Late Cenomanian-Turonian Ammonites From Wadi Qena, EGY
Late Cenomanian-Turonian Ammonites From Wadi Qena, EGY
Late Cenomanian-Turonian Ammonites From Wadi Qena, EGY
6389
ABSTRACT:
Nagm, E. and Wilmsen, M. 2012. Late CenomanianTuronian (Cretaceous) ammonites from Wadi Qena, central
Eastern Desert, Egypt: taxonomy, biostratigraphy and palaeobiogeographic implications. Acta Geologica Polonica,
62 (1), 6389. Warszawa.
In Egypt, marine Upper CenomanianTuronian strata are well exposed in the Eastern Desert. The southernmost
outcrops are located in the central part of Wadi Qena, where the lower Upper Cretaceous is represented by the fossiliferous Galala and Umm Omeiyid formations. From these strata, numerous ammonites have been collected
bed-by-bed and 13 taxa have been identified, which are systematically described herein. Four of them (Euomphaloceras costatum, Vascoceras globosum globosum, Thomasites gongilensis and Pseudotissotia nigeriensis) are
recorded from Egypt for the first time. The ammonite ranges are used for a biostratigraphic zonation of the lower
Upper Cretaceous succession in the northern and central part of Wadi Qena: the Upper CenomanianLower Turonian has been subdivided into five biozones (including a new upper Lower Turonian biozone based on the occurrence of Pseudotissotia nigeriensis), and one biozone has been recognized in the Upper Turonian.
Palaeobiogeographically, the ammonite assemblage has a Tethyan character. During the Early Turonian, influences
of the Vascoceratid Province were predominant with strong affinities to typical Nigerian faunas. This shows the
significance of faunal exchange between Egypt and Central and West Africa via the Trans-Saharan Seaway. Compared to contemporaneous ammonoid faunas from the northern part of the Eastern Desert, Boreal influences are
much less obvious in Wadi Qena. Thus, the present study greatly enhances the knowledge of the Late Cretaceous
palaeobiogeography and biostratigraphy of Egypt and adjacent areas.
Key words: Upper Cretaceous; Ammonites; Systematic palaeontology; Biostratigraphy;
Palaeobiogeography; Egypt.
INTRODUCTION
Marine lower Upper Cretaceous successions are
well exposed in the northeastern part of Egypt (Sinai
and Eastern Desert; Text-fig. 1). The southernmost
exposures of Upper CenomanianTuronian sediments
64
knowledge of the taxonomy of the Late CenomanianTuronian ammonite fauna in Wadi Qena by means
of a modern systematic approach and description of a
large fauna of ammonites collected bed-by-bed from
the Galala and Umm Omeiyid formations. In total, 90
ammonites have been collected during two field cam-
Text-fig. 1. Geographical and geological framework. A: map of Egypt with position of Wadi Qena (B); B map of Wadi Qena with position of study area (C); C: geological
map of study area (modified after Conoco, 1987)
65
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
GEOLOGICAL SETTING
Wadi Qena is located in the central part of the
Egyptian Eastern Desert (Text-fig. 1A, B). The main
part of Wadi Qena is about 200 km long and runs from
the southern slopes of the Southern Galala Plateau,
near the Gulf of Suez, towards the south southeast. Near
the town of Qena City it grades into the River Nile valley. Wadi Qena is bordered by the uniform, elevated and
flat-topped Eocene limestone Plateau in the west and
the serrated, varicoloured basement rocks of the Red
Sea Mountains range in the east (Text-fig. 1B). Wadi
Qena clearly developed along faults that run parallel to
the Gulf of Suez and the Red Sea Mountains, which are
well exposed at numerous places within the wadi, especially on the eastern side (Bandel et al. 1987). Sedimentary successions are well exposed on the western
flank of the wadi while Quaternary alluvial fans predominate in the centre (Text-fig. 1C).
