Symbiosis Institute of Business Management, Bengaluru: Strategic Analysis of Company
Symbiosis Institute of Business Management, Bengaluru: Strategic Analysis of Company
Symbiosis Institute of Business Management, Bengaluru: Strategic Analysis of Company
MANAGEMENT, BENGALURU
PREPARED BY:
Group 05 – Section:A
Neeraj Garg-19020841021
Nishtha Gupta- 19020841023
Riya Rai- 119020841026
Kshitij Anand– 19020841014
Puja Samanta-19020841024
Introduction to IndiGo Airline
• It is headquartered in Gurgaon, India’s largest airline in terms of passengers
flown with a market share of 47.5% as of November 2019.
• Estabhlished in early 2006 by Rahul Bhatia, founder of InterGlobe
Enterprises and Rakesh Gangwal, a United States-based NRI.
• InterGlobe holds a 51.12% stake in IndiGo, and 48% is by Gangwal's
company Caelum Investments.
• Started its operations on 4th August 2006 with a service from New Delhi to
Imphal via Guwahati.
• IndiGo has a fleet of 257 planes and offers 1500 domestic flights per day
• Three Pillars:
1. offering low fares,
2. being on-time and
3. delivering a courteous and hassle-free experience
Market Share(2019)
Vistara, 4.80%
Indigo, 46.80%
90.00%
85.00%
80.00%
75.00%
Spicejet Indigo Vistara Air India Go Air
FACTS and FIGURES about INDIGO
IndiGo has
become
synonymous with
being on-time.
Vision Statement
To be India’s largest & fastest growing airline through 3 things:
• Affordable Fares
• On-time performance
• Hassle-free travel experience
There is enormous potential for the airline industry, in a country like India
where only a single-digit percentage of the 1.3 billion-strong population
flies, and where more and more people are taking to the skies amid rising
incomes and the sector's expansion. India’s aviation market is
continuously growing and expected to become the third-largest in the
world by 2025. The country has had the world's fastest-growing domestic
aviation market for the past three years, according to the industry body. It
forecasts that air passenger numbers to, from and within India will more
than triple over the next 20 years to more than 500 million passenger
journeys a year.
PESTEL ANALYSIS
• Political /Legal Factors
✓ The government has opened up the Indian skies by allowing up to 49% FDI in Domestic
Airlines, which is expected to give an impetus to the sector, which is reeling under
immense cost side pressures.
✓ Government allowing the direct import of ATF is another move in the right direction
to decrease the operating costs
✓ Micro-managing by the government is seen as an excellent negative for the industry as
the airlines are not given enough freedom to run their operations
✓ The slow growth of airport infrastructure because of government impasse
✓ Lack of government initiatives stalling the growth of the sector.
✓ Overall the government is slowly waking up to the issues plaguing the sector and is
taking few steps to improve the health of the industry, Indigo which is the market leader
in the LCC segment, stands to be benefitted the most.
• Economic factor
✓ The slowdown of the economy is a huge negative for the industry as the capacity is
getting underutilized and the companies are being forced to reduce the ticket prices to
reduce the capacity wastage
✓ Consistently high oil prices, along with high taxes, contribute significantly to the
operational costs.
✓ The depreciating value of rupee is adding to costs as a substantial portion of other
operating expenses like lease rentals, maintenance, ex-pat salaries and a part of sales
commissions are USD-linked or USD-denominated
✓ The industry operates under the high cost of capital, which again adds to the operational
costs, but the positive side for indigo airlines is that it is in a far better position
financially than the competition, which helps it to raise capital comparatively at a lower
cost.
• Social factors
✓ Changes in the travel habits of people have far-reaching implications in the airline
industry. The airlines have to recognize individuals from varied income groups and
should serve them accordingly, especially in a country like India.
✓ India being a land of extremes and having population belonging to different cultures
and traditions; airline need to choose the destinations, food offerings, etc. keeping in
mind their tastes and preferences
✓ With the income levels rising in the Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities, there is a demand being
generated for air connectivity in these cities also.
• Technological factors
✓ The airline industry is in the process of adopting a new standard for distributing airfare
information which the IATA has termed as NDS which stands for New Distribution
Capability which will help the airlines to tailor the services to each customer and will
add value to both the airline as well as the customer
✓ Growth of Electronic ticketing satellite-based navigation systems
✓ Leveraging technology has made check-in times to reduce which has contributed to
efficiency improvements for the airlines
✓ The AAI has been developing modern communication, navigation, surveillance, and air
traffic management systems for improving India's aviation sector, which will help the
country meet the expected growth and increasing demands for air passenger and cargo
services over the next decade.
