CASE STUDY FOCUS: STRATEGIC FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND DECISION-

MAKING
Objective:

This case study focuses on equipping you with the analytical tools and strategic insights
required to navigate the complex financial and operational decisions faced by EcoTech
Innovations Ltd. As emerging leaders, you will evaluate and recommend critical
strategies that influence the company’s sustainability and profitability.

Preparatory Guidance:
This case study will be released one week before your final examination, providing you
with the opportunity to immerse yourself in EcoTech’s financial challenges and strategic
opportunities. Specific requirements will only be disclosed during the exam to test your
ability to apply learned concepts under timed conditions.
Study Focus:

• Develop a comprehensive understanding of key financial tools such as CVP

analysis, variance analysis, and capital investment appraisal.

• Be prepared to apply these tools to assess EcoTech’s performance and strategic

decisions.
Strategic Reflection:

• Think beyond numbers. Consider how financial metrics influence EcoTech’s

broader sustainability goals, operational efficiencies, and competitive positioning.

Detail and Strategy:

• Pay attention to both quantitative details and their qualitative implications, linking
financial performance with EcoTech’s mission of innovation and sustainability.

1/20
SECTIONS OVERVIEW

SECTION A: Decision-Making Amidst Uncertainty

Cost-Volume-Profit Analysis (CVP):

Explore the profitability metrics for EcoTech’s product lines, understand break-even points,
and perform sensitivity analysis to identify financial risks. Develop actionable
recommendations for profitability improvements.
Short-Term Decision Making:

Evaluate the strategic implications of a bulk order proposal using variable costing
principles. Assess how such decisions align with EcoTech’s operational balance,
sustainability practices, and market positioning.
SECTION B: Performance and Cost Analysis

Variance Analysis:
Uncover underlying trends in EcoTech’s financial performance by calculating and
interpreting key variances. Propose strategies to address discrepancies while maintaining
the company’s commitment to sustainability.

Activity-Based Costing (ABC):

Use ABC to analyze product-specific profitability, focusing on identifying and managing
cost drivers. Discuss how ABC supports strategic pricing and profitability in a
sustainability-driven business.
SECTION C: Strategic Analysis

Capital Investment Appraisal:

Evaluate the SolarFlow Home Battery project’s financial viability using metrics such as
ARR, Payback Period, NPV, and IRR. Reflect on how these metrics align with EcoTech’s
long-term goals and market vision.

Transfer Pricing Policy:

Examine how strategic transfer pricing fosters collaboration between divisions, supports
sustainability-focused innovation, and enhances overall operational efficiency and market
competitiveness.

Good luck!

2/20
Introduction to the Case Study Structure

This case study is divided into clear sections to help you analyze EcoTech Innovations
Ltd.’s strategic and financial decisions effectively:

1. Business Context and Background

Provides insights into market trends, EcoTech’s strategic vision, competitive
positioning, and growth opportunities in the renewable energy storage industry.
2. Market and Financial Projections
Includes key financial data such as investment details, sales projections, and the
pricing structure for the SolarFlow Home Battery models, along with material and
labor cost breakdowns.
3. Strategic Decisions
Focuses on fixed operating costs, cost of capital, and bulk order decisions that
impact EcoTech’s financial and operational strategies.

4. Year 1 Financial Performance

Analyzes the company’s financial outcomes for its first year of operations,
evaluating budgeted vs. actual performance metrics.
5. Strategic Transfer Pricing
Discusses mechanisms to enhance profitability and financial efficiency, ensuring
seamless collaboration between EcoTech’s Core Battery Production Division and
Integrated Energy Solutions Division.

This structured approach will guide you in identifying key information, performing financial
analysis, and addressing EcoTech’s strategic challenges effectively.

3/20
Business Context and Background
EcoTech Innovations Ltd., a sustainability-driven technology company based in the UK, is
revolutionizing the home energy storage sector with its flagship product, the SolarFlow
Home Battery. Known for delivering cutting-edge, eco-friendly solutions that seamlessly
integrate with modern households, EcoTech’s entry into the renewable energy market
addresses the growing global concerns about energy efficiency, rising electricity costs, and
the need for energy independence.

1.1. Recent Market Trends

The home energy storage market has experienced rapid growth, driven by the following
key trends:

• Increasing energy prices and demand for cost-efficient electricity solutions.

