Permutation and Combination
Permutation and Combination
Permutation and Combination
1. Introduction
A. Useful Relations
2. Fundamental Principle of Counting
3. Permutations
4. Permutation of r Objects Out of n Objects
5. Permutations under Some Conditions
6. Combinations
7. Problems Involving Both Permutations and Combinations
8. Problem Solving Strategy
9. Let's Sum Up
1. INTRODUCTION
The other day, I wanted to travel from Bangalore to Allahabad by train. There is no direct train
from Bangalore to Allahabad, but there are trains from Bangalore to Itarsi and from Itarsi to
Allahabad. From the railway timetable I found that there are two trains from Bangalore to Itarsi
and three trains from Itarsi to Allahabad. Now, in how many ways can I travel from Bangalore to
Allahabad?
There are counting problems which come under the branch of Mathematics
calledcombinatorics.
In another situation suppose you are painting your house. If a particular shade or colour is not
available, you may be able to create it by mixing different colours and shades. While creating
new colours this way, the order of mixing is not important. It is the combination or choice of
colours that determine the new colours; but not the order of mixing.
In this lesson we shall consider simple counting methods and use them in solving such simple
counting problems.
Top
A. USEFUL RELATIONS
(i). 0!=1!=1
(ii). nC0=
n!
0!*n!
=
1
0!
=1
(iii). n!=n*(n−1)!
(iv). nPr=
n!
(n−r)!
(v). (n+1).nPr=n+1Pr+1
(vi). nCr=
nPr
r!
(vii).nCr=nCn−r
(viii).n−1Cr−1+n−1Cr=nCr
Top
2. FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE OF COUNTING
Let us now solve the problem mentioned in the introduction. We will write t1,t2 to denote trains
from Bangalore to Itarsi and T1,T2,T3, for the trains from Itarsi to Allahabad. Suppose I take t1 to
travel from Bangalore to Itarsi. Then from Itarsi I can takeT 1 or T2 or T3. So the possibilities
are t1T1,t2T2 and t3T3 where t1T1 denotes travel from Bangalore to Itarsi by t1 and travel from
Itarsi to Allahabad by T1. Similarly, if I take t2 to travel from Bangalore to Itarsi, then the
possibilities aret2T1,t2T2 and t2T3. Thus, in all there are 6(2*3) possible ways of travelling from
Bangalore to Allahabad.
Here we had a small number of trains and thus could list all possibilities. Had there been 10
trains from Bangalore to Itarsi and 15 trains from Itarsi to Allahabad, the task would have been
very tedious. Here the Fundamental Principle of Countingor simply the Counting
Principle comes in use:
If any event can occur in m ways and after it happens in any one of these ways, a
second event can occur in n ways, then both the events together can occur
in m*n ways.
Top
Example 2.1:
How many multiples of 5 are there from 10 to 95?
Solution:
As you know, multiples of 5 are integers having 0 or 5 in the digit to the extreme right (i.e. the
unit’s place).
Example 2.2:
In a city, the bus route numbers consist of a natural number less than 100, followed by one of
the letters A,B,C,D,E and F. How many different bus routes are possible?
Solution:
The number can be any one of the natural numbers from 1 to 99.
There are 99 choices for the number.
The letter can be chosen in 6 ways.
Number of possible bus routes are 99*6= 594
Top
Example 2.3:
There are 3 questions in a question paper. If the questions have 4,3 and 2 solutions respectively,
find the total number of solutions.
Solution:
Here question 1 has 4 solutions, question 2 has 3 solutions and question 3 has 2 solutions.
Example 2.4:
Consider the word ROTOR. Whichever way you read it, from left to right or from right to left, you
get the same word. Such a word is known as palindrome. Find the maximum possible number
of 5-letter palindromes.
Solution:
The first letter from the right can be chosen in 26 ways because there are 26 alphabets.
Having chosen the first two letters, the third letter can be chosen in 26 ways.
=> All the three letters can be chosen in 676*26=17576 ways.
It implies that the maximum possible number of five letter palindromes is 17576because the
fourth letter is the same as the second letter and the fifth letter is the same as the first letter.
Note: In Example 2.4 we found the maximum possible number of five letter palindromes. There
cannot be more than 17576. But this does not mean that there are 17576 palindromes. Because
some of the choices like CCCCC may not be meaningful words in the English language.
Top
Example 2.5:
How many 3-digit numbers can be formed with the digits 1,4,7,8 and 9 if the digits are not
repeated?
