Aeb 02406
Aeb 02406
Aeb 02406
Engineering
Bulletin
Title: This AEB is for the following applications:
Charge Air Cooling – Industrial
Application Installation Requirements Automotive Industrial Marine
G-Drive Genset
The objective of this AEB is to present design guidelines, recommendations and requirements for the Charge Air
Cooling system for industrial applications. This bulletin should be used by OEMs to assist in machine (vehicle)
design but is not a substitute for validation of machine (vehicle) systems.
Table of Contents
1 Installation Requirements......................................................................................................................................... 3
2 Recommendations ................................................................................................................................................... 4
3 Charge Air Cooling System - Discussion ................................................................................................................. 7
3.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 7
3.2 Design for Heat Transfer ................................................................................................................................. 8
3.2.1 Charge Air Cooling System Function .......................................................................................................... 8
3.2.2 Cooler Core Sizing ...................................................................................................................................... 8
3.2.2.1 Emissions Related Installation Instructions ........................................................................................ 9
3.2.2.2 Charge Air Cooler Outlet Temperature Derate/Alarm Set Point ....................................................... 10
3.2.2.3 Maximum Allowable Air Temperature Rise over Ambient at Turbo Compressor Inlet (Intake System
Temperature Rise) ............................................................................................................................................. 10
3.2.2.4 Heat Rejection .................................................................................................................................. 11
3.2.3 Condensation ............................................................................................................................................ 14
3.2.4 Design for Charge Air Cooler System Performance ................................................................................. 14
3.2.4.1 Maximum Pressure Drop from Turbocharger Compressor Air Outlet to Intake Manifold (IMPD) ..... 14
3.2.4.2 System Layout .................................................................................................................................. 14
3.2.4.3 Installations Involving Various Heat Exchangers Installed Front to Back (in Series) ....................... 15
3.2.5 Design for Cooling Fan and Fan Drive Performance ................................................................................ 16
3.2.5.1 Fan to Core Match ............................................................................................................................ 16
3.2.5.2 Fan to Core Distance........................................................................................................................ 16
3.2.5.3 Fan Shroud ....................................................................................................................................... 17
3.2.5.4 Fan Tip to Shroud Clearance ........................................................................................................... 17
3.2.5.5 Fan Immersion.................................................................................................................................. 17
3.2.5.6 Fan Air Supply and Exhaust ............................................................................................................. 17
3.2.5.7 Cooling Fan Control.......................................................................................................................... 17
3.2.5.8 Variable Speed/Pitch Fan Clutches .................................................................................................. 18
3.2.5.9 On/Off Fan Clutches ......................................................................................................................... 19
3.2.5.10 Viscous Air Sensing Fan Clutches ................................................................................................... 19
3.2.5.11 Alternate Temperature Input for Cooling Fan Control on EGR Engines ........................................... 19
3.3 Design for Charge Air Cooler Durability ........................................................................................................ 20
3.3.1 Cooler Construction .................................................................................................................................. 20
3.3.2 Cooler Mounting ....................................................................................................................................... 21
3.3.3 System Tube Work ................................................................................................................................... 21
3.3.3.1 Tube Routing and Bending ............................................................................................................... 21
3.3.3.2 Tube Material.................................................................................................................................... 22
3.3.3.3 Tube Welding ................................................................................................................................... 22
3.3.4 System Hoses ........................................................................................................................................... 22
3.3.5 Turbocharger Boost Pressure Reactions .................................................................................................. 22
3.3.6 System Clamps ......................................................................................................................................... 23
3.3.7 System Cleanliness .................................................................................................................................. 23
3.3.7.1 Aluminum Particle Specifications ..................................................................................................... 23
3.3.7.2 Steel and Other Particles.................................................................................................................. 24
3.3.8 Cold Weather Operation ........................................................................................................................... 26
3.3.8.1 Intake Air Heaters ............................................................................................................................. 26
3.3.8.2 Temperature Modulated Engine Cooling Fans ................................................................................. 26
3.3.8.3 Temperature Controlled Variable Pitch Cooling Fans ...................................................................... 26
3.3.8.4 Airflow Shutters ................................................................................................................................ 27
3.3.8.5 Winterfronts ...................................................................................................................................... 27
3.3.9 Intake Air Location .................................................................................................................................... 27
4 Definitions .............................................................................................................................................................. 27
5 Reference Documentation ..................................................................................................................................... 28
Appendix A Charge Air Cooling System Performance Verification Testing ............................................................. 29
Appendix B Test Procedures ................................................................................................................................... 34
6 Change Log............................................................................................................................................................ 41
1 Installation Requirements
The following items are requirements for design of the charge air cooling system based on Cummins testing and
service experience with industrial engine installations. These requirements are based on best-practice of OEMs
and end-users with successful installations in current use.
Unless otherwise noted, the requirements listed below apply to all the applications indicated in the title block of
this AEB. In order to obtain Cummins concurrence with Charge Air Cooling Systems, the system must:
Charge Air Cooling Heat Transfer Requirements
1. The charge air cooling system must meet the required “Maximum CAC delta Temperature (CAC dT) at an
ambient of 25 °C (77 °F)” specification on the Engine Performance Data Sheet when tested according to
procedure outlined in this document. The test that establishes this requirement is the “Charge Air Cooler Delta
Temperature (CAC dT)” shown in Appendix B. Engines without Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) may use
CAC dT or IMTD (Intake Manifold Temperature – ambient temperature). Engines with EGR must use the CAC
dT instead of IMTD.
See Section 3.2.2.1 Emissions Related Installation Instructions
2. When ambient temperatures are less than 25 °C (77 °F) the CAC_Out temperature must not exceed the
"Maximum CAC outlet temperature at <= 25 °C (77 °F) ambient" or “Charge air cooler outlet temperature for
Full Fan-on” on the Engine Performance Data Sheet.
See Section 3.2.2.1 Emissions Related Installation Instructions
3. The charge air cooling system must maintain an intake manifold temperature less than or equal to the “Intake
manifold air temperature derate/alarm temperature" specification on the Base Engine Data Sheet when tested
at the machine’s limiting ambient temperature (LAT).
See Section 3.2.2.2 Charge Air Cooler Outlet Temperature Derate/Alarm Set Point
Charge Air Cooling System Performance Requirements
4. The charge air cooling system, including OEM CAC tubing must not exceed the "Maximum allowable pressure
drop across charge air cooler and OEM CAC piping (IMPD)" specification on the Engine Performance Data
Sheet when tested according to the procedure outlined in this document.
See Section 3.2.4.1 Maximum Pressure Drop from Turbocharger Compressor Air Outlet to Intake Manifold
(IMPD)
5. Temperature modulated engine cooling fans must be directly controlled by CAC_Out temperature using an
OEM supplied sensor in the CAC outlet or CAC outlet tubing. This control is in addition to other fan controls
(such as those using engine coolant temperature).
See Section 3.2.5.7 Cooling Fan Control and 3.2.5.8 Variable Speed/Pitch Fan Clutches
See Section 3.2.5.11 Alternate Temperature Input for Cooling Fan Control on EGR Engines if a CAC outlet
temperature sensor cannot be used.
Charge Air Cooling Durability Requirements
6. The charge air connection tubing must be made of a) aluminized steel, b) stainless steel, or c) internally and
externally powder coated steel tubing. It must not made of aluminum or untreated steel
See Section 3.3.3.2 Tube Material
7. The charge air system tubing, hoses, clamps, and mounting must meet the requirements defined in AEB
24.20 Hose Material and Hose Requirements and Recommendations. AEB 24.20 describes the required hose
and clamp types and materials required for charge air cooler plumbing.
