Portfolio 100 17.7
58/248
Managing Yield Curve Risks
➢ Decompose the risk into sensitivity to the following three categories of yield
curve movement:
P
− DL xL − DS xS − DC xC
教
P
程
金
59/248
Example
➢ Suppose for a given portfolio that key rate changes are considered to
be changes in the yield on 1-year, 5-year, and 10-year securities.
Estimated key rate durations are D1 = 0.50, D2 = 0.70, and D3 = 0.90.
What is the percentage change in the value of the portfolio if a parallel
shift in the yield curve results in all yields declining by 50 bps?
A. ‒1.05%.
B. +1.05%.
C. +2.10%.
:
育
教
➢ Correct Answer: B
程
60/248
Example
➢ Winter asks Madison to analyze the interest rate risk portfolio positions
in a 5-year and a 20-year bond. Winter requests that the analysis be
based on level, slope, and curvature as term structure factors. Madison
presents her analysis in Exhibit.
A. 0.3015%.
教
程
B. 0.6030%.
金
C. 0.8946%.
➢ Correct Answer: B
⚫ Change in 20-year bond yield = –0.3015% × 2 = –0.6030%.
62/248
Example
➢ Based on Exhibit, the results of Analysis 2 should show the yield on the
five-year bond:
A. decreasing by 0.8315%.
B. decreasing by 0.0389%.
C. increasing by 0.0389%.
➢ Correct Answer: C
:
育
the level factor and the curvature factor will lead to the yield on the
five-year bond increasing by 0.0389%, calculated as follows:
⚫ Change in five-year bond yield = 0.4352% – 0.3963% = 0.0389%.
63/248
4.3 Maturity Structure of Yield Curve Volatilities
➢ In modern fixed-income management, quantifying interest rate volatilities is
important for at least two reasons.
64/248
Maturity Structure of Yield Curve Volatilities
➢ Term structure of interest rate volatilities: a representation of the yield
volatility of a zero-coupon bond for every maturity of security.
➢ Interest rate volatility is not the same for all interest rates along the yield
curve. The volatility term structure typically shows that short-term rates are
more volatile than long-term rates.
65/248
Maturity Structure of Yield Curve Volatilities
➢ On the basis of the typical assumption of a lognormal model, the
uncertainty of an interest rate is measured by the annualized standard
deviation of the proportional change in a bond yield over a specified time
interval.
⚫ For example, if the time interval is a one-month period, then the
specified time interval equals 1/12 years.
➢ The square root rule of interest volatility
1
month = annual annual = month 12
:
育
12
教
67/248
5.1 Developing Interest Rate Views
➢ (1) Several macroeconomic factors influence bond pricing and required
returns such as inflation, economic growth, and monetary policy,
among others.
69/248
Developing Interest Rate Views
:
育
教
程
金
70/248
Developing Interest Rate Views
➢ In recent years, central banks have increasingly used their balance sheets
for large-sale asset purchases.
higher-risk assets.
育
教
of maturity segments.
71/248
Developing Interest Rate Views
➢ Other factors that influence bond prices, yields, and the bond risk premium
include fiscal policy, the maturity structure of debt, and investor
demand.
➢ (2) Fiscal Policy: benchmark government bonds are the means by which
nations fund their cumulative (current and past) budget deficits.
⚫ Greater deficits require more borrowing, which influences both bond
supply and required yield.
⚫ Thus, fiscal supply-side effects affect bond prices and yields by
increasing (decreasing) yields when budget deficits rise (fall).
:
育
✓ This term refers to investors’ selling off higher-risk asset classes such as
程
74/248
5.3 Developing Interest Rate Views
➢ To capitalize on a steeper curve under which long-term rates rise relative
to short-term rates, traders will short long-term bonds and purchase
short-term bonds.
➢ A trader forecasts curve flattening, whereby short-term rates rise relative
to long-term rates, she may capitalize on this trend by purchasing long-
term bonds and selling short-term bonds short.
➢ In both the expected steepening and flattening trades, the position may be
designed as duration neutral in order to insulate from changes in the level
of the term structure.
➢ Fixed-income investors with long-only investment mandates may alternate
:
育
portfolio, and those with similar duration that combine short and long
程
:
育
教
程
金
76/248
Developing Interest Rate Views
➢ Morgan Salaz is a fixed income analyst responsible for advising fixed
income clients about bond trading opportunities. In the current
recessionary environment, the level of government bond yields is low and
the term structure is nearly flat. Salaz’s firm forecasts that after a brief
recession, economic growth will return quickly during the coming 12
months.
➢ 1. Which of the following changes to the yield curve is consistent with
Salaz’s expectation of increasing economic growth over the coming year?
A. Decrease in the level
:
demand for longer-term bonds, which raises their yields. The reduced
asset purchases of long-maturity bonds would add to the effect of
greater economic activity, both of which will increase the term spread.
78/248
Learning
Module
2
:
育
教
程
79/248
1. Arbitrage opportunity
Framework 2. Introduction of arbitrage free valuation
80/248
1. Arbitrage Opportunity
➢ Arbitrage-free valuation: an approach to security valuation that
determines security values that are consistent with the absence of arbitrage
opportunities.
⚫ Arbitrage opportunities are opportunities for trades that earn riskless
profits without any net investment of money.
✓ Arbitrage opportunities arise as a result of violations of the law of
one price.
◆The law of one price states that two goods that are perfect
substitutes must sell for the same current price in the absence
of transaction costs.
:
育
⚫ Value additivity. the value of the whole must equal the sum of the
金
➢ Value additivity
⚫ Asset A is a simple risk-free zero-coupon bond that pays off one
dollar and is priced today at 0.952381 (1/1.05).
⚫ Asset B is a portfolio of 105 units of Asset A that pays off 105 one
year from today and is priced today at 95. The portfolio does not
:
育
➢ Dominance
⚫ Consider two assets, C and D, that are risk-free zero-coupon bonds.
⚫ It appears that Asset D is cheap relative to Asset C.
⚫ If both assets are risk-free, they should have the same discount rate.
To make money, sell two units of Asset C at a price of 200 and
:
育
use the proceeds to purchase one unit of Asset D for 200. The
教
reconstitution
84/248
2. Arbitrage-Free Valuation
➢ A fundamental principle of valuation is that the value of any financial
asset is equal to the present value of its expected future cash flows.
⚫ This principle holds for any financial asset from zero-coupon bonds to
interest rate swaps. Thus, the valuation of a financial asset involves the
following three steps:
✓ Step 3 Calculate the present value of the expected future cash flows
程
金
85/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation
➢ For option-free bonds, performing valuation discounting with spot rates
produces an arbitrage-free valuation.
⚫ The set of possible interest rate paths that are used to value bonds with
binomial model over multiple periods
87/248
Binomial Interest Rate Tree
:
育
教
程
金
88/248
Binomial Interest Rate Tree
➢ Determine interest rate in interest rate trees
⚫ i1,L = the lower one-year forward rate one year from now at Time 1,
⚫ i1,H = the higher one-year forward rate one year from now at Time 1.
:
育
教
程
金
89/248
Binomial Interest Rate Tree
➢ Construction of a binomial interest rate tree
⚫ Interest rate tree is generated using specialized computer software in
practice.
✓ We fit the interest rate tree to the current yield curve by choosing
interest rates so that the model produces the benchmark bond values.
We should ensure that the model is arbitrage free.
✓ The distance of adjacent forward rates are 2σ.
◆Compute one forward rate by another forward rate given for the
period in the tree.
:
育
◆If the interest rate volatility increases, the forward rates shown in
教
程
◆If the interest rate volatility decreases, the forward rates shown
in the binomial interest rate tree will converge to the implied one-
year forward rate.
90/248
Example
2.0% A C
育
教
B D
程
E
金
91/248
Example
➢ Correct Answer:
➢ Time 1
➢ Time 2
:
育
92/248
3.2 Arbitrage-Free Valuation with Binomial Tree
➢ Option free; 2 years; annual coupon rate of 6%
100
6
?
7.20%
? (Today)
100
4.50%
6
?
