Finals
Finals
- Yield to Maturity (YTM): This is the internal rate of return on a bond, assuming
it is held to maturity and that all coupon and principal payments are made on
time. It essentially reflects the bond's long-term return.
- Example: Suppose you purchase a bond for $950 that has a face value of
$1,000 and matures in 10 years, with an annual coupon of $50. The YTM
calculation would consider the price, coupon payments, and time to maturity to
provide a percentage yield.
The formula for YTM doesn't have a simple closed form and is typically solved through trial and
error or using a financial calculator. However, the basic components are:
The YTM formula is approximated by solving for YTM in the following equation:
Where:
2. Analyze the Yield Curve and Its Implications for Fixed Income Investments
- Inverted Yield Curve: Downward sloping; short-term bonds have higher yields
than long-term bonds, signaling a possible recession. Investors expect interest
rates to fall, reflecting future economic slowdown.
- Flat Yield Curve: No significant difference between short and long-term bond
yields, indicating economic uncertainty or a transition phase.
Why It Works:
If interest rates rise, bond prices fall, but because the portfolio is
designed with the same duration as the liabilities, the present value of
the liabilities will also decrease at a similar rate.
If interest rates fall, bond prices rise, but the liabilities will also become
more expensive. In both scenarios, the pension fund can still meet its
liability payments because the portfolio's duration has been matched
with the liabilities.
In other words, Duration Matching helps investors align their portfolios with
their interest rate outlook. If an investor expects interest rates to rise, they can
reduce the portfolio’s duration to limit losses from falling bond prices.
Conversely, if they expect rates to fall, they may increase duration to take
advantage of rising bond prices.
For example:
- If interest rates are expected to fall, managers might increase the portfolio's
duration to take advantage of the expected rise in bond prices (since bond
prices rise as interest rates fall).
- If rates are expected to rise, managers might reduce the portfolio’s duration to
minimize the negative impact of falling bond prices.
Active Bond Management Strategies:
1. Barbell Strategy:
- Involves holding a mix of short-term and long-term bonds while avoiding
intermediate maturities.
- Why use it? If rates are expected to rise in the short term but stabilize in the
long term, managers might hold short-term bonds to minimize duration risk
while using long-term bonds to lock in higher yields.
Example: If a portfolio manager expects short-term interest rates to rise but
believes long-term rates will remain low, they might use a barbell strategy—
holding short-term bonds to reduce risk and long-term bonds to capture higher
yields.
Answer:
The barbell strategy involves holding a combination of short-term and long-
term bonds while avoiding intermediate-term bonds. In this case:
Short-term bonds: These are less sensitive to interest rate increases,
providing flexibility to reinvest in higher yields once the short-term rates
rise.
Long-term bonds: These offer higher yields available in the current market
and provide stability once interest rates stabilize in the future.
Explanation:
The portfolio manager is expecting short-term rates to rise, meaning that short-
term bonds would mature quickly, allowing reinvestment at higher rates, which
reduces the portfolio's interest rate risk. On the other hand, long-term bonds
are held to lock in the current higher yields, as long-term rates are expected to
stay low. The barbell strategy helps the manager balance between reducing risk
in the short term and capturing higher yields over the long term.
2. Ladder Strategy:
- Involves holding bonds with staggered maturities at regular intervals (e.g., 1
year, 2 years, 3 years, etc.).
- Why use it? Provides regular cash flow and allows for reinvestment
opportunities as bonds mature. This strategy helps manage liquidity and
reduces the risk of interest rate changes by spreading investments across
different maturities.
Example: A portfolio manager holds bonds maturing every year for the next 10
years. Each year, as one bond matures, they have the opportunity to reinvest
the principal at the prevailing interest rate.
Answer:
The ladder strategy involves buying bonds with staggered maturities, so that
one or more bonds mature at regular intervals, allowing the manager to
reinvest the proceeds.
Explanation:
In this example, the manager has a bond maturing each year for 10 years. The
benefit of the ladder strategy is twofold:
1. Liquidity: The manager has cash flow coming in each year, providing
flexibility to reinvest or meet any cash needs.
2. Risk management: Because the portfolio is spread across different
maturities, the interest rate risk is spread out as well. If rates rise, the
manager can reinvest maturing bonds at higher yields, but if rates fall, the
portfolio still holds bonds purchased at higher previous rates.
This strategy helps smooth out the effects of fluctuating interest rates by
ensuring some bonds are maturing at all times.
3. Bullet Strategy:
- Focuses on holding bonds with a single, specific maturity date that aligns
with a future liability or financial need.
- Why use it? This strategy is useful for investors with known future liabilities
(e.g., a pension fund with a big payout due in 10 years). By investing in bonds
that all mature around the same time, the portfolio is aligned with this future
need.
Example: If a pension fund needs to make a large payment in 10 years, the
portfolio manager might invest in bonds that all mature in 10 years, aligning
with this future liability.
Answer:
The bullet strategy focuses on investing in bonds that mature at a specific
future date, matching the expected payout date for a large liability.