• Government incentives and subsidies promoting renewable energy adoption.

• Growing consumer interest in self-sufficiency, particularly for homes with solar

panel installations.

• Technological advancements in battery storage efficiency, AI-driven energy

management, and smart grid compatibility.

Consumers are now prioritizing energy storage solutions that provide:

• Reliable backup power to mitigate power outages.

• Sustainable, long-term energy savings.

• Smart home integration for real-time energy monitoring and optimization.
With climate change concerns and increasing reliance on decentralized energy sources,
solar battery storage solutions like SolarFlow are becoming essential for modern, eco-
conscious households.
1.2. EcoTech’s Strategic Vision

EcoTech envisions the SolarFlow Home Battery as a transformative product in the

renewable energy storage sector.

• SolarFlow Basic Model is designed for cost-conscious homeowners, offering

efficient battery storage at an affordable price.
• SolarFlow Advanced Model targets high-income, tech-savvy consumers, combining
premium battery technology with AI-driven optimization and smart grid compatibility.

4/20
Both models reflect EcoTech’s mission to advance sustainability and innovation without
compromising efficiency or performance.
Key features of the SolarFlow line include:

• AI-powered energy optimization, maximizing energy efficiency and minimizing

waste.

• Real-time monitoring of battery health, energy consumption, and solar charge

levels via the EcoTech mobile app.

• Sleek, compact design that integrates seamlessly with existing solar panel systems.
• Recyclable and durable battery materials, aligning with EcoTech’s commitment to
sustainability.
By prioritizing innovation and affordability, EcoTech ensures that both residential and
commercial consumers can transition smoothly to clean, independent energy solutions.
1.3. Competition and Differentiation

The home energy storage market is highly competitive, with established brands like Tesla
Powerwall, LG Chem, and Sonnen dominating the industry.

EcoTech differentiates itself by focusing on sustainability, smart technology, and

affordability:
• SolarFlow Basic provides an affordable entry point for homeowners looking for
efficient, cost-effective battery storage.
• SolarFlow Advanced offers AI-driven smart optimization, high storage capacity, and
seamless grid integration, catering to high-performance energy users.
Unique Selling Propositions (USPs) of SolarFlow Batteries:
1. Smart Home Connectivity
o SolarFlow integrates with EcoTech’s Smart Energy Hub, allowing users to
monitor energy usage, battery status, and optimize energy efficiency.
2. Sustainability Metrics Dashboard

o Users can track their carbon footprint reduction and energy savings through
EcoTech’s proprietary analytics dashboard.

3. Subscription-Based Battery Maintenance

o A predictive maintenance system detects battery wear and schedules
automatic servicing and software updates.

5/20
 4. Renewable Energy Compatibility

o SolarFlow is optimized for solar-powered homes, reducing reliance on the

traditional grid.

5. Circular Economy Initiative

o EcoTech operates a battery recycling and refurbishment program, ensuring
old battery cells are repurposed or safely disposed of.
By aligning SolarFlow with a broader ecosystem of energy-efficient solutions, EcoTech
creates a holistic, future-proof energy storage experience for homeowners and
businesses.

1.4. Challenges and Opportunities

Challenges

1. Regulatory Compliance & Safety Standards

o The energy storage industry is subject to stringent regulations, requiring
ongoing R&D investment to ensure compliance with UK, EU, and US safety
standards.

2. Managing Production Costs

o Lithium battery technology is capital-intensive, making cost-efficient
manufacturing a key challenge.

3. Competition with Established Brands

o Companies like Tesla and LG have strong brand loyalty and established
distribution networks.
Opportunities
1. Growing Demand for Renewable Energy Storage
o The transition to decentralized energy grids and home-based solar power is
creating massive opportunities for companies like EcoTech.
2. Government Incentives & Green Energy Policies

o Many governments offer tax credits and subsidies for solar battery
installations, making SolarFlow an attractive investment for homeowners.

3. Expanding into Emerging Markets

o Developing regions with unstable electricity grids present huge growth
potential for battery storage solutions.

6/20
By strategically marketing the SolarFlow Basic and SolarFlow Advanced models, EcoTech
Innovations Ltd. is well-positioned to disrupt the home energy storage market and
establish itself as a leader in sustainable energy technology.