:
育
5.30%
教
(Year 1)
程
100
金
6
(Year 2)
93/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation with Binomial Tree
➢ Solution:
100
6.0
98.88
6.0
104.88
? 7.20% 100
4.50% 6.0
100.66
6.0
106.66
5.30%
:
育
100
教
6.0
程
1
金
1
V1,U = (100 + 6) + (100 + 6) / (1 + 7.20%) = $98.88
2 2
1 1
V1,L = (100 + 6) + (100 + 6) / (1 + 5.30%) = $100.66
2 2
1 1
V0 = (98.88 + 6) + (100.66 + 6) / (1 + 4.50%) = $101.22
2 2 94/248
3.3 Pathwise Valuation
➢ Pathwise valuation: For a binomial interest rate tree with n period, there
will be 2n paths. The Cash flow can be discounted by choosing a specific
path.
➢ Example: pathwise valuation
⚫ Use the pathwise valuation approach to determine the value of a three-
year, 3% annual-pay treasury bond. The interest rate tree is shown as the
following.
⚫ One-period forward rate in year
:
0 1 2
育
教
3.50% 6.00%
金
4.50%
30 30 1030
value1 = + + = $943.80
教
96/248
4. Monte Carlo Method
➢ The Monte Carlo method: involves randomly selecting paths in an effort to
approximate the results of a complete pathwise valuation. This method is often
used when a security’s cash flow are path dependent.
➢ The implications for valuation models
⚫ Cash flows for MBS are dependent on the path that interest rates follow
and can not be properly valued with the binomial model or any other
model that employs the backward induction methodology.
➢ Steps in the valuation of an MBS using the Monte Carlo simulation model:
⚫ Step 1: Simulate interest rate paths (e.g. 1,000 different paths) using
assumptions concerning volatility and probability distribution.
:
育
⚫ Step 2: Generate spot rates from the simulated future one-month interest
教
rates;
程
⚫ Step 3: Determine the cash flow along each interest rate path;
金
➢ Yield curve modelers often include in the Monte Carlo estimation is mean
程
98/248
5. Term Structure Models
➢ Term structure models:provide quantitatively precise descriptions of how
interest rates evolve.
99/248
Term Structure Models
⚫ Arbitrage-free model
100/248
Term Structure Models
➢ Multiple factor models
is consistent with the central bank controlling the short end of the
程
金
rate curve.
✓ Both the Vasicek and CIR models assume a single factor, the short-
term interest rate, r.
structure models.
102/248
5.1.1 Cox-Ingersoll-Ross Model
➢ Cox-Ingersoll-Ross Model
⚫ The CIR model assumes that every individual has to make consumption and
investment decisions with their limited capital.
✓ The individual must determine his or her optimal trade-off assuming
that he or she can borrow and lend in the capital market.
✓ Ultimately, interest rates will reach a market equilibrium rate at which no
one needs to borrow or lend.
⚫ The CIR model assumes that the economy has a constant long-run interest
rate that the short-term interest rate converges to over time.
✓ Mean reversion is an essential characteristic of the interest rate that
:
育
sets it apart from many other financial data series. Unlike stock prices,
教
for example, interest rates cannot rise indefinitely because at very high
程
drt = k ( − rt )dt + rt dz
t = time
教
程
σ = volatility
dz = a small random walk movement
104/248
Cox-Ingersoll-Ross Model
➢ Cox-Ingersoll-Ross Model
drt = k ( − rt )dt + rt dz
⚫ The model has two parts:
✓ A deterministic part (sometimes called a “drift term”), the expression
in dt;
✓ A stochastic (i.e., random) part, the expression in dz, which models
risk.
⚫ The deterministic part, k(θ - r)dt, ensures mean reversion of the interest
:
育
⚫ The random component varies as rates change. In other words, the short-
rate volatility is a function of the short rate. Importantly, at low rates, rt, the
term becomes small, which prevents rates from turning negative..
105/248
5.1.2 Vasicek Model
➢ Vasicek Model
⚫ The Vasicek model has the same drift term as the CIR model and thus
tends toward mean reversion in the short rate.
⚫ The stochastic or volatility term follows a random normal distribution
for which the mean is zero and the standard deviation is 1.
:
✓ As a result, the market yield curve can be modeled with the accuracy
教
embedded options.
⚫ Advantage over equilibrium model: the ability to calibrate arbitrage-free
models to match current market prices.
107/248
5.2.1 The Ho-Lee Model
➢ The Ho-Lee Model
drt = t dt + dzt
⚫ The drift term, θt, is time dependent. This time dependency means
there is a value for θt at each time step, which is critical for the model to
produce prices that match market prices.
⚫ The Ho–Lee model, similar to the Vasicek model, has constant volatility,
and interest rates may become negative because of the symmetry of the
:
育
108/248
5.2.2 The Kalotay–Williams–Fabozzi model
➢ Kalotay–Williams–Fabozzi (KWF) model
d ln(rt ) = t dt + dzt
lognormally.
教
程
✓ The main implication of modeling the log of the short rate is that it
金
:
育
教
程
金
110/248
Example
1. Which term structure model can be calibrated to closely fit an
observed yield curve?
A. The Ho-Lee Model
B. The Vasicek Model
C. The Cox-Ingersoll-Ross Model
➢ Correct Answer: A
B. has a drift term that differs from that of the Vasicek model.
金
112/248
1. Fixed-income securities with embedded
Framework options
2. Valuation of callable and putable bonds
• Valuation of callable or putable bond
• Valuation of an embedded option
• Effect of interest rate volatility
• OAS calculation and explanation
• Interest rate risk
:
育
floating-rate bond
程
金
4. Convertible bonds
113/248
1. Bonds with Embedded Options
➢ Simple Options
⚫ Callable bonds give the issuer the option to call back the bond; the
investor is short the call option.
✓ European-style option: the option can only be exercised on a single
day immediately after the lockout period
✓ American-style option: the option can be exercised at any time after
the lockout period
✓ Bermudan-style option: the option can be exercised at fixed dates
:
育
114/248
Bonds with Embedded Options
➢ Simple Options
⚫ A putable bond gives the investor the right to exercise the option is at
the discretion of the bondholder. The put provision allows the
bondholders to put back the bonds to the issuer prior to maturity,
usually at par.
✓ Extendible bond: At maturity, the holder of an extendible bond
has the right to keep the bond for a number of years after maturity,
possibly with a different coupon.
:
育
115/248
Bonds with Embedded Options
➢ Complex Options
⚫ Sinking fund bond requires the issuer to set aside funds over time to
程
金
116/248
2.1 Valuation and Analysis: Callable and Putable
➢ Example: Strike price is 100; Annual coupon rate is 6%
⚫ Callable? (100.90)
⚫ Putable? (101.75)
100
6.0
98.88
6.0
7.20%
? 100
4.50% 6.0
100.66
:
育
6.0
5.30%
教
100
程
6.0
金
1 1
Vcallable = (98.88 + 6) + (100 + 6) / (1 + 4.50%) = 100.90
2 2
1 1
V putable = (100 + 6) + (100.66 + 6) / (1 + 4.50%) = 101.75
2 2 117/248
2.2 Valuation of an Embedded Option
Vcall = Vnoncallable − Vcallable Vcallable = Vnoncallable − Vcall
Vput = Vputable − Vnonputable Vputable = Vnonputable + Vput
➢ Example: 2 years; annual coupon rate of 6% 100
6.0
98.88
6.0
7.20%
? 100
4.50% 6.0
100.66
6.0
:
5.30%
育
1 1 6.0
V0 = (98.88 + 6) + (100.66 + 6) / (1 + 4.50%) = $101.22
程
2 2
金
➢ Callable bond:
1 1
Vcallable = (98.88 + 6) + (100 + 6) / (1 + 4.50%) = 100.90
2 2
➢ Call option:
Vcall = V pure − Vcallable = 101.22 − 100.90 = 0.32 V put = V putable − V pure = 101.75 − 101.22 = 0.53
118/248
2.3 Effect of Interest Rate Volatility
➢ The procedure to value a bond with an embedded option in the presence of
interest rate volatility
⚫ Generate a tree of interest rates based on the given yield curve and
interest rate volatility assumptions.
