Lesson - 5 Labour Law
Lesson - 5 Labour Law
Lesson - 5 Labour Law
Labour Law
Employer -employee relationship
Employment involves two persons, the employer who
employs a person to do some work for him and an
employee or workman who undertakes to do that work. In
the kind of employment we are concerned with, there is an
agreement of the use of the service of the employee in the
way that the employer wants. This agreement is the best
indication of the true relationship between them.
Contract of Employment
A contract of employment can be defined as an agreement
between two parties one party (workman) agrees to hire
his service to the other (employer) for a consideration
which is called wages or salary.
It is important to establish a contract of employment
between the parties before the provisions of the Labour
laws can be utilized for the benefit of the workman.
Contract of employment/service and contract for
service
In order to establish the existence of a contract of
employment, it is necessary to distinguish between a
“contract of service” and “contract for service”, the
contract of service giving rise to the master and servant
relationship, while the contract for service arises an
1
employer and independent contractor relationship. This is
a question of law depending upon the rights conferred and
the duties imposed on the parties by the contract.
Labour law gives all the benefits and protections to a
workman and not to an Independent contractor. Therefore
it is important to consider the difference between a
Workman and an Independent contractor.
There are three tests available to distinguish an
employee from an Independent contractor
1. The control test
Here it is found out whether the employer has control and
supervision over the employee regarding the manner in
which the work is to be done. If the employer has control
over the employee not only to tell what is to be done but
also to tell how the work has to be done, and to supervise
him, such an employee is a workman.
2. Economic Reality or multiple Test
In this test matters such as the right to engage work,
suspend and dismiss the employee, the method of payment
,whether the statutory deductions are made from the
wages for EPF and hours of work, who supplies the tools
& materials for the work are also considered in
distinguishing a workman from an Independent
contractor.
In Ready Mixed Concrete Vs. Minister of Pension the
above criteria were laid down in determining the master
and servant relationship. In this case a driver of a lorry
2
had a contract with a company under which he drove his
own lorry but painted in company colors. He could employ
a substitute driver. He was paid on mileage and for the
work done. He did the repairs and maintenance in his own
expenses. Held he was an Independent contractor, because
he provided his own equipment (lorry)
2. Integration or organization Test
According to the above test under a contract of service a
man is employed as a part of the business whereas under a
contract for services, his work although done for the
business, is not integrated into it, but is only accessory to
it. That is an employee is part and parcel of the
organization. But an Independent contractor will perform
work for the organization and he is an outsider.
This test is used mostly for professional people. With the
developing technology and specialization, employers
recruit people for particular skills. Therefore the
employers may not have sufficient knowledge or skill to
instruct such employees how the work has to be done.
Therefore this a test is applied to see whether he is part of
the business or mere an accessory.
Cassidy Vs.Minister of health
A resident surgeon in a hospital was held to be an
employee ,even though the hospital did not have control to
tell how the work has to be done, because he was part of
the organization.
3
Difference between workman and an Independent
contractor
Employee Independent
Contractor
1.Uses his own tools
1.Uses masters tools 2.he himself liable for
2.employer is liable for the his contracts and torts
contracts which entered by the 3.Usually has a specific
employee and torts duration
3.No specific time period to 4.Payment can done
complete the work according to the special
4.employee could be time rated, way
piece rated or performance 5..Independent
rated contractor is an
5.employee is an integral part of accessory
the business 5.Independent contractor
6.employee can claim EPF, ETF cannot claim
and Gratuity EPF,ETF,Gratuity
7.Usually employee cannot 6.He can delegate his
delegate his duties powers
4
ifferent Sectors of Employment
There are 9 sectors of employment.
1 .Government Servants/ State Officers/ Public
Officers
Government servants or public officers probably
constitute the single largest category of employees.
They are persons who hold paid office under the
Republic of Sri Lanka.
Applicable Laws: The Establishment Code
under Article 33(4) of the Constitution, the Cabinet is
empowered to formulate "schema of recruitment and codes
of conduct for public officers, the principles to be followed
in making promotions and transfers, and the procedure for
the exercise and the delegation of the powers of
appointment, transfer, dismissal and disciplinary control of
public officers,"
Remedies available to Public Officers
The Industrial Disputes Act expressly precludes public
officers from seeking any form of relief or redress under
the Act, in connection with their employment.
Article 55(5) of the Constitution takes away the public
officer's right to go to a civil court in regard to any
matter covering his appointment.
The only recognizable right of a public officer under
the Constitution is administrative appeals for redress;
but the Constitution also expressly reserves to a public
officer the right to petition the Supreme Court under
Article 126 for violation of his fundamental rights.
