Physiological Bases of Mosquito Ecology
Physiological Bases of Mosquito Ecology
Physiological Bases of Mosquito Ecology
Distinguished Achievement Award Presentation at the 2002 Society of Vector Ecology Meeting
ABSTRACT: The research carried out during more than 30 years in the author’s laboratory is briefly reviewed.
Quantitative analyses of basic physiological processes, such as growth and development, digestion and excretion,
oogenesis and fecundity, reserve synthesis and resulting flight-potentials of Aedes aegypti were summarized and
compared with several other mosquito species, particularly with Anopheles. These studies led to the recognition
of distinctly different physiological strategies, for which the term “physiotype” has been coined, providing a basis
for understanding the different ecotypes. Journal of Vector Ecology 28(1): 1-11. 2003.
First and foremost, let me express my sincere stoichiometric relationships and principles governing
gratitude to the Society for Vector Ecology for this the metabolic events during the reproductive cycles of
prestigious Distinguished Achievement Award and for Ae. aegypti (Briegel 1985, 1990a) and Anopheles species
the opportunity to attend this meeting. It is good to see (Briegel and Rezzonico 1985, Briegel and Hörler 1993,
so many scholars of mosquito biology together again. I Klowden and Briegel 1994). Once we had quantified
also appreciate the opportunity to present a short blood ingestion, protein digestion, and excretion of the
overview of our work that has been carried out during catabolites, we had a metabolic background for entering
the last three decades, mainly in Switzerland. I will try to the field of reproductive physiology and oogenesis
draw a general and very personal picture of some (Briegel 1985, 1986, Lea et al. 1978, Briegel et al. 2002).
physiological aspects of mosquito life styles that may We then expanded to larval development (Timmermann
provide a background for a better understanding of and Briegel 1996, 1998, 1999) and to other mosquito
ecological situations encountered in the field. For that species, and we finally became entangled in the flight
purpose, I would like to point out the advantages of fully potential and energetics of female mosquitoes (Briegel
quantitative analytical procedures available in the et al. 2001a,b, Briegel and Timmermann 2001). Using flight
laboratory and what we can learn from such studies. We mills, we were able to record the flight distances, the
worked in several fields of comparative physiology with patterns of flight activity, and the utilization of reserves
different mosquito species. in comparison to pre-flight conditions and to those that
My research began with studies of blood digestion had not flown. During all phases of our research, I had
in Aedes aegypti (Briegel and Lea 1975, 1979, Briegel always intended to address and answer basic questions
1981, 1983). We clarified the enzymatic and endocrine about the mosquito and its actual behavior in the field
regulations of the processing of the blood meals (Graf and/or ecological adaptations of certain species. I will
and Briegel 1982, Hörler and Briegel 1995, 1997), and for select a few examples and results to put parts of the
the first time, achieved the purification of mosquito physiological mosaic together to reveal a picture of the
trypsin and characterized its synthetic pathway (Graf and ecophysiology of a species. In doing so, distinct
Briegel 1985, 1989, Graf et al. 1986, 1998). Because there species-specific strategies could be identified.
is no digestion without excretion, we also quantitatively The larval period of mosquitoes is a primary target
studied the excretory processes in great detail (Briegel of all control methods. Therefore, we studied their growth
1975, 1980a, b, 1986, Briegel et al. 1979, von Dungern and and development, their proteolytic enzymes, and their
Briegel 2001a,b). This led us to an understanding of synthesis of reserves (Timmermann and Briegel 1996,
2 Journal of Vector Ecology June, 2003
Figure 1. Effect of depth of water in the larval rearing containers in five mosquito species. These containers were
rat cages (22x40 cm, 15 cm high) filled with water to depths of 0.5, 1, 2, 5, and 14 cm, each with 200 larvae. Total
eclosion of imagoes is expressed as a percent of newly hatched larvae. Optimal development was always at water
depths of 0.5 to 1 cm.
