LLE - Pooja
LLE - Pooja
LLE - Pooja
1. Introduction.........................................................................................................................2
2. Liquid –liquid extraction.....................................................................................................3
2.1 Advantages of solvent extraction....................................................................................4
2.2 Application of Extraction................................................................................................4
3. Liquid-Liquid Equilibria.....................................................................................................4
4. Ternary System....................................................................................................................5
4.1 Type 1 Ternary System...................................................................................................6
4.1.1 Effect of Temperature On E.T.D Type- 1 System............................................................7
4.2 Type 2 Ternary System:........................................................................................................7
4.2.1 Effect of Temperature On E.T.D Type 2 Ternary System........................................8
4.3 The carrier and the solvent are partially immiscible:.........................................................8
6.3 Multistage Counter-Current Extraction......................................................................13
6.3.1 Minimum solvent requirement.................................................................................15
7 . IMMISCIBLE SYSTEMS...............................................................................................16
7.1 multistage Cross- current operation.............................................................................16
7.2 multistage Counter current operation..........................................................................16
8 . CLASSIFICATION OF EXTRACTON EQUIPMENT...............................................17
9 . Stage Wise Equipment for Extraction............................................................................19
9.1 The mixer settler............................................................................................................19
9.1.1 Advantages.........................................................................................................................19
9.1.2 Disadvantages..............................................................................................................20
9.2 York-Scheibel Column..................................................................................................20
10 . Differential Contact Equipment for Extraction.........................................................21
10.1 spray column..................................................................................................................21
10.1.2 Dis Advantages................................................................................................................21
10.2 Packed column...............................................................................................................22
10.3 Rotary disc contactor.....................................................................................................23
10.4 Pulsed Column Extractor..............................................................................................24
1. Introduction
a. The bringing the feed and solvent into intimate contact by dispensing one
phase into the others as droplets.
b. Separation of extract and raffinate phase that have different densities.
c. Removal and recovery of solute from the extract phase in a relatively pure
form.
d. Removal and recovery of solvent from each phase by distillation.
2.1 Advantages of solvent extraction
Selectivity of extraction directly from fermentation broths or from reaction
medium in the case of bio transformations wherein whole cells or enzymes
are used for conversion of a substrate into a desired product.
Reduction in product loss due to hydrolytic or metabolic/microbial
degradation as the product is transferred to a second phase with different
physical and chemical properties.
Suitability over a wide range of scales operation.
The schematic diagram shown in Fig.1 & steps indicates the various streams
involved in a typical liquid-liquid extraction operation. The equilibrium
concentration of such systems can be represented in a triangular coordinate
system. In some operations, the solutes are the desired product, hence the extract
stream is the desirable stream. In other applications, the solutes may be the
contaminants that need to be removed, and in this instance the raffinate is the
desirable product stream.
4. Ternary System
The ternary systems usually follow any one of the two categories given below:
a. one pair partially soluble (type1 ternary system) and two pairs partially
soluble (type 2 ternary system)
b. Insoluble systems.
The equilibrium data for a liquid-liquid system are of vital importance in the
selection and design of an extraction equipment. By it three binary mixtures can
be formed: A-B, B-C, C-A. The mutual miscibility behaviour of the components
in each of these binaries determines the nature of the equilibrium diagram for the
ternary system.
A-C and B-C are miscible pairs and A-B is partially miscible pair. About 75% of
ternary liquid systems are fall in this category.
B-C and A-B are only partially soluble and A is completely soluble in C. ( Open
ternary system)
It is not necessary that K should be greater than 1. K can be less than 1. But higher
value of K is desirable because higher the distribution coefficient, lesser is the
amount of solvent required for desired separation. Unfortunately, solvents which
provide the higher value of K normally provide poor value of α.
5.3 Recoverability
It is always necessary to recover the solvent from extract phase for reuse. Hence
selected solvent must be easily recoverable from the extract phase. In most of the
cases. solvent is separated from extract phase by distillation. If selected solvent to
be separated or recovered by distillation than it should not form an azeotrope with
the solute and also it should provide higher value of relative volatility. Lesser
value of latent heat of vaporization of solvent is also desirable for low cost of
recovery. Water is not an attractive solvent for extraction as it forms azeotrope or
non-ideal solution with many organics and it has very high value of latent heat of
vaporization.
