06 Samss 001
06 Samss 001
06 Samss 001
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Document Responsibility: Non-metallic Standards Committee
3 March 2013
Page 1 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Scope
This specification defines the requirements for critical elastomeric sealing and seat
materials for permanent use in onshore and offshore equipment. It describes general
principles and gives requirements and recommendations for the selection and
qualification of elastomeric materials as well as manufacturers of these elements.
The specification applies to all sealing elements such as elastomeric o-rings, bonded
flexible hose liner elastomeric materials, elastomeric materials in flexible joints, and
elastomer lined valves.
Any conflicts between this specification and other applicable Saudi Aramco
Materials System Specifications (SAMSSs), Engineering Standards (SAESs),
Standard Drawings (SASDs), or industry standards, codes, and forms shall be
resolved in writing, prior to submission of bids or start of related work, by the
Company or Buyer Representative through the Manager, Consulting Services
Department, Saudi Aramco, Dhahran.
2.2
Direct all requests to deviate from this specification in writing to the Company or
Buyer Representative, who shall follow internal company procedure SAEP-302
and forward such requests to the Manager, Consulting Services Department, Saudi
Aramco, Dhahran.
References
Material supplied to this specification shall comply with the latest edition of the
references listed below unless otherwise noted:
3.1
175-XXX
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
ASTM D746
ASTM D792
ASTM D1415
ASTM D2240
ASTM D297
ASTM D1141
ASTM D1414
ASTM D3032
ASTM D1418-06
British Standards
BS 1806
BS 6442
ISO 1432
ISO 1817
ISO D34
ISO R 812
ISO 34-1:2005
ISO 36:2005
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
ISO 37
ISO 48
ISO 815-1
ISO 1432
ISO 1432
ISO 1817
ISO 2781
ISO 2921
ISO 3601-1
ISO 3601-3:2005
ISO 7619-1
Rubber, Vulcanized or Thermoplastic Determination of Indentation Hardness Part 1: Durometer Method (Shore Hardness)
ISO 13628-10:2005
Page 4 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
NACE TM0297-2002
SHELL
Definitions
Accelerated Test: A test at temperatures and selected pressure values chosen to
accelerate seal degradation effects.
Compression Set: % 100 x [(Original seal height - Post test seal height) /
Interference].
Elastomer: A material compounded from rubbers and other constituents, and
then cured to form a rubbery material.
Fluid (or medium): A fluid or medium anything that flows without a recovery
such as gas, liquid, supercritical gas, or a mixture of these fluid if it is not in a
container.
Room Temperature: 20C 2C.
Seal Type: A seal design of specified geometry, size and orientation.
Compression Set, %: 100 x [(Original sample height - Post-test height) /
Interference]
Elastomer: Amorphous material mechanically mixed with other constituents to
form a rubber compound which is then shaped by flow into articles by the
manufacturing processes of molding or extrusion and (invariably) chemically
Page 5 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Abbreviations
COC
Certificate of conformance
CSD
CUT
DSC
DTMA/TMA/DMTA/DMA
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
ED
Explosive Decompression
FPSO
MDSC
RGD
QC
Quality Control
Operational Requirements
Elastomeric materials selection shall be based on evaluation of compatibility with
service environment, functionality under service and the design lifetime.
When selecting elastomeric material for a specific service, the following properties shall
be considered and evaluated before use.
Chemical resistance based on published data or laboratory tests to be conducted if such
data is not available. ISO 1817, ASTM D 471, ASTM D 1460 and ASTM D 3137 are
examples of the standards to be adopted when evaluating elastomeric sealing element
chemical resistance for specific service. Tables A.1 of Annex A provide guidelines for
the Chemical Resistance of Oilfield Elastomers.
Clause 3.2 provides references to relevant industry standards for the above tests.
The test conditions and durations shall be as given in this specification. In cases where
this specification deviates from the industry standards, it is the responsibility of the
equipment buyer to supply all of the required technical information about service
conditions and environment.
6
Documentation Requirements
The following documentations shall be required:
Page 7 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Standard
Documentation
Quality
Control Test
1- Elastomers
Specific Gravity
ASTM D 792
ASTM D 2240
Tensile Properties
Compression set at 100C
for 7 days under Nitrogen
Low temperature properties
by DSC or DMA
ASTM 1414
ASTM D 1414
ISO11357-2
ASTM E1640
Tear strength
Low temperature stiffening
at 20C to -20C
Ageing/RGD characteristics
(Annex 3)
H2S; Hydrogen Sulfide aging
resistance for services
where H2S 1000ppm
ASTM D 624
ISO 1432
A
A
NACE TM-0187 or
manufacturers
testing procedure
A: Properties to be documented for each manufacturer for each material. Nominal values with
tolerances shall be given.
