Cyberbullying Guidance2
Cyberbullying Guidance2
Cyberbullying Guidance2
UNDERSTAND,
PREVENT
AND RESPOND
Guidance for schools
Contents
Foreword 3 4. Cyberbullying: Supporting school staff 27
2. Preventing cyberbullying 12
Checklist 16
3. Responding to cyberbullying 18
Responding to incidents 18
“When we were younger we learned lots
When and how to contact the service providers 19 about cyberbullying. You have to talk about it
Investigation 21 to each generation though.”
Young person aged 16, Childnet focus group
Changing bullying behaviour 24
Checklist 25
Co-funded by:
Foreword
Childnet originally produced the hugely popular The majority of people who spend time online have not
Guidance for schools on preventing and responding to experienced cyberbullying. However, bullying in any context
cyberbullying in 2007 – one of the first national level resources can have severe and long-lasting negative effects, so it is
of its kind. This was followed by guidance produced critical that schools are equipped to help make sure that the
specifically for school staff in 2009. These initial guidance experience of technology is a positive, productive and creative
documents and resources have been used by schools and one for everyone in their community.
organisations across the UK and internationally to help
effectively understand, prevent and respond to cyberbullying. This new guidance has drawn from best practice and
knowledge from schools, key organisations and experts
Since then, our knowledge and understanding of working in the area, and from young people themselves.
cyberbullying (also known as online bullying) has grown,
alongside a rising demand from schools and other In order to effectively respond to the challenge of bullying,
organisations that work with children and young people for schools and other providers who support young people need
support and information. The kinds of technologies we use to ensure they understand cyberbullying, and know how to
have changed, and our use of technology has increased. The prevent and respond to incidents. Childnet International has
vast majority of people in the UK now use technology routinely worked with the Government Equalities Office to produce
to carry out a wide range of everyday activities. Digital literacy this guidance. The guidance provides important information
has continued to become increasingly important for children, and clear advice on the subject, and will support schools in
young people, and adults alike. New research into who is reviewing how they take action.
being cyberbullied, and the impacts of cyberbullying, has
been carried out. Although there is still more to do in this
area, an increasingly complex picture is emerging of bullying
Will Gardner
CEO Childnet International
behaviour that is carried out using technologies. Research
Director of the UK Safer Internet Centre
also shows that cyberbullying is increasing, particularly among
girls, and it is one of the most significant technology-related
concerns schools and parents have.
Anti-Bullying Alliance (ABA) 145 schools and organisations supporting schools (including
local authorities, police forces, and advisory services) provided
Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL)
us with information about effective and innovative practice in
The Boarding Schools’ Association relation to addressing cyberbullying.
Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre (CEOP), The guidance was also developed in consultation with young
a National Crime Agency Command people, recognising the importance of listening to their
experiences and ensuring these inform the recommendations
Children’s Commissioner for England made to schools. Young peoples’ opinions, concerns and
Department for Education understanding of cyberbullying shaped development of this
guidance, and an overview of what they told us is included
The Diana Award (‘What young people have told us’). Childnet staff talked
to five groups of young people between the ages of 12-17 in
E-safety Ltd
2015 from the following schools and organisations:
Facebook
\ Holloway School, Islington, London
Google \ John Roan School, Greenwich, London
Government Equalities Office \ First Out group for young people, Leicester Lesbian
Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Centre
Kent County Council
\ Stretford High School, Trafford, Manchester
National Association of Headteachers (NAHT)
NASUWT, The Teachers’ Union Our sincere thanks go to the many individuals and
organisations who contributed to the development
National Union of Teachers (NUT) of this guidance.
NSPCC
O2
Ofsted
Parent Zone
Stonewall
YoungMinds
• Cyberbullying takes different forms: threats and • The key elements of an effective approach are:
intimidation; harassment or stalking (e.g. repeatedly understanding and talking about cyberbullying; integrating
sending unwanted texts or instant messages); cyberbullying prevention into relevant policies and
vilification and defamation; ostracism and peer rejection; practices; ensuring reporting routes are accessible and
impersonation; and forwarding or publically posting private visible; promoting the positive use of technology; and
information or images. evaluating the impact of prevention activities.
