MOD 2 Evolution & Development (1)
MOD 2 Evolution & Development (1)
MOD 2 Evolution & Development (1)
Natural selection & the elusiveness (not easy to find, catch, remember) of happiness
(happiness can be hard to come by)- Evolutionary Psychology
At the heart of evolutionary psychology is the idea that human beings possess a set of
specialized psychological mechanisms that have evolved to address problems humans
repeatedly encountered in their environments. These problems might include finding food,
selecting mates, navigating social hierarchies, or ensuring the survival of offspring.
Evolutionary psychology rests on several core assumptions about human behavior and cognition:
● Adaptation through Natural Selection: The primary assumption is that the human brain
has evolved to solve adaptive problems faced by our ancestors. Over thousands of
generations, natural selection shaped the mind to efficiently handle tasks such as
detecting danger, choosing mates, and forming social alliances.
● Specialized Psychological Mechanisms: Rather than being a general-purpose cognitive
machine, the human brain consists of specialized mechanisms designed to process
information relevant to survival. These mechanisms evolved to deal with recurrent
environmental problems such as finding food, avoiding predators, or forming
relationships with others.
● Universal Human Behaviors: Evolutionary psychologists argue that many behaviors are
universal across cultures and societies because they reflect basic human instincts shaped
by evolution. For instance, the universal fear of snakes and spiders may stem from an
ancestral need to avoid venomous creatures that posed a threat to survival.
The roots of evolutionary psychology can be traced back to Charles Darwin, whose theory of
natural selection laid the groundwork for understanding how physical traits evolve. Darwin’s
work also extended to emotional expressions. In his 1872 book "The Expression of the
Emotions in Man and Animals", Darwin proposed that emotional expressions, like facial
expressions of anger or fear, had evolutionary significance. These expressions communicated
important information to others, such as signaling aggression or warning of danger.
● William James (1890): In his seminal work The Principles of Psychology, William
James advanced the idea that human behavior and emotions have evolved to solve
adaptive problems. He introduced the term "evolutionary psychology," considering many
human behaviors as instinctive and designed for survival.
● William McDougall (1908): McDougall further developed this perspective, arguing that
human behaviors, particularly social behaviors, are motivated by instincts that trigger
emotional responses to environmental stimuli. These emotional states, like fear or anger,
would, in turn, promote adaptive behaviors, such as fight or flight.
However, as behaviorism became dominant in the early 20th century, the idea of instinct-driven
behavior was overshadowed by theories that emphasized learned behavior and rejected innate,
biological predispositions. John B. Watson, a prominent behaviorist, argued that human behavior
is primarily shaped by experience and that the mind is a "blank slate" at birth, shaped entirely by
environmental influences.
These cross-cultural patterns suggested that human nature is not entirely shaped by culture or
experience but is influenced by biological instincts. Evolutionary psychology reemerged in the
1980s as a major theoretical approach, grounded in the belief that evolutionary pressures have
shaped not only our bodies but also our minds.
5. Modern Evolutionary Psychology (1980s to Present)
Evolutionary psychology gained prominence in the late 20th century as a synthesis of ideas from
several fields, including ethology, cognitive psychology, evolutionary biology, social
psychology, and anthropology. It applies Darwin’s theory of evolution to understand human
behavior by positing that the human brain is the product of evolutionary pressures that selected
for mental mechanisms capable of solving problems related to survival and reproduction.
Modern evolutionary psychologists emphasize the role of both natural selection and sexual
selection in shaping human behavior:
● Natural Selection: The process through which traits that increase an organism’s chances
of survival and reproduction are passed on to future generations. For instance, traits like
problem-solving abilities and emotional regulation might have evolved to help
individuals survive and thrive in complex environments.
● Sexual Selection: The process by which traits that enhance an individual's attractiveness
to potential mates or improve reproductive success are favored. Traits such as physical
attractiveness, dominance, or the ability to provide resources might have evolved
through sexual selection.
Evolutionary psychologists suggest that human beings are born with a set of psychological
adaptations designed to promote survival and reproduction:
● Social Behavior and Cooperation: Humans are social animals, and many psychological
mechanisms have evolved to promote cooperation within groups. For example, altruism
(helping others without direct personal gain) could have evolved because helping
relatives or group members increases the likelihood of passing on shared genetic
material.
● Mate Selection: Evolutionary psychology provides a framework for understanding mate
preferences. For instance, research consistently shows that men are attracted to women
in their peak fertility years, while women tend to prefer men who can provide resources,
such as older males or those with financial stability.
● Parental Investment: Human parental investment is characterized by extended care for
offspring, which is relatively rare among mammals. This extended care is thought to
have evolved because human infants are born in a helpless state and require prolonged
care for survival.
● Fear and Threat Detection: Human beings are particularly attuned to detecting threats.
