3 Urban Poor Living in Slums A Case Study PDF
3 Urban Poor Living in Slums A Case Study PDF
© 2013. Dr. Sribas Goswami & Prof. Samita Manna. This is a research/review paper, distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non-
commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Urban Poor Living in Slums: A Case Study of
Raipur City in India
Dr. Sribas Goswami α & Prof. Samita Manna σ
Abstract - The appearance of slums may be seen as a inadequate infrastructure and lacking in proper sanitary
byproduct in the process of urbanization in a developing and drinking water facilities. Living conditions in slums
Year 2013
country like India. Cities are a part of the fundamental have a direct impact on people’s health. One of the
changes in the society leading to socio-economic
major challenges that face urban planners globally is the
development and modernization. The cities, irrespective of
proliferation of slums in urban areas and the host of
their size, provide possibilities of varied occupations and
collective services, such as health, education, cultural, health hazards that they bring along with their wake.
technological, commercial or industrial services and thus act However, the prolific spread of slums has been a 20
21
15
as focal points of development opportunities. In spite of rampant problem in urban areas worldwide. The living
Raipur’s prominent role in the economy of the region, urban conditions in slums are usually unhygienic and contrary
A
industrial sources in the city has not shown any
slum is a compact area of overcrowded
appreciable decrease during the last few years. Increase
populations, poorly built congested dwelling
in pollution levels in slum areas is also fuelled by ever-
condition, unhygienic environment usually with
growing traffic.
Author α : Assistant Professor in Sociology, Serampore College, West The movement of large number of rural
Bengal, India. E-mail : sribasgoswami@gmail.com migrants to the urban areas has far reaching social
Author σ : Vice - Chancellor, Sidho Kanho Birsha University, Purulia,
West Bengal, India. E-mail : samita.manna@gmail.com implications in transforming the nature and character of
© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Urban Poor Living in Slums: A Case Study of Raipur City in India
urbanization in India. The migrants move into the city not reasons of growth of slums can broadly be summarized
only physically but also bring along their culture, style of namely-
life, values, etc. The new groups are trying to gain Land encroachment
access to the city’s socio-economic system, often by
Locational incompatibility
forming communities of their own, in competition with
the old groups of more educated, skilled and affluent Unplanned development
urban dwellers who create dichotomies and tensions. Unauthorized construction
The emerging urbanizing society is increasingly Temporary/semi-permanent structures
becoming a rural-urban environment, both as a way of Absence / inadequacy of basic amenities.
life and physical form. It must be understood that the The key question may be asked here is why do
rapidly expanding urban environment is not taking
Year 2013
environment deteriorates because of the crowding, and antipathy on the part of the government to assist
pollution, wealthy, and middle-class families, including them; high acceptable building standards and rules and
those who have fallen on hard times, hangs on to their regulations; loop sided planning and zoning legislation.
properties. “The root cause of urban slumming seems to
lie not in urban poverty but in urban wealth” (Verma, II. Objectives of Study
2002).
Raipur city and leading forces of development- The present study mainly focuses on the several
aspects of slum development in Raipur city. The main
City Population and Economic Changes thrust of this study is to examine various concerns of
• Urban population is increasing rapidly slums. The following objectives have been framed for
• Urban population soon numerically dominant the present study. These are follows:
• Urban economic activities driving national 1. To examine the demographic characteristics of slum
economics dwellers.
• Havoc changes in communication systems 2. To examine the nature and extent of slum and
factors responsible for growth.
Global Economic Factors
3. To evaluate the people’s participation in slum
• Globalization improvement programme.
• Market liberalization 4. To know the living conditions and infrastructural
• Rapid technological change facilities available in the slum areas.
• Localization 5. To study the health and nutrition level of slum
Global Political Factors dwellers.
6. To explore the level of general awareness among
• Decentralization
the residents of slums.
• Devolution
7. To see the various policy measures and
• Rise of Governance- moving beyond
programmes initiated by the government.
government
8. To review the environmental aspects of the city.
• Rise of municipal civic leadership
9. To identify the problems and constraints of slum
As aforesaid, slum settlements have been in development.