• Cyberbullying can be characterised in several specific • Awareness-raising and promoting understanding about
ways that differ from face-to-face bullying. These include cyberbullying are essential to enable ongoing discussion
the profile of the person carrying out the bullying; the and to ensure members of the community are not
location of online bullying; the potential audience; unknowingly facilitating cyberbullying because of a lack
the perceived anonymity of the person cyberbullying; of understanding.
motivation of the person cyberbullying; and the digital
• Prevention activities can include staff development and
evidence of cyberbullying.
home-school events such as special assemblies with
• For the majority of people, most experiences of technology parents and carers. Schools should consider creative
are useful and positive. Research figures vary but indicate approaches which are relevant to the technologies their
that around 10% of young people have experienced community use.
cyberbullying. Cyberbullying can affect and involve all
• Cyberbullying can be addressed within the curriculum, for
members of the school community – pupils, staff, parents
example through citizenship and PSHE, and in relation to
and carers.
Spiritual, Moral, Social and Cultural development (SMSC).
• Every school must have measures in place to prevent all Other curriculum areas, including drama and computing,
forms of bullying, including cyberbullying. can also help bring cyberbullying issues to life.
1. Understanding
cyberbullying
The use of mobile and internet connected technologies are a
part of everyday life. Young people and adults are socialising 1.1 What is cyberbullying?
online, exchanging information and pictures, sharing links,
Bullying is purposeful, repeated behaviour designed to cause
and creating and uploading their own content to blogs and
physical and emotional distress. Cyberbullying (or online
video hosting sites. Technology can be a powerful, positive
bullying) is bullying using technologies, particularly over the
tool, in all areas of life, including education and learning and
internet or via mobile and gaming networks.
enables us to do many things that would not otherwise
be possible. Cyberbullying is the use of technologies by an
individual or by a group of people to deliberately
Technology does not cause people to behave badly –
and repeatedly upset someone else.
however, some people use technology to carry out harmful
actions, including cyberbullying. It is important for school • Technology can be used to carry out a wide range
communities, and people working in educational settings of unacceptable or illegal behaviours. Cyberbullying
that support children and young people, to understand what can include:
cyberbullying is – in order to effectively prevent and address
‒‒ intimidation and threats
harmful behaviour, and promote positive and constructive
uses of technology. ‒‒ harassment and stalking
‒‒ vilification/defamation
‒‒ exclusion or peer rejection
1.2 Forms that closed group, which can protect members from unwanted
contact, but can also be used to exclude others. Functions
cyberbullying can take that can be used to block abusive behaviour can also be
used to exclude others online.
Threats and intimidation
• Threats can be sent by mobile phone, email, within online Identity theft/unauthorised access
games, via comments on websites, social networking sites and impersonation
or message boards.
• ‘Hacking’ is generally used to mean accessing someone
• Threats can include violence, including sexual violence,
else’s account, by finding out or guessing their username
or threats to disclose information about someone that
and password information for example. Unauthorised
may harm them, or that they are not ready to share – for
access of systems, accounts or files is not automatically
example, the threat to make someone’s sexual orientation
a form of cyberbullying, but it is always a serious issue.
or gender identity known (to ‘out’ someone) when they
Unauthorised access to computer material is illegal.
may not feel ready for this.
• There are cases where sites have been set up which
make use of school logos and name, or using photographs
Harassment or stalking of staff or students taken from the school website
without permission.
• Repeatedly sending unwanted text or instant messages, or
making phone calls (including silent calls).
• Sharing private, sexually provocative or sexually explicit • In other research, just over 1 in 10 (11%) young people
photographs or films of adults (of people aged 18 and over) in England said they had experienced cyberbullying
without their consent, and with intent to cause distress by phone or online in the last year.
(‘revenge porn’), is an offence, regardless of whether the
subject initially consented to the creation of the content or
created the pictures themselves. Who is cyberbullied?