1998, 1999, Hörler and Briegel 1995, 1997). Different During the fourth and last instar, 80-90% of the growth
feeding mechanisms are commonly recognized among and biosynthesis takes place; if not enough is
various groups (Dahl 1993). We quantitatively accumulated, the larvae can wait for 2-3 weeks until they
demonstrated that mosquito larvae could utilize only a finally pupate or die. If they pupate they give rise to
narrow water segment between the water surface and small or large imagoes, while the dead larvae provide
the deeper zones (Figure 1, Timmermann and Briegel, additional food for their sisters and brothers. I say sisters
unpublished data). This observation provided a general and brothers, because during the fourth instar the sexual
understanding of mosquitoes that usually breed in differences in growth and biosynthesis become
shallow water ponds, always close to the surface or to expressed (Timmermann and Briegel 1999). Because most
the margins. Therefore, our interests were centered mosquito larvae live in stiff opposition between feeding
around the nutritional aspects. It turned out that mosquito in the water column or on the bottom and breathing at
larvae definitely require food of animal origin in addition the surface, the biosphere accessible to them is often
to plant debris (Timmermann and Briegel 1996) in order confined to only a few centimeters, particularly in the
to meet their needs for the essential poly-unsaturated Anophelines, which lack a siphon and spend most of
fatty acids that apparently do not occur in plant material, their lives at the surface (Timmermann and Briegel 1993).
as already had been shown by Dadd (1981, 1983). These constraints are reflected in variable imaginal body
Mosquito larvae feed continuously, similar to caterpillars. sizes and their teneral reserves that in turn, strongly
Some elegant endocrine mechanisms regulating molting affect the life of the imagoes (Briegel 1990b, Figure 2).
and metamorphosis in Lepidoptera have been revealed After eclosion, insects enter a shorter or longer
(Nijhout 1975), but to our surprise, mosquito larvae were “maturation period,” the teneral phase. In mosquitoes
different. While caterpillars are able to adapt their molts this lasts about one day. This is a very important period,
to their nutritional status, even through supernumerary because so many covert effects take place at all levels:
instars, this is impossible in mosquitoes. They are anatomical differentiation, behavioral maturation, the
programmed for four larval instars, and the environmental, hormonal system, the digestive system, vitellogenesis,
mainly dietary conditions, determine their final body size. and also the flight muscles. All require their time before
We found an absolute value for each instar in the diameter the true nature of the mosquito and its blood-sucking
of their head capsule (confirming Dyar’s rule with a factor habits become manifested. Among all these aspects, the
of 1.1), whereas the thorax diameter indicates the biomass quantity of teneral reserves “inherited” from the larva
acquired by the larva (Timmermann and Briegel 1998). are crucial (Figure 2, Briegel 1990a, b).
June, 2003 Journal of Vector Ecology 3
When studying the physiology of any insect, there recognized so far; autogenous females and males are
is one very important parameter to consider that is not considered at this point.
obvious but often neglected: body size. We had initiated First, let’s consider the classic case of Ae. aegypti,
rigid evaluations of mosquito body sizes in all our which has been thoroughly studied in so many respects.
research. In insects, particularly in mosquitoes, weight The linear regression for protein against body size and
determinations are often misleading except for the dry the exponential regression for lipid have been shown in
weights. Therefore, morphometric measures are always Figure 2 with the isometric and positive allometric
best, but for physiological considerations, volume and functions, respectively (Briegel 1990a). Within a few
not linear dimensions are required (Schmidt-Nielsen hours of eclosion, these females begin to take sugar if
1984). Consequently, we decided for the simplest available, thus improving their teneral lipids. When
treatment, which is the cubic value of the wing length, or deprived of sugar, they avidly take blood meals within
some other length of the exoskeleton. In this way, body one day and can survive, but not necessarily reproduce,
size is a dependable measure for these reserve conditions unless they are of large body size. Blood meals add a
that follow significant isometric or allometric substantial amount of protein. In our experiments we
relationships, although with species-specific slopes and always gave measured blood meals by enema to each
extent (Briegel 1990a, b; and Figure 2). We routinely female (0.5–5 µl), followed by individual micro-analyses
produced mosquitoes covering the whole spectrum of of intestinal enzyme activities, of the yolk components,
possible sizes in several species (Briegel 1990a, b). This and of the principal catabolites (Briegel 1985, 1986,
is easily accomplished by manipulating the food supplies 1990a). Figure 4 combines such measurements during a