Market and Financial Projections with Strategic

Insights
EcoTech Innovations Ltd. is poised to redefine the home energy storage market with the
launch of its SolarFlow Home Battery, addressing the growing demand for sustainable,
self-sufficient energy solutions. Backed by a £80 million investment, this flagship product
combines advanced energy storage technology with environmental responsibility, catering
to the evolving needs of modern households.

Strategic Insights:
Sustainability-Driven Innovation

• SolarFlow leverages high-efficiency lithium-phosphate batteries (LiFePO4) that

offer a longer lifespan and greater safety compared to traditional lithium-ion
alternatives, reducing environmental impact while lowering long-term consumer
costs.

• The product integrates seamlessly with EcoTech’s smart energy ecosystem,

allowing users to monitor energy storage, track consumption, and optimize
efficiency via the EcoTech app.
Tailored Market Positioning

• With the Basic Model priced at £3,000, EcoTech targets budget-conscious

consumers seeking an affordable home battery solution that maximizes solar
energy usage.

• The Advanced Model, priced at £5,500, offers premium features like AI-driven
energy optimization, extended storage capacity, and smart home integration,
appealing to high-income, eco-conscious buyers.
Industry-Specific Alignment

• By focusing on sustainability and smart home energy management, SolarFlow

aligns with emerging trends in the renewable energy sector, where consumers
increasingly prioritize energy independence and cost efficiency.
• EcoTech’s subscription model for battery maintenance and software updates further
aligns with the industry's shift toward service-based solutions, increasing long-term
customer loyalty.

7/20
Scalable Financial Plan

• A 4-year product lifecycle allows EcoTech to expand market reach, recoup

investments, and adapt to evolving energy technologies.

• The SolarFlow Home Battery's revenues over its 4-year product lifecycle are critical
for EcoTech to establish a strong market presence, enhance brand recognition, and
build customer trust, especially as the company ventures into new markets, such as
the United States.

Initial Investment of £80 Million

This substantial investment underscores EcoTech’s commitment to innovation and
environmental responsibility. It includes:
• Extensive research and development (R&D) to create cutting-edge battery
technology, AI-driven energy management, and sustainable materials.
• A comprehensive marketing campaign designed to generate significant market
buzz and establish SolarFlow as a top-tier home energy solution.
• Investment in scalable production facilities to ensure responsiveness to growing
consumer demand, allowing for future expansion into international markets.

Project Lifespan
The SolarFlow Home Battery is projected to have a 4-year lifespan, aligning with industry
norms and the pace of advancements in battery storage technology and smart energy
management. This timeline allows EcoTech to achieve strategic goals such as:
• Market penetration and customer loyalty, ensuring strong adoption rates among
homeowners and small businesses.
• Innovation leadership, maintaining competitiveness in a rapidly evolving industry
where battery efficiency and connectivity are continuously improving.
The 4-year duration reflects the typical product lifecycle in the home energy storage
market, where advancements in battery chemistry, software optimization, and grid
integration necessitate upgrades within this period. This ensures SolarFlow remains
relevant and competitive, especially as consumers expect smart energy solutions to
evolve over time.
Additionally, the durability of SolarFlow’s LiFePO4 batteries supports a 4-year operational
lifespan, balancing environmental sustainability with economic viability. The timeline also
provides EcoTech sufficient time to:

• Recoup its investment through battery sales and service subscriptions.

8/20
 • Generate steady revenue from battery installations and maintenance services.

• Plan for the next-generation SolarFlow models, incorporating feedback and

emerging trends in home energy technology.

By adopting a 4-year lifecycle, EcoTech ensures SolarFlow remains a flagship product that
delivers long-term value to consumers while positioning itself to introduce upgraded
models and sustain market leadership.

Year 1 Sales Volume Projections

• SolarFlow Basic (200,000 units): Designed for the average household, the Basic
model balances affordability with advanced battery technology. Sales projections
are based on rising consumer demand for reliable, eco-friendly home energy
storage.

• SolarFlow Advanced (45,000 units): Targeted at premium consumers, the Advanced

model combines AI-driven energy management with extended storage capacity. It
appeals to eco-conscious homeowners looking for enhanced energy efficiency, as
well as tech-savvy users who prioritize smart home integration.

