Women and Law
Women and Law
Women and Law
PROJECT TITLE
SUBJECT
SOCIOLOGY
N.S.RUPESH
2017057
SEMESTER 1
Page |2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1) Acknowledgement
2) Abstract
3) Chapter – 1 Women Rights
4) Chapter – 2 Violations of Women Rights
5) Chapter – 3 Policies for rural Women Empowerment
6) Chapter – 4 Legal measures to Combat Sexual Assault
7) Chapter – 5 Acts enacted for discrimination against women
8) Conclusion
9) Bibliography
Page |3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT :
N.S.Rupesh.
Page |4
ABSTRACT
SELECTION OF TOPIC :
This topic was selected by researcher because today, women are immorally
trafficked, female infanticide, illiteracy among girls, violence against women are being
done.
RESEARCH PROBLEM :
Aim of the topic is that are laws related women in India sufficient to eradicate
women related issues ?
REVIEW OF LITERATURE :
In this research, researcher will refer the books, journals, articles, research studies.
RESEARCH DESIGN :
Doctrinal research design.
IDENTIFICATION OF VARIABLE :
Dependent variable :
1)The efficacy of law related to women in India
Example :- Sati abolition act, widow remarriage act, child marriage prevention act,
dowry prohibition act, prevention of sexual offense at work place.
Independent variable :
Women and Law.
HYPOTHESIS :
Women and Law.
This topic was selected by researcher because today, women are immorally
trafficked, female infanticide, illiteracy among girls, violence against women are being
done.
Page |5
Aim of the topic is that are laws related women in India sufficient to eradicate
women related issues ?
In this research, researcher will refer the books, journals, articles, research studies.
Dependent variable :
1)The efficacy of law related to women in India
Example :- Sati abolition act, widow remarriage act, child marriage prevention act,
dowry prohibition act, prevention of sexual offense at work place.
Independent variable :
Women and Law.
Example :- Maternity benefit act, beti bacho beti padhao, the equal remuneration act.
Laws related to women in India are not sufficient to eradicate the problems and the
inequalities related to women.
COLLECTION OF DATA :
The researcher will collect the data from books, journals, and from the
authenticsources of government organization.
CLASSIFICATION OF DATA :
The data will be classified in various heads.
INTERPRETATION OF DATA :
The researcher will interpret the data in sociological terms.
Chapter – 1
Women Rights
Women rights are the rights and entitlements claimed for women and girls
worldwide, and formed the basis for women’s rights movement in the nineteenth century.
These rights are made institutionalizedor supported by law, local custom and behaviour,
in some countries, but whereas they are ignored and suppressed in other countries.They
differ from broader notions of human rights through claims of an inherent historical and
traditional bias against the exercise of rights by women and girls, in favour of men and
boys.
Issues commonly associated with notions of women's rights include, though are
not limited to, the right: to bodily integrity and autonomy; to be free from sexual
violence; to vote; to hold public office; to enter into legal contracts; to have equal rights
in family law; to work; to fair wages or equal pay; to have reproductive rights; to own
property; to education.1
1
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women%27s_rights#cite_note-Hosken-1 Last visited 16-10-17.
Page |7
CHAPTER – 2
Throughout the world, there are practices in the family that are violent towards worn and
harmful to their health. Young girls are circumcised, live under severe dress codes, given
in prostitution, denied property rights and killed for the sake of honour in the family.
These practices and many others constitute a form of domestic violence but have avoided
national and international scrutiny because they are seen as cultural practices that deserve
tolerance and respect. The universal standards of human rights are often denied full
operation when it comes to the rights of women. Cultural relativism is therefore often an
excuse to allow for inhuman and discrimination practices against problems posed by
cultural relativism, and the implications for women’s rights, will be one of the most
important issues in the field of international human rights.2
Article 5 states, ‘State Parties shall take all appropriate measures to modify the social and
cultural patterns of conduct of men and women, with a view to achieving the elimination
of prejudices and customary and all other practices which are based on the idea of the
inferiority or the superiority of the either of sexes or on stereotyped roles for men and
women’.