See Section 3.3.4 System Hoses
8. The loads due to the boost pressure forces, charge air system plumbing geometry, and charge air system
plumbing weight must meet the specifications as defined in AEB 64.13 Cummins Turbo Technologies-
Turbocharger Load Limits. AEB 64.13 describes the maximum load limits for the intake air and charge air
cooler plumbing attachment to the turbocharger.
See Section 3.3.5 Turbocharger Boost Pressure Reactions
9. For engines with variable geometry turbocharger (VGT), all OEM drawings for air system components
downstream of the air filter must specify the cleanliness requirements outlined in this document. This includes
intake air pipes and hoses, charge air cooler tubing and hoses, and any other clean air side of the intake air
and charge air cooler system.
See Section 3.3.7 System Cleanliness
2 Recommendations
Design for Heat Transfer - Core Design
1. The charge air core design should use the maximum frontal surface area available.
3. The core fin spacing should be as large as possible to reduce plugging and provide for ease of cleaning.
4. The charge air core header tanks should not block the fan swept area.
5. The outside edges of the charge air cooler assembly should be sealed or baffled to prevent recirculation of
the hot air.
6. The charge air cooling package should have a shroud to maximize the flow to the full charge air core and be
as close as possible to the fan tips to maintain the fan efficiency while not allowing fan blade to shroud contact.
7. The adjacent cooling cores should be arranged to avoid fan air flow blockage.
8. If the machine (vehicle) is to be used in an environment where core plugging could occur frequently, the
design should include methods for easy core access for blow-off and cleaning.
9. If the CAC's core area is smaller than the radiator core, the CAC header tanks should not cover the radiator
core area, thus blocking airflow.
10. Avoid adding heat exchangers in front of the CAC core that can preheat the CAC cooling air to a point where
it cannot meet the CAC cooling requirements.
11. It is recommended that excessive CAC cooling effectiveness should be avoided. Excessive cooling can cause
condensation to build up in the intake piping and cause corrosion, or freeze up in cold conditions, potentially
causing a no-start condition.
13. The fan should be selected to have the largest possible diameter and the fan ratio as low as possible.
14. Consider using a temperature modulated fan to reduce fuel consumption, noise, core plugging and other
benefits.
15. The fan axial engagement into the shroud should be optimized to take fullest advantage of the fan air flow.
This can often be tested and optimized by varying the fan spacer length to change the engagement distance.
16. All piping between the engine and charge air cooler should be flexible enough to provide for relative motion
between the engine and charge air cooler. See AEB 24.20 for hose design recommendations.
17. To ensure good airflow sweep of the heat transfer cores, a distance of at least 102 mm (4 in) between the fan
and core is recommended. Blower type fans may require a greater distance.
18. Fan performance improves as the clearance from the fan blade tips to the shroud is reduced. For best
performance, the tip clearance should not exceed 13-19 mm (0.5-0.75 in).
19. For installations having the CAC and radiator cores front to back (in series), the fan should be immersed about
1/2 of the fan depth into the shroud. Optimum fan immersion should be determined through testing.
20. Grille open area should be maximized, and grille elements designed for low air resistance.
21. Avoid obstructions in front of or behind the fan that may disrupt airflow, particularly near the fan perimeter
where air velocity is highest.
22. Attention should be focused on the engine compartment venting to allow maximum open area and ensure low
restriction cooling air intake or exhaust.
23. Cooling systems using variable speed or variable pitch fan controls may provide noise, power, and fuel
economy improvements over direct-drive fixed-blade fans when properly applied.
24. Cummins does not recommend the use of on/off type fan clutches for industrial equipment using charge air
cooled engines that do not have significant ram air through the cooling system.
25. The cooling fan should remain actuated until both the intake air temperature and coolant temperature switches
are in the “off” position.
26. Cummins discourages the use of the bi-metallic strip in the fan hub that senses cooling air temperature for a
viscous fan clutch because it is difficult to control CAC outlet temperature under all loading and ambient
conditions.
27. Cummins encourages the use of winter fronts that equalize the exposure of each CAC core tube to cooling
airflow to provide more uniform temperature distribution over the cooler core area.
28. Either a blower fan or suction fan arrangement may be used as long as the charge air cooling performance
requirements are met. A suction fan arrangement is usually the more efficient alternative.
29. The cooler can be a significant source of charge air flow restriction within the system. Avoid CAC designs
which use:
30. Large radius bends are recommended to keep system pressure drop as low as possible. Bend radii should
be 1.5 times the tube diameter or larger.
31. Abrupt diameter changes and the use of mitered joints should be avoided. Tube diameter needs to be
balanced between pressure drop requirements and engine transient response.
32. Excessive system volumes may slow engine throttle response and result in transient surge issue evidenced
by a loud “chuffing” noise from the turbocharger.
Charge Air Cooling System Durability Recommendations: Core Density, Durability, and Cleaning
33. The charge air cooler core fin density (fins/in or fins/cm) and fin type should be selected to prevent fouling
during operation in the machine’s expected environment.
34. Cummins recommends heat exchanger cores with no greater than 8-10 fins/in, and non-louvered fins for
equipment used in a dirty environment (such as construction, agricultural, and mining).
35. The charge air cooler mounting should be designed to isolate the charge air cooler core from frame twist and
shock loads.
36. The charge air cooler mounting should be designed to restrict motion and avoid contact between the fan and
the shroud and core.
37. The charge air cooler core and its mounting should be designed and constructed to handle cyclic pressure
and thermal expansion.
38. The charge air cooler core, tanks and its mounting should be designed and constructed to withstand combined
vibration and pressure cycle oscillations expected to occur during worst case machine work duty cycle and
maximum charge air cooler temperatures.
39. Cummins recommends the industry standard CAC that uses a brazing process to join the core to the end
tanks.
40. Fabricated header tanks may be prone to failure if improperly designed and welded. To meet OEM cooler life
expectancies, equipment operating cycles with frequent and rapidly changing charge air temperatures and
pressures may require a cooler using a non-rigid, gasket joint between the core tubes and end tanks, and/or
set of side plates with expansion joints.
41. For installations where the various heat exchangers are installed front to back, debris may become trapped
between these two cores, where it is not easily cleaned without removal of the CAC. To reduce plugging
issues, Cummins recommends the equipment manufacturer:
43. A full 360° hose bead is recommended on the charge air tube ends to prevent hose blow-off. See AEB 24.20
for full details.
44. The charge air tubing to and from the cooler should be direct and include as few bends as possible.
45. All changes in air direction should be done with tubing rather than hoses. Molded hose elbows in the charge
air system are prone to blow-off due to high boost pressures and temperatures and relative movement of the
system.
46. Charge air tubing that includes 90° bends are prone to hose blow-off and should be bracketed to the engine.
If the tubing is bracketed to the engine, the attachment point on the tubing should be kept close to the hose
connection on the engine in order to minimize stresses caused when relative motion occurs between the
engine and CAC. Tubing which is bracketed to the engine must also meet the requirements defined in AEB
21.46 Installation Requirements - Guidelines for OEM Installed Hardware. Rotatable 90 and 45 degree elbows
attached to the turbo compressor outlet are available to direct the charge air toward the CAC and minimize
the need for 90° bends in the tubing.
47. Rigidly braced tubing is acceptable if tension straps are installed across the hose connecting the turbo
compressor outlet elbow and the discharge tube. See AEB 64.13 for details.