The fight-or-flight response, a key evolutionary adaptation, helps individuals respond
quickly to danger by preparing the body for action. This response is triggered by
environmental cues that indicate potential threats, such as the presence of a predator.
7. Evolutionary Explanations of Fear and Phobias
Fear is considered an adaptive response to potential threats in the environment. Some fears, like
the fear of snakes or spiders, appear to be innate, even in infants who have never had direct
experiences with these creatures. Evolutionary psychologists argue that this predisposition to fear
certain animals may have evolved because these animals were associated with danger in
ancestral environments. For example, venomous snakes and spiders posed real threats to early
humans, so an instinctive fear of these creatures may have helped ensure survival.
● Adaptive Fears: Fear of heights and strangers is another common fear in infants. These
fears are seen as adaptive because they help infants avoid potentially dangerous
situations. The fear of heights, for instance, likely evolved to prevent falls from
dangerous heights, while fear of strangers may help protect infants from potential harm
by unfamiliar individuals.
● Phobias: Phobias are often irrational fears that extend beyond what would be considered
adaptive. For example, while a mild fear of snakes may have been beneficial, an intense,
irrational fear of harmless snakes or even images of them may result in phobic behavior.
Such phobias may be the result of an overactive fear response that is no longer tied to real
threats in the modern environment.
While evolutionary psychology has contributed valuable insights into human behavior, it has also
faced criticism for several reasons:
Evolution is change over time. Natural selection is the engine that drives such change through
the adaptation of species to their environment.
Charles Darwin -Natural selection is a scientific theory that explains how organisms adapt and
evolve over time. It's based on the idea that organisms that are best suited to their environment
are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing on their genes to the next generation. This
process can lead to species changing and diverging, and can even result in the extinction of
less-adapted populations
The human capacity for the positive and negative feelings is shaped by the forces of evolution,
thus the evolutionary perspective should be relevant to the study of happiness.
The concept of natural selection, as proposed by Charles Darwin, suggests that traits and
behaviors (including emotions like happiness) that enhance survival and reproductive success are
favored over time, leading to their prevalence in populations. Here's a detailed exploration of
how natural selection and evolutionary psychology intersect with the concept of happiness
From an evolutionary perspective, emotions serve adaptive functions. Happiness, like other
emotions, likely evolved because it conferred benefits to our ancestors in terms of survival and
reproduction. For example:
Evolutionary psychologists believe that happiness is an adaptive trait that helped early humans
survive and reproduce. It's a proximate goal that motivates behaviors that lead to outcomes that
increase the likelihood of survival and reproduction. Happiness can help in many ways,
including:
● Being fitter
● Being more attuned to our environment
● Being more social
● Being more energetic
● Being more creative
In evolutionary parlance, we would say that happiness is a proximate outcome. It matters, and it
is nice. But it is not an ultimate evolutionary outcome. From an evolutionary perspective,
ultimate outcomes pertain to outcomes that bear on increases in the likelihood of survival and
reproduction. Thus, we may be thrilled to have a piece of chocolate cake on the table in front of
us at a birthday party. But that momentary happiness is not an end goal in itself. We evolved to
be happy when presented with rich food offerings because our ancestors, who were motivated to
find rich foods, were more likely to eat and thus to survive and reproduce.
A common take on the point of life suggests that life is about being happy. That take on life
is wrong. Happiness, like any affective state, is a proximate goal that evolved primarily because
it helped to motivate behaviors that, on average, led to outcomes associated with increases in
survival and/or reproduction.
Happiness is fueled by dopamine, a chemical in the brain associated with motivation and
reward-seeking behavior. Dopamine increases when we're pleasantly surprised.
3. Social Functions
Happiness also serves important social functions. Displaying happiness can communicate
positive social status, attract mates, and strengthen social bonds. In ancestral environments where
cooperation and social cohesion were crucial for survival, being perceived as a positive and
cooperative individual could increase one's chances of survival and reproductive success.
1. Social Bonds: Humans are inherently social creatures. Forming close relationships and
social networks has been essential for our ancestors' survival. Positive social interactions
contribute to our sense of happiness by fulfilling our need for connection and support.
2. Status and Hierarchy: Evolutionary psychology suggests that our sense of self-worth
and happiness can be influenced by our social status. Historically, higher social status
often meant better access to resources and mates, so feeling valued or achieving a higher
status can contribute to happiness.
3. Group Dynamics: Being part of a group and receiving social validation can enhance our
happiness. Group memberships and social acceptance can provide a sense of belonging
and security, which are critical for emotional well-being.
4. Reciprocity and Altruism: Acts of kindness and reciprocity strengthen social bonds and
contribute to happiness. Altruistic behaviors can enhance group cohesion and increase
individual feelings of satisfaction and happiness.