and/or the population densities during the larval period. gonotrophic cycle of large Ae. aegypti. Figure 5
Different reproductive strategies are recognized. Females demonstrates the perfect synchronization amongst the
may or may not profit from the larval reserve various processes: yolk volume parallels the appearance
accumulations, and accordingly they seek additional of yolk protein and yolk lipid, whereas glycogen appears
sources. Of course, blood from vertebrates is a valuable, at the end, shortly before chorionation. Uric acid
although a difficult and dangerous source for the synthesis parallels urea formation, and both coincide
additional protein required. This is the central issue of with yolk deposition, as shown in Figure 4. All the events
hematophagy and of most investigations on mosquito taking place in such a narrow sigmoid area (hatched
physiology, besides the problems of pathogen area in Figure 4) point out the remarkable capability of
transmission. However, there is an equally important and the fat body cells to distribute the nitrogen units to
more variable story involving the synthesis and reserves synthetic mechanisms (vitellogenin) and to the catabolic
of lipids, their needs for yolk production, and their mechanisms (uricotely, ureotely, and ammonotely). In
energetic significance. addition, the carbohydrate units obtained through
Total protein always follows a highly significant and protein degradation are also converted to appropriate
linear correlation with body size because protein at this amounts of lipid synthesis. Hematin defecation marks
stage represents mainly a structural component. Lipids the end of the digestion period and was shown to be
on the other hand can follow linear correlations with regulated on a neuronal basis (Briegel and Lea,
body size, equal to protein or much higher, or they show unpublished data, Van Handel and Klowden 1996). These
exponential correlations of steep or flat inclinations measurements also allowed the determination of the
(Briegel 1990a, b). To compensate for low teneral lipids, extent of the utilization of blood for oogenesis in large
females may seek sugar sources, which then enter the and small females, and the establishment of complete
lipogenetic pathways, in most cases before blood meals protein budgets (Figure 6). As a rule, blood meal protein
are added (Briegel et al. 2001a, b). Hormonal factors is always ingested in surplus of the need for
suppress glycogen synthesis, thus favoring lipogenesis vitellogenesis. In Ae. aegypti, roughly one-third of the
to some degree of obesity (Van Handel 1965, Lea and human blood protein is utilized for synthesis of yolk
Van Handel 1970). The amount of sugar ingested before protein, while two-thirds are deaminated and split equally
a blood meal and the extent of subsequent reserve build- for renewed lipid synthesis and for energy requirements.
up are detrimental for the survival of the females (Figure Ziegler and Ibrahim (2001) found a remarkable mechanism
3). Sugar solutions provided in various concentrations in which after a blood meal, yolk lipid is taken from the
clearly affect the survival of a population. As will be pre-blood meal lipid stores in the fat body, while the
shown later, the amount of lipids accumulated until the lipid synthesized from the blood protein is deposited
time of a blood meal largely contributes to the into the fat body for the next gonotrophic cycle. In
reproductive potential of a female mosquito. Selected addition, we had found evidence for a threshold of one
examples shall demonstrate the metabolic strategies calorie for the female lipid content plus the blood meal
4 Journal of Vector Ecology June, 2003
Figure 2. Teneral protein (P) and lipid (L) of four mosquito species, measured shortly after eclosion and plotted
against body size. All possible body sizes measured as wing length (mm) and presented as cubic value (WL3) were
produced by manipulating larval densities and food supplies. Only the regression lines are shown. The small
hatched segment represents the minimal amounts of lipid observed when females were starved to death, thus
indicating the extent of lipids available for mobilization under extreme nutritive stress. (Data from Briegel 1990a, b;
Briegel et al. 2001; and unpublished data).
Figure 6. Nitrogen partitioning during a gonotrophic cycle of four mosquito species fed human blood (h). All
females had access to sucrose before the blood meal. Ae. aegypti was also fed rodent blood (r), and furthermore
were kept in dryness (d) or with access to drinking water (w). The black segments are for haematin which always
accounts for 2-3%. Note the variable protein input by blood meal, caused by the body sizes and midgut volumes of
the different Anopheles species; in Ae. aegypti blood meals were given by enema. The average number of eggs
matured for each condition is added at the bottom of each bar. The segment with vertical shading represents the
maternal, extraovarian protein deposit, synthesized from the blood meal before and/or together with the yolk
protein. Further explanations see text. Abbreviations: Y for yolk, UA for uric acid, UR for urea, AM for ammonium
plus amino nitrogen (combined). In An. gambiae the budget was not completed.