Annual Sales Volume Growth

A 10% annual growth rate in sales volume is forecasted for both the SolarFlow Basic and
Advanced models. This growth is driven by:
• EcoTech’s innovative product design, leveraging AI and IoT capabilities to enhance
energy efficiency.
• Targeted marketing strategies, aimed at homeowners, small businesses, and
environmentally conscious consumers.
• Expansion into emerging markets, capitalizing on increasing global demand for self-
sufficient energy solutions.

Pricing Structure for SolarFlow Home Battery Models

a) Pricing Structure
• SolarFlow Basic

o Price: £3,000 per unit

o Description: Designed for a broad consumer base, this model provides
essential home battery storage features at an affordable price. It is ideal for
households looking to maximize solar energy usage, reduce electricity bills,
and increase energy independence while maintaining a cost-effective and
eco-friendly energy solution.

9/20
 • SolarFlow Advanced

o Price: £5,500 per unit

o Description: Positioned as a premium offering, the Advanced model includes
enhanced features such as AI-driven energy optimization, increased storage
capacity, and smart home integration. It appeals to eco-conscious and tech-
savvy homeowners who value cutting-edge energy management technology
and seamless integration with their smart home ecosystems.

b) Direct Material Costs

• SolarFlow Basic

o Cost: £800 per unit

o Details: Utilizes high-efficiency lithium-phosphate (LiFePO4) batteries,
ensuring a long lifespan, enhanced safety, and sustainable energy storage.
The design emphasizes durability and cost-effectiveness to provide
consumers with a reliable and eco-friendly solution.
• SolarFlow Advanced

o Cost: £1,300 per unit

o Details: Incorporates premium-grade battery cells with extended capacity,
advanced thermal management systems, and AI-enabled energy monitoring.
These high-end components enhance performance, safety, and overall
energy efficiency, reinforcing its position as a top-tier energy storage
solution.
c) Direct Labour Costs

• SolarFlow Basic
o Labour Rate: £30 per hour

o Production Time: 1.5 hours per unit

o Details: The Basic model benefits from optimized manufacturing processes
and targeted training programs, allowing for efficient assembly while
maintaining consistent quality and affordability.

• SolarFlow Advanced
o Labour Rate: £35 per hour
o Production Time: 2 hours per unit

10/20
 o Details: Designed with precision and sophistication, the Advanced model
requires specialized expertise to assemble its intricate energy management
system and AI-enhanced components. This reflects the superior
craftsmanship and technological advancement that distinguish this premium
energy solution.

Annual Fixed Operating Costs of £35 Million

EcoTech Innovations Ltd. has strategically allocated £35 million in annual fixed operating
costs for the SolarFlow Home Battery, comprising an annual cash outflow of £15 million
and a depreciation expense of £20 million.

a) Depreciation Expense (£20 million)

EcoTech Innovations allocates £20 million annually to depreciation costs, derived from its
initial investment of £80 million, using straight-line depreciation over the 4-year lifespan of
the SolarFlow Home Battery project. This allocation reflects the company’s significant
investment in advanced manufacturing assets to support the production of both the
SolarFlow Basic and SolarFlow Advanced models.

To ensure fair allocation of these fixed costs, Machine Hours is selected as the cost driver.
This metric directly measures the time manufacturing assets are utilized for each product,
ensuring costs are distributed proportionally. Due to the complexity and precision required,
the SolarFlow Advanced model demands more machine hours per unit than the simpler
SolarFlow Basic model, with the details outlined in Figure 1.

11/20
 Figure 1 - Strategic Allocation of Depreciation expense Based on Machine Hours

SolarFlow Basic Model Machining Strategy

The Basic Model requires 1.5 hours per unit, reflecting streamlined production
processes focused on affordability and mass-market scalability.
Key characteristics include:

• Efficient use of manufacturing lines to meet high production volumes.

• Streamlined processes that reduce complexity and optimize cost efficiency.

• Integration of energy-efficient techniques to align with sustainability goals.

SolarFlow Advanced Model Machining Strategy

The Advanced Model requires 3.0 hours per unit, reflecting the additional resources
and precision needed for advanced features.

Key characteristics include:

• Advanced quality control systems for AI-driven energy management and smart
connectivity.
• Custom assembly processes tailored for high-capacity energy storage and
premium lithium-phosphate batteries.
• Intensive testing to ensure grid compatibility and seamless integration with
home energy systems.

b) Breakdown of Annual Cash Outflow (£15 Million)

This £15 million cash outflow is distributed strategically across:

• Research and Development (R&D): 60% (£9 million)

• Marketing: 25% (£3.75 million)
• Distribution: 15% (£2.25 million)

This balanced distribution ensures EcoTech maintains its competitive edge in the
renewable energy sector.