Article 2 of the convention states, ‘state parties condemn discrimination against women in
all its forms agree to pursue by all appropriate means and without delay a policy of
eliminating discrimination against women3.’
Article 4 states, ‘ States should condemn violence against women and should not invoke
any custom, tradition or religious consideration to avoid obligations with respect to its
elimination.’
2
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 1
3
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 2
Page |8
principles are often in conflict with many religions and customary laws that regulate
marriage and family life throughout the world. Many of these laws and practises go
against cherished international principles.
There are many cultural practices throughout the world that are violent towards women.
In the section some of more disturbing violating are described, in order to highlight the
nature of the problems.
The main reasons given for the continuation of this practice are custom and tradition.
The main reasons given for the continuation of practice are custom and tradition. In
societies where FGM is practised, a girl is not considered an adult or a complete woman
until she goes through the “operation”. Some societies believe that all persons are
hermaphroditic and the removal of the clitoris makes the female a “pure woman”. It is
said also to test a woman’s ability to bear pain and defines her future roles in life and
marriage while preparing her for the pain of childbirth. FGM is also a result of the -
*patriarchal power structures which legitimise the need to control women’s lives. It arises
from the stereotypical perception of women as the principal guardians of sexual morality,
but with uncontrolled sexual urges.
FGM reduces a woman’s desire for sex, reduces the chances of sex outside marriage and
thus promotes virginity. It is also deemed necessary by society to enhance her husband’s
sexual' pleasure. A husband may reject a woman who has not gone through the
”operation”. Health reasons are also put forward as justifications for FGM. Unmutilated
women are considered unclean. It is believed that FGM enhances fertility. It is considered
that the clitoris is poisonous and that it could prick the man or kill a baby at childbirth. In
some FGM-practising societies, there is a belief that the clitoris could grow and become
like a man’s penis. Even though FGM pre-dates Islam, religious reasons are given for the
continuation of FGM in some societies4.
HONOUR KILLING :
4
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 5
P a g e | 10
manhood. Ironically, it is not unheard of for female relatives to either carry out the
murder or be accomplice to it. As honour killings often remain a private family affair,
there are no official statistics on practice or frequency and the real number of such
killings is vastly greater than those reported. The Washington Post Foreign Service
reports that 278 murders were reported in Punjab in 1999, The Special Task Force for
Sindh of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan received reports of 196 cases of
honour killings in 1998 and more than 300 in 1999. Every year more than 1,000 women
are killed in the name of honour in Pakistan alone. During the summer of 1997, Khaled
Al-Qudra, then Attorney-General in the Palestinian. National Authority stated that he
suspected that 70 per cent of all murders in Gaza and the West Bank were honour
killings. They are usually attributed to natural causes. In Lebanon, 36 honour crimes were
reported between 1996 and 1998, in Jordan 20 honour killings in 1998 and in Egypt 52
similar crimes in 1997. In Iraq more than 4000 women have been killed since 1991. The
same report stated that between 1996 and 1998 in Bangladesh, about 200 women were
attacked with acid by husbands or close relatives, but the number of deaths is unknown.
In the West there are honour killings among immigrant communities5.
WITCH HUNTING :
Another cultural practice that is found mainly in Asian and African communities is
witch hunting or witch burning. This practice is common in societies where there is a
belief in superstition and the evil spirit. Sixteenth and seventeenth century England
abounded with witches. Epileptic fits, illness and death were thought to be connected with
witchcraft. Women branded as “witches" were tortured to confess. They were beaten and
put on the racks and even burnt alive. The practice was brutal and directed against
women.
The South African regions of Northern Transvaal and especially Venda report incidents
of witch burning even today. The women branded as Witches are stoned or beaten to
death before being burnt. There is a belief that the body of the “witch” along with her
magic paraphernalia must be completely destroyed to get rid of the effect of the ”witch”.