• Environmental
✓ With air traffic growing, ecological concerns are also gaining growing importance.
More technological and operational improvements are necessary to outweigh the
impact of traffic growth to reduce the environmental footprints of the aerospace
industry.
✓ The two main environmental issues associated with aviation are noise and emissions.
Within emissions, the distinction is to be made between local air quality and climate
change.
✓ Noise: The significant sources of aircraft noise are the aircraft’s engines and,
particularly during the approach, airframe noise when the aircraft’s flaps/slats are fully
extended and the landing gear is deployed. Air traffic movements have significantly
increased and will continue to grow; as a result, aircraft noise continues to have a very
significant environmental impact around airports and be a source of disturbance to the
public. Many airports have implemented noise-related charging schemes, night time
restrictions or even night curfews. The number of airports affected in this way will
likely increase further during the next decade.
✓ Local air quality: Air pollutants such as Nitrogen Oxides (NO2 and NO) and
particulate matter (PM); have been identified as key contributors from air transport to
the problems of local air quality. Exposure to particulate matter can lead to impacts
ranging from minor effects on the respiratory system to premature mortality. It is,
therefore, likely that air quality will be a significant feature in the debate concerning
additional runway capacity.
✓ Alternative Fuels: Alternative fuels should become a significant driver in reaching the
objective of carbon-neutral growth for aviation. Drop-in biofuels have been
successfully tested and are already in use on specific commercial routes. The industry
is aiming at replacing 6% of current fossil fuel with biofuel by 2020. Beyond the
complex issue of life cycle assessment, the major challenge will be to ensure that
biofuels are supplied reliably and cost-effectively to air operators.
✓ Land acquisition has become one of the pressing issues plaguing the industry because
it is stalling the building of new infrastructure which is the need of the hour
✓ Future objectives: The ultimate aim for the sector must be sustainable development,
where the environment is not sacrificed for growth and future generations will be able
to continue to benefit from air travel. The aviation industry has already started to tackle
this formidable task, but continued and imaginative effort is required to ensure the
sector maximizes the use of its "environmental capacity."
2 Great Europe
Britain
3 Norway Europe
4 USA USA
9 Ireland Europe
10 Germany Europe
A codeshare agreement enables two airlines to sell seats on each other’s' flights
to provide passengers with a more excellent choice of destinations.
• Connecting flights: This will provide clearer routing for the customer,
allowing a customer to book travel from a point in India to Europe through
Istanbul under one carrier's code, instead of a customer booking from India
to Istanbul under one code, and from Istanbul to Europe under another code.
• This also helps the cooperating airlines in synchronizing their schedules.
Advantage for Indigo
• This will help Indigo in getting access to European markets. It can tap in
passengers who choose to fly from Istanbul to Europe and from Qatar to
other parts of the middle east.
• This will help Indigo in driving down the operational costs.
To tap the booming aviation market in China, Indigo opened its first
international call to Guangzhou in China to cater to queries from people who
speak in Cantonese, Mandarin and English.
6. Improving market share in cargo
Indigo wants to strengthen its market share in cargo, which is at nearly 34%
in the domestic market at the moment. IndiGo has set itself a target of
enhancing it to match its passenger market share.
There is a duopoly of two significant suppliers of aircraft, i.e., Airbus and Boeing.
• IndiGo comprises of Airbus-A320, and as suppliers are limited, the switching cost
is high.
• The shortage of commercial aircraft pilots in India makes the supply of pilots
limited, hence increasing their power.
• There are only four suppliers for ATF (Aviation Turbine Fuel) - IOC, Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation, Bharat Petroleum, and ONGC, and they possess more
power since their number is limited.
• The higher bargaining power of suppliers results from high brand value.
3. Bargaining Power of Buyers (HIGH)
• Buyers lack in power since they are large in number and highly fragmented.
• Furthermore, the players in a particular strategic group have minimalistic
differentiating points.
4. Competitive Rivalry (HIGH)
It is difficult to earn high returns in this sector as the aviation industry is a highly
competitiveindustry. Below are themajor reasons forthehigh competition:
▪ Very little scope for differentiation between competitors’ products and
services – closest competitors are Spice Jet, Go Air.
▪ Mature Industry with very little growth
▪ No brand loyalty demonstrated by customers
▪ Significant exit barriers
• RARE: Owing to the low fare tickets it offers to the customers, IndiGo
has achieved the highest market share in the Indian domestic Airline
industry. The small average fleet age and a single type of aircraft is a
rarity in the Indian Airline Industry.
