X Files
X Files
X Files
To assess for hypercortisolism, the clinician should ask about weight gain, central obesity, easy bruising, severe hypertension, diabetes, virilization, fatigue, or
proximal muscle weakness.
To assess for a pheochromocytoma, the patient should be asked about hypertension and spell-like symptoms including the development of sudden or severe
headaches, palpitations, sweating, or anxiety attacks
For patients with hyperaldosteronism, the inquiry should also include a history of hypokalemia, fluid retention, or hypertension. It is also important to ask about a
history of cancer, weight loss, or a smoking history because an adrenal incidentaloma could represent a metastatic lesion
Clinical
• Physical examination should include assessment of the patient’s blood pressure, heart rate, and physical appearance, looking for suggestive features of hormone
excess such as anxiety, central obesity, hirsutism, dorsocervical fat pad, facial plethora, proximal muscle weakness or wasting, violaceous striae, skin thinning, or
tremor.
Diagnosis
The major goal of imaging studies is to differentiate between benign and malignant lesions
CT SCAN:
ATTENUATION:The radiographic features of an adrenal incidentaloma, in addition to its size, should be considered in determining the risk of malignancy. Most
adrenal adenomas contain a significant amount of intracellular fat and, hence, have a low attenuation on noncontrast CT scans. In contrast, nearly all malignant
lesions have low intracellular lipid content; their CT attenuation is, consequently, higher. The threshold value typically used in the diagnosis of an adrenal adenoma by
unenhanced CT imaging is 10 Hounsfield units (HU): if the lesion is less than 10 HU on noncontrast CT, it is benign, whereas if it is greater than 10 HU, it warrants
further evaluation.
Adrenal Incidentaloma
CT SCAN:
WASH-OUT:Another imaging feature that can prove useful in the characterization of adrenal
nodules when contrast-enhanced CT scans are performed is a phenomenon termed contrast
washout, in which adenomas take up the intravenous contrast rapidly but also rapidly lose the
contrast medium on delayed images. Malignant lesions usually enhance rapidly but have a slower
washout of the contrast medium. Lipid-poor adenomas, which have higher HU measurements
similar to malignant lesions on unenhanced CT, show a rapid contrast washout on contrast-
enhanced CT just like the lipid-rich adenomas. Thus, contrast washout kinetics allows a distinction
to be made between lipid-poor adenomas and malignant lesions.
SIZE: It is highly unusual for a malignant lesion, if left untreated, to remain stable in size for more
than 6 months. The primary concern regarding size is the risk of adrenocortical carcinoma, which
increases in lesions larger than 4 to 5 cm in diameter. In making the decision regarding
adrenalectomy, size must be considered in conjunction with the radiographic appearance of the
lesion. For example, a 4.5-cm adrenal lesion that has imaging characteristics diagnostic of an
adenoma may be observed depending on the clinical scenario, such as in an older patient
Fine-Needle Aspiration Biopsy: Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy has a very limited role in the
diagnostic evaluation of the adrenal incidentaloma. Mazzaglia and Monchik showed in their
retrospective analysis that cytopathology from an FNA biopsy was unhelpful in distinguishing
between benign and malignant primary adrenal lesions. Other studies evaluating the role of FNA
biopsy in the adrenal incidentaloma concluded that the FNA biopsy rarely changed management
and was associated with a significant risk of complications (including hematoma, pain, error or
delay in diagnosis, and inadvertent biopsy of a pheochromocytoma with resulting severe
hypertension) and subsequent increased difficulty of adrenalectomy.
ESMO:Biopsy of adrenal tumours is usually contraindicated because of the risk of tumour spillage,
poor diagnostic power to discriminate benign from malignant adrenocortical tumours and risk of
hypertensive crises in phaeochromocytoma. However, a biopsy might be indicated in an adrenal
mass without any hormone excess in patients with a history of extra-adrenal cancers to exclude
or prove an adrenal metastasis of an extra-adrenal malignancy, and in patients in whom tumour
sequencing is desired.
Clinicians can almost always make the decision to proceed with adrenalectomy based on
clinical, biochemical, and radiologic assessment alone.
Adrenal Incidentaloma
ESMO: Most ACCs show an inhomogeneous appearance in CT or MRI with irregular margins and irregular enhancement of solid components after intravenous injection of
contrasted agent. Detection of local invasion or tumour extension into the inferior vena cava, as well as lymph node or other metastases including lung and liver is mandatory
before planning any surgery. Therefore, cross-sectional imaging of the chest, abdomen and pelvis is required preoperatively.
For PPGLs, conventional radiological imaging can be important to determine the presence of metastases. How ever, neither CT nor MRI can be used to determine whether
PPGLs are benign or malignant. Malignancy can only be determined from the presence of metastatic lesions at sites where chromaffin cells are normally absent. Without
such evidence, all PPGLs should be considered potentially malignant, with risk dependent on several factors as outlined below.
• tumour size >/=5 cm;
• any extra-adrenal paraganglioma;
• known succinate dehydrogenase complex iron sulfur subunit B (SDHB) germline mutation; or
• plasma methoxytyramine more than threefold above the upper cut-offs of reference intervals.
MOLECULAR BIOLOGY AND METASTATIC RISK. At least 35% of PPGLs result from germline mutations of over 18 tumour-susceptibility genes identified to date, Risk is
particularly high, reaching 70% in patients with PPGL due to mutations in the SDHB gene.34 The vast majority of all metastatic PPGLs, including disease due to SDHB
mutations, develop from noradrenergic or dopaminergic PPGLs with poorly developed secretory pathways. Nevertheless, a small minority of about 10% of metastatic PPGLs
develop from adrenal adrenergic tumours that are characterised by production of epinephrine, as manifested by increased plasma or urinary metanephrine.
