Sidney Lumet(1924-2011)
- Director
- Writer
- Producer
Sidney Lumet was a master of cinema, best known for his technical
knowledge and his skill at getting first-rate performances from his
actors -- and for shooting most of his films in his beloved New York.
He made over 40 movies, often complex and emotional, but seldom overly
sentimental. Although his politics were somewhat left-leaning and he
often treated socially relevant themes in his films, Lumet didn't want
to make political movies in the first place. Born on June 25, 1924, in
Philadelphia, the son of actor Baruch Lumet
and dancer Eugenia Wermus Lumet, he made his stage debut at age four at
the Yiddish Art Theater in New York. He played many roles on Broadway
in the 1930s and also in the film
...One Third of a Nation... (1939).
After starting an off-Broadway acting troupe in the late 1940s, he
became the director of many television shows in the 1950s. Lumet made
his feature film directing debut with
12 Angry Men (1957), which won the
Golden Bear at the Berlin Film Festival and earned three Academy Award
nominations. The courtroom drama, which takes place almost entirely in
a jury room, is justly regarded as one of the most auspicious
directorial debuts in film history. Lumet got the chance to direct
Marlon Brando in
The Fugitive Kind (1960), an
imperfect, but powerful adaptation of
Tennessee Williams' "Orpheus
Descending". The first half of the 1960s was one of Lumet's most
artistically successful periods.
Long Day's Journey Into Night (1962),
a masterful, brilliantly photographed adaptation of the Eugene O'Neill
play, is one of several Lumet films about families. It earned
Katharine Hepburn,
Ralph Richardson,
Dean Stockwell and
Jason Robards deserved acting awards in
Cannes and Hepburn an Oscar nomination. The alarming Cold War thriller
Fail Safe (1964) unfairly suffered from
comparison to Stanley Kubrick's
equally great satire
Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (1964),
which was released shortly before.
The Pawnbroker (1964), arguably
the most outstanding of the great movies Lumet made in this phase,
tells the story of a Holocaust survivor who lives in New York and can't
overcome his experiences in the Nazi concentration camps.
Rod Steiger's unforgettable performance in
the title role earned an Academy Award nomination. Lumet's intense
character study The Hill (1965) about
inhumanity in a military prison camp was the first of five films he did
with Sean Connery. After the overly talky
but rewarding drama The Group (1966)
about young upper-class women in the 1930s, and the stylish spy
thriller
The Deadly Affair (1967), the
late 1960s turned out to be a lesser phase in Lumet's career. He had a
strong comeback with the box-office hit
The Anderson Tapes (1971).
The Offence (1973) was commercially
less successful, but artistically brilliant - with Connery in one of
his most impressive performances. The terrific cop thriller
Serpico (1973), the first of his films
about police corruption in New York City, became one of his biggest
critical and financial successes. Al Pacino's
fascinating portrayal of the real-life cop Frank Serpico earned a
Golden Globe and the movie earned two Academy Award nominations (it is
worth noting that Lumet's feature films of the 1970s alone earned 30
Oscar nominations, winning six times). The love triangle
Lovin' Molly (1974) was not always
convincing in its atmospheric details, but Lumet's fine sense of
emotional truth and a good Blythe Danner
keep it interesting. The adaptation of
Agatha Christie's
Murder on the Orient Express (1974),
an exquisitely photographed murder mystery with an all-star cast, was a
big success again. Lumet's complex crime thriller
Dog Day Afternoon (1975), which
Pauline Kael called "one of the best "New
York" movies ever made", gave Al Pacino the
opportunity for a breathtaking, three-dimensional portrayal of a
bisexual man who tries to rob a bank to finance his lover's sex-change
operation. Lumet's next masterpiece,
Network (1976), was a prophetic satire on
media and society. The film version of
Peter Shaffer's stage play
Equus (1977) about a doctor and his
mentally confused patient was also powerful, not least because of the
energetic acting by
Richard Burton and
Peter Firth. After the enjoyable
musical The Wiz (1978) and the
interesting but not easily accessible comedy
Just Tell Me What You Want (1980),
Sidney Lumet won the New York Film Critics Circle Award for his
outstanding direction of
Prince of the City (1981), one
of his best and most typical films. It's about police corruption, but
hardly a remake of Serpico (1973).
Starring a powerful Treat Williams, it's
an extraordinarily multi-layered film. In his highly informative book
"Making Movies" (1995), Lumet describes the film in the following way:
"When we try to control everything, everything winds up controlling us.
Nothing is what it seems." It's also a movie about values, friendship
and drug addiction and, like "Serpico", is based on a true story. In
Deathtrap (1982), Lumet successfully
blended suspense and black humor.
The Verdict (1982) was voted the
fourth greatest courtroom drama of all time by the American Film
Institute in 2008. A few minor inaccuracies in legal details do not mar
this study of an alcoholic lawyer (superbly embodied by
Paul Newman) aiming to regain his
self-respect through a malpractice case. The expertly directed movie
received five Academy Award nominations. Lumet's controversial drama
Daniel (1983) with
Timothy Hutton, an adaptation of
E.L. Doctorow's "The Book of Daniel" about
two young people whose parents were executed during the McCarthy Red
Scare hysteria in the 1950s for alleged espionage, is one of his
underrated achievements. His later masterpiece
Running on Empty (1988) has a
similar theme, portraying a family which has been on the run from the
FBI since the parents (played by
Christine Lahti and
Judd Hirsch) committed a bomb attack on a
napalm laboratory in 1971 to protest the war in Vietnam. The son
(played by River Phoenix in an
extraordinarily moving, Oscar-nominated performance) falls in love with
a girl and wishes to stay with her and study music.
Naomi Foner's screenplay won the Golden
Globe. Other Lumet movies of the 1980s are the melancholic comedy drama
Garbo Talks (1984); the occasionally
clichéd Power (1986) about election
campaigns; the all too slow thriller
The Morning After (1986) and
the amusing gangster comedy
Family Business (1989). With
Q&A (1990) Lumet returned to the genre of
the New York cop thriller. Nick Nolte shines
in the role of a corrupt and racist detective in this multi-layered,
strangely underrated film. Sadly, with the exception of
Night Falls on Manhattan (1996),
an imperfect but fascinating crime drama in the tradition of his own
previous genre works, almost none of Lumet's works of the 1990s did
quite get the attention they deserved. The crime drama
A Stranger Among Us (1992)
blended genres in a way that did not seem to match most viewers'
expectations, but its contemplations about life arouse interest. The
intelligent hospital satire
Critical Care (1997) was unfairly
neglected as well. The courtroom thriller
Guilty as Sin (1993) was cold but
intriguing. Lumet's Gloria (1999) remake
seemed unnecessary, but he returned impressively with the
underestimated courtroom comedy
Find Me Guilty (2006) and the
justly acclaimed crime thriller
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead (2007).
In 2005, Sidney Lumet received a well-deserved honorary Academy Award
for his outstanding contribution to filmmaking. Sidney Lumet tragically
died of cancer in 2011.