American Indians and Crime: Bureau of Justice Statistics
American Indians and Crime: Bureau of Justice Statistics
American Indians and Crime: Bureau of Justice Statistics
Department of Justice
Office of Justice Programs
American Indians
and Crime
The rate for American Indians (124 violent crimes per 1,000
American Indians) was more than twice the rate for the Nation
(50 per 1,000 persons)
Janet Reno
Attorney General
Raymond C. Fisher
Associate Attorney General
Laurie Robinson
Assistant Attorney General
No11l Brennan
Deputy Assistant Attorney General
American Indians
and Crime
By Lawrence A. Greenfeld
and Steven K. Smith
BJS Statisticians
Violent victimizations*
• American Indians, experience per
All races
capita rates of violence which are more
American Indian
than twice those of the U.S. resident
Black
population.
White
Asian
0 60 120
Number of violent victimizations
per 1,000 persons age 12 or older
Murder*
• The murder rate among American
American Indian Indians is 7 per 100,000, a rate similar
Black
to that found among the general
White
population. The rate of murder among
Asian
blacks is more than 5 times that among
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Number of murders per American Indians.
100,000 persons, 1992-96
Age*
* ,
Average annual rate, 1992-96. American Indians in this report include
Alaska Natives and Aleuts. Asians
include Hawaiian Natives and Pacific
Islanders.
Offender race*
Race of victims • At least 70% of the violent victimiza-
American Indian tions experienced by American Indians
Black are committed by persons not of the
White same race — a substantially higher rate
Asian of interracial violence than experienced
0% 25% 50% 75% by white or black victims.
Percent of violent victimizations
that were interracial
Lethal violence
American Indians
Handgun
All races
*
Average annual rate or percentage, 1992-96.
Under age 18
• American Indian arrest rates for
American
Indian All ages violence among youth were about the
Black same as the rates among white youth
in 1996.
White
*
Average annual percentage, 1992-96.
U.S. total
• An estimated 63,000 American Indians
are under the care, custody, or control
American Indian
of the criminal justice system on an
Black average day — about 4% of the Ameri-
White can Indian population age 18 or older.
Asian
0 5,000 10,000 • On average in 1997 about 2,000
Total under correctional supervision
American Indians per 100,000 adults
or control per 100,000 adults, 1997 (persons age 18 or older) were serving
a sentence to probation, about half the
rate found among blacks.
American Indians have higher per The NCVS collects information on the
capita rates of violent criminal victimi- Nation's experience with crime. It also
zation than whites, blacks, or Asians collects information on the race of the
in the United States, according to data victim and the race of the offender as
from the National Crime Victimization reported by the victim.
Survey (NCVS).
The NCVS provides estimates of the
Population estimates from the Bureau violent crimes of rape, sexual assault,
of the Census for July 1, 1998, indicate robbery, and assault for persons age
that American Indians account for just 12 or older. During 1992-96 the NCVS
under 1% of the U.S. population: found that American Indians experi-
enced an average of almost 150,000
All races 270,029,000 100.0% violent crimes per year from among the
American Indian* 2,357,000 0.9 estimated 10.8 million violent crimes
White 222,932,000 82.6
occurring on average per year among
Black 34,370,000 12.7
Asian 10,370,000 3.8 all racial groups. Victimization data for
1996 indicate that American Indians
Two demographic factors distinguish accounted for about 1.4% of all violent
American Indians from other racial victimizations that year, about the
groups: in 1998 the median age of the same percentage as in preceding
American Indian population is nearly 8 years.
years younger than the U.S. resident
population, and American Indians are American Indian tribes in the
the most likely to report Hispanic United States, 1996
ethnicity.
Median Percent The indigenous peoples in the
Race age Hispanic United States belong to about 550
All races 35.2 years 11.3% federally recognized tribes that
American Indian 27.4 15.2 have a distinct history and culture
White 36.3 12.4 and often a separate language.
Black 29.9 5.0
Asian 31.2 5.8 Percent of
Tribe American Indians
Cherokee 16.4%
This report presents data on the rates Navajo 11.7
and characteristics of violent crimes, Chippewa 5.5
including murder, experienced by Sioux 5.5
American Indians. Information is also Choctaw 4.4
Pueblo 2.8
*In this report the term American Indian refers Apache 2.7
to Alaska Natives, Aleuts, and American All other tribes 51.0
Indians. The term Asian encompasses Asians, Source: U.S. Bureau of Census,
Hawaiian Natives, and Pacific Islanders. Statistical Abstract of the United
States, 1997, table 51, p. 51.
