Keeping Quiet
Keeping Quiet
Ans. The poet, Pablo Neruda wishes to count to twelve so that we maintain silence and refrain from
physical activity for a short period. In this brief time, we can reflect and look inward to introspect. It will
promote peace and brotherhood among men. It will make us energetic.
2. Which is the exotic moment that the poet refers to in ‘Keeping Quiet’?
Or
What is considered an ‘exotic moment’ in the poem?
Or
Ashim sir
Why quietness would be an exotic moment for the speaker in ‘Keeping Quiet’? 2019
Ans. An “exotic moment” in ‘Keeping Quiet’ would be a moment of silence, when everyone would
refrain from speech and be still, without activity. This would be an unusual moment of excitement.
Being silent and contemplating is usually alien to human behaviour. Hence, being silent is considered to
be an exotic moment in the poem.
3. What is the sadness that the poet refers to in the poem ‘Keeping Quiet’? (2013, 2014, 2015)
Ans. The sadness that Neruda talks about in ‘Keeping Quiet’ is the sorrow of not understanding
ourselves. We go about life rather mechanically without knowing what we like or what we want to do.
We are immensely busy in achieving materialistic things which ultimately leads to sadness. We can
understand ourselves only if we stop all our actives for moments and do some quiet introspection.
4. What symbol from nature does the poet invoke that there can be life under apparent stillness?
Ans. The poet use nature as a symbol to explain his idea that there can be life under apparent stillness.
An example from nature is the earth itself, as, when everything seems dead, it later proves to be alive.
5. What are the different kinds of wars mentioned in the poem? What is Neruda’s attitude towards
these wars? (2013, 2017)
Ans. The poet writes about was against humanity and nature. Green wars, wars with poisonous gases
and wars with fire are the kinds of wars mentioned in the poem. Neruda’s attitude towards war is one of
rejection. He feels that such wars may bring victory, but there are no survivors to celebrate the victory.
6. Do you think that the poet advocates total inactivity and death?
Ans. No, the poet does not advocate total inactivity and death. He clarifies that he has no truck with
death. According to him, life is meant to be lived to the fullest. He just wants the inhuman and
destructive activities to stop. He says that the essence of life is activity while inactivity is death.
Ans. We can learn certain lessons from the earth. There is a period of hibernation and inactivity, after
which there is revival and activity. During winter, nature appears to be sleeping and at rest. This stillness
of winter gives way to the bloom of spring, where nature is rejuvenated after a period of rest. The earth
is never dead when everything seems to be dead, it remains still alive. Similarly, we must keep quiet
and introspect in order to lead more meaningful and fulfilling lives.
(a) What does the poet mean by ‘not move our arms’ so much?
Ans. The poet wants us not to move our arms so much because physical activity leads to stopping out
introspection. Not moving our arms also suggests stopping all kinds of violence.
9. What does the poet to convey by addressing the fishermen and the man gathering salt?
Ans. The poet is against any kind of violence. He wants the fisherman that they should not harm whales
in the sea and introspect and analyse their actions and their consequences. The poet against any kind of
self-torturing in his greed to collect more and more salt, the salt gathering man has hurt his hand. He
must look after himself and take care of his hand.
11. What does the poet say about different kinds of wars? What alternative does he suggest? (2017)
Or
What is Pablo Neruda’s opinion about different kinds of wars? 2019
Ans. The poet wants a total cessation of all kind of wars. Green wars against the environment, wars with
poisonous gases and fire must stop immediately. Instead of indulging in wars, the people must come out
in their best dresses with their brothers. They should go out for a walk, enjoying themselves doing
nothing.
12. Why does the poet say “I want no truck with death”?
Ans. The poet clarifies that he wants no association with death. He is advocating stillness and quietness
to introspect, not total inactivity or death.
13. What is the significance of the phrase ‘On the face of the earth’ in Neruda’s?
Ans. The significance of the phrase ‘on the face of the earth’ is that although different people speak
different languages on this earth, for a moment, they should stop talking in different languages and
remain silent for self-introspection.
15. “Fishermen in the cold sea would not harm whales. “ What is meant by the above line by Neruda?
Ans.Neruda means that the fishermen would not strive to catch or harm sea life or creatures in the sea.
He wants the fisherman that they should introspect and analyse their actions and their consequences
When silence is maintained, and there is no movement, the fishermen would also be still and not be
involved in fishing. The sea creatures would also get temporary respite from the nets of the fishermen.
16. “… and the man gathering salt would look at his hurt hands. ” What is meant by, gathering salt in the
above lines? How are his hands hurt?
Ashim sir
Ans. Same as question 9
17. What is the meaning of ;Wars with gas and Wars with fire
Ans. Wars with gas mean chemicals are used to produce poisonous gas. E.g.- the gas used in
concentration camps during the Holocaust, in Germany.
Wars with fire mean using weapons like guns and firearms to shoot.