Low solubility of solvent in the raffinate phase is desirable. Solvent which is more
insoluble is preferred. More insoluble solvent can separate wide range of
composition of feed mixture. Also, it gives less solvent loss and adds less impurity
in the final raffinate. Generally, a solvent which is more insoluble provides higher
selectivity.
5.5 Density
Higher density difference between solvent and diluent or extract and raffinate
phase is desirable. It makes the decantation easier. In most of the systems, density
difference decreases to zero at plait point, but in some system it can become zero
at an intermediate solute concentration and can invert the phases at higher con-
centration.
For such a system, in the desired range of separation in the extractor, if density
difference passes through zero then use of continuous contact equipment like
packed tower is not preferred but mixer-settler type stage wise extractor can be
used. Other option is to use two continuous contact extractors in series.
A high interfacial tension promotes rapid coalescence and generally requires high
mechanical energy for agitation to produce small droplets. Conversely, low inter-
facial tension requires lesser mechanical energy for agitation to produce small
droplets but at the same time it provides slow coalescence rates.
The solvent should be inert towards the other components of extraction system
and to the common materials of construction.
5.8 Other properties: Viscosity, Vapour Pressure and Freezing Point. All these
properties of solvent should be low for ease in handling, transportation and storage. The
solvent should be nontoxic, non-flammable and of low cost.
The quantities of extract and raffinate can be computed from mixture rule
given by material balance given in Eq. (2)
xm1−x 1
E 1= M1( ) (6
y 1−x 1
The point F corresponds to feed mixture and S, the solvent. Once the feed and solvent are
mixed, the mixture has an effective solute concentration of XM1 and is located as M1 which
lies on the line joining F and S. Thus the point M1 lies within the curve. However, on
settling, the mixture forms the two phases E1 and R1 and the line joining the points E, and R1
intersects the feed line FS which is M1. Though many lines can be drawn through the point
M1, only one line could be the tie line which will correspond to the equilibrium composition
of extract and raffinate phases. The tie line could be located by a trial and error procedure
using the equilibrium curve as shown.
6.2 Cross-Current Operation
F + S1 = R1 + E1 = M1 ………………………. (7)
( F xf + S 1 ys)
XM1 =
(F +S 1)
( Ri−1+Siys)
Similarly for any stage I, X Mi =
(Ri−1+ Si)
F + ENp+1 = E1 + R Np
i.e. F - E1 = R Np - ENp+1………………………….14
F + En+1 = E1 + R, ……………….17
F - E = R, - En+1……………. 18
F - E1 = R1 - E2 = R2 - E3 = R
Fig. counter current operation-graphical representation of stages
Here R, which is defined as a difference point, is the net flow outward not only at
the last stage but also between any two adjacent stages and it remains constant. In
other words, any line joining FE1, R1E2, R2E3, ... and extended must pass through
the point R as shown in Fig.
1. Plot ternary data and draw the distribution curve adjacent to the ternary data in
rectangular co-ordinates as shown in Fig.
2. Locate the feed point (F), solvent point (E Np+1) and the raffinate point (R Np) leaving
the systems based on their composition.
❑
3. Join FS and locate XM where, XM= ❑
4. Join R Np and XM and extend it to intersect the bimodal curve which gives E1.
5. Join F and E1. Similarly join R Np and ENp+1-
6. Lines FE, and R Np ENp+1 are extended to meet and the meeting point is R.
7. Through E, and with the help of distribution curve, locate R, on solvent
lean layer.
8. Join R1 with R and extend the line to obtain E2 on the solvent rich layer
part of the ternary data plot.
9. Through E2 and with the distribution curve, obtain R2.
10. Proceed similarly till R Np is crossed, thus number of stages needed for
a specific operation is obtained.
11. However, if the number of stages are specified, there are two possible questions that
arise.
6.3.1 Minimum solvent requirement
The minimum solvent needed is fixed by the tie line which passes through the point of
intersection of line FE mm and solvent lean layer curve (the corresponding point of
intersection is F'). The procedure to determine the minimum amount of solvent is given
below and shown in Fig.