American Indians have higher per The NCVS collects information on the
capita rates of violent criminal victimi- Nation's experience with crime. It also
zation than whites, blacks, or Asians collects information on the race of the
in the United States, according to data victim and the race of the offender as
from the National Crime Victimization reported by the victim.
Survey (NCVS).
The NCVS provides estimates of the
Population estimates from the Bureau violent crimes of rape, sexual assault,
of the Census for July 1, 1998, indicate robbery, and assault for persons age
that American Indians account for just 12 or older. During 1992-96 the NCVS
under 1% of the U.S. population: found that American Indians experi-
enced an average of almost 150,000
All races 270,029,000 100.0% violent crimes per year from among the
American Indian* 2,357,000 0.9 estimated 10.8 million violent crimes
White 222,932,000 82.6
occurring on average per year among
Black 34,370,000 12.7
Asian 10,370,000 3.8 all racial groups. Victimization data for
1996 indicate that American Indians
Two demographic factors distinguish accounted for about 1.4% of all violent
American Indians from other racial victimizations that year, about the
groups: in 1998 the median age of the same percentage as in preceding
American Indian population is nearly 8 years.
years younger than the U.S. resident
population, and American Indians are American Indian tribes in the
the most likely to report Hispanic United States, 1996
ethnicity.
Median Percent The indigenous peoples in the
Race age Hispanic United States belong to about 550
All races 35.2 years 11.3% federally recognized tribes that
American Indian 27.4 15.2 have a distinct history and culture
White 36.3 12.4 and often a separate language.
Black 29.9 5.0
Asian 31.2 5.8 Percent of
Tribe American Indians
Cherokee 16.4%
This report presents data on the rates Navajo 11.7
and characteristics of violent crimes, Chippewa 5.5
including murder, experienced by Sioux 5.5
American Indians. Information is also Choctaw 4.4
Pueblo 2.8
*In this report the term American Indian refers Apache 2.7
to Alaska Natives, Aleuts, and American All other tribes 51.0
Indians. The term Asian encompasses Asians, Source: U.S. Bureau of Census,
Hawaiian Natives, and Pacific Islanders. Statistical Abstract of the United
States, 1997, table 51, p. 51.
Annual average
Number of Rate of violent victimi-
Population violent zation per 1,000
age 12 or older victimizations persons age 12 or older
All races 213,660,000 10,784,826 50
American Indian 1,204,014 149,614 124
White 180,543,825 8,880,083 49
Black 25,587,158 1,570,386 61
Asian 6,325,003 184,743 29
Note: The NCVS estimates of the racial distribution of the resident population
age 12 or older for the period 1992-96 correspond closely to the estimates
reported by the Bureau of the Census in their P-25 series of population
estimates. The NCVS estimate shows that American Indians represented
0.6% of those interviewed while the P-25 estimate shows that American Indians
account for 0.8% of the resident population age 12 or older.
The average annual violent crime rate The average annual violent crime
among American Indians & 124 per rate per 1,000 persons age 12 or
1,000 persons age 12 or older & is older during that period was 49 for
about 2½ times the national rate whites and 61 for blacks.
(table 1).
The aggravated assault rate among
All races American Indians (35 per 1,000) was
American Indian more than 3 times the national rate
Black (11 per 1,000) and twice that for
White blacks. The rate of robbery experi-
Asian enced by American Indians (12 per
0 60 120 1,000) was similar to that of black
Number of violent victimizations
per 1,000 persons age 12 or older residents (13 per 1,000) (table 3).
For the 1992-96 period, the average The types of violent crimes experi-
annual per capita rate of violent victimi- enced by American Indians were
zation translates into about 1 violent generally similar to that found across
crime for every 20 residents age 12 or the Nation (table 4). The most
older. Substantial variation, however, common type of violent crime experi-
was evident by race. American enced by American Indian victims was
Indians experienced about 1 violent simple assault (56%).
crime for every 8 residents age 12 or American Indian
older compared to 1 violent victimiza- Black
tion for every 16 black residents, 1 for White
every 20 white residents, and 1 for Asian
every 34 Asian residents. 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Number of simple assaults per
Types of violent crime 1,000 persons age 12 or older
Among all the violent crimes reported
The Nation's population of American by American Indians, 28% were
Indians age 12 or older experienced an aggravated assault, 10% robbery, and
annual average of 126,400 simple and 6% rape/sexual assault. Asian and
aggravated assaults, 14,800 robberies, black victims of violence were more
and 8,400 rapes or sexual assaults likely than American Indian or white
during 1992-96. victims to have reported a robbery.
Average annual
number of victimizations 10,784,826 149,614 8,880,083 1,570,386 184,743
American Indians
for American Indians is more than 3
Rural
All races times that found among urban whites.