48. Hose clamps of the constant tension type are recommended. See AEB 24.20 for charge air hose clamping
requirements and recommendations.
49. Hose materials should be Nomex®-reinforced, bellows type, and silicone with external reinforcing rings. See
AEB 24.20 for charge air hose material requirements and recommendations.
50. The tubing between the engine and the charge air cooler must be adequately supported to prevent blow-off
and overloading of the turbocharger. See AEB 64.13 for complete turbocharger loading requirements and
recommendations.
51. Both ends of the charge air tubing should be installed with flexible hoses to allow the engine and charge air
cooler core to remain isolated.
52. The center of gravity of the charge air tube should be kept as close to a straight line drawn between the
centers of the hoses on either end of the tube.
53. The weight of the charge air tubing should not impose a force greater than 44 N (10 lbf) in the intake manifold
connection.
3.1 Introduction
This document is intended to help design a machine’s engine charge air cooling system that will enable the engine
to properly operate in all conditions it may encounter while in service. The information contained in this document
is a compilation of best practices, recommendations, engine specifications, design alternatives, and other
information to consider when designing the charge air cooling system. It is applicable to all light-duty, mid-range,
heavy-duty and high-horsepower Cummins industrial engines
Many new Cummins turbocharged engines for industrial applications require the use of charge air cooling (also
referred to as air-to-air or CAC) heat exchanger to reduce the temperature of the air entering the intake manifold.
An air-to-air CAC is more effective than an air-to-coolant (jacket-water) aftercooler to reduce the temperature of
the charge air entering the cylinders. A low charge air temperature is necessary to meet emissions requirements
while improving engine performance and efficiency. In addition to the charge air cooler, the system includes
ducting from the turbocharger to the CAC and from the CAC to the engine intake manifold.
Turbocharg
er
Intake
Charge Air Manifold
Cooler
Figure 1 Charge Air Cooling System Components
The long-term integrity of the charge air cooling system is the responsibility of the equipment and component
manufacturers. While specifying performance of the system components, Cummins will not attempt to establish
detailed durability test requirements. Performance of the charge air cooling system is critical to engine durability,
performance, and emissions compliance. Failure of system components will cause power loss, increased
emissions, and possibly engine damage. The charge air cooler, tubing, cooling fan, and fan control must meet
Cummins requirements and the design constraints of the particular piece of industrial equipment.
Note: Engines which use Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR), such as Cummins Tier 4 engines, mix exhaust gas
into the charge air as it enters the intake manifold. This mixing of the exhaust gas with the charge air causes the
intake manifold temperature to be higher than the CAC outlet temperature. For this reason the intake manifold
temperature or engines with EGR cannot be used where CAC outlet temperature is specified as a test requirement
or for fan controller temperature. For engines without EGR (pre Tier 4 Engines): CAC Outlet Temperature = Intake
Manifold Temperature (IMT).
Requirement 1: The charge air cooling system must meet the required “Maximum CAC delta Temperature (CAC
dT) at an ambient of 25 °C (77 °F)” specification on the Engine Performance Data Sheet when tested according
to procedure outlined in this document. The test that establishes this requirement is the “Charge Air Cooler Delta
Temperature (CAC dT)” shown in Appendix B. Engines without Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) may use CAC
dT or IMTD (Intake Manifold Temperature – ambient temperature). Engines with EGR must use the CAC dT
instead of IMTD.
Requirement Background: Failing to follow these instructions when installing a certified engine in a piece of
non-road equipment violates United States federal law (40 CFR 1068.105(b)), subject to fines or other penalties
as described in the Clean Air Act.
Requirement 2: When ambient temperatures are less than 25 °C (77 °F) the CAC_Out temperature must not
exceed the "Maximum CAC outlet temperature at <= 25 °C (77 °F) ambient" or “Charge air cooler outlet
temperature for Full Fan-on” on the Engine Performance Data Sheet.
Requirement Background: Failing to follow these instructions when installing a certified engine in a piece of
non-road equipment violates United States federal law (40 CFR 1068.105(b)), subject to fines or other penalties
as described in the Clean Air Act.
Maximum CAC Outlet delta Temperature (Ambient to CAC Outlet) (CAC dT) is the amount that the CAC outlet
temperature can be above the operating ambient temperature with the engine at full power output.
Note: For engines without EGR, the intake manifold temperature is equal to CAC outlet temperature. For engines
with EGR, intake manifold temperature (IMT) is not the same as CAC outlet temperature (IMT is higher due to
addition of EGR gases into the intake manifold).
The engine’s emission certification is based on an ambient temperature of 25 °C (77 °F). Therefore, in order to
comply with the engine’s emission certification, the following conditions must be satisfied.
Table 1 Charge Air Cooler Operating Temperature
Ambient Temperature
Under which the Machine Charge Air Cooler Outlet Temperature
Operates
25 °C (77 °F)+ CAC dT (Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25
25 °C (77 °F) °C (77 °F) (CAC dT))
(Per Engine Performance Data Sheet)
Must NOT exceed the Charge air cooler outlet temperature for full
< 25 °C (77 °F) Fan-On
(Per Engine Performance Data Sheet)
For the system to concur with Cummins requirements and the engine to be in compliance with US EPA and other
regulating agencies’ emissions regulations, the CAC_Out must be less than or equal to ambient temperature plus
CAC dT when the ambient air temperature is 25 °C (77 °F). When the ambient temperature is less than 25 °C
(77 °F), the CAC Outlet Temperature must not exceed the “Maximum CAC outlet temperature at <=25 °C (77 °F)
ambient” or “Charge air cooler outlet temperature for full Fan-On” as specified on the Engine Performance Data
Sheet.
Requirement 3: The charge air cooling system must maintain an intake manifold temperature less than or equal
to the “Intake manifold air temperature derate/alarm temperature" specification on the Base Engine Data Sheet
when tested at the machine’s limiting ambient temperature (LAT).
Requirement Background: Maintaining the CAC_Out will avoid triggering the faults.
Exception: On many engines which utilize EGR, the “Intake manifold air temperature derate / alarm temperature"
is not specified on the Base Engine Data Sheet. In this case, it is not necessary to validate for this requirement.
This is the maximum allowable CAC_Out on non-EGR engines and maximum allowable intake manifold
temperature on EGR-equipped engines. During high ambient conditions, the CAC_Out must be maintained to a
level such that the CAC_Out is less than or equal to the "Intake manifold air temperature derate/alarm
temperature" on the Base Engine Data Sheet. If the intake manifold air temperature (IMT) on EGR-equipped
electronic engines is exceeded a fault code and/or derate may result.
A recommended method of estimating the CAC_Out Temperature at the OEM design-LAT (Limiting Ambient
Temperature) condition would be to use the following formula based on the actual CAC test results:
CAC_Out_T at Design LAT = Tested_CAC_Out_T + 1.2 * (Design LAT - Test_Ambient_T)
Example: An engine is tested at 30 °C (86 °F) ambient and has a maximum CAC_Out temperature at maximum
load of 65 °C (149 °F) during the test.
This gives a CAC_dT of (65-30) = 35 °C or (149-86) = 63 °F.
If the desired LAT of the vehicle is 50 °C (122 °F), then the equation above gives us:
CAC_Out_T_at_design_LAT = 65+1.2*(50-30)=65+24 = 89 °C or (CAC_Out_T_at_design_LAT =
149+1.2*(122-86)=149+43.2 = 192.2 °F)
If the "Intake manifold air temperature derate/alarm temperature” on the Base Engine Data Sheet is 90
°C (194 °F), then this predicts an acceptable intake manifold temperature at the OEM design LAT since
90 °C is greater than 89 °C (or 194 °F >192.2 °F).