12/20
b1. Research and Development (R&D) – 60% Allocation (£9 million)

EcoTech dedicates 60% of its annual fixed operating costs to Research and Development
(R&D). This significant investment highlights the company’s commitment to creating
innovative, eco-friendly energy storage solutions.
Core Strategy

• R&D is at the heart of EcoTech’s success, driving innovation to ensure the

SolarFlow Home Battery meets high standards of sustainability, efficiency, and
smart energy management.
• The SolarFlow Basic and SolarFlow Advanced models are designed with unique
features tailored to different customer needs:
o Basic Model: Focuses on cost efficiency and broad accessibility.

o Advanced Model: Offers AI-driven energy optimization and premium battery

technology.

To ensure R&D resources align with actual effort and complexity, development hours are
used as the cost driver for allocating R&D costs. The detailed focus areas and associated
development hours for each product are summarized in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Model-Specific R&D Focus

SolarFlow Basic Model (12,000 SolarFlow Advanced Model

Focus Area
Hours) (20,000 Hours)

Cost efficiency and broad Innovation and premium energy

Strategic Focus
accessibility. management.

R&D Investment - Simplified, high-efficiency - AI-driven energy storage and

Areas battery technology. optimization.

- Optimization of battery - Smart grid integration and real-

production processes. time monitoring.

- Research into affordable, - Next-gen lithium-phosphate

sustainable materials. battery development.

b2. Marketing - 25% Allocation (£3.75 million)

EcoTech Innovations allocates 25% of its annual fixed operating costs to marketing
SolarFlow Home Battery, supporting both the Basic Model and Advanced Model. This

13/20
investment aligns with EcoTech’s dual-market strategy, balancing broad market reach with
premium brand positioning.
To effectively allocate these costs, EcoTech structures its marketing activities into specific
components, as shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Marketing Cost Pool – Key Components

Marketing
SolarFlow Basic Model SolarFlow Advanced Model
Activities

Mass-market campaigns: Targeted campaigns: renewable energy

Advertising Costs
TV, radio, online ads forums, premium home magazines

Promotional Discounts, bundles for Exclusive events, influencer

Expenses solar system buyers partnerships

General brochures, Premium content highlighting AI-driven

Content Marketing
instructional videos energy optimization

Customer Loyalty programs, broad Personalized follow-ups, premium

Engagement customer support technical assistance

Market Research & Trend analysis and Focused research for high-end smart
Analytics competitive insights home users

Using sales revenue as the cost driver for marketing costs is justified by the following
factors:
• Reflects Product Value

o Marketing investments are tied to the perceived value of each product.

o The Advanced Model, with its higher price point, requires premium marketing
initiatives to communicate its advanced features and justify its value.
• Strategic Alignment

o The Basic Model focuses on mass adoption, requiring broad-scale, high-

reach campaigns.

o The Advanced Model demands specialized, high-impact strategies to

establish a premium brand presence.

• Proportional Resource Allocation

o Allocating costs based on revenue ensures each product receives
investments proportional to its contribution.
14/20
b3. Distribution - 15% Allocation (£2.25 million)

EcoTech Innovations dedicates 15% of its fixed operating costs to optimizing distribution
channels for SolarFlow Home Battery. This allocation underscores the company’s
commitment to making its products widely accessible, ensuring efficient supply chain
management.

By investing in adaptive and efficient distribution, EcoTech aims to meet demand promptly
while maintaining its sustainability commitment through eco-friendly logistics.

Figure 4: Strategic Allocation of Distribution Resources

Focus Area SolarFlow Basic Model SolarFlow Advanced Model

Niche markets via high-end energy

Distribution Broad market reach via solar
consultants and direct-to-consumer
Target retailers and e-commerce.
sales.

Cost Driver Production Volume Production Volume

- Fixed depreciation of transport - Fixed depreciation of transport

Key Components vehicles. vehicles.
of Costs - Fixed salaries for logistics
- Fixed salaries for logistics team.
team.

Cost-effective logistics to ensure Premium delivery standards and

Strategic Focus wide accessibility and timely eco-friendly packaging for
delivery. exclusivity.