B: Properties to be documented based on each batch with a minimum 3 samples per test per batch.
The acceptance criteria shall identified prior to the test and based on qualification test results.
General
Materials shall be selected and designed by the Manufacturer in accordance with
the requirements of this standard and specified on their equipment data sheets.
Page 8 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Elastomer Type
NBR Nitrile
Acrylonitrile-butadiene
HNBR
Hydrogenated acrylonitrile-butadiene
FKM-1
FKM-2
FKM-3
FKM-4
FKM-5
Tetrafluoroethylene-propylene copolymer
FFKM
Perfluoro elastomer
NOTE: Nitrile (NBR) elastomers shall not be specified for sour, H2S, services.
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
On-site audits shall be performed on a random basis after the manufacturer has become
a qualified supplier to Saudi Aramco.
9
General
The requirements for testing of elastomeric sealing elements are divided into two
sections. The first section defines the aging test requirements and the second
defines the requirements for rapid gas decompression testing. The different test
regimes shall be selected based on analysis of service requirements for the
different equipment components and the material in question. Such assessment
shall address all fluids coming into contact with both sides of the elastomeric
sealing element and the chemistry of these fluids. The service life of the
elastomeric seal in the relevant service environment shall be evaluated using
appropriate methodologies.
9.2
General
This specification describes test procedures for the prediction of the
progressive degradation of elastomeric sealing elements exposed to
fluids at elevated temperatures and recommended pressure over an
extended period of time. It is applicable where prediction of service life
of an elastomeric sealing element is required or for comparing the
performance of different elastomeric sealing materials. The prediction
shall be based on tests performed at three different temperatures, all of
which shall be above the defined service temperature.
When no previous knowledge about the behavior of an elastomeric
sealing material in a certain fluid exists, an initial pre-check test shall be
performed. The test period shall be sufficient to reach saturation of the
fluid in the elastomeric material at the test temperature. Aging test can
proceed if no immediate changes in volume or weight occur.
The manufacturer shall, during aging accelerated testing for obtaining
results for extrapolation to service life, limit the test temperature to
ensure that the same chemical and/or physical processes will occur as
during service.
When extrapolating data from the present procedures appropriate
statistical techniques shall be applied. For example, if progressive
degradation is dependent on a single chemical ageing process, a method
Page 10 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Approval Criteria
The approval criteria shall be determined prior to starting the aging test.
Based on documented experience the following criteria have been
identified as a baseline. The sealing element manufacturer shall justify
any deviation from these requirements.
The following property changes are acceptable for elastomeric sealing
element:
9.3
Test Temperatures
The tests shall be run at a minimum of three test temperatures, all of
which are above service temperature. The accelerated results shall be
used to conduct the extrapolation when Arrhenius methodology is
utilized. The limitations to extrapolation regarding temperature inherent
in the Arrhenius method shall apply.
Test temperature versus time details shall be fully described in the Test
Report.
9.3.2
Test Pressure
A test pressure of 100 (10) bar or higher shall be used. This pressure
shall be attained by pressurization of the gas mixture after heating to the
selected temperature.
The pressure versus time details shall be described in the Test Report.
Page 11 of 18
9.3.3
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
9.3.4
Fluid Composition
30
10
60
9.3.5
Volume%
Fluid Composition
30
3% CO2, 95%CH4
10
60
9.3.6
Exposure Time
The exposure time required for lifetime predictions shall be based on the
time to reach saturation of the test samples and be sufficiently long as to
allow for reliable extrapolation according to the requirements of
Arrhenius plot.
Page 12 of 18
9.4
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
9.4.2
9.4.3
9.4.4
b.
Test Conditions
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
Pre-Test Measurements
a.
b.
Hardness, Shore A.
c.
d.
Post-Test Examination
a.
b.
c.
d.
Compression set, %.
e.
Page 13 of 18
9.4.5
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
9.5.
General
Testing shall be per manufacturer testing procedure. All relevant
documentation including test methods and test results shall be submitted
to Saudi Aramco for review and approval. Testing shall fulfill the
minimum requirements given in Table 9.2 below.