existence from a long time, in the sense that an
individual other than the land owner has built houses a) Selection of Slums
with or without the consent of the land owner. But they Raipur city has total 154 slums in which 135
were not illegal ‘slum’ settlements as we define and slums are declared formally by the government located
categorize them today. The term ‘slum’ is in fact a more in various places within the city boundary. Some of
recent western-initiated development. This delineation of these are situated in the heart of the city. It should be
such informal or spontaneous settlements as slum noted that out of 135 slums only few are densely
settlements represented a growing change in attitude populated whereas others are thinly populated. These
from outright hostility to that of support and protection. slums have 22777 dwelling units with total population 1,
Urbanization poses several socio-economic and 59,120. According to the demographic characteristic a
environmental problems for cities in India and one list is prepared on the basis of population size and the
among them is the rise of slums. In Raipur the following list is stratified accordingly with two phases namely East
and West phase. Two slums from each phase are taken encouraging that 92% people are literate. They can read
as sample covered with all the components are selected and write. In the present study it has been observed
for in-depth survey. During the process of selection of that 98% respondents are married and 2% respondents
these slums, following factors are taken into are widow. Present study also shows that 65.66%
consideration: (a) large population with diversified respondents are working or acting as money earner. But
characteristics: (b) they should have been covered with 34.34% respondents are not working because their
socio-economic programmes. It is found that large family member earns. 1.66% respondents’ monthly
slums are mostly situated in the East and the West part income is up to Rs.1000. But 28% respondents earn
of the city. So samples are taken from the highest money in between Rs.1001-Rs. 2000, 17.33%
populated slums from Eastern and Western phase of the respondents monthly income lie in between Rs.2001-Rs.
city as these four slums have greater opportunity to 5000, where as 19.66% earn more than Rs. 5000.
Year 2013
represent the slum community of Raipur as a whole. In
the east Gandhinagar and Moulipara both are big slums III. Findings from the Study: Some Facts
in terms of population and size and have 5782 and 4830 a) Environmental Aspects of Slums
population respectively. Both slums have 957 and 878 Environmental changes may be driven by many
numbers of families in each. From west part Kushalpur factors including economic growth, population growth, 20
21
17
and Kota Basti are highest populated slums which have urbanization, intensification of agriculture, rising energy
municipal or notified areas in either solid or semi-solid fish, wastes from slaughter houses, food packaging
form excluding industrial hazardous wastes but industries, cold storage units, community halls, religious
including treated bio-medical wastes. places, etc are the major source of industrial waste. The
city is having 400 educational institutions (schools,
a) Domestic Waste
colleges, etc.) and 420 hotels (restaurants, lodge and
Daily waste comes from 1,14,819 (2001
guest houses) and 500 hospitals (poly clinics,
Census) houses in Raipur city consisting of household
dispensaries, general hospitals, etc.).
waste, kitchen, house cleaning, old papers, packing,
bottles, crockery wares, furnishing materials, garden d) Street Sweeping
trimmings, etc. The city is having 970 km of road length. The
main sources of this waste are unconcerned throwing,
b) Trade & Commercial Waste
Year 2013
conditions, overcrowded environment, poor sanitation, auspicious occasion. Moreover, the practice of offering
occupational hazards, group rivalries and clashes, these items to guests or as gifts is prevalent among
stressful conditions together with lack of open space for Chhattisgarhi’s regardless of socio-economic status.
children’s recreation etc. are detrimental to the health of They are also routinely offered to various Hindu deities
people in the slums. An overview of women’s and and then consumed by the devotees on every religious
children’s health status presents a sobering picture. occasion. Rationing system in slums is not effective.
Deaths and illnesses are highest among poor women in
a) Several aspects of human development in slums
the world wide and among women in developing
For a very long time, economists have
countries particularly (Davis, 1962). In addition to the
measured well being of societies, economies and
suffering of women, yet another cause of concern is
people by the yardstick of income. Growth was
their almost apathetic attitude towards their own health
Year 2013
measured on the basis of economic indicators like per
and its management during illness. Women are found to
capita income, production and productivity of the
seek treatment only when their health problem caused
economy, and the status of employment. In effect, an
great physical discomfort or when it affects their work
economy that produced more goods and services than
performance. The situation with respect to women’s and
another was deemed to be better off. Growth was 20
21
19
children’s health in the urban slums is not different;
consequently measured by the increase of aggregate
rather their health is neglected the most. Insecurity
income in an economy. In the last few decades,
these dimensions of welfare are desirable in themselves; civil society. These meet social needs of the individual
hence, they are socially valued. They are also desirable against socially recognized conditions like infirmity,
because of their instrumental value in sustaining the unemployment, old age and poverty. These
development process and enlarging available programmes may be contributory or non-contributory in
opportunities and choices for people. While equality in nature. Urban poor are group of individuals who have
development outcomes may not be a feasible goal of constraints to opportunities and who are living in
equity and social justice, such an approach to human absolute or relative poverty in urban areas. Generally the
wellbeing emphasizes equality in opportunities for all in unorganized marginalized groups are socially
the process of development. This study demonstrates discriminated from organized counterparts which
that socio-economic development, emancipative cultural increase the gap of social security. These marginalized
change and democratization constitute a coherent get low wages; their wages are inadequate to meet their
Year 2013
syndrome of social progress – a syndrome whose families physiological, social and security needs if they
common focus has not been properly specified by are self-employed. Slum dwellers get entangled in the
classical modernization theory. Here this syndrome is vicious cycle of low education, low skills, high
specified as ‘human development’, arguing that its three exploitation web and they never get an opportunity to
2
20 components have a common focus on broadening upgrade their skills to secure better jobs in formal
human choice. Socio-economic development gives sector. They also move from one improvised area to
Global Journal of Human Social Science (C ) Volume XIII Issue IV Version I
people the objective means of choice by increasing urban slum with no consolidation of their working status
individual resources; rising emancipative values and virtually no increment in spite of long association
strengthen people’s subjective orientation towards with their employer. This further degrades their standard
choice; and democratization provides legal guarantees of living and makes them susceptible to immoral and
of choice by institutionalizing freedom rights. Analysis of illegal practices.
