Managed Futures For Institutional Investors: Analysis and Portfolio Construction
Managed Futures For Institutional Investors: Analysis and Portfolio Construction
Managed Futures For Institutional Investors: Analysis and Portfolio Construction
FOR INSTITUTIONAL
INVESTORS
L_____i_____L__
Galen Burghardf
Brian Walls
BLOOMBERG PRESS
An Imprint of
Contents
Acknowledgments
Introduction: Why Invest in CTAs?
What Kind of Hedge Fund Is a CTA?
Why Do CTAs Make Money?
How Much Should You Invest?
What About the Risks?
They're a Good Fit for Institutional Investors
How the Book Is Structured
xiii
1
1
2
7
9
10
11
CHAPTER 2
Where Are the Data?
The CTA Universe and Your Range of Choices
The Fluid Composition of a Database
How Backfilled Data Can Mislead
Trading Programs and Lengths of Track Records
Returns Net of Fees and Share Classes
Sources of Data for Indexes of CTA Performance
17
18
19
19
20
27
41
42
44
46
48
49
50
CHAPTER 3
Structuring Your Investment: Frequently Asked Questions 53
How Many Managers Should You Choose?
What Are CTA Funds?
What Are Multi-CTA Funds?
55
58
60
Vll
viii
Contents
62
66
66
68
69
69
71
71
71
72
CHAPTER 5
Two Benchmarks for Momentum Trading
Data and the Trend-Following Sub-Index
Trend-Following Models
Laying the Groundwork for Analyzing Returns to Trend Following
Constructing a Portfolio
Simplifying Assumptions
How Did the Models Do?
The Newedge Trend Indicator
Next Steps
CHAPTER 6
The Value of Daily Return Data
How Good Are Daily Data?
Estimating Return Volatility
Distributions of Estimated Volatility
Beware a False Sense of Confidence
What If Underlying Returns Are Highly Skewed?
Effect on Drawdown Distributions
75
76
79
87
87
89
94
94
97
99
101
108
108
110
114
115
124
124
129
130
138
139
145
146
148
Contents
CHAPTER 7
Every Drought Ends in a Rainstorm: Mean Reversion,
Momentum, or Serial Independence?
IX
151
CHAPTER 8
Understanding Drawdowns
Drawdown Defined
What Should They Look Like?
What Forces Shape the Distributions?
The Distribution of All Drawdowns
The Distribution of Maximum Drawdowns
The Core Drawdown Function
Empirical Drawdown Distributions
Reconciling Theoretical and Empirical Distributions
Putting a Managers Experience in Perspective
What about Future Drawdowns?
Further Questions
CHAPTER 9
How Stock Price Volatility Affects Returns
A Look at Historical Returns
Stock Price Volatility and Returns on the S&P 500
S&P 500 Volatility Dominates Market Volatility
CTA Returns, Correlations, and Volatility
Conclusion
CHAPTER 10
The Costs of Active Management
Forgone Loss Carry-Forward
Liquidation and Reinvestment
Other Costs
Conclusion
CHAPTER 11
Measuring Market Impact and Liquidity
A Very Fat Data Set
181
182
183
184
185
187
190
192
192
197
198
199
201
202
203
206
210
215
217
217
220
224
225
227
229
Contents
A Representative Market Maker
Fitting the Curve to the Data
Hidden Liquidity
Estimating the Risk-Aversion Parameter
Volume, Volatility, and Market Impact Profiles
Where Do We Go from Here?
Appendix
234
237
238
243
243
246
247
253
255
256
262
270
275
277
CHAPTER 13
A New Look at Constructing Teamwork Portfolios
279
CHAPTER 14
Correlations and Holding Periods: The Research Basis
for the Newedge AlternativeEdge Short-Term
Traders Index
Review of Previous Research
Index Methodology and Construction
How Low Are the Correlations?
Why Are the Correlations Low?
Holding Period and Return Correlation
Why Are There Not More Short-Term Traders?
Replicating the Index
Cautions and Managing the Index
Conclusion
Appendix
281
282
287
291
296
297
298
304
305
308
308
313
314
316
316
316
Contents
CHAPTER 15
"There Are Known Unknowns": The Drag of Imperfect
Estimates
Improving Risk-Adjusted Returns
Throwing Out the Losers
Due Diligence and Evaluation
Bibliography
About the Authors
Index
XI
319
321
331
338
341
343
345