2006 Minnesota gubernatorial election

2006 Minnesota gubernatorial election

November 7, 2006

Nominee Tim Pawlenty Mike Hatch Peter Hutchinson Party Republican Democratic (DFL) Independence Running mate Carol Molnau Judi Dutcher Maureen Reed Popular vote 1,028,568 1,007,460 141,735 Percentage 46.69% 45.73% 6.43%

Pawlenty:      40–50%      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%      80–90%      >90% Hatch:      40–50%      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%      80–90%      >90% Tie:      40–50%      50%      No votes

Governor before election Tim Pawlenty Republican Elected Governor Tim Pawlenty Republican

The 2006 Minnesota gubernatorial election took place on November 7, 2006. Incumbent Tim Pawlenty was endorsed by the state Republican convention on June 2, 2006, while the state Democratic–Farmer–Labor convention endorsed Mike Hatch on June 10, 2006. The party primaries took place on September 12, 2006, with Hatch defeating DFL challengers Becky Lourey and Ole Savior and incumbent Pawlenty defeating Sue Jeffers. In the November 7 general election, Pawlenty received a plurality of the votes, defeating Hatch by a margin of 1%. As a result, this election was the closest race of the 2006 gubernatorial election cycle.

As of 2024, it is the last time a Republican won a statewide race in Minnesota.

Democratic–Farmer–Labor primary

Candidates

Declared

• Mike Hatch, 28th Minnesota Attorney General since 1999, former Minnesota Commissioner of Commerce (1983–89), and former State Party Chair of the Minnesota Democratic–Farmer–Labor Party (1980–83). Hatch received the strongest support of all candidates in the statewide caucus straw poll, and continued to hold his lead into the party convention, in which he received the endorsement after seven ballots. Hatch's running mate was 18th Minnesota State Auditor (since 1995) Judi Dutcher.
• Becky Lourey, State Senator from senate district 8 since 1997, former State Representative from legislative districts 8B (1993–97) and 14B (1991–93), businesswoman, activist, and homemaker. Lourey lost the DFL endorsement race to Mike Hatch, but continued to seek the DFL nomination in the primary election. Her running mate was businessman, former NFL defensive back (1976–79), and former Minneapolis Planning Commission member (1992–2001) Tim Baylor.
• Ole Savior, artist and perennial candidate. At the DFL state convention, Savior was eliminated on the first ballot for the party endorsement, after winning just one vote out of 1,500, but he continued to seek the nomination in the primary. Savior's running mate was Dan Fischer.

Withdrawn

• Kelly Doran, real estate developer. Doran withdrew his candidacy on March 24, 2006.
• Steve Kelley, State Senator from senate district 44 since 1997, former State Representative from legislative district 44A (1993–97), and attorney. Kelley withdrew his candidacy on June 10, 2006, after failing to defeat Hatch in the endorsement fight, throwing his support behind Hatch's campaign.
• Bud Philbrook, former State Representative from legislative district 48B (1975–77), non-profit executive director, and attorney. Philbrook withdrew his candidacy on October 24, 2005.

Results

Democratic–Farmer–Labor gubernatorial primary election, 2006

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Democratic (DFL)	Mike Hatch	231,643	73.20
	Democratic (DFL)	Becky Lourey	77,430	24.47
	Democratic (DFL)	Ole Savior	7,397	2.34
Total votes			316,470	100.00

Independence primary

Candidates

• Pam Ellison, 2000 congressional candidate, former gubernatorial aide, and consultant. Ellison's running mate was Kari Johnson.
• Peter Hutchinson, former Minnesota Commissioner of Finance (1989–91), former Superintendent of Minneapolis Public Schools (1993–97), and consultant. Hutchinson won the Independence Party straw poll in March, and was endorsed at the June 24 convention. Hutchinson's running mate was physician and former University of Minnesota Board of Regents member (1997–2005) and chair (2001–03) Maureen Reed.

Results

Independence gubernatorial primary election, 2006

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Independence	Peter Hutchinson	7,725	66.09
	Independence	Pam Ellison	3,964	33.91
Total votes			11,689	100.00

Republican primary

Candidates

• Sue Jeffers, Minneapolis bar owner and noted opponent of smoking bans and non-public use of eminent domain. A self-described Libertarian Republican, Jeffers was also endorsed by the Libertarian Party (which later withdrew its endorsement, as Minnesota law does not allow fusion candidates) and the Minnesota and National chapters of the Republican Liberty Caucus. Though included in neither the statewide caucus straw poll nor the party endorsement process, Jeffers challenged Governor Pawlenty for the Republican nomination in the September primary. Her running mate was Ruth Hendrycks.
• Tim Pawlenty, incumbent 39th Governor of Minnesota since 2003, former Majority Leader of the Minnesota House of Representatives (1999–2003), former State Representative from legislative district 38B (1993–2003), former Eagan City Councilor (1989–93), former member of the Eagan Planning Commission, attorney, and businessman. Pawlenty was endorsed by the state Republican party after winning the first ballot, unopposed. His running mate was incumbent 46th Lieutenant Governor of Minnesota (since 2003) Carol Molnau.

