IndiaMGNREA EN
IndiaMGNREA EN
IndiaMGNREA EN
Observatory
T
he Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA) is an Indian job-
guarantee scheme, enacted by legislation on 25 August 2005. The scheme provides a legal
guarantee for 100 days of employment in every financial year to adult members of any rural
household willing to do public work- related unskilled manual work at the statutory minimum
wage of Rs.100 per day. The Act focuses on rural areas, where poverty is higher than in urban
areas, and is particularly valuable during lean periods when the rural population are not able to
obtain jobs. By providing a legal guarantee to work, it marks a paradigm shift from all earlier
and existing wage employment programs. NREGA is an innovative answer to the long-standing
problem of providing social safety nets in rural areas. First, it aims to provide gainful
employment and reduce poverty, improving the purchasing power of the rural people. Second,
it aims to create public assets in the rural areas such as roads, water tanks and other common
resources that will help residents overcome other hardships associated with poverty.
The Inclusive Cities Observatory was launched in 2008 by the UCLG Committee on Social
Inclusion, Participatory Democracy and Human Rights with the aim of creating a space for
analysis and reflection on local social inclusion policies. The initiative was developed with the
scientific support of Professor Yves Cabannes (University College of London) and the Centre for
Social Studies (CES) from the University of Coimbra. At present, the Observatory contains more
than sixty study cases mostly developed between 2008 and 2010. Even though many of these
cases refer to policies that have already come to an end, they still have much to offer: from
capitalizing on the learning acquired by other local authorities to discovering suggestive and
alternative means to address social inclusion challenges from a local perspective.
Context
Social context
Persistent poverty
The Indian economy has been growing faster than many of the world’s largest developed
economies over the past decade, yet the extent of poverty has not decreased at a desirable rate.
Detailed studies by the Planning Commission, based on analyses of National Sample Survey
(NSS) data from 1997 and 1998, found that general monthly expenditures are below the ‘poverty
line’ level and even after economic reform policy, poverty levels have not declined. The Ministry
of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation reports that over 81 million of Indians live below the
poverty line (in UNESCO 2010). In order to decrease the rate of poverty through gainful
employment, the Government of India introduced the National Anti-Poverty Programme.
MGNREA is part of this program.
Urbanization
India’s urban population increased from 17% (63.4 million) in 1950 to 27.7% (288.5 million)
in 2000, and by 2010 there were more than 364 million people (30% of the population) living
in urban areas across the country (UNESCO 2010). Despite initiatives regarding local governance
and planning that are strongly influenced by 73th and 74th Constitutional Amendments and the
Jawaharlal Nehru Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM) launched by the Government of India in
2005, cities in India ‘continue to be plagued by issues of poverty and social exclusion,
increasing pressure on land and poor infrastructure and urban services’ (UNESCO 2010: 2). For
these reasons, the MGNREA (under the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission
programme) strives to counter this rapid urbanization, the migratory fluxes from rural to urban
areas, and the destruction of the balance between rural and urban areas. Complementary
programs initiated to address this situation include major initiatives that link urban
development to social equity and justice, such as the National Urban Poverty Reduction Strategy
(2010-2020): “A New Deal for the Urban Poor – Slum-free cities”, and important schemes, such
as Rajiv Awas Yojana to give property rights to slum dwellers and the Swarna Jayanti Shahari
Rozgar Yojana (SJSRY) for self employment and skill development among the urban poor. Basic
services to the urban poor and slum dwellers are provided under the umbrella of the Jawaharlal
Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM). (UNESCO 2010, Foreword)
Policy development
The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA) is an Indian job-
guarantee scheme, enacted by legislation on 25 August 2005. The Preamble to the Act states:
The Act aims to provide the enhancement of livelihood security of the households in rural areas
of the country by providing at least one hundred days of guaranteed wage employment in every
financial year to every household whose adult members volunteer to do unskilled manual work.
Named after the father of the nation, Mahatma Gandhi, in 2009, the Act focuses on rural areas,
where poverty is higher than in urban areas, and is particularly valuable during lean periods
when the rural population is not able to obtain jobs. The NREGA, by providing a legal guarantee
to work, marks a paradigm shift from all earlier and existing wage employment programs because
it is an Act and not just a scheme. NREGA is an innovative answer to the long-standing problem
of providing social safety nets in rural areas, and is a rights-based approach (IFPRI 2010).
The Act has two-fold objectives: First, it aims to provide gainful employment and reduce
poverty, improving the purchasing power of the rural people, primarily semi-skilled or unskilled
people living in rural India, and was primarily meant for people living below the poverty line.
Second, it aims to create public assets in the rural areas such as roads, water tanks, and other
common property resources that will help residents overcome other hardships associated with
poverty.
