SB03 - Se Asia
SB03 - Se Asia
INTRODUCTION
Copyright ©2022. The American Association of Petroleum Geologists. All rights reserved.
Manuscript received March 18, 2021; provisional acceptance April 22, 2021; revised manuscript
received July 10, 2021; final acceptance July 15, 2021.
DOI:10.1306/09152121048
tectonic and volcanic settings in the world and com- Oil and gas production is a major contributor to
prises many basins with complex geological histories the national GDP of most nations in the region. Sixty
(Tapponnier et al., 1982; Longley, 1997; Hall, 2012; percent of current daily production of 5.6 million
Hutchison, 2014). It is also a region with equally BOE per day in Southeast Asia is gas, mainly for
complex local politics surrounding one of the world’s domestic energy and liquefied natural gas (LNG)
most contested territories, the South China Sea. export (Wood Mackenzie Lens database, 2021). The
However, it is this very complexity that also offers total daily oil production of Southeast Asia is 2.4 mil-
the industry a diverse set of opportunities for hydro- lion BOPD, which is significantly lower than the oil
carbon exploitation, from frontier to mature basins. demand of the region, estimated at 9 million BOPD
Geopolitically, Southeast Asia consists of 10 (International Energy Agency, 2020). The huge dif-
nations—Malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore, Thailand, ference between supply and demand puts most
Myanmar, the Philippines, Vietnam, Cambodia, Southeast Asian nations as net oil importers.
Laos, and Brunei—collectively known as the Associa- Geologically, the region has undergone many tec-
tion of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). With a tonic events and, as a result, is characterized by
total population of more than 600 million in an area numerous Cenozoic basins (Figure 2), with up to 40
half the size of the United States (Figure 1), it is one basins considered to be significant, prolific hydrocar-
of the most populous regions in the world and the bon basins (Doust, 2017). At least five producing
location of the world’s most densely populated island, basins have individually produced more than 5 billion
Java. Most of the 4.4 million km2 of Southeast Asia’s BOE; they represent a considerable resource that has
land area is in islands and archipelagoes, with many been actively exploited over 100 years, and the resour-
overlapping claims in disputed marine areas. The ces continue to grow with further exploration. The
average per capita gross domestic product (GDP) for Malay, Greater Luconia, Northwest Sabah, Greater
the Southeast Asian nations ranges broadly, from US Sumatra, and Kutei Basins (Figures 2, 3) are the five
$1200 for Myanmar to US $64,000 for Singapore super basins of Southeast Asia. The first three basins
(International Monetary Fund, 2019), reflecting the are located in Malaysia, whereas the last two are
diverse sets of economies of these nations. located in Indonesia. Some of these basins are made
up of several smaller but genetically related subbasins. maturity. However, significant potential remains, as
For example, the Greater Luconia Basin includes has been repeatedly demonstrated by recent discov-
Central and North Luconia, as well as the Balingian eries in traditional as well as less-explored frontier
and Tatau subbasins that share a common source areas. In this paper, we will be showing how South-
rock and, to some extent, hydrocarbon plays. east Asian basins, particularly the super basins,
To date, 96 billion BOE of petroleum has been developed tectono-stratigraphically and outline their
discovered from these five basins, from which main petroleum systems and plays. We will also be
approximately 60 billion BOE has already been pro- discussing some examples of recent successes and
duced. An estimated 35 billion BOE of recoverable offer some thoughts on how these super basins
reserves and at least 30 billion BOE of estimated pro- keep producing some significant volume from
spective resources remain yet to be found (Figure 3). time to time from the thinking and technological
However, out of these five basins, the Malay Basin perspectives.
has shown signs of a plateauing creaming curve for
some time and, although modern three-dimensional
(3-D) seismic data and interpretation technologies TECTONO-STRATIGRAPHIC EVOLUTION
are expected to contribute to new prospective SUMMARY
resources, it will probably not add significant yet-to-
find reserves that warrant it remaining a super basin The Southeast Asian super basins are located on the
in the future. The Malay Basin, therefore, will not be Sunda Shelf and share a common tectonic history
discussed further in this paper. (Figure 2). The Sundaland, which is the geologic core
Because hydrocarbons in Southeast Asia have of the Sunda Shelf, sits at the juncture of many
been produced continuously for nearly 150 yr, there plates, sandwiched between the India and South
is a perception that the traditional onshore and off- China plates to the west and north, respectively, to
shore petroleum basins have reached exploration the south by the Australia plate, and to the east by
5.3 15
2.1
15 3.9 3.9
3.9 Greater
10.9
7.2
Luconia
10 3.3 10
13.4 5.5
2.1
5 Kutei
7.9 5.0 1.5
4.5
2.7
0 1.2 5
Greater Sumatra NW Sabah Malay Greater Luconia Kutei
Sedimentary Basins
Oil Produced Gas Produced
0
Condensate Produced Oil Resources Remaining Pre 1966 1971 1976 1981 1986 1991 1996 2001 2006 2011 2016
Gas Resources Remaining Condensate Resources Remaining 1961
YTF (Mean)
Figure 3. Significant oil and gas resources have been found and produced in Southeast Asia (SEA) basins, with much potential remain-
ing (data from Wood Mackenzie Lens database, 2021). BBOE 5 billion barrels of oil equivalent; YTF 5 yet-to-find.