While both men and women are accused of being witches, statistics show that women are
twice as more likely to be so accused. Although the Witchcraft Suppression Act helps
5
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P.6
P a g e | 11
people who are accused of being witches, many people who take violent action against
”witches” are not prosecuted under the Act6.
BEAUTY :
In many societies, the desire for beauty has often affected women in diverse ways. In the
western world in the twenty first century the beauty myth than a thin female physique is
only accepted shape is imposed on women by the media via magazines, advertising and
television. This message is sent to young impressionable girls who strive to attain this
perfect image without realising that this image is often unrealistic. Advertisements
continue to portray women in their traditional roles or as bodies to sell a product. This
culture of impractical ideals result in many practices that cause a great deal of abuse to
the female bodies. Cosmetic surgery of every part of the female body has led to many
health problems and complications for many women. In addition, eating disorder due to
unhealthy food habits has also raised a great deal of concern in the western world. Girls
and women are disproportionately affected by eating disorders and cultural demands for
thinness in the western world. It is established that only 5 to 10 per cent of people with
eating disorder are male.
INCENT :
In many parts of the world, incest is culturally tolerated. Many countries do not list
incest crime in their panel code. The form incest takes varies from forced mastrubasion,
to sexualised beating, touching of genitals, fellatio, cunnilingus and rape. Fathers,
brothers, stepfathers, uncles, cousins, and even grandfathers mostly engage in these
practices. Women commit incest more rarely, but the number may be larger than realised.
There are cases of parents and guardians inviting neighbours to commit incest or
instances where the guardian knows of these crimes but turns a blind eye.
Incest is practised by certain cults, like the Hindu Sakti sect in India, in the belief
that it is a higher grade of sexual intercourse and an advanced step towards religion. In an
endogamous Indian group called Baiga, incestuous marriage ispractised. The victims are
6
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 27
P a g e | 12
mainly females. Many of the survivors of incestuous practices suffer from varies
psychological and physical disorders. One of the main problems is the enormous
emotional difficulty in reporting these crimes, especially in the face of disbelief and lack
of punishment for the perpetrator7.
In the past, the protection of women’s reproductive rights has not been a high
priority among national or international bodies. Historically, the main duty of women was
to bear men’s children, preferably sons. The health issues connected with this process
went unnoticed. The consequences of early, frequent and excessive childbearing were
explained by fate, destiny and divine will rather than as the results of oppressive cultural
and social practices and governmental neglect of reproductive health services. There are
various cultural practices unique to different parts if the world which are harmful for
women and their reproductive rights is violence against women. Lack of control over
their sexual and reproductive health care result in the violation of women’s human rights.
A women’s ability to bear children is linked to the continuity of families, clans and social
groups. This has been the object of regulation by families, religious institutions and
governmental authorities. The ability to bear children may be advantageous because it
gives a women emotional satisfaction, but it can also be an oppression, a barrier or even
an obstacle. Therefore, her control over her fertility is critical. In some societies women
have virtually no say in the matter of postponing childbearing or having a child
immediately after marriage. There is a great deal of pressure to produce a child within a
reasonable time, but to become pregnant too soon is also scorned by the elders. While
women are used as child producers, their reproductive cycle is not given much attention.
In many countries there are no trained birth attendants. The traditional birth attendants are
untrained and the base their practices on various cultural beliefs, like evil spirits and
supernatural powers. Various practices during child delivery cause harm to the mothers.
Pressing the abdomen to force the baby out, pulling the baby out by force, giving a very
hot bath to the delivering mother or even inserting certain herbs into the women’s vagina
7
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 28
P a g e | 13
to accelerate the birth and isolating mothers who have just given birth are some of these
practices. In the Southern Highland province of Papua New Guinea, women are expected
to give birth unattended. It is believed that a women’s blood is a source of contamination,
leading to illness and death8.
