The Moral Issue of Artificial Insemination
The Moral Issue of Artificial Insemination
The Moral Issue of Artificial Insemination
ARTIFICIAL INSEMINATION
Both naturally and traditionally, procreation
has been understood as human conception
resulting from the sexual union of a man and
woman. Procreation always presupposes sex and
vice-versa. This traditional, naturalistic outlook
has also molded our thinking and moral values.
We usually argue, for instance, that sex without
procreation is immoral, insofar as thenatural
purpose of the reproductive organs, so we are
taught, is to reproduce or procreate
The discovery of the infertile period in the
menstrual cycle, however, has injected a
new consideration into the ethical
evaluation of acts that deliberately
exclude procreation from sex. On the
twenty-eight day cycle of a woman, only
about six days are fertile and and twenty-
two days are supposedly infertile.
Artificial Insemination
- refers to an assisted method of reproduction in
which the sperm is provided typically by means
of masturbation and is injected into the
womans reproductive tract through a catheter.
How AI performed?
Techniques of the procedure
1. A medication is administered to active egg development
2. The semen is obtained by means of masturbation after a
designated few days of refraining from ejaculation
3. The seminal processing follows which is characterized by
washing and purification of the semen specimen at the
laboratory
4. The purified and segregated male germ cell is finally
inseminated or injected either into the cervix as in
cervical insemination
Three types of AI
1. Homologous Insemination
- commonly called as artificial insemination by husband
- in which the semen is obtained from the husband himself
2. Heterologous Insemination
- commonly called as artificial insemination by donor
- a technique in which the semen is acquired from a donor other than the
husband.
3. Artificial Insemination
- procedure simply takes place between the unmarried man and woman
who may not regard marriage act as the only licit means of transmitting life
Justification for AIH
1. husbands impotence
2. anatomical defects of husbands urethra
3. deficient sperm count or oligospermia
4. types of spinal injury, and certain physical and
psychological problems that hinder normal intercourse
5. some husband undergo vasectomy for contraceptive
purposes have their semen stored eventual use in the
future
6. physiological obstructions in the genital apparatus of
the wife
Justifications for AID
1. the husband is sterile
2. the husband is carrier of a hereditary
disease
3. the wife oocytes are defective, or she may
also be a carrier of certain genetically
linked disorders
4. the wifes fallopian tubes are severely
damaged by gonorrhea
Is Artificial Insemination is
Moral?
Transgression of the Will of God Expressed in the Law of
Nature
1. Arbitrary Exclusion of the Marital Act from
Procreation
- the natural devised means of transmitting life
embedded within the reproductive faculty of both husband and
wife is no other than the marital act.
2. Distortion of the Meaning and Purpose of
Sexuality
- the meaning and purpose of sexuality are deeply
inscribe within its natural expressions.
Application of Ethical
Theories
Natural law ethics/ Roman Catholic
. Immoral
Situational ethics\
. Moral
. Our right to overcome childlessness
Utilitarianism
. moral since it produces more happiness
Pragmatism
. Moral since it is practical, beneficial and useful and workable
Emmanuel Kant
. Principle of autonomy
. It is moral only if and only if the couple it is voluntary and mutually
agreed