Operational risk management

See also: Risk management

Operational risk management (ORM) is defined as a continual recurring process that includes risk assessment, risk decision making, and the implementation of risk controls, resulting in the acceptance, mitigation, or avoidance of risk.

ORM is the oversight of operational risk, including the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes and systems; human factors; or external events. Unlike other type of risks (market risk, credit risk, etc.) operational risk had rarely been considered strategically significant by senior management.

Four principles

The U.S. Department of Defense summarizes the principles of ORM as follows:

• Accept risk when benefits outweigh the cost.
• Accept no unnecessary risk.
• Anticipate and manage risk by planning.
• Make risk decisions in the right time at the right level.

Three levels

In Depth

In depth risk management is used before a project is implemented, when there is plenty of time to plan and prepare. Examples of in depth methods include training, drafting instructions and requirements, and acquiring personal protective equipment.

Deliberate

Deliberate risk management is used at routine periods through the implementation of a project or process. Examples include quality assurance, on-the-job training, safety briefs, performance reviews, and safety checks.

Time Critical

Time critical risk management is used during operational exercises or execution of tasks. It is defined as the effective use of all available resources by individuals, crews, and teams to safely and effectively accomplish the mission or task using risk management concepts when time and resources are limited. Examples of tools used includes execution check-lists and change management. This requires a high degree of situational awareness.

Process

The International Organization for Standardization defines the risk management process in a four-step model:

1. Establish context
2. Risk assessment
   • Risk identification
   • Risk analysis
   • Risk evaluation
3. Risk treatment
4. Monitor and review

This process is cyclic as any changes to the situation (such as operating environment or needs of the unit) requires re-evaluation per step one.

Deliberate

Link between deliberate and time critical ORM process

The U.S. Department of Defense summarizes the deliberate level of ORM process in a five-step model:

1. Identify hazards
2. Assess hazards
3. Make risk decisions
4. Implement controls
5. Supervise (and watch for changes)

Time critical

The U.S. Navy summarizes the time-critical risk management process in a four-step model:

1. Assess the situation.

The three conditions of the Assess step are task loading, additive conditions, and human factors.

• Task loading refers to the negative effect of increased tasking on performance of the tasks.
• Additive factors refers to having a situational awareness of the cumulative effect of variables (conditions, etc.).
• Human factors refers to the limitations of the ability of the human body and mind to adapt to the work environment (e.g. stress, fatigue, impairment, lapses of attention, confusion, and willful violations of regulations).

2. Balance your resources.

This refers to balancing resources in three different ways:

• Balancing resources and options available. This means evaluating and leveraging all the informational, labor, equipment, and material resources available.
• Balancing Resources versus hazards. This means estimating how well prepared you are to safely accomplish a task and making a judgement call.
• Balancing individual versus team effort. This means observing individual risk warning signs. It also means observing how well the team is communicating, knows the roles that each member is supposed to play, and the stress level and participation level of each team member.

3. Communicate risks and intentions.

• Communicate hazards and intentions.
• Communicate to the right people.
• Use the right communication style. Asking questions is a technique to opening the lines of communication. A direct and forceful style of communication gets a specific result from a specific situation.

4. Do and debrief. (Take action and monitor for change.)

This is accomplished in three different phases:

• Mission Completion is a point where the exercise can be evaluated and reviewed in full.
• Execute and Gauge Risk involves managing change and risk while an exercise is in progress.
• Future Performance Improvements refers to preparing a "lessons learned" for the next team that plans or executes a task.

Benefits

Operational Risk Management (ORM) is not just a compliance requirement; it’s a foundation of business strategy that ensures long-term success. Implementing an effective operational risk management framework offers many benefits for businesses including,

• Enhanced decision making,
• Improved regulatory compliance
• Increased operational efficiency
• Protection of reputation, and
• Financial stability

The integration of operational risk management processes helps companies realize significant benefits, such as developing intellectual capital and management techniques that can be applied across various branches to mitigate crises and solve operational problems.

Chief Operational Risk Officer

The role of the Chief Operational Risk Officer (CORO) continues to evolve and gain importance. In addition to being responsible for setting up a robust Operational Risk Management function at companies, the role also plays an important part in increasing awareness of the benefits of sound operational risk management.

Most complex financial institutions have a Chief Operational Risk Officer. The position is also required for Banks that fall into the Basel II Advanced Measurement Approach "mandatory" category.

Software

The impact of the Enron failure and the implementation of the Sarbanes–Oxley Act has caused several software development companies to create enterprise-wide software packages to manage risk. These software systems allow the financial audit to be executed at lower cost.

Forrester Research has identified 115 Governance, Risk and Compliance vendors that cover operational risk management projects. Active Agenda is an open source project dedicated to operational risk management.

See also

• Basel II
• Benefit risk
• Cost risk
• Data governance
• Fuel price risk management
• Futures techniques
• Key risk indicator (KRI)
• Operational risk
• Optimism bias
• Risk
• Risk management
• Risk management tools
• Solvency II
• Tactical Risk Management
• Three lines of defence

References

General

• OPNAVINST 3500.39C OPERATIONAL RISK MANAGEMENT (ORM)
• MARINE CORPS ORDER 3500.27B OPERATIONAL RISK MANAGEMENT (ORM)

External links

• The Institute of Operational Risk The institute provides professional recognition and enables members to maintain competency in the discipline of operational risk.
• Operational Risk Institute An association of operational risk training professionals that renders key training on Op Risk related subjects including Business Continuity.
• Operational Risk Management of U.S. Insurers How well do you understand operational Risk Management.