To become part of this programme, a member of a rural household submits their name, age, and
address with a photo to the Gram Panchayat. The Gram Panchayat registers the individual after
making an enquiry and issues a job card. The job card contains the details of the adult member
enrolled and his/her photo. The registered person can submit an application for work in writing
(for at least 14 days of continuous work) either to the Gram Panchayat or to a Programme
Officer. The Panchayat or programme officer accepts the valid application and issues a dated
receipt of application. A letter providing work will then be sent to the applicant and also
displayed at the Panchayat office. The employment is provided within a radius of 5 km. If it is
beyond 5 km, a higher wage is paid. Wages are fixed by minimum wage regulation and are
deposited directly to a bank by the lowest level of administrative unit, namely, the village
Panchayat.
The programme limits the migratory fluxes from the countryside to urban areas, and employs
mostly women who did not have paid work previously – around one-third of the stipulated
workforce is women. Thus, as Tewari (2010) notes, ‘NREGA serves as an effective safety net for
the unemployed, especially during years of famine and drought, supplementing household
incomes and reducing migration to cities by villagers in search of work. It helps the rural poor
economically by not just putting cash in their hands, but also helping them create sustainable
assets.’
At the beginning of 2011, as a result of the positive response to the initial application of the
Act, the effective working days have been augmented from 100 to 180 per annum (policy
website). Further, while the wage is set as manual work at the statutory minimum wage of
Rs.100 per day, all the different States have decided to augment the salary.
Background
The policy was introduced in 2005 as the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme,
described as the ‘most radical and largest plan of public employment, poverty reduction and
rural development in human history’ (Capacity Building, Draft report, 2010). In 2009, the name
of Mahatma Gandhi was added to the policy, which has become one of the directive principles
and Article 21 of Fundamental Rights of the Constitution of India.
Policy goals
The overarching objective of the policy is to improve access and support the right to work for
the rural poor, thereby creating a real alternative for the people who usually have to find diverse
solutions migrating from rural to urban area. The main objectives are partially summarized in a
report prepared by the Ministry of Food and Disaster Management of Bangladesh1:
• To improve access to and support the right to work;
• To reduce the phenomenon of migration from the countryside to the city;
• To increase the power of the rural people below the poverty line;
• To create local and sustainable assets;
Chronological development
1 In 2008-09, the Government of Bangladesh choose to repeat the structure of the Indian policy, in Bangladesh,
aiming to address seasonal problems like flooding and river erosion by employing the rural extreme poor.
The Act was implemented in three phases beginning in 2006. In Phase 1 (beginning 2 February
2006), the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act was launched in 200 selected districts. In
Phase 2 (2007-08), it was extended to 130 more districts. In Phase 3 (from 1 April 2008
onwards), it was extended to the remaining 285 districts. The focus of the Act is on works
relating to soil and water conservation, drought proofing, land development, flood protection,
rural connectivity, and so forth. The choice of works suggested in the Act aim to address
problems of chronic poverty like drought, ground water depletion, deforestation, and soil
erosion, so the process of employment generation can proceed with attention to sustainably
improving the productivity of land.
Beneficiaries
The policy aims to help people who live in rural areas. The application of the Act, in different
States, includes several ameliorations and involves a large percentage of women. The policy
guarantees the right to work, simultaneously reducing the phenomenon of countryside-to-city
migration, enabling women to find a job in their district and near their houses, and allowing
men to remain in their village. Entire villages have been improved through such changes, which
have occurred from the implementation of the Act.
Financing
The National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme is a centrally sponsored programme through
a cost-sharing agreement between the Government of India and each State government. In
fiscal year 2009-10, the Central Government outlay for the scheme was Rs. 39,100 crores (U.S.$8
billion), had been augmented proportionally from 2006.
The salaries of individuals participating in the program are distributed by the National
Employment Guarantee Fund. The percentage of the cost-sharing arrangement for the wages
differs from state to state, but the central Government of India usually covers a major part of
the cost. For example, in the case of Bihar, the proportion is 90% paid by the central
government and 10% paid by the local State government (IFPRI 4/2010). There is some
variation in the financing percentage based on the type of worker: for skilled or semi-skilled
workers, their minimum wages are sponsored by the Government of India at 75%, with the
remaining 25% covered by the State. Normally the Government of India will bear the total
expenditure incurred on unskilled workers. The administrative costs incurred in paying the
unemployment allowance are fully borne by the State government.
Main obstacles
NREGA involves two challenging features:
First, the program is “transaction-intensive” in terms of time and space: It requires day-
to-day action throughout a country that spans an entire subcontinent. Second, the
program requires discretion, since decision-making on issues such as the type of
infrastructure to be created under the program cannot easily be standardized. (IFPRI
4/2010: 1)
The Act is implemented through a decentralized system of power, and its effectiveness can be
adjusted in a sensitive manner at the local level, so to improve its implementation and correct
some faults in the program. An IFPRI (2010) report notes that implementation is crucial to
determining how the governance challenges of the programme can be met:
In particular, it is essential to identify how the actual process of program implementation
differs from what is foreseen in the implementation guidelines, and to identify where
exactly the opportunities for leakage and mismanagement arise. Likewise, it is crucial to
find out how much influence various actors have on the implementation process, and how
local power structures and informal bureaucratic processes affect program implementation.