Assessment for Adrenal Hormone Excess
Several factors should be considered when performing a biochemical evaluation in a patient with an adrenal nodule, including patient age, sex, medications, and limitation of
assays or varying reference ranges of tests
• Screening for Hypercortisolism If no clinical features of hypercortisolism, an overnight 1-mg dexamethasone suppression test should be performed. Here, the patient is
instructed to take 1 mg of dexamethasone the night before ablood draw. Serum cortisol levels are checked the following morning between 8 am and 9 am. In normal
individuals, the cortisol level should suppress to less than 1.8 μg/dL. A cortisol level above 5 μg/dL after administration of dexamethasone is usually diagnostic of
hypercortisolism. Cortisol levels between 1.8 and 5 μg/dL should spur further workup for possible hypercortisolism. The patient usually undergoes confirmatory testing
with an adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) level as well as a 24-hour urinary cortisol level or a midnight solitary cortisol level. An elevated urinary cortisol and a low
or suppressed ACTH level further support the diagnosis.
• Screening for Hyperaldosteronism Plasma potassium, aldosterone, and renin activity are measured and a ratio of plasma aldosterone concentration to the plasma
renin activity is calculated. A ratio of more than 20 while not taking mineralocorticoid receptor antagonists such as spironolactone should spur further confirmatory
testing with aldosterone suppression testing: either a saline infusion test or a 24-hour urinary aldosterone test while the patient maintains a high sodium diet. Patients
should be off mineralocorticoid receptor antagonists for 6 weeks before testing. Once primary hyperaldosteronism is confirmed, it is important to differentiate
idiopathic hyperaldosteronism from bilateral cortical hyperplasia. Adrenal vein sampling for aldosterone and cortisol is recommended for all patients with bilateral
adrenal nodules, a unilateral nodule less than 1 cm, normal-appearing glands, or age older than 45 years to determine if there is unilateral aldosterone hypersecretion
which would be amenable to surgical management.
Adrenal Incidentaloma
Assessment for Adrenal Hormone Excess
• Screening for Pheochromocytoma The simplest screening test to rule out pheochromocytoma is measurement of plasma free metanephrines (metanephrines and
normetanephrines). False-positive results, primarily with the normetanephrine component of the assay, can occur. If either the metanephrine or normetanephrine is
elevated mildly, then further testing with 24-hour urine for catecholamines and fractionated metanephrines should be done to confirm or rule out this diagnosis.
• Screening for Sex Hormone-Secreting Tumors Screening for virilizing or feminizing tumors is only performed if suggestive clinical features or suspicion for
adrenocortical carcinoma is present. Plasma dehydroepiandrostenedione sulfate levels should be measured. Elevated levels are concerning for an adrenocortical
carcinoma. 17-Estradiol can also be checked if clinical features of feminization are noted in men and postmenopausal women only.
STAGING AND RISK ASSESSMENT
ACC
• In the assessment of disease stage, the authors recommend the tumour, node, metastasis (TNM) classification proposed by the European Network for the Study of
Adrenal Tumours (ENSAT). As indicated above for correct staging, at least a CT of the chest, abdomen and pelvis (or FDG-PET/ CT including full-dose CT) is required.
Recent data suggest that lymph node involvement correlates with stage IV rather than stage III behaviour .
• ACC PROGNOSIS: Overall, the prognosis of ACC is limited. However, prospective data suggest that in patients with complete resection of a localised stage II tumour 5-
year overall survival (OS) can be as high as 90%.38 In metastatic ACC, median survival is about 15 months. However, even in this group, there is a subgroup of patients
with long-term survival. It is well established that disease stage and margin-free resection are currently the most important prognostic factors in ACC. (ESE)eENSAT
guidelines, a comprehensive literature search for prognostic factors has been carried out and only the proliferation marker Ki-67 and glucocorticoid excess showed a
robust association with prognosis [IV, A]
PPGL
• Phaeochromocytomas are catecholamine-producing neuroendocrine tumours arising from chromaffin cells of the adrenal medulla or extra-adrenal paraganglia. The
latter are usually called paraganglioma, leading to the combined term phaeochromocytomas and paragangliomas (PPGLs). For first-time patients without any history
of disease or known mutation, size and location of the primary tumour, and when available, any elevations of plasma methoxytyramine during biochemical testing
seem important to consider when evaluating risk for malignancy. ‘high risk of metastases’ when any patient presents with one or more of the following criteria:
• (i) adrenal phaeochromocytoma >/=5 cm;
• (ii) an extra-adrenal paraganglioma;
• (iii) a known SDHB germline mutation; or
• (iv) plasma methoxytyramine more than threefold above the upper limit of reference intervals.
• Adjuvant treatment: More than half of the ACC patients who have undergone complete removal of the tumour have a relapse risk, often with metastases. This
aggressive behaviour provides the rationale for the use of adjuvant therapy. Mitotane has been the reference drug for the management of ACC for decades and is
increasingly used also in adjuvant settings following surgical removal of ACC. Two recent meta-analyses have reported that adjuvant mitotane treatment reduces
the risk of recurrence and death. On these bases, the recent ESEeENSAT guidelines on the management of ACC suggest that patients at high risk of recurrence
(stage III, or R1-RX resection, and/or Ki-67 index >10%) should be offered adjuvant mitotane [IV, B]. By contrast, adjuvant therapy has to be discussed on an
individual basis in patients fulfilling all the following criteria: stage I or II disease, histologicallyproven R0 resection and Ki-67expressed in </=10% of neoplastic
cells, which define the category of low risk of recurrence [V, B] There are no data regarding the optimal duration of adjuvant mitotane; however, the authors
recommend that adjuvant mitotane should be administered for at least 2 years [V, B], because the greatest frequency of disease recurrence is expected within
this time frame.
• Adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) is able to reduce the risk of local recurrence but does not prevent distant recurrences and, as a consequence, does not impact OS.4
Therefore, it is reasonable to associate mitotane with RT in selected patients with stage III ACC and/or R1 or RX resection, although the combination carries
increased toxicity [IV, B]
• Special considerations on mitotane. Mitotane is a difficult drug to manage, with a long half-life, dose-limiting toxicity and a narrow therapeutic window.
Adrenal Incidentaloma
ACC-MANAGEMENT OF ADVANCED/METASTATIC DISEASE
• Prognosis of advanced ACC patients is limited, the 5-year OS being <15%. However, prolonged survival has been reported especially in patients with resectable
oligometastatic disease, with long intervals between recurrences.
• In general, first-line therapy in patients with advanced/metastatic disease is mitotane alone or mitotane plus chemotherapy (ChT). Surgery and locoregional
therapies should be adopted in addition to systemic therapy in selected patient populations (Figure 3). The goal of the therapy is to control tumour growth,
hypersecretion-related symptoms and prolong survival.
• Mitotane monotherapy. Mitotane is the only drug approved by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) in locally advanced inoperable and metastatic patients.
Response rates in metastatic ACC vary between 13% and 35% but much of these data are derived from retrospective series, including studies in 1960s with overall
variability in response criteria.
• Mitotane mono therapy is indicated in the management of patients with a low tumour burden and/or more indolent disease (i.e. patients with favourable
prognostic parameters). At disease progression, ChT with etoposide, doxorubicin and cisplatin (EDP) should be added to mitotane monotherapy [I, A].
• Cytotoxic ChT. The combination of EDP and mitotane (EDP-M) is recommended in first-line settings based on the FIRM-ACT trial results [I, A]
• In second-line settings, after failure of EDP-M, the treatment options are limited and enrolment of patients into clinical trials should be considered first. Most
patients with advanced ACC remain in good clinical condition but urgently seek therapy. In the absence of trials, possible options are the association of gemcitabine
plus capecitabine
• Surgery and local therapies. Surgery, including surgery of the primary tumour, may be recommended in all patients with oligometastatic ACC if a complete
resection of all tumoural lesions is feasible [V, B]. A cytoreductive resection may also be indicated in rare cases of severe symptomatic hormone excess, after
attempts to control the symptoms with a combination of fast-acting anti-secretory agents (i.e. metyrapone) and mitotane
• In case of a recurrence following ACC surgery, two critical questions must be addressed: (i) What is the time interval since the resection? and (ii) Did recurrence
occur during ongoing mitotane therapy (with effective blood levels)?
• If the disease-free interval is at least 12 months and another complete R0 resection/ablation seems feasible, then surgery or, alternatively, other local therapies
are clearly recommended [IV, A]. However, if this time interval is <6 months or if complete resection/ablation is not feasible, then, the EDP-M provides the
treatment of choice, especially if the recurrence occurred during ongoing mitotane treatment at therapeutic levels [IV, A].
• Management of hormone excess. In addition to sequelae of the malignant disease, patients with overt hypercortisolism suffer from immunosuppression, diabetes
and muscle weakness, which can significantly impact QoL. Similarly, severe androgen excess may dramatically impair well-being in women. Therefore, medical
therapy to control hormonal excess is recommended [V, A]. Mitotane is frequently able to diminish steroid excess, but its efficacy is often delayed by several weeks.
In these circumstances, steroidogenic enzyme inhibitors, such as metyrapone or ketoconazole, can be useful [V, B].
• Metyrapone is a well tolerated drug and its metabolism and elimination are not altered by concomitant mitotane. Therefore, it can be safely administered in
association with mitotane and cytotoxic ChT. Local therapies including liver embolisation may also be discussed. All patients with clinically overt hormone excess
should be managed by physicians experienced with these endocrine problems.
ESMO Recommendations ACC
LOCOREGIONAL
• Complete en bloc resection of all adrenal tumours suspected to be ACC by a
surgeon experienced in adrenal and oncological surgery is the mainstay of a
potentially curative approach. Open surgery is the standard treatment but in
tumours <6 cm without evidence of local invasion, laparoscopic adrenalectomy
is reasonable, if the surgeon has sufficient experience.
• Additionally,a locoregionallymphadenectomyissuggested.
• Perioperative hydrocortisone replacement is required in all patients with
autonomous cortisol secretion [V, A].
• Adjuvant mitotane is recommended in patients at high risk of recurrence (stage
III, or R1-RX resection, and/or Ki-67 index >10%) [IV, B].
• Adjuvant therapy has to be discussed on an individual basis in patients with
low risk of recurrence (stage I/II, R0 resection and Ki-67 index 10%) [V, B].
• Adjuvant RT is only suggested on an individualised basis (in addition to
mitotane) in patients with R1 or RX resection or in stage III [IV, B].
• After complete resection, radiological imaging every 3 months for 2 years, then
every 3-6 months for at least another 3 years is recommended [V, B].
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ADVANCED
• In most patients with metastatic ACC, first-line therapy with mitotane alone or
mitotane plus ChT is recommended; EDP-M is the first-line treatment of choice
[I, A].