An alternative is to calculate the design-LAT (Limiting Ambient Temperature) at the "Intake manifold air
temperature derate/alarm temperature” on the Base Engine Data Sheet (IMT_Alarm_T). This can be done via
the following equation:
Design LAT = (IMT_Alarm_T - Tested_CAC_Out_T ) / 1.2 + Test_Ambient_T
Example: An engine is tested at 30 °C (86 °F) ambient and has a maximum CAC_Out temperature at maximum
load of 65 °C (149 °F) during the test. The "Intake manifold air temperature derate / alarm temperature” on the
Base Engine Data Sheet is 90 °C (194 °F).
This gives a CAC_dT of (65-30) = 35 °C or (149-86) = 63 °F.
The Design LAT of the machine is = (90 – 66) / 1.2 + 30 or 55 °C.
If the calculated Design LAT exceeds the required LAT for the application, then this above requirement is
met and considered acceptable.
The "Intake manifold air temperature derate / alarm temperature" is typically not shown on the Base Engine Data
Sheet on engines with cooled EGR. In this case, it is not necessary to perform the above calculations.
3.2.2.3 Maximum Allowable Air Temperature Rise over Ambient at Turbo Compressor Inlet (Intake
System Temperature Rise)
AEB 24.21 Industrial Installation Requirements - Air Intake System for Off-Highway Applications specifies a
temperature limit published on the Engine Performance Data Sheet due to heating of the intake air as it travels
into the air inlet, through the air cleaner, and into the turbocharger.
The intake air moving from ambient to the inlet of the engine turbocharger is heated due to the environment under
the hood and this preheating of the intake air will affect the capability of the CAC to bring the CAC dT down to the
required value. The more heat that is added at the engine inlet, the more the CAC will need to be sized to bring
the CAC dT down to an acceptable value.
Proper sizing of the CAC also involves consideration of installation specifications such as fan airflow, design
ambient temperature, air preheating due to other heat exchangers, fan arrangement (blower or suction), and
cooling air recirculation in addition to the engine performance information provided on the Engine Performance
Data Sheet.
Rated Power
105 °F LAT 110 °F LAT 115 °F LAT 120 °F LAT 125 °F LAT
Environment FT
500 500 500 500 500
(Altitude)
Environment F
(Ambient 105 110 115 120 125
Temperature)
Intake Manifold IN_HG
68.5 67.6 67.5 66.9 66.3
Pressure
Turbocharger IN_HG
Compressor Outlet 72.6 71.7 71.6 70.95 70.3
Pressure
Intake Air Flow FT3/MIN 1640.5 1640 1653.5 1657 1660.5
Charge Air Flow LB/MIN 112.25 111.2 111.15 110.45 109.7
Turbocharger F
Compressor Outlet 443.05 448.05 455.4 460.9 466.35
Temperature
Maximum Intake F
Manifold
168 173 178 180 180
Temperature
(Maximum IMT)
Q(Btu/min) = charge air flow (lb/min) * 0.241 (Btu/lb*°F) * [Tcoh – Max IMT]
Q = 111.15 (lb/min) * 0.241 (Btu/lb*°F) * [455.4 (°F) – 178 (°F)] = 7504 (Btu/min) heat rejection to CAC at 115 ° F
(46 °C) ambient
The heat rejection required from the CAC is not listed on the Engine Data Sheet, because it varies considerably
with the turbocharger compressor inlet temperature. If the CAC heat rejection is needed for design calculations,
it can be determined with the Cummins Advisor software, using the worksheet in Attachment 1 of AEB 24.06, or
calculated using the following steps:
1. Determine ambient temperature targets:
Target 1 = Emissions certification point 25 °C (77 °F)
Target 2 = Machine’s maximum intended (limiting) ambient temperature (LAT)
2. Estimate intake system temperature inlet rise (𝑇𝑖𝑟 ) at ambient targets. This is dependent on the intake system
plumbing and compartment temperature. A properly designed intake air system minimizes heating of the
intake air. A typical range is 3 - 11 °C (5 - 20 °F).
3. Record following Engine Data Sheet parameters at rated power, peak power, and peak torque
Charge Air Mass Flow
Turbocharger Compressor Outlet Temperature (𝑇𝑐𝑜𝑑 )
Maximum CAC dT
4. Calculate turbocharger compressor inlet temperature (𝑇𝑐𝑖 ) at ambient targets
𝑇𝑐𝑖 = 𝑇𝑖𝑟 + 𝐴𝑚𝑏𝑖𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝑡𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒𝑡
5. Calculate turbocharger compressor outlet temperatures (𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ ) at ambient targets. The turbocharger
compressor outlet temperature will rise as the turbocharger compressor inlet temperature rises, but it is not a
one-for-one relationship.
𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ (℉) = 𝑇𝑐𝑜𝑑 + 1.4 × (𝑇𝑐𝑖 − 77)
𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ (℃) = 𝑇𝑐𝑜𝑑 + 1.4 × (𝑇𝑐𝑖 − 25)
6. Identify the maximum allowable CAC_Out at ambient targets:
Max CAC_Out at 25 °C (77 °F) = (See “Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)” on
the Engine Performance Data Sheet).
Max CAC_Out (at LAT) = See “Intake manifold air temperature derate/alarm temperature" specification
on the Base Engine Data Sheet.
7. Calculate required charge air cooler (CAC) heat rejection (Q)
𝑄(𝐵𝑡𝑢/𝑚𝑖𝑛) = 𝑐ℎ𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒 𝑎𝑖𝑟 𝑓𝑙𝑜𝑤(𝑙𝑏/𝑚𝑖𝑛) × 0.241(𝑏𝑡𝑢/𝑙𝑏 × ℉) × (𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ − 𝐶𝐴𝐶 𝑂𝑈𝑇 𝑡𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒𝑡)
𝑄(𝑘𝑊) = 𝑐ℎ𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒 𝑎𝑖𝑟 𝑓𝑙𝑜𝑤(𝑘𝑔/𝑠) × 1.02(𝑘𝐽/𝑘𝑔 × ℃) × [𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ − 𝐶𝐴𝐶 𝑂𝑈𝑇 𝑡𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒𝑡]
Example: QSX15-C, FR10377, 525 hp at 2100 rpm
CAC dT = 35 °C (63 °F)
Machine parameters:
LAT = 50 °C (122 °F)
Assume 𝑇𝑖𝑟 at 25 °C (77 °F) = 3 °C (5 °F)
Assume 𝑇𝑖𝑟 at LAT = 7 °C (12 °F)
Table 4 Parameters to determine CAC Heat Rejection (Example Only, English Units)
Rated
Power Peak Peak
Parameter Calculation/ Reference
and Power Torque
Speed
CAC Flow, 96 89 73 From Rating Data Sheet on GCE
(lb/min)
𝑇𝑐𝑜𝑑 , (°F) 361 368 382 From Rating Data Sheet on GCE
o
𝑇𝑐𝑖 (77 F), (°F) 82 82 82 𝑇𝑐𝑖 = 𝑇𝑖𝑟 + 𝐴𝑚𝑏𝑖𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝑇𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒𝑡
𝑇𝑐𝑖 (LAT), (°F) 134 134 134 𝑇𝑐𝑖 = 𝑇𝑖𝑟 + 𝐴𝑚𝑏𝑖𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝑇𝑎𝑟𝑔𝑒𝑡
o
𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ (77 F), (°F) 368 375 389 𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ = 𝑇𝑐𝑜𝑑 + 1.4 × (𝑇𝑐𝑖 − 77)
𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ (LAT), (°F) 441 448 462 𝑇𝑐𝑜ℎ = 𝑇𝑐𝑜𝑑 + 1.4 × (𝑇𝑐𝑖 − 𝐿𝐴𝑇)
Max CAC_Out 140 140 140 Max CAC_Out (at 77 °F) = (“Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at
(at 77 °F), (°F) 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)” on the Engine Performance Data
Sheet)
Max CAC_Out 190 190 190 𝑀𝑎𝑥 𝐶𝐴𝐶 𝑂𝑢𝑡
(at LAT), (°F) = See “Intake manifold air temperature derate
/ alarm temperature" specification on the Base Engine Data Sheet
Q (77 °F), 5275 5041 4381 Q (Btu/min) = charge air flow (lb/min) * 0.241 (Btu/lb*°F) * [Tcoh
(Btu/min) (77°F) – CAC_OUT target]
Q 5807 5534 4785 Q (Btu/min) = charge air flow (lb/min) * 0.241 (Btu/lb*°F) * [Tcoh
(LAT),(Btu/min) (LAT) – CAC_OUT target]
3.2.3 Condensation
It is recommended that excessive CAC cooling effectiveness should be avoided. Excessive cooling can cause
condensation to build up in the intake piping and cause corrosion, or freeze up in cold conditions, potentially
causing a no-start condition.
