Ch03b-RiverDynamics v3
Ch03b-RiverDynamics v3
River Dynamics 1
Moving water has power. A swiftwater rescuer needs to understand moving water. This section covers
river dynamics which provide the foundation for river reading. The dynamics of moving water covered in
this section includes river currents, river obstacles, and river hazards.
River Currents
<b> River Right and River Left – River right and river left are an orientation used by river users. The
orientation is noted on many of the diagrams. Looking downstream, river right is the right shore and river
left is the left shore. Looking upstream, river right is the left shore (if looking downstream), and river left
is the right shore (if looking downstream). Looking upstream, what is on the right is really on the left, and
what is on the left is really on the right.
<b> Primary Current (Figure 3.1) – The primary current refers to the general direction in which the
river is flowing. It is the current found in an unobstructed main channel. In Figure 3.1, the primary flow is
represented by the laminar flow. The slowest moving water is next to the bottom and each successive
layer of water toward the surface flows faster than the layer below it. The fastest moving water is found
just below the surface. This is because the air next to the surface creates friction which slows the surface
water slightly.
1
This section was written by Robert B. Kauffman who is solely responsible for its content. The source material for this
section was adapted from a draft of Building Your Canoe Basics (Chapter 6) in Outdoor Adventures: Canoeing. American Canoe
Association (eds), Human Kinetics, March , 2008. This section is copyrighted © Robert B. Kauffman, 2016.
River Features
Rocks are the main obstacles found in a river.
The depth of the rock in the water and its size
are key factors in determining the effect of the
rock on river dynamics. Pillows, holes and
eddies are closely related. A totally submerged
rock may have little or no effect on the surface
current. As the rock gets closer to the surface,
it will force the water passing over it upward
to the surface creating a small wave or pillow Figure 3.6: Chutes and Waves – Water speeds up in a constriction
downstream of the rock. As the rock or of the channel and then it is dissipated as it drops. This creates a
obstruction widens, water from the side cannot series of standing waves. Source: author – [file:\RIDY-Chutes.cdr]
fill in behind the rock. This results in a
depression or void behind the rock. Now the water flowing over the rock attempts to fill the void creating
a hole or hydraulic behind the rock. As the rock becomes exposed, the water can no longer flow over the
rock and can only fill the void behind the rock from the sides. Eddies are created by the water filling in
the void from the sides behind an exposed rock.
<b> Eddies (Figure 3.7) – Eddies are formed behind rocks or other obstructions in the river. Water flows
past the obstruction creating a void behind the object which the water attempts to fill. There are three
distinct parts of an eddy which are created by the water attempting to fill the void.
The first part of the eddy is where the water in the main current rushes by the rock so fast that in order to
fill the void the water has to flow back upstream (see #1 in Figure 3.7). This creates a very strong current
differential between the main current and the current in the eddy. The interface between the downstream
current and the upstream current creates an eddy line or even an eddy wall. As the current increases
dramatically, the eddy line becomes an eddy wall. An eddy wall is the vertical height difference between
the downstream current and the current in the eddy attempting to fill the void behind the rock. If there is
an eddy wall, there is a noticeable downhill current inside the eddy also. For a rescue swimmer, this
powerful of an eddy can be problematic and the rescue swimmer can find the eddy unfriendly. However,
most eddies will have an eddy line where there is little or no vertical difference between the main current
and the upstream current in the eddy.
Conceptually, the three parts of an eddy have many of the same characteristics as a hole or hydraulic.
Both are caused by the river attempting to fill a void. In a sense, an eddy is a hole rotated on its side.
Most eddies are friendly and rescue swimmers will use them extensively as they eddy hop down a river.
However, remember that some eddies can be violent and very unfriendly also.
<b> Hydraulics and Holes (Figure 3.8) – A hole occurs in the river when a rock or other obstruction of
sufficient width to prevent the water from filling in the obstruction from the side forces the water flowing
over the rock to fill the void or depression behind the rock. As the water flows over the rock, it plunges
down to the bottom of the river and races downstream. As it races downstream, the water shoots back up
to the surface where it moves in one of three directions. A portion of the water re-circulates back
upstream to fill the void behind the rock (1). Further downstream, some of the water comes up to the
surface and continues on downstream (3). This water travels at a slower rate than the general flow of the
river and quickly picks up speed as it moves downriver. In between or at the interface of the upstream and
downstream flow, the flow is neutral in that it is not really flowing downstream or upstream (2). This
neutral area is called the “boil.”
