Nox Control
Nox Control
Nox Control
1
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
Ultra Low NOx Burners Key Considerations for Process Fired Heaters
Ultra Low NOx Burners have design features and with Ultra Low NOx Burners
operating philosophy, which are different from a Every design step in fired heater and burner design
conventional burner. An Ultra Low NOx burner uses is critical for optimum performance. Oversight at
fuel staging and flue gas inspiration (internal flue any stage, from fuel gas supply to flue gas disposal
gas recirculation). system, will adversely affect burner performance
In fuel staging, combustion is carried out in stages, and hence fired heater capacity, overall thermal
efficiency, and run length. Proper burner selection,
one fuel-rich and the other fuel-lean. Fuel gas is
number of burners, fired duty per burner, and
injected into the combustion zone in two stages
which creates a fuel-lean zone and delays location of burners etc. are very important for
optimum performance of a fired heater. Following
completion of the combustion process. This keeps
are the most critical parameters that are need to be
combustion away from the stoichiometric mixture of
fuel and air where flame temperature peaks. evaluated when designing a fired heater with Ultra
Low NOx burners:
These burners are designed to re-circulate relatively
(1) Burner Design Parameters
cooler flue gas from the firebox back into the
(2) Heater design parameters
combustion zone using the pressure energy of fuel
(3) Fuel Gas Delivery System
gas. This re-circulation of largely inert flue gases
(4) Operating Parameters
into the combustion zone reduces the peak flame
temperature and average O2 concentration.
A fired heater with well-designed burners with good
The fuel-air mixture gets diluted by re-circulated engineering practice should be able to attain
flue gas resulting in lower combustion rates. Lower followings:
burning rates increase the flame length which can Minimize flame-to-flame interaction
often result in flame to flame interaction as well as Prevent leaning of flames
flame impingement on tubes. Prevent flame impingement
Flame to flame interaction can result in the merging Prevent burner to re-circulate flue gas from its
of flames from individual burners. Merged flame is own flame
much longer than stand-alone flame. The prolonged Meet the emission requirements
flames can tilt towards the tubes and flame tails can
impinge on tubes.
Secondary
Zone
Staged
Primary
Fuel Gas
Zone
Flue Gas
Primary
Fuel Gas
Combustion
Air
2
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
36,000
(1) Burner Design Parameters:
34,000
2.1 Selection of number of burners 3 Burners
32,000 4 Burners
Increasing the number of burners will reduce the
heat liberation per burner. This will result in the 30,000
3
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
get the cold flue gases for internal flue gas Ultra Low NOx burners for forced draft
recirculation. This lack of internal flue gas application. In this type of application, higher air
recirculation increases the NOx emission from pressure drop across the burner (say 2 InchWC)
the inner circle burner. The overall NOx from can significantly improve burner performance.
the heater will go up and may not meet the The higher air pressure drop results in better
emission requirement. flame pattern, minimize tube impingement, and
lower NOx. It becomes more critical in
2.3 Heat Liberation and Overdesign application with large number of burners in a
A good engineering practice for specifying the single chamber such as in a Coker heater. The
overdesign for a burner as per API-560 is as coupling of flames results in much higher NOx
follows: values than expected based on shop test of a
5 or fewer burners : 120% single burner.
6 or 7 burners : 115%
2.4 Burner Performance Shop Test
8 or more burners : 110%
The burner test is critical for Ultra Low NOx
It has been common practice in the industry to Burners. With conventional and low NOx
overdesign the burners. Additional margin on burners, the performance seen in the test is
burner design is sometimes applied on top of similar to multi-burner heaters. However this
margin on fired heater design. Overdesign shifts may not be always true with ultra-low NOx
the burner design point away from the actual burners. If burners are not placed with sufficient
operating point. spacing, the flames may merge, resulting in
longer flame length. It may also result in flame
In a case study, burners were designed with impingement on furnace tubes. Ultra-low NOx
120% margin on required firing rate. The draft burners are more prone to flame interaction in
available at heater design condition is 0.6 multi-burner heaters. Therefore, it is always
InchWC. However the draft utilized at heater recommended to carry out a burner test. Also, if
design condition will be 0.41 InchWC instead of a burner supplier has a sufficiently large heater,
0.6 InchWC actually available. This overdesign try to test two or more burners with the same
on the burner reduces the draft loss requirements spacing as the actual heater. The test furnace
for actual heater operating condition which conditions (e.g. Bridge wall temperature, draft
results in a larger flame dimension. It is highly etc.) should replicate that of the actual heater.
recommended to minimize the overdesign to
avoid increasing the overall flame dimension. It is critical to measure flame dimensions during
test. Visually establish the flame dimensions
An adequate air pressure drop should be used for may not be correct. It is recommended to use
Desired layout: Burners in one circle Non-desired layout: Burners in two circles
Figure-3 : Burner Layout Options
4
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
CO probing to establish more reliable flame API recommends a clearance between tubes and
dimension. CO levels must be low in the firebox burners. For natural draft, fuel gas fired burners;
outside of the flame envelope. CO levels of this can be translated into the following
more than 2000 ppm are generally considered as equations:
flame. ࡽ
ିࢀ = + .