• IMITABILITY: Many strategies used by IndiGo like less turnaround time
and using a single type of Aircraft are imitable. Thus, in the long run,
these differentiators will not be very useful for indigo.
• ORGANIZATION: IndiGo has created a brand name in the Indian
Airline Industry by offering brand value through unique value proposition
and strategic initiatives in just 10years of its inception.
• Good Employee Relationship is a crucial factor in sustaining a
competitive advantage. During times of slow revenue generation, other
airlines have resorted to laying off their employees. However, IndiGo has
taken a positive approach while dealing with its loyal employees at the
time of economic slowdown.
SWOT
ST WT
1)Effective incentive programs to prevent 1)Create a tie-up with other LCC players
talent drain like Air Asia for the Indian customer base
2)Sign anti-poaching agreement with to provide last mile connectivity
competitors 2)Offer business class seats, continue
3)Continue to successfully hedge fuel innovation of value added services while
prices by importing. focusing on cost optimization
Operations
Functional
Level
Strategies
Marketing Finance
A) Operations
• A single type of aircraft: Indigo’s fleet consists of A-320-232
aircraft. It results in much more flexibility as the use of the same
crew from pilots to flight attendants to the ground force helps in
cutting on training and up-gradation costs.
• Single Class: There will not be any extra expenditure and crew for
privileged passengers, and expensive lounges at airports won’t be
required.
• Low average fleet age: Fewer maintenance costs as Indigo has an
average fleet age of fewer than three years.
• Fuel: Indigo’s aircraft try to save fuel by using software to optimize
flight planning for minimum fuel-burning routes and altitudes.
• Route Planning: Indigo operates over a fewer number of
destinations but with a higher frequency. It means Indigo can keep
its aircraft in the air for a more extended period and save up on
airport charges and customers don't have to look for connecting
flights.
• Tightly framed Maintenance Contracts: IndiGo has a Power by
the Hour contract with International Aero Engines (IAE), which
provides the engines that put the onus of performance delivery on
the manufacturer. IndiGo has similar agreements with Airbus, as
well as with the vendors for other critical components. These
contracts probably come at a premium, but it means that IndiGo
does not have to pull out planes from service for repairs and also
does not have to maintain a large inventory of spares.
B) Marketing
• Low expenditure on advertising.
• Word of mouth.
• The market share is 30%, and the highest passenger load factor of
close to 90% compared to 77% of JetLite and 81% of Spice Jet.
This means better revenue for Indigo comparatively.
C) Financial Aspects
• Indigo has gone on record to tell that the company has practically
no debt.
STRATEGIC MODELS
Core strategies for cost reduction:
• Fuel-efficient aircraft
• New technologies and biofuel to reduce emissions
• Installing winglets to decrease drag and fuel use
• Removing excess weight
• Limit the airplane idling times
The top 3 Costs for any Airlines accumulate due to:
a) Fuel
It is one of the highest operating costs for airlines. With the
understanding that fuel prices won’t drop in the future, the airlines
can sign a contract to buy it for a period at the current rate. Hence
fuel hedging can be used to manage the operating costs.
b) More seats
The LCCs can charge less for their positions, and thus increase
revenue by increasing the number of passengers. E.g., Boeing
B737-400 aircraft can carry 168 passengers.
c) Labour and maintenance cost
The decision of maintenance by their staff and appointing full-
time labour for minimal jobs should be subjected to the criterion
test periodically to validate the continuation of the practice to enter
the alliance of services.
Strategy analysis
The strategy of positioning has been chosen as a cost leader for analysis
purposes in the LCC segment in the domestic carrier market in India. It is
assumed and perceived that the secondary strategy of reducing fuel costs
and lowering labour/maintenance costs are to be achieved.
Framing of options:
• Fuel hedging for 75% of total fuel consumption and
• Outsourcing maintenance and labour at ten least profitable destinations
will stir IndiGo Airlines to be the Cost leader in the LCC segment in
India.
Core assumptions:
Core assumptions in these strategic options are as follows:
• Fuel hedging will lead to substantial price stability and lessen fuel costs.
• Outsourcing maintenance and labour at less profitable destinations will
streamline operations and enhance profitability.
A. Value test- Since the crude prices are a low historical value, it is
recommended that entering a long-term fuel contract may help offer
a competitive advantage to this airline. Through an ABC analysis
of total destinations of IndiGo, ten destinations have been identified
and they are at the bottom in the performance chart. Hence
operations at these destinations need to be out-sourced which will
help to reduce the cost of services. Thus this strategy passes the
value test.