Cyberbullying can affect all members of the school
1.3 Characteristics of
community. However, some of the research in this area
indicates that some members of the community are
• asserting and increasing their popularity and social status The age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales is
• inability or unwillingness to empathise with others 10. It is worth noting the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS)
Guidelines on prosecuting cases involving
• to feel powerful and in control communications sent via social media:
• from boredom or as a form of entertainment
“The age and maturity of suspects should be given
significant weight, particularly if they are under the age of
While technology does not cause bullying, it may be used 18 […] Children may not appreciate the potential harm and
by people who would not necessarily bully others face-to- seriousness of their communications and a prosecution is
face. The perceived anonymity of some online activities, rarely likely to be in the public interest”.
or disinhibition due to the physical and emotional distance
between people using technology, may mean that the person These laws include:
bullying will do things that they would not do in person.
• Equality Act 2010: establishes that it is against the law
Bullying may also be, or felt to be, supported institutionally to discriminate against anyone because of protected
and culturally. Young people may be bullying within characteristics. Protected characteristics include disability,
environments where respect for others, and treating others gender reassignment (when a person undergoes a
well, is not seen as important – or where disrespect and poor process, or part of a process – social or medical – for the
treatment is tolerated or encouraged. Individuals who do purpose of reassigning their sex), race (including colour,
not conform to social norms may face discrimination within nationality, ethnic or national origin), religion or belief, sex
intolerant communities. and sexual orientation.
Resources
creating, showing, distributing, possessing with a view to
distributing, and publishing any advertisement of indecent
photographs of children (people under the age of 18).
Are school staff aware of the different forms Department for Education (2015) Behaviour
that cyberbullying can take, and the specific and discipline in schools
characteristics of cyberbullying?
Ofsted (2015) Inspecting safeguarding in
Does the school share a clear understanding early years, education and skills from
of what cyberbullying is, and why it is September 2015
not acceptable?
Department for Education (2015) Working
Does the school support all staff in their together to safeguard children
duty to understand, prevent and respond to
cyberbullying through policy, procedures, and
regular training and development opportunities?
• Schools and other educational settings should take A positive whole school community ethos which promotes
proactive measures to help prevent cyberbullying from mutual respect and trust can help reduce incidents and the
occurring, and to reduce the impact of any incidents that impact of incidents. All members of the school community
do happen. should be confident that bullying behaviours and actions will
be challenged, wherever they take place.
• All state schools are required to have a clear policy on
tackling all forms of bullying, which is owned, understood
and implemented by the whole school community.
• All schools are required to follow anti-discrimination laws, “We have a weekly parent bulletin where we
and staff must act to prevent discrimination, harassment pass on information about internet issues to
and victimisation within the school. parents. By having this as a regular activity
we can flag problem behaviours and guidance
without creating moral panics about
Cyberbullying prevention should build on these
individual issues.”
requirements, promoting and maintaining a safe and
Assistant principal, secondary school
welcoming environment.
The school should consider what it could do to actively Cyberbullying can also be addressed through the citizenship
promote the welfare of groups that are disproportionately curriculum, through Personal Social Health and Economic
affected by cyberbullying. Include discussion of prejudice- education (PSHE), as well as Religious Education (RE).
related bullying and hate incidents. Sexist, racist,
homophobic, biphobic and transphobic cyberbullying, as well
as cyberbullying related to disability, should be addressed. Publicising Sanctions
Pupils need to be aware of the importance of safe physical
and digital environments and how to behave responsibly
Many schools have found taking a creative when using technology. Pupils, parents and carers, staff
approach to understanding and talking about and governors should all be aware of the consequences of
cyberbullying can be particularly effective – cyberbullying. Young people and their parents and carers
with pupils producing plays, films, songs, should be made aware of pupils’ rights and responsibilities
websites, games and posters. in their use of technologies, and what the sanctions are for
cyberbullying and instances of online abuse. Information
should be accessible to all pupils.
Children and young people need to be encouraged to take Staff can be disciplined, and in some cases will be prohibited
responsibility for their own actions, and be equipped to from teaching, if they participate in unacceptable professional
know how to respond if they are cyberbullied, or if they see conduct. This includes sustained or serious bullying, which
someone else being cyberbullied. They also need to be given includes cyberbullying.
assurance that they are not on their own when it comes to
addressing cyberbullying – that the school will help them if
they or anyone they know is being cyberbullied.