The sedimentary rocks of Wadi Qena range in age
from Palaeozoic to Quaternary (Text-fig. 1C). Most of
the Palaeozoic rocks are non-marine and well developed in the northern part of the wadi. The distribution
of the Palaeozoic sediments was more or less controlled by older, pre-Cenomanian structural events
(Said 1990; Issawi et al. 1999). The first marine transgression took place during the Late Cenomanian. This
resulted in the deposition of shallow marine, mixed siliciclastic and carbonate sediments. During Late CenomanianTuronian times, the southern shoreline of the
Tethyan seaway was situated immediately south of the
study area. The marine transgression continued with
some phases of regression during the later parts of the
Late Cretaceous and Tertiary, leaving Coniacian
Eocene strata in the study area (see Text-fig. 1C).
SECTIONS
Two sections, located on the western margin in the
northern part of Wadi Qena (Text-fig. 1C), have been
measured bed-by-bed. One section, measured at N 27
57` 57``, E 32 30` 58``, is termed the north Wadi Qena
section (Text-fig. 2). The other section, located 25 km
south of the north Wadi Qena section, was measured at
the mouth of Wadi El-Burga entering Wadi Qena at N
27 44` 51``, E 32 33` 55`` and is consequently termed
the Wadi El-Burga section (Text-fig. 2).
The sedimentary succession starts with the Palaeozoic Naqus Formation (non-marine, kaolinitic,
medium- to coarse-grained sandstones; see Abdallah et
al. 1992 and Issawi et al. 1999) which, in places,
overlies basement rocks unconformably. Along a trun-
66
Text-fig. 2. Graphic logs of the North Wadi Qena and Wadi El-Burga sections with stratigraphic distribution of the zonal ammonite markers. The dashed lines represent
inferred ranges of taxa depending on other stratigraphic data. For location see Text-fig. 1C
67
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
D
86.4 (100)
92.9 (100)
57.3 (100)
72.5 (100)
Wb
20.6 (23.8)
20.2 (21.7)
16.1 (28.0)
18.3 (25.2)
Wh Wb/Wh U
51.0 (59.0) 0.40 8.1 (9.3)
51.7 (55.6) 0.39 8.8 (9.4)
33.7 (58.8) 0.47 4.9 (8.5)
46.9 (64.6) 0.39 4.4 (6.0)
DESCRIPTION: Most of the specimens are fully septate internal moulds with very involute coiling. The
Text-fig. 3. Whorl section and suture line of Neolobites vibrayeanus (dOrbigny, 1841), Upper Cenomanian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 301
68
69
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
Text-fig. 5. Suture line and whorl section of Pseudaspidoceras sp., Upper Cenomanian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 304
70
Text-fig. 6. A Neolobites vibrayeanus (dOrbigny, 1841) (A1, A2 - lateral and ventral views of AfK 298, 1; A3 - lateral view of AfK 300, 1; A4, A5 - lateral
and ventral views of AfK 301, 1). B Euomphaloceras costatum Cobban, Hook and Kennedy, 1989 (B1, B2 - lateral and ventral views of AfK 305, 1).
C Pseudaspidoceras sp. (C1, C2 - lateral and ventral views of AfK 304, 1). All specimens from the Upper Cenomanian of the Galala Formation
71
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
DESCRIPTION: Both specimens are fragmentary internal moulds with relatively evolute coiling as well as
a deep and wide umbilicus (ca. 35%). The umbilical
shoulders are feebly rounded with vertical walls.
Flanks are short and convex with a broadly rounded to
nearly flat venter (in the latter case, faintly defined ventrolateral shoulders are present). The whorl section is
compressed to slightly depressed (Text-fig. 7, specimen AfK 302). The ornamentation is not preserved in
specimen AfK 302 (Text-fig. 9A34), while very
weak, shallow ribs, especially towards the venter, occur in specimen AfK 303 (Text-fig. 9A12, a fragment
of a body chamber). The suture line, characterized by
a deep external lobe and a wide, deep adventive lobe,
is clearly visible in specimen AfK 302 (see Text-fig. 7).
