Everyday Realities of Street Children and Private School Children
Everyday Realities of Street Children and Private School Children
Everyday Realities of Street Children and Private School Children
Socioeconomic Differences:
Everyday Realities of Street Children and Private I
School Children
YUKO OKUMA
Abstract
Starting with the author's encounter with a stone-throwing incident, which involved
different socioeconomic groups of children-street children and private school
children-at Katipunan Avenue, this article seeks to understand the processes by which
these two groups of children come to know about socioeconomic differences in their
everyday lives. It first describes the avenue as an interface situation where encounters
between street children and private school children are likely to happen. It subsequently
clarifies the modes and the contents of children's knowledge construction of the other at
the interface situation.
Three findings are drawn from data gathered through key informant interviews and
observations. One, children construct their common-sense knowledge of the other as they
adjust to or reconcile with their own socioeconomic positions. Two, the ongoing process
of knowledge construction involves the reinforcement of their understanding through
actual encounters between the two groups and under the influence of other people and
elements that are directly and indirectly related to interface encounters. Ultimately, the
children themselves actively maintain social reality of socioeconomic differences.
r.,
,I Volume 52 January-December 2004 17
I
nearby depressed areas seek earnings to In the parking space of Jollibee and
survive everyday life and struggle to protect National Bookstore, a middle-aged
their interests by sharing space with others woman attends to cars parking in National
on the street. Their daily life starts with the Bookstore, while another middle-aged
opening of the restaurants and stores in male parking attendant takes charge of
Katipunan Avenue in the morning. They are
.
the Jollibee parking space. They do this all
usually congregated in the same flourishing day, but for a little money. Under the stairs
spots as the wealthier people are. of the overpass, two vendors with small
portable stands sell candies, small packs
Around KFC, some street children of snacks and cigarettes to passers-by.
persistently follow passers-by or approach Near the tricycle station at the overpass,
cars stopped by traffic signals to beg for a young adult male deep-fries fishballs
coins and food. A street child hails taxies on a makeshift stand while people gather
for customers of KFC, while younger around it to skewer and eat them.
ones sell sampaguita to persons walking
by the area. A middle-aged male parking Compared to other spots, McDonald's
assistant in charge of directing cars at has the largest number of street children in
the parking area of KFC receives a few the stretch.They play energetically with their
coins for his service. A vending shop sells peers atthe exterior walkwayof McDonald's,
hotdogs and orange juice right beside the doing cartwheels and headstands or
tricycle station, where street workers such chasing each other. At the same time, they
as tricycle drivers, parking attendants and beg for coins or meals from the customers
street children take a rest to have some coming out of or entering McDonald's.
cheap merienda (snacks). Here, young adult males work as parking
attendants for customers of McDonald's. '1
1
At the overpass area, some younger A female vendor sells newspaper, candies
street children sell sampaguita to and cigarettes at a corner of the parking
customers of National Bookstore and area of McDonald's. This has become a
Jollibee. At the same time, they play, dance gathering place for street children, young
and sing with their peers by the entrances adult parking attendants and other street
of these establishments to catch customers' workers like tricycle drivers.
attention. Depending on the concentration
of customers, these children move to When restaurants and shops close and
the nearby parking area of Starbucks the number of customers decrease, those
and Shakey's. Some persistently follow working on the street also start withdrawing
passers-by until they are given something, from the avenue. Many restaurants are
but they are usually ignored. closed around nine or ten o'clock at night.
1
18 Philippine Sociological Review
I
j
I
After ten o'clock, only a few vendors and alongside the disadvantaged who barely
parking attendants stay on the street. survive their everyday life in poverty and
However, some street children who are try to receive blessings of the privileged.
still eager to earn by begging or selling
sampaguita transfer to McDonald's, which Because of its socioeconomic
is open and still bustling with customers characteristics, face-to-face encounters
until midnight. specifically between street children and
private school children frequently happen
Around the closing time of Pizza in the stretch. Well-off students from the
Hut also at midnight, the street children surroundingeliteprivateschoolshavemeals
start gathering around the restaurant while chatting with their friends in those fast-
to collect leftover foods that Pizza Hut foods restaurants along Katipunan Avenue.
gives them. The children are able to eat On the other hand, street children beg them
to their stomachs' content. After midnight, for coins and food or sell sampaguita to
Starbucks is the only cafe that is open until them in the streets outside. Some students
early in the morning (usually 1:00 AM, but give street children coins or leftovers and
also 3:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays). buy sampaguitafrom them, while others are
A few street children still beg around oblivious to the presence of street children.
Starbucks or sleep in the sidewalks and There are also students who are intolerant
parking lots of the restaurants, but most of of street children. They try to avoid street
them go home to depressed areas nearby. children or show disgust and disdain for
At this time, Katipunan Avenue becomes them. Corresponding to these negative
empty and silent. reactions, some street children quickly give
up and withdraw their asking. However,
there are also other street children who try
Shared Realities of Streetchildren to counterattack the students verbally or
and Private School Children physically.
f.
i Volume 52 January-December 2004 27
Almost in the same way as street full parental attention for their needs and
children, private school children can study in fine schools without caring
commonly understand street children about their everyday livelihood. Although
as disadvantaged in comparison to their they sometimes become conscious of
own privileged conditions in terms of social inequality (as. a student asserts,
parents' ability (to fulfill their parental 'every child should be able to go to
obligations), education, activities they school and his or her needs should be
are engaged in, food" consumption level, fulfilled'), they strongly believe that the
material possessions, appearance, living situations of street children would never
conditions, opportunity and security,among happen to them and that they would
others. For example, a student showed her attain a successful and brilliant future
idea as follows: that street children would never be able
to. Hence, they eventually think that these
'They [street children] are unfortunate differences are the natural order of their
unlike me. Unfortunate because they
have no parents to guide them. They everyday reality. The' following statement
are not studying and are not learning is well exemplified this:
anything. They do not have enough
food to eat for a day. They are not
'I don't want to be like them because I
comfortable wit,h their lives, and also do
want to do well in my life. I don't want
not feel stable in life because they are
to get into bad things. I want to be
working. They can't do anything about
protected... a good future.'
it. They might be playing but they don't
learn anything.'