2.4 Updating existing of mobile devices and websites as well as sanctions for their
misuse. It is important that rules are well-publicised and that
policies and practices parents are made aware of them. All staff members should
apply rules consistently.
Cyberbullying issues will impact on a range of other
policies – staff development, ICT support and infrastructure,
and e-learning strategies, for example. 2.5 Making reporting
Schools should ensure that their anti-bullying policy and/or cyberbullying easier
school behaviour policy makes reference to specific types of
bullying, including cyberbullying. Reporting any incident of bullying can be difficult for the
person being bullied and for bystanders. It may be particularly
difficult for young people to report cyberbullying if reporting
will reveal something about their online activities that they do
“County schools take a wide range not want to share.
of approaches to ensuring their anti-
cyberbullying work is effective. This includes Engagement with technology involves feelings as well as
the involvement of student councils in actions – above all it is a social activity that allows young
people to feel connected to their peers. Telling a young
updating policies to ensure student voice is
person who has been cyberbullied to keep their mobile phone
heard – some schools have student versions
switched off, delete an account, or to stay off the internet as a
of key policies to ensure they are accessible
response to cyberbullying may be interpreted as a disruption
and understood.” of their social life and perceived as a punishment. In some
Local Authority e-Safety officer
cases, the knowledge that this is likely to be a response may
prevent reporting.
Inflexible blocking and filtering policies can make it difficult • staff and students should never reply to upsetting
for school staff to address incidents (for example, contacting messages or images. Instead, they should keep any
service providers), and may restrict access to sites and evidence and report the incident.
information that is useful and relevant to students. Education
and discussion around digital literacy, responsible use and • encourage staff and pupils to become familiar and
online safety is essential to help children and young people confident with the account management tools of
deal confidently with problems that may arise, whether in or the services they use, particularly privacy and
out of school. blocking features.
Resources
The Your Own Technology Survey (YOTS) is a free The Childnet Digital Leaders Programme helps to
tool to help schools and researchers better understand empower young people in both primary and secondary
the digital technology their students use out of school. schools to champion digital citizenship and digital
creativity within their schools and to educate their
The UK Safer Internet Centre have produced a peers, parents and teachers about staying safe online.
guide for education settings and filtering providers
about establishing ‘appropriate levels’ of filtering and The Diana Award Anti-Bullying Campaign
monitoring: www.saferinternet.org.uk/advice- empowers young people, professionals and parents to
centre/teachers-and-professionals/appropriate- tackle all forms of bullying as Ambassadors who help
filtering-and-monitoring to keep their peers safe online and offline.
• work with the person bullying to restore relationships and Illegal content and activity includes:
make sure all pupils involved feel safe inside and outside
• indecent images of children (under the age of 18)
of school. Where there is evidence of bullying behaviour,
appropriate sanctions should be applied. School staff should not view illegal images unless doing so is
unavoidable or necessary. Staff should never copy or forward
• pupil/s that have been bullied should feel safe and
illegal images.
confident that there will not be a repeat incident, and that
the school community has learnt from the incident. If a young person (under the age of 18) has produced or
shared material consensually, without pressure or malice, it
may be appropriate for the school to manage the incident
Bullying incidents can bring the school community into
directly, after they have conducted a full and robust risk
disrepute. In the case of media interest, ensure staff follow the
assessment.
school or local authority process for talking to and managing
press contact.
The UK Council for Child Internet Safety (UKCCIS) provide The quickest and most effective route to getting inappropriate
further advice in Sexting in schools and colleges. material taken down from the web will be to have the person
who originally posted it remove it:
Contact the Internet Watch Foundation if illegal images
have been posted on the internet. • if you know who the person responsible is, explain why the
material is hurtful and request they remove it.
Contact CEOP if there is any concern that a child has been
coerced into produced images, or is being groomed or • pupils can be asked to delete offending content from their
sexually exploited. mobile phones or other devices.
• obscene content, for example depictions of rape • refusal to delete material from a personal device is likely to
or torture. These can be reported to the Internet constitute reasonable grounds for confiscation.