Many users do not specify a burner test if they Where:
have used a similar burner in the past. Even CB-T = Burner to Tube Clearance, ft
though operating conditions and heat liberation QB = Burner Liberation, MMBtu/hr
are similar performance test is still
For Ultra Low NOx application, adding 6 inch to
recommended. A small difference in tip drilling
API recommended spacing seems to provide
(which is very common) can have a big impact
needed clearance for proper flue gas
on NOx emissions and flame stability.
recirculation. The modified equation shall be:
(2) Heater design parameters: ࡽ
ିࢀିࢁࡸࡺ = +
3.1 Burner to Tube Spacing and Flue Gas Table-1 provides suggested clearances for Ultra
Recirculation Low NOx Burners.
It is suggested to maximize burner to tube Table-2 provides summary of results form a case
clearance not only to avoid flame impingement study comparing the required minimum Tube
on tubes but also for better internal flue gas Circle Diameter (TCD) for a fired heater with
recirculation. This spacing becomes even more conventional burners and Ultra Low NOx
critical for a vertical cylindrical heater. In a Burners.
well-designed furnace, the hot flue gases should
flow upward through the center of the heater. 3.2 Bridge Wall (Firebox) Temperature
The cold flue gas should flow downward behind Ultra Low-NOx burner performance is much
and along the tubes. A smaller clearance more dependent on firebox temperature
between the burner and tubes may not allow compared to conventional burners. Burner NOx
cold flue gases to flow downward. The small and other emissions are a function of firebox
space will be filled with hot gases. Refer to temperature. Higher firebox temperature leads to
Figure-4 for a typical flue gas flow profile in higher NOx formation.
heaters with a normal firebox and a tight firebox.
The firebox temperature calculation methods
Burner Burner
Normal firebox : With flue gas re-circulation Tight firebox: With no or low flue gas re-circulation
Figure-4 : Firebox flue gas flow profile
5
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
generally used are empirical correlations based The overall heat transfer may not be affected in
on experimental data. The heat transfer in the applications where the heater has a convection-
radiant section is calculated with widely used section preheat coil followed by a radiant-
Lobo-Evans method. This method assumes section in which further heating occurs. In this
complete flue gas mixing in the firebox such that case, the total heat absorption for both the
there are no longitudinal or transverse radiant and convection coils will be about the
temperature gradients. The equation for radiant same, regardless of the Bridge Wall
heat transfer is as follows: Temperature.
࢘ ࢀࢍ ࢀ࢙ However, it is very important to correctly
= . ૠ ቈ൬ ൰ − ൬ ൰ + ૠ(ࢀࢍ − ࢀ࢙)
∝ ࢉࡲ estimate Bridge Wall Temperature where there
are two or more separate services, one in the
Where: radiant section and one or more in the
qr = Total heat absorbed in Radiant Section, Btu/hr
Tg = Average Radiating flue gas temperature in convection section. If the Bridge Wall
radiant section, °R Temperature is higher than expected, the
Ts = Temperature of cold surface (Tube Metal radiant-section absorption will be relatively low
Temperature), °R and the convection-section absorption relatively
αAcp = Equivalent Cold Plane area, ft2
F = Overall exchange factor
high. In this case, such as when the radiant
This correlation was developed based on section consists of a process coil and the
operating data from heaters using conventional convection section consist of a steam-generating
burners. Ultra Low NOx burner flames are coil. An error in the predicted bridgewall
significantly different than a conventional burner temperature would result in an error in one or
flame. An Ultra Low NOx burner flame is cooler both of the predicted duties as well as in the
than conventional burner flame. A lower flame guaranteed heater efficiency.
temperature will result in lower heat transfer in An accurate prediction of bridgewall
the radiant section. Therefore, the flue gas temperature is required, not only for emission
temperature leaving the radiant section will be prediction, but also to correctly predict heat
higher than that of a heater with conventional absorptions and other heater performance
burners. One must account for this when parameters.