⚫ At each node of the tree, determine whether the embedded options will
be exercised.
⚫ Apply the backward induction valuation methodology to calculate the
bond's present value. This methodology involves starting at maturity
and working back from right to left to find the bond's present value.
:
育
Ru = Rd e2 t
程
金
⚫ where Rd is the rate in the down state, a is the interest rate volatility
(10% here), and t is the time in years between "time slices" (a year, so
here t = 1).
119/248
Effect of Interest Rate Volatility
➢ Effect of volatility on the arbitrage-free value of an option
➢ Interest rate volatility effect on the value of a callable or putable bond:
⚫ The values of call and put options increase when interest rate volatility
increases
✓ The value of a callable bond decreases
✓ The value of a putable bond increases
⚫ The value of a straight bond is unaffected by changes in the volatility of
interest rate
:
育
教
120/248
2.4 Option-Adjusted Spread
Description Character
CF1 CF2 Assume the interest rate
Z-spread Pmarket = + + ... volatility is zero
(1 + R1 + Z )1 (1 + R2 + Z ) 2
The constant spread added
Pmarket =
CF1'
+
CF2''
+ ...
to all one-period rates in
(1 + R1 + OAS )1 (1 + R2 + OAS ) 2 the tree such that the
OAS
calculated value equals the
Option cost =Z-spread – OAS market price of the risky
bond
:
⚫ US treasury securities
教
⚫ A specific sector of the bond market with a certain credit rating higher
程
金
121/248
2.4.1 Calculate OAS
➢ Calculate OAS
⚫ Suppose that the market price of a three-year 4.25% annual coupon bond
callable in one year and two years from now at 10% interest rate volatility is
101.00. To determine the OAS, the constant spread added uniformly to all the
one-period forward rates that justifies the given market price of 101.00 is 28.55
bps; this number is the OAS
C=4.25 V3=104.25
R2,HH=5.5258%
+28.55bps
C=4.25 V2,HH=98.524
R1,H=3.8695% V3=104.25
C=4.25
+28.55bps
:
V0=101.000 R2,HL=4.5242%
育
V1,H=99.126 +28.5bps
R0=2.5%
教
+28.55bps V2,HL=99.466
C=4.25
程
V3=104.25
R1,L=3.1681% C=4.25
金
+28.55bps R2,LL=3.7041%
V1,L=100.512 +28.55bps
Called at 100 V2,LL=100.25 V3=104.25
Called at 100
Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
122/248
2.4.2 OAS Application — Relative valuation
➢ OAS is often used as a measure of value relative to the benchmark.
⚫ An OAS lower than that for a bond with similar characteristics and
credit quality indicates that the bond is likely overpriced (rich) and
should be avoided.
⚫ A larger OAS than that of a bond with similar characteristics and credit
quality means that the bond is likely under- priced (cheap).
123/248
Example
➢ An analyst makes the following spread estimates relative to U.S. Treasuries
for a callable corporate bonds:
⚫ G-spread relative to the Treasury yield curve is 240 basis points
⚫ Z-spread relative to the Treasury yield curve is 225 basis points
⚫ OAS relative to the Treasury yield curve is 190 basis points
➢ The analyst also determine that the Z-spread over Treasuries on
comparable option-free bonds in the market is 210 basis points. Determine
whether the bond is overvalued, undervalued, or properly valued
➢ Answer:
:
which is 210 basis points. This bond is overvalued, because its OAS of
程
190 basis points is less than the required OAS. It is not appropriate to
金
124/248
2.4.3 Effect of Interest Rate Volatility on OAS
➢ The dispersion of interest rates on the tree is volatility dependent, and so is
the OAS.
➢ The following Exhibit shows the effect of volatility on the OAS for a callable
bond. As interest rate volatility increase, the OAS for the callable bond
decreases.
125/248
2.5.1 Effect of Changes in the Interest Rates
➢ Effect of changes in the Level of interest rates
⚫ Interest rate declines: the price of a callable bond rise less than the
equivalent straight bond.
⚫ Interest rate increase: the price of a putable bond fall less than the
equivalent straight bond.
:
育
教
程
金
126/248
Effect of Changes in the Yield Curve
➢ Effect of changes in the Shape of the yield curve
⚫ Call option
✓ Interest rate decline, the value of an embedded call option increases
✓ Value of a call option will be lower for an upward sloping yield curve
◆A higher interest rate scenario limits the probability of the call
option being in the money.
◆As an upward-sloping yield curve becomes flatter, the call
option value increases.
⚫ Put option
:
育
flattens
◆When yield curve is upward sloping, the probability of the put
option going in the money is higher
127/248
2.5.2 Effective Duration and Effective Convexity
➢ Effective duration and effective convexity
⚫ Modified duration and modified convexity, can be used only for option-
free bonds because these measures assume that a bond’s expected cash
flows do not change when the yield changes.
convexity.
育
教
ED = EC =
2 ( curve ) ( PV0 )
金
( ) ( PV0 )
2
curve
128/248
Effective Duration
➢ Using the binomial model to compute effective duration and convexity.
➢ The procedure for calculating the value of PV+ is as follows:
⚫ Step 1 Given a price (PV0), calculate the implied OAS to the benchmark
yield curve at an appropriate interest rate volatility.
⚫ Step 2 Shift the benchmark yield curve down, generate a new interest
rate tree, and then revalue the bond using the OAS calculated in Step 1.
This value is PV–.
⚫ Step 3 Shift the benchmark yield curve up by the same magnitude as in
:
育
Step 2, generate a new interest rate tree, and then revalue the bond
教
ED =
( PV− ) − ( PV+ )
2 ( curve ) ( PV0 )
129/248
Effective Duration
➢ Comparison of effective durations among callable, putable and straight
bonds
⚫ Effective duration (zero-coupon) ≈ maturity of the bond
⚫ Effective duration of fixed-rate bond < maturity of the bond
⚫ Effective duration of floater ≈ time (years) to next reset
⚫ Effective duration (callable) ≤ effective duration (straight)
✓ When interest rates fall, call option gives the issuer the right to retire
the bond at the call price. The call option reduces the effective
duration of the callable bond relative to that of the straight bond.
:
育
✓ When interest rates rise, the investor can put the bond and reinvest
金
the proceeds of the retired bond at a higher yield. Thus, the put
option reduces the effective duration of the putable bond relative to
that of the straight bond.
130/248
Effective Convexity
➢ Comparison among effective convexities of callable, putable and
straight bonds
⚫ Straight bonds have positive effective convexity
✓ The increase in the value of an option-free bond is higher when
rates fall than the decrease in value when rates increase by an equal
amount
⚫ Callable bonds are unlikely to be called and will exhibit positive
convexity when rates are high
:
育
132/248
2.5.3 One-Side Durations
➢ One-side durations - that is, the effective durations when interest rates go
up or down – are better at capturing the interest rate sensitivity of a callable
or putable bond than the (two-side) effective duration, particularly when the
embedded option is near the money.
⚫ The fact that the one-side up-duration is higher than the one-side
down-duration confirms that the callable bond is more sensitive to
interest rate rises than to interest rate declines.
:
133/248
2.5.4 Key Rate Duration
➢ Key rate duration: shifting any par rate has an effect on the value of the
bond
⚫ Option-free bond
✓ Trading at par, the bond’s maturity matched rate is the only rate
that affects the bond’s value. Its maturity key rate duration is the
same as its effective duration, and all other key rate durations are
zero.
✓ Not trading at par, shift the maturity-matched par rate has the
:
育
greatest effect.
教
程
⚫ Key rate durations can sometimes be negative for maturity points that
金
are shorter than the maturity of the bond being analyzed if the bond is
a zero-coupon bond or has a very low coupon.
134/248
Key Rate Duration
135/248
Key Rate Duration
➢ Key rate duration
⚫ Callable bonds
✓ with low coupon rate are unlikely to be called, hence, the rate that
has the highest effect on the value of the callable bond is the
maturity-matched rate.
✓ As the bond’s coupon increase, however, so does the likelihood of
the bond being called. The rate that has the highest effect on the
callable bond’ value is the time-to-exercise rate.