Watch Foundation. • if pupils refuse to delete content, a parent or carer should
• hate crimes and incidents, including racist material. be contacted.
Contact your local police. Incidents can also be reported • pupils can be asked to list to whom they have forwarded
to True Vision. information, and where it is posted.
• ‘Revenge pornography’ – the publication of sexual images If the person who posted the material is not known, contact
of an adult without their consent. Contact the Revenge the site or service hosting the material to make a report to get
Porn Helpline. the content taken down. Service providers should remove
• stalking and harassment. Contact the emergency services material that breaches their terms and conditions.
if there is an imminent threat of danger, alternatively,
contact the local police or the National Stalking Helpline.
When and how to contact
• threats of violence, rape or death threats. Contact the
service providers
emergency services if there is an imminent threat of danger.
Alternatively, contact the local police. Addressing cyberbullying and ensuring the people involved
• images or recordings of a crime, e.g.an assault on a take responsibility for their actions is not something that can
member of the school community are not illegal, but should be achieved just by using technology. Many sites and services
be passed to the police. provide blocking and privacy tools, and these features can
sometimes be useful in stopping unwanted or upsetting
contact. For example, if a social networking service member
is receiving unwanted messages from another member,
blocking the account is a way of stopping messages being
received from that account.
Sexually explicit photographs and videos of young
people under the age of 18 are legally regarded Staff, pupils, and parents and carers can contact the service
as indecent images of children. They are illegal to provider or host (i.e. the chatroom, the social network
produce, forward or show to others, or possess, provider, or mobile operator) to report what has happened
regardless of whether the pictures were taken and and get advice on how to stop this happening again. The
shared with the permission of the young person service provider may be able to block particular senders or
they depict. callers (for landlines), take down materials, or even delete the
accounts of those that are abusing the service.
Sexual images used to bully or coerce should be
reported to the police. Where appropriate, the police
are able to record incidents so as to limit the long term
negative impact on young people.
When making a report to a social media site it is Service providers can investigate and shut down any
important that you identify the correct report category, accounts that have been misused and clearly break the law
to make sure the platform can review the content or their terms of service. The best evidence for the service
correctly. For example, if a page is using the name of provider is archived or recorded conversations, and most
your school and the school logo without permission, IM providers allow the user to record all messages. Some
that isn’t offensive or abusive in itself – so unless services, for example Snapchat, only display pictures and
the content is abusive the report will be rejected. messages on your phone for a short time. Users can take
If, you report the page for the unauthorised use of copies of offensive posts by taking a screen shot or by using
your intellectual property (school name and logo), or apps that have been developed to take screenshots on behalf
impersonation, the report is likely to succeed. Take of the user.
some time to understand the site’s terms of use.
One of the most common types of calls from schools It is illegal to make copies of sexual images of children under
to the POSH helpline are about comments parents the age of 18 or possess these. Copies of indecent images
or carers make about the members of school staff of children must not be printed, saved or forwarded. In
online. While what you are reading may hurt your this instance, the service provider can be contacted with a
feelings and feel personally abusive, comments may description of the image, time sent and account it was
not be objectively abusive or threatening. sent from.
Mobile phones Some social network providers also enable users to pre-
moderate any comments left on their profile, or review
Malicious, abusive or threatening calls or texts are illegal. Calls pictures their name is tagged with before they are visible
should be reported to the mobile phone company – all UK by others. This can help a user prevent unwanted or hurtful
operators have a nuisance or malicious call team, who will be comments or images appearing on their profile, or being
able to assist and advise you. You do not need to know the returned in searches for their name. Some services allow you
person responsible for making the call. to disable or restrict comments, messages and who can view
your content. Account holders can also usually set their profile
to private, so they can select who is able to access and see
their profile and activity.