Company’s Cost of Capital at 8%

This competitive rate of 8% reflects EcoTech’s strong financial stability and market
credibility, enabling the company to innovate sustainably while ensuring attractive returns
for stakeholders. By maintaining a balanced capital structure, EcoTech can fund research
and development, expand production capabilities, and optimize its cost of capital to
support long-term growth.

Expected Income Tax Rate of 20%

The 20% income tax rate is factored into EcoTech’s financial planning to ensure
compliance with tax regulations while optimizing net income. This rate reflects the
company's commitment to transparent and effective fiscal management, ensuring
profitability and long-term financial sustainability.

15/20
Strategic Decision on a Bulk Order for EcoTech
Innovations Ltd.
EcoTech Innovations Ltd. is preparing to strengthen its market presence with the
SolarFlow Basic and Advanced models. In its inaugural year, the company achieved
notable sales milestones, building brand recognition and establishing a foothold in the
sustainable home energy market.

As EcoTech enters its second year, a significant opportunity emerges from GreenPower
Distributors, a major US-based retailer specializing in renewable energy solutions.
GreenPower proposes a bulk order for the SolarFlow Basic Model, presenting EcoTech
with a strategic crossroads to balance immediate market penetration in the US with
operational and financial considerations.
This special order represents a potential catalyst for EcoTech’s international expansion,
while also requiring careful consideration of production capacity, pricing strategy, and long-
term sustainability.

Order Details:
• Quantity: GreenPower Distributors proposes to purchase 15,000 units of the
SolarFlow Basic Model.
• Offered Price: GreenPower offers a purchase price of £2,500 per unit, reflecting a
bulk discount from the standard retail price of £3,000. This discount is intended to
incentivize EcoTech’s entry into the US market while acknowledging the volume of
the order.
• Delivery Timeline: The retailer requests delivery within 45 days of order
confirmation, necessitating swift production and logistical coordination.
• Packaging Requirements: GreenPower requests custom eco-friendly packaging
tailored to the US market, including recyclable materials and bilingual labeling
(English and Spanish). This adds an additional cost of £8 per unit, factoring in
design, materials, and compliance with US consumer preferences for sustainable
products.
• Payment Terms: The proposed terms include 50% payment upfront and the balance
upon delivery, providing EcoTech with an immediate infusion of working capital.
• Future Potential: GreenPower hints at the potential for recurring bulk orders,
contingent on the success of this initial transaction, suggesting a pathway to
establish a strong presence in the growing US market for sustainable energy
solutions.

16/20
Strategic Implications

EcoTech Innovations Ltd. faces a pivotal decision with GreenPower’s bulk order proposal.
By carefully weighing the operational challenges, financial trade-offs, and strategic
benefits, the company can determine whether this opportunity aligns with its long-term
vision of becoming a global leader in renewable energy storage solutions.

This deal represents not just an order, but an opening to secure a foothold in the US
market, provided EcoTech ensures that operational efficiency and brand integrity are
preserved throughout the process.

Year 1 Financial Performance

The following analysis presents the financial performance of EcoTech Innovations Ltd.’s
SolarFlow Home Battery series during its first year, with a detailed comparison between
the budgeted and actual results for the Basic and Advanced models.
The analysis evaluates sales volume, material costs, labor costs, fixed overheads, and
overall profitability, linking them with the company’s strategic decisions and market
dynamics. This comprehensive overview offers insights into operational efficiency, financial
health, and areas for improvement.
Table 1: Year 1 Financial Performance Analysis of SolarFlow Home Battery Series

Financial Metrics SolarFlow Basic SolarFlow Advanced

Budgeted Sales Volume (units) 200,000 45,000

Actual Sales Volume (units) 180,000 50,000

Budgeted Material Cost Per Unit (£) 800 1,300

Actual Material Cost (£) 144,000,000 65,000,000

Actual Direct Labour Hours Used (Hours) 270,000 100,000

Actual Direct Labour Cost (£) 8,100,000 3,500,000

Budgeted Direct Labour Rate (£/hour) 30.0 35.0

Budgeted Direct Labour Hours Per Unit 1.5 2.0

Budgeted Fixed Overheads (£) 35,000,000

Actual Fixed Overheads (£) 30,000,000

17/20
Notes: The fixed overhead cost represents shared expenses incurred collectively for both
the models. These costs include elements such as R&D, marketing, distribution and
depreciation expenses.