During cold weather operation, excessive condensation can build up in a charge air system when operating at
high system effectiveness. This may result in a number of undesirable conditions, including corrosion, sensor
damage / failure, or a no-start condition. This may result when the system has excessive design margin against
the CACdT limit, as may be the case when a charge air cooler is designed for a high charge air system heat
rejection, and is applied to a much lower charge air system heat rejection. For example, a system designed for a
higher power engine is also used in a low power installation.
The likelihood of condensation occurring is a function of engine duty cycle, cold weather, charge air system
effectiveness under full and part load conditions, relative humidity, and operator intervention.
Mitigating the build-up of condensation can be accomplished in several ways, one of which is optimizing CAC
effectiveness. Limiting CAC effectiveness during cooler ambient temperatures conditions will substantially reduce
the build-up of condensation during cold weather operation. Using a variable speed / pitch fan is an excellent way
of limiting CAC effectiveness during cooler ambient temperatures. The CACdT limits published on DATA sheet
must still be met under hot weather operation. Generally speaking, limiting CAC effectiveness 82-87% at the full
load design condition will minimize condensation build-up.
However, CAC design alone will not prevent condensation under all conditions; some conditions are more
problematic than others, such as idle operation and extremely low ambient temperatures. Condensation at idle
can be reduced by turning off the fan or minimizing its speed, or with the application of cold weather aids such as
winterfronts, shutters, or under hood air. At extremely low ambient temperatures, below -12 °C (10 °F), CAC
effectiveness and fan speed may not be sufficient to prevent condensation and freezing. The use of cold weather
aids, such as winterfronts, shutters, or under hood air, are necessary to minimize condensation and freezing.
Additional cold weather operation information, such as under hood warm air options, can be found in AEB 174.04,
or in Cummins’ Service Literature on cold weather operation.
Requirement 4: The charge air cooling system, including OEM CAC tubing must not exceed the "Maximum
allowable pressure drop across charge air cooler and OEM CAC piping (IMPD)" specification on the Engine
Performance Data Sheet when tested according to the procedure outlined in this document.
Requirement Background: Maintaining the IMPD within maximum requirements may prevent engine response
problems and low power complaints. Reduced air flow to the engine may also cause exhaust emissions to
vary beyond allowed limits.
This is the maximum allowable restriction of the complete charge air cooling system, measured with the engine
at full power output. This restriction includes the charge air ducting and cooler.
3.2.4.2 System Layout
Typically, the CAC is installed either front to back or side by side (over/under) with the engine radiator
Engine
Radiator
Charge Air
Cooler
Engine
Radiator
Charge Air
Cooler
Either is acceptable provided all the engine cooling and charge air cooling performance requirements are met. If
space is available, the side by side arrangement is preferable as it does not preheat the air entering the engine
radiator, has less cooling air flow restriction, and is easier to service.
If the CAC is mounted front to back, position the CAC upstream of all other heat exchangers so it will receive the
lowest temperature cooling air.
If the CAC is mounted side by side with the engine radiator, position the other heat exchangers (such as the air
conditioning condenser or hydraulic oil cooler) so that the cooling air flow restriction is balanced across the fan
sweep and the fan efficiency is maximized. The cooling system supplier can typically modify the proposed CAC
core thickness and density to balance the fan air flow with the other side of the cooling package while avoiding
placing any other cooler cores ahead of the CAC.
3.2.4.3 Installations Involving Various Heat Exchangers Installed Front to Back (in Series)
For installations where the various heat exchangers are installed front to back, debris may become trapped
between these two cores, where it is not easily cleaned without removal of the CAC. To reduce plugging issues,
Cummins recommends the equipment manufacturer:
install seals between the cores
match the fin density of the two cores so that debris will pass through both
improve serviceability by using swing-out cores
Industrial equipment is primarily cooled by fan airflow and not ram airflow generated by road speed. Since the fan
airflow must pass through both the charge air and the radiator cores, smoothing the transition between these
cores creates greater system efficiency. Matching the size and shape of these two cores as closely as possible
can achieve this. Since the CAC's core area is often smaller than the radiator core, ensure that the CAC tanks do
not cover the radiator core area, resulting in undesirable airflow blockage.
Air
Blockage
Requirement 5: Temperature modulated engine cooling fans must be directly controlled by CAC_Out temperature
using an OEM supplied sensor in the CAC outlet or CAC outlet tubing. This control is in addition to other fan
controls (such as those using engine coolant temperature).
Requirement Background: A low charge air temperature is necessary to meet emissions requirements while
improving engine performance and efficiency. This requirement is needed in order to meet the "Maximum CAC
outlet delta temperature (CAC dT) at an ambient of 25 °C (77 °F)" on the Engine Performance Data Sheet.
Exception: Some fan drive systems have a minimum fan speed, such that the fan cannot be controlled below this
speed. This is common on viscous type fan clutches, hydraulically driven fans, and multi-speed fan clutches. If it
can be shown during testing that the "Maximum CAC outlet delta temperature (CAC dT) at an ambient of 25 °C
(77 °F)" shown on the Engine Performance Data Sheet at this minimum fan speed, then it is not necessary to add
CAC outlet temperature control for the fan speed control. It should be noted, systems that are capable of this,
likely are not well optimized for fuel consumption and fan noise.
The air temperature at the turbocharger compressor outlet is a function of compressor inlet temperature and boost
pressure. At low boost conditions (very light engine loads), the compressor outlet temperature will be
approximately equal to the compressor inlet temperature. At full boost conditions (heavy engine loads), the
compressor outlet temperature can rise higher than compressor inlet temperature, reaching 120-177 °C (250-350
°F) above the ambient temperature. If a sudden load is applied to the engine, this change in boost and subsequent
change in temperature can occur within a few seconds. This sudden change combined with the fact that there is
very little thermal inertia in a CAC cooling system will cause the CAC_Out to change very quickly as well.