the Philippines plate (Figure 2). It is a heterogeneous to the subduction zones in Sulawesi, and this could
collage of Paleozoic and Mesozoic basement rocks suggest that the rifting could form in a back-arc set-
and is host to an assemblage of smaller basins, which ting. The extension continued until the Oligocene,
came about from the “Clash of Giants” related to the where it was abruptly halted by an uplift event.
collision between the Indian and Eurasian plates in These rifts in the eastern edge of Sundaland are char-
the late Eocene and the collision with the Australian acterized by marine sediment fill.
plate in the Miocene. The second event is the late Eocene hard colli-
There are several large tectonic events that sion between India and mainland Eurasia (Gibbons
drive the formation of the basins in and around the et al., 2015; Figure 4). This gave rise to transtensional
periphery of the Sunda Shelf, of which three are basins that stretch from Myanmar (Moattama basin)
important from the perspective of the petroleum sys- to offshore Thailand and Malay peninsula. The rifting
tem (Figure 4). The first is the late Paleocene–late of the South China Sea also seems to start during
Eocene soft collision of the Indian plate and Eurasian this period and continues to ca. 20 Ma (Barckhausen
plate (Gibbons et al., 2015; Hu et al., 2016), which et al., 2014). During this event, several major north-
formed the back-arc basins in Sumatra and Java along west-southeast trending, right-lateral faults systems,
the southern edge of Sundaland. These deep basins namely, the Sagaing, Three Pagodas, and Red River
host the major source rocks in the region and act as faults, from west to east, formed or became reacti-
the kitchen for the present-day hydrocarbon accu- vated to accommodate the northward movement of
mulations. Most of the source rocks that were depos- India. The movements of these faults, which extend
ited during this period were of lacustrine origin since farther to the southeast, also formed the extensional
these basins formed within the inland terrane of Sun- basins in the South China Sea, mainly around Bor-
daland and were protected from marine incursion by neo (Pubellier and Morley, 2014). Following similar
volcanic arc. depositional trends as the first event, the basins in
Toward the eastern edge of Sundaland, rifting the center of Sundaland were also filled with lacus-
started in the Kutei Basin, which may have been trine sediments, whereas the basins to the east con-
driven by extension in the Celebes Sea and the tinue to be filled with marine sediments.
Makassar Strait earlier in the early Eocene (Moss The third significant tectonic event is the colli-
et al., 1997). Both extension centers are in proximity sion of the Australian plate with Sundaland in the
NW NW
MALAY
SABAH SABAH
SU
SU
MA
LUCONIA LUCONIA
MA
TR
TR
A
A
KUTEI KUTEI
0 1000 0 1000
Kilometer Kilometer
(C) (D)
90 E 100 E 110 E 120 E 130 E 140 E
9Ma 6Ma
30 N
20 N
10 N
NW
MALAY NW MALAY SABAH
SABAH
LUCONIA
LUCONIA
SU
SU
0N
MA
MA
KUTEI
KUTEI
TR
TR
A
10 S
0 1000 0 1000
Kilometer Kilometer
Legend :
Deep marine
Shallow marine
Carbonate
Volcanic
Subduction zone
Figure 4. The India–Eurasia collision (Paleocene–Oligocene) gave birth to countless Cenozoic basins, whereas the late Miocene collision
with the Australian plate is responsible for basin inversion and fault reactivation (modified after Pubellier and Morley, 2014; Hall, 2012).
(A) Subduction in the south and southwest of Sundaland formed back-arc basins of Sumatra and Java. (B) The India-Laurasia collision trig-
gered trantensional opening of multiple basins in the center of Sundaland including the Malay Basin. (C) Collision between Australia and
Banda Sea plates led to the formation of localized highs in Greater Luconia, Northwest Sabah and offshore Java basins, which encouraged
the growth of carbonate buildups. (D) The collision between the Philippines plate with the Sunda Shelf gave rise to inland uplifts and trig-
gered many deep-water fan depositions across Southeast Asia.
Figure 5. Southeast Asia comprises several tectonic settings that formed many related basins (Darman and Sidi, 2017).
Mts. 5 Mountains; St. 5 Strait.