We are considering an evolutionary interpretation remains an endless future for the field of basic
that the physiological and endocrine principles physiology.
governing the discrete gonotrophic cycles in Culicines
have evolved later, representing an apomorph status. I Acknowledgments
even dare to think that the possibility for acyclic
reproduction in tropical Anopheles as a plesiomorph I would like to thank all the brilliant students who
status might contribute to or explain the fact that passed through my laboratory as highly motivated
Plasmodium has adopted Anophelini as their vectors, biologists. The most important and productive
and not the Culicini. contributions and discussions were with R. Graf, E. Hörler,
In conclusion, I would like to convey a few personal and S.E. Timmermann, to name just a few. Much of my
remarks. Some entomologists have objected to issues own work largely depended on the competent and
raised from our physiological laboratory investigations reliable laboratory technicians, E. Csibi and R. Haigis.
versus ecological and epidemiological field studies. I The most substantial part, however, was played by Arden
never claimed that our laboratory-based results with O. Lea, who continuously asked stimulating questions
controlled and constant conditions would represent the before and after experiments. As a post-doc in his highly
actual life of a given vector in its natural environment, scientific and unusually creative surroundings, I received
and I am aware of many additional parameters in the the best training I could ever have had. Equally important
field that equally govern mosquito ecology. What I have was the absolute freedom of research I was always
always tried to provide, however, was a valid and largely granted by the director of our institute, Prof. R. Wehner.
quantitative background, and to present a framework Finally, the continuous and generous support of our
against which ecologists could seek additional research during 26 years by the Swiss National Science
possibilities or interpretations of their findings. In the Foundation is greatly appreciated.
laboratory I think we could stretch that frame to the
extremes, while other parameters were kept constant, to REFERENCES CITED
enable a view on the full metabolic potential of a given
species. I am also aware that a next generation of Briegel, H. 1975. Excretion of proteolytic enzymes by
physiologists will have to take the next and more difficult Aedes aegypti (L.) after a blood meal. J. Insect
steps to investigate such additional parameters. There Physiol. 21: 1681-1684.
remains a lot of work for future physiologists to do but Briegel, H. 1980a. Determination of uric acid and hematin
all this is a challenging outlook for young entomologists. in a single sample of excreta from blood-fed insects.
The hard core of this work ought to be done at the bench, Experientia 36: 1428.
much more than on computer screens, and then be Briegel, H. 1980b. Stickstoffexkretion bei Weibchen von
combined with field studies. Aedes aegypti (L.) nicht endokrin reguliert. Rev.
The different strategies presented above reflect a Suisse Zool. 87: 1029-1033.
biodiversity on the physiological level; there is no Briegel, H. 1981. Regulation of blood digestion in
physiology of “the mosquito.” Each group and even mosquitoes: effect of age of the female and role of
species has its own set of metabolic adaptations, the neuroendocrine system in Aedes aegypti.
required to fit its respective ecological niche. It will be Parasitology 82: 98-101.
interesting to unravel new and arrange alternative Briegel, H. 1983. Manipulation of age-dependent kinetics
strategies among the many mosquito vector species. To of the induction of intestinal trypsin in the mosquito
ease comparative approaches along the lines presented Aedes aegypti (Diptera: Culicidae). Entomologia
here, I suggest a new term for these adaptations: the Generalis 8: 217-223.
“physiotype,” in analogy to the ecotypes recognized Briegel, H. 1985. Mosquito reproduction: incomplete
by ecologists. utilization of the blood meal protein for oogenesis.