Strategic Division and Transfer Pricing Enhancement

To streamline operations and enhance the development and market launch of its
SolarFlow Home Battery, EcoTech Innovations Ltd. has reorganized its operations into two
focused divisions:
1. Core Battery Production Division

2. Integrated Energy Solutions Division

Each division is tasked with distinct responsibilities, ensuring a cohesive strategy that
maximizes efficiency, market competitiveness, and alignment with sustainability objectives.

5.1. Core Battery Production Division

• Objective: Specializes in manufacturing essential battery components, including
high-efficiency lithium-phosphate (LiFePO4) cells, battery management systems
(BMS), and thermal regulation units, which are crucial for the SolarFlow Home
Battery's functionality.
• Variable Cost of Production: Maintains cost efficiency with a production cost of £800
per unit, covering material costs and direct labor. This reflects EcoTech’s
commitment to providing high-quality, sustainable battery solutions at competitive
costs.
• Circular Economy Initiatives:

o The Core Division collects used battery modules through a customer return
program, ensuring that these components are efficiently gathered from
consumers.
o The Integrated Division is responsible for refurbishing and repurposing
battery cells for use in new storage systems or secondary applications.
o This collaboration aligns with EcoTech’s circular economy principles,
reducing waste and production costs, while extending the lifecycle of battery
materials.
• Shipping and Handling Costs: £40 per unit is incurred for shipping and handling in
external transactions. For internal transactions, these costs are eliminated,
demonstrating operational efficiencies within EcoTech’s supply chain.

18/20
 • External Market Selling Price: Core battery components are priced at £1,300 per
unit for external sales, enabling EcoTech to strengthen its presence in the
sustainable energy storage market.

5.2. Integrated Energy Solutions Division

• Responsibility: Oversees the final assembly of the SolarFlow Home Battery,
integrating core battery components with advanced AI-driven energy optimization
systems and smart grid compatibility. This division also manages marketing,
customer support, and sales operations.
• Integration Costs:

o £1,200 per unit for the Basic Model, covering casing, thermal management
systems, and connectivity features.

o £1,800 per unit for the Advanced Model, reflecting premium AI-driven
optimization, extended energy storage capacity, and smart home integration.

• Market Preparation Costs:

o £100 per unit for the Basic Model.

o £180 per unit for the Advanced Model, covering branding, compliance with
international energy regulations, and customized smart energy software.
• Refurbishment and Innovation:

o The Core Division collects battery modules through the customer return
program, ensuring a streamlined process for recovering used materials.

o The Integrated Division then reconditions these batteries, integrating them

into new storage systems or secondary applications such as backup energy
units.
o This collaborative approach reduces dependency on raw materials, creates
cost savings, and supports EcoTech’s circular economy initiatives.

• Bought-In Price for Alternatives: If sourcing battery components externally, the

division would face a bought-in price of £1,300 per unit, making internal sourcing a
cost-efficient strategy.
5.3. Strategic Transfer Pricing and Market Alignment

EcoTech Innovations Ltd. adopts a robust transfer pricing strategy to foster collaboration,
enhance operational efficiency, and maintain market competitiveness.

19/20
• Core Battery Production Division:

o This division is responsible for manufacturing lithium-phosphate battery

modules and battery management systems (BMS), which are integral to the
SolarFlow Home Battery product line.
o The Core Division also collects used batteries through the customer return
program, ensuring a consistent supply of materials for refurbishment.
o By delivering cost-effective, high-quality battery modules, the division
supports scalability and innovation.
o The competitive transfer pricing of these battery components ensures that
the Integrated Division can maintain affordability for the Basic Model while
supporting premium positioning for the Advanced Model.

• Integrated Energy Solutions Division:

o This division focuses on the final assembly of SolarFlow Home Battery units,
integrating the sustainable energy storage components provided by the Core
Division with advanced AI-based energy management and smart grid
functionalities.
o It also reconditions the used battery cells collected by the Core Division,
reintegrating them into secondary applications or extended-lifecycle storage
solutions.
o This collaboration ensures cost efficiency while appealing to diverse
consumer needs—ranging from affordability in the Basic Model to high-
performance energy storage in the Advanced Model.

o Internal sourcing underpins healthy profit margins and enhances market

responsiveness.

20/20