Solution:
Three digit numbers will have unit’s, ten’s and hundred’s place.
Out of 5 given digits any one can take the unit’s place.
This can be done in 5 ways ------- (i)
After filling the unit’s place, any of the four remaining digits can take the ten’s place.
This can be done in 4 ways ------- (ii)
After filling in ten’s place, hundred’s place can be filled from any of the three remaining digits.
This can be done in 3 ways ------- (iii)
If there are n events and if the first event can occur in m1 ways, the second event can
occur in m2 ways after the first event has occurred, the third event can occur
in m3 ways after the second event has occurred, and so on, then all the n events can
occur in m1*m2*...*mn−1*mn ways.
Top
Example 2.6:
Suppose you can travel from a place A to a place B by 3 buses, from place B to place C by 4
buses, from place C to place D by 2 buses and from place D to place E by 3 buses. In how many
ways can you travel from A to E?
Solution:
Suppose you want to arrange your books on a shelf. If you have only one book, there is only one
way of arranging it. Suppose you have two books, one of History and one of Geography.
You can arrange the Geography and History books in two ways. Geography book first and the
History book next, GH or History book first and Geography book next; HG. In other words, there
are two arrangements of the two books.
Now, suppose you want to add a Mathematics book also to the shelf. After arranging History and
Geography books in one of the two ways, say GH, you can put Mathematics book in one of the
following ways: MGH, GMH or GHM. Similarly, corresponding to HG, you have three other ways
of arranging the books. So, by the Counting Principle, you can arrange Mathematics, Geography
and History books in3*2=6 ways.
In general, if you want to find the number of permutations of n objects n≥1, how can you do it?
Let us see if we can find an answer to this.
Theorem 3.1
The total number of permutations of n objects is n(n–1)....2.1
Proof:
Using the counting principle, the total number of arrangements of n different objects is
n(n−1)(n−2)...2.1 ----------(3.1)
The product n(n–1)...2.1 occurs so often in Mathematics that it deserves a name and notation. It
is usually denoted by n! (read as n factorial).
n!=n(n–1)...3.2.1
Top
Example 3.1
Suppose you want to arrange your English, Hindi, Mathematics, History, Geography and Science
books on a shelf. In how many ways can you do it?
Solution:
Suppose you have five story books and you want to distribute one each to Asha, Akhtar and
Jasvinder. In how many ways can you do it? You can give any one of the five books to Asha and
after that you can give any one of the remaining four books to Akhtar. After that, you can give
one of the remaining three books to Jasvinder. So, by the Counting Principle, you can distribute
the books in 5*4*3 i.e. 60 ways.
More generally, suppose you have to arranger objects out of n objects. In how many ways can
you do it? Let us view this in the following way. Suppose you haven objects and you have to
arrange r of these in r boxes, one object in each box.
Suppose there is one box. r=1. You can put any of the n objects in it and this can be done in n
ways. Suppose there are two boxes. r=2. You can put any of the objects in the first box and
after that the second box can be filled with any of the remaining n–1 objects. So, by the
counting principle, the two boxes can be filled inn(n–1) ways.
Theorem 4.1
The number of permutations of r objects out of n objects is
n(n–1)..(n–r+1)
Proof:
Suppose we have to arranger objects out of n different objects. In fact it is equivalent to filling r
places, each with one of the objects out of the given n objects.
The first place can be filled in n different ways. Once this has been done, the second place can be
filled by any one of the remaining (n–1) objects, in (n–1) ways.
Similarly, the third place can be filled in (n–2) ways and so on. The last place, the rthplace can be
filled in [n–(r–1)] i.e. (n–r+1) different ways. You may easily see, as to why this is so.
Using the Counting Principle, we get the required number of arrangements of r out ofn objects
is n(n−1)(n−2)...(n−r+1)
Top
Example 4.1
If you have 6 New Year greeting cards and you want to send them to 4 of your friends, in how
many ways can this be done?
Solution:
n!
(n−r)!
Top
5. PERMUTATIONS UNDER SOME CONDITIONS
n(nr−1)
n−1
The number of permutations of n different things taken not more than r at a time :
nP1+nP2+nP3+...+nPr
We will now see examples involving permutations with some extra conditions.
Top
Example 5.1
Suppose 7 students are staying in a hall in a hostel and they are allotted 7 beds. Among them,
Parvin does not want a bed next to Anju because Anju snores. Then, in how many ways can you
allot the beds?
