43.

1 Measuring Pop Size and Density

Sunday, March 9, 2025 8:24 AM

Understanding how ecologists measure population size and density is crucial for analyzing ecosystems, tracking species populations, and making conservation decisions. This
section covers methods of measuring population size, their advantages and limitations, and how they are used in real-world studies.

1. Population Density vs. Population Size

• Population Size (NNN) – The total number of individuals in a population.

• Population Density – The number of individuals per unit area or volume.

Why It Matters:

• High-density populations may face more competition for resources (e.g., deer in a forest).
• Low-density populations may struggle to find mates (e.g., endangered tigers).

2. Methods to Measure Population Size & Density

Method Definition Best For Strengths Weaknesses

Direct Manually counting every individual in a given Small, easily visible populations - High accuracy when feasible. - Not possible for large,
Counting area. (e.g., trees, coral reefs). mobile, or hidden species.
- Works well for small, enclosed - Time-consuming.
areas.
Quadrat Randomly placing square plots (quadrats) and Plants, fungi, sessile (non- - Fast & cost-effective for - Accuracy depends on
Sampling counting individuals inside them. moving) animals (e.g., barnacles). estimating populations. how quadrats are placed.
- Works well for organisms that - Does not work well for
don't move. mobile species.
Line Laying a long measuring tape (transect) and Large plants (trees, cacti), - Easier for tracking species over - Misses organisms
transect counting organisms along its length (small area stationary animals (coral reefs). large areas. outside the transect line.
if possible).
- Reduces observer bias. - Less accurate for patchy
distributions.
Mark- Tagging and releasing animals, then recapturing Mobile species (fish, birds, - Allows for population estimation - Assumes marked animals
Recapture them to estimate total population. mammals). without counting every individual. mix evenly.
Pitfall traps - beetles / baited live - - Works for species that move - Trap-shy or trap-happy
komoto dragons / mist nets - birds widely. behavior can bias
estimates.

3. Detailed Explanation of Each Method

A. Direct Counting (Census Method)

• Definition: Counting every single individual in a population.

• Example: A census of elephant populations in a national park using aerial photography.

• Strengths:

✔ Very accurate when feasible.

✔ Works well for small, isolated populations (e.g., island species).

• Weaknesses:

❌ Not practical for large or highly mobile populations.

❌ Time-intensive and expensive (e.g., counting every fish in a lake).

B. Quadrat Sampling (Used for Plants & Sessile Animals)

• Definition: A square frame (quadrant) is placed randomly, and organisms inside are counted.

• How It Works:

1. Choose multiple quadrat locations.

2. Count the organisms inside each quadrat.

Population Ecology - 43 Page 1

 2. Count the organisms inside each quadrat.
3. Calculate average density and extrapolate to the whole area.

• Example Calculation

• Strengths:

✔ Efficient and cost-effective.

✔ Works well for plants, fungi, and corals.

• Weaknesses:

❌ May not be representative if placement is biased.

❌ Not useful for mobile species like birds or mammals.

C. Transect Sampling (Used for Trees & Large Stationary Organisms)

• Definition: A long tape measure (transect line) is placed across an area, and all organisms touching it are counted.

• Example: A 100m line is stretched across a forest, and trees within 1m of the line are counted.

• Strengths:

✔ More efficient than quadrats for large organisms like trees.

✔ Reduces observer bias compared to quadrat placement.

• Weaknesses:

❌ Misses organisms outside the transect (does not account for patchy distributions).
❌ Not useful for mobile species.

D. Mark-Recapture Method (Used for Mobile Animals)

• Definition: A sample of animals is captured, marked, and released. Later, another sample is taken, and the proportion of marked animals is used to estimate population
size.

• Formula:

Example Calculation:

1. A researcher captures and marks 50 turtles.

2. A week later, they recapture 40 turtles, of which 10 are marked.
3. Using the formula:

Estimated total population: 200 turtles.

Population Ecology - 43 Page 2

Estimated total population: 200 turtles.

Assumptions:

- Assumes the ratio of marked to unmarked individuals in the second sample is the same as the ratio of marked individuals to the total population size in the first
sample.

Strengths:

✔ Best method for mobile species.

✔ Works in large areas (e.g., ocean fish, birds).

Weaknesses:

❌ Trap-shy animals may avoid capture, leading to overestimation.

❌ Trap-happy animals may return to traps, leading to underestimation.
❌ Assumes no immigration or emigration.

4. Real-World Applications

• Quadrat & Transects: Used in forest management, coral reef monitoring, and plant species conservation.

• Mark-Recapture: Used in wildlife conservation (tracking endangered species like wolves).

• Direct Counting: Used for census of endangered species (e.g., counting rhinos using drones).