Text-fig. 7. Whorl section and suture line of Vascoceras cauvini Chudeau, 1905, Upper Cenomanian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 302
72
Wb
48.0 (73.2)
39.6 (75.4)
46.4 (77.4)
45.6 (68.6)
Wh Wb/Wh
U
30.2 (46.1) 1.58 13.2 (20.1)
27.4 (52.1) 1.44 9.0 (17.1)
33.0 (55.0) 1.40 7.8 (13.0
35.2 (53.0) 1.29 9.1 (13.7)
Text-fig. 8. Whorl section and suture line of Vascoceras globosum globosum (Reyment, 1954), Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 308
73
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
Text-fig. 9. A Vascoceras cauvini Chudeau, 1909 (A1, A2 - ventral and lateral views of AfK 303, 1; A3, A4 - lateral and ventral views of AfK 302, 1; Upper
Cenomanian of the Galala Formation). B Vascoceras globosum globosum (Reyment, 1954) (B1, B2 - lateral and ventral views of AfK 308, 1; Lower Turonian
of the Galala Formation). C Vascoceras kossmati Choffat, 1898 (C1, C2 - lateral and apertural views of AfK 309, 1; Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation)
74
Text-fig. 10. Whorl section and suture line of Vascoceras kossmati Choffat, 1898, Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 309
75
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
DESCRIPTION: The specimen has a preserved diameter of ~82 mm and a moderately wide, deep umbilicus with broadly rounded umbilical shoulders. The
whorl section (Text-fig. 12) is only slightly compressed
(Wb/Wh = 0.97), with the greatest width at the umbilical shoulders. The flanks are convex, ending at
rounded ventrolateral shoulders. The venter is fairly
broad and flat. The suture line (Text-fig. 12) shows narrow lobes and broad, weakly incised saddles. Ornamental features are not preserved.
REMARKS: Wright and Kennedy (1981) revised
the genus Thomasites and discussed the relationship
of the present species to other species referred to the
genus. West African faunas of T. gongilensis (e.g.,
Text-fig. 12. Whorl section and suture line of Thomasites gongilensis (Woods, 1911), Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 314
76
Text-fig. 13. A Vascoceras kossmati Choffat, 1898 (A1, A2 - lateral and ventral views of AfK 311, 1). B Neoptychites cephalotus (Courtiller, 1860) (B1, B2
- apertural and ventral views of AfK 313, 1). C Thomasites gongilensis (Woods, 1911) (C1, C2 - apertural and lateral views of AfK 314, 1). D Thomasites
rollandi (Thomas and Peron, 1889) (D1, D2 - apertural and lateral views of AfK 316, 1). All specimens from the Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation
77
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
Text-fig. 14. Whorl section and suture line of Thomasites rollandi (Thomas and Peron, 1889), Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 315
78
MEASUREMENTS:
Specimen
D
AfK 328 68.5 (100)
AfK 329 91.1 (100)
AfK 330 84.0 (100)
AfK 331 85.8 (100)
AfK 332 78.5 (100)
Wb
19.7 (28.7)
33.4 (36.6)
20.1 (23.9)
27.3 (31.1)
23.4 (29.8)
Wh Wb/Wh
U
37.5 (54.7) 0.36 6.0 (8.7)
50.3 (55.2) 0.66 11.7 (12.8)
43.0 (51.1) 0.46 9.8 (11.6)
47.0 (54.7) 0.58 7.7 (9.0)
42.3 (53.8) 0.55 8.2 (10.4)
DESCRIPTION: All specimens are smooth, fully septate internal moulds with a maximum preserved diameter of 91 mm (specimen AfK 329, Text-fig. 16B46).
Coiling is involute (U ~10%) with a moderately deep
umbilicus and feebly rounded umbilical walls. The
flanks are high, subparallel, with convex inner and
converging outer parts. Two prominent keels at the
ventrolateral shoulders mark the contact with the venter, which is characterized by a siphonal keel, resulting
in the distinctive tricarinate appearance of the ventral
area (Text-fig. 15). The three keels have the same relative height in all specimens. The whorl section (Textfig. 15) is compressed, with the maximum breadth directly above the umbilical shoulder. The suture line
(Text-fig. 15) is characterized by very broad saddles and
narrow lobes; the adventive lobe is deeply incised.
REMARKS: The flat, tricarinate venter, the compressed whorl section and a suture line with broad
saddles and narrow lobes (deeply incised adventive
lobe) are characteristic of Pseudotissotia nigeriensis
(e.g., Meister 1989). Based on these characters, the
specimens from the upper Galala Formation of Wadi
Qena are unequivocally attributed to Woods species
and represent its first proven occurrence in Egypt.
Our specimens closely match the Nigerian material as
described by Woods (1911) and Meister (1989).