Results

Republican gubernatorial primary election, 2006

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	Tim Pawlenty (incumbent)	147,622	88.87
	Republican	Sue Jeffers	18,490	11.13
Total votes			166,112	100.00

Other candidates

Nominated by petition

• Walt E. Brown (Independent; used the ballot designation "Quit Raising Taxes"). Brown's running mate was Wesley C. Nelson.
• Leslie Davis (American). Davis's running mate was Gregory K. Soderberg.
• Ken Pentel (Green). Pentel's running mate was Danene Provencher.

Former candidates

• Jonathon "The Impaler" Sharkey (VWP) – Self-proclaimed vampire. Sharkey's campaign was jeopardized on January 30, 2006, when he was arrested in Princeton, Minnesota on felony charges stemming from allegations of stalking and flight, in Indiana. Sharkey's campaign website was taken down. It was discovered that the stalking charge had been dismissed on September 29, 2003, when Sharkey pleaded guilty to two counts of invasion of privacy and was ordered to submit to mental health treatment. At his trial on July 18, 2006, he was found not guilty of the felony escape charge. Nevertheless, Sharkey's arrest and jailing effectively terminated his campaign.

General election

On November 7, 2006, Tim Pawlenty narrowly won the general election, 46.7% to 45.7%, in a four-way race between himself, DFL candidate Mike Hatch, Independence Party candidate Peter Hutchinson, and Green Party candidate Ken Pentel. After Pawlenty opted out of spending limits, Hatch followed suit. Outspending Hatch by $1 million, Pawlenty's campaign set a new spending record for a Minnesota gubernatorial campaign. The race was also affected by negative advertising by 527 groups, as well as issue-oriented groups opposing liberal causes in the state.

A major issue in the campaign that was considered to have hurt the DFL nominees was lieutenant gubernatorial candidate Judi Dutcher's response to a question about E-85. When asked about the impact of the gasoline alternative on the economies of rural Minnesota by then KSAX-TV anchor Corey Poppe, Dutcher was unable to comment, asking Poppe to define E-85. In the subsequent questioning about her response, gubernatorial candidate Mike Hatch reportedly called a Forum Communications reporter "a Republican whore" and promptly hung up the phone. Hatch claimed he had said "hack", not "whore", but the incident, occurring only three days before the last poll listed in this article, is believed to have swung the race. It put Hatch on the defensive in the campaign's last week.

Additionally, Pawlenty made illegal immigration an issue, running ads accusing Hatch of trying to give illegal immigrants college tuition. Hatch responded with an ad saying that illegal immigration laws had not been enforced under Pawlenty's tenure. Pawlenty also ran ads accusing Hatch of being responsible for raising health care costs, a claim Hatch disputed. Pawlenty campaigned on a record of leading the state through hard times, balancing record budget deficits without raising major state tax rates or diminishing the state's "nation-leading" status on most socioeconomic indicators.

Pawlenty won by piling up large margins in suburban counties as well as in central and southern Minnesota regions anchored by St. Cloud and Rochester. In his victory speech, noting that he would have to deal with a DFL House and Senate, Pawlenty said it was "a time tonight to be humble and time to be grateful." He promised that "the next four years are going to be different than the last four years" and that he would build "a common agenda" with DFLers who swept legislative and constitutional offices.

Hatch ran ahead in Minneapolis, St. Paul and their inner-ring suburbs, and won by large margins around Duluth and the Iron Range. In his concession speech, Hatch advocated that legislators get back to "sitting down and getting to know each other in private" to establish common ground for bipartisan legislation, and called for an end to partisan rancor. Had the Hatch/Dutcher ticket been successful, he stated that this would have been one of his administration's first goals.