:
育
⚫ Putable bonds
教
✓ with high coupon rates are unlikely to be put, their prices are most
程
137/248
Key Rate Duration
138/248
3. Valuation of Floater with Cap or Floor
➢ Options in floating-rate bonds (floaters) are exercised automatically
depending on the course of interest rates—that is, if the coupon rate rises
or falls below the threshold, the cap or floor automatically applies.
⚫ The capped floater protects the issuer against rising interest rates and
is thus an issuer option.
Value of capped floater= Value of straight bond – Value of embedded cap
⚫ The floor floater protects the investor against declining interest rates
:
➢ Similar to callable and putable bonds, capped and floored floaters can be
valued by using the arbitrage-free framework.
139/248
Example
➢ A two-year floating rate note pays LIBOR set in arrears. Par value is
$100. The following is the two-year binomial LIBOR tree:
➢ Compute:
:
育
2. The value of the floater, assuming that it is capped with a cap rate
程
3. The value of the floater, assuming that it is floored with a floor rate
of 5.20%. Also compute the value of the embedded floor.
140/248
Example
➢ Correct Answer :
1. An option-free bond with a coupon rate equal to the required rate
of return will be worth par value. Hence the straight value of the
floater is $100.
2. The value of the capped floater is $99.69 as shown below:
$99.35 $100
$4.50 $7.20
$99.69 7.20% $6.50
:
4.50%
育
$100
$100
教
$4.50
$5.30
程
5.30%
金
141/248
Example
⚫ Note that when the option is not in the money, the floater is valued
at par
⚫ The upper node in the year 2 shows the exercise of the cap (the
coupon is capped at $6.50 instead of $7.20)
⚫ The year 0 value is the average of the year 1 values (including their
:
don’t require any adjustment as the coupon rate is below the cap
程
rate.
金
$99.69 =
(99.35 + 4.50) + (100 + 4.50) / 2
1.045
coupons)
金
➢ Market conversion price is the market price of bond divided by the conversion
教
ratio
程
straight value
程
⚫ Many investors use the straight value as a measure of the downside risk of a
金
convertible bond
⚫ The greater the premium over straight value, the less attractive the
convertible bond.
145/248
Valuation and Analysis: Convertible Bond
➢ Corporate actions—such as stock splits, bonus share issuances, and
rights or warrants issuances—affect a company’s share price and may
reduce the benefit of conversion for the convertible bondholders. Thus, the
terms of issuance of the convertible bond contain detailed information
defining how the conversion price and conversion ratio are adjusted
should such a corporate action occur during the life of the bond.
⚫ For example: ABC, Inc., $1 billion, 0.25% Convertible Bonds
✓ Conversion price: $57.14 per share
✓ Conversion Rate: Each bond of par value of $1,000 is convertible to
:
⚫ Suppose that ABC performs a 2:1 stock split to its common shareholders.
教
程
share
✓ The conversion rate adjusted to 35 (i.e., 17.5 × 2) shares per $1,000
of nominal value.
146/248
Valuation and Analysis: Convertible Bond
➢ As long as the convertible bond is still outstanding and has not been
converted, the bondholders receive interest payments.
➢ If the issuer declares and pays dividends, common shareholders receive
dividend payments. The terms of issuance may offer no compensation to
convertible bondholders for dividends paid out during the life of the bond
at one extreme, or they may offer full protection by adjusting the
conversion price downward for any dividend payments at the other
extreme.
⚫ Typically, a threshold dividend is defined in the terms of issuance.
:
育
three.
程
⚫ an adjusted conversion price that is lower than the initial conversion price.
金
bonds usually have a protection period. Subsequently, they can be called but
育
➢ If a convertible bond is callable, the issuer has an incentive to call the bond
金
when the underlying share price increases above the conversion price in order to
avoid paying further coupons. Such an event is called forced conversion
because it forces bondholders to convert their bonds into shares.
149/248
4.2 Valuation of Convertible Bond
➢ Valuation of convertible bond
Noncallable/nonputable convertible = Straight value of bond
bond value + Value of the call option on the stock
➢ Most convertible bonds are callable, giving the issuer the right to call the
issue prior to maturity.
= Straight value of bond
Callable convertible bond value + Value of the call option on the stock
- Value of the call option on the bond
:
育
Callable and putable convertible + Value of the call option on the stock
程
bond value
金
150/248
4.3 Effects of Embedded Option
➢ Effects of embedded option in convertible bond
151/248
4.4 Analysis of Convertible Bond
➢ Comparisons between convertible bonds and stocks
✓ Reason: The convertible bond’s price has a floor =its straight bond
value.
152/248
Analysis of Convertible Bond
➢ Comparison between underlying stock and risk-return characteristics of the
convertible bond
⚫ Fixed-income equivalent: When underlying share price < the conversion
price, the convertible bond is described “busted convertible” and exhibits
mostly bond risk-return characteristics.
✓ The call option is out of money, the share price movements do not
significantly affect the price of the call option or the convertible bond.
⚫ Common stock equity: When the underlying share price > the
conversion price, a convertible bond exhibits mostly stock risk-return
characteristics.
:
育
✓ The call option is in the money, the price of the call option and thus the
教
153/248
Example
➢ Nick Andrews, a fixed-income investment analyst, has been asked by
his supervisor to prepare an analysis of the convertible bond issued by
Heavy Element Inc., a chemical industry company, for presentation to
the investment committee. Andrews has gathered the following data
from the convertible bond’s prospectus and market information:
⚫ Issuer: Heavy Element Inc.
⚫ Issue Date: 15 September 2010
⚫ Maturity Date: 15 September 2015
⚫ Interest: 3.75% payable annually
:
育
➢ Correct Answer: C
育
to:
程
金
A. $0.88.
B. $2.24.
C. $9.00.
➢ Correct Answer: A
155/248
Example
4. The risk—return characteristics of the convertible bond on 16
September 2012 most likely resemble that of:
A. a busted convertible.
B. Heavy Element's common stock.
C. a bond of Heavy Element that is identical to the convertible bond
but without the conversion option.
➢ Correct Answer: B
5. As a result of favorable economic conditions, credit spreads for the
chemical industry narrow, resulting in lower interest rates for the debt
:
of companies such as Heavy Element. All else being equal, the price of
育
教
A. decrease significantly.
金
➢ Correct Answer: B
157/248
Example
7. A few months have passed. Because of chemical spills in lake water at
the site of a competing facility, the government has introduced very
costly environmental legislation. As a result, share prices of almost all
publicly traded chemical companies, including Heavy Element, have
decreased sharply. Heavy Element's share price is now $28. Now, the
risk–return characteristics of the convertible bond most likely resemble
that of:
:
育
A. a bond.
教
B. a hybrid instrument.
程
金
➢ Correct Answer: A
158/248
Learning
Module
4
:
育
教
程
159/248
1. Modeling credit risk and the credit
valuation adjustment
Framework 2. Valuing risky bonds in an arbitrage-free
framework
3. Credit scores and credit ratings
4. Structural model and reduced-form
credit models
5. Credit spread analysis
:
spreads
教
程
160/248
1. Modeling Credit Risk
➢ Credit risk is the risk associated with losses stemming from the failure of a
borrower to make timely and fully payments of interest or principal. Credit risk
depends on:
⚫ Expected exposure is the projected amount of money the investor could
lose if an event of default occurs, before factoring in possible recovery.
⚫ Probability of default (POD) is the probability that the bond issuer will not
meet its contractual obligations on schedule.
⚫ Recovery rate is percentage of the loss recovered from a bond in default.
⚫ Loss given default (LGD) is the amount of loss if a default occurs.
✓ Loss given default (%) =100% - Recovery rate
:
育
⚫ Credit valuation adjustment (CVA) is the value of the credit risk in present
value term. ( the sum of PV of expected loss)
⚫ Fair value of corporate bond = VND – CVA
✓ VND: the value for the corporate bond assuming no default
161/248
Probability of Default
➢ Probability of default
⚫ Actual probability of default
✓ The actual default probability for the corporate bond can observed
from historical data.
⚫ Risk-neutral probability of default
✓ In practice,we use the risk neutral probability of default, which is
the probability of default implied in the current market price.
