A Grinding System
A Grinding System
A Grinding System
All these factors working together at optimum efficiency results in parts with required Surface quality
resulting into components performance at optimum cost.
Just consider: A grinding wheel lower in price may be giving more no of components but with a higher %
rejection. Though the grinding cost per component may appear low, the total cost of such an operation is
definitely high. Besides the cost of rejections, the cost of time spend in checking and segregating
rejections, dressing cost – all of this considered together will show a much higher cost incurred in such
grinding system.
Apart from these quantifiable parameters, the Total cost also includes factors like
• Rejection cost
• WIP/in-process material on shop floor.
• Abrasive Inventory carrying cost
• Possible thru-put increase.
Most of our efforts on improvisation in a Grinding process are focused on improving one of the following
–
• Parts per wheel
• Parts per dress
• Productivity etc.
It is very well possible that a Grinding wheel with higher initial price thereby higher Abrasive cost per
component will still result in lower Total cost per component – which finally drives the price and margins
for a product.
The technical output from FIS can be collected and analysed to arrive at the Economic aspects of
Grinding. These economic aspects then helps us to arrive at the Economic output i.e Total Cost of
Grinding system.
How to calculate Cost per component?
At Grindwell Norton ltd. We have arrived at a table, which helps us to arrive at the cost per component
considering all the aspects of the grinding system simultaneously. for more details please mail to:
charu.joshi@saint-gobain.co.in
The Field Instrumentation System (FIS) is a tool developed by Saint Gobain Abrasive’s Higgins Grinding
Technology Center (HGTC), Worcester to offer solutions to customers using the concept of ‘System
Approach’. The System Approach utilizes all parts of the grinding system to influence the microscopic
interactions of the process. It integrates science/engineering/management aspects of the process
simultaneously thereby optimizing the outputs from a System – both Technical and Economical.
Today, maximizing System outputs is attempted thru Trial and Error approach – using only the Quality of
components produced as the source of information. The FIS gives an insight into the ‘Process’ and hence,
aids the user to adopt a more scientific approach to Process optimization. FIS Collects and analyses the
macroscopic variables like power consumed, slide velocity, part size change, wheel behavior v/s time
elapsed. This collection and analysis of macroscopic data helps to understand the microscopic
interactions taking place at the grinding zone. Having established thisThese macroscopic variables can
then be controlled to get the desired microscopic interaction and thereby desired performance from
grinding system.
The FIS consists of hardware for measurement of power and slide position with respect to time and a
software ( developed by HGTC ) to analyze these signals.
The FIS has been used and found beneficial for the following –
1.Grinding Cycle Optimization - The FIS can be used to study the power drawn by the process at
different Material removal rates (MRR). This can be used to find the forces in grinding – Tangential and
Normal. Measuring deflections in the system ( using process with and without spark-out ) and using the
forces in grinding, the System Stiffness can be calculated. The System Stiffness decides the part size
repeatability and drives the Cpk values in an operation. Combining Stiffness values along with relation
between power and MRR, new grinding cycles can be designed to yield –
2.Evaluation of New products – In any process, change of any input variable has an impact on the
process, which is generally interpreted from the output part quality – in the absence of measurement of
process. The FIS gives an insight into the effect of input variable on microscopic interactions in the
process and hence, provides better insight on Real performance of any New product.
This helps in understanding of Non – performance of a product and can attribute the reasons to
the right factor.
The FIS has been in use in India for the last 4 years and has been found very beneficial at
all accounts where it was used.
What Is Centerless Grinding?
• Grinding wheel,
• Regulating wheel and
• Work blade
If the work piece rests on a flat work blade that is on center with the
regulating and grinding wheels, the contact points form three sides of a
square. As the part is ground in this setup, any high spot on the work piece
will shift the work slightly on the blade, allowing the grinding wheel to
cut a directly opposite low spot. Over time this setup will create three
lobes on the work piece that may be dimensionally accurate but far from
round. Setting the centerline of a work piece on
the centerlines of the grinding and
Setting an angled work blade so regulating wheels will not produce
it slopes toward the regulating rounding. In this setup, any high spot will
wheel and supports the work create a diametrically opposite low spot.