To meet Cummins requirements, any cooling fan system must have sufficient airflow to:
1. Maintain CAC_Out of less than Ambient T + CAC dT on a 25 °C (77 °F) standard condition day when running
rated speed and load.
2. Maintain IMT of less than intake manifold derate/alarm set point at high ambient temperatures and all
operating speed and load conditions. The intake manifold temperature may be higher than the CAC_Out due
to EGR flow into the intake manifold.
3. Accommodate sudden CAC_Out temperature rise.
4. When ambient temperatures are less than 25 °C (77 °F) the CAC_Out temperature must not exceed the
“Charge air cooler outlet temperature for full Fan-On” on the Engine Performance Data Sheet.
The “Charge air cooler outlet temperature for full fan-on” listed on the Engine Performance Data Sheet is the sum
of a standard day temperature 25 °C (77 °F) and the “Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)”
value on the Engine Performance Data Sheet. The term “fan-on temperature” applies to all fan control designs. It
is intended only as a general fan sensor temperature guideline for fan speed control. For on/off type fan clutches
this would be the temperature at which the fan must be on. For variable speed/pitch fans, actual fan-on
temperature will depend on the fan control design, the machine design, and the results of testing.
3.2.5.8 Variable Speed/Pitch Fan Clutches
CAC outlet temperatures can rise very rapidly because the turbocharger compressor outlet temperature is a
function of boost pressure and because there is relatively little thermal inertia in the CAC cooler. Therefore, it is
recommended that variable speed or variable pitch fans begin rising above their idle speed/pitch setting before
reaching the “Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)”.
As a fan control design starting point, the fan air flow should reach 50-75% of max air flow by 38 °C (100 °F) CAC
outlet temperature. It should also operate at maximum speed/pitch 5 °C (9 °F) before reaching the “Maximum
coolant temperature for engine protection controls” listed on the Engine Performance Data Sheet.
The fan speed/pitch must be calibrated to provide the specified CAC dT or less whenever the CAC outlet
temperature is equal to or higher than the “Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)” specified
on the Engine Performance Data Sheet. This may be less than full fan speed if the CAC has been sized to provide
the cooling requirement at this reduced fan speed/pitch. Sizing the CAC to meet the required CAC dT with less
than full fan speed/pitch may provide significant fuel economy and noise benefits. See Table 5 for the
recommended fan control curve for an engine with a “Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)”
of 35 °C (63 °F). Actual fan control temperature settings will vary by application and operating cycle. Confirm fan
control settings through testing.
Note: Depending on operating conditions, the measured difference between CAC_Out and IMT may be more
than this. If the fan is controlled based on the IMT sensor instead of an OEM supplied CAC_Out sensor, the
cooling fan will operate more than necessary in some operating conditions and thus will not be fully optimized for
fuel economy and noise. If fuel economy and noise are critical for the application, then an OEM supplied CAC
outlet temperature sensor should be used to control the fan.
Cast
Aluminum
End Tank
Brazed
Aluminu
m Core
Engin
e Charg Engin Charg
e Air e e Air
Cooler Cooler
Bad Piping: Pipe with bend at Turbo outlet Good Piping: Pipe with bend at Turbo
is not supported – prone to hose blow-off. outlet is bracketed to engine.
Engin Charg
Engin Charg
e e Air
e e Air
Cooler
Cooler
Bad Piping: Molded hose used for bend at Good Piping: Rotatable turbo elbow used
turbo outlet – prone to hose blow-off. with straight pipes.
Requirement 6: The charge air connection tubing must be made of a) aluminized steel, b) stainless steel, or c)
internally and externally powder coated steel tubing. It must not made of aluminum or untreated steel
Requirement Background: The specifications protect the durability and integrity of the system and avoid
failures during the emissions warranty period for the machine.
Corrosion resistant steel rather than aluminum tubing is recommended. Aluminum tubing loses much of its
strength above the 204 °C (400 °F) temperatures present on the hot side of the system, making it prone to
deformation under clamp loads. Aluminum tubing also has much greater thermal expansion than stainless steel
clamps, causing high stresses in the tubing and clamp at high temperatures. These high stresses may break the
clamps or crush the tubing. Stainless steel or internally and externally powder coated steel tubing is acceptable
as an alternative to aluminized steel.
Corrosion resistant steel charge air tubing must be fully protected from both internal and external corrosion. Most
aluminized steel tubing is fully protected except for a narrow internal weld seam. Testing has shown that corrosion
of this narrow weld seam in aluminized steel tubing is not a problem, so it does not need to be protected and is
therefore preferred. Alternatively, stainless steel or powder coated tubing can be used, but stainless steel is
typically more expensive than aluminized steel tubing and care must be taken to ensure that powder coated tubing
is fully coated on the inside of the tubing and will not chip off over the life of the machine.
3.3.3.3 Tube Welding
If the tubing is fabricated from multiple pieces welded together, the welding process will destroy the protective
aluminum coating. A rust-preventative paint or similar treatment must protect these welded areas. Cummins
recommends that the tubing layout utilize the minimum number of welded connections possible.
Requirement 7: The charge air system tubing, hoses, clamps, and mounting must meet the requirements defined
in AEB 24.20 Hose Material and Hose Requirements and Recommendations. AEB 24.20 describes the required
hose and clamp types and materials required for charge air cooler plumbing.
Requirement Background: The specifications protect the durability and integrity of the system and avoid
failures during the emissions warranty period for the machine.
Both the dynamic flow and static pressure of the boost air exiting the turbocharger compressor result in forces
acting along the axis of the CAC tubes. These boost forces may react against the turbocharger’s compressor
cover and induce two forms of moments. See AEB 64.13 for complete requirements and recommendations and
additional information.
Requirement 8: The loads due to the boost pressure forces, charge air system plumbing geometry, and charge
air system plumbing weight must meet the specifications as defined in AEB 64.13 Cummins Turbo Technologies-
Turbocharger Load Limits. AEB 64.13 describes the maximum load limits for the intake air and charge air cooler
plumbing attachment to the turbocharger.
Requirement Background: The specifications protect the durability and integrity of the system and avoid
failures during the emissions warranty period for the machine.
Charge air cooling connections must meet AEB 24.20 hose and clamp and tubing design requirements. See AEB
24.20 for hose and clamp requirements and recommendations.
Requirement 9: For engines with variable geometry turbocharger (VGT), all OEM drawings for air system
components downstream of the air filter must specify the cleanliness requirements outlined in this document. This
includes intake air pipes and hoses, charge air cooler tubing and hoses, and any other clean air side of the intake
air and charge air cooler system.
Requirement Background: Any contamination in the system will be ingested directly into the engine cylinders
and passed through the turbo machinery, and may result in serious engine damage.
The variable geometry turbocharger (VGT) is more complex than older turbocharger designs and is much more
sensitive to damage due to foreign objects that may pass through the turbine side of the turbocharger. Therefore,
cleanliness of the charge air cooling system is critical to engine and turbocharger durability. Any contamination in
the system will be ingested directly into the engine cylinders and passed through the turbo machinery, and may
result in serious engine damage.
Therefore the specifications in Sections 3.3.7.1 and 3.3.7.2 need to be met in order to avoid damage to the turbine
side of the turbocharger. Maximum allowed particle specifications must meet the SAE standards specified by
J1726 FEB 2010 or later versions.
3.3.7.1 Aluminum Particle Specifications
The area denoted in grey in Figure 10 indicates the maximum surface area of an aluminum particle face that is
allowed through the CAC in order to avoid failure.