5. Possible Exam Questions

1. Why do ecologists prefer to estimate population density rather than count every individual in most species?

✅ Correct Answer: Direct counts are often impractical due to high mobility or large population sizes.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• Population density always remains constant over time → Wrong because populations fluctuate due to births, deaths, immigration, and emigration.

• Quadrats and transects are only used in small-scale studies → Wrong because these methods can be used in large-scale field studies.

• Population density is only important for large mammals → Wrong because it is important for all species, including plants and insects.

2. Which of the following is a major assumption of the mark-recapture method?

✅ Correct Answer: Marked individuals mix randomly with the population before recapture.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• Marked individuals do not die or emigrate → Wrong because mortality and movement can occur, but should be low for accurate results.

• All individuals are equally likely to be captured → Wrong because some individuals may be trap-happy or trap-shy.

• The initial capture sample is large enough to include at least 50% of the population → Wrong because a smaller percentage can still give accurate estimates.

3. What is the biggest limitation of using quadrat sampling for estimating population size?

✅ Correct Answer: Quadrat placement must be random to avoid bias in density estimates.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• Quadrat sampling can only be used for trees → Wrong because it can be used for any sessile organisms, including corals and fungi.

• Quadrat sampling requires measuring the entire population → Wrong because it uses a small sample to estimate a larger area.

• Quadrat sampling is the most accurate method for mobile species → Wrong because mobile species can move in and out of the sampled area.

4. Why is a line transect better than a quadrat for measuring tree populations?

✅ Correct Answer: A transect allows sampling across a gradient of environmental conditions.

Population Ecology - 43 Page 3

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• Transects provide more accurate population density estimates → Wrong because both methods can be accurate depending on sampling design.

• Transects capture only the largest trees → Wrong because they sample trees along a line, regardless of size.

• Transects work only for single-species forests → Wrong because they can be used in diverse ecosystems.

5. A researcher wants to estimate the population of sea turtles in a coastal region. Which method would be most
effective?

✅ Correct Answer: Mark-recapture, because sea turtles are mobile and difficult to count directly.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• Quadrat sampling → Wrong because sea turtles are mobile, and quadrats work best for sessile species.

• Transect sampling → Wrong because transects are better for counting stationary organisms like trees or corals.

• Direct counting → Wrong because sea turtles move over a large range, making direct counts inaccurate.

6. A study on prairie grass density uses quadrat sampling. The researcher places quadrats only in the most vegetated
areas. What problem does this cause?

✅ Correct Answer: The study overestimates population density due to biased quadrat placement.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• The study underestimates grass coverage → Wrong because it is overestimating, not underestimating, density.

• The study provides an accurate density estimate → Wrong because sampling bias makes the estimate unreliable.

• The study underestimates total land area → Wrong because area estimation is separate from density estimation.

7. A biologist captures and marks 50 fish. One week later, they recapture 40 fish, of which 10 are marked. What is the
estimated total population?

✅ Correct Answer:

The estimated population size is 200.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• 100 → Wrong because this underestimates total population size.

• 400 → Wrong because this overestimates the population.

• 50 → Wrong because this ignores the recapture data.

8. A quadrat study samples 5 plots, each 1 square meter, in a forest. The number of ferns per plot is recorded as: 4, 7,
5, 6, and 8. What is the estimated density per square meter?

✅ Correct Answer:

Estimated fern density = 6 per square meter.

Population Ecology - 43 Page 4

❌ Incorrect Answers:

• 5 → Wrong because this miscalculates the average.

• 7 → Wrong because this does not represent the correct mean.

• 10 → Wrong because this overestimates the density.

9. Which of the following are assumptions of the mark-recapture method? (Select all that apply.)

✅ Correct Answers:

☑ Marked individuals mix randomly with unmarked individuals.

☑ The ratio of marked to unmarked individuals remains constant.

☑ No significant immigration or emigration occurs between sampling periods.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

☐ Marked individuals must be recaptured at a 50% rate → Wrong because mark-recapture works with lower recapture rates.

☐ The entire population must be sampled → Wrong because mark-recapture estimates the total population without counting every individual.

10. Which of the following factors affect population density estimates using quadrats? (Select all that apply.)

✅ Correct Answers:

☑ The size of the quadrat relative to organism distribution.

☑ The number of quadrats sampled.

☑ Whether the quadrats are placed randomly or non-randomly.

❌ Incorrect Answers:

☐ The movement speed of the organisms → Wrong because quadrats are used for sessile organisms, not mobile ones.

☐ The temperature of the environment → Wrong because temperature may affect organism behavior, but not quadrat methodology itself.

Population Ecology - 43 Page 5