piece centerline above the Over time, the work piece will look like
centerline of the regulating and the exaggerated shape shown at the
grinding wheels is how the bottom.
centerless operation is able to
generate roundness. In this setup if a high spot comes in contact with either
the blade or the regulating wheel, it does not create a directly opposite low
spot because of the angle created between the centerlines of the wheels and
To enable the centerless grinding work piece.
process to create rounding action on the
work piece, it must be placed above the Instead of grinding a lobe shape in the work piece, the high spot is gradually
centerline of the wheels. In this setup, reduced by the action of the grinding wheel. So rather than creating a low
high spots no longer create spot on the periphery of the work equal to the high spot, the grinding wheel
diametrically opposed low spots. generates a proportionally smaller low spot at its contact with the work
Instead, the high spots are ground and a piece.
gradual rounding of the work piece
takes place. The angle of the work blade helps keep the work piece in contact with and
under the control of the slower rotating regulating wheel to resist any
tendency to "spin up" to the speed of the grinding wheel. In some cases, a spin-up can take a work piece from 850
rpm to near 60,000 rpm in the blink of an eye.
Setup Keys
• Centers of grinding wheel & regulating wheel should be in the same line
• Work blade is inclined towards the regulating wheel. Angle should be in between 0 to 45 deg; (best is 30 deg)
steeper blade means faster rounding action, for large & longer work shallow blade angle is best.
• Center Height of the job should be half the dia of job from centerline of grinding & regulating wheel and
maximum 10 mm above the center
• Too high – will produce chatter marks; Too low- will produce work out of roundness
• Regulating wheel runs at a slower speed than grinding wheel. Best speed of regulating wheel is 30 RPM. It is
used to control the speed of revolution & through feed of the work piece.
• Best blade for resisting wear is tungsten carbide but this can scour the work when
grinding with softer materials. In this case a cast iron blade should be used.
The two most common centerless grinding techniques are infeed and thrufeed.
The work piece is placed between the wheels, and the grinding Infeed centerless
cycle begins. After spark-out, the finished part is removed and grinding is analogous to
the next one goes in. Infeed centerless grinding is analogous to plunge grinding on a
plunge grinding on a center-type machine in that the workpiece center-type machine.
is static in the axial direction. For continuous, production-type The work is placed on
centerless grinding, the thrufeed method is very effective. the blade, and the
Thrufeed grinding is accomplished by passing the workpiece regulating wheel moves
between the grinding and regulating wheel. Basically, raw into a programmed feed
Thrufeed grinding is material goes in one side of the grinding zone, and finished to begin the grind. The
generally applied to workpieces come out. work does not move
continuous, volume axially in this type of
production applications. The work is driven axially between the wheels by inclination of centerless grinding.
The wheels are dressed in the regulating wheel relative to the grinding wheel. Because all of the points to be ground
such a way that the on the workpiece contact all the points on the wheels, this centerless grinding method is
workpiece is driven best applied to straight cylindrical parts without shoulders or other interfering features.
through the cutting zone,
across the face of the In thrufeed grinding, the regulating wheel is inclined, creating a feed angle relative to the
grinding wheel. Often a grinding wheel. This feed angle allows the regulating wheel to perform the dual purpose
single pass is sufficient to of rotating the workpiece against the grinding wheel and driving the workpiece across the
finish the workpiece. face of the grinding wheel.
The regulating wheel can be swiveled relative to the grinding wheel. However, to do its job and use the full width of
the grinding wheel, line contact between the workpiece, grinding wheel and regulating wheel must be m˜aintained.
Therefore, the regulating wheel must be trued with a diamond block located on the truing attachment. The diamond
block is a device that adjusts the diamond contact relative to the workpiece height above the grinding and regulating
wheel centerline.
"A quick check to see if the thrufeed setup is running correctly," says Mr. Payne, "is to look at the wear line across
the top of the workblade. This line should be parallel to the top of the blade. If it runs uphill, from front to back, there
is too much diamond block offset. It's the opposite if the line runs downhill."
Is Centerless Grinding For You?
Friability: - is a measure of the grain’s ability to fracture and break down during use.
• White aluminum oxide (typically a white wheel – think a manual tool and cutter wheel) is the
most friable type of aluminum oxide (i.e. breaks down easiest).
