Combined Boxing Protocol Docs
Combined Boxing Protocol Docs
Combined Boxing Protocol Docs
Guiding Question: How does our perception of high quality work shift when looking
at external examples?
LSBoxingProtocol:HighQualityWork
March2015
Team PriorKnowledge
CommonText
ExpertText
PK
Thereisadifferenceinbeliefandpractice
abouthowmuchscaffoldingisappropriate.
Isitokthatovelofcratsmanshipisntalways
evidentinfinalproductalone?
Thevalueoffullyrepresentingtheprocess
Finalproductsseemmissingsomething
entirelychildlikewithoutthefullpicure
WouldappreciateanECEspecificrubricfor
HQW
Wasthistheonlystorythechildwrote?
Illustrations&storywereconnected
Isthereacorrelationbetweenthevertical
alignmentofthelevelofqualityandteacher
familiarityELsdefinitionofHQ?
Iwonderwhatwasthestartingpointfor
thestory?Didtheteachergivethe
studentsPrompts?
Iwonderwhyauthenticitybecamemore
ofachallengeintheuppergrade
levels?
Whatstheprocessofhighquality
work?(fromworkselectiontofinaldraft)
WhyisthelevelofqualityworkNOT
aligned?Isityourunderstandingofthe
Howmanyroundsofcritiquetook
placeforbutterfulystories(illustration)?
OurQWisgreat!
Valueofshowingprocessalongwith
product
Whatquestionsdidteachersaskto
pushthinking&encouragedetails?
Itseemslikestorytellingisavery
commonproductinPK
Handwrittenortyped?
Whatmakesahighquality
productready?(spelling,
accuracy,neatness)
Choiceinmaterials?
Detailed!
Experts?
Youngerstudentsworkalmost
seemstohavemore
craftsmanship
ELcompelsstudentstoproduceHQW
Craftsmanshipissupportedbyexperts
whosharetheirwisdom&techniques
Authenticpurpose
Reallifemeaning/purpose
Multipledrafts&critique
Teachersgivefeedbacktokeeppushing
workforward
WhatdoesfeedbackonHQW
look/soundlike?
Howdoyouengagedstudentsatthis
ageindeveopingestablishedcriteria?
Teacherssupport
Reflect
Studentsworkhard*
Perseverance*
Authentic
Creatingrealworkforreal
audiences*
Engaginginrevision*
Analyzingmodelstobuildavision
ofquality
Doeshighquality=beautiful?
Critique***
Real,publicaudience*
Wholeschoolcelebratesculture
Persevaerancecandomorethan
youthought
Drafting*
Models
Feedbackfrommanysources
Reflection
Howdoespeercritiqueworkfor
subjectivepiecces?
Highqualityworkismaking
multipledrafts*
Qualityoverquantity
Highexpectations
Expertsintopic
Createrealworkforrealaudiences
Multipledraftsthinkingabouthowthis
looksinEC
Studentsneed
motivation
toproduce
manydrafts/careaboutquality
qualityworkdifferentorchoiceofwork
tocritiqueandrevisevaried?
Doesthehighqualityworkdependon
whochoseittogothroughtherevision
process?
Doallteachersusearubrictoassess
highqualitywork?Eveninlower
grades?
Howbigisthisworkintermsofthe
wholeexpedition?
Howmuchstudentvoiceishonoredfor
thiswork?
Whatelementsdidtheyhighlightfor
stories?
Authenticityharderatoldergrades?
Timeline.Whorevises?Howmany
people?Experts?
Howhighqualityworkpromotedatall
grades?
Guidelines?Audience?
Meetingall3criteriaischallenging?
Howdidtheyusepeercritiquefor
storiesinPK?
DoesLowerSchooluserubrics?
Authenticity(dontforget)
AppropriatescaffoldingisnecessaryforHQW
VerticalalignmenthowcanwebegininK?
TeachersneedtobefamiliarwithhowHQis
defined
Yearlongexpedition
Providingmoretimeandexposuretotopicof
study
Studentsneedwaystoevaluatetheirown
work/becomeindependent
Alotofconnectionstolocal
community
feelsauthentic
Connection:ABusinessforCharity
@KettleFalls(2nd)&TwoRivers(1st)
Howelsecanworkbeauthentic?
