This process of symbolization, unfortunately, has too often resulted in such distortion of Hypatia's contributions: her mutilation in the streets of Alexandria has generated a continuing violence at the hands of numerous historians. From...
moreThis process of symbolization, unfortunately, has too often resulted in such distortion of Hypatia's contributions: her mutilation in the streets of Alexandria has generated a continuing violence at the hands of numerous historians. From the sixth-century writings of Damascius to more recent writers like Charles Kingsley, Edward Gibbon, and Carl Sagan, the tragedy of Hypatia's death has been used as an occasion for a miscreant euhemerization that falsifies historical fact, at best in the service of a larger narrative, at worst in the service of propaganda. These tendentious historians present Hypatia as a noble pagan martyr, a sacrificial virgin murdered at the instigation of Cyril, the evil Christian bishop of Alexandria, for her refusal to abandon the religion of the Greeks. She becomes the embodiment of Hellenism destroyed by the onslaught of mindless Christianity, the epitome of the end of the wisdom of the ancients. This rendering of Hypatia's death may be high drama, but it is poor history that does a disservice to Hypatia's real contributions and ignores the continuation of the Alexandrian philosophical tradition after her death. Examination of her significance must begin, therefore, with a refutation of this idealized portrait and then continue with a development of her life and work using more reliable historical sources as well as legitimate inferences that may be drawn from the intellectual and cultural context in which she lived. Unraveling Polemical Knots Attempts to use the death of Hypatia for polemical ends began with the work of the Athenian scholar Damascius, the last head of the Academy before it was closed by Justinian. He wrote in exile, as one of the last of the pagans, and was anxious to exploit the scandal of Hypatia's death. Consequently, he placed responsibility for her death in the hands of Cyril's men so that readers would picture her as the martyr of Hellenism, comparable to the heroized Emperor Julian, who had sought to restore paganism as the religion of the empire and was reportedly killed by a traitorous Christian (Lacombrade, 1978; Chuvin, 1990). But the death of Julian qualifies as "martyrdom" even less than does that of Hypatia. Damascius's views were influential in antiquity; they served as the basis of much of the information in the Byzantine lexicon-encyclopedia known as the Suda that The Beauty of Reasoning No handiwork of Callimachus, Who handled marble as if it were bronze, Made draperies that seemed to rise When sea-wind swept the corner, stands.