(IFPRI 4/2010: 1)
In pragmatic terms, the Act has had some trouble linked with the payment of wages and the
use of funds, which are being addressed through both social audits and technological solutions.
While the NREGA stipulates that workers should be paid within 15 days, some workers in
Bhilwara, a district in Rajasthan, received their payments only after 3-4 months, a problematic
situation in times of rapid inflation (Tewari 2010). In September-October 2009, a social audit
of NREGA was conducted by NGOs in Bhilwara (the first district to be covered by such a check),
which uncovered ‘some cases of corruption, irregularities and delayed payments’ (Tewari 2010).
Delayed payments, however, may be due to non-municipal systems since 75% of the payments
are made through post office accounts, rather than the NREGA bureaucracy itself. In different
States the local governments have joined with an international NGO to apply a technological
system to control the application of the law to the various villages (Manju Rajpal, district
collector of Bhilwara and a former NREGA commissioner, 2010)
Such work must contribute to the public good and must not displace existing jobs.
Communities have significant scope to identify their own priorities and needs. (Philip
2011)
Further information
This case was researched and written by Claudia Roselli (PhD student, School of Planning and
Architecture, New Delhi, and Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University of
Architecture, Florence) under the supervision of Drs. Giovanni Allegretti and Nancy Duxbury at
the Centre for Social Studies, University of Coimbra, Portugal, in 2011.
UCLG Committee on Social Inclusion, Participatory Democracy and Human Rights
Website: https://www.uclg-cisdp.org/
Contact information: cisdp1@uclg.org | +34 933 42 87 70
References
Bordia Das, M., 2010, Employment Programs by Any Other Name. URL:
http://blogs.worldbank.org/endpovertyinsouthasia/employment-programs-any-other-name
and http://www.accountabilityindia.in/accountabilityblog/1165-employment-programmes-
any-other-name
Central Employment Guarantee Council, 2010, Draft Report of the Working Group of Capacity
Building. URL: http://www.nregaconsortium.in/downloads/capacity_building.pdf
Im4change, 2011, Right To Work (MG-NREGA).URL:
http://www.im4change.org/empowerment/right-to-work-mg-nrega-39.html?pgno=1
Inclusive Media for Change, 2011, MGNEGA: Mixed Success so Far. URL:
http://www.im4change.org/news-alert/mgnrega-mixed-success-so-far-3513.html
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), 2010 (March), Promise and Realities of
Community-Based Agricultural Extension, IFPRI Discussion Paper 00959. URL:
http://www.ifpri.org/sites/default/files/publications/ifpridp00959.pdf
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), 2010 (April), How to Overcome the
Governance Challenge of Implementing NREGA: Insights from Bihar Using Process-Influence
Mapping, IFPRI Discussion Paper 00963.URL: http://www.ifpri.org/publication/how-overcome-
governance-challenges-implementing-nrega
Mahatma Ghandi National Rural Employment Act, Report to the People, 2 February 2006 to 2
February 2010, Ministry of Rural Development, Government of India.
PACS team, 2011, A background note on MGNREA in Jharkhand. State Consultations in PACS on
Thematic Issues. URL: http://www.pacsindia.org/sites/pacsindia.org/files/Background-note-
MGNREGA-Jharkhand-2011.pdf
Pal, Parthaprati & Ghosh, Jyaiati, 2007 (July), Inequality in India: a survey of recent trends.
DESA Working Paper No. 45. URL: http://www.un.org/esa/desa/papers/2007/wp45_2007.pdf
Philip, K., 2011, Work for ourselves, City Press. URL:
http://www.citypress.co.za/SouthAfrica/Features/Work-for-ourselves-20110709
PTI, 2010 (20 April), US heaps praise on India's NREGA, India Today. URL:
http://indiatoday.intoday.in/site/story/US+heaps+praise+on+India's+NREGA/1/93694.html
South Asia Media Net, 2010, USA lauds India's 100-day rural employment scheme. URL:
http://southasia.oneworld.net/globalheadlines/usa-lauds-indias-100day-rural-employment-
scheme
Tewari, R., 2010 (18 February), NREGA schemes check villagers’ exodus to cities, Livemint.com.
URL: http://www.livemint.com/2010/02/17211832/NREGA-schemes-check-villagers.html
UNESCO, 2010 (March), Historic Districts for All – India: A Social and Human Approach for
Sustainable Revitalisation. Brochure for Local Authorities. New Delhi, India: UNESCO
Publishing. URL: http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0018/001894/189482e.pdf
United Nations Development Programme (UNPD), 2009, Employment Guarantee Quickening
India’s March Towards MDGs. Report on an International Seminar on Rural Poverty: Key
Initiatives in Achieving Millennium Development Goals and the Role of NREGA, 21-22 January
2009, National Agricultural Science Centre, New Delhi. New York: United Nations Development
Programme. URL: http://undp.org.in/node/213 [14 March 2010]
World Bank, 2000 (27 September), Overview of Rural Decentralization in India: Volume 1. URL:
http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/civilservice/june2004seminar/RuralDecent.pdf