Acc Chem Res 2008 Hiyama-Denmark Coupling Review
Acc Chem Res 2008 Hiyama-Denmark Coupling Review
Acc Chem Res 2008 Hiyama-Denmark Coupling Review
CON SPECTUS
n the panoply of modern synthetic methods for forming carbon-carbon and carbon-heteroatom bonds, the transition
metal-catalyzed cross-coupling of organometallic nucleophiles with organic electrophiles enjoys a preeminent status. The
preparative utility of these reactions is, in large measure, a consequence of the wide variety of organometallic donors that
have been conscripted into service. The most common of these reagents are organic derivatives of tin, boron, and zinc, which
each possess unique advantages and shortcomings. Because of their low cost, low toxicity, and high chemical stability, organosilanes have emerged as viable alternatives to the conventional reagents in recent years. However, unlike the tin- and
zinc-based reactions, which require no activation, or the boron-based reactions, which require only heating with mild bases,
silicon-based cross-coupling reactions often require heating in the presence of a fluoride source; this has significantly hampered the widespread acceptance of organosilanes.
To address the fluoride problem, we have introduced a new paradigm for palladium-catalyzed, silicon-based crosscoupling reactions that employs organosilanols, a previously underutilized class of silicon reagents. The use of organosilanols either in the presence of Brnsted bases or as their silanolate salts represents a simple and mild alternative to the
classic fluoride-based activation method. Organosilanols are easily available by many well-established methods for introducing carbon-silicon bonds onto alkenes, alkynes, and arenes and heteroarenes. Moreover, we have developed four different protocols for the generation of alkali metal salts of vinyl-, alkenyl-, alkynyl-, aryl-, and heteroarylsilanolates: (1)
reversible deprotonation with weak Brnsted bases, (2) irreversible deprotonation with strong Brnsted bases, (3) isolation of the salts from irreversible deprotonation, and (4) silanolate exchange with disiloxanes. We have demonstrated the
advantages of each of these methods for a number of different coupling classes.
The defining feature of this new process is the formation of a covalently linked palladium silanolate species that facilitates the critical transmetalation step. We have verified the intermediacy of a critical species that contains the key Si-O-Pd
linkage by its identification as the resting state in reaction mixtures, by X-ray analysis, and by demonstrating its competence in thermal cross-coupling with no additives. Our conclusions contradict the long-standing dogma that silicon-based
cross-coupling reactions require the generation of a pentacoordinate siliconate prior to transmetalation. This revelation has
opened a new vista for discovery of reactions that involve this critical process.
Work in this field (silicon-based cross-coupling) has been quite active since the initial disclosure of siletane cross-coupling from these
laboratories.... Future studies are focused on several fronts, including the extension of scope to
incorporate less reactive substrates such as chlorides and triflates, further optimization of alkenyl/
1486
1486-1499
November 2008
SCHEME 1
Introduction
Transition-metal-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions are now
considered to be among the most general methods for the formation of carbon-carbon and carbon-heteroatom bonds.1
Since the independent reports from Kumada and Corriu,2 on
the reaction of organomagnesium reagents with organic
halides, numerous other organometallic nucleophiles have
been developed with varying levels of utility. The most popular among these are organotin, organoboron, and organozinc
reagents because of their stability and good functional group
compatibility.1 Nevertheless, an enduring objective in this field
is the search for reactions that proceed under mild conditions
without toxic byproducts and that employ cheap, readily available starting materials.
In recent years, the cross-coupling reactions of organosilicon compounds have emerged as viable alternatives.3 The
development of organosilanes as cross-coupling partners has
been slower than that of the other organometallic compounds
because of the lower reactivity of organosilanes. However, in
1989, Hiyama reported a major breakthrough by capitalizing on the high affinity of fluoride for organosilanes,4 to
enhance the rate of transmetalation through the formation of
pentacoordinate siliconates.5 In the pentacoordinate complex,
transmetalation is facilitated by the enhanced polarization of
the Si-C bond. Since the pioneering work of Hiyama and
Hatanaka,6 organosilanes have achieved broader utility
through the introduction of heteroatoms7 on the silicon moiety. In particular, chloro- and fluorosilanes are more potent
cross-coupling partners, but they are also hydrolytically sensitive and thus more difficult to handle. Accordingly, heteroatom surrogates (siletanes, 2-pyridyl-, 2-thienyl-, and
benzylsilanes)8 have been introduced that have a greater stability and can be converted to more reactive heterofunctional
silanes in the presence of fluoride sources.7,8 For example,
SCHEME 2
November 2008
1486-1499
1487
tually stimulating this investigation would be and what surprises lay waiting to be discovered.