Steps
1. Plot the ternary data and draw the distribution curve.
2. Locate F, E Np + 1 and R Np.
3. Arbitrarily draw the line R Np E mm and check with the help of x-y plot whether the
points F' and E m. correspond to a tie line. If not, by trial and error locate a suitable R
Np E mm line which will ultimately correspond to tie line.
4. Join F E Np + 1 and E mm R Np to find the intersection of these lines, X m.
5. Since,
6. the determined ENp+1 will be the minimum solvent required. (Since, all the other
quantities are known.)
7 . IMMISCIBLE SYSTEMS
7.1multistage Cross- current operation
In insoluble systems, the solvent (B) and the non-solute component in feed solution
(A) are insoluble and remain so at all solute concentrations. Since A and B are insoluble, the
amount of A and B both in their feed streams and the leaving streams remain constant. If X is
the solute concentration in feed stream or raffinate stream expressed in mass ratio (kg of C/kg
of A) and Y is the solute concentration in solvent or extract stream expressed in mass ratio
(kg of C / kg of B), then a mass balance around stage n with reference to Fig. 10.15 yields
where A is the non-solute component in feed and B , is the quantity of pure solvent
used in nth stage, - A/B ,, is the slope of the operating line for stage n. For a typical three
stage cross-current operation the construction of operating lines and the determination of final
concentration of raffinate is shown in Fig.
If the two solvents are immiscible, the solvent in the raffinate streams remains as A,
and the added solvent in the extract streams as S. The material balances for the solute may
then be written as
This is the equation of a straight line of slope A/S, known as the operating line, which
passes through the points (Xf, Y1) and (X ,., Yn+1). In Figure 13.14, the equilibrium relation,
Y, against X ,., and the operating line are drawn in, and the number of stages required to pass
from X, to X ,, is found by drawing in steps between the operating line and the equilibrium
curve. In this example, four stages are required, and (X ,., Yn+1) corresponds to (X4, Ys). It
may be noted that the operating line connects the compositions of the raffinate stream leaving
and the fresh solvent stream entering a unit, X ,, and Yn+1,respectively.
Phase Contact By
Phase Contact by Gravity Centrifugal Force
Rotary Reciprocating
Spray columns Pulse-packed
contactors contactors Static mixer
Packed columns Column Vibrating-plate
Plate columns Pulse plate Extractor
Column Perforated plate Ultrasonic extractor
Mixer settler Column
Controlled- Scheibel columns Electrically-sided
Karr column
cycling columnOldshue- Rushton extractor
pulsed mixer column
settler Rotary disk
Contactor
Kuhni column
Grasser raining-
Bucket contactor
9 . Stage Wise Equipment for Extraction
Each mixer settler provides a single stage of extraction. The two phases enter the
mixing section where they are mixed using an impeller. Later the two phases are allowed to
separate by gravity due to their density differences. Typically, mixer settler has mixing time
of the order of a few minutes and settling times of several minutes.
If no. of theoretical stages, required for desired separation, is less than or equal to
four, mixer settler is probably the most economical amongst all types of extractors. In this
extractor, turbine or propellers are used as agitators. Amongst all types agitators, pitched
blade turbine agitator is found to be most effective for mixing of two soluble liquids. For
small vessels, propellers are selected for mixing.
The normal ratio of impeller to tank diameter is 0.25 to 0.33. The dispersion can also
be achieved by the dispersion of one liquid through another liquid in the form of fine droplets
with the help of nozzles.
9.1.1 Advantages
o Provides better contact of extract and raffinate phases and thus provides higher
rate of mass transfer.
o Higher efficiency or attain separation closer to equilibrium.
o Requires limited instrumentation.
o Reliable scale up.
o Requires low head room.
o Low capital cost.
o Provides more stage wise flexibility.
o Offers wide range of capacities and simple operation.
9.1.2 Disadvantages
This column is provided with mixing and horizontal packed compartments arranged
alternately as shown in Fig. Mixing is done by a turbine impeller which is attached to a
mechanically driven central shaft. The packed compartments are provided with wire mesh to
reduce axial mixing.