• In selected patients (e.g. low tumour burden and/or more indolent disease),
mitotane monotherapy is reasonable.
• Surgery and locoregional therapies should be adopted in addition to systemic
therapy in selected patient populations.
• Surgery is the treatment of choice only if all tumoural lesions can be removed
[V, B].
• Local therapies (e.g. RT, RFA, cryoablation, microwave ablation,
chemoembolisation) are of value for therapy in advanced ACC, and an
individualised treatment approach is required
Adrenal Incidentaloma
PPGL-MANAGEMENT OF LOCOREGIONAL DISEASE
• As in ACC, the surgical excision of the tumour is the first line treatment of PPGLs. However, laparoscopic/ minimal invasive surgery is commonly the technique of first choice
for resection adrenal and extra-adrenal PPGLs [V, A], because local invasion is rare and the likelihood of rupture of the capsule seems less common than in ACC. It is obvious,
however, that the resection should be complete and if there is any risk that this cannot be achieved by laparoscopic surgery, an open approach should be carried out.
• In patients with PPGL, exposure to high levels of circulating catecholamines during surgery could cause hypertensive crises and arrhythmias. Therefore, all patients with
PPGL should receive preoperative preparation at least 10-14 days before surgery [V, A].5 Blood pressure targets for the treatment are <130/80 mmHg in the supine
position, and a systolic blood pressure preferably >90 mmHg in the upright position.
• The noncompetitive a-adrenoreceptor antagonist, phenoxybenzamine, is traditionally the most frequently used adrenergic blocking agent. A standard starting dose is 10 mg
twice daily with adjustments over the following days. Alternatively, doxazosin, a competitive and selective a1-adrenoreceptor antagonist, can be similarly effective. If the
target blood pressure is not reached, calcium antagonists (slow-release nifedipine) or metyrosine may be used. Blockade of b-adrenergic receptors is indicated in patients
developing tachyarrhythmias but should never be started before blockade of a-receptors. Beta blockers are not administered until adequate alpha blockade has been
established, because unopposed alpha-adrenergic receptor stimulation can precipitate a hypertensive crisis.
• Hypertensive crisis during surgery: such crises can be induced by other manipulations during surgical procedure (e.g. intubation, insufflation of peritoneum, direct
palpation of the PPGL) or administration of certain drugs (e.g. opioids, benzodiazepines). Therefore, it is strongly recommended that anaesthesia is supervised by an
experienced anaesthesiologist alert to the diagnosis of a catecholamine-producing tumour.
• Post-operative care should also focus on glucose levels because hypoglycaemia may occur after reduction of catecholamine levels.
• Cytoreductive debulking surgery (R2) in malignant phaeochromocytoma may improve QoL and survival by reducing tumour burden and controlling hormonal
hypersecretion [V, B]
• Despite a recurrence risk, there is no established indication of adjuvant treatment in PPGLs
FNA should be performed in any nodule (regardless of size) with the following suspicious sonographic features: :
• Subcapsular locations adjacent to the recurrent laryngeal nerve or trachea
• Extrathyroidal extension
• Extrusion through rim calcifications
• Associated with sonographically abnormal cervical lymph nodes
FNA should be performed in nodules ≥1 cm (as determined by largest dimension) if they are solid and
hypoechoic with one or more of these suspicious sonographic features:
• Irregular margins
• Microcalcifications
• Taller than wide shape
• Rim calcifications with extrusion of soft tissue
• FNA can be considered in selected patients with nodules <1 cm if there is a strong family history of thyroid
cancer, known syndromes associated with thyroid cancer, young age, a history of therapeutic childhood head
and neck or whole body radiation, or preference for FNA over observation. However, most patients with
suspicious subcentimeter nodules can be observed
Management of Thyroid Nodules
FNA technique — Tissue for histologic or cytologic examination may be obtained from the thyroid by several
different techniques, including cutting needle biopsy, large- or fine-needle aspiration, or fine-needle capillary
sampling. FNA biopsy is the most commonly used approach. A complete discussion of the techniques, their value
and limitations, and potential complications can be found elsewhere FNA is a simple and safe office procedure in
which tissue samples are obtained for cytologic examination using 23- to 27- gauge (commonly 25-gauge) needles
with or without local anesthesia. With experience, adequate samples can be obtained in 90 to 97 percent of
aspirations of solid nodules. Ultrasound-guided FNA biopsy can be performed for nonpalpable nodules and for
nodules that are technically difficult to aspirate using palpation methods alone, such as predominantly cystic or
posteriorly located nodules. In patients with large nodules (>4 cm), ultrasound-guided FNA directed at several
areas within the nodule may reduce the risk of a false-negative biopsy.
• Multiple nodules — Patients with multiple nodules have the same risk of malignancy as those with a single
nodule, although the risk of cancer in each individual nodule in a patient with multiple nodules is lower than the
risk of cancer in a nodule in a patient with only one nodule [19,35]. Thus, the sonographic features of each
nodule should be assessed independently to determine the need for FNA biopsy. If there are multiple coalescent
nodules and none have suspicious sonographic features, FNA biopsy of the largest nodule is reasonable [7]. The
nodules that are not biopsied should be monitored with periodic ultrasonography
• Thyroid scintigraphy — Thyroid scintigraphy is used to determine the functional status of a nodule. A subnormal serum TSH, indicating overt or subclinical hyperthyroidism,
increases the possibility that a thyroid nodule is hyperfunctioning. Since hyperfunctioning nodules rarely are cancer, a nodule that is hyperfunctioning on radioiodine imaging
does not require FNA. Radionuclide scanning is contraindicated during pregnancy. If a women is breastfeeding, breastfeeding should be held if a radionuclide scan is obtained.