SCHEME 3
halide. How else can the Si-C bond be activated for transmetalation in the absence of fluoride? Initial hypotheses proposed that the conjugate base of silanol (E)-4 could serve this
function in two ways (Figure 1): (1) the in situ generated silanolate (i) could form an organopalladium(II) silanolate complex (ii) by the displacement of the halide from the
organopalladium(II) complex (ArylPdLnX), and (2) a second
equivalent of i could serve as the nucleophilic activator to form
the desired pentacoordinate siliconate (iii). This species would
undergo intramolecular transmetalation with simultaneous formation of polysiloxanes. In this proposal, the role of the second silanolate is analogous to the established role of fluoride
in the preceding transformation.
1486-1499
November 2008
kobs)k[Pd]1
(1)
n)1
when
(2)
n)0
when
(3)
This equation is consistent with the saturation of a reactive intermediate prior to transmetalation, but it was not clear
whether that species is ii or iii. These possibilities were distin-
amount of palladium relative to K (E)-4 . Under these conditions, a first-order dependence on silanolate was observed.
These critical experiments revealed an inconsistency with our
original proposal (Figure 1).16 If iii were a reactive intermediate prior to transmetalation a second-order dependence on
K+(E)-4- should be observed with a superstoichiometric loading of palladium and substoichiometric amount of K+(E)-4-.
This result suggests that the transmetalation proceeds directly
from an arylpalladium(II) silanolate ii complex (Figure 2). These
data also imply that the first-order dependence on K+(E)-4(under catalytic conditions) is consistent with a turnover-limiting bimolecular displacement of halide by K+(E)-4- (i to ii).
Therefore, at high concentrations of K+(E)-4- intramolecular
transmetalation from an arylpalladium(II) silanolate (ii to iv)
becomes turnover limiting.
These results mandated a revision of the original mechanistic proposal to incorporate an intramolecular transmetalation from a neutral species (Figure 2, ii to iv), thus contradicting
the dogma that silicon-based cross-coupling reactions require
the generation of a pentacoordinate silicate prior to transmetalation (Hiyama-Hatanaka paradigm). Furthermore, these
observations illustrate the critical importance of the Si-O-Pd
linkage for this new transmetalation pathway. To confirm this
new hypothesis, additional evidence was needed to support
the intermediacy of ii by its isolation and demonstration of its
kinetic competence in the absence of additional silanolate.
This rate equation is consistent with a turnover-limiting transmetalation of an arylpalladium(II) silanolate and is similar to the
observed rate equation for the cross-coupling of K+(E)-4- (eq 3).
These data once again rule out activation by a second equivalent of silanolate to generate a pentacoordinate siliconate prior
to transmetalation. Moreover, the key arylpalladium(II) silanolate intermediate (iii) could be detected by 31P NMR spectroscopy in reaction mixtures (L-L ) dppp). Finally, complex 12 was
independently synthesized and fully characterized including
single-crystal X-ray analysis (Figure 4).19
The isolation of 12 allowed for the demonstration that
arylpalladium(II) silanolate complexes can undergo transmetalation in the absence of an activator. Heating 12 to 100 C
provides the biaryl product in quantitative yield. This result
unambiguously demonstrates that a neutral arylpalladium(II)
November 2008
1486-1499
1489
SCHEME 4
1486-1499
November 2008
SCHEME 5
SCHEME 6
1.3. Aryl Silanolates. In contrast to alkenyl- and alkynylsilanolates, arylsilanolates are less reactive cross-coupling partners and require more forcing conditions to undergo
productive reaction. After thorough optimization, we found
that Cs2CO3 in toluene at 90 C effects the cross-coupling of
dimethyl(4-methoxyphenyl)silanol 16 with ethyl 4-iodobenzoate.18 Optimization studies revealed that the level of hydration of Cs2CO3 significantly influences the overall conversion.
