WKS 17 Energy Safety COP For Power Systems Earthing
WKS 17 Energy Safety COP For Power Systems Earthing
WKS 17 Energy Safety COP For Power Systems Earthing
COVER PAGE
NZECP:35 1993
for
FOR
On the 1st day of February 1993, the Secretary of Commerce issued the Electrical Code of
Practice for Power Systems Earthing ("the Code")
On the 4th day of February 1993, pursuant to Section 38 of the Act the Secretary published
in the Gazette a notice of intention to apply to me for approval of the code, and there has
been consultations with such persons (or their representatives) as will be affected by the
Code and they have had the opportunity to consider possible effects and comment on those
effects.
I have considered the comments concerning those effects and where necessary amendments
were made to the Code.
Therefore Pursuant to Section 38 of the Act, I, John Luxton, Minister of Energy, have this
day approved the Code as attached to this approval, which Code shall come into force on the
1st day of April 1993.
John Luxton
Minister of Energy.
COMMITTEE REPRESENTATION
This Code of Practice for Power Systems Earthing was prepared by the Ministry of
Commerce, Chief Electrical Inspector’s Office.
Represented on the working party which was responsible for the preparation of this
Code of Practice were the following:
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The source material for this Code was derived from the following documentation,
ESA (Australia) Section 12 of the Guidelines for Design and Maintenance of
Overhead Distribution and Transmission Lines C(b)1 1991, IEEE Guide for Safety in
AC Substation Grounding (ANSI/IEEE 80) 1986, Earthing Handbook issued by the
Electricity Authority of NSW 1975.
REVIEW
This Code of Practice will be revised as occasions arise. Suggestions for improvement
of this Code are welcome. They should be sent to the Chief Electrical Inspector’s
Office, Ministry of Commerce, P O Box 1473, WELLINGTON.
CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... 1
SECTION 1
SECTION 2
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
2.2 PERFORMANCE OF EARTHING SYSTEMS ................................. 7
2.3 DESIGN, SELECTION AND INSTALLATION ............................... 7
2.4 EARTH ELECTRODES .................................................................... 7
2.5 TESTING AND INSPECTION.......................................................... 8
2.6 PERMISSIBLE SHOCK CURRENT AND STEP AND
TOUCH VOLTAGES ....................................................................... 9
SECTION 3
CURRENT LIMITATION
3.1 LIMITATION OF SHOCK CURRENTS .......................................... 10
SECTION 4
SECTION 5
SECTION 6
DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS
6.2 DISTRIBUTION EARTHING SYSTEM.......................................... 15
6.3 CONNECTION OF NEUTRAL TO EARTH.................................... 15
6.4 IMPEDANCE OF EARTH FAULT CURRENT PATH .................... 16
6.5 EARTHING CONNECTIONS AND EARTHING AT
DISTRIBUTION CENTRES ............................................................ 16
6.6 EARTHING OF FITTINGS OTHER THAN AT DISTRIBUTION
CENTRES ........................................................................................ 16
6.7 EARTHING CONNECTIONS.......................................................... 17
6.8 LOW VOLTAGE EARTHING CONDUCTORS ASSOCIATED
WITH LV SYSTEM ......................................................................... 17
6.9 CONNECTIONS TO EARTHING ELECTRODES .......................... 18
INTRODUCTION
This code of practice is intended to provide guidance on acceptable methods for determining
the safety of earthing systems associated with works.
NZECP 35 2
SECTION 1
1.1 SCOPE
1.2 INTERPRETATIONS
1.2.1 Distribution Centre - means any substation or generating station from which
electricity is supplied direct at low or high voltage to an electricity distribution
system of works or to an electrical installation. The distribution centre may
consist of one or more transformers on a pole, on the ground, underground, in
a building, in a generating station, or in a zone substation; and includes the
enclosure or building surrounding the transformer(s) and switchgear, if any.
1.2.2 Distribution System - means that portion of an electricity supply system from
where electricity at low or high voltage is conveyed from a distribution centre,
to the premises of consumers connected to that distribution centre, but does
not include distribution or service mains.