Figure 10 Maximum Allowed Dimensions of an Aluminum Particle through the Charge Air Cooler
Table 6 Maximum Allowed Aluminum Particle Specifications for CAC Cleanliness Specified by SAE
Standard J1726 FEB 2010
Maximum Allowed
Maximum Allowed Aluminum Particle
Aluminum Particle
Specification Description
Specification Value
Weld Spatter
Figure 11 Unacceptable weld spatter
NOTES:
1. TUBE ENDS TO BE CAPPED WITH PLASTIC (PIPE
OD) END CAPS.
A
NOTES:
1. COMPONENT MUST BE VISUALLY CLEAN AND
FREE OF DEBRIS
NOTES:
1. CHARGE-AIR-COOLER OPENINGS TO BE CAPPED WITH
PLASTIC END CAPS.
C
Figure 12 Examples of cleanliness recommendations to use on OEM drawings (Examples A, B and C)
In addition to stopping cooling airflow, a variable pitch fan can also be used to change the airflow direction. An
installation using a suction fan could be switched to a blower fan arrangement during cold ambient temperatures
by changing the fan blade orientation. This allows preheated air from the engine compartment and the engine
radiator (for series heat exchanger core arrangements) to warm the air flowing through the charge air cooler core.
Winterfronts should have a minimum open area of at least 400 cm2 (62 in2) on engine of less than 8 liter
displacement and 775 cm2 (120 in2) for engines greater than 8 liter displacement. This open area should be in
front of the Charge Air Cooler and the open area should equalize the exposure of each CAC tube to cooling airflow
to provide more uniform temperature distribution over the cooler core area.
4 Definitions
Term Definition
Must This is used to indicate a mandatory practice or requirement.
Shall This is used to indicate a mandatory practice or requirement.
Should This is used to indicate a strongly recommended practice.
May Indicates guidance only. A practice that can be deviated from.
CAC Charge Air Cooler
CAC dT Charge Air Cooler delta temperature – difference between the CAC outlet
temperature and ambient (atmospheric) air temperature
CAC_Out Charge Air Cooler outlet temperature – temperature measured in the OEMs
CAC plumbing downstream of the cooler. For non-EGR engine this is the
same as the Intake Manifold Temperature.
Charge Air This is the mass flow of engine charge air that must be cooled by the charge
Flow air cooler.
EGR Exhaust Gas Recirculation
IMPD Maximum Pressure Drop from Turbocharger Compressor Air Outlet to the
Intake Manifold. This is the maximum allowable restriction of the complete
charge air cooling system, measured with the engine at full power output.
IMT Intake Manifold Temperature
IMTD Intake Manifold Temperature Differential; replaced by more general term CAC
dT to accommodate both EGR and non-EGR engines.
5 Reference Documentation
AEB /
Document
Number Title
AEB 21.46 Installation Requirements - Guidelines for OEM Installed Hardware
AEB 24.20 Hose Material and Hose Requirements and Recommendations
AEB 64.13 Cummins Turbo Technologies-Turbocharger Load Limits
Low Ambient Temperature Test Conditions (10 °C (50 °F) to 21 °C (70 °F))
The minimum ambient temperature allowed during a cooling qualification test is 21 °C (70 °F). Cummins will not
accept a cooling test conducted at an ambient temperature below 21 °C (70 °F).
Cummins has conducted a number of tests to understand and measure the cooling performance impact of ambient
temperature on cooling system performance. Through this testing, reasonable correction factors have been
established allowing for testing at an ambient between 10 °C (50 °F) and 21 °C (70 °F), then adjusting back to a
25 °C (77 °F) ambient. However, it is still recommended to conduct testing at an ambient of 21 °C (70 °F) or above
when possible.
In order to improve testability, Cummins now allows cooling system testing to an ambient as low as 10 °C (50 °F).
All cooling results must be corrected back to 25 °C (77 °F) ambient condition to be considered for compliance with
Cummins requirements. When testing at a lower ambient, it is important to remember to lock the fan on to prevent
cycling and that each rating must be loaded as an individual calibration. Several cold weather algorithms are
based on a fueling threshold. Attempting to run a higher rating at part load to simulate a lower rating may induce
these algorithms to become active, rendering the cooling test invalid.
Engine temperatures should be stable for data to be valid. Typical warm-up time is 30 minutes at full load.
Engine speed and load should be maintained at a steady state condition or as close as is reasonably possible
until all temperatures stabilize. Stabilization is achieved when the engine outlet coolant temperature does
not change more than 0.5 °C (1.0 °F) in 5 minutes. Charge Air Cooler outlet temperature (CAC_Out) should
be stable in a much shorter time than coolant outlet temperature, but coolant outlet temperature often affects
the CAC_Out temperature maximum readings. As a result, CAC_Out should no longer fluctuate once coolant
outlet temperature is stable.
Note: If ambient temperature is changing during the testing, record (coolant out minus ambient and CAC_Out
versus ambient) to track the testing results for full stabilization.
The test must be conducted at maximum heat rejection conditions. Steady state full load testing or worst
case duty cycle testing are acceptable machine loading conditions.
Additional heat loads (such as torque converter cooling or hydraulic cooling) must be included when
conducting the cooling test. Disconnect or turn off any heat sinks, (such as the cab heater) during the cooling
test.
The test must not be conducted when moisture (such as rain, fog, or road spray) will enter the cooling cores.
For electronic engines, the coolant temperature must be greater than 71 °C (160 °F) and the intake manifold
temperature must be greater than 25 °C (77 °F) during the test.
On electronic engines, if the coolant temperature drops below 71 °C (160 °F) it must be overridden via
Calterm to 85 °C (185 °F). This is to ensure the engine is running on the correct fueling and timing tables.
A correction factor must be applied to CAC outlet delta temperature (CAC dT) when tested at these lower ambient
temperatures. This correction factor (increase the measured CAC dT by 1° per each 5° change in ambient
temperature (regardless if it’s °C or °F)) must be used to correct to a 25 °C (77 °F) standard day temperature.
Example:
Ambient Test Temperature = 15 °C (59 °F)
Measured CAC dT = 30 °C (54 °F)
Correction Factor = (25 °C – 15°) * 1°/5° = 2 °C
Corrected CAC dT = 32 °C (58 °F)
Pressure Measurement
1. Turbocharger compressor outlet pressure – Install a pressure tap into the turbo compressor outlet elbow.
2. Intake manifold pressure – Install a pressure tap in the intake manifold or inlet elbow attached to the manifold.
Use a different location than the CAC outlet temperature thermocouple location. Do not install the temperature
and pressure measurements into a common tee.
6. Is the CAC fin density designed to prevent dirt and debris entrapment?
7. Is the cooler installation designed to prevent dirt and debris entrapment and also allow for good cleaning
access?
8. Are all charge air system direction changes done with tubing rather than hoses?
9. Is the charge air tubing made of aluminized steel and not of aluminum or untreated steel?
10. Is the CAC isolated from the engine by the use of a flexible hose on each end of the system tubing?
11. Does the charge air tube work prevent excessive boost pressure reactions at the turbocharger?
12. Is the system tubing adequately supported to prevent hose blow-off?
13. Are the system hoses Nomex® reinforced, bellows-type, and silicone hoses with external reinforcing rings?
14. Does all the system tubing have continuous, 360° hose beads?
15. Are hose clamps of the constant tension type?
16. Is the OEM installing clean, dirt free systems?
17. Does the cooling fan control maintain proper CAC_Out under all operating conditions and ambient
temperatures?