(Ayoko maging katulad nita. Kasi gusto
ko mapaganda buhay ko. Ayokong
-Fatima, Grade 5,
mapasama. Gusto ko protektado ako...
17 March 2003
magandang future.)
the disadvantaged situations. A student only beg in the streets without studying as
refers to this: 'DSWD should take a role to lazy and not making own efforts:
improve the situations of street children'.
To their understanding, street children 'They [street children) are only begging,
not working. Theyare not studying. They
should be the objects of social aid by these just beg and beg (hingi lang nang hingl).
organizations. That's not work. They will not be able to
improve their lives.'
Both street children and private school Similarly, private school children's
children actively construct their common- common-sense knowledge of street
sense knowledge of the other through children is constructed mainly through
everyday encounters with various kinds their actual encounters with the street
of social actors in the interface situation. children at the interface situation.However,
However, the modes of knowledge parental influence is also quite significant
construction appear to be slightly different. for private school children in learning
about socioeconomic differences between
Street children's common-sense the other group and their own. Moreover,
knowledge of private school children is private school children's exposure to moral
constructed mainly through their actual education in school and mass media is
encounters with a variety of social actors also identifiable as their way of acquiring
at face-to-face situations (private school knowledge, which is not a mode of social
children, street peers, and other social construction among street children. These
actors in the street). Parental influence on two latter modes accordingly affect their
Baldus, Bernd and Verna Tribe. 1978. "The Development of Perceptions and Evaluations of
Social Inequality among Public School Children." Canadian Review of Sociology and
Anthropology, 15 (February): 50-60.
Banaag, Cornelio. 1997. Resiliency- Stories Found in Philippine Streets. AusAID and UNICEF.
Berger, Peter and Thomas Luckmann. 1966. The Social Constitution of Reality. England:
Penguin Books.
Calago, Cindy. 2002. "The Agency of the Child in Social World of Sex Work:' MA thesis, Ateneo
de Manila University.
Elkin, Frederick and Gerald Handel. 1984. The Child and Society: The Process of
Socialization. 4 th ed. New York: Random House.
Gecas, Viktor. 1979 "The Influence of Social Class on Socialization." In Contemporary Theories
About the Family, ed. Wesley Burr et at, 365-404. New York: Free Press.
Giddens, Anthony. 1984. The Constitution of Society. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of
California Press.
1110, Jeanne Frances. 2003. On Their Own Behalf: Case Studies of Child and Youth
Participation in the Philippines. Quezon City: Consuelo Foundatdion and the Institute
of Philippine Culture.
Jocano, Jose Landa. 2002. Slum as a Way of Life: A Study of Coping Behavior in an Urban
Environment. Metro Manila: PUNLAD Research House.
Johoda, Gustav. 1959. "Development of the Perception of Social Differences in Children from
6 to 10." British Journal of Psychology 50: 159-175.
Kerbo, Harold. 1991. Social Stratification and Inequality: Class Conflict in Historical and
Comparative Perspective. McGRAW-Hili, Inc.
Kerkvliet, Benedict. 1980. "Classes and Class Relations in a Philippine Village." Philippine
Sociological Review 28: 31-50.
Kerkvliet, Benedict. 1990. Everyday Politics in the Philippines: Class and Status Relations in a
Central Luzon Village. University of California Press.
Kohn, Melvin. 1959. "Social Class and Parental Values." American Journal of Sociology 64
(January): 337-351.
Lewis, Oscar. 1966a. "The Culture of Poverty." Scientific American 215 (4): 19-25.
Lewis, Oscar. 1966b. La Vida: A Puerto Rican Family-in the Culture of Poverty. San Juan and
New York: Random House.
Long, Norman and Ann Long, eds. 1992. Battlefields of Knowledge: The Interlocking of Theory
and Practice in Social Research and Development. London and New York: Routledge.
Porio, Emma. 1994. "Children of the Streets: Socialization and Formation of the Self in
Rapidly Urbanizing Contexts." Philippine Sociological Review 42: 40-52.
Shimizu, Hiromu. 1993. "Filipino Children in Family and Society: Growing Up in a Many-people
Environment." In SA 21 Readings, 106-128. Quezon City: Office of Research and
Publications.
Strauss, Anselm and Juliet Corbin. 1998. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and
Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. SAGE Publications.
Torres, Amaryllis. 1996. Profiles of Disadvantaged Children: Street Children in Six Philippine
Cities. Quezon City: Office of Research Coordination, University of the Philippines.
Weber, Max. 1947. The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. Glencoe: Free Press.
Wright, James and Sonia Wright. 1976. "Social Class and Parental Values for Children: A
Partial Replication and Extension of Kohn's Thesis." American Sociological Review 41
(June): 527-537.