Solution:
Therefore, in each of these cases, the beds can be allotted 4*5!=480 ways.
=> The beds can be allotted in:
2*600+5*480=1200+2400= 3600 ways
Top
Example 5.2
In how many ways can an animal trainer arrange 5 lions and 4 tigers in a row so that no two
lions are together?
Solution:
| L | T | L | T | L | T | L | T | L |
Example 5.3
There are 4 books on fairy tales, 5 novels and 3 plays. In how many ways can you arrange these
so that books on fairy tales are together, novels are together and plays are together and in the
order, books on fairy tales, novels and plays.
Solution:
There are 4 books on fairy tales and they have to be put together.
They can be arranged in 4! ways.
So, by the counting principle all of them together can be arranged in 4!*5!*3!=17280 ways
Top
Example 5.4
Suppose there are 4 books on fairy tales, 5 novels and 3 plays as in Example 5.3. They have to
be arranged so that the books on fairy tales are together, novels are together and plays are
together, but we no longer require that they should be in a specific order. In how many ways can
this be done?
Solution:
First, we consider the books on fairy tales, novels and plays as single objects.
These three objects can be arranged in 3!=6 ways.
Let us fix one of these 6 arrangements.
This may give us a specific order, say, novels -> fairy tales -> plays.
Given this order, the books on the same subject can be arranged as follows.
The 4 books on fairy tales can be arranged among themselves in 4!=24 ways.
The 5 novels can be arranged in 5!=120 ways.
The 3 plays can be arranged in 3!=6 ways.
Example 5.5
In how many ways can 4 girls and 5 boys be arranged in a row so that all the four girls are
together?
Solution:
Let 4 girls be one unit and now there are 6 units in all.
They can be arranged in 6! ways.
Solution:
There are 7 letters in the word ‘Bengali; of these 3 are vowels and 4 consonants.
(i) Considering vowels a, e, i as one letter, we can arrange 4+1 letters in 5! ways in each of
which vowels are together. These 3 vowels can be arranged among themselves in 3! ways.
=> Total number of words =5!*3!
=120*6=720
So there are total of 720 ways in which vowels are ALWAYS TOGEGHER.
Now,
Since there are no repeated letters, the total number of ways in which the letters of the word
‘BENGALI’ cab be arranged:
=7!=5040
So,
Total no. of arrangements in which vowels are never together:
=ALL the arrangements possible – arrangements in which vowels are ALWAYS TOGETHER
=5040–720=4320
(ii) There are 4 odd places and 3 even places. 3 vowels can occupy 4 odd places in4P3 ways and
4 constants can be arranged in 4P4 ways.
=> Number of words =4P3*4P4= 576
Top
6. COMBINATIONS
Let us consider the example of shirts and trousers as stated in the introduction. There you have
4 sets of shirts and trousers and you want to take 2 sets with you while going on a trip. In how
many ways can you do it?
Let us denote the sets by S1,S2,S3,S4. Then you can choose two pairs in the following ways:
[Observe that {S1,S2} is the same as {S2,S1}. So, there are 6 ways of choosing the two sets that
you want to take with you. Of course, if you had 10 pairs and you wanted to take 7 pairs, it will
be much more difficult to work out the number of pairs in this way.
Now as you may want to know the number of ways of wearing 2 out of 4 sets for two days, say
Monday and Tuesday, and the order of wearing is also important to you. We know that it can be
done in 4P4=12 ways. But note that each choice of 2 sets gives us two ways of wearing 2 sets
out of 4 sets as shown below:
Theorem 6.1
Let n≥1 be an integer and r≤n. Let us denote the number of ways of choosing r objects out of n
objects by nCr. Then
nCr=
nPr
r!
Top
Example 6.1
Find the number of subsets of the set {1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11} having 4 elements.
Solution:
Here the order of choosing the elements doesn’t matter and this is a problem in combinations.
We have to find the number of ways of choosing 4 elements of this set which has 11 elements.
11*10*9*8
1*2*3*4
= 330 ways
Top
Example 6.2
12 points lie on a circle. How many cyclic quadrilaterals can be drawn by using these points?
Solution:
For any set of 4 points we get a cyclic quadrilateral. Number of ways of choosing 4 points out of
12 points is 12C4=495
Example 6.3
In a box, there are 5 black pens, 3 white pens and 4 red pens. In how many ways can 2 black
pens, 2 white pens and 2 red pens can be chosen?
Solution:
5P2
2!
=
5*4
1*2
=10
3P2
2!