Text-fig. 15. Whorl section and suture line of Pseudotissotia nigeriensis (Woods, 1911), Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation, specimen AfK 328
79
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
Text-fig. 16. A Thomasites rollandi (Thomas and Peron, 1889) (A1, A2 lateral and apertural views of AfK 315, 1). B Pseudotissotia nigeriensis (Woods, 1911) (B1,
B2 - lateral and apertural views of AfK 328, 1; B3 - lateral view of AfK 334, 1; B4, B5, B6 - apertural, lateral and ventral views of AfK 329, 1). All specimens from
the Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation
80
81
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
MEASUREMENTS:
Specimen
D
AfK 317 101.3 (100)
AfK 318 107.4 (100)
AfK 319 114.1 (100)
AfK 320 81.8 (100)
AfK 321 57.9 (100)
AfK 322 45.5 (100)
AfK 323 43.8 (100)
Wb
36.8 (36.3)
31.8 (29.6)
36.9 (31.9)
22.5 (27.5)
20.0 (34.5)
15.4 (33.8)
12.9 (29.4)
Wh
Wb/Wh
U
50.2 (49.5) 0.73 13.0 (12.8)
47.5 (44.2) 0.66 17.4 (16.2)
67.0 (56.2) 0.55 23.1 (20.2)
42.9 (52.4) 0.52 10.0 (12.2)
33.7 (58.2) 0.59 3.6 (6.2)
25.9 (56.9) 0.59 5.8 (12.7)
23.8 (54.3) 0.54 5.4 (12.3)
REMARKS: Barroso-Barcenilla and Goy (2007) described several species of Choffaticeras from Spain
and discussed their relationship. The Lower Turonian
of Egypt yielded abundant Choffaticeras (cf. Nagm
2009; Nagm et al. 2010a, b); however, only two
species are represented in Wadi Qena, i.e., Choffaticeras (Choffaticeras) securiforme and Choffaticeras
(C.) segne (and eight species are known in contemporaneous strata of Wadi Araba in the northern part of the
Eastern Desert; Nagm 2009; Wilmsen and Nagm, in
prep.). The well-preserved and large population of C.
(C.) segne from the Eastern Desert confirms the view
of Kennedy et al. (2008) that C. (C.) quaasi is a junior synonym of C. (C.) segne (Wilmsen and Nagm, in
prep.).
OCCURRENCE: The species is known from the
Lower Turonian of Tunisia, Israel, Syria, Jordan,
France and Spain. In the study area, it characterizes the
middle Lower Turonian Choffaticeras spp. Zone,
which is (as defined by Nagm et al. 2010b) equivalent
to the upper part of the standard Watinoceras coloradoense Zone (Kennedy 1984; Wright et al. in Wright
and Kennedy 1984) or the Watinoceras spp. Zone
(Hancock 1991).
Text-fig. 18. Whorl section and suture line of Choffaticeras (Choffaticeras) segne (Solger, 1903), Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation, A, B - specimen AfK 321;
C - specimen AfK 317; D - specimen AfK 323
82
Text-fig. 19. Choffaticeras (Choffaticeras) segne (Solger, 1903) from the Lower Turonian of the Galala Formation. A1, A2 - lateral and apertural views of AfK 319, 1;
A3, A4 - apertural and lateral views of AfK 317 , 1; A5, A6 - apertural and lateral views of AfK 325, 1
83
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
Text-fig. 20. Suture line and whorl section of Coilopoceras requienianum (dOrbigny, 1841), Upper Turonian of the Umm Omeiyid Formation, specimen AfK 339
84
Text-fig. 21. Coilopoceras requienianum (dOrbigny, 1841) from the Upper Turonian of the Umm Omeiyid Formation. A1, A2 - lateral and apertural views of AfK 339, 1;
A3, A4 - apertural and lateral views of AfK 341, 1
85
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
86
REFERENCES
Abdallah, A.M., Darwish, M., El Aref, M. and Helba, A.
1992. Lithostratigraphy of the Pre-Cenomanian clastics
of north Wadi Qena, Eastern Desert, Egypt. Geology of
the Arab World, Cairo University, 255280.
Aly, M.F., Smadi, A. and Abu Azzam, H. 2008. Late CenomanianEarly Turonian ammonites of Jordan. Revue de
Palobiologie, 27 (1), 4371.