Explanation:
In this case, the pension fund knows it has a major liability due in 10 years. The
portfolio manager can align the bond investments by purchasing bonds that all
mature in exactly 10 years. This way, when the pension fund needs to make the
payout, the bond principal will become available at the right time.
The bullet strategy minimizes interest rate risk because the manager is not
concerned with fluctuating interest rates in the short term; they only care about
the bond values maturing when they need the cash. By focusing on bonds that
mature in the same period as the liability, the portfolio and liability durations
are matched, ensuring the money will be available when needed.
Conclusion:
Barbell Strategy: Useful when expecting short-term rate increases but
stable long-term rates, balancing flexibility and yield.
Ladder Strategy: Mitigates interest rate risk by staggering bond maturities
and providing liquidity over time.
Bullet Strategy: Focuses on aligning bond maturities with a specific future
liability, reducing interest rate risk for a known financial obligation.
Each strategy helps manage interest rate risk differently, depending on the
investor's forecast of the interest rate environment and their financial needs.
Active bond portfolio management is a dynamic approach where managers
continuously adjust bond holdings and portfolio duration based on interest rate
and yield curve forecasts. Strategies like barbell, ladder, and bullet are designed
to balance risk and reward, helping managers to respond effectively to changing
economic conditions and interest rate environments.
Challenges:
- Hedging with Derivatives: Investors can use currency forwards, futures, and
options to hedge against adverse currency movements. For instance, if an
investor expects the euro to weaken, they can enter a forward contract to sell
euros at a predetermined rate.
- Currency ETFs: Investors can use exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that focus on
specific currencies or currency baskets to gain exposure while managing risk.
For example, a U.S. investor might use a euro ETF to hedge against euro
exposure.
- Dynamic Hedging: This strategy involves adjusting the hedge ratio based on
market conditions and currency forecasts. For instance, if an investor
anticipates a strengthening of the dollar, they may reduce their hedge on
foreign assets.
Conclusion:
Benefits:
- Risk Reduction: Consider an investor based in the U.S. who invests solely in
U.S. stocks during a market downturn caused by a domestic recession. If the
investor instead diversifies by investing in European and Asian markets, the
negative impact of the recession can be mitigated. For instance, during the U.S.
recession in2008, emerging markets like Brazil and China continued to grow,
allowing diversified investors to potentially offset some losses.
Challenges:
- Currency Risk: Suppose the investor buys shares in a German company. If the
euro depreciates against the dollar from1.20 to1.10, the value of the
investment decreases when converted back to dollars, resulting in a loss despite
any gains in the stock price.
- Dynamic Hedging: If the investor expects the U.S. dollar to strengthen, they
may choose to reduce their exposure to foreign investments by decreasing the
size of their hedging contracts in anticipation of favorable currency movements.
2. Example of Holdings:
- U.S. ETFs (e.g., S&P500 ETF)
- European ETFs (e.g., Euro Stoxx50 ETF)
- Asian ETFs (e.g., MSCI Asia ex-Japan ETF)
- Emerging Market ETFs (e.g., MSCI Emerging Markets ETF)
- International Bonds (e.g., a global bond fund)
Where:
Rp = Portfolio return
Rf = Risk-free rate (e.g., return on Treasury bills)
σp = Standard deviation of the portfolio's excess return
Example Calculation:
Assume a portfolio return (Rp) of 10% (0.10), a risk-free rate (Rf) of 2%
(0.02), and a standard deviation (σp) of 15% (0.15).
Jensen's Alpha
Jensen's Alpha measures the excess return of a portfolio over the predicted
return based on the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). The formula is:
Example Calculation:
- Assume a portfolio return (Rp) of 10%, a risk-free rate (Rf) of 2%, a portfolio
beta (β) of 1.2, and the market return (Rm) of 8%.
Benchmark
A benchmark is a standard against which the performance of a portfolio can be
measured, often represented by an index like the S&P 500.
Example Assessment:
Assume the portfolio returned 8% for the year, while the benchmark index
returned 5%.
Analysis:
Peer Comparison:
If peer portfolios (similar in profile to our portfolio) generated an average return
of 7%, then our portfolio's performance, at 8%, surpasses both the benchmark
and peers, indicating good management.
Overall Portfolio Return: Assume the weights are 60% stocks, 30% bonds, and
10% real estate.
Interpretation: The analysis shows that stock allocation provided the highest
contribution to performance, followed by bonds and real estate. This assists in
understanding whether the performance is driven by asset allocation decisions
or specific security selection within those allocations.
Conclusion
Strategies:
Calendar Rebalancing:
- Description: This strategy involves rebalancing the portfolio at regular
intervals (e.g., quarterly, annually) regardless of market conditions.
- Example: An investor sets a calendar reminder to review and rebalance their
portfolio every six months. If their target allocation is 70% equities and 30%
bonds, they will adjust their holdings back to these percentages at each review,
regardless of market changes.
Percent-Range Rebalancing:
-
Description: This strategy allows for rebalancing when asset class weights
deviate from target allocations by a specified percentage (e.g., +/-5%).