• A brown aluminum oxide (typically a gray wheel – think a bench grinder) is the least friable
(i.e. the most durable).
(Note this is the durability of the grain, not the wheel. All vitrified wheels are basically made of
glass and extremely fragile.)
Zirconia Alumina: -
It is used for rough grinding operation, like cutoff operation.
Silicon Carbide (SiC): -
• Grey Iron
Chilled Iron
Brass
Soft Bronze
Aluminium
Stone
Rubber
Cast iron
Non-ferrous metals
Non-metallic materials.
• Traditionally, before diamond-grinding wheels were readily available, silicon carbide
wheels were the wheels of choice for grinding carbide-cutting tools.
• Wheels containing silicon carbide grain are almost always either black or green in color
and will be typically called out in the marking system by the letter “C.” Another way to
easily identify silicon carbide is simply by looking at the wheel. Wheels containing silicon
carbide will “sparkle” when tilted to the light.
• A number of factors make silicon carbide unique. Silicon carbide is extremely hard and
sharp, like ceramic, but is also very friable. This property allows silicon carbide to
perform well on both extremely hard materials (due to its sharpness) and extremely soft
materials (due to its friability, or “re-sharpening” property). It is quite a versatile grain in
environments where the material is either too hard for aluminum oxide to penetrate or
too soft to create an environment for aluminum oxide grains to breakdown.
Grit Size:
Grit size is the second position in the grinding wheel marking system, and will typically
range between 46 and 220 on vitrified bonded abrasive wheels. (There are uses for grits down to 4
and up to over 600 in various bonded abrasive applications.) The lower the grit size number, the
larger the grain size. The chart below depicts this relationship:
A Grit
Grit size has a direct effect on the rate at which the material is removed as well as the scratch
depth that remains afterwards. The first things to consider when selecting a grit size are the required
surface finish and any radiuses that need to be ground in the part. The chart below is a good reference,
but it’s just a starting point. These factors can vary depending on dressing and grinding parameters.
As a rule, coarser grit is selected for fast-cutting action and fine grit where a high
finish is required.
Grain Penetration
It’s also important to understand grain penetration when considering grit size. In a given
operation, the smaller the grit size the higher the unit pressure per grain, as illustrated below:S
ize
Avage Particle Siz
This helps understand the next crucial point: Many users mistakenly move to a courser grit
size when burn is present on a ground component, but that is the opposite of what they should do!
Moving to a finer grain can help alleviate a burn. Burns are often caused by rubbing of the grain
on the ground surface. By moving to a smaller grit size you create more unit pressure on the grain,
therefore allowing for better grain penetration into the material.
• A relatively fine grit-size works best on hard and brittle material.
• A coarser grit capable of taking heavier cuts can be used advantageously on soft and
ductile materials. To explain, on hard materials the increased number of cutting points, on
the face of a moderately fine grit wheel (Fig. 1) will remove stock faster than the fewer
cutting points presented by a coarser wheel (Fig. 2). The larger abrasive grains in a coarser
grit wheel can not penetrate as deeply into the hard work-piece without burning it.
On soft ductile materials, however, the larger grains penetrate easily and provide the necessary
chip clearance to minimise wheel loading (Fig. 3) and heat generation.
Grade:
Grade is the measurement of the relative hardness of the grinding wheel. Manufacturers
create different grades by varying the ratio of bond to abrasive grain in the wheel. Grade is called
out by a letter in the 3rd position of the marking system. The letter “A” would be the softest grade
and the letter “Z” would be the hardest. By adjusting the grade, you allow the wheel to release
grains at an increased or decreased rate. Typical precision grinding operations using vitreous
bonded wheels will usually use a grade between D and M. The grade of the wheel affects its
material removal rate, as a softer wheel offers the constant presence of new sharp grains and the
release of older dull grains. Grade also affects the form holding capability of the wheel. It is
difficult to hold a tight part form with a soft wheel grade. The chart below covers these points and
more:
A harder grade can be used on soft, easily penetrated materials than on hard materials
which naturally tend to dull the wheel faster. However, the softer grade wheel releases the dulled
grains more readily, enabling the new, sharp grains lying under it to do the work.