Victim-offender relationship
American Indians
Intimate
All races
Family
Acquaintance
Stranger
Table 10
Intimate and family violence involve a comparatively high level of alcohol and
drug use by offenders as perceived by victims — as is the case for Indian and
non-Indian victims. Indian victims of intimate and family violence, however,
are more likely than others to be injured and need hospital care.
Family v iolence
Interracial Intimate v iolence
Alcohol-involved
Victims injured
Note: Intimate violence refers to victimizations involving current and former spouses,
boyfriends, and girlfriends. Family violence refers to victimizations involving spouses
and other relatives. Alcohol-involved incidents included only those incidents in which
the victim felt that he/she could determine whether the offender had been using drugs
or alcohol.
Alcohol, drugs, and crime victims of violence were the most likely
to report such perceived use by the
Alcohol and drug use was a factor in offender.
more than half of violent crimes against
American Indians (table 11). Overall, in 55% of American Indian
violent victimizations, the victim said
Substantial differences can be found the offender was under the influence of
by race in the reports of victims of alcohol, drugs, or both. The offender’s
violence of their perceptions of drug use of alcohol and/or drugs was
and alcohol use by offenders. Among somewhat less likely in violent crimes
those who could describe alcohol or committed against whites (44%) or
drug use by offenders, American Indian blacks (35%).
Table 12
Percent reporting
workplace violence 31% 26% 32% 25% 31%
Table 15
Confrontational actions
Used physical force toward offender 18% 14% 15% 9%
Weapons 3 3 4 1
No weapons 16 11 12 9
Chased, tried to catch/hold offender 2 1 1 1
Defended self/property 16 15 16 11
Scared or warned off offender 4 5 5 5
Nonconfrontational actions
Persuaded or appeased offender 7% 9% 8% 11%
Ran away, hid, locked door 12 12 11 14
Got help or gave alarm 4 4 4 3
Other 7 12 10 9
Note: Victims may have used more than one measure.
Type of Injury
Sexual assault 2% 4% 2% 2% 3%
Shot/internal injuries 1 3 1 3 2
Broken bones/concussion 2 5 2 2 1
Bruises 18 18 18 19 17
Other injuries 3 2 2 4 2
Treatment for injuries
Not treated 57% 48% 59% 45% 55%
Treated 44 53 41 55 44
At hospital 19 32 16 26 24
Note: The percent treated was calculated on those injured during the violent incident.
Detail may not add to total because of rounding.
Table 19. Average dollar loss Table 20. Economic loss to American
per victim of violence, by race Indian victims of violent crime, by type
of victim, 1992-96 of loss, 1992-96
Race of victim Average
of violence dollar loss American Indian
All $878 victims of violence
American Indian 936 Reason Average loss Estimated total
White 818 for loss per victim annual loss
Black 1,081 Total $936 $35,123,400
Asian 810
Medical expenses $2,407 $21,227,333
Cash loss 223 960,907
Property
Loss $155 $1,403,370
Repair 152 1,907,680
Replacement 191 1,013,064
Lost pay from &
Injury $641 $4,433,797
Other causes 754 4,116,086
Table 22
150
100
50
0
1976 1980 1984 1988 1992 1996
Murders
Murders with known American
circumstances All races Indian White Black Asian
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Violent felony 14 11 16 11 27
Other felony offenses 10 5 10 11 8
Suspected felony 4 4 4 3 3
Brawl under the influence
of alcohol/drugs 5 13 6 4 2
Arguments 43 45 38 50 35
Other circumstances 24 22 27 21 25
Number 344,928 2,515 181,043 156,203 4,545
Note: Table excludes an estimated 101,446 murder victims for whom the
circumstances were not known.
Source: FBI, Supplemental Homicide Reports, 1976-96.
American Indian
White
Argument murders
Black
Violent f elony murders
Asian
Percent of murder
Victims of American
all races Indian White Black Asian
Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Victim/offender had
prior relationship 81.2 83.9 78.4 84.5 70.9
Victim/offender
were strangers 18.8 16.1 21.6 15.5 29.1
Same race 13.8 3.9 14.4 13.4 8.2
Different races 5.0 12.2 7.1 2.1 20.9
Number of murder victims 281,603 2,242 147,417 128,551 3,393
Note: Table excludes victims with unknown relationship
to offender and victims and offenders of unspecified races.
Handgun
Rifle/shotgun
Other firearm
Knife
Blunt object
Personal weapon*
Murder weapons
Unlike the pattern of violent crime arrest rates for other racial
groups & higher for youth than for the whole population &
among American Indians the arrest rates for those under
age 18 did not vary from the overall rate.
