Easy-to-make "cheater's" fudge with two flavors in one! Chocolate and peanut butter like a Reese's peanut butter cup. No candy thermometer required.

Creamy Double Decker Fudge. Discover our recipe rated 4.5/5 by 37 members.

Experience the velvety pleasure of The Finest Mackinac Island Fudge, a recipe that captures the essence of this beloved American classic. Each delectable bite of this fudge transports you to a world of creamy chocolatey perfection, where the exquisite combination of cocoa, luxurious unsalted butter and the perfect balance of brown sugars come together to create an orchestra of flavors. The subtle hints of vanilla and just a touch of salt elevate this treat beyond expectations transforming it…

Tastes like a Reese's Cup! And it is so easy to make!

An easy 2-layer fudge with a bottom chocolate layer and a top peanut butter layer.

Creamy buckeye fudge tastes just like the favorite Ohio candy, with a layer of sweet chocolate fudge on top of a layer of creamy peanut butter fudge.

Buckeye fudge is a dreamy combination of creamy peanut butter fudge alongside smooth, rich, chocolate fudge. This rich treat tastes like the classic Buckeye candies.

It must be close to Christmas since I’ve made my grandma’s double-decker fudge. My dad insists my grandma made this fudge by mistake when she didn’t have enough chocolate to make a full batch of fudge. I have my doubts. My grandma didn’t have a reputation as a good cook, so I think the things she did well are even suspect. No matter how she came up with her double-decker fudge, I loved it as a kid, and it always makes me think of Christmas. I try to make it every year. This year I’m going to…

Tiger butter is a smooth and creamy combination of peanut butter and chocolate. When the layers are swirled together, the fudge looks like it has tiger stripes!