=
3*2
1*2
=3
4P2
2!
=4*
3
1*2
=6
=> By the Counting Principle, 2 black pens, 2 white pens, and 2 red pens can be chosen in
10*3*6= 180ways.
Top
Example 6.4
A question paper consists of 10 questions divided into two parts A and B. Each part contains five
questions. A candidate is required to attempt six questions in all of which at least 2 should be
from part A and at least 2 from part B. In how many ways can the candidate select the questions
if he can answer all questions equally well?
Solution:
The candidate has to select six questions in all of which at least two should be from Part A and
two should be from Part B. He can select questions in any of the following ways:
Part A Part B
(i) 2 4
(ii) 3 3
(iii) 4 2
If the candidate follows choice (i), the number of ways in which he can do so is:
5C2*5C4=10*5=50
If the candidate follows choice (ii), the number of ways in which he can do so is:
5C3*5C3=10*10=100
Similarly, if the candidate follows choice (iii), then the number of ways in which he can do so is:
5C4*5C2=5*10=50
Therefore, the candidate can select the question in 50+100+50= 200 ways.
Top
Example 6.5
A committee of 5 persons is to be formed from 6 men and 4 women. In how many ways can this
be done when:
Solution:
Example 6.6
The Indian Cricket team consists of 16 players. It includes 2 wicket keepers and 5 bowlers. In
how many ways can a cricket eleven be selected if we have to select 1 wicket keeper and at least
4 bowlers?
Solution:
So far, we have studied problems that involve either permutation alone or combination alone. In
this section, we will consider some examples that need both of these concepts.
Example 7.1
There are 5 novels and 4 biographies. In how many ways can 4 novels and 2 biographies can be
arranged on a shelf?
Solution:
After selecting any 6 books (4 novels and 2 biographies) in one of the 30 ways, they can be
arranged on the shelf in 6!=720 ways.
By the Counting Principle, the total number of arrangements =30*720= 21600
Top
Example 7.2
From 5 consonants and 4 vowels, how many words can be formed using 3 consonants and 2
vowels?
Solution:
In permutation and combination problems, it is very important to recognize the type of problem.
Many students mistakenly approach a combination problem as a permutation, and vice versa.
The steps below will help you determine the problem type.
We have three questions to ask ourselves in order to identify the problem type:
1. Is it a permutation or combination?
Check any two typical arrangements with the same combination. If the two arrangements are
counted only once, it is a combination problem. Otherwise, it is a permutation.
For example, if you are asked for a lock code, then 321 and 123 could be two possibilities, and
the two numbers are formed from the same combination (Same number of 1’s, 2’s, and 3’s). So,
lock codes must be permutations.
For another example, suppose you have 5 balls numbering 1 through 5. If you are asked to
select 3 out of the 5 balls and you are only interested in the numbers on the balls, not the order
in which they are taken, then you have a combination problem.
Problems that by definition connote ordering (though not directly stated) are permutations.
For example, 3 digits form a 3-digit number. Here, the 3-digit number connotes ordering.
For another example, if you are to answer 3 questions, you probably would not be asked to
answer a particular question more than once. So, you would not allow repetition in the
calculations. Though not often needed, such logical assumptions are allowed and sometimes
expected.
If the problem itself defines slots for the arrangements, it is a permutation problem. Words like
arrange" define slots for the arrangements.
For example:
In how many ways can the letters of the word XYZ be transformed to form new words?
In how many ways can the letters of the word XYZ be altered to form new words?
For example:
If you are to list countries in a coalition, you can hardly list a country twice.
(Here, repetition automatically is not allowed unless specified otherwise.)
If you have 3 doors to a room, you could use the same door for both entering and exiting.
(Here, repetition is automatically allowed.)
Top
For example, if the original question is to find the words formed from the word GARGUNTUNG,
then, in this step, you collect the information: G exists thrice; U exists twice, and so on.
Once the problem type is recognized, use the corresponding formula or model to solve it.
Top
9. LET’S SUM UP
If there are n events and if the first event can occur in m1 ways, the second event can occur
in m2 ways after the first event has occurred, the third event can occur in m3 ways after the
second event has occurred and so on, then all the n events can occur in:
m1*m2*m3*...*mn−1*mn ways.
The number of permutations of n objects taken all at a time is n!
nPr=
n!
(n−r)!
nPn=n!
n!
r!(n−r)!
nCr=nCn−r
nCr+nCr−1=n+1Cr