1.2.3 Earthed - means electrically connected to the general mass of the earth.
1.2.5 Earth fault current path - means the complete loop through which earth fault
current flows. It includes system plant as well as dedicated earth connections
and the main body of the earth.
1 April 1993
3 NZECP 35
1.2.6 Earth grid - means a system of interconnected bare conductors buried in the
earth providing a common earth for fittings. The grid may be specifically
designed to control surface potential gradients.
1.2.7 Earth impedance in respect of an earth electrode system - means the ohmic
impedance at system frequency between the electrode system and the general
mass of earth.
1.2.10 Frequented location - means any urban area associated with a city or town
other than a Special Location.
1.2.15 System voltage - means the difference of potential normally existing between
conductors, or between conductors and earth. (phase to phase in a multi phase
system and phase to earth in a single phase system).
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 4
1.2.17 Touch voltage - means the voltage which will appear between any point of
contact with uninsulated metalwork located within 2.5 metres from the surface
of the ground and any point on the surface of the ground within a horizontal
distance of 1.25 metres from the vertical projection of the point of contact
with the uninsulated metalwork.
HV High Voltage
Hz Hertz
Ib Permissible body current limit
kg Kilograms
kV Kilo-volts (1000 volts)
LV Low Voltage
MEN Multiple Earthed Neutral
NZECP New Zealand Electrical Code of Practice
PVC Polyvinyl chloride
t Time
1.4.2 Subsections are numbered by one full stop between two numbers. (eg 1.4)
1.4.3 Clauses are numbered by two full stops between three numbers. (eg 2.2.1)
1.4.4 Paragraphs contain numbering punctuated by one or more full stops together
with a parenthesised letter. (eg (a))
1 April 1993
5 NZECP 35
Figure 1
unearthed
metal likely equipment earthing
to become connection (conductor)
alive
power system neutral
transformer
tank connection
earth grid
earth vertical
electrode driven
rod
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 6
Figure 2
1 April 1993
7 NZECP 35
SECTION 2
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
The performance of the earthing system shall satisfy the safety and functional
requirements of the electrical installation and the fittings of that installation.
The earthing system may be used jointly or separately for protective or
functional purposes according to the requirements of the installation.
The design, selection and installation of the earthing systems shall be such as
will ensure:
(a) Protection against indirect contact;
(b) Proper functioning of electrical protective devices;
(c) That the protective and functional requirements are complied with
under the expected conditions;
(d) Earth fault currents and earth-leakage currents can be carried without
danger including thermal, thermomechanical and electromechanical
stresses;
(e) Adequate strength or additional mechanical protection appropriate to
the assessed external influences;
(f) The value of earthing resistance is in accordance with the protective
and functional requirements of the installation and is continuously
effective.
2.4.2 The type and embedded depth of the earth electrodes shall be such that soil
drying and freezing will not increase the earth resistance of the earth
electrodes above the required value. Where practicable, the earth electrodes
shall be embedded below permanent moisture level, except for electrodes
which are used for gradient control.
2.4.3 The design of the electrode shall take into consideration the type,
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 8
temperature and moisture content of the soil as well as the magnitude and
duration of expected current flow so as to minimise soil dryness in the vicinity
of the electrodes.
2.4.4 The material and total cross-sectional area of the earth electrodes shall be such
as to provide a conductance of not less than that of the earthing conductor.
2.4.5 The design, selection of materials, and construction of the earth electrodes
shall take into consideration the possible deterioration and increase of
resistance due to corrosion over the expected period of use of the installation.
2.4.6 In areas where corrosion is likely to be severe, the electrodes shall be of hard
drawn copper, copper clad or stainless steel, or other metal of such a nature or
so treated as to be not less resistant to corrosion than hard drawn copper, or
copper clad or stainless steel.
2.4.7 In areas where corrosion is not severe, galvanised or plain steel electrodes may
be used.
2.5.2 Inspections of earthing systems shall verify the connections from the earth grid
to driven rods and the connections from earth grid to system neutrals.
2.5.3 Initial testing of an earthing system shall verify that the actual earth impedance
is below its maximum safe calculated value.