8
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 25
P a g e | 14
CHAPTER – 3
Rural women have a unique ability to reduce poverty and malnutrition in the
developing world. But gender inequality is undermining their potential to become agents
of change. The fight against rural poverty depends on increased efforts to redress gender
imbalances and empower rural women. Around the world, women are more vulnerable to
chronic poverty than men. Because of cultural norms, lack of control over resources,
“genderneutral" international trade policies, and many other factors, women worldwide
struggle with life's basic needs -particularly how to feed their families and themselves.
Within the framework of a democratic polity, our laws, development policies, Plans and
programmes have aimed at women’s advancement in different spheres. From the Fifth
Five Year Plan (1974-78) onwards has been a marked shift in the approach to women’s
issues from welfare to development. In recent years, the empowerment of women has
been recognized as the central issue in determining the status of women. The National
Commission for Women was set up by an Act of Parliament in 1990 to safeguard the
rights and legal entitlements of women. The 73rd and 74th Amendments (1993) to the
Constitution of India have provided for reservation of seats in the local bodies of
9
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 155
P a g e | 15
Panchayats and Municipalities for women, laying a strong foundation for their
participation in decision making at the local levels. India has also ratified various
international conventions and human rights instruments committing to secure equal rights
of women. Key among them is the ratification of the Convention on Elimination of All
Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) in 199310.
POLICY PRESCRIPTION :
Poverty Eradication :
Since women comprise the majority of the population below the poverty line and
are very often in situations of extreme poverty, given the harsh realities of intra-
household and social discrimination, macro-economic policies and poverty eradication
programmes will specifically address the needs and problems of such women. There will
be improved implementation of programmes which are already women and convergence
of services, by offering them a range of economic and social options, along with
necessary support measures to enhance their capabilities.
10
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P.157
P a g e | 16
Micro Credit :
In order to enhance women’s access to credit for consumption and production, the
establishment of new, and strengthening of existing micro-credit mechanisms and micro-
finance institution will be undertaken so that the outreach of credit is enhanced. Other
supportive measures would be taken to ensure adequate flow of credit through extant
financial institutions and banks, so that all women below poverty line have easy access to
credit.
Globalization :
Globalization has presented new challenges for the realization of the goal of
women’s equality, the gender impact of which has not been systematically evaluated
fully. However, from the micro-level studies that were commissioned by the department
of women and child development, it is evident that there is need for reframing policies for
access to employment and quality of employment. Benefits of the growing global
economy have been unevenly distributed leading to wider economy have been unevenly
distributed leading to wider economic disparities, the feminization of poverty, increased
gender inequity through often deteriorating working conditions and unsafe working
P a g e | 17
environment especially in the informal economy and rural areas. Strategies will be
designed to enhance the capacity of women and empower them to meet the negative
social and economic impacts, which may flow from the globalization process.
11
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 162
P a g e | 18
CHAPTER – 4
For most of the women, the community provides the contours for the enjoyment of
social space. It determines the nature of their social interactions and the type of values
that will condition their lives. Community is a social space outside the family but not
fully under the control of the state. It is the site for flourishing private organizations and
intermediary associations which have an impact on the lives of women as part of their
daily interactions. From neighbourhood association, to private corporations, religious
grouping, trade unions and professional associations, the community provides the basis
for what is now called civil society. Though ephemeral in concept, the community is also
the site of a women’s social identity whether that identity is defined in secular, ethenic or
religious terms.
In many instances, women and girl children are subjected to violence by their
community because of their sexuality and sexual behaviour. A key component of
community identity, and therefore the demarcation of community boundaries, is the
preservations of communal honour. Such honour is frequently perceived, by both
community and non-community members, as residing in the sexual behaviour of the
women of the community. Communities, therefore, “police” the behaviour of their female
members. A women who is perceived to be acting in a manner deemed to be sexually
inappropriate by communal standards is liable to be punished. Such punishments range
from eviction from the community to corporal punishment, such as flogging and stoning,
and death. In many cases, the restrictions on women’s sexuality, as defined by the
community, are sanctioned by the state through the promulgation of laws and policies
reflecting the communal values.