In contrast, in a frowning hole, the middle of the hole is downstream of the sides. From the upstream side
of the hole, it looks like it is frowning. Since the middle of the hole is downstream, the force of the hole
tends to move the swimmer or paddler to the center of the hole where it is strongest and most powerful.
These holes are often called keepers because they keep a person stuck in the hole. They are difficult to
exit because the swimmer or paddler has to literally paddle uphill to reach the side of the hole where they
can extricate themselves from the hole.
If you are paddling a canoe or kayak you can easily feel where you are in the hole. If you are on the
upstream side of the boil, you can feel the pull of the current pulling the canoe upstream and into the hole.
Conversely, if you are on the downstream side of the boil, you can feel the boat slipping downstream and
dropping out of the hole. If you are sitting on the shore and watching the paddler you can play a little
mental game where you look closely at the attitude of the canoe and tell where the canoe is in the hole.
Look at the trim of the boat. If the stern is lower than the bow, then the canoe is in the downstream
portion. Unless they paddle hard, they are out of the hole, and they might as well ferry to the shore and try
again. If the bow is lower than the stern, the canoe will move upstream and into the hole.
Understanding these currents on an experiential level can be of benefit to the swiftwater rescuer. The
rescuer can approach the victim in the downstream current behind a low head dam or keeper hole and
throw a rope to the victim trapped in the hole. This area is perfectly safe for the rescuer, but the rescuer
needs to know exactly where they are in terms of these three currents. Once the rescuer crosses the boil, it
is all downhill and they too can become a victim. This is not an uncommon situation. This author has
reviewed more than one case where the rescuer crossed the boil and died. It is important to know where
you are in terms of the currents pictured in Figure 3.8.
River Hazards
<b> Strainers (Figure 3.11) – Strainers are formed when water flows through an obstacle. Much like
spaghetti in a colander, water flows through the strainer leaving the victim trapped helplessly. Stainers are
most commonly formed by trees and rocks. STRAINERS ARE KILLERS. They are extremely dangerous
and river users should always avoid them.
Trees are the most commonly encountered form of strainers found on a river. As a river continues to
carve out a bend in the river, trees along the bend will fall into the river channel as the river current
undermines the foundation underneath the tree. Also, a strainer on the bend of a river is particularly
dangerous since the current is faster there and the rescue swimmer who is flowing with the current is
more likely to be swept into the strainer.
For most boaters, a good indication of an undercut rock is that normal river features like an eddy don’t
behave as they normally do. They seem weird or different and they act weird because the currents are
different. The eddy pictured
in Figure 3.12 is modeled
after and uncut rock on the
Lower Youghiogheny River.
<b> Low-head Dams (Figure 3.13) – A low-head dam and a hydraulic are essentially the same with some
important differences (see Figure 3.8). Examination of Figure 3.8 and Figure 3.13 suggests that they are
essentially the same diagrams. However, there are some important differences. The hydraulic behind a
low-head dam is a “perfect” hydraulic. It goes from one river abutment to the other. The only exit may be
to dive down and catch the water moving downstream. In contrast, naturally formed hydraulics are
imperfectly formed and can usually be escaped. A low-head dam is designed to disperse the kinetic
energy of the falling water upward rendering it harmless. Unfortunately, hydraulic is perfectly formed and
extends from one abutment to the other abutment. This is why they are called the drowning machine.
A horizon line is the usual indicator of a river wide obstacle like a waterfall or low-head dam. Actually,
this is a variation of the differential heights created by upstream and downstream Vs (see Figure 3.3),
except there is no height differential. Hence, the horizon line. As you look downstream, there will often
be a section of calm
or smooth-looking
water followed by a
line across the river
where the water
drops out of sight.
Trees on your side of
the horizon line will
look normal.
However, the trees
just downstream from
the horizon line often
look as if someone
cut a section out of
their trunks. If the
horizon line is
formed by a low-head
dam there are usually Figure 3.12: Low Head Dams – Low head dams are perfect hydraulics from abutment to
abutment. They are killers and should be avoided. Source: author –
abutments on each
[file:\RIDY-HydraulicLowHeadDam.cdr]
side of the dam which
are a clear indication
of the dam.