2 .Provincial Public Service
1. Permanent
A permanent employment is where the contract is
automatically renewed each month until the employee
reaches the age of retirement.
The employee is guaranteed security of employment with
all benefits like EPF, ETF, bonus, gratuity and so on,
unless there is disruption of service due to illness or for
some other reason. Some of these reasons may be
misconduct on his part; or, termination of his services
unilaterally by his employer; or the establishment going
8
into liquidation.
2. Temporary
A temporary employee is one who is recruited to fill a
vacancy created by a permanent employee going on leave;
or someone recruited to do a job which is of a temporary
nature, the duration of which is limited by the job or by
time.
Such employees are also entitled to EPF and ETF
benefits; and where the duration of employment exceeds
180 days in a continuous period of 12 months, the
provisions of the Termination of Employment of
Workmen (Special Provisions) Act shall apply, provided
the employment is in a scheduled employment and the
employer had 15 or more employees on the average in the
6-month period preceding such termination.
3. Casual
A casual employee is one who is employed by chance or
on no regular contract of employment. For example, an
odd-job gardener or a person who undertakes to wash and
polish a car; An employer cannot expect a casual employee
to arrive for work continuously. He cannot as a right
expects the work from employer.
4. Probation
Probation implies a 'fixed and limited period of time'
during which an organization employs a new employee in
order to assess his aptitudes, abilities, characteristics,
conduct and his devotion to work, before taking him into
9
the permanent cadre. It is a trial period during which the
employee is tested by the employer. It follows therefore,
that the employer should have the right to discontinue a
probationer if he does not come up to expectations. But the
termination should base on bona fide reasons.
5. Seasonal
Certain types of employment - such as harvesting of paddy
or sugar-cane, drying of tobacco, working in tourist hotels,
etc., - are by their very nature seasonal. There is no
assurance of regular employment since work i s available
only during a certain season of the year and the employee
is discontinued at the end of that season. Nonetheless, any
such employee is entitled to EPF and ETF benefits for the
period he is employed.
6. Fixed-term Contract
A fixed-term contract is a contract of employment which
expires on a definite date, not on the happening of a
particular event or on the completion of a particular task
at some time in the future. A fixed-term contract does not
lose its legal character as fixed-term merely because it
provides for its premature termination by notice.
7. Apprenticeship (Trainees / Learners)
In the case of apprentice there is no contract of service.
Therefore, he cannot be considered a workman in the
normal sense. An apprentice is a person who is there to
learn the trade, and the master or employer has
undertaken to train him and prepare him to understand
the trade in which he is engaged .
10
Relevant labour Statutes
The shop and Office Employees Act (Regulation of
Employment and Remuneration) No 19 of 1954
This Act covers the following areas of the employees
-4days
19
Payment of Gratuity Act No 12 of 1983
This Act provides for payment of gratuity by
employers to their workmen, for the amendment of the
Land Acquisition Act, the Land Reform Law and the
Industrial Disputes Act.
The Act is divided into 2 parts. Part I concerns the
payment of gratuity to workers in the plantation sector;
while Part II concerns such payment to all other
employees.
Calculation of Gratuity
Monthly rated workman-half month salary for each
year of completed service computed at the rate of
salary last drawn by the workman
Daily payment workman -14 days salary for each
year of completed service computed at the rate of
such pay last draw by that workman
Piece rated workman-The daily wage or salary shall
be computed by dividing the total wage or salary
received by him for a period of 03 months
immediately preceding the termination of his
employment ,by the number of days worked by him in
that period. Then it should compute as above.
The following employees are excluded by this act
Domestic servant
Personal chauffeur in a private household
Employees of co-operative societies
Employees who are entitled to a pension under any
non contributory pension scheme
Workman designated under the Indian Repatriates
Law of 1978
20
Any establishment employing less than 15 employees
during the period of 12 months immediately
preceding the termination of the service of a
workman
Forfeiture of Gratuity
Any workman to whom a gratuity is payable under
Part II of this Act and whose services have been
terminated for reasons of fraud, misappropriation of
funds of the employer, wilful damage to property of
the employer, or causing the loss of goods, articles or
property of the employer, shall forfeit such gratuity
to the extent of damage or loss caused by him.
Where there is a dispute over such forfeiture, the
aggrieved workman may apply to a labour tribunal for
adjudication.
21
Industrial Disputes Act no 43 of 1950
Objective
This act has been enacted to prevent, investigate and
settle industrial disputes. This act is applicable to the
employees in the private sector, semi Government
sector eg Corporations, Boards etc.
But it is not applicable to the employees of the Crown
(Government / Public Servants) and to the employees
in the Local Government Service and three armed forces
including the judiciary.