Table 9.2 Minimum Test Requirements for H2S Resistance
Test Condition
9.5.2
Required Value
1000 minimum
5% minimum
Test Temperature
175F (75C)
Exposure Duration
96 hours minimum
Approval Criteria
The following property changes are acceptable for elastomeric sealing
element under H2S aging test.
9.5.3
Elongation; 5%
Hardness; + / -3 units
Test Report
A test report containing the tests results highlighted in 9.5.2 shall be
submitted to Saudi Aramco for assessment and approval.
Page 14 of 18
9.6
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
General
Rapid gas decompression, RGD, occurs in all types of fluid handling
devices, including valves, hoses, compressors, and in many other
equipment. Rapid decompression is also known as explosive
decompression (ED), an operational condition during which the applied
system pressure is quickly released, resulting in the expansion of
absorbed gas damaging elastomeric seals. Below is a typical example
for an O-ring that experienced ED.
Test Conditions
Test conditions for ED shall be those given below in Table 9.3.
Table 9.3 Minimum Required Conditions for Explosive Decompression
Testing Using O-Ring Test Fixture Pressure Vessel Apparatus or
Autoclave Apparatus with Free-Standing O-Ring Test Samples
Test Conditions
2000
Fluid composition
Test temperature
Exposure Duration
48 hours
Page 15 of 18
9.6.3
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
Test Conditions
Hold Period
1 hour
0 psi
Decompression rate
1000 psi/minute
Number of
pressurization/decompression cycles
O-ring squeeze
14 - 22%
Groove fill
70%-90%
Common Elastomers
Elastomers that are commonly used in ED shall be those highlighted in
Table 7.0 above.
9.6.4
9.6.5
Failure Criteria
The failure criterion for ED shall be based on NORSK M-710 standard
internal inspection rating method commonly used in the oil and gas
industry. Test seals are cut into 4 equal quadrants and each section is
rated as described in Table 9.4. Seals with rating 4 or 5 are classified as
not acceptable.
Table 9.4 Description of Rating Number System
for Each Seal Cross Section Surface
Description
No internal cracks, holes or blisters of any size
Less than 4 internal cracks, each shorter than 50% of cross
section with a total crack length less than the cross section.
Less than 6 internal cracks, each shorter than 50% of the
cross section, with a total crack length of less than 2,5 times
the cross section.
Less than 9 internal cracks of which max. 2 cracks can have
a length between 50% and 80% of the cross section.
More than 8 internal cracks or one or more cracks longer
than 80 % of the cross section.
Crack(s) going through cross section or complete separation
of the seal into fragments.
Rating
#0
#1
#2
#3
#4*
#5*
Page 16 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
9.6.6
Test Report
Record the rating of each seal by listing the individual ratings for each cut
section in the order of the highest first to the lowest last. Thus, a rating for
a whole seal of 1000 means that one cut section had a few small cracks of
rating #1 but no other cut section had any crack at all. Rating of 5422
would mean that one section had one or more cracks going through seal
cross section, one section had more than 8 cracks or at least one longer
than 80% of seal cross section and the other two sections had less than
6 cracks of which each were shorter than 50% of seal cross section.
The overall rating for a set of three replicate seals is defined on a worst
case basis as the highest rating for each cross section over the three
replicates. Thus, if the rating for 3 seals were 1110, 3110, 2220, the
overall rating would be 3220 and the seal had passed the test.
Comparisons between materials shall be based on overall ratings made
on the same basis and with the same number of replicate seals.
The test report shall also state the following:
10 September 2011
3 March 2013
a)
Date of tests.
b)
c)
d)
Initial observations.
e)
f)
g)
h)
Revision Summary
New Saudi Aramco Materials System Specification.
Editorial revision to change the document responsibility from Materials and Corrosion
Control to Non-metallic Standards Committee.
Page 17 of 18
06-SAMSS-001
Selection and Qualification of Elastomeric
Sealing Materials and Manufacturers
NBR
HNBR
FKM
FEPM
FFKM
Poor
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Corrosion Inhibitors,
K2CO3 based
Poor
Fair to good
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Fair to good
Excellent
Excellent
Poor
Poor
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Fair to good
Fair to good
Excellent
Fair to good
Excellent
Explosive Decompression
(ED)
Poor
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Fair to good
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Hydraulic Fluid,
water/glycol (HFC)
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Poor
Poor
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Poor
Fair to good
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Poor
Poor
Poor
Poor
Excellent
Steam
Poor
Fair to good
Poor
Excellent
Excellent
Toluene
Poor
Poor
Excellent
Fair to good
Excellent
Page 18 of 18