As a final consideration, I believe that models J. lnsect Physiol. 31: 15-21.
created on computer screens are too simplistic and often Briegel, H. 1986. Protein catabolism and nitrogen
misleading. Our knowledge is far too limited to feed into partitioning during oogenesis in the mosquito Aedes
theoretical programs. One should not be afraid to ask aegypti. J. Insect Physiol. 32: 455-462.
about the secrets of the life of the insect by devising Briegel, H. 1990a. Metabolic relationship between female
clever experiments. It is far more interesting, challenging, body size, reserves, and fecundity in Aedes aegypti.
rewarding, and true. We have only started to understand J. Insect Physiol. 36:165-172.
merely five to six species a little better, out of the dozens Briegel, H. 1990b. Fecundity, metabolism, and body size
of vector species and parasites they transmit. There in Anopheles (Diptera: Culicidae), vectors of malaria.
10 Journal of Vector Ecology June, 2003
J. Med. Entomol. 27: 839-850. Dahl, C. 1993. Differential particle uptake by larvae of
Briegel, H., A.O. Lea, and M.J. Klowden.1979. three mosquito species (Diptera: Culicidae). J. Med.
Hemoglobinometry as a method for measuring blood Entomol. 30: 537-543.
meal sizes of mosquitoes. J. Med. Entomol. 15: 235- Graf, R., A.O. Lea, and H. Briegel. 1998. A temporal profile
239. of the endocrine control of trypsin synthesis in the
Briegel, H. and A.O. Lea. 1975. Relationship between yellow fever mosquito, Aedes aegypti. J. Insect
protein and proteolytic activity in the midgut of Physiol. 44: 451-454.
mosquitoes. J. Insect Physiol. 21: 1597-1604. Graf, R., A.S. Raikhel, M.R. Brown, A.O. Lea, and H.
Briegel, H. and A.O. Lea. 1977. Ecdysone, the ovarian Briegel. 1986. Mosquito trypsin: immuno-
hormone and intestinal proteases in mosquitoes. cytochemical localization in the midgut of blood-
Experientia 33: 813. fed Aedes aegypti. Cell Tissue Res. 245: 19-27.
Briegel, H. and A.O. Lea. 1979. Influence of the endocrine Graf, R. and H. Briegel. 1989. The synthetic pathway of
system on tryptic activity in female Aedes aegypti. trypsin in the mosquito Aedes aegypti L. (Diptera:
J. Insect Physiol. 25: 227-230. Culicidae) and in vitro stimulalion in isolated
Briegel, H. and E. Hörler. 1993. Multiple blood meals as a midguts. Insect Biochem. 19: 129-137.
reproductive strategy in Anopheles (Diptera: Graf, R. and H. Briegel. 1982. Comparison between
Culicidae). J. Med. Entomol. 30: 975-985. aminopeptidase and trypsin activity in blood-fed
Briegel, H. and L. Rezzonico. 1985. Concentration of host females of Aedes aegypti. Rev. Suisse Zool. 89: 845-
blood protein during feeding by anopheline 850.
mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae). J. Med. Entomol. Graf, R. and H. Briegel. 1985. Isolation of trypsin isozymes
22: 612-618. from the mosquito Aedes aegypti (L.). Insect
Briegel, H. and S.E. Timmermann. 2001. Aedes albopictus: Biochem. 15: 611-618.
physiological aspects of development and Hörler, E. and H. Briegel. 1995. Proteolytic enzymes of
reproduction. J. Med. Entomol. 38: 566-571. female Anopheles: Biphasic synthesis, regulation,
Briegel, H., A. Waltert, and R. Kuhn. 2001a. Reproductive and multiple feeding. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol.
physiology of Aedes (Aedimorphus) vexans in 28: 189-205.
relation to its flight potential. J. Med. Entomol. 38: Hörler, E. and H. Briegel. 1997. Chymotrypsin inhibitors
557-565. in mosquitoes: activity profile during development
Briegel, H., I. Knüsel, and S.E. Timmermann. 2001b. Aedes and after blood feeding. Arch. Insect Biochem.
aegypti: size, reserves, survival, and flight potential. Physiol. 36: 315-333.
J. Vector Ecol. 26: 21-31. Klowden, M.J. and H. Briegel. 1994. The gonotrophic
Briegel, H., M. Hefti, and E. Di Marco. 2002. Lipid cycle and multiple feeding potential of some
metabolism during sequential gonotrophic cycles Anopheles and Aedes mosquitoes (Diptera:
in large and small females of Aedes aegypti. J. Insect Culicidae). J. Med. Entomol. 31: 618-622.