Definition for the Industrial Dispute
An Industrial Dispute is a dispute or a difference
between
an employer and a workman,
employers and workmen or
between workmen and workmen connected with
• Employment or non-employment
• Terms of employment
• Conditions of labour
• The termination of services of the workman or
• Reinstatement of service of a workman.
Mechanisms to settle an industrial disputes
1. Conciliation
2. Arbitration
3. Labour Tribunal
4. Industrial Court
5. Collective agreements
22
1. Conciliation
2. Arbitration
a. Voluntary Arbitration
If the parties to the dispute consent, the commissioner may refer that
dispute for settlement by arbitration to an arbitrator nominated jointly
by such parties or in the absence of such nomination, to an arbitrator
appointed by the commissioner. This is known as 'voluntary arbitration'.
Because
b. Compulsory Arbitration
3. Labour Tribunal
4. Industrial Court
24
The Industrial Court also has been established to solve industrial disputes. However
only the Minister can refer matters to an industrial Court.
A workman cannot directly make an application to the Industrial Court. The Industrial
Court consists a panel of five persons appointed by the President of Sri Lanka. The
Minister may select/appoint one or more persons to the court.
According to the Industrial Disputes Act, an Industrial Court has three main functions
As per the Section 17(1),24(1) and 31(1) c Industrial Disputes Act, the
Arbitrator, Labour Tribunal and the Industrial Court should make orders as
may appear to them to be just & equitable. Just & equitable means a fair & a
reasonable order. A just & equitable decision has the following limitations. Sri
Lankan Courts have identified the guidelines to be followed in making awards or
orders as follows,
In granting a just and equitable order the tribunal and arbitrators should act
judicially by following the principles of natural justice.
Ex.Weeramanthry J. has expressed this view in CTB Vs. Gunasinghe
Ex.U.C Panadura Vs.Cooray
The decision must not violate any statutory provision or decisions of the
higher courts.
Before they give their award or order, they should consider all the
material evidence and material question involved must be considered
related to the case.
A just an equitable order must also contain reasons why they made such
award or order. It must not take in to account irrelevant matters and
extraneous issues. Ex.CTB Vs.Thungadasa
In making the award or order, they are not bound by any contract of
employment or collective agreements made between the employer &
workmen.That means the order must not contrary to the public interest.
25
5. Collective Agreement
This is defined under section 5(1) of the industrial Dispute Act. This has been
defined as "An agreement made between
Relating to;
Definition
Section 02 of the Trade union ordinance defines a trade union as any association or
combination of workmen or employers, whether temporary or permanent, having among
its objects one or more of the following objects.
26
a.)The regulation of relations between workmen and employers, or between workmen and
workmen or between employers and employers or
Section 08 of the ordinance stated that, every trade union formed should
register itself within 3 months from the date it was so established.
Every application for registration of a trade union shall be made to the Registrar
in the prescribed form and shall be signed by at least 7 members of the union,
any of whom may be officers thereof.-Sec 09 The application should be with
following particulars,
1. Picketing
Picketing is understood to mean persons either singly or in groups attending at or near
premises connected with a dispute. The aim may be to communicate information; or to
persuade others; or to cause physical obstruction. The lawfulness of the acts of pickets
depends upon the nature of their attendance and the means used (peaceful or not).
2. Go- Slow
Go -slow is a deliberate slowing down of work and production below normal levels. It is
considered as an unfair labour practice, since it affects production and causes financial loss
to the employer.
A go slow is a breach of contract, for it is an implied condition of service that an employee,
in so far as he is capable of working, should work at a reasonable speed in order to promote
those commercial interests for which he is employed. If he deliberately goes slow, he breaks
his contract and is guilty of grave misconduct which severe disciplinary action
Where more than one workman is guilty of the same misconduct, it is unfair labour
practice for an employer to select at random some of the employees and dismiss them as it
would be discriminatory to punish a few and to let others go scot free.
3. Work to Rule
Work to rule occurs where an employee performs his duties by interpreting them strictly
according to the rules and standing orders issued by the establishment, the objective being
to wilfully disrupt the smooth operations of the establishment, without openly violating its
rules.
It would be a breach of his employment contract for an employee to give the employer's
rules an unreasonable construction. Where, in obeying lawful instructions, the employee
seeks to obey them in a wholly unreasonable way, it will amount to disrupting the
system.
Work to rule involves-a breach of the positive obligation of faithful service owed by an
employee to his employer.
4. Boycott
Boycott is refusal to deal with or patronise a business. It is an unfair labour practice and
thus illegal, amounting to misconduct. It is not a strike or a limited form of it. Boycott
may be used not only against those who have a trade relationship with the employer but
also against those who have a trade relationship with the employer, such as buyers
suppliers or transporters.