ExpeditiontopicshowdoesHQW
showwhataschoolvalues?
WecanpushkidstocreateHQW,but
howdowemakeitimportanttothem?
1st
Buildsperseverance
Canbechallengingforsomestudentsto
keeptrying
Variousvoicesforfeedback
peers
experts
teachers
Abouttheprocesstakestime
Highexpectationsscaffoldtogetthere
Realworldimplications
Models
:readings,activities
Howtostudentindependence
IsitmorelikelythatworkwillbeHQif
itsimportanttothem?Yes,sohow.
Prompts/draftswhatdotheylooklike?
Whatwasthescaffoldingforthework?
Ongoingquestionjustbecausestudents
can
dosomething,
should
theydoit?(DAP)
HQbutauthenticidk?
Inworkattheseams,Ihopewemakesure
theworkistargetingallgradelevels,insupport
Rubricsasastudenttoolfeelsmore
supportivethanateacherscoringguide
Verticallyaligned?
HowdoyouresearchinK?(books,
computers)
Whatdoesnotetakinglooklike?
Researchbuddy
WhatdoesascaffoldedtasklooklikeinK?
ex.birddrawingshowcanwemakeitmore
authentic
writing/research
Notjustaboutcraftsmanship
Critique
Peercritique
Peerreviewsaswellasteacher
Feedbackfromteachers&peers
Craftsmanship
Noworksamplesthatshowall3qualities
Aftereachstageoftheproduct,theworkwas
higherquality
Sharingsimilarwork/studyofstudents
ofotherschoolsimportant
Connectiontorealworld/realwork
importantentomologisthat
Multipledrafts
Targettedfeedback
Highexpectations
Creativitytokeepthekidsinvolved
Studentdriven
Productforauthenticaudience
Allowingstudentstostruggleand
encourageperseveringthroughstruggle
Givingopportunitestoshowexemplars
show/talkaboutprocesstogetthere
Multipledraftswitheachdraftthecleanerthe
craftmanshipbecame
SeveraldraftsmorethanIamusedtousing
moretimetofocusongreetingcards?
Multipledraftsassumptions:
peerreview
teacherpushing
perseverance/practice
Multipledraftsalonedoesnot=success,
multipledrafts+peer/expertcritique=more
HQW
Studentlearnedthatwithpeercritiquetheir
productcouldbebetter
Craftmashipgoesup,authenticitygoesdown
Rubricdesignedasteachertoolvs.student
tool
CanwegetmorePDoncreatingstudent
friendlyrubrics?
Howtoliftstrugglingstudentstocomplete
complextasks
Verticalalignment
Howcanweverticallyalignwithhowwethink
HQWlooks?(commonlanguage
understanding)
IsQWcommonlydefinedatCapitalCity?
Peopleconfusecraftmanship(looks)vs.info
Studentvoiceandownershipis
importantinHQW
Studentswereawareoftime,energy,
&effortofHQW
Howmuchwasitstudentdrivenand
howmuchofitwasteacherwork?
Howwerethekidskeptexcitedabout
anyofthework?
Notenoughfocusonproduct?
CreatingHQproductvs.covering
content
Lotsoffocusoncraftsmanship
HowdoeventsfitintoHQW?
Kidsuselanguageaboutrevision
Stillwonderingaboutcomplexity&
differentiation
Draft/draft/draft
Alotofpracticesurroundingtaling
aboutprocess(2ndgradeexample)
K/1stillquestionsaboutteachervs.
studentinfinaldraft
(forlackofbetterword)
WhatisELsCenterforStudentWork?
2nd
Requireshigherorderthinkingfrom
students
Goesthroughmultiplesubjects
Manydrafts
Goesthroughmultiplerevisions/drafts
Goesthrougharevision&critique
process
Studentcentered&driven
Studentsfeelownershipfortheirwork
Meetscriteriastudentsareawareofthe
criteria&selfassessagainstit
Hasauthenticpurposeandaudience
hasanauthenticaudience/purposecan
thishappensansaudience?realworld
Thereisalevelofcraftsmanship
HQWlooksdifferentatdifferentlevels&
evendifferentinsidethesamelevel
Studentproduceworkunderateachers
guidance,theirworkisoriginal,teachers
donotdotheworkforthem!