2.5.4 When work has taken place that may have interfered with the earthing system,
the system in that area shall be inspected and checked. All parts of the earthing
system exposed by excavation shall be inspected for damage or deterioration.
2.5.5 Where there is any probability of significant corrosion of the buried earth grid
or of connections to it, more frequent inspections of the earth grid and
connections shall be carried out and replacements made where necessary.
1 April 1993
9 NZECP 35
2.5.6 To enable the integrity of the earthing installation and its suitability for present
fault levels to be assessed the following records shall be maintained:
(a) Initial design calculations;
(b) Results of periodic inspections;
(c) Updating of fault level;
(d) Drawings showing the location of all earth grid connections and or
joints.
2.6.1 Any earthing system shall be constructed to minimise the risk of electric shock
to persons.
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 10
SECTION 3
CURRENT LIMITATION
3.1.1 Where works are installed in an enclosed area with restricted access and where
control over ground conditions is being employed to control shock currents,
shock currents shall be deemed to be safe if they are limited to less than Ib as
determined by:
provided that:
(a) t is within the range of 0.3 to 3 seconds; and
3.1.1.1 When this method of determining shock current is applied a record shall be
kept of all information relating to the determination and control of shock
current.
1 April 1993
11 NZECP 35
SECTION 4
Step voltages shall not exceed TWICE the values of touch voltage as
determined in subsection 4.1.
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 12
Figure 3
1 April 1993
13 NZECP 35
SECTION 5
5.2.1 The power system neutral earth is provided by the interconnection of the
station earthing system with the power system neutral.
5.2.2 Power system neutral earthing shall comprise one of the following
connections:
(a) A solid connection, usually to a transformer starpoint:
(b) An impedance connection employing, a resistance, a reactance, or an
earthing transformer.
5.3.1 All fittings and any uninsulated metalwork, other than cable screens or
armouring, which are liable to become alive shall be connected to the earthing
system with a minimum of one conductor, capable of carrying full design fault
current for the duration of any fault which may liven the fitting or uninsulated
metalwork. Cable screens and armouring shall be regarded as metalwork
traversing the earth grid shall be bonded or left unbonded in accordance with
clause 5.3.2.
5.3.2 Metalwork bonded to the earth grid and projecting beyond the earth grid may
introduce a hazard from transferred potential and shall be considered during
the design.
5.3.4 If necessary earthing systems shall be upgraded where fault levels increase
above the original design level.
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 14
5.3.5 Allowances shall be made for current distribution in the earthing system.
5.4.2 Telecommunications circuits into high voltage stations may be protected by the
appropriate use of isolation transformers and/or optocouplers.
5.4.3 Cross-bonding of long cable sheaths may be carried out in order to limit
induced sheath voltages.
5.4.4 Fences and pipes sectionalised by inserting insulating sections may be used to
prevent transfer of potentials.
5.4.5 Services, such as telecommunications systems, near the earthing systems shall
be designed to avoid danger to people using or maintaining the services.
1 April 1993
15 NZECP 35
SECTION 6
DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS
6.2.1 Earth fault current paths for distribution systems may include:
(a) The transformer winding;
(b) The distribution system phase conductor;
(c) The return earth path between the location of the fault and the
distribution centre earth electrode; and
(d) The earth connections at the distribution centre which form the MEN
system including the distribution system neutral.
6.3.1 In a low voltage alternating current system, the neutral conductor shall be
earthed at or near the distribution centre (see subsection 6.8). It shall also be
earthed at such other places as will ensure that under fault conditions the
earthing system provides a low impedance path for earth fault currents. Where
applicable, fault conditions shall include those faults involving the associated
high voltage system.
6.3.2 Separate LV and HV earths may be installed to minimise the earth potential
rise on the LV neutral during HV earth faults.
6.3.4 In a high voltage system, the neutral conductor shall be earthed at or near the
source of supply by:
(a) Direct earthing of the neutral point;
(b) Earthing an artificial neutral point obtained from an earthing
transformer;
(c) Earthing in accordance with paragraph (a) or (b) of this clause via an
earthing resistor or reactor.