designing fired heater. An Ultra Low NOx
In a case study, an estimated performance of a
burner installed in an existing fired heater
fired heater with conventional burner and Ultra
(burner retrofit) may result in loss of capacity or
Low NOx burners were analyzed. The case
overall thermal efficiency.
study was for a vertical cylindrical heater with
6
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
process coil in radiant section only. Convection Table-2 : Case Study: Required Minimum Tube Circle
section is used for waste heat recovery (steam Diameter for Conventional vs ULNB
coil). The Bridge wall temperature with Conventional ULNB
conventional burners is estimated as 1,560°F as Burner
compared to 1,620°F with Ultra Low NOx Burner design liberation, MMBtu/hr 10.0 10.0
burners. This increase in bridge wall temperature Number of burners 8 8
Burner spacing, Inch 30” 40”
do not only affect the firing rate & NOx
Burner circle diameter, ft-inch 6’-6” 8’-9”
emission but also affect the mechanical integrity
Burner to tube clearance, ft-inch 4’-0” 4’-6”
of heater components like tube supports,
Min. tube circle diameter, ft-inch 14’-6” 17’-9”
structural steel, refractory etc.
with similar firing rate, bridgewall temperature
3.3 Heat Density per unit area and excess, will have different NOx. The one
with lower heat density will likely to have lower
Heat density is not used for conventional NOx.
burners. However, it is a very significant
parameter for Ultra Low NOx Burners. The 3.4 Common Air Plenum Design
reason for this is the importance of flue gas
Common combustion air plenums are sometimes
internal circulation in ULNB.
provided to better control the combustion air.
The following formula can be used to determine These need to be designed to provide equal air to
area heat density: all the burners. It is possible to achieve relatively
ࡽ ࢈ ∗ uniform combustion air flow to each individual
ࡴ ࢋࢇ࢚ࡰࢋ࢙࢚࢟ = burner for a well-designed burner plenum. It is
Where: always recommended to carry out a
Qb = Burner Heat Release Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) analysis to
n = Number of Burners
A = Floor Area (inside the tube circle or between tube
ensure proper air distribution to each burner.
rows) The example in Table-3 demonstrates how air
A = πd2/4 (for Vertical Cylindrical Heaters)
d = Tube Circle diameter
mal-distribution can starve some burners of
A = LxW (for Cabin / Box Heaters) combustion air.
L = Heater Length
W = Heater width (tube center to center)
It is very common to target 2% or even lower
Flue gas flow patterns in the radiant section of excess O2 (2% O2 is equivalent to 10% excess
properly designed process fired heaters are air). Most new fired heaters are able to operate
usually similar irrespective of heater geometry / at lower excess air because of lower tramp air
type. In most fired heaters, tubes are placed (lower air leakage) due to better sealing of
along the walls, and the burners reside in the casing.
middle. As heat is transferred from the flue gas, As noted in the table, a heater operating with
it cools and flows downward close to tubes. This 10% excess air will have a few burners starving
results in a region of hot upward gas flow in the for air at 10% air mal-distribution. A lower
middle of the heater and cool downward flow combustion air supply would result in sub-
adjacent to the tubes. However, this recirculation stoichiometric operation for that burner. This
decreases as over-firing increases. An over-fired will increase CO emissions.
heater may have very little flue gas recirculation.
The extreme case is plug flow case with no flue (3) Fuel Gas Delivery System
gas downward flow.
The Ultra Low NOx Burner tip orifices are very
This over-firing characteristic can easily be small compared to conventional burners. Burner
correlated with heat density. It is recommended ignition ports in most of Ultra Low NOx burners
to limit area heat density to a maximum of are 1/16 inch. These small ports can and will get
250,000 Btu/hr.ft2. plugged if the fuel gas delivery system is not
Two heaters with different area heat density but design to reliably supply clean, dry fuel.
7
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner
The fuel delivery system for Ultra-Low NOx Table-3 : Common Air Plenum – Air Mal-distribution
burner applications must have a filter /coalescer Design % Mal- Maximum Minimum
located downstream of the knockout drum. Use Excess Air distribution Excess Air Excess Air
of stainless steel fuel piping downstream of the (%) (%) (%)
filter/coalescer is also recommended. Fuel 15 5 20.75 9.25
piping downstream of the filter/coalescer may 10 26.5 3.5
require insulation and heat tracing depending on 15 32.25 (-)2.25
local site conditions.
10 5 15.5 4.5
10 21.0 (-)1.0
(4) Operating Parameters: 15 26.5 (-)6.5
8
Know the Secret of Fired Heater Design and Operation with Ultra Low NOx Burner