Topics?
Buildsonstudentsauthenticexperiences
Appliedskills
Howdowemaketheproductauthenticand
relatedtothelearningtarget?
Purposeandaudienceforced?
selfreflection+assessmentforstudents
Goodintrotoproject,thendetailabouthow
artportion(finalproduct)wasHQW.Im
wonderingaboutthebusinessaspect,sinthat
wasthelearningtargetcomplexity.
Revisonforwhatpurpose?(ie.lotsof
insect/birddrawingsotherspacesforrevision)
Isabookanauthenticproduct?Whomisthe
audience?
Howdowecloselyalignproductstoour
guidingquestions?
ReminderofwhatHQWlookslike
HQW/expeditionsneedtohitcloseto
homeforkids
Differentkindsofproducts
3rd
Audience
Howcanataskbequalityformoststudents?
Lotsofediting
Local
4th
Drafts
Levelofqualityisdeterminedchildby
child
Helpingstudentsmoveforward
Pushesstudents
Critique/feedback
Feedbackiscritical
Supportedbyschoolstructures
Takestime
Ischallenging
Showingprocessmatters
Studentabilitytoconnectthedots,describe
theprocessiscrucial
Tasksneedtomeetstudentswheretheyare
Havingglobalstandardsvs.specific
taskbasedonesishard
Streamliningtheprocess.Keepingall
studentsmotivatedhow?
Isitapieceofworkorabodyofwork?
Movefromteacherbasedrubricstostudent
involvedrubricshow?
Howimportantispresentation?
Purposefulmaking
Howcanexpectationsofqualitybehigherfor
a3rdgradervsa6th?
Complextext?
Verticallyalignedcomplexity&authenticity?
local?
writing?Art
Youngergradequalityisuncleardue
tothelevelofteacherhelp
Highquality=parent/guardian
participation?
Drafting,drafting,drafting
Art/imageseemstomatter
Focus
Attentiontodetail/process/backing
HQworkisdifferentiated
HQworkismultistep
Workintendedforpublicaudiences
HQwork@CCPCSisstilldevelopinginthe
areaofauthenticity
CCPCSwillcontinuetodevelopasystematic
andunifiedcriteriaofHQWthatwilltranlate
intorubricsandtoolsforuse
Integratingreading,writing,
arts
emphasisonbeauty
ShouldHQWshowevidenceofrigor
acrossallcontentareas?(Notseeing
alotofmath)
HQworkgoesthroughtherevision
process:critique,feedback,incorporating
peer/adultfeedback
HQWinovlesmultipledrafts,revision,
andcritque
multipledraftsalways?(timing
feedback)
rubricsselfreflection+peercritique
Doesitdependonthestudentor
gradelevelexpectations?
Whatdoesavisionofqualitylooklike?
Authenticity
Contentoverload/overlap=nottimefordepth/quality?
Importanceofprocessshowing
Roleofteacherinyoungergrades
Craftsmanshipreliesonmultiplestagesof
work,notjustviewedinthefinalproductalone
Qualitygoesupasgradesgodown,why?
Whatarethebehindthescenesworkthat
raisecomplexity,&craftsmanship&
authenticity?
Studentsneedexposure&practicewithusing
rubrics&applyingthemtobothstrong&weak
models
Howcanwemakesurerubricsarevertically
aligned?
Creatingstudenttoolsvs.teachertools
WhatexpectationsforHQWweresharedwith
KettleFallsstudents?
Exampledemonstrateduseoftechnology,
multistepprocesspracticeforpresentation
writtenworkdraftedandimproved.
EvidenceofHQwrittencomponent
rehearsal?
WhatmethoddoesELusetoevaluateHQ
work?
Balancebetweencoolprojectsand
authenticity
Finalproductsoutofcontext&without
rubricsistrickytoevaluate
Productsweremultisensoryand
openendedwithstudentchoice
embedded
Howcanourstudentsbemore
investedinthepeerrevisionprocess?