⚫ Usually, risk-neutral default probability is higher than actual
default probability.
:
⚫ The reason for the difference between actual (or historical) and
育
163/248
Credit Analysis of Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
A 5-Year, Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
164/248
Credit Analysis of Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
➢ Exposure on date T (2):
⚫ Date 1: 100/(1.03)4 = 88.8487
⚫ Date 2: 100/(1.03)3 = 91.5142
⚫ Date 3: 100/(1.03)2 = 94.2596
⚫ Date 4: 100/(1.03)1 = 97.0874
⚫ Date 5: 100
➢ The recovery rate is 40%, recovery on date T (3):
⚫ Date 1: 88.8487 X 0.4 = 35.5395
⚫ Date 2: 91.5142 X 0.4 = 36.6057
:
育
165/248
Credit Analysis of Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
➢ Risk-neutral probability of default (POD) and probability of survival (POS) on
date T (5&6):
⚫ Date 1:
✓ POD = 1.25%
✓ POS = 1-1.25% = 98.75%
⚫ Date 2:
✓ POD = 98.75% X 1.25% = 1.2344%
✓ POS = 98.75% - 1.2344% = 97.5156%
⚫ Date 3:
✓ POD = 97.5156% X 1.25% = 1.2189%
✓ POS = 97.5156% - 1.2189% = 96.2967%
:
育
⚫ Date 4:
教
⚫ Date 5:
✓ POD = 95.0930% X 1.25% = 1.1887%
✓ POS = 95.0930% - 1.1887% = 93.9043%
166/248
Credit Analysis of Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
➢ Expected loss = LGD X POD (7)
⚫ For example, date 3: Expected loss = 56.5558 X 1.2189% = 0.6894
➢ Risk-free discount factors based on the flat government bond yield
curve at 3.00%, DFT=1/1.03T (8)
⚫ For example, date 5: DF = 1/1.035=0.862609
➢ Present value (PV) of the expected loss for each year = EL X DF (9)
⚫ For example, date 5: PVEL = 0.7132 X 0.862609 = 0.6152
➢ Credit valuation adjustment (CVA) is the sum of PVEL is 3.1549
➢ Fair value = VND – CVA = 86.2609 – 3.1539 = 83.1060
:
育
100
⚫ = 83.1060, YTM = 3.77%
(1+𝑌𝑇𝑀)5
➢ The yield on the 5-year, zero-coupon government bond is 3.00%. Therefore,
the credit spread is 77 basis points: 3.77% – 3.00% = 0.77%.
167/248
Credit Analysis of Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
➢ Projected annual rates of return
35.5395
⚫ = 83.1060,
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅
⚫ IRR = -57.24%
0 36.6057
⚫ + = 83.1060,
:
1
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 2
育
⚫ IRR = -33.63%
教
程
金
168/248
Credit Analysis of Zero-Coupon Corporate Bond
➢ If the issuer defaults on date 5:
0 0 0 0 40.0000
⚫ 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + = 83.1060,
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 5
⚫ IRR = −13.61%
169/248
2.2 Analysis of Coupon-Paying Corporate Bond
➢ A fixed-income trader at a hedge fund observes a 3-year, 5% annual
payment corporate bond trading at 104 per 100 of par value. The
research team at the hedge fund determines that the risk-neutral
probability of default used to calculate the conditional POD for each
date for the bond is 1.50% given a recovery rate of 40%. The
government bond yield curve is flat at 2.50%.
➢ Based on these assumptions, does the trader deem the corporate bond
:
育
170/248
Analysis of Coupon-Paying Corporate Bond
➢ Solution:
171/248
Analysis of Coupon-Paying Corporate Bond
➢ The exposures are the values for the bond plus the coupon payment
for each date assuming a yield to maturity of 2.50%. (2)
⚫ For example, the exposure is 109,8186 for date 1 when two years to
maturity remain.
5 105
⚫ 5+ 1 + 2 = 109.8186
1.025 1.025
➢ Recovery = Exposure X 40% (3)
⚫ For example, date 1: Recovery = 109.8186 X 40% = 43.9274
➢ LGD = Exposure – Recovery (4)
:
育
➢ If this 3-year, 5% bond were default-free, its price would be 107.1401 (VND).
5 5 105
⚫ 1 + 2 + 3 = 107.1401
1.025 1.025 1.025
➢ Therefore, The fixed-income trader at the hedge fund would deem this
教
173/248
Analysis of Coupon-Paying Corporate Bond
➢ The projected annual rates of return:
43.9274
✓ = 104, IRR = -57.76%
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅
5 42.9756
✓ 1 + = 104, IRR = -33.27%
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 2
5 5 42.0000
✓ + + = 104, IRR = -22.23%
程
1 2
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 3
金
5 5 105
✓ 1 + 2 + 3 = 104, IRR = 3.57%
1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅 1+𝐼𝑅𝑅
174/248
2.3 Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ The first step is to build the binomial interest rate tree under the assumption
of no arbitrage.
➢ The second step is confirming that the binomial interest rate tree has been
correctly calibrated.
➢ The third step is to assess the fair value for the risky bond. This is done in
three steps:
⚫ First, determine the value for the corporate bond assuming no default
:
育
(VND).
教
⚫ Third, the fair value of the risky bond is the VND minus the CVA.
175/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ The Exhibit displays the data on annual payment benchmark government
bonds. This is the par curve because each bond is priced at par value. The
coupon rates are equal to the yields to maturity. The 1-year government
bond has a negative yield to reflect the conditions seen in some financial
markets. However, on a par curve whereby all the bonds are priced at 100, it
is shown as having a negative coupon rate.
Exhibit 1. Par Curve for Annual Payment Benchmark Government Bonds, Spot Rates,
Discount Factors, and Forward Rates
Maturity Coupon rate Price Discount factor Spot rate Forward rate
:
育
1.5918% 4.1692%
育
(0.5000) (0.3750)
教
2.4820% 4.0018%
程
(0.2500) (0.2500)
3.4134%
金
(0.1250)
3.2764%
(0.0625)
Date 0 Date 1 Date 2 Date 3 Date 4
177/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ Consider a 5-year, 3.50% annual payment corporate bond. A fixed-
income analyst assigns an annual default probability of 1.25% (the
hazard rate) and a recovery rate of 40% to this bond and assumes 10%
volatility in benchmark interest rates. To determine the fair value for the
bond under these assumptions.
default (VND).
教
⚫ Third, the fair value of the risky bond is the VND minus the
CVA.
178/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ Value of a 3.5% Annual Payment Corporate Bond Assuming No Default
96.4659
7.2918% 103.50
94.6788
3.50
6.2197%
95.6703 97.6692
3.50 103.50
3.7026% 5.9700%
98.4920 96.7465
1.9442% 3.50 3.50
5.0922%
103.5450 98.6769
98.1435
-0.2500% 3.50 3.50 4.8878% 103.50
3.0315%
101.0803 98.4909
:
4.1692%
99.5175
教
100.2352 103.50
4.0018%
程
2.4820% 3.50
金
99.9551 3.50
3.4134%
100.2165
3.2764% 103.50
⚫ The binomial interest rate tree for benchmark rates can be used to
calculate the VND for the bond. The VND is 103.5450 per 100 of par
value.
⚫ This could also have been obtained more directly using the benchmark
discount factors:
180/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ Step 2: determine CVA
182/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ The expected loss at date 4 is 0.737337.
183/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ The yield to maturity (YTM) for the corporate bond given a fair value of
100.0056 is 3.4988%.
⚫ YTM = 3.4988%
➢ The credit spread over the benchmark bond is 0.7488%, given the 5-year
par yield for the government bond is 2.75%.