RICE-OXLEY
AND
ABU-BAKAR
639
(A) (B)
Cretaceous
Figure 7. (A) Chronostratigraphy of the main Southeast Asia basins with main play elements. (B) Simplified basin fill evolution showing
the synrift and postrift periods (modified after Doust and Lijmbach, 1997; Clements et al., 2011). Numbering 1–4 in part (B) corresponds
to the period shown by the same numbering in part (A).
initial basin fills gave rise to type I source rocks in the During this early postrift period, major deltas started
lacustrine-filled basins of Sumatra and West Java and to form extensively on the edge of the South China
type II/III source rock in the marine-filled basins of Sea, especially in northwestern Borneo and offshore
East Java and Kutei. Vietnam. In Central Luconia, carbonate platforms
The centrally located basins of Sundaland also grew on the highs of major rotated fault blocks formed
started to form in the Eocene and continued opening during the previous rifting event (Figures 2, 7B).
in the Oligocene (Madon et al., 2019, 2020). During These carbonates form very significant reservoirs for
this period, terrestrial to lacustrine sediments of type Southeast Asia. Carbonates also accumulated on highs
I and type III source rocks were deposited in the cen- in the form of reefs, which could be found from
tral part of Sundaland, such as the Malay Basin, Sumatra in the west to the Philippines in the east.
whereas the eastern basins in Kutei were closer to the Source rock deposited during this time in these paralic
open sea and likely filled with marine sediments that basins are rich in fluvial deltaic type II/III allochtho-
contain type II source rocks (Figures 2, 7). nous land-plant material.
The opening of the South China Sea during this In the late Miocene–Pliocene, subduction of the
period resulted in an extensive transgression or Philippines oceanic plate underneath the northeast-
marine flooding over most of Sundaland that intensi- ern fringe of Sundaland, near Northwest Sabah, led
fied during the early to middle Miocene. In Sunda- to inversions accompanied by local erosion in many
land’s marginal basins, such as the Northwest Sabah areas. Extensive uplift occurred on the Borneo hin-
Basin, reservoirs were deposited in shelfal to bathyal terland, which became the source for the Baram
marine environments (Figures 2, 7). and Makaham deltas in the Northwest Sabah and
During the middle Miocene, the cessation of rift- Kutei Basins, respectively, that built thick, upward-
ing gave rise to major regression in the center of Sun- shallowing, regressive deltas (Figure 6D, E). These
daland and is marked by a marine erosional surface deltas consist of growth faults in the shallow-water
known regionally as the mid-Miocene unconformity. areas and thrust anticlines in the deep-water areas.
(B)
Figure 9. (A) Southeast Asia oil and gas demands are increasing and current production from its basins cannot meet its domestic demand.
(B) Exploration and production activities are rallying to meet Southeast Asia’s future energy demand by exploring emerging plays, especially
gas, and building facilities for hydrocarbon evacuation. LNG 5 liquefied natural gas; MMBO 5 million barrels of oil; vs 5 versus.
demand. But with its long exploration history, are These recent discoveries were not accidental but
there still giants waiting to be explored in Southeast were the results of new approaches and thinking that
Asia? Recent discoveries such as the aforementioned were undertaken by successful oil and gas companies,
Lang Lebah and Kaliberau Dalam all have significant as well as host nations. In this paper, we suggest three
resources that suggest that the likelihood is high. of the most significant approaches taken to continue
Figure 10. Kasawari found 5 TCF gas with >1 km of gas column, one of the 2011 giant discoveries. The “blown trap” feature can be
seen in the seismic section, circled in red. Location in Figure 8. TWT 5 two-way traveltime.
Miocene to Pliocene deep-water turbidites, was wildcats drilled in the region and contributed quite
another dogma-breaking find given the prevailing significant resources to the region, approximately 11
belief at that time that the deep-water play of billion BOE or 38% of discovered volume (Mair and
Northwest Sabah was gas-prone. Since then, Tan, 2015). Most key discoveries in deep water in
deep-water wildcats accounted for 13% of total new Southeast Asia is distributed around Borneo–
Figure 13. Map showing areas where deep-water exploration was active in Southeast Asia between 2000 and 2014 (Mair and Tan, 2015)
Figure 14. (A) Seismic expression in deep-water Northwest Sabah Basin showing the Kikeh field in the thrust belts (modified after Jones
et al., 2016). The inset map shows the location of seismic lines. (B) Seismic expression of deep-water Kutei Basin showing the location of
Merakes and Jangkrik fields (modified after Roniwibowo et al., 2019). Hor 5 horizon; TWT = two-way traveltime.