The addition of 3.0 equiv of water per equiv of Cs2CO3 proves
to be general for reactions of a range of aryl bromides and
aryl iodides in the presence of [allylPdCl]2 with dppb or Ph3As
to suppress homocoupling of the halide (Scheme 6). The
scope in the aryl halide partner is broad; however a similar
range is not found for the dimethyl(aryl)silanol component. For
example, cross-coupling of dimethyl(4-trifluorotolyl)silanol with
4-bromoanisole provides the product with poor selectivity and
low yield (54%). A solution to these problems will be
addressed in the Isolation section below.
1.4. Five-Membered Heterocyclic Silanolates. Fivemembered heterocycles are well represented within the fields
of pharmaceutical, materials, and natural product chemistry.
Moreover, indole-containing compounds are among the most
common heterocycles in nature, and the broad range of biological activity has stimulated research into their construction
for decades.26
Given the importance of 2-substituted indoles, N-Boc-dimethyl(2-indolyl)silanol (18) and N-methyl-dimethyl(2-indolyl)silanol (19) were prepared to evaluate the utility of silanolbased reagents.27 The sodium silanolates of 18 and 19 are
formed in situ under the action of NaOt-Bu, and these salts are
excellent coupling partners for a range of aryl halides. Optimal conditions for the cross-coupling reaction of 18 and 19
employ NaOt-Bu (2.0 equiv), [Pd2(dba)3] CHCl3 (5 mol %), and
CuI (1.0 equiv). A variety of substrates including electron-rich,
electron-poor, and 2-substituted aryl iodides react smoothly
under these conditions (Scheme 7).
However, the cross-coupling of 19 with electron-deficient
aryl iodides affords the desired product in lower yields
because of the formation of the 2,3-bisaryl indole as the major
product. Fortunately, the less reactive aryl bromides led to the
generation of the desired products in good yields (Scheme 8).
4-Isoxazolylsilanols (22) are also viable substrates for the
cross-coupling reaction under NaOt-Bu activation. The isoxazole is constructed by dipolar cycloaddition of alkynyldimethylsilyl ethers (23) and in situ prepared aryl nitrile oxides
(Scheme 9). The silicon function controls the regioselectivity of
the [3 + 2] cycloaddition, and it enables further functionalization through the cross-coupling reaction. Optimal conditions
for the coupling employ NaOt-Bu and [Pd2(dba)3] CHCl3 in toluene or dioxane at 80 C to produce the 3,4,5-trisubstituted
isoxazoles 25.28
1.5. Synthetic Application. The reversible deprotonation
protocol was highlighted in the total synthesis of the antifungal agent (+)-papulacandin D (26).29 One of the key steps in
the synthesis is the cross-coupling reaction of glucal silanol 27
with aromatic iodide 28 (Scheme 10).
November 2008
1486-1499
1491
SCHEME 7
SCHEME 9
SCHEME 10
SCHEME 8
1486-1499
November 2008
Finally, a strategy that combines both fluoride-free and fluoride-promoted reactions has been developed for the sequential cross-coupling reaction of differently functionalized 1,4bissilylbutadienes.30 One end of the 1,4-bissilylbutadiene
bears a silanol that can easily be converted to the potassium
silanolate with KOSiMe3. The other end bears a safety-catch
November 2008
1486-1499
1493
SCHEME 13
SCHEME 15
SCHEME 14
SCHEME 16
tions of both preformed sodium 2-furylsilanolate Na+36and 2-thienylsilanolate Na+37- proceed in an analogous
fashion to Na+35- with electron-deficient and electron-rich
aryl iodides. In addition, the cross-coupling of Na+36- and
Na+37- with aryl bromides can be effected with the Pd(I)
catalyst 41 (Scheme 15).
Unfortunately, the preformation protocol could not be
extended to N-Boc-dimethyl[(5-methoxy)-2-indolyl]silanol 42.
Attempts to prepare Na+42- with 1.0 equiv of NaH led to
20% protiodesilylation. The problem of protiodesilylation in
the preformation of 42 could be solved by the use of
NaHMDS, which provided an 82% yield of the desired cross1494
1486-1499
November 2008
SCHEME 17
The first cross-coupling reaction is initiated by the preformation of Na+30- with NaH. The resulting silanolate reacts
smoothly with 50 in the presence of Pd2(dba)3 CHCl3, to
afford triene 51 in 77% yield. The second cross-coupling reaction is initiated by in situ unmasking of the benzylsilane to the
corresponding silanol in TBAF 3H2O. The cross-coupling reaction of 51 with (E)-iodopropenoate 49 provides the key tetraene 52 in 79% yield (Scheme 18).