28
5. Gherao
The term Gherao means a physical blockage of a target either by encirclement or forcible
occupation. The target may be a place, a person or persons, usually the managerial or
supervisory staff of an industrial establishment. Some of the offences complained of are
cruel and inhuman - like confinement in a small space without lights or fans and for long
periods without food or communication with the outside world. Gherao is an act of
serious misconduct.
6.Strike
The term strike generally denotes the collective action resorted to by a body of employees
to express its grievances and to win its demands from an employer.
A strike involves two essential ingredients: a complete cessation of work and concerted
action. It is a consequence of an industrial dispute and it is to coerce or force the employer
to accept the terms and conditions affecting employment, proposed by the striking
employees.
Mere absence from work does not amount to taking part in a strike. There should be
evidence that the absence of the workmen was the result of some concerted action with a
view to enforcing an industrial demand.
The right to strike is a legitimate trade union mechanism available to I workers and
their organisations for the promotion and protection of their economic and social interests.
Although the right to strike is not stated in explicit terms in any of the labour laws of Sri
Lanka, the immunity from, or victimisation for any act done in contemplation or in
furtherance of a trade dispute granted to workers under the Trade Unions Ordinance,
enables workmen to go on strike.
However, the freedom to strike has its limitations, in that it does not include the
freedom to commit or threaten physical violence to person and/or property.
Illegal Strikes
A strike could be held illegal If it is in violation of sections 32(2), 40(1) (/), 40(1) (fff) and
40(1) (m) of the Industrial Disputes Act. Strikes are also illegal when workmen go on
strike in violation of any law or emergency regulation in force for the time being.
7.Lock-out
Lock-out means withholding of work by an employer from his employees with a view to
forcing or compelling them to accept his terms of employment. It is a weapon available to
the employer in order to persuade his employees by coercive means to accept his demands.
It is resorted to sometimes by the employer as a security measure and in certain other
instances, as a weapon corresponding to what the employees have in the shape of a strike.
29
in compelling persons employed by him, to accept terms or conditions of or affecting
employment."
30
Termination of Employment of Workmen (Special Provisions)
Act No. 45 of 1971
Section 2 (1) of the above Act prohibits the termination of any workman in a scheduled
employment without ,
The definition of the scheduled employment includes all employees covered by the
Factories Ordinance, the Shop and Office Employees Act, and persons employed in
any trade which that the Wages boards Ordinance has applied .
In the following Instances the provisions of this act will not apply,
a) to an employer by whom less than 15 workmen on an average have been
employed during the period of 6 months preceding the month in which
the employer seeks to terminate the employment of a workman; or
b) to the termination of employment of any workman who has been employed
for a period less than 180 days in a continuous period of 12 months; or '
c) to the termination of employment of any workman who has been
employed by an employer where such termination was effected by way of
retirement in accordance with the provisions of any collective agreement, or
any contract of employment;
31
i) to the termination of employment of any workman who has been
employed by an employer in contravention of the provisions of any law
for the time being in force.
Commissioner may in his absolute discretion decide the terms and conditions subject to
which his approval should be granted, including any particular terms and conditions
relating to the payment by the employer to the workman of a termination of such
employment.
The commissioners decision made under the above provision is final ,conclusive and
cannot be called in question by way of writ or in any court tribunal or other institution
established under the IDA
However, a writ may lie against the Commissioner's decision, if it is not consistent
with the evidence adduced at the inquiry, or if the Commissioner has
made a finding for which there is no evidence, or i holding the inquiry there is a
violation of the principles of natural justice in the procedure adopted by the
Commissioner.
As long as the Commissioner has followed the correct procedure in conducting the
inquiry and there is evidence to support his findings, the Appeal Court would not
review the Commissioner's findings even though in the Court's perception of the
evidence, it may be inclined to come to a different conclusion.
Powers of the Commissioner
i. to enter and inspect at all reasonable hours of the day or night any place in
which workmen are employed in scheduled employments for the purpose of
examining any register or record of wages, or of ascertaining whether the
provisions of this Act are being complied with; or
ii. where any such record or register is not available for examination, to require
the production of such record or register on a specified later date for
examination in such place or at his office; or
iii. to cross examine any person whom he finds in such place and whom the
Commissioner has reasonable cause to believe is an employer or a workman; or
iv. to hold such inquiries as he may consider necessary for the purposes of this
Act.
32
Consequences of an illegal termination
The provisions with regard to retrenchment contained in IDA do not apply to workers
covered by the TEW Act.
33
34