Northwest Sabah Basin in Malaysia and Kutei Basin Figure 14B). These Pliocene sands were thought to
in Indonesia (Figure 13). have been charged also from a biogenic source in
In the Northwest Sabah Basin, early deep-water addition to a thermogenic contribution (Saller et al.,
exploration activities were focused in the toe thrust 2006).
areas following the Kikeh play opener. Several repli- Similar to Northwest Sabah, there are several
cate discoveries followed (e.g., Gumusut-Kakap plays in the deep-water Kutei Basin that have not yet
field), and exploration expanded across the basin with been tested. For example, the extension of the
oil being prominent in the southwestern part of the proven Miocene fluvio-deltaic to deep-water sedi-
basin, near the Baram delta, whereas gas dominated ments of the Mahakam delta beyond the midlower
the northeastern part (e.g., Rotan-1 discovery) and in slope, the structural and stratigraphic traps toward
the ultradeep-water Baram delta province in Brunei the basin floor, and the Eocene-Miocene carbonates
(e.g., Kelidang NE-1, Keratau-1, and Kempas-1 dis- (Satyana, 2017).
coveries; Figure 8). Most of the discoveries in the toe Geographically, a large part of the deep-water
thrust setting were targeting structural traps. areas in Northwest Sabah and Kutei Basins remain
The challenge to delineate the complex sand dis- relatively underexplored. This fact is illustrated in the
tribution, however, remains. Turbidites were derived two maps from Westwood Energy, showing wells
from a narrow shelf and transported down an unsta- drilled since 2008 (Figure 15). These maps highlight
ble slope, where syndepositional, thrust-modified the bias toward shallow-water wells but, more impor-
slope topography influenced sand distribution down tantly, the scarcity of wells in very large parts of the
and along the slope. Given the complexity of the sed- basins, especially in the ultra-deep-water areas.
imentary fill, it is no surprise that the synkinematic A new, interesting play is emerging in Northwest
sands deposited in structural lows and the deeper, Sabah deep water, which may replicate the success
prekinematic sands and their lateral extension into of the Oligocene–Miocene carbonates in other parts
other parts of the basins have not been fully tested in of Southeast Asia. This play was proven in the Pala-
this basin. wan Trough in the Philippines with the discovery of
In the Kutei Basin of Indonesia, only the Pliocene the Malampaya field in the last millennium; however,
slope channels of the Mahakam delta have been it was not pursued in the adjacent Northwest Sabah
proven over the last two decades with discoveries Basin, largely because of deeper water depth and
such as Eni’s 2.5 TCF in-place gas at Jangkrik and 2 absence of good seismic data. The 2018 Tepat-1 well
TCF in-place gas at Merakes (Meciani and Orsi, 2018; drilled by the consortium of Total, PETRONAS, and
Shell, therefore, called for a celebration when the the Sabah Trough that could provide a focus for
consortium successfully tested a frontier Oligocene– future exploration drilling.
Miocene carbonate play and found significant oil and If we continue with the theme of replicating suc-
gas pay in >2800 m of water depth (Figure 16). The cess, then the synrift may be the next, and last, fron-
Tepat discovery was a breakthrough in replicating tier play to pursue in the deep-water basins of
success and testing a new idea in these frontier areas. Southeast Asia. The synrift play and synrift lacus-
The play relies on the presence of an Eocene to Oli- trine source rocks have contributed to key discover-
gocene source rock within the Eocene–lower Oligo- ies in the Song Hon Basin in Vietnam, Pearl River
cene synrift or an early postrift shallow marine source Mouth Basin in China, as well as in the Gulf of Thai-
rock, coeval with the deposition of the carbonate res- land. The Eocene to Oligocene synrift sediments,
ervoirs. The Tepat discovery has opened a new observed on both two-dimensional and 3-D seismic
exploration play in the Northwest Sabah Basin and data in all these basins including Sabah, Greater
many interesting carbonate features are observed in Luconia, and Kutei Basins (Figure 6A–E), remain
the recently acquired (2014–2017) regional multi- untested and may offer future deep-water explora-
client 3-D data (18,000 km2), covering much of tion opportunities.
Figure 16. Tepat is a deep-water oil and gas discovery in Oligocene–Miocene carbonates in the underexplored Sabah Trough (seismic
image courtesy of TotalEnergies). Location in Figure 15. MC3D 5 multiclient three-dimensional seismic data; PSDM 5 pre-stack depth
migration.
(A)
(B)
Figure 17. Example of new ways of working and continuous improvements in petroleum arrangements to attract different players
including (A) enhancement in the fiscal and nonfiscal terms, simplification of bidding process to boost more value creation in mature basin
and accelerate gas exploration and development, and (B) data enrichment through multiclient data acquisition activities in frontier
basins and open data access. 2-D 5 two-dimensional; 3-D 5 three-dimensional; DW 5 deep water; Expl 5 exploration; HP 5 high pres-
sure; HT 5 high temperature; PSC 5 production sharing contract; PVB 5 progressive volume based; R/C 5 revenue over cost model.