:
➢ We can say that the credit risk on this corporate bond is captured by a CVA
程
184/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ For this example we use a no-arbitrage binomial interest rate tree for
20% volatility to value the 5-year, 3.50% annual payment corporate
bond using the same credit risk parameters as in the previous
calculations. 93.7706
103.50
10.3757%
93.3858
3.50
8.0804%
93.1558 96.7697
3.50 103.50
4.3999% 6.9550%
97.226 96.1232 3.50
2.1180% 3.50 5.4164%
103.5450 98.4158 98.8897
-0.2500% 3.50 3.50 103.50
:
2.9493% 4.6621%
育
102.3458 99.5136
3.50 3.50
教
1.4197% 3.6307%
100.3635
程
102.1817 103.50
1.9770% 3.50 3.1251%
金
101.8902 3.50
2.4338% 101.3764
103.50
2.0948%
Date 0 Date 1 Date 2 Date 3 Date 4 Date 5
185/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Bonds
➢ Determine CVA
Exhibit 3. CVA Calculation for the 3.50% Corporate Bond Assuming 20%
Volatility
Expected Discount CVA per
Date LGD POD
Exposure Factor Year
0
⚫ The net effect is to reduce the expected exposure to default loss. The top of
教
the tree shows less potential loss because the current value of the bond is
程
lower, which more than offsets the greater exposure to loss at the bottom of
金
the tree.
➢ Conclusion: the fair value of the bond will increase with a higher interest
rate volatility.
187/248
2.4 Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ Consider a 5-year “floater” that pays annually the 1-year benchmark
rate plus 0.50% (quoted margin) , using the binomial interest rate
tree for 10% interest rate volatility. Notice that the interest payment is
set at the beginning of the period and paid at the end of the period.
➢ Assume that for the first three years the annual default probability (the
hazard rate) is 0.50% and the recovery rate 20%. The credit risk of the
issuer then worsens: For the final two years the probability of
:
育
default goes up to 0.75% and the recovery rate goes down to 10%.
教
➢ Determine the fair value for the bond under these assumption.
188/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ Determine VND
100.4660
7.2918% 107.7918
100.9122
6.7197
6.2197%
101.3689 100.4718
4.2026 106.4700
3.7026% 5.9700%
101.8442 100.9271
2.4442 5.5922
1.9442% 5.0922%
102.3633 100.4767
0.2500 101.3911 105.3878
-0.2500% 3.5315 4.8878%
3.0315%
101.8707 100.9396 4.6692
:
1.5918% 2.0918
育
4.1692%
101.4098 100.4808
教
2.9820 104.5018
2.4820% 4.0018%
程
3.9134
金
100.9500
3.4134% 100.4841
3.2764% 103.7764
190/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ These are the calculations for the bond values for date 2:
➢ These are the calculations for the bond values for date 1:
➢ These are the calculations for the bond values for date 0:
教
程
191/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ Determine CVA
192/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ The calculation for the expected exposure recognizes that the bond values
for each date follow the probabilities of attaining those rates, whereas
possible interest payments use the probabilities for the prior date. For
example, the expected exposure to default loss for date 4 is 105.6535:
193/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ Probability of default (POD) and probability of survival (POS)
⚫ The POS into the fourth year is 98.5075%: (100% - 0.50%)3 = 98.5075%.
Therefore, the POD for date 4 increases to 0.7388%: 0.75% x 98.5075%
= 0.7388%.
:
育
⚫ The POS into the fifth year is 97.7687% (= 98.5075% - 0.7388%). The
教
程
➢ Given these assumptions about credit risk, the CVA for the floater is 2.4586.
194/248
Arbitrage-Free Valuation for Risky Floater
➢ The discount margin for a floating-rate note is a yield measure commonly
used on floating-rate notes in the same manner that the credit spread
issued with fixed-rate bonds.
➢ Given these assumptions about credit risk, the CVA for the floater is 2.4586.
The fair value is 99.9047, the VND of 102.3633 minus the CVA. Because the
security is priced below par value, its discount margin (DM) must be
higher than the quoted margin of 0.50%.
➢ The arbitrage-free framework can be used to determine the DM for this
:
育
that are used to get the bond values at each node in the tree.
程
金
⚫ Credit scores are used primarily in the retail lending market for small
businesses and individuals.
⚫ Credit ratings are used in the wholesale market for bonds issued by
corporations and government entities as well as for asset-backed
securities (ABS).
:
育
⚫ Credit rating and credit scoring are ordinal measures, a higher rating
教
implies lower credit risk, but the difference between difference in scores
程
金
✓ Not cardinal measure, e.g. A scores 600, B scores 300, A’s credit
quality is higher than B, but not twice than B.
196/248
3.1 Credit Scores
➢ The FICO score, which is the federally registered trademark of the Fair Isaac
Corporation, is used in the United States by about 90% of lenders to retail
customers.
➢ Five primary factors are included in the proprietary algorithm used to get
the score:
⚫ 35% for the payment history
⚫ 30% for the debt burden
⚫ 15% for the length of credit history
⚫ 10% for the types of credit used
:
育
➢ Fair Isaac Corporation, on its website, notes items that are not included in
金
the FICO credit score: race, color, national origin, sex, marital status, age,
salary, occupation, employment history, home address, and child/family
support obligation.
197/248
3.2 Credit Ratings
➢ Credit ratings are widely used in corporate and sovereign bond markets.
➢ The three major global credit rating agencies are Moody's Investors
Service, Standard & Poor's, and Fitch Ratings. Each provides quality
ratings for issuers as well as specific issues.
⚫ Notching is an adjustment to the issuer rating to reflect the priority of
claim for specific debt issues of that issuer and to reflect any
subordination.
✓ The issuer rating is typically for senior unsecured debt.
:
育
(positive, stable, or negative) for the issuer as well as when the issuer is
under “watch”.
198/248
Credit Transition Matrix
➢ The rating agencies report transition matrixes based on their historical experience. It
shows the probabilities of a particular rating transitioning to another over the course
of the following year and representative credit spreads for a 10-year corporate bond.
202/248
4.1 Structural Model
➢ Structural model depends on the structure o f the company’s balance
sheet- its assets, liabilities, and equity. It also can be called a company-
value model because the key variable is the asset value of the company.
⚫ In Exhibit the asset value has
been volatile prior to now, time
0, but has remained above the
horizontal line that represents
the default barrier. If the asset
value falls below the barrier, the
company defaults on the debt.
:
育
✓ At maturity:
育
⚫ The key parameter in this process is the default intensity, which is the
育
risk models are thus also called intensity-based and stochastic default
金
rate models.
⚫ Default intensity can be estimated using regression models. These
regression models employ several independent variables including
company specific variables as well as macro-economic variables.
205/248
4.3 Credit Analysis Models
➢ Assumption of the structural models:
⚫ The company’s assets trade in frictionless markets that are arbitrage free.
⚫ The debt liabilities are zero-coupon bonds that mature at time T.
⚫ The probability of default is endogenous (internal) to this structural model
➢ Advantages of structural models:
⚫ It provides insight into the nature of credit risk. The company defaults
when the value of its assets dips below the default barrier.
⚫ It provides an option analogy for understanding a company’s default
:
育
⚫ Assumptions of simple balance sheet and traded assets are not realistic.
⚫ It can be difficult in practice because of limitations in available data.
⚫ The credit risk measures do not explicitly consider the business cycle.
206/248
Credit Analysis Models
➢ Assumptions of the reduced-form models:
⚫ Reduced-form models treating default as an exogenous (external) variable
that occurs randomly.
➢ Advantages of reduced-form models:
⚫ The inputs are observable variables, including historical data.
⚫ The default intensity is estimated using regression analysis on company-
specific variables (e.g., leverage ratio, net income-to-assets ratio, and cash-
to-assets ratio) and macroeconomic variables (e.g., unemployment rate, GDP
growth rate, measures of stock market volatility). This flexibility allows the
model to directly reflect the business cycle in the credit risk measure.
:
育
default.
金
⚫ Therefore, they can be used for internal risk management, for banks’
internal credit risk measures, and for publicly available credit ratings.
208/248
5. Interpreting Changes in Credit Spreads
➢ Components of a corporate bond yield
⚫ Benchmark bond yields, in general, capture the macroeconomic
factors affecting all debt securities.
⚫ The spread over the benchmark bond yield captures the
microeconomic factors that pertain to the corporate issuer and the
specific issue itself.