Predictions

Source	Ranking	As of
The Cook Political Report	Tossup	November 6, 2006
Sabato's Crystal Ball	Tilt D (flip)	November 6, 2006
Rothenberg Political Report	Tossup	November 2, 2006
Real Clear Politics	Tossup	November 6, 2006

Polling

Two-way

Source	Date	Mike Hatch (DFL)	Tim Pawlenty (R)	Undecided
University of Minnesota	October 28, 2006	45%	39%	7%
Mason-Dixon	October 27, 2006	44%	43%	7%
St. Cloud State University	October 27, 2006	46%	36%	7%
Rasmussen	October 25, 2006	45%	44%	2%
Zogby/WSJ	October 19, 2006	45%	45%
Rasmussen	October 4, 2006	50%	46%	2%
Zogby/WSJ	September 11, 2006	42%	41%
Gallup	September 5, 2006	44%	43%
Zogby/WSJ	July 24, 2006	43%	43%
Star Tribune Minnesota Poll	July 15, 2006	41%	43%
Rasmussen	June 30, 2006	47%	42%
Zogby/WSJ	June 21, 2006	40%	45%
Rasmussen	May 10, 2006	49%	39%
Rasmussen	February 28, 2006	45%	40%
Rasmussen	January 29, 2006	44%	47%

Three-way

Source	Date	Mike Hatch (DFL)	Tim Pawlenty (R)	Peter Hutchinson (IP)	Undecided
Star Tribune Minnesota Poll	November 4, 2006	45%	40%	7%	7%
Star Tribune Minnesota Poll	October 14, 2006	46%	37%	7%	6%
Survey USA	September 28, 2006	44%	45%	6%	3%
Pioneer Press/MPR Poll	September 22, 2006	39%	42%	5%	11%
The Humphrey Institute	September 21, 2006	44%	42%	6%	5%
Star Tribune Minnesota Poll	September 16, 2006	42%	42%	7%	5%
Rasmussen	September 1, 2006	39%	45%	7%
Zogby/WSJ	August 28, 2006	43%	41%	5–9%
Rasmussen	August 7, 2006	36%	46%	6%
Survey USA	July 24, 2006	36%	50%	8%

Debate & forum

2006 Minnesota gubernatorial election debate & candidate forum

No.	Date	Host	Moderator	Link	Republican	DFL	Independence
Key:  P  Participant   A  Absent   N  Not invited   I  Invited  W  Withdrawn
					Tim Pawlenty	Mike Hatch	Peter Hutchinson
1	Oct. 29, 2006	KSTP-TV League of Women Voters Minnesota Education Fund	Tom Hauser		P	P	P
2	Nov. 3, 2006	Almanac WCCO (AM)	Eric Eskola Cathy Wurzer	C-SPAN	P	P	P

Results

County Results for the Independence Party:

Hutchinson

•      <4%%
•      4-5%
•      5-6%
•      6-7%
•      7-8%
•      8%<

Minnesota gubernatorial election, 2006

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	Tim Pawlenty (incumbent)	1,028,568	46.69
	Democratic (DFL)	Mike Hatch	1,007,460	45.73
	Independence	Peter Hutchinson	141,735	6.43
	Green	Ken Pentel	10,800	0.49
	Independent	Walt E. Brown	9,649	0.44
	American	Leslie Davis	3,776	0.17
	Write-in		949	0.04
Total votes			2,202,937	100.00
	Republican hold

Counties that flipped from Republican to Democratic

• Blue Earth (Largest city: Mankato)
• Clay (Largest city: Moorhead)
• Grant (Largest city: Elbow Lake)
• Aitkin (largest city: Aitkin)
• Pine (largest city: Pine City)
• Rice (largest city: Faribault)
• Winona (largest city: Winona)

Counties that flipped from Independence to Republican

• Dodge (Largest city: Kasson)
• Faribault (Largest city: Blue Earth)
• Waseca (Largest city: Waseca)
• Olmsted (largest city: Rochester)

Counties that flipped from Democratic to Republican

• Yellow Medicine (Largest city: Granite Falls)
• Lake of the Woods (Largest city: Baudette)

Counties that flipped from Independence to Democratic

• Fillmore (largest city: Spring Valley)
• Freeborn (largest city: Albert Lea)
• Mower (largest city: Austin)

See also

• U.S. gubernatorial elections, 2006
• List of Minnesota gubernatorial elections

External links

Campaign Websites (Archived)

• Kelly Doran for Governor
• Mike Hatch for Governor
• Pam Ellison for Governor
• Peter Hutchinson for Governor
• Sue Jeffers for Governor
• Steve Kelley for Governor
• Becky Lourey for Governor
• Tim Pawlenty for Governor
• Jonathon "The Impaler" Sharkey for Governor

Other

• Minnesota Governor Candidates Directory and E-Debate- from E-Democracy.Org