VIbration Analysis Guide
VIbration Analysis Guide
TO VIBRATION-
BASED
CONDITION
MONITORING
Dr Bubathi Muruganantham
Application Engineering Manager Honeywell Process Measurement & Control
Offering Management
Pune, India
October 2024
TABLE OF
CONTENTS
1 Vibration
2 Types of vibration monitoring
3 Vibration sensors
4 Types of faults in rotating machines
4.1 Shaft unbalance
4.2 Shaft misalignment
4.3 Bent shaft
4.4 Looseness
4.5 Oil whirl and oil whip
4.6 Bearing fault
4.7 Gear fault
4.8 Bladed machines faults
4.9 Stator faults
4.10 Broken rotor bars
4.11 Eccentricity
4.12 Cracked shaft
5 Standards used in vibration-based condition monitoring
6 Mounting location and its effects
7 Processing of vibration data
8 Definitions
9 References
AMPLITUDE
Amplitude represents the intensity of motion from a neutral
position over a time interval or at a specific time. Amplitude can be
expressed/measured as displacement, velocity and acceleration
of motion. It is measured in mm, mm/s, mm/s2, g (9.81 m/s2), dB,
etc. As seen in Figure 1, amplitude is represented by arrows.
PHASE
Phase is a measure of the time difference between two waveforms. Phase
of vibration signal represents the vibration referring to a reference point
or space. It is measured in degrees (0°-360°). Phase can be relative
(comparison between two vibration sources) and absolute (comparison
between a vibration source and a reference point such as speed). Relative
phase is between -180° to 180°. Absolute phase is between 0° to 360°.
• Cause impacts, such as gear tooth contacts or the impacts generated by the
rolling elements of a bearing passing over flaws in the bearing raceways.
Some of the most common machinery problems that cause vibration include:
• Looseness
• Gear wear
• Rubbing
• Resonance
For the vast majority of machines in a plant, it is not economical to equip them with
permanent sensors for continuous monitoring. The time interval of intermittent
monitoring must be shorter than the minimum required lead times for maintenance
and production planning purposes. In offline monitoring, a large number of
machines can then be monitored intermittently with a single sensor and data logger.
PERMANENT INTERMITTENT
METRIC
MONITORING MONITORING
Generic application Critical machines Non-critical machines
Velocity measurement
• An indicator of the level of vibration severity and is proportional to
the level of fatigue that a mechanical system is sustaining.
Acceleration measurement
• Acceleration is the parameter that gives the best indication of the internal forces
associated with a particular source of vibration (Force = mass × acceleration)
One can convert signal from one measurement to another. For example, using
differentiation (mathematical), displacement to velocity to acceleration can
be estimated. However, due to differentiation, signal is noisy. Hence, this
approach is rarely used. Conversely, acceleration to velocity or velocity-
to-displacement conversion is done through integration. Integration
is carried out accurately with a cheap electronic circuit or via software.
That is one of the main reasons why the accelerometer is the standard
transducer for vibration measurements, since its output signal can be
easily integrated once or twice to obtain velocity or displacement.
Table 2: Advantages and disadvantages of proximity probes Figure 6: Location of proximity probes [Ref: 9.a]
ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Application: Ideal for remote permanently Size: Higher in size requiring large magnetic
installed base
Insight: Provides direct information on Frequency range: Typically from 10-1000 Hz
vibration severity
ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Do no load the measurement object and can Expensive
easily change the measurement point by
deflecting the light beam Bulky and difficult to move around
ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
No interference with the machine Costlier than contact type
Effect: Excitation forces rotating at the shaft speed is generated mainly in radial
direction. Dynamic balancing (adding weights) to shaft is done to mitigate effect.
Figure 9: Shaft unbalance [Ref: 9.d]
Detection: Fault is detected at a frequency of 1* RPM in the form of a 180°phase
shift across the coupling. (Note: RPM = rotation per minute of shaft).
Detection:
Parallel Misalignment
Angular misalignment
4.4 LOOSENESS
Definition: Not enough tightening between different mechanical (a)
Detection: (b)
Cause: At lower loads, there is a mismatch in velocity of oil adjacent to the shaft
and the bearing surface. Also, due to alignment of foundation, thermal effect.
Detection: Stator fault in induction motors will show at pole passing frequency.