Physiol.48: 547-554. Langley, P.A. 1977. Physiology of tsetse flies (Glossina
Briegel, H., T. Gut, and A.O. Lea. 2003. Sequential spp.)(Diptera: Glossinidae): a review. Bull. Entomol.
deposition of yolk components during oogenesis Res. 67: 523-574.
in an insect, Aedes aegypti (Diptera: Culicidae). J. Lea, A.O. 1975. The control of reproduction by a blood
Insect Physiol. (in press). meal: the mosquito as a model for vector
Bursell, E., K.C. Billing, J.W. Hargrove, C.T. McCabe, endocrinology. Acta Trop. 32: 112-115.
and E. Slack. 1974. Metabolism of the blood meal in Lea, A.O. and E. Van Handel. 1970. Suppression of
tsetse flies (a review). Acta Trop. 31: 297-320. glycogen synthesis in the mosquito by a hormone
Clements, A.N. 1999. The biology of mosquitoes. Vol. 2. from the medial neurosecretory cells. J. Insect
CABI Publishing, Oxon, UK. Physiol. 16: 319-321.
Dadd, R.H. 1981. Essential fatty acids for mosquitoes, Lea, A.0., H. Briegel, and H.M. Lea. 1978. Arrest,
other insects and vertebrates. In: G. Bhaskaran, S. resorption, or maturation of oocytes in Aedes
Friedman, and J.G. Rodriguez (eds.) Current Topics aegypti: dependence on the quantity of blood and
in Insect Endocrinology and Nutrition. pp. 189- the interval between blood meals. Physiol. Entomol.
214. Plenum Press, New York. 3: 309-316.
Dadd, R.H. 1983. Essential fatty acids: Insects and Mercer, D.R. 1999. Effects of larval density on the size of
vertebrates compared. In: T.E. Mittler and R.H. Dadd Aedes polynesiensis adults (Diptera: Culicidae). J.
(eds) Metabolic Aspects of Lipid Nutrition in Med. Entomol. 36: 702-708.
Insects. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado. Nijhout, H.F. 1975. A threshold size for metamorphosis in
June, 2003 Journal of Vector Ecology 11
the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta (L.). Biol. Timmermann, S.E. and H. Briegel. 1999. Larval growth
Bull. 149: 214-225. and biosynthesis of reserves in mosquitoes. J.
Renshaw, M., J.B. Silver, and M.W. Service. 1995. Insect Physiol. 45: 461-470.
Differential lipid reserves influence host-seeking Van Handel, E. 1965. The obese mosquito. J. Physiol.
behaviour in the mosquitoes Aedes cantans and 181: 478-486.
Aedes punctor. Med. Vet. Entomol. 9: 381-387. Van Handel, E. and M.J. Klowden. 1996. Defecation by
Schmidt-Nielsen, K. 1984. Scaling: Why is animal size the mosquito, Aedes aegypti, is controlled by the
so important? Cambridge University Press, terminal abdominal ganglion. J. Insect Physiol. 42:
Cambridge, UK. 139-142.
Timmermann, S.E. and H. Briegel. 1993. Water depth and von Dungern, P. and H. Briegel. 2001a. Enzymatic analysis
larval density affect development and accumulation of uricotelic protein catabolism in the mosquito
of reserves in laboratory populations of mosquitoes. Aedes aegypti. J. Insect Physiol. 47: 73-82.
Bull. Soc. Vector Ecol. 18: 174-187. von Dungern, P. and H. Briegel. 2001b. Protein catabolism
Timmermann, S.E. and H. Briegel. 1996. Effect of plant, in mosquitoes: ureotely and uricotely in larval and
fungal, and animal diets on mosquito development. imaginal Aedes aegypti. J. Insect Physiol. 47: 131-
Entomol. Exp. Appl. 80: 173-176. 141.
Timmermann, S.E. and H. Briegel. 1998. Molting and Ziegler, R. and M.M. Ibrahim. 2001. Formation of lipid
metamorphosis in mosquito larvae: a morphometric reserves in fat body and eggs of the yellow fever
analysis. Mitt. Schweiz. Entomol. Ges. 71: 373-387. mosquito, Aedes aegypti. J. Insect Physiol. 47: 623-
627.