:
4. Elusiveness of Happiness:
Some say that happiness is like a butterfly, and that the more we pursue it, the more
elusive it becomes. Instead, happiness may be more likely to come when we focus on
other things, such as purpose, connecting with others, or contributing to something larger
than ourselves.
Despite its evolutionary origins and adaptive functions, happiness can be elusive for modern
humans for several reasons:
This theory posits that individuals evaluate their happiness relative to a neutral point,
often determined by their recent experiences or circumstances. When positive events
occur (such as a salary increase or buying a new car), individuals may experience a
temporary boost in happiness. However, over time, they adapt to these new
circumstances, and their happiness tends to return to its previous baseline level. This
phenomenon, known as the adaptation level theory, suggests that our happiness levels are
more stable than we might expect in response to life events.
2. Hedonic Treadmill: The hedonic treadmill concept suggests that humans have a baseline
level of happiness to which they typically return, regardless of positive or negative life
changes. This tendency to revert to a stable level of happiness after significant events can
make sustained happiness feel fleeting or hard to maintain.
3. Modern Lifestyles: The mismatch between our evolved psychological mechanisms and
modern environments can also contribute to the elusiveness of happiness. Many aspects
of contemporary life—such as sedentary lifestyles, digital technology, and urban
living—may not align well with our evolved preferences and needs. This discrepancy can
lead to feelings of dissatisfaction or stress, despite material comfort and convenience.
Modern environments present new challenges and opportunities that differ from ancestral ones.
Evolutionary mismatches occur when behaviors or emotional responses that were adaptive in the
past may not align with contemporary circumstances:
● Technology and Overabundance: In modern societies, technological advancements and
abundance of resources can lead to hedonic adaptation—a phenomenon where
individuals quickly adapt to positive changes, leading to temporary happiness followed
by a return to baseline levels.
● Social Comparison and Stress: Social comparison, a mechanism shaped by evolution to
gauge one's position within a group, can contribute to feelings of inadequacy or
dissatisfaction in modern, competitive societies where success and status are highly
valued
Modernization changes the roots of happiness. In agrarian societies with little or no economic
growth or social mobility, peoples’ options are severely limited and religion makes people
happier by lowering their aspirations. Economic development and democratization bring changes
conducive to happiness by giving people a broader range of choices in how to live their lives.
5. Complexity of Well-being
Happiness, from an evolutionary perspective, is not just about momentary pleasure but also
about overall well-being and life satisfaction. Achieving sustained happiness requires navigating
various psychological, social, and environmental factors that influence our subjective well-being.
● Threat Detection and Stress Response: Early human survival depended on the ability to
detect threats and respond to stress. The brain’s limbic system, particularly the amygdala,
evolved to quickly react to danger. However, this also makes modern humans susceptible
to chronic stress and anxiety.
● Reward Pathways: The brain’s reward system, especially involving dopamine, evolved
to reinforce behaviors that increased survival and reproduction. Activities that bring
pleasure (such as eating, social bonding, and success) release dopamine, encouraging
repetition and thus fostering well-being within safe and resourceful environments.
● Adaptive Playfulness: Play evolved as a way for younger members of species to develop
skills, creativity, and social bonds, which remain essential for adult well-being. The joy
of play and creative expression fosters cognitive flexibility, stress relief, and social
cohesion.
● Creativity and Resilience: The capacity for imagination and creativity allows humans to
mentally simulate outcomes, solve problems, and innovate. Creativity is linked to
dopamine release, contributing to a sense of purpose and resilience.
● Limbic system
This part of the brain is responsible for motivation and emotion, and works quickly. It can create
initial emotional responses to events, such as the fight-or-flight response. The limbic system also
processes memory, and interacts with the PFC to create a relationship between emotions and
thoughts
The prefrontal cortex (PFC) and limbic system are two parts of the brain that work together
to regulate emotions and thoughts, which can affect wellbeing:
● Neuroplasticity
Neuroplasticity, also known as neural plasticity or brain plasticity, is a process that involves
adaptive structural and functional changes to the brain. A good definition is “the ability of the
nervous system to change its activity in response to intrinsic or extrinsic stimuli by reorganizing
its structure, functions, or connections.” Clinically, it is the process of brain changes after injury,
such as a stroke or traumatic brain injury (TBI). These changes can either be beneficial
(restoration of function after injury), neutral (no change), or negative (can have pathological
consequences).
● Adaptation and Resilience: Neuroplasticity allows the brain to adapt to new situations
and challenges. Individuals with higher neuroplasticity may find it easier to recover from
adversity, learn new skills, and cope with stress, all of which are crucial for promoting
well-being.
● Learning and Growth: Neuroplasticity underpins learning and memory formation. As
we engage in activities that stimulate neural growth, such as learning a new language or
playing a musical instrument, we experience a sense of accomplishment and fulfillment,
contributing positively to well-being.