Structure:
The structure of a grinding wheel is a measurement of its porosity, or the amount of air
relative to other components. Structure is represented by a number that generally ranges from 4 to
30. The lower the number, the less porous the wheel. A 4, 5 or 6 structure would be considered a
very dense wheel. At the other end of the spectrum, 24 – 30 structure wheels are very porous.
Manufacturers typically induce structures over an 8 by putting an additional ingredient into the
mix that will burn off during firing and leave small hollows in the wheel. Porosity can be
“engineered” into the construction of a Targa wheel, which has an extruded ceramic grain.
High porosity leads to better coolant delivery into the cut plus better removal of the swarf
from the grind zone, so porous wheels are typically used in surface and creepfeed grinding
applications. The downside of a porous wheel is shorter wheel life.
Grade/Structure Shifts
Structure can affect wheel life positively or negatively. This creates a problem when
adjusting more than one wheel parameter at a time. In general, shifting the structure by three
points is equivalent to one letter grade. So if you move from an “E” grade “18” structure to an “F”
grade in a “21” structure you will have two wheels which act the same as regards hardness. The
below chart demonstrates this fact:
The bond type is called out by the 5th position in the marking system.
• The vitrified call-out letter is almost always a “V,” while the others vary depending on the
grinding wheel manufacturer.
• One of the most important things to remember when using vitrified grinding wheels is that
they are extremely fragile. The manufacturing process is very similar to that of china
dinner plates. It is a glass bond fired in a kiln at high temperatures (approximately 2300°
F) for a set time. As the wheel size increases, so does the “burn time,” or length of time in
the kiln.
• Vitrified bonds wear by pressure breaking the bond posts in the grinding wheel. The
majority of vitrified grinding wheel wear comes from the truing process. This is why an
increase in parts per dress is directly related to an increase in wheel life. Other key points
to remember about vitrified bonds versus other bonds:
• Excellent resistance to abrasion from the part
• Good form holding ability
• Free cutting bond (porosity)
• Excellent ability to draw coolant into grind zone
• “Self sharpening” bond (releasing of dull abrasive grains)
Vitrified bonded wheels are generally used for fast-cutting action and commercial finish.
Resinoid, Rubber and Shellac bonded wheels produce the highest finish
Bond Modification:
Abrasive Grain Grit Size Grade Structure
Bond Type Bond Modification
5SG 60 – L 8 V HP
The 6th and last position in the wheel marking system is what we call the bond
modification. This is basically the wheel manufacture’s way to internally identify the differences
in the bond system. It designates, among other things, bond traits, speed limitations, and specialty
bonds for specific abrasives. And wheel manufacturers generally do not release the meanings of
each modification.
Whether the grinding is done wet or dry
Generally for precision grinding, coolant is necessary. However, in some cases (e.g. Tool
Regrinding) the process may be dry, in which case a softer grade wheel may be necessary.
Whereas for wet grinding, a one grade harder wheel can be used as the coolant reduces the
heat generated in grinding.
WHEEL SPEED
• The speed at which the grinding wheel is to be operated often dictates the type of
bond.
• Vitrified Bonded wheels should not be used at peripheral speeds over 33 meters
per second except for specially designed wheels.
• Standard organic bonded wheels (resinoid, rubber and shellac) are used in most
applications of over 35 meters upto 45 meters per second, and specially designed
wheels for speeds upto 80 meters per second.
• The speed at which a grinding wheel revolves is important. Too slow a speed
means wastage of abrasive without much useful work achieved, whereas an
excessive speed may result in a hard grinding action and may introduce the danger
of breakage. Hence the safe operating speed marked on the wheel or blotter, in
revolutions per minute must never be exceeded.
• As a general rule, it is best to operate a grinding wheel at somewhere near the
speed recommended for a certain grinding operation. Some of the more common
operating speed guidelines for particular types of grinding wheels are listed below,
in surface meters per second. A mild abrasive such as 86A, 32A or 38A is best
Conclusion
The grinding wheel is a unique part of the grinding process. Abrasive cost is typically only
2-4% of the entire process cost. But that 2-4% can affect more than 15% of your process cost by
improving cycle times, improving quality, and combining operations. When you look at the
grinding process as a system you can permanently improve it, leading to meaningful savings: The
type of savings that will help you compete in the global economy.