The amount of time will depend on which isotope is used. Scintigraphy utilizes one of the radioisotopes of iodine (usually 123-I) or technetium-99m pertechnetate. Most
benign and virtually all malignant thyroid nodules concentrate both radioisotopes less avidly than adjacent normal thyroid tissue
• Nonfunctioning – Nonfunctioning nodules appear cold (uptake less than surrounding thyroid tissue) (image 1), and they may require further evaluation by FNA
• Autonomous – Autonomous nodules may appear hot (uptake is greater than surrounding thyroid tissue) (image 2) if they are hyperfunctioning. Autonomous nodules that do
not make sufficient thyroid hormone to suppress serum TSH concentrations will appear indeterminate on thyroid scintigraphy. Autonomous nodules account for only 5 to 10
percent of palpable nodules. Only a few patients with autonomous nodules have been found to have thyroid cancer [27-29], and only a few of these cancers were aggressive
[30]. Furthermore, in some of these patients, the cancer was adjacent to the autonomous nodule rather than within it. Since hyperfunctioning nodules rarely are cancer, a
nodule that is hyperfunctioning on radioiodine imaging does not require FNA.
• Indeterminate – Because scintigraphy is two dimensional, its limitations result from the superimposition of abnormal nodular tissue and normally functioning thyroid tissue.
Thus, while over 80 percent of nonautonomous nodules greater than 2 cm appear cold, smaller nodules present as a filling defect in less than one-third of cases [27]. The
remaining majority of smaller nodules are indeterminate on thyroid scintigraphy [31]. They could represent either small, nonfunctioning nodules anterior or posterior to
normally functioning thyroid tissue, or autonomous nodules that do not produce sufficient thyroid hormone to suppress TSH
• These indeterminate nodules should not be referred to as warm or functioning, since the majority are, in fact, nonfunctioning nodules. Indeterminate nodules on scintigraphy
should be evaluated by FNA if they meet sonographic criteria for sampling
Management of Thyroid Nodules
FNA cytology — There are six major categories of results that are obtained from fine-needle aspiration (FNA), each
of which indicates different subsequent management.
Nondiagnostic (Bethesda I) — A nondiagnostic biopsy is cytologically inadequate. It is critical that the absence of
malignant cells not be interpreted as a negative biopsy if no or scant follicular tissue is obtained. For patients with
nondiagnostic FNA biopsies, we repeat the FNA in approximately four to six weeks, using ultrasound guidance if not
used for the first FNA. In a study of patients with a nondiagnostic cytology specimen after a palpation FNA, repeating
the FNA under ultrasound guidance significantly improved the diagnostic yield for both solid and cystic nodules
Benign nodules (Bethesda II) — Patients with benign nodules (macrofollicular or adenomatoid/hyperplastic nodules,
colloid adenomas, nodular goiter, and Hashimoto's thyroiditis) are usually followed without surgery. There is still
controversy concerning the efficacy of T4 (levothyroxine) therapy for these patients. In the absence of a history of
childhood neck irradiation, patients with benign nodules should not be treated with T4. We perform periodic
ultrasound monitoring of benign thyroid nodules, initially at 12 to 24 months, then at increasing intervals over time
(eg, two to five years), with the shorter intervals for large nodules or nodules with worrisome ultrasound features
and the longer interval for smaller nodules with classic benign ultrasonographic features. We repeat the FNA within
12 months if the nodule has highly suspicious ultrasound features despite a benign biopsy. reassessment is
warranted when there is any of the following [7,46]:Substantial growth (more than a 50 percent change in volume
or 20 percent increase in nodule diameter with a minimum increase in two or more dimensions of at least 2
mm)Appearance of suspicious ultrasound features New symptoms are attributed to a nodule
Indeterminate nodules (Bethesda III) The risk of malignancy with these cytologic classifications ranges from 10 to 40 percent. Unless a sample for molecular testing was
saved at the time of the initial biopsy, a repeat FNA with a sample for molecular testing (if available) after a 6- to 12-week interval (or earlier) is indicated in most
patients with indeterminate cytology. If the TSH is subnormal (indicating overt or subclinical hyperthyroidism) and the nodule shows architectural atypia (FLUS or
follicular neoplasm), the possibility that the nodule is hyperfunctioning is increased, and thyroid scintigraphy should be obtained (if not previously performed) prior
to repeating the FNA. Since hyperfunctioning nodules rarely are cancer, a nodule that is hyperfunctioning on radioiodine imaging does not require repeat (or even
initial) FNA. Repeat FNA should be performed in patients with nonfunctioning nodules. If molecular testing is available (either at initial or subsequent FNA), further
management then depends on the results of molecular testing.
For patients with indeterminate FNA cytology who have a benign molecular pattern on molecular testing, we suggest observation
For patients with a suspicious molecular pattern using these techniques, diagnostic lobectomy or total thyroidectomy is indicated in most patients.