● Recovery from Injury and Illness: Neuroplasticity plays a crucial role in recoveryfrom
brain injuries, strokes, and neurological disorders. The brain's ability to reorganize and
form new connections can facilitate rehabilitation and improve functional outcomes,
which can enhance overall well-being.
● Mental Health and Emotional Regulation: Neuroplasticity is closely linked to
emotional regulation and mental health. Practices like mindfulness meditation, which
promote neuroplastic changes in brain regions associated with emotional processing and
stress response, have been shown to improve well-being by reducing anxiety and
depression.
● Lifestyle Factors: Lifestyle choices, including exercise, diet, and social interactions, can
influence neuroplasticity. Physical exercise, for example, has been found to enhance brain
plasticity by promoting the release of growth factors that support neuronal growth and
connectivity, thereby contributing to improved well-being.
● Age-related Changes: While neuroplasticity declines with age, the brain retains some
capacity for reorganization throughout life. Engaging in mentally stimulating activities
and maintaining social connections can help preserve neuroplasticity and support
well-being as we age.
● Cognitive Functions
● Evolutionary Mismatch
Modern environments and lifestyles can sometimes conflict with our evolved brain functions,
leading to mismatches that may impact well-being. Understanding these mismatches can help in
developing strategies to support well-being in contemporary societies.
While our brains have evolved over millennia, modern lifestyles present new challenges (e.g.,
technological advancements, urbanization) that can impact well-being. Understanding our
evolutionary heritage helps us recognize how mismatches between our ancestral adaptations and
modern environments can affect mental health and overall well-being.
The developmental origins of well-being
● Maternal Health and Stress Impact: The prenatal period is crucial because fetal brain
development is highly sensitive to the mother's environment, including nutrition,
hormone levels, and stress. High maternal stress during pregnancy can increase cortisol in
the fetus, leading to an altered HPA (hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal) axis, which governs
stress response throughout life. Infants exposed to higher cortisol in utero often exhibit
higher baseline stress levels and are more prone to anxiety or emotional dysregulation as
they grow up.
● Nutrition’s Role in Brain Development: Proper maternal nutrition is critical for the
development of the brain’s architecture, particularly for neural pathways and regions
linked to emotional regulation and cognitive functions. Nutrient deficiencies in utero can
impair these areas, potentially leading to developmental delays or behavioral issues that
affect well-being.
● Epigenetics and Gene Expression: Epigenetic changes, which can turn genes "on" or
"off," are influenced by early-life environments. For example, a highly stressful
environment can activate genes associated with hyper-reactivity to stress, increasing
susceptibility to anxiety or depression. These changes underscore how the environment
literally shapes biological pathways that later influence well-being.
● Attachment Theory and Secure Base: Attachment theory, founded by John Bowlby and
Mary Ainsworth, suggests that secure attachment—characterized by consistent
responsiveness from caregivers—provides infants with a "secure base." This base allows
them to explore the world confidently and return for support, building trust and security.
Secure attachment is associated with higher self-esteem, emotional resilience, and the
ability to form healthy relationships later in life, all of which enhance well-being.
● Stress Regulation via Attachment: Securely attached children show a well-regulated
stress response, including a balanced HPA axis. In stressful situations, they can
self-soothe or seek help, thanks to the trust built through early caregiving. This stress
regulation extends into adulthood, helping them manage anxiety, conflict, and loss more
effectively, thus supporting long-term well-being.
● Impact of Different Attachment Styles: Insecure attachment, whether avoidant,
anxious, or disorganized, can impair a child’s capacity to regulate emotions, leading to
relationship difficulties, low self-esteem, and anxiety. Avoidantly attached children, for
instance, may struggle with intimacy and vulnerability, affecting future well-being in
close relationships.
● Role of Family and Cultural Values: Socialization begins in early childhood, where
family and culture instill beliefs, values, and behaviors. For example, cultures that
emphasize collectivism often promote community, cooperation, and empathy, which help
foster well-being by reinforcing social bonds. On the other hand, individualistic values
may promote autonomy and self-efficacy, which also supports well-being but in a more
self-reliant way.
● Development of Self-Concept: As children grow, they develop a sense of “self” through
interactions with caregivers, peers, and their environment. Positive affirmations,
encouragement, and a sense of acceptance contribute to a healthy self-concept. This is
central to self-esteem, a strong predictor of life satisfaction and resilience. A child who
feels valued develops a sense of self-worth, contributing to mental and emotional
stability.
● Role of Identity in Well-Being: Adolescence, in particular, is a time for identity
exploration. Developing a clear, stable identity and understanding one's unique
characteristics help provide direction and purpose. A strong, positive identity acts as an
anchor, particularly during challenges, and is associated with better emotional health and
resilience.
● Oxytocin's role in fostering social connections and trust.