There are several approaches to rescuing a victim caught in the hydraulic of a low head dam. Several of
these are in the province of the rescue squad and their specialized equipment. The first rule for any rescue
attempt is to understand that the hydraulic behind a low head dam is a drowning machine. This applies to
rescuers also. An untethered rescuer trapped in the hydraulic becomes another victim. There are cases
where a bystander with full knowledge of the dangers of low head dams attempted a rescue and drowned
in his rescue attempt to rescue two victims. One victim recycled out of the hydraulic and survived. The
other victim along with the rescuer drowned.
<b> Old Man-made Structures (no figure) – Most rivers contain man-made structures such as old dams
or bridge abutments that have fallen in disuse. Sometimes these structures are potentially a fun place to
play with a canoe or kayak. Always use caution around these structures. Rip-rap may contain large spikes.
Old dams and bridge abutments may contain reinforcing rods or sharp rocks that can create nasty injuries.
Check the site at low water for hazards and if there is any doubt, find another place to play.
<b> Drowning Trap Flows (Figure 3.14, Figure 3.15, and Figure 3.16) – Any water level on the river
can be hazardous. Ask people when the river is dangerous. Most people associate flood-like conditions
with danger like muddy water, water flowing over the banks, water in the trees, floating debris and big
waves. Floods and high water are dangerous and most people recognize the danger and stay off the river
(Figure 3.14).
On many rivers, recreational fatalities tend to occur at moderate water levels when the river is well within
its banks and the river looks perfectly normal (i.e. It is not flooding). The normal cycle of flows for rivers
is that during the summer when most people visit the river, the water level drops to where the moving
water is no longer a contributing factor in the fatalities. However, if the water level rises, the river can
become very dangerous (Figure 3.15).
Figure 3.15: Normal Summer Flows – In the summer when most people visit rivers, the river is
at low flow where it tends to lose its power as a contributing factor in accidents. Source: author –
[file:\RIDY-DrowningTrapNormal.cdr]
Depth, velocity and deceptiveness define the drowning trap (Figure 3.16). At these moderate flows the
river has the power (depth and velocity) to drown, yet it is deceptive since people tend to associate flood
conditions with danger rather than moderate flows. The cross-sectional profile of a typical eastern river
illustrates the relationship between moderate drowning trap flows, summer low flows and flood levels
which people normally perceive as being dangerous.
The depth of the water is a key determinant of its velocity and its power. Imagine standing in moving
water about waist deep. With some deliberate care you can brace yourself against the current and stand in
the water. Add another foot of water so that the water is above your waist. Now the river current can
easily move you. Perhaps it may knock you off your feet and sweep you downstream. When the river's
speed reaches that of person walking fast, it begins to have the power to move you, knock you over and
depending on circumstances, drown you.
A good indicator of drowning trap levels is when annual vegetation on gravel bars are inundated during
the summer months. Look for those areas which were under water during the spring runoff. When this
vegetation becomes either partially of fully under water, the river is higher than normal and may be in the
drowning trap flows.
The third component of the drowning trap is deceptiveness. When asked, most people correctly associate
flood-like conditions as being dangerous. And they are dangerous. However, in the Drowning Trap flows
the river is well within its banks and to the casual visitor, the river looks perfectly normal. A study on the
Summary
Having an understanding of river dynamics is important for the rescue swimmers. First, it helps the rescue
swimmer not to become a second victim. This was evident in rescues behind a low head dam. Second,
understanding and having familiarity with river dynamics is important as the rescuer moves in the river. It
helps to facilitate a rescue, and again, it helps the rescuer in not becoming a second victim during the
rescue. Third, understanding river dynamics goes hand-in-hand with river rescue. Last, wading and
swimming rapids helps the rescuer to become familiar with the medium with which they are working.
This familiarity is always a good thing.
References
Bennett, J., (1996). The Complete Whitewater Rafter. Camden, Maine: Ragged Mountain Press.
Dillon, P. And Oyen, J., (eds) (2009). Building Your Canoe Basics (Chapter 6) in Outdoor Adventures:
Canoeing. Champaign, Illinois: Human Kinetics, March.
Dillon, P. And Oyen, J., (eds) (2009). Water Safety and Survival Skills (Chapter 5) in Outdoor Adventures:
Kayaking. Champaign, Illinois: Human Kinetics, March.
Kauffman, R., Taylor, S., and Price, R., (1991). A Recreational Gauging and Information System to Alert
Potomac River Users of Dangerous Water Levels. Annapolis, Maryland: Department of Natural
Resources, Boating Administration, Planning and Policy Program. 305 pp.
Kauffman, R. (2015). Swiftwater Rescue Packet. McHenry, Maryland: Garrett College. Unpublished
packet.