3. Isolation. To streamline the manipulation of (aryl)- and
(heteroaryl)dimethylsilanolates, their salts can be isolated from
the irreversible deprotonation protocol. The salts are stable,
storable solids that can be charged directly into a reaction
mixture and are competent nucleophiles for a broad range of
organic halides.
3.1. Sodium N-SEM-Dimethyl(2-indolyl)silanolate. The
sodium salt of N-SEM-dimethyl(2-indolyl)silanolate (53) (SEM
Vol. 41, No. 11
November 2008
1486-1499
1495
) 2-(trimethylsilyl)ethoxymethyl) is easily prepared following the irreversible deprotonation protocol using NaH.
Removal of the solvent affords Na+53- as a colorless, freeflowing solid. This silanolate undergoes smooth cross-coupling with aryl chlorides (under conditions developed for
K+4-) to provide excellent yields of 2-substituted indoles 54
with a broad substrate scope (Scheme 19).27
SCHEME 20
SCHEME 19
The general utility of phosphine oxides in preparative reactions of aryl bromides was established by a survey in the presence of 5 mol % of Ph3PdO with 2.5 mol % of [allylPdCl]2.
Both electron-deficient and electron-rich aryl bromides reacted
within 1 h to afford moderate yields of the desired unsymmetrical biaryl products (Scheme 20).36
1496
1486-1499
November 2008
CHART 1
SCHEME 23
SCHEME 24
November 2008
1486-1499
1497
addition, the unique nature of silicon has enabled the amalgamation of the fluoride-promoted cross-coupling of organosilanes and this new silanolate-based process for the
development of sequential cross-coupling reactions.
The discovery of the fluoride-free process continues to stimulate the development of milder and more diverse conditions
and reagents for organosilicon cross-coupling reactions. Current
studies are focused on the demonstration of alkenyl-alkenyl
cross-coupling and the more difficult cross-coupling of alkylsilanols. Mechanistic studies are underway to elucidate the molecular detail of the elementary steps in the transmetalation of
palladium silanolates as well as the potential similarities to the
transmetalation process for organoboron compounds. Finally,
more exploratory endeavors involve the use of silanolates as precursors for the generation of organometallic species derived from
other elements, such as gold, nickel, copper, and rhodium.
From our current vantage point, it is remarkable that our
initial foray into the field of cross-coupling chemistry began
modestly with the testing of the strain-release Lewis acidity
concept and now has developed into a stimulating and
rewarding endeavor that continues to surprise, entice, and
challenge us at many different levels.
We are pleased to acknowledge the experimental and intellectual contributions of our co-workers in the cross-coupling subgroup, Aaron Bailey, John Baird, Christopher Butler, Timothy
Chang, Christophe Eggertswyler, Jack Liu, Jeff Kallemeyn, Tetsuya Kobayashi, Joseck Muhuhi, Michael Ober, Russell Smith,
Ramzi Sweis, Steve Tymonko, and Nathan Werner, whose
efforts have forged ideas into realities. Funding for this research
was provided by the National Institutes of Health (Grant
GM63167), Johnson and Johnson, Merck, and Aldrich. We are
also grateful to Johnson Mathey for gifts of palladium catalysts.
Note Added after ASAP. This paper was published on the
web on August 6, 2008 with an error in equation 3. The
revised version was published on October 28, 2008.
BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION
Scott E. Denmark was born in Lynbrook, New York, on 17 June
1953. He obtained an S.B. degree from MIT in 1975 and his
D.Sc.Tech from the ETH Zurich in 1980. That same year, he
began his career at the University of Illinois, and since 1991 he
has been the Reynold C. Fuson Professor of Chemistry. He is primarily interested in the invention of new synthetic reactions and
the origin of stereocontrol in fundamental bond-forming processes. Professor Denmark is currently the Editor-in-Chief of
Organic Reactions, is on the Board of Editors of Organic Syntheses, and is a Co-Editor of Topics in Stereochemistry.
1498
1486-1499
November 2008
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
November 2008
1486-1499
1499