Shepard's Citations

Shepard's Citations is a citator used in United States legal research that provides a list of all the authorities citing a particular case, statute, or other legal authority.^[1] The verb Shepardizing (sometimes written lower-case) refers to the process of consulting Shepard's to see if a case has been overturned, reaffirmed, questioned, or cited by later cases.^[1] Prior to the development of electronic citators like Westlaw's KeyCite during the 1990s, Shepard's was the only legal citation service that attempted to provide comprehensive coverage of U.S. law.^[1]

History

The name derives from a legal service begun by Frank Shepard (1848–1900) in 1873, when Shepard began publishing these lists in a series of books indexed to different jurisdictions.^[1] Initially, the product was called Shepard's Adhesive Annotations. The citations were printed on gummed, perforated sheets, which could be divided and pasted onto pages of case law. Known as "stickers", these were literally torn to bits and stuck to pertinent margins of case reporters.

By the early 20th century, the Frank Shepard Company was binding the citations into maroon volumes with Shepard's Citations stamped in gold on their spines, much like the ones still found on library shelves.^[2]

Under the leadership of William Guthrie Packard, the company endured the Great Depression and continued to grow. It moved to Colorado Springs in 1948; in 1951, it adopted the name Shepard's Citations, Inc.^[3] In 1966, Shepard's Citations was acquired by McGraw Hill.^[4]

In 1996, Shepard's was purchased by Times Mirror and Reed Elsevier (owner of LexisNexis since 1994).^[5] In 1998, LexisNexis bought full ownership of Shepard's.^[6] After this acquisition, LexisNexis engaged in a "multi-million-dollar Citations Redesign (CR) project" that "redesigned the way we process case law and citations".^[2]

Decline of print usage

In March 1999, LexisNexis released an online version, named Shepard's Citation Service.^[7] While print versions of Shepard's remain in use, their use is declining. Although learning to Shepardize in print was once a rite of passage for all first-year law students,^[2] the Shepard's Citations booklets in hardcopy format are cryptic compared to the online version, because of the need to cram as much information about as many cases in as little space as possible.^[1]

Shepard's in paper format consists of long tables of citations (with full case titles omitted) preceded by one or two-letter codes indicating their relationship to the case being Shepardized.^[8]^[9] Before computer-assisted legal research became widely available, generations of lawyers (and law clerks and assistants) had to manually locate the Shepard's entry for a case, decipher all the cryptic abbreviations, then manually retrieve all the cases that were marked by Shepard's as criticizing or overruling a particular case, to determine whether the later cases had directly overruled that particular case on the specific holding of interest to one's client.^[1] In many jurisdictions in the U.S., it is still possible to cite a case as good law even though it has been overruled, as long as it was overruled on another holding and not the specific holding for which it is being cited.

In 2004, market research by LexisNexis indicated that most attorneys and librarians conduct the majority of their research online, but "that there are a number of experienced attorneys, principally in smaller firms, who still prefer print and who are extremely unlikely to change their ways".^[2]

The American textbook Fundamentals of Legal Research formerly included a lengthy illustrated explanation of how to use Shepard's in print, but in the 10th edition released in 2015, that section was replaced with a brief explanation that such "detail is unnecessary for the many researchers who have access to one or more online citators".^[10] It was followed by a recommendation that researchers without access to an online citator should telephone or email LexisNexis directly for assistance.^[10]

Online

LexisNexis and Lexis Advance database users can Shepardize most citations online; cases are displayed with a text link to Shepardize the case and usually also have an icon indicating the status of the case as citable authority.^[1] Either the text link or the icon, when clicked or activated, will bring up a full Shepard's report for the case.

The Shepard's report indicates exactly how later cases cited the case being Shepardized with plain English phrases like "followed by" or "overruled" rather than by using the old abbreviations.^[1] Additionally, the report shows the full case title (that is, the names of the plaintiff and defendant) and full citation for each of the later cases. This is important because lawyers can usually distinguish criminal from civil cases by looking at the title. Criminal cases (with the exception of habeas corpus cases) are always titled U.S. v. [defendant], People v. [defendant], or State v. [defendant]. Often, a criminal case may cite a civil case for a point of law which a civil litigator does not care about, and vice versa.

Finally, the online report has the convenience of allowing the user to simply click on the hyperlink for any listed case to retrieve it almost instantly (if it is within the user's access plan), whereas users of Shepard's print version had to dash through long law library aisles to retrieve heavy legal reporter volumes, one for each case (and then someone had to put all those volumes back).

While most citations can be Shepardized online, there are some sources that are only Shepardizable in the print Shepard's Citations volumes. Most significant among these are the uncodified United States Statutes at Large, which are treated in the print publication Shepard's Federal Statute Citations but are not Shepardizable online. There are other more specialized sources not as widely used as the Statutes at Large that are included in print Shepard's Citations publications, but not included in the online service.