All ages
All races
Y outh
American Indian
Black
White
Asian
Probation (47%)
Probation (57%)
Federal prisons (2%)
Parole (12%)
American Indians comprised just over Compared to jail inmates of all races,
1% of the offenders on probation or when the statuses of conviction are
parole or in State or Federal prisons combined, American Indians were less
but an estimated 2.9% of persons in likely to have been jailed for a violent
local jails nationwide. American or drug offense (table 34). However,
Indians accounted for 2.5% of those consistent with their higher arrest rates
detained in local jails who had not for driving under the influence of
been convicted of crimes and 3% of alcohol, a substantial percentage of
the convicted offenders in jail serving American Indians reported that they
shorter sentences or awaiting transfer were in jail charged with or convicted
to other institutions. of an offense involving driving while
intoxicated (DWI). American Indians
accounted for an estimated 10% of
unconvicted jail inmates charged with
DWI and just over 4% of convicted
DWI offenders in local jails.
All offenses
Violent
Property
Public-order
&
Distribution of Indian country suspects investigated, by Federal court district&
Number of investigations
None
Fewer than 50
50 to 99
100 or more
Table 37. Tribal jail capacity and jail staff, by State and tribe, 1998
Capacity
State Tribe Adult Juvenile Staff
Alaska Metlakatla Indian Community 8 4
Arizona Navajo Nation 208 36 96
Colorado River Indian Tribes 30 8 12
Fort Mohave Indian Tribe 1 1 4
White Mountain Apache Tribe 31 17 22
Hopi Tribe 68 28 8
Tohono O'Odham Nation 33 16 31
Gila River Indian Community 73 32 40
Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian
Community 70 33 18
San Carlos Apache Tribe 38 14
Hualapai, Havasupai, Prescott
Apache, and Tonto Apache 36 8 7
Supai Tribe 4 2
Pascua Yaqui Tribe 1 1 6
California Chehalis Indian Tribe 2 1
Colorado Southern Ute Tribe 4 5
Ute Mountain Ute Tribe 14 2 5
Idaho Shoshone-Bannock Tribe 24 4 4
Michigan Saginaw Chippewa Tribe 2 6 9
Minnesota Boise Forte Tribe 8 1
Red Lake Chippewa Tribe 18 4 13
Mississippi Mississippi Band of Choctaw
Indians 32 8 17
Montana Blackfeet Tribe 34 34 12
Crow Tribe 12 2 5
Gros Ventre and Assiniboine Tribe 8 5
Assiniboine and Sioux Tribe 21 21 19
Northern Cheyenne Tribe 10 3 3
Chippewa Cree Tribe 22 4 3
Confederated Tribes of Salish and
Kootenai 16 4 11
Nebraska Omaha Tribe 20 12 9
Capacity
State Tribe Adult Juvenile Staff
Nevada Battle Mountain, Duckwater, Ely,
Goshute, South Fork, Elko Band,
and Wells Band 28 5
New Mexico Jicarilla Apache Tribe 0 8 0
Laguna Pueblo Tribe 12 4 5
Mescalero Apache Tribe 24 7
Taos Pueblo 8 5
Ramah Navajo 10 5
Isleta Pueblo 6 6
Zuni Pueblo 22 12 13
Navajo Nation 41 14 21
North Dakota Spirit Lake Sioux Tribe 25 8 5
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe 42 8 8
Turtle Mountain Chippewa Tribe 22 8 8
Three Affiliated Tribes 8 6
Oklahoma Sac and Fox Nation 69 23
Oregon Confederated Tribes of Warm
Springs 32 12 13
BIA Law Enforcement Services 4
South Dakota Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe 53 10 24
Crow Creek Sioux Tribe 10 4 2
Lower Brule Sioux Tribe 14 2 4
Oglala Sioux Tribe 52 32 31
Rosebud Sioux Tribe 48 16 12
Sisseton-Wahpeton Sioux Tribe 16 4 5
Utah Uintah and Ouray Tribe 24 5
Washington Olympic Peninsula Tribe 14 4 8
Puget Sound Tribe 7 1 7
Kalispel and Spokane Tribe 8 4
Confederated Tribes of Yakama
Nation 30 17 10
Wisconsin Menominee Tribe 32 10 16
Wyoming Shoshone and Arapaho Tribe 26 4 6
Total 1,462 536 649
Note: Data were supplied by the Bureau of Indian Affairs, U.S. Department of the
Interior. Data are for April 1998. Staff of the facilities includes juvenile and adult
detention officers and dispatchers.