Neck US. Neck US is the most effective tool for detecting structural disease in the neck, particularly when remnants of normal thyroid tissue are present. Combined
with the results of FNA cytology [58] and serum Tg assays, neck US findings can achieve an accuracy of nearly 100% [59]. The shortcomings of US include substantial
operator dependency [60], a high frequency of non specific findings [61] and the possibility of unsatisfactory visualisation of deep structures and those acoustically
shadowed by bone or air
Other imaging studies. Other imaging studies should be ordered if locoregional and/or distant metastases are known to be present [IV, A] or suspected (based, for
example, on rising serum Tg or TgAb levels in the absence of sonographically identifiable neck disease or in patients with intermediate-to-high risks of
persistent/recurrent disease, irrespective of the neck US findings)
• A Whole Body Scan with gamma camera can be carried out after the administration of diagnostic or therapeutic doses of RAI. Because its sensitivity is low (27%—
55%), diagnostic WBS is not indicated during follow-up [IV, A] [64]. Uptake is highly specific (91%—100%) for the presence of thyroid tissue, but false-positive
results are possible. In these cases, single-photon emission computed tomography or computed tomography (CT) offers better anatomic resolution
• (FDG—PET) combined with CT is useful for assessing the extent of disease and defining the prognosis [65, 66]. Its sensitivity is around 94%, and specificity is
between 80% and 84%. FDG—PET is more sensitive than therapeutic WBS for detecting persistent disease in patients with negative cross-sectional imaging studies,
serum Tg levels >10 ng/dl, and/or aggressive histotypes (e.g. aggressive PTC, poorly differentiated TC, widely invasive follicular carcinoma)
• CT is best for neck and chest imaging. Contrast enhancement is used for studies of the neck and mediastinal lymph nodes but not for the lungs. All forms of RAI
treatment should be deferred for at least 6 weeks after administration of any iodinated contrast medium.
• Contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is appropriate for exploring the neck, liver, bones and brain [64]. MRI of the neck is subject to substantial
image degradation due to respiratory motion,and a CT scan is often a better alternative.
• Suspected aerodigestive-tract involvement should always be assessed endoscopically.
Follow-up strategies. All patients with DTC should have neck US and serum Tg and TgAb assays 6—18 months after primary treatment (surgery 6RAI therapy). The
subsequent follow-up schedule will depend on the initially estimated risk of persistent/recurrent disease and responses to therapy (Figure 3).
• PTC patients at low risk for recurrence who have no evidence of structural disease at the first follow-up visit can be monitored with periodic (12—24 months) Tg
and TgAb assessments. Repeat neck US scans can be carried out as needed, depending on serum Tg and TgAb levels
• Low- or intermediate-risk PTC patients with a biochemical incomplete or indeterminate response to treatment should have serum Tg and TgAb assays and a neck
US every 6—12 months. Rising Tg or TgAb levels warrant further imaging studies
• In patients with high-risk PTCs, poorly differentiated TCs or widely invasive FTCs, serum Tg and TgAb levels should be assessed every 6—12 months if the response
to therapy is excellent or biochemical indeterminate/incomplete. Cross-sectional or functional imaging studies should be repeated if detectable Tg levels persist [IV,
B]
Thyroid Cancer (ESMO)
Management of advanced/metastatic disease
Locoregional therapy
•Single lesions that are symptomatic or progressive may be eligible for locoregional treatments
(e.g. palliative surgery, EBRT, percutaneous therapies)
•Bone resorption inhibitors (bisphosphonates and denosumab) can be used alone or combined
with locoregional treatments in the management of thyroid cancer-related bone metastases [V,
B]
•There is limited evidence that conservative techniques (RFA, cryotherapy) are effective for
treating TC-related bone lesions [V, B]
•Metastasectomy is not the standard approach for lung metastases but it may be considered
for oligometastasis in patients with good PS [V, C]
•RFA is a possibility for solitary lung lesions or those causing a specific symptom due to their
volume and location [V, C]
•Invasion of the upper aerodigestive tract should always be excluded in TC patients with
locoregional disease
• Distant metastases occur in fewer than 10% of patients with DTC. Half are present when the tumour is first discovered; the others are found later, sometimes decades after initial treatment.
• Metastases are observed most frequently in patients with aggressive histological subtypes (e.g. tall-cell, hobnail, solid, diffuse sclerosing and columnar-cell variants): vascular invasion, large
primary tumours, macroscopic extrathyroidal extension, bulky locoregional nodal disease. The most common sites are lungs and bones (involved in 49% and 25% of all cases, respectively).
Bone metastases are more common in FTC than in PTC. The overall mortality rates 5 and 10 years after diagnosis of distant metastases are 65% and 75%,respectively
• One-third of patients have lesions that are not RAI-avid and are considered RAI-refractory. If the distant metastases are RAI-avid, 131I is administered every 6 months for 2 years and less
frequently thereafter. Between treatments, suppressive doses of levothyroxine are given to maintain serum TSH levels below 0.1 mIU/ml (unless there are specific contraindications) When
distant metastases lose their ability to concentrate RAI or structural progression occurs within 6—12 months after RAI administration, the disease is considered RAI-refractory
• Overall, one out of three patients with distant metastases will be cured with RAI and have a near-normal life expectancy
• Bone metastases: The relatively long survival perspective places TC patients with bone metastases at high risk of skeletal-related events (SREs), i.e. pathological fractures, spinal cord
compression, need for radiation (for pain or impending fracture) or surgery and hypercalcaemia. Up to 37% of TC patients experience SREs, and they are associated with poorer prognoses.