Influences upon Science Citation Index and Google

In 1960, Eugene Garfield developed Science Citation Index (SCI), which he later expressly acknowledged was heavily influenced in several ways by Shepard's Citations. SCI indexes scientific journal articles, and shows what other articles they have been cited by. SCI also counts the number of citations each article gets, thus forming a citation index of the most-cited articles and journals.^[11] In turn, SCI inspired several other scientists to research the possibility of developing superior citation indexes. Examples are the eigenvalue-based method developed by Gabriel Pinski and Francis Narin in 1976 and the PageRank link analysis algorithm using the similar idea created by Sergei Brin and Larry Page, which became the heart of the Google search engine.^[12]

References

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h Mersky, Roy M.; Dunn, Donald J. (2002). Fundamentals of Legal Research (8th ed.). New York: Foundation Press. pp. 312–340. ISBN 9781587780646.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Morris, Jane W. (May 2004). "The Future of Shepard's Citations in Print" (PDF). The Newsletter on the Committee of Relations with Information Vendors. Vol. 26, no. 3. American Association of Law Librarians. p. 3.
^ "Appeal of P.S. Docket No. 1/88e". United States Postal Service. Archived from the original on June 6, 2011.
^ "The McGraw-Hill Companies Timeline". Retrieved August 23, 2014.
^ Lee, Patrick (July 4, 1996). "Times Mirror to Boost Its Legal Publishing Unit with Shepard's". Los Angeles Times. ISSN 0458-3035. Retrieved August 23, 2014.
^ Barringer, Felicity (July 28, 1998). "The Media Business: Times Mirror Sells Legal Unit to British–Dutch Publisher". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved August 23, 2014.
^ Rebollo, Robyn (August 31, 1999). "One More Look at Shepard's Citation Service: A Private Law Librarian's Perspective". LLRX: Law and Technology Resources for Legal Professionals.
^ Putman, William H.; Albright, Jennifer R. (2014). Legal Research (3rd ed.). Stamford, Connecticut: Cengage Learning. p. 221. ISBN 9781305147188. Retrieved 14 December 2020.
^ Bouchoux, Deborah E. (2020). Legal Research Explained (5th ed.). New York: Wolters Kluwer. p. 374. ISBN 9781543801644.
^ ^a ^b Barkan, Steven M.; Bintliff, Barbara A.; Whisner, Mary (2015). Fundamentals of Legal Research (10th ed.). St. Paul, Minnesota: Foundation Press. p. 321. ISBN 9781609300562.
^ "Discovering Shepard's Citations". Web of Stories. Interview with Eugene Garfield.
^ "Hypersearching the Web". Scientific American. June 1999 – via Cornell University.

External links

Illustration of how to use the index from the University of Delaware library

[Mersky-1] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h Mersky, Roy M.; Dunn, Donald J. (2002). Fundamentals of Legal Research (8th ed.). New York: Foundation Press. pp. 312–340. ISBN 9781587780646.

[Lexis-2] Morris, Jane W. (May 2004). "The Future of Shepard's Citations in Print" (PDF). The Newsletter on the Committee of Relations with Information Vendors. Vol. 26, no. 3. American Association of Law Librarians. p. 3.

[3] "Appeal of P.S. Docket No. 1/88e". United States Postal Service. Archived from the original on June 6, 2011.

[4] "The McGraw-Hill Companies Timeline". Retrieved August 23, 2014.

[5] Lee, Patrick (July 4, 1996). "Times Mirror to Boost Its Legal Publishing Unit with Shepard's". Los Angeles Times. ISSN 0458-3035. Retrieved August 23, 2014.

[6] Barringer, Felicity (July 28, 1998). "The Media Business: Times Mirror Sells Legal Unit to British–Dutch Publisher". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved August 23, 2014.

[OneMoreLook-7] Rebollo, Robyn (August 31, 1999). "One More Look at Shepard's Citation Service: A Private Law Librarian's Perspective". LLRX: Law and Technology Resources for Legal Professionals.

[Putman-8] Putman, William H.; Albright, Jennifer R. (2014). Legal Research (3rd ed.). Stamford, Connecticut: Cengage Learning. p. 221. ISBN 9781305147188. Retrieved 14 December 2020.

[Bouchoux_Page_374-9] Bouchoux, Deborah E. (2020). Legal Research Explained (5th ed.). New York: Wolters Kluwer. p. 374. ISBN 9781543801644.

[BarkanPage321-10] Barkan, Steven M.; Bintliff, Barbara A.; Whisner, Mary (2015). Fundamentals of Legal Research (10th ed.). St. Paul, Minnesota: Foundation Press. p. 321. ISBN 9781609300562.

[11] "Discovering Shepard's Citations". Web of Stories. Interview with Eugene Garfield.

[12] "Hypersearching the Web". Scientific American. June 1999 – via Cornell University.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]