B. Execution Test. Individual professional Hedging companies in
India offer services at a decent price. These fuel contracts offered
by these various fuel companies are of International standard and
their execution is very feasible in India. The legal framework in
India helps to elaborate agreements relating to outsourcing and
sharing the workforce for sundry jobs. It is observed that the
proposed hypothesis passes the execution test as well.
C. Scalability Test. Fuel hedging can be scaled on a yearly basis. But
these days quarterly fuel hedging contracts are also available. The
scaling of out-sourcing maintenance and other non-core functions
situation is very helpful. This strategy is scalable.
D. Defensible test. The process of fuel hedging and outsourcing is not
innovative, but the way it is implemented can be marked as
differentiation for the Airlines. To finalize hedging contracts and
review performance, top-notch consultants are to be hired.
Operations analytics can be used to get the best solution for the non-
core activities at an unsustainable destination. For a good strategy,
the confidentiality of techniques and tools of analytics and selection
with proper evaluation criteria for continuation with the hedging
contract firm is maintained.
CONCLUSION
It was found that most of the passengers are more price-conscious than
quality conscious. The combination of operational performance and
financial engineering has amplified Indigo’s valuation.
Based on the parameters of cost, punctuality, baggage handling, query
handling, Speed of Service Offered, and Less Cancellation by The
Airlines, passengers perceive Indigo as the best Low-cost Airline.
However, throughout the research, it was seen that the Spice jet is in close
competition with the leading carrier Indigo with other Airlines following.
It was also found that although low-cost airline passengers have a highly
favorable perception of low-cost airlines, the highly price-sensitive and
would readily switch to a full-service carrier as it offers a lower fare.
In conjunction with the above findings, the frequency of flights in Indigo
Airlines to a particular destination was the least due to which passengers
were not able to travel from Indigo. However, in terms of least waiting
time to check-in, passengers chose IndiGo as most effective as compared
to other airlines. The primary factors that can attract more people are
effective operations, efficient service, and the brand name.
Secondly, the performance of Indigo airlines with their competitors and
derive lessons to be learnt. It was found that Indigo used six-year sale
and leaseback agreements, so the airline is continuously replacing its
aircraft, preventing the need for overall checks and significant repairs.
Indigo’s on-time performance, with providing consistently low fares and
Courteous and Hassle-free travel, are the reasons for its immense
success. It focused on inorganic expansion by adding a plane every six
weeks with a turnaround time of fewer than 30 minutes. Hence, it can be
concluded that Indigo has the leanest workforce with the staff trained in
every aspect of customer experience at their fly learning and
development Centre. Employees are recognized as Individuals in Indigo
Airlines with the majority of implementation of suggestions given by
them to Indigo Airlines. This is beneficial to both employees as well as
Indigo.
STRATEGIC RECOMMENDATIONS:
• Increase number of destinations served
• Offer low-priced corporate travel packages
• Introduce air cargo service
• Offer flights to unserved destinations through a tie-up with FSC
• value-seeking Segment prefers booking hotels/cabs with flight
tickets so Cross-sell ibis-InterGlobe Hotels (Group synergy)
• Most travelers buy beverages & light snacks at the airport-Price is
a significant deterrent. Tie-up with shops for a discount for IndiGo
customers.
• Booking cabs after flight adds to hassle. Pre-paid cab booking at
destination available before even boarding the flight-cuts down
the hassle.
References
https://www.goindigo.in/
http://blueoceanuniversity.com/frontpage/portercase/17750-indigo-
aviation
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/tourism/analysis-of-budget-airline-
company- indigo-airlines-tourism-essay.php
http://www.academia.edu/23579703/Competition_and_Strategy_Indigo_A
irlines https://www.scribd.com/document/322221744/IndiGo-
Airline-Strategy- Presentation-by-Suddhwasattwa-Mukherjee
https://www.marketing91.com/marketing-strategy-of-indigo-
airlines/
https://cio.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/strategy-and-
management/how-technology-became-indigos-passport-to-
profitability/63104457
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/transportation/airlines-
/- aviation/rivals-allege-indigo-of-using-its-strength-to-squeeze-
them- out/articleshow/66423453.cms
http://tarunguptaspeaks.blogspot.com/2014/10/business-strategies-
making- difference.html
https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-strategies-used-by-Indigo
https://dlscrib.com/download/indigo_58f3259cdc0d606074da983e_pdf
http://www.academia.edu/23579703/Competition_and_Strategy_Indigo_Airlines
https://www.academia.edu/32387451/SUCCESS_STORY_OF_INDIGO_AIRL
INES_A
_CASE_STUDY