18. If shutters or variable pitch fan blades are used to prevent overcooling in extremely cold ambient temperatures,
do they open at or before the value listed on the Engine Data Sheet?
19. If winter fronts are used to prevent overcooling in extremely cold ambient temperatures, does the winter front
provide a partial open area in front of the CAC to prevent excessive CAC outlet temperatures?
5. Run the engine with load so that it operates steady state at the operating condition defined above. For
mechanical engines, use the intake manifold pressure reading in conjunction with the engine speed to
confirm you are running at the maximum airflow operating condition. For electronic engines, this information
can be retrieved from the engine datalink.
6. Record the intake air temperature (measured at the turbocharger inlet) at the maximum airflow
operating condition after the engine compartment temperature stabilizes.
Intake air temperature: °C (°F)
7. The amount of intake air heating (intake temperature rise over ambient) is calculated by subtracting the
ambient air temperature from the intake air temperature.
Air temperature rise over ambient: Delta °C (Delta °F)
Is this value greater than the maximum allowable value on the datasheet? Yes/No
Special Considerations
Special care must be taken when attempting to load a machine to maximum power by means other than
the way the machine was intended to operate (such as stalling the hydraulic pumps on a hydraulic or
hydrostatic machine). Excessive heat can be generated during the test that will overload the machine’s
hydraulic, engine or other machine cooling systems. Special arrangements may be required to deal with
the increased heat loads.
“Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)” Delta °C (Delta °F)
(user reference only)
The minimum ambient temperature at which an accurate CAC performance test can be run is 10 °C (50 °F).
Cummins will not accept test results run at an ambient below 10 °C (50 °F). For ambient below 21 °C (70 °F)
and >= 10 °C (50 °F) a correction factor must be used to correct to a 25 °C (77 °F) standard day temperature.
The correction is done by increasing the measured CAC dT by 1° per each 5° change in ambient temperature
(regardless if °C or °F).
All thermocouples must be installed with the sensing tip in the fluid being measured and not touching any
metallic surface. It is required that you meet the CAC dT defined on the Engine Performance Data Sheet for
all speed and load conditions.
Test Procedure
1. I nstall a thermocouple in the tubing between the charge air cooler and the intake manifold to read
the temperature of the air as it exits the charge air cooler.
2. Locate another thermocouple outside the vehicle to measure ambient air temperature. This
thermocouple should be located out of the sun and away from any heat source. Record the
ambient temperature.
Are all temperature probes located away from undesired heat sources? Yes/No
3. Install a pressure tap in the intake manifold or inlet elbow attached to the manifold. Use a different
location, but one that is near the location of the intake manifold temperature thermocouple
(mechanical engines only). Do not install the temperature and pressure measurements into a
common tee.
4. For applications with variable speed engine cooling fans, make sure the fan is operating at the fan
speed that would be commanded when the CAC outlet temperature is equal to the "Charge air cooler
outlet temperature for full Fan-On" as published on the Engine Performance Data Sheet.
5. Connect all instrumentation to a data logging device if available.
6. Run the engine with load so that it operates steady state at the operating condition defined above.
For mechanical engines, use the intake manifold pressure reading in conjunction with the engine
speed to confirm you are running at the maximum power operating condition. For electronic engines,
this information can be retrieved via the engine datalink.
7. After 5-10 min of operation, the charge air cooler outlet temperature (CAC_Out) will
typically stabilize at a maximum value. Record this value.
CAC outlet temperature
(CAC_Out) at rated speed and power: °C (°F)
8. ( Optional) Repeat the test at a second operating condition. Record the intake air temperature.
CAC outlet temperature (CAC_Out) at operating point: °C (°F)
9. The amount of CAC intake air heating (intake temperature rise over ambient (CAC dT)) is
calculated by subtracting the ambient air temperature from the CAC outlet temperature
(CAC_Out).
CAC dT = CAC outlet temperature (CAC_Out) – Ambient Air Temp (a smaller value is better).
Record your measured CAC dT: Delta °C (Delta °F)
10. Is your measured CAC dT greater than the maximum allowable? Yes/No
CAC dT “Maximum CAC outlet to ambient at 25 °C (77 °F) (CAC dT)” specified on the Engine
Performance Data Sheet?
If yes, you are not compliant with Cummins requirements.
Special Considerations
Special care must be taken when attempting to load a machine to maximum power by means other than
the way the machine was intended to operate (such as stalling the hydraulic pumps on a hydraulic or
hydrostatic machine). Excessive heat can be generated during the test that will overload the machine’s
hydraulic, engine or other machine cooling systems. Special arrangements may be required to deal with
the increased heat loads.
6 Change Log
Deleted “Is the CAC Outlet Temperature less than the IMT 22-23
Derate/Alarm Set Point printed on the Engine Data Sheet
when tested according to the procedure outlined in this 25
recommendation?” from Installation Review Check Sheet
section.
Re-ordered Tests in Appendix A.
Added text “For applications with variable speed engine
cooling fans, make sure the fan is operating at the fan speed 26
that would be commanded when the CAC outlet temperature 27
is equal to the "Charge air cooler outlet temperature for full
Fan-On" as published on the Engine Performance Data
Sheet.”
Deleted “and to make sure that the intake manifold temperature
does not exceed the alarm/derate set point during high
ambient operation. For engines without EGR, the intake 29
manifold temperature is equivalent to CAC outlet
temperature.”.
Deleted “If the engine is equipped with EGR the CAC dT test
should be performed. If the engine is not equipped with EGR
the IMTD test should be performed. The major difference 29
between the IMTD and CAC dT tests is the location of the
intake manifold temperature thermocouple.”.
Deleted mention of IMTD.
Changed “70 °F” to “50 °F”.
Changed text from “F o r e n g i n e s w i t h o u t E G R , i nstall 29-30
a thermocouple in the engine intake manifold or elbow 29
attached to the manifold to read the temperature of the air as 29
it enters the manifold. Intake manifold temperature on
electronic engines can be monitored and/or logged via the
engine datalink. For engines with EGR, install a
thermocouple in the engine intake piping before the EGR
mixer. It is important to take the temperature measurement
before hot EGR exhaust gases are mixed with the charge air
from the charge air cooler.” to “I nstall a thermocouple in the
piping between the charge air cooler and the intake manifold
to read the temperature of the air as it exits the charge air
cooler.”
Changed text to “operating at the fan speed that would be
commanded when the CAC outlet temperature is equal to
the "Charge air cooler outlet temperature for full Fan-On" as 30, 31
published on the Engine Performance Data Sheet”
11 29Jun12 Liz McLean Updated AEB to most recent format – no content changes. All
10 25Aug11 S. de Silva Updated Approver number in header. 1
Added Definitions section. 1
Added relationship between CAC Outlet Temperature and 1, 3
Intake Manifold Temperature for engines without EGR
(black box on page 3). 4
Showed the Emissions Related Installation Instructions in table 5
format.
Clarified how to calculate maximum allowable CAC Outlet 6, 14
Temperatures at ambient targets.
Added Tables to reflect Charge Air Cooler Operating 14, 15
temperature conditions and maximum allowed particle
specifications. 16, 17
Included CAC Cleanliness Specifications (Text and visual) with 25, 26
respect to SAE J1726 FEB 2010.
Edited OEM Air System Pipe Prints.
Clarified Appendix A test names.
09 31Mar11 R. Bergstedt Updated Approver number in header. 1
Clarified cleanliness requirement for VGT product only. 1
Added recommendations for OEM drawing cleanliness. 12-14
23-30