:
育
教
程
金
209/248
5.1 Evaluating Changes in Credit Risk Parameters
➢ Probability of default
⚫ POD (+) => PVEL (+) => CVA (+) => Fair value (-) => YTM (+) =>
Credit Spread (+)
➢ Recovery rate
⚫ RR (+) => PVEL (-) => CVA (-) => Fair value (+) => YTM (-) =>
Credit Spread (-)
:
育
210/248
Evaluating Changes in Credit Risk Parameters
➢ Edward Kapili is a summer intern working on a fixed-income trading desk
at a major money-center bank. His supervisor asks him to value a 3-year,
3% annual payment corporate bond using a binomial interest rate tree
model for 20% volatility and the current par curve for benchmark
government bond par curve. (This is the binomial tree in Exhibit 1). The
assumed annual probability of default (the hazard rate) is 1.50%, and the
recovery rate is 40%.
➢ The supervisor asks Mr. Kapili if the credit spread over the yield on the 3-
:
育
to 20%.
金
➢ Mr. Kapilis intuition is that doubling the probability of default has the
larger impact on the credit spread. Is his intuition correct?
211/248
Evaluating Changes in Credit Risk Parameters
➢ Mr. Kapili first determines the fair value of the 3-year, 3% annual payment
bond given the assumptions for the original credit risk parameters.
➢ Determine VND = 104.4152
98.6591
103
4.3999%
100.2313
3
2.1180%
104.4152
100.0492
-0.2500% 3 103
2.9493%
:
102.0770
育
3
1.4197%
教
101.0032
程
103
金
1.9770%
212/248
Evaluating Changes in Credit Risk Parameters
➢ Determine CVA
3 3 103
⚫ 1 + 2 + 3 = 101.7168, YTM = 2.40%
1+𝑌𝑇𝑀 1+𝑌𝑇𝑀 1+𝑌𝑇𝑀
213/248
Evaluating Changes in Credit Risk Parameters
➢ Calculate the fair values under the new credit risk parameters.
3.00% Default Probability, 40% Recovery Rate
Expected Discount CVA per
Date LGD POD
Exposure Factor Year
0
1 104.1541 62.4925 3.0000% 1.002506 1.8795
2 102.9402 61.7641 2.9100% 0.985093 1.7705
3 103.0000 61.8000 2.8227% 0.955848 1.6674
8.7327% CVA = 5.3174
:
育
教
3 3 103
⚫ 1 + 2 + 3 = 99.0978, YTM = 3.32%
1+𝑌𝑇𝑀 1+𝑌𝑇𝑀 1+𝑌𝑇𝑀
➢ Credit spread = 3.32% -1.50% = 1.82% (+)
214/248
Evaluating Changes in Credit Risk Parameters
➢ Calculate the fair values under the new credit risk parameters.
1.50% Default Probability, 20% Recovery Rate
Expected Discount CVA per
Date LGD POD
Exposure Factor Year
0
1 104.1541 83.3233 1.5000% 1.002506 1.2530
2 102.9402 82.3522 1.4775% 0.985093 1.1986
3 103.0000 82.4000 1.4553% 0.955848 1.1463
4.4328% CVA = 3.5978
:
育
教
3 3 103
⚫ 1 + 2 + 3 = 100.8173, YTM = 2.71%
1+𝑌𝑇𝑀 1+𝑌𝑇𝑀 1+𝑌𝑇𝑀
➢ Credit spread = 2.71% -1.50% = 1.21% (+)
215/248
5.2 The Term Structure of Credit Spreads
➢ A credit curve shows the spread over a benchmark security for an issuer for
outstanding fixed-income securities with shorter to longer maturities.
➢ Key drivers of the term structure of credit spreads
⚫ Credit quality is a key factor.
✓ The credit term structure for the most highly rated securities
tends to be either flat or slightly upward sloping.
✓ Securities with lower credit quality, however, face greater
sensitivity to the credit cycle. The greater likelihood of default
:
育
216/248
The Term Structure of Credit Spreads
➢ Key drivers of the term structure of credit spreads
⚫ Financial conditions are another critical factor affecting the credit spread
term structure.
✓ A stronger economic climate is generally associated with higher
benchmark yields but lower credit spreads for issuers whose default
probability declines during periods of economic growth.
⚫ Market supply and demand dynamics are another critical factor
influencing the credit curve term structure.
✓ Given that new and most recently issued securities tend to represent the
largest proportion of trading volume and are responsible for much of
:
育
the volatility in credit spreads, the credit curve will be most heavily
教
volatility, will tend to drive a steeper credit spread curve, while the
育
教
⚫ When a bond is very likely to default, it often trades close to its recovery
金
218/248
The Term Structure of Credit Spreads
➢ Two further considerations are important when analyzing the term
structure of credit spreads.
⚫ The first concerns the appropriate risk-free or benchmark rates used
to determine spreads.
✓ The duration and maturity of the most liquid or on-the-run
government bonds rarely match that of corporate bonds trading in
the secondary market, so it is often necessary to interpolate
between yields of the two government securities with the closest
:
育
duration.
教
程
analysis.
教
程
222/248
Credit Analysis for Securitized Debt
➢ A second critical aspect of the credit exposure associated with ABS
relates to the origination and servicing of assets over the life of the
transaction.
⚫ Investors are exposed to the ability of the servicer to effectively manage
and service the portfolio over the life of the transaction.
➢ Finally, the structure of a collateralized or secured debt transaction is a
critical factor in analyzing this type of investment.
⚫ A key question related to the issuer is its relationship to the originator,
namely the degree to which the bankruptcy of the obligor is related to
:
育
the SPE may be deemed a true sale, which otherwise allows for the
金
ability to separate risk between the originator and SPE at a later date.
⚫ Second, additional credit enhancements are a key structural element to
be evaluated in the context of credit risk.
223/248
Credit Analysis for Securitized Debt
➢ A covered bond is a senior debt obligation of a financial institution that
gives recourse to the originator/issuer as well as a predetermined
underlying collateral pool.
⚫ The dual recourse to both the issuing financial institution as well as the
underlying asset pool has been a hallmark of covered bonds.
plays a role as well. These asset pools vary across jurisdictions but are
育
教
224/248
Learning
Module
5
:
育
教
程
225/248
1. Credit default swaps (CDS)
Framework
fundamentals
• CDS fundamentals
• Structure and features of credit
default swaps
• Common types of credit events
2. Types of credit default swaps
3. Pricing and valuation of CDS
:
育
4. Applications of CDS
226/248
1. Credit Default Swaps (CDS) Fundamentals
➢ Credit default swaps (CDS) is essentially an insurance contract for the
reference, the reference obligation is the fixed income security on which the
swap is written-usually a bond but potentially also a loan.
⚫ The protection buyer pays the seller a premium that is either paid
:
育
⚫ The difference between the standardized coupon rate and the credit
spread is paid upfront by one of the parties to the contract.
227/248
Credit Default Swaps (CDS) Fundamentals
➢ The CDS market is large, global, and well organized. The unofficial industry
governing body is the International Swaps and Derivatives Association
(ISDA), which publishes industry-supported conventions that facilitate the
functioning of the market. Parties to CDS contracts generally agree that their
contracts will conform to ISDA specifications. These terms are specified in a
document called the ISDA Master Agreement, which the parties to a CDS
sign.
➢ Each CDS contract specifies a notional amount, or "notional" for short,
which is the amount of protection being purchased.
:
➢ The credit protection buyer is short and the credit protection seller is
育
教
long.
程
228/248
Structure and Features of CDS
➢ When there is a credit event, the swap will settle in cash or physical delivery.
⚫ Physical settlement on CDS after a Credit Event.
seller buyer
教
程
金
➢ In cash settlement:
⚫ Payout amount =payout ratio × notional principal
⚫ Payout ratio = 1- recovery rate (%)
229/248
Common Types of Credit Events
➢ Common types of credit events
⚫ Bankruptcy: is a declaration provided for by a country’s laws that typically
involves the establishment of a legal procedure that forces creditors to defer
their claims.
⚫ Failure to pay: occurs when a borrower does not make a scheduled
payment of principal or interest on any outstanding obligations after a grace
period, without a formal bankruptcy filing.
⚫ Restructuring: refers to a number of possible events, including reduction or
deferral of principal or interest, change in seniority or priority of an
:
scheduled to be paid.