- Example: If an investor’s target allocation is 60% stocks and the actual
allocation drifts to 65% or 55%, they will rebalance to restore the target
allocation. This method is more responsive to market movements and helps
control risk.
- Threshold-Based Rebalancing:
- Description: Set specific thresholds based on market volatility ( how much
and how quickly prices move over a given span of time. In the stock
market, increased volatility is often a sign of fear and uncertainty
among investors. This is why the VIX volatility index is sometimes
called the “fear index.”) or other indicators to determine when to rebalance.
- Example: An investor may choose to rebalance only when the volatility of the
equity market exceeds a certain level (e.g., VIX index above 20), indicating
increased risk.
Approaches:
Dynamic Hedging:
- Description: Adjusting the portfolio to include hedging strategies (like
options) to protect against downturns.
- Example: An investor holding a significant equity position may buy put
options to hedge against potential losses if they expect a market correction.
Customization Strategies:
Goals-Based Investing:
- Description: Create sub-portfolios tailored to specific financial goals, each
with its own risk profile and time horizon.
- Example: An investor saving for retirement in 20 years may have a growth-
oriented portfolio (80% stocks, 20% bonds), while another investor saving for a
home down payment in 5 years may have a conservative portfolio (30% stocks,
70% bonds).
Risk Tolerance Assessment:
- Description: Use questionnaires and discussions to assess an investor's
comfort level with risk, which will guide asset allocation decisions.
- Example: A risk-averse investor may prefer a portfolio with a higher allocation
to bonds (60% bonds, 40% stocks) compared to a more aggressive investor who
may prefer 80% stocks and 20% bonds.
Conclusion
By developing tailored strategies for portfolio rebalancing, implementing
dynamic asset allocation approaches, and customizing portfolio strategies based
on individual goals and risk tolerance, investors can create a robust investment
plan that adapts to market changes and aligns with their financial objectives.
Encourage students to think critically about how these strategies can be applied
in real-world scenarios and consider the trade-offs involved in each approach.
This discussion can also lead to deeper conversations about the importance of
discipline in investment management and how to balance risk and return
effectively.
Chapter 13 BEHAVIORAL FINANCE AND ASSET PRICING THEORY
- Loss Aversion: Investors feel losses more strongly than equivalent gains,
prompting overly conservative or risk-averse decisions.
- Overconfidence: Investors overestimate their abilities, often leading to
excessive trading or underestimating risks.
- Disposition Effect: A tendency to sell winning investments too early while
holding onto losing ones.
- Representativeness Heuristic: Misjudging probabilities based on how much
something resembles a familiar pattern (e.g., assuming past high-performing
stocks will continue to outperform).
- Herding: Following the crowd, often driven by fear of missing out or assuming
collective wisdom is correct.
---
Behavioral biases can create market inefficiencies, influence asset pricing, and
affect individual portfolio performance.
Key impacts include:
- Price Deviations: Investor sentiment can cause prices to deviate from
fundamental values, as seen with stocks influenced by high trading volume or
IPO enthusiasm.
- Market Bubbles and Crashes: Emotional and psychological factors, such as
irrational exuberance, can inflate asset prices, leading to bubbles. When
sentiment reverses, crashes often follow.
- Suboptimal Returns: Investors acting on biases like the disposition effect may
lock in lower returns by selling winners prematurely or holding losers for too
long.
Example: The NASDAQ bubble (1997–2000) saw tech stock prices soar due to
investor optimism, only to plummet when expectations corrected.
---
- Education and Awareness: Teach investors about common biases and their
impacts. Behavioral finance training can help investors recognize and avoid
errors.
- Use of Rules-Based Investing: Employ systematic approaches, such as dollar-
cost averaging or rebalancing portfolios periodically, to reduce emotional
decision-making.
- Diversification: A well-diversified portfolio minimizes the risk of emotional
reactions to individual asset performance.
- Professional Advice: Engaging financial advisors can help investors stay
disciplined, especially during volatile markets.
- Monitoring Media Influence: Be cautious of sentiment-driven trading
prompted by news or social media.
Example:
A financial advisor recommending speculative derivatives to a risk-averse retiree
would breach investment suitability standards and could face penalties or legal
consequences.
Answer:
Adherence to these regulations protects investors, promotes fair markets, and
enhances confidence in financial systems.
Example:
An investment manager who receives a commission for recommending a
particular fund but discloses this relationship to the client exemplifies ethical
behavior. Conversely, failing to disclose the commission would be unethical and
could erode trust.
Answer:
Ethical guidelines serve as a compass for navigating complex investment
decisions, ensuring transparency, and aligning with client interests while
upholding industry standards.
Answer:
Integrating ESG factors helps investors align portfolios with broader social and
environmental values while mitigating risks associated with unsustainable
practices.
Conclusion
Investment activities are governed by a robust interplay of legal, ethical, and
ESG considerations. Understanding the regulatory framework ensures
compliance and investor protection. Applying ethical principles fosters trust and
fairness, while integrating ESG factors promotes sustainable and responsible
investment practices.