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 16
6.3.5 In addition the neutral may be earthed at other points in the system.
6.4.1 In an alternating current system, the impedance of the earth fault current path
(including the distribution centre or zone substation transformer, the phase
conductor of the distribution system and the earth return path) shall be such as
to ensure the correct operation of the protective devices which disconnect the
supply. A minimum factor of safety of two (2) shall be used when calculating
the impedance required and specifying protective device operating values.
6.4.2 The earthing system impedance shall be such that the earthing system, and any
fitting connected to it, does not introduce a danger to persons and property.
6.5.2 All fittings associated directly with any high voltage system shall be earthed by
a minimum of two independent earthing systems and connected in such a
manner that either can be disconnected independently for the purpose of
testing.
1 April 1993
17 NZECP 35
6.6.2 Any metalwork liable to become alive within 2.5 metres of the ground and
with which persons may come into contact shall be connected to earth (but
may not require a separate earthing connection), provided that the impedance
to earth is such that the step and touch potentials specified in sections 4 of this
Code are not exceeded. Any such metalwork may also be connected to a
multiple earthed neutral system.
6.6.3 Lightning arresters shall be earthed by a direct earth connection which presents
a low earth impedance path to high frequency currents. They may be bonded
to the earthing point of high voltage systems.
6.6.4 The metal operating handles of all high voltage switching fittings shall be
directly earthed unless the handles are insulated to the full working voltage so
as to avoid hazardous touch potentials.
6.7.1 Earthing conductors used for making connections of fittings to earth shall have
a capacity not less than the size calculated on the Nomogram in figure 4, page
19 of this Code. The clearance times specified in the Nomogram relate to the
protection associated with the portion of high voltage line and the distribution
centre fuses.
6.7.3 Buried conductors shall be copper and shall be bare unless there are special
reasons for using insulated copper. Bare aluminium shall not be buried.
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 18
6.9.1 Where conductors which are connected to earth electrodes, and are accessible
to the public (as at pole type distribution centres or where the neutrals within
the distribution system are connected to earth) those conductors shall be
protected against mechanical damage.
6.9.2 The conductors shall be brought out of the ground parallel and close to the
foot of the pole and shall be protected to a height of 2.5 metres. Fibreglass
channel section or a suitable wood may be used to provide mechanical
protection.
6.9.3 Joints between earthing conductors and earth electrodes shall be of adequate
mechanical strength and current carrying capacity and so arranged as to ensure
that there will be no failure of the connection under any conditions of use or
exposure that may be reasonably anticipated. Clamps and similar mechanical
connections shall be so designed and constructed that the connection will not
slacken off under use.
6.9.4 Where conductors connecting driven electrodes in parallel are not kept above
the ground, they shall be buried no less than 0.5 metres below the surface.
Connections of conductors to such electrodes shall be made by welding, or
exothermic welding, processes.
6.9.5 If test links are inserted in earthing conductors connected to electrodes, they
shall be bolted links and arranged so that the opening of one link does not
interfere with earth connections other than the one under test.
1 April 1993
19 NZECP 35
Figure 4
EXAMPLE: THE CALCULATED FAULT CURRENT IS 20 000 AMPERES AND THE FAULT
CLEARING TIME IS 1 SECOND. WHAT IS THE MINIMUM STANDARD SIZE COPPER
CONDUCTOR REQUIRED? METHOD: DRAW A STRAIGHT LINE THROUGH 1 SECOND ON RIGHT
HAND ORDINATE AND 2X104 ON RIGHT HAND SIDE OF CENTRE ORDINATE TO CUT LEFT
HAND ORDINATE. THE NEAREST CONDUCTOR SIZE ABOVE POINT OF INTERSECTION IS
7/4.50. NOTE: THE ABOVE FAULT DURATIONS ARE FOR A ONE SHOT OPERATION WITH A
COOLING PERIOD OF ONE MINUTE. WHERE AUTO RECLOSERS ARE USED THE TOTAL "ON"
TIME BEFORE LOCKOUT SHOULD BE USED.
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 20
Figure 5
1 April 1993
21 NZECP 35
Figure 6
1 April 1993
NZECP 35 22
Figure 7
1 April 1993
23 NZECP 35
Figure 8
1 April 1993