data from the World Values Surveys demonstrates that Although, Government organizations have
the linkage between individual resources, emancipative passed some acts on social security benefits like
values and freedom rights is universal in its presence ‘Minimum Wages Act’, ‘Maternity Benefit Act’, ‘Equal
across nations, regions and cultural zones. Remuneration Act’, ‘Building and Other Construction
Poor societies, whose citizens suffer from Workers Act’, ‘Workmen's Compensation Act’, and
inadequate resources most obviously in India, tend to ‘Contract Labour Act’, but they are partially implemented
be dominated by conformity values that reflect in totality because of ill-informed workers and lack of
constraints on human autonomy. These societies are awareness. The government has passed the
usually governed by authoritarian regimes. Even if they ‘Unorganized Workers Social Security Bill’ which
have a democratic constitution, such formal ensures security of the informal sector too, wherein it
democracies seldom operate effectively because highly covers ten social security schemes like pension,
corrupt elites deprive people of their rights (Heller 2000). maternity insurance, general insurance, welfare scheme
This chapter covers social security, occupational for artisans and weavers and health insurance. There is
mobility, provision for weaker section, participation in an eager need for unemployment insurance too, which
decision making process, social justice and cultural should also include retirement and old age pension and
development of slum dwellers. some other fringe benefits. Trade Unions in India have
Although, India is experiencing significant primarily represented the workers of organized sector
economic growth, the gap between the rich and the which comprise a merely eight percent of workforce. The
poor is still widening. No obvious benefit can be rest of them has labor regulations and are totally
observed for the poor and under privileged. One of the unprotected with no social security. In Raipur several
reasons identified is that the large population of the urban poverty alleviation programmes are under
underprivileged youth residing in urban slums implementation.
completely lack or have negligible vocational skills, Some Central Government sponsored Programmes are
which prevents them from taking advantage of the vast mentioned here.
employment opportunities in the cities of India. There is Swarna Jayanti Sahari Rozggar Yojna
a mismatch between the skilled manpower required and National Slum Development Programme
skilled manpower available. Every year, thousands of Balika Samrudhi Yojna
graduates are churned out but they do not have the Special Nutrition Programme
specific skill sets that are required by the market. If this Individual Latrines- Low Cost Sanitation Programme
trend persists, it will impact the economic growth of the VAMBAY
city in the long run. Some State Government sponsored Programmes
as follows:
b) Social security for urban poor
Rajiv Nagar Bata Programme
Social Security refers to social programmes that Urban Programme for Advancement of Household
provide set of benefits available from the government or Income
© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Urban Poor Living in Slums: A Case Study of Raipur City in India
Rajiv Yuva Sakthi all city residents and institutions to provide opportunities
Welfare Programme Sponsored by Women, SC, ST and viable solutions. It is a process of planning with the
Minorities and Other slum dwellers themselves.
Corporations
Slum problems are widespread and
Some Raipur Municipal Corporation sponsored Pro- multidimensional in nature; therefore they can be solved
grammes are mentioned here. by comprehensive programmes. Infrastructural
Indira Sahara Yojna development and civic amenities are required
Samajik Pension Yojna adequately. After bifurcation, Raipur’s formation as
Briddha Pension Yojna capital has brought qualitative and quantitative changes
Goswara among the slum dwellers. Environmental degradation is
Year 2013
general phenomenon in slum. Therefore, a system has
c) Amenities Stated for Urban Poor in 11th Five Year
to be evolved whereby the garbage from slums can be
Plan (Government of India).
collected from each household and placed in the
The Eleventh Plan recognizes slum dwellers,
nearest big garbage collection depots or transaction
most of who are employed in the informal sector, as
stations, and after that it can be cleaned by municipal 20
21
21
important contributors to cities’ economy. Even though
services. Improved hygienic conditions with increased
relocation of slums may sometimes be inevitable,
awareness on preventive social medicine can reduce