Surface Grinder
In grinding, an abrasive material rubs against the metal part and removes tiny
pieces of material. The abrasive material is typically on the surface of a wheel or belt
and abrades material in a way similar to sanding. On a microscopic scale, the chip
formation in grinding is the same as that found in other machining processes. The
abrasive action of grinding generates excessive heat so that flooding of the cutting
area with fluid is necessary.
The figure above is of the horizontal spindle, reciprocating table type, as detailed
below.
Other Types of Flat Surface Grinding
Other types of flat surface grinding machine configurations are shown below.
Surface Grinding Design Guidelines
2. Magnetic chucks are typically used for holding down parts during surface
grinding. If the part can be designed to be compatible with a magnetic chuck,
convenience and throughput increase. Use of a magnetic chuck requires a
ferrous (magnetic) material and a flat seating surface opposite the ground
surface.
Centered Grinding
Grinding for surfaces of rotation (axially symmetric surfaces) can be either
centered or centerless. Centered grinding involves fixturing the part on a spindle
axis as it is ground, as illustrated below.
This configuration can be compared to fixturing a part on a lathe with or without a tail stock. The abrasive material is on a grinding
wheel that rotates in a direction such that rolling or sliding contact occurs where the wheel and work piece touch. Centered grinding is
accurate and stable, but set-up takes time and through-put suffers.
Centered Grinding Part Design: External
2. For inside corners, the best practice is to machine a relief at the corner prior
to grinding so that a sharp ninety-degree male object can be placed in the
corner. This is illustrated below.
For internal holes with sharp corners, the figure below illustrates recommended
practice.
a. The figure below shows how inside radii merging with cylindrical
surfaces are to be avoided.
b. The illustration below shows how tapers and angular surfaces should be
replaced by straight surfaces if possible.
2. Radii should be the same in order to simplify wheel dressing and minimize
tool changes.
3. Hole depth to diameter aspect ratio should be minimized. This is for the same
reasons that bored holes are not too deep. Avoiding length to diameter ratios
of more than six is a good practice.
4. If possible, blind holes should be avoided. Blind holes restrict the flow of
coolant.
Circumferential interruptions should be avoided. Even axial interruptions
should be avoided.
5. An option to consider is a hardened and ground liner. This option must be
weighed against the tolerance build up and extra logistics involved.
Adequate access for coolant flow should be provided. This can be difficult since
the coolant shed by the rotating grinding wheel provides an effective "curtain"
which prevents coolant exchange
Through-Feed Grinding
In through-feed grinding, the part rotates between the grinding wheel and a
regulating wheel as shown below.
For through-feed grinding, one or both wheels of the centerless grinding machine
are canted out of the horizontal plane, as shown below. This imparts a horizontal
velocity component to the work piece, so that outside feed mechanisms are not
necessary.
The grinding wheel is canted with respect to the other two axes so that a
component of its surface velocity pushes the part in the direction shown below.
This auto feeding characteristic is useful for rapidly processing many parts in quick
sequence.
Because of the axial movement, through-feed parts can only have right circular
cylindrical ground surfaces. The wheel cannot be dressed to grind more complex
shapes.
Below are parts produced with the through-feed centerless grinding process. As can
be seen from the quantities produced, through-feed grinding is primarily a mass-
production process because of its high throughput.
In-Feed Grinding
In-feed grinding differs from through-feed grinding in that the part is not fed axially
so that the ground surface does not need to be a right circular cylinder. The
grinding wheel can be dressed to accomodate the part. Once the work piece part is
in place, the grinding wheel is fed in radially.
Because of the set up time involved for each part, in-feed griding does not have the
high throughput of through-feed grinding. In-feed grinding is illustrated below.
End-Feed Grinding
In end-feed grinding, the part moves in axially between the grinding wheels, stops
for grinding, and then moves out again. The wheel can be dressed to form more
complex shapes, but the part can only get progressively smaller in diameter. End-
feed grinding is illustrated below.
1. The largest diameter of the workpiece should have the ground surface, if
possible. This allows through-feed grinding.
5. As the following diagram shows, internal grinding should allow for as large a
diameter tool support as possible. This illustration shows a hole with an
entrance that is smaller than that of the ground area.