Recommended use of bone resorption inhibitors (bisphosphonates or denosumab) [V, B], external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) or other locoregional treatments in reducing SREs. If the
bone metastases are RAI-avid, RAI therapy may control the disease for some time and alleviate or delay symptoms, but it is unlikely to eliminate these lesions. Surgery followed by EBRT is
associated with the best outcomes, at least for limb lesions [88]. If surgery is not feasible, bone lesions associated with pain or a high fracture risk should be treated with fractionated (20 Gy
in five fractions or 30 Gy in 10 fractions) or single-fraction (8 Gy) EBRT and/or with interventional radiology techniques, including cementoplasty and thermal ablation
• Lung metastases: The lung is a common site of TC metastasis. The lesions are usually multiple, bilateral, of varying size (from a few millimetres to 1 cm) and asymptomatic. Metastasectomy is
not the standard approach for these lesions, but it may be considered for oligometastasis in patients with good performance status (PS) [V, C]. RFA is also a possibility for solitary lesions or
those causing a specific symptom due to their volume and location [V, C]. RFA is considered for lesions <2—3 cm in patients not eligible for surgery or those requiring an extensive resection
• Liver metastases: Liver metastases are rare in DTC but more common in MTC. Liver involvement usually presents with multiple lesions, but if true solitary lesions are detected, they may be
candidates for local ablation. In MTC patients with a dominant lesion that is growing more rapidly than the background disease, local ablation (e.g. RFA) may be useful for controlling
symptoms, systemic ones in particular, such as diarrhoea. The outcome of RFA will depend on the size of the lesion (optimally <30 mm), its location (at least 3 mm from all vessels) and its
visibility on US. If both surgery and RFA are contraindicated, hepatic intra-arterial embolisation with drug-eluting beads might be an option.
• Invasion of upper aerodigestive tract: Invasion of the upper aerodigestive tract should always be excluded in TC patients with locoregional disease. Suspicious symptoms
include haemoptysis and dysphagia. In selected cases (e.g. bleeding, exophytic lesions), local treatment (e.g. laser excision) is advisable before starting antiangiogenic
multikinase inhibitor (MKI) therapy
• Systemic therapy and personalised medicine. TSH suppression (serum level <0.1 lIU/ml) is recommended for all TC patients with persistent structural disease in the absence
of specific contraindications [III, B] [77]. Not all patients with RAI-refractory disease require systemic MKI therapy immediately. Lenvatinib and sorafenib should be considered
the standard first-line systemic therapy for progressive, metastatic, RAI-refractory DTC.
• Adverse Effects of MKIs: AEs occurred in 98.6% of patients receiving sorafenib during the DECISION trial [96]: hand—foot syndrome,diarrhoea, alopaecia, rash or
desquamation, fatigue, weight lossand hypertension were the most common. Serum TSH levels exceeding 0.5 mIU/ml were observed in 33.3% patients in the sorafenib arm.
TSH increases are a recognised AE of sorafenib and other MKIs, and levels should be checked monthly to ensure that suppression is maintained. 37.2% (77/207) of the
sorafenib-treated participants. Nine developed a second malignancy: squamous-cell skin cancer in seven cases (one patient also had melanoma), acute myeloid leukaemia and
bladder cancer in the remaining two cases. Skin cancer is a consequence of sorafenib’s paradoxical activation of mitogen-activated protein kinase signalling in keratinocytes
harbouring mutated or activated RAS.
Thyroid Cancer (ESMO)
ANAPLASTIC THYROID CANCER
• ATCs are very rare tumours that usually present at an advanced stage, display
extremely aggressive behaviour, and are associated with a very poor prognosis. They
are morphologically heteroge- neous and must be distinguished from other neck
tumours, including squamous carcinoma of the larynx, sarcomas and lymphomas.
Preoperative biopsy assessment includes diagnostic immunomarkers that can
differentiate ATC from large cell lymphoma or pleomorphic sarcoma. The molecular
profile of ATC includes mutations of the TERT promoter (associated with BRAF or RAS
mutations) and TP53 [21, 22], as well as targetable abnormalities (e.g. NTRK and ALK
rearrangements).
• In the eighth edition of the UICC TNM staging system [23], diagnosis of ATC is no
longer associated with pT4 stage by default. Cases treated with resection are staged
like other TC histotypes, based on tumour size and extension
• ATCs are considered one of the most aggressive solid tumours in humans. The median
survival after the initial diagnosis is 4 months and only one out of five patients
survives more than 12 months (1-year survival rates: 10%—20%). Long-term survival
has been reported, but the estimated rate at 10 years is <5%. The dismal prognosis
stems from the fact that over 40% of the patients present at diagnosis with large
primary tumours (mean size: 6 cm), gross extrathyroidal extension and locoregional
and distant metastases, which make complete resection unlikely
• Surgery. ATC is rarely amenable to complete resection (Figure 5). Total thyroidectomy
with bilateral central neck dissection may be carried out in those very rare cases of
localised ATC in M0 patients. Tracheostomy may be needed to alleviate symptoms in
patients with moderately progressive disease
• Radiotherapy. Optimal outcomes in terms of survival and local disease control in ATC
require complete or near-complete [no residual tumour (R0) or microscopic residual
tumour (R1)] resection followed by high-dose EBRT, with or without concomitant ChT .
• Palliative EBRT: In patients with unresectable disease, EBRT has a role in symptom
control [V, C] [133]. The aim is usually to reduce the rate of growth of the neck mass
and thereby the pressure symptoms.
• To date, cytotoxic ChT has been the primary treatment for metastatic disease, but it
is associated with very low response rates and significant toxicities [133].
Recommended regimens consist of single-agent therapy with paclitaxel or doxorubicin
or combined treatments (e.g. carboplatin/paclitaxel, docetaxel/doxorubicin)
administered weekly or every 3—4 weeks
• Patients with BRAF V600E-positive malignancies should be treated with the BRAF
inhibitor dabrafenib (150 mg twice daily) plus the MEK inhibitor trametinib (2 mg
once daily) if they are available [V, B
Thyroid Cancer (ESMO)
MEDULLARY THYROID CANCER
• MTC is morphologically heterogeneous and can mimic virtually all other primary
thyroid tumours. Demonstration of calcitonin (Ctn) expression is mandatory for
the diagnosis. Medullary thyroid cancer is a form of thyroid carcinoma which
originates from the parafollicular cells (C cells), which produce the hormone
calcitonin. Medullary tumors are the third most common of all thyroid cancers
and together make up about 3% of all thyroid cancer cases.