One of the problems with perforated plate and indeed packed columns is that
redispersion of the liquids after each stage is very poor. To overcome this, SCHEIBEL and
KARR (8) introduced a unit, shown in Figure 13.30, in which a series of agitators is mounted
on a central rotating shaft. Between the agitators is fitted a wire mesh section which
successfully breaks up any emulsions. Some results for a column 292 mm diameter, with 100
mm diameter agitators and with packing sections 230 and 340 mm, are shown in Figure
13.31. It is found that one theoretical stage is obtained in a height of 0.45-0.75 m. This is a
significant improvement on that usually obtained in a packed column. Although there are few
data on large units, there should be no fall in efficiency as the diameter is increased.
o Efficient Separation
o Compact Design
o Lower Pressure Drop
o Heat-Sensitive Materials
o Versatile
o Good for Close Boiling Mixtures
o Energy Efficient
o Easy to Scale Up
o Continuous Operation
9.2.2 Disadvantages
o Limited Capacity
o High Initial Cost
o Clogging
o Complex Operation.
o Not for High Viscosity
o Packing Issues
o Less Flexible
o Not for Dense Mixtures.
o High Energy consumption
o High Maintenance
Applications
o Low number of stages
o High flow rate
o Very high residence time
o Moderate to high interfacial tension
o low to high viscosity
o low to high density differences
o high floor space
Two methods of operating spray columns are shown in Figure 13.32. Either the light
or heavy phase may be dispersed. In the former case (a) the light phase enters from a
distributor at the bottom of the column and the droplets rise through the heavier phase, finally
coalescing to form a liquid-liquid interface at the top of the tower. Alternatively, the heavier
phase may be dispersed, in which case the interface is held at the bottom of the tower as
shown in (b). Although spray towers are simple in construction, they are inefficient because
considerable recirculation of the continuous phase takes place. As a result, true
countercurrent flow is not maintained and up to 6 m may be required for the height of one
theoretical stage. There is very little turbulence in the continuous phase and lack of interface
renewal, and appreciable axial mixing results in poor performance.
Fig. spray columns
10.1.1advantages
o simple Design: Easy to operate with a straightforward setup.
o Good for Small-Scale Operations: Ideal for laboratory or pilot-scale
extraction.
o Low Cost: Generally cheaper to install and maintain than other columns.
o Efficient for Low-Volume Flows: Works well for smaller liquid flows and
lower throughput.
o Effective for Heat-Sensitive Materials: Can handle temperature-sensitive
compounds without high heat exposure.
o Flexible: Can be used for a variety of liquid-liquid extraction processes.
o Simple Maintenance: Easier to clean and maintain than more complex column
types.
o Low Efficiency: Lower mass transfer efficiency than other types of columns.
o Limited Capacity: Not suitable for large-scale operations.
o High Pressure Drop: Requires more energy for pumping liquids.
o Inconsistent Spray: Hard to achieve uniform spray distribution.
o Not for Viscous Liquids: Struggles with thick or sticky liquids.
o Temperature Control Issues: Difficult to maintain uniform temperature.
o Emulsion Formation: Higher chance of creating emulsions, reducing
separation.
o High Maintenance: Requires frequent cleaning and nozzle replacements.
o Poor for Close-Boiling Mixtures: Less effective for separating closely boiling
components.
More:- Chemical Engineering World
They are two types of columns that are used for extraction operation; packed column and
sieve plate column.
In packed tower type extractor, standard commercial packings, used in vapour- liquid system,
are used. This includes structured packings, Raschig and Pall rings, Berl and Intalox saddles
and other random packings. Packing reduces the vertical back mixing of the continuous phase
and thereby reduces height required for mass transfer. It is recommended to redistribute the
dispersed phase at about every 1.5 to 3 m distance to generate new droplets. Size of packing
should preferably be less than one-eight of the tower diameter to minimize the wall effect.
Flooding velocity in packed tower is the velocity of dispersed phase or continuous phase at
which dispersed phase is coming out from the outlet pipe of continuous phase.
Applications
o Small no of stages required
o Chemically stable
o Easy phase separation
o Low valu
It comprises a tall vertical tower provided with inlets for both feed and solvent streams to
enter and outlets for both product (Raffinate and Extract) streams. It has a central shaft
attached with rotor discs and is driven by a motor. Stators of centrally hollowed rings
attached to the wall of the tower alternate position to the rotors. This can be operated at high
speeds and it finds wide application in petroleum industries.