教
程
230/248
2. Types of CDS
➢ (1) A CDS on one specific borrower is called a single-name CDS.
⚫ The borrower is called the reference entity, and the contract specifies a
reference obligation, a particular debt instrument issued by the
borrower that is the designated instrument being covered.
⚫ The designated instrument is usually a senior unsecured obligation,
which is often referred to as a senior CDS, but the reference obligation is
not the only instrument covered by the CDS. Any debt obligation issued
by the borrower that is pari passu (ranked equivalently in priority of
:
育
➢ Correct Answer: C.
教
⚫ The buyer of a CDX is long credit exposure and the seller of a CDX is
教
➢ (3) A third type of CDS is the tranche CDS, which covers a combination of
borrowers but only up to pre-specified levels of losses—much in the same
manner that asset-backed securities are divided into tranches, each covering
particular levels of losses.
234/248
Example
➢ SGS recently buys €400 million of protection on the on-the-run CDX
high yield index that includes a Maxx bond; the index contains 100
entities. Maxx bond defaults and trades at 30% of par after defaults.
➢ Correct Answer:
⚫ Post the default event, the remainder of the CDX continues with a
notional principal of $396 million.
235/248
Example
➢ Assume that an investor sells $500 million of protection using the CDX IG index,
which has 125 reference entities. Concerned about the creditworthiness of a few
of the components, the investor hedges a portion of the credit risk in each. For
Company A, he purchases $3 million of single-name CDS protection, and
Company A subsequently defaults.
through the index CDS and is short $3 million notional credit exposure
教
through the single-name CDS. His net notional credit exposure is $1 million.
程
金
➢ Solution to 2:
upfront payment:
育
教
60%, the estimated CDS spread for the period would be 80 bps for the
period. Assuming a $100 notional contract value and a period of a year,
the CDS contract fair value would be (the present value of) $0.80.
237/248
CDS Pricing Conventions
➢ Premium leg: The series of payments the credit protection buyer promises
to make to the credit protection seller.
➢ Protection leg: The contingent payment that the credit protection seller
may have to make to the credit protection buyer.
⚫ Upfront premium (%) = 100 – Price of CDS in currency per 100 par
238/248
Example
➢ Assume a high-yield company’s 10-year credit spread is 600 bps, and
the duration of the CDS is eight years. What is the approximate upfront
premium required to buy 10-year CDS protection? Assume high-yield
companies have 5% coupons on their CDS.
➢ Correct Answer:
500 bps coupon plus the present value of the difference between
教
239/248
Example
➢ Imagine an investor sold five-year protection on an investment-grade
company and had to pay a 2% upfront premium to the buyer of
protection. Assume the duration of the CDS to be four years. What are
the company’s credit spreads and the price of the CDS per 100 par?
➢ Correct Answer:
⚫ The value of the upfront premium is: (-2%)/4 = -50bps. The sign of
the upfront premium is negative because the seller is paying the
premium rather than receiving it.
:
育
because the company’s credit spread is less than the fixed coupon,
程
protection buyer.
⚫ The price in currency would be 100 minus the upfront premium,
but the latter is negative, so the price is 100 - (-2) = 102.
240/248
3.2 Valuation after Inception of CDS
➢ Market participants constantly assess the current credit quality of the reference
entity to determine its current value and credit spread.
➢ A approximation of the change in value of the CDS for a given change in spread
is as follows:
⚫ Profit for the buyer of protection ≈ Change in spread in bps × Duration ×
Notional
⚫ % change in CDS price = Change in spread in bps × Duration
✓ The protection buyer is short credit risk and hence benefit when credit
spreads widen.
:
➢ As with any financial instrument, changes in the price of a CDS gives rise to
育
opportunities to unwind the position, and either capture a gain or realize a loss.
教
⚫ In buying a naked CDS, the investor is taking a position that the entity's
credit quality will deteriorate, whereas the seller of a naked CDS is taking
the position that the entity's credit quality will improve.
➢ 2) A party can take a long position in one CDS and a short position in
another, called a long/short trade. One CDS would be on one reference
:
⚫ This transaction is a bet that the credit position of one entity will
程
金
242/248
Applications of CDS
➢ 3) Another type of long/short trade, called a curve trade, involves buying a
CDS of one maturity and selling a CDS on the same reference entity with a
different maturity.
⚫ We will assume the more common situation of an upward-sloping credit
curve, meaning that long-term CDS rates are higher than short-term rates.
⚫ An investor who believe that long-term credit risk will increase relative to
short-term credit risk (credit curve steepening) can go short (buy) a long-
term CDS and long (sell) a short-term CDS.
⚫ In the short run, a curve-steepening trade is bullish. It implies that the
:
short-term outlook for the reference entity is better than the long-term
育
教
outlook.
程
short-run outlook for the reference entity looks worse than the long-run
outlook and reflects the expectation of near-term problems for the reference
entity.
243/248
Applications of CDS
➢ 4) In principle, the amount of yield attributable to credit risk on the bond
should be the same as the credit spread on a CDS. A difference in the
credit spreads in bond markets and CDS markets is the foundation of a
strategy known as a basis trade.
➢ An investor wants to be long the credit risk of a given company. The
company's bond currently yields 6% and matures in five years. A
comparable five-year CDS contract has a credit spread of 3.25%. The
investor can borrow in the market at a 2.5% interest rate.
➢ Identify a basis trade that would exploit the current situation.
:
➢ Solution:
育
教
➢ The bond and CDS markets imply different credit spreads. Credit risk is
程
cheap in the CDS market (3.25%) relative to the bond market (6%-
金
244/248
Applications of CDS
➢ 5) CDS indexes also create an opportunity for a type of arbitrage trade.
⚫ If the cost of the index is not equivalent to the aggregate cost of the
index components, an investor might go long the cheaper instrument
and short the more expensive instrument.
➢ 6) Another type of trade using CDS can occur within the instruments issued
by a single entity.
⚫ Investors can use the CDS market to first determine whether any of
these instruments is incorrectly priced relative to the CDS and then buy
the cheaper one and sell the more expensive one.
245/248
Example
➢ An investor believes that a company will undergo a leveraged buyout (LBO)
transaction, whereby it will issue large amounts of debt and use the
proceeds to repurchase all of the publicly traded equity, leaving the
company owned by management and a few insiders.
1. Why might the CDS spread change?
2. What equity-versus-credit trade might an investor execute in
anticipation of such a corporate action?
➢ Solution to 1:
⚫ Taking on the additional debt will almost surely increase the probability
:
➢ Solution to 2:
程
⚫ The investor might consider buying the stock and buying credit
金
protection. Both legs will profit if the LBO occurs because the stock
price will rise as the company repurchases all outstanding equity and
the CDS price will rise as its spread widens to reflect the increased
probability of default.
246/248
It’s not an end but just the beginning.
If you have people you love, allow them to be free beings. Give and don't
expect. Advise, but don't order. Ask, but never demand. It might sound simple,
but it is a lesson that may take a lifetime to truly practice. It is the secret to true
Love. To truly practice it, you must sincerely feel no expectations from those
who you love, and yet an unconditional caring.
如果你有爱的人,允许他们自由随意的存在。给予而不指望;建议而不命令;请
:
求而不要求;可能听起来简单,但这需要一辈子去实践。这就是真爱的秘诀。真
育
教
正去实践它,你必须对那些你爱的人没有期望,并给予无条件的关爱。
程
金
247/248
问题反馈
➢ 如果您认为金程课程讲义/题库/视频或其他资料中存在错误,欢迎您告诉我
们,所有提交的内容我们会在最快时间内核查并给与答复。
➢ 如何告诉我们?
⚫ 将您发现的问题通过电子邮件告知我们,具体的内容包含:
✓ 您的姓名或网校账号
✓ 所在班级(eg.2305CFA二级ReX智能班)
✓ 问题所在科目(若未知科目,请提供章节、知识点)和页码
:
育
✓ 您对问题的详细描述和您的见解
教
程
⚫ 请发送电子邮件至:academic.support@gfedu.net
金
➢ 非常感谢您对金程教育的支持,您的每一次反馈都是我们成长的动力。后续
我们也将开通其他问题反馈渠道(如微信等)。
248/248