• Basal serum calcitonin concentrations usually correlate with tumor mass but also
reflect tumor differentiation, and they are almost always high in patients with a
palpable tumor [6]. Most MTCs also secrete carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA),
which, like calcitonin, can be used as a tumor marker [11,12]. In addition, the
expression of CEA on MTC cells has led to the use of anti-CEA antibodies for
immunotherapy. Rare primary Ctn-negative neuroendocrine carcinomas of the
thyroid exist and must be distinguished from metastases from neuroendocrine
neoplasms of the lung. In these cases, carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA)
determination can be useful, being the only neck tumour expressing this marker.
The preoperative diagnosis can also be challenging in the absence of a consistent
immunophenotype.
• RET and RAS proto-oncogene mutations are detected in 90% of MTCs and are
considered the predominant drivers of these tumours [141]. RET mutations occur
sporadically, as somatic events, or can be inherited as germline events associated
with familial MTC or the multiple endocrine neoplasia syndromes type 2A and 2B
(MEN2A and MEN2B). All patients with MTC should thus be offered genetic
counselling and be screened
• Ctn and CEA are valuable diagnostic, prognostic and predictive markers for use
with MTC. Their serum concentrations are directly related to the C-cell mass
• An analysis of 300 consecutive cases of MTC treated with total thyroidectomy and compartment oriented lymph node dissections found that preoperative serum Ctn levels <20 pg/ml (normal
reference range: <10 pg/ml) were associated with almost no risk of nodal metastases. Ctn levels exceeding 20 pg/ml were associated with nodal metastases to the ipsilateral compartments of
the neck (central and lateral); higher levels were associated with increasingly extensive locoregional spread (levels >50 pg/ml: nodes of the contra lateral central compartment of the neck;
levels >200 pg/ml: nodes of the contralateral lateral compartment; levels >500 pg/ ml: upper mediastinal nodes). Serum Ctn levels exceeding 500 pg/ml suggest distant metastatic disease and
should be explored with additional whole-body imaging procedures
• Serum Ctn should be measured 60—90 days after thyroidectomy
• Doubling times for postoperative serum Ctn and CEA levels (defined as the interval of time in which the tumour markers levels have doubled) are established prognostic markers in MTC [IV,
B] [148—150]. They are currently considered the best available predictors of tumour behaviour, recurrence and cancer related death. A Ctn doubling time exceeding 6 months is associated
with 5- and 10-year survival rates of 92% and 37%, respectively; shorter doubling times predict markedly worse survival (25% and 8% at 5 and 10 years, respectively)
• Preoperative screening for pheochromocytoma and hyperparathyroidism is highly recommended for all patients with MTC
Thyroid Cancer (ESMO)
MEDULLARY THYROID CANCER
• Neck US should be carried out to identify regional metastases;
• if sonographic (or clinical) findings are suspicious, contrast-enhanced CT of the neck and
chest is indicated.
• Work-up for distant metastases, including chest CT, liver and axial bone MRI and 6-fluoro-
(18F)-L-dihydroxyphenylalanine (FDOPA)-PET scan (if available), should be done if serum
Ctn levels exceed 500 pg/ml or clinical findings are suspicious.
• Neck dissection, when needed, should be done by surgeons with substantial experience
in TC surgery. The initial approach will depend on preoperative serum Ctn levels and neck
imaging findings
• For carriers of germline mutations, the recommended age for prophylactic total
thyroidectomy depends on the type of mutation.
• Individuals with germline M918T mutations should undergo total thyroidectomy within
the first year of life. For those with a C634F or A883F mutation (also considered high
risk), surgery can be postponed until age 5 unless Ctn levels increase. Those with other
mutations should be monitored from age 5 on with Ctn assays and neck US, and surgery
should be done if Ctn levels increase or if the parents request it .
Follow Up
• Ctn and CEA monitoring should both be included in the early and long-term
postoperative staging work-ups [IV, B] [150]. Serial measurements allow the calculation of
doubling times, which provide useful information as described above. Currently available
data indicate that Ctn doubling times should be based on at least four consecutive
measurements, preferably obtained over a 2-year period
• Contrast- enhanced whole-body (brain, neck, thorax, abdomen and pelvis) CT with ultra-
thin reconstructions is sensitive and specific enough to allow one to estimate the burden
of systemic disease and to assess and identify target lesions. As indolent tumours, MTCs
generally display low avidity for FDG, so FDG—PET—CT is not recommended for their
staging, but it can be useful for assessing advanced disease characterized by
dedifferentiation and rapid progression
• The systemic therapies currently approved for MTC have not been shown to improve OS,
so evidence-based guidance is lacking on when to start these drugs and how patients
with indolent disease should be followed. Decisions are based mainly on clinicians’
experience.
Systemic therapy and personalised medicine
•Cabozantinib [I, A] and vandetanib [I, A; ESMO-MCBS v1.1 score: 2] are the first-line systemic therapy for patients with progressive, metastatic MTC
•In patients with RETM918T or RAS-mutant MTCs, cabozantinib offers significant PFS and OS advantages over wild-type MTCs [II, C]
•There is little evidence to support the use of either ChT or radionuclide therapy in patients with MTC, although either might be considered whenMKIs are contraindicated