• If the bullying was via mobile phone, has the person Where a device contains material that needs to be passed to
responsible withheld their number? If so, it is important to the police, school staff can confiscate and secure the device,
record the date and time of the message and contact the for example by placing it in a locked draw.
mobile operator. Steps can be taken to trace the call, but
the mobile operator can only disclose this information to Where a member of staff finds an item which is banned under
the police, so police would need to be involved. the school rules, i.e. evidence which relates to cyberbullying
but does not constitute a criminal offence – they should
• Has a potential criminal offence been committed? If so,
take into account all relevant circumstances and use their
the police may have a duty to investigate. Police can issue
professional judgement to decide whether to return it to its
a RIPA (Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000)
owner, retain it or dispose of it. Legal content can be deleted,
request to a service provider, enabling them to disclose the
but staff should be aware of how to capture and retain
data about a message or the person sending a message.
evidence of cyberbullying incidents and of when this
This may help to identify the person responsible. Relevant
would be useful.
criminal offences here include harassment and stalking,
threats of harm or violence to a person or property, any It is recommended that where possible school staff do
evidence of sexual exploitation (for example grooming or not delete content. Young people can be asked to delete
inappropriate sexual contact or behaviour). offensive or upsetting content, and confirm they have
done so.
Investigating allegations
against staff
Some messages might allege abuse against a teacher
or other member of staff. There have been cyberbullying
incidents where pupils, or parents and carers have made
unfounded and malicious claims against staff members.
It is critical to take every claim seriously and investigate
it thoroughly.
Once the person/s responsible for cyberbullying have been • ensure the person carrying out the bullying takes
identified, it is important that – as in other cases of bullying – responsibility for their actions, recognises the harm caused,
appropriate sanctions are applied. and does not repeat the behaviour.
Staff resignation as a consequence of cyberbullying, • The school can request that students and staff should not
in cases where the school has failed to take adequate take, share or publish photographs of other members of
steps to address the situation, may prompt claims of the school community without the subject’s permission.
constructive dismissal. Schools should clearly communicate expectations,
acceptable conduct and potential sanctions regarding
• Schools are required to provide staff with training and inappropriate image-taking and use by staff, pupils
information relating to abuse, including cyberbullying; have and parents.
procedures in place for addressing cyberbullying incidents;
• School-owned devices should be provided for staff
and include acceptable use in relation to online and mobile
members who need to take images of pupils for
communications in their staff behavioural policy.
school purposes.
• School staff should be supported in their use of • You can use search engines to check what images and
technologies including social media. text are associated with your name, or with a combination
Schools are required to ensure staff receive regular training of your school and name. This will help establish what
and information relating to online safety and cyberbullying. information other people can easily find about you.
In addition, school staff behavioural policies must include • You can search within social networking services.
the acceptable use of technologies and the use of social
media, including communications between staff • Staff may only become aware of other people posting
and students. objectionable material when a colleague or student
alerts them. Encouraging everyone to report any
For further information about these requirements, see the inappropriate material they find is an important way
Department for Education statutory guidance, Keeping to address cyberbullying.
children safe in education.
5. What young
people have told us
What did young people tell us about effective • cyberbullying doesn’t always have to be extreme, but it
approaches in preventing and responding can be the regularity or the number of people involved that
to cyberbullying? makes it particularly upsetting.
This guidance has been developed in consultation with • while many young people were aware of cyberbullying
young people. Childnet International talked to five groups of incidents in their school, they also recognised that they
secondary-aged young people between the ages of 12-17, might not always know about it.
about cyberbullying, what effective strategies schools are • there can be a tendency to typecast people as either a
implementing and what can be improved to help support “bully” or a “victim” but it is often not as clear cut as this.
young people more effectively.
What young people have told us UNDERSTANDING, PREVENTING AND RESPONDING TO CYBERBULLYING 30
What reasons did young people give for why they might • Inclusion of cyberbullying when the school talks
not tell someone they were being cyberbullied? about bullying
• Fear of the bully or worried the bullying might escalate • Cyberbullying should not be addressed as an isolated
issue, but be integrated across behavioural, pastoral and
• Embarrassment citizenship activities
• Not wanting others to see them as a ‘snitch’
• Telling someone would be perceived as a sign What young people would do to help someone who
of weakness was being cyberbullied
What young people have told us UNDERSTANDING, PREVENTING AND RESPONDING TO CYBERBULLYING 31
© 2016 Childnet International
www.childnet.com