Figure 17: Stator winding shorted [Ref: 9.h]
Effect: Broken bars cause torque and speed oscillations in the rotor,
provoking premature wear of bearings and other driven components.
Detection: 1x harmonic running speed with rotor fault frequency Figure 18: Missing rotor bar [Image ref: 9.i]
sideband (rotor fault frequency/slip frequency * number of poles).
4.11 ECCENTRICITY
Definition: Offset between the axis of rotation and the axis of symmetry.
Eccentricity can take place in different types of mechanical elements, such
as pulleys, gears and in any relative positioning between two concentric Eccentric Eccentric
pieces -- for example, the rotor and stator of an electric motor. pulley bearing
ISO 10816-1 is a document that sets out guidelines for the measurement and
evaluation of mechanical vibration of machines, as measured on non-rotating parts.
Class I machines may be separate driver and driven, or coupled with units comprising
operating machinery up to approximately 15kW (approx 20hp).
Class I machinery - electrical motors 15kW (20hp) to 75kW (100hp), without special
foundation, or Rigdly mounted engines or machines up to 300kW (400hp) mounted on
special foundations.
Class III machines are large prime movers and other large machinery with large rotating
assemblies mounted on rigid and heavy foundation which are reasonably stiff in the direction
of vibration.
Class IV includes large prime movers and other large machinery wuth large rotation assemblies
mounted on foundations which are relatively soft in the direction of the measured vibration (i.e.,
turbine generators and gas turbines grater than 100MW (approx 13500hp) output.
VELOCITY
VELOCITY RANGE LIMITS AND MACHINE CLASSES
SEVERITY
Large Machines
Small Medium Less Rigid
mm/s in/s Machines Machines Rigid Supports Supports Class
RMS Peak Class I Class II Class III IV
0.28 0.02 Good
0.45 0.03
0.71 0.04
1.12 0.06
1.80 0.10
2.80 0.16
4.50 0.25 Satisfactory
7.10 0.40
11.20 0.62 Unsatisfactory
18.00 1.00 (alert)
28.00 1.56 Unacceptable
45.00 2.51 (danger)
The ISO 10816-3 standard provides criteria for evaluating the
vibration of machinery according to measurements taken on non-
rotating parts, such as bearings, bearing pedestals or housings.
0.08 1.4
Newly
0.04 0.7 commissioned
machinery
0.00 0.0
The method of securing the sensor in the machine directly determines the
high frequency cutoff (Table 6), since the sensor machine contact acts as a
mechanical low pass filter. High frequencies are very low in amplitude (and
energy) and are the first type of content to be affected by the mounting method,
as there may be loss of energy during transmission to the vibration sensor.
Figure 21: Methods to mount a vibration sensor and its frequency spectrum
Handheld 2000 Hz
The best mounting method is, of course, by screwing the sensor to the
surface of the machine at the measurement location. However, due to
the cost, this method is only used in permanent monitoring systems.
In order to capture signals at very high frequency (from 6 to 15 kHz),
the use of silicon-based greases and adhesives is recommended.
DO’S
• For measurements above 1,000Hz (60,000 cpm), the spot-faced surface should
be flat within 1 mil and have a surface texture no greater than 32 microinches.
DON’TS
• Avoid getting debris between the sensor and the surface as this
can dramatically reduce the upper frequency response limit.
b. https://power-mi.com/content/seismic-velocity-transducers
c. https://power-mi.com/content/piezoelectric-transducers
d. https://ludeca.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/
Ludeca-Betavib-UnbalanceVibration-Infographic.pdf
e. https://power-mi.com/content/looseness
f. http://dx.doi.org/10.1166/jnn.2017.13775
g. http://ijtf.org/2021/performance-enhancement-of-centrifugal-pump-
through-cavitation-reduction-using-optimization-techniques/
h. https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/54865
i. https://www.eaton.com/ecm/groups/public/@pub/@
electrical/documents/content/pct_918822.pdf
j. https://power-mi.com/content/eccentricity
k. https://www.efficientplantmag.com/2012/07/
failure-analysis-of-machine-shafts/
l. https://www.iso.org/standard/78311.html
Honeywell Process
Measurement and Control
2101 CityWest Blvd
Houston, TX 77042
Honeywell House, Arlington Business Park LoRaWAN® is a mark used under license
from the LoRa Alliance®
Bracknell, Berkshire, England RG12 1EB UK
Bluetooth® is a registered trademark