Inmostcommunities,theoptionavailabletowomenforsexualactivityisconfinedtomarri
age withamanfromthesamecommunity.Womenwhochooseoptionswhicharedisapprovedof
bythecommunity,whethertohaveasexualrelationshipwithamaninanon-marital
relationship,tohaveSucharelationshipoutsideofethnic,religiousorclasscommunities,orto
liveouttheirsexualityinwaysotherthanheterosexuality,areoftensubjectedtoviolenceand
P a g e | 19
degradingtreatment.Single,widowedordivorcedwomenlivingaloneareoftentargetedby
violenceandrapeinthecommunity.Women,”unprotected”byamarriageunionwithaman,
arevulnerablemembersofthecommunity,oftenmarginalisedincommunitysocialpractices
andthevictimsofsocialostracismandabuse.
12
Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal publications, New Delhi. P. 37
P a g e | 20
The Indian Forum against the Oppression of Women has Enumerated in distinct forms of
rape:
CHAPTER – 5
ACTS ENACTED FOR DISCRIMINATION AGAINST WOMEN
The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006
The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act was made effective in 2007. This act defines child
marriage as a marriage where the groom or the bride are underage, that is, the bride is
under 18 years of age or the boy is younger than 21 years. Parents trying to marry
underage girls are subject to action under this law. Since the law makes these marriages
illegal, it acts as a major deterrent.
Special Marriage Act, 1954
It is not applicable to the state of Jammu and Kashmir and also extends to intending
spouses who are Indian nationals and living abroad.
According to this act, taking or giving of dowry at the time of the marriage to the
bride or the bridegroom and their family is to be penalized. Dowry system, giving and
taking of dowry, is a norm in India. Dowry is often asked of the bride and her family by
the groom and his family. The system has taken strong roots because women after
P a g e | 22
marriage move in with their spouse and in-laws. Also, over the centuries, the lack for
economic independence of women and the taboo towards divorce has resulted in bride
burning. When demands for dowry evenafter marriage are not met by the girl’s families,
many women are tortured, beaten and even burnt. It is one of the major challenges that
our society is grappling with. Women openly complaining about it has helped to spread
the word and encourage other women to take a stand.
The Indian Divorce Act allows the dissolution of marriage, mutual consent, nullity of
marriage, judicial separation and restitution of conjugal rights.Family Courts are established
to file, hear, and dispose of such cases.
This act regulates the employment of women and maternity benefits mandated by
law. It states that a woman employee who has worked in an organization for a period of at
least 80 days during the 12 months preceding the date of her expected delivery is entitled
to receive maternity benefits, which includes maternity leave, nursing breaks, medical
allowance, etc.
The Act came into effect into 1972, was amended in 1975 and 2002. The aim of
the Act is to reduce the occurrence of illegal abortion and consequent maternal mortality
and morbidity. It clearly states the conditions under which a pregnancy can be ended or
aborted and specifies the persons qualified to conduct the same.
P a g e | 23
To ensure women’s safety at workplace, this Act seeks to protect them from
sexual harassment at their place of work. Thirty-six percent of Indian companies and 25
percent among MNC’s are not complaint with the Sexual Harassment Act according to a
FICCI-EY November 2015 report.
Sexual harassment at workplace also includes – the use of language with sexual
overtones, invasion of private space with a male colleague hovering too close for comfort,
subtle touches and innuendoes.
The NCW represents the rights of women in India and provides a voice for their issues
and concerns. The National Commission for Women Act aims to improve the status of
women and worked for their economic empowerment.
laws in place to protect the interests of women. Only if you are aware of your rights can
you fight against any injustice meted out to you at home, at the workplace, or in the
society13.
13
https://yourstory.com/2016/06/laws-that-protect-women-rights Last visited 16-10-17.