Bandel, K., Kuss, J. and Malchus, N. 1987. The sediments
of Wadi Qena (Eastern Desert, Egypt). Journal of African
Earth Sciences, 6 (4), 427455.
Barber, W. 1957. Lower Turonian ammonites from northeastern Nigeria. Bulletin of the Geological Survey of
Nigeria, 26, 186.
Barroso-Barcenilla, F. and Goy, A. 2007. Revision and new
data of the ammonite family Pseudotissotiidae in the
Iberian Trough, Spain. Geobios, 40, 455487.
Barroso-Barcenilla, F. and Goy, A. 2010. The ammonite
genus Vascoceras Choffat, 1898 (family Vascoceratidae
Douvill, 1912) in the Iberian Trough, Spain. Palaeontographica, 290 (46), 199235.
87
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT
88
monites from the environs of Saumur, and the provenance of the types of Ammonites vibrayeanus and Ammonites geslinianum. Cretaceous Research, 2, 1949.
Kennedy, W.J. and Wright, C.W. 1979. Vascoceratid ammonites from the type Turonian. Palaeontology, 22 (3),
665683.
Kennedy, W.J. and Wright, C.W. 1984. The Cretaceous ammonite Ammonites requienianus dOrbigny, 1841.
Palaeontology, 27 (2), 281293.
Kennedy, W.J., Juignet, P. and Girard, J. 2003. Uppermost
Cenomanian ammonites from Eure, Haute-Normandie,
northwest France. Acta Geologica Polonica, 53 (1), 118.
Kennedy, W.J., Gale, A.S., Ward, D.J. and Underwood, C.J.
2008. Early Turonian ammonites from Goulmima, southern Morocco. Bulletin de lInstitut Royal des Sciences
Naturelles de Belgique, 78, 149177.
Korn, D., Ebbighausen, V., Bockwinkel, J and Klug, C.,
2003. The A-mode sutural ontogeny in prolecanitid ammonites. Palaeontology, 46, 11231132.
Kossmat, F. 1895. Untersuchungen ber die sdindische
Kreideformation. Beitrge zur paleontologie sterreich-Ungarns und des Orients, 9, 97203.
Kullman, J. and Wiedmann, J. 1970. Significance of sutures
in phylogeny of Ammonoidea. Paleontological Contributions, University of Kansas, 44, 132.
Lehmann, J. and Herbig, H.-G. 2009. Late Cretaceous ammonites from the Bou Angueur syncline (Middle Atlas,
Morocco) stratigraphic and palaeobiogeographic implications. Palaeontographica, A 289, 4587.
Luger, P. and Grschke, M. 1989. Late Cretaceous ammonites from the Wadi Qena area in the Egyptian Eastern Desert. Palaeontology, 32 (2), 355407.
Meister, C. 1989. Les ammonites du Crtac suprieur dAshaka, Nigria. Bulletin des Centres de Recherches Exploration-Production (Elf Aquitaine), 13, 184.
Meister, C. and Abdallah, H. 1996. Les ammonites du Cnomanian suprieur et du Turonien infrieur de la rgion
de Gafsa-Chotts, Tunisie du centre-sud. Geobios, 29
(5), 349.
Meister, C., Alzouma, K., Lang, J. and Mathey, B. 1992. Les
ammonites du Niger (Afrique occidentale) et la transgression transsaharienne au cours du CnomanienTuronien. Geobios, 25, 55100.
Nagm, E. 2009. Integrated stratigraphy, palaeontology and
facies analysis of the Cenomanian Turonian (Upper
Cretaceous) Galala and Maghra el Hadida formations of
the western Wadi Araba, Eastern Desert, Egypt. PhD thesis, Wrzburg University, 1213, (http://www.opusbayern.de/uni-wuerzburg/volltexte/2009/3988/).
Nagm, E., Wilmsen, M., Aly, M.F. and Hewaidy, A. 2010a.
Upper CenomanianTuronian (Upper Cretaceous) ammonoids from the western Wadi Araba, Eastern Desert,
Egypt. Cretaceous Research, 31, 473499.
89
CENOMANIAN TURONIAN AMMONITES FROM EGyPT