P a g e | 25
RELEVENT CASES
Honour Killing :
Manoj – Babli
Honour killing case was the honour killing of Indian newlyweds Manoj Banwala
and Babli in june 2007 and the successive court case. Which historically convicted
defendants for an honour killing. The individuals involved in murder included relatives of
Babli. Relatives of Manoj, especially his mother, defended the relationship.
Mr. Bose has very strenuously contended that in view of Section 29(4) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, Section15 of that Act has no application to the
impugned marriage. Sub-section (4) of Section 29 runs as follows:
"Nothing contained in this Act shall be deemed to affect the provisions contained in
the Special Marriage Act, 1954 (43 of 1954) with respect to marriages between Hindus
solemnized under that Act, whether before or after the commencement of this Act."
This criminal appeal arises out of common judgment and order passed by the Karnataka
High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 1755 of 2003 and Criminal Appeal No. 665 of 2004,
whereby and whereunder the court has partly allowed the appeal, and in so far as the
appellant is concerned, while maintaining the conviction for offences punishable
under Section 4 of Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 and Sections 498-A and 304-B of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860, has modified the sentence for the offence punishable
under Section 3 of the DowryProhibition Act, 1961 from 5 years and a fine of Rs.
2,50,000/- to 2 years and a fine of Rs. 1,25,000/- and, in default, to undergo simple
imprisonment for 6 months.
Maternity Benefit Act :
Municipality Corporation Of Delhi v. Female Workers on 8 march 2000
The Corporation in their written statement, filed before the Industrial Tribunal, pleaded
that the provisions under the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 or Central Civil Services
(Leave) Rules were not applicable to the female workers, engaged on muster roll, as they
were all engaged only on daily wages. It was also contended that they were not entitled to
any benefitunder the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948. It was for these reasons that
the Corporation contended that the demand of the female workers (muster roll) for grant
of maternity leave was liable to be rejected.
National Commision For Women Act :
Richhpal Singh And Ors. vs State Of Rajasthan on 4 January, 2005
Thousands of teachers by way of instant bunch of Writ petitions, as mentioned in
Schedule appended to each petition, have challenged the Constitutional validity of the
Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Ordinance, 2004 and Rajasthan Panchayati Raj
(Amendment) Rules, 2004 providing for selection of Teachers Gr.III by the Public
Service Commission and have prayed for restoring the autonomy to the Panchayati Raj
Institutions in the matter of selection & appointment of primary school teachers.
Petitioner-teachers have also prayed for restoration of the Notification dated 14.7.2003
providing to fill-up the posts of Teacher Gr.III to the extent of 75% from Para
Teachers/Shiksha Sahyogi and 25% from the open market. It is further prayed that their
services be regularized as Teacher Gr.III, who have been in continuous service for a
considerable time as Para Teacher or Shiksha Sahyogi.
P a g e | 27
CONCLUSION
Women rights are the rights and entitlements claimed for women and girls
worldwide, and formed the basis for women’s rights movement in the nineteenth
century.Throughout the world, there are practices in the family that are violent towards
worn and harmful to their health. Young girls are circumcised, live under severe dress
codes, given in prostitution, denied property rights and killed for the sake of honour in the
family. There are many traditional practices like Female genital mutilation, Honour
Killing, Witch Hunting, Beauty, Violation of Reproductive Right Incent, which leads to
discrimination of women and their rights. There are also many policies made for the
women living in the rural places. Rapes are now becoming a big problem in all over the
world. There are many laws enacted for the welfare of women. According to me the laws
enacted by the Indian government are not sufficient to eradicate violence against women
happening in the present India.
\
P a g e | 28
BIBILOGRAPHY
Books :
1. Women and The Law, Laxmidhar Chouhan, 1st edition, 2007. Mittal
publications, New Delhi.
e-sources :
1. https://en.wikipedia.org
2. http://www.indiankanoon.com