Glass and Ceramics Conservation 2010

Interim Meeting of the ICOM-CC Working Group

October 3–6, 2010
Corning, New York

Hannelore Roemich, Editorial Coordinator

ICOM Committee for Conservation

in association with The Corning Museum of Glass
 © 2010 ICOM Committee for Conservation

ICOM-CC Glass and Ceramics Working Group Committee:

Gerhard Eggert
President
Hannelore Roemich
Editorial Coordinator

Review Panel for Papers

Renske Dooijes, Leiden
Gerhard Eggert, Stuttgart
Agnès Gall-Ortlik, Barcelona
Isabelle Garachon, Amsterdam
Stephen P. Koob, Corning
Laurianne Robinet, Gif-sur-Yvette (France)
Kate van Lookeren Campagne, Amsterdam

For The Corning Museum of Glass:

Editor: Richard W. Price
Design and Typography: Jacolyn S. Saunders
Editorial Adviser: David Whitehouse
Proofreader: Monica S. Rumsey
Reference Librarian: Gail P. Bardhan

ISBN: 978-0-87290-182-7
Library of Congress Control Number: 2010931220

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced,

stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any
means, whether electronic or mechanical, including photocopying,
recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission in writing of
the publisher.

Cover Image:
[FILL-IN]
Contents
10 Introduction

History, Technology, and Training

15 Recording Oral Memories in Fire Arts Conservation
Agnès Gall-Ortlik and Pau Maynés

22 From Mender to Restorer: Some Aspects of the History of Ceramic Repair

Isabelle Garachon

32 What Color Has Saffron? Understanding German Recipes for the Production
of Colored Glazes in the 16th Century
Helena Fuertes and Christoph Krekel

41 Training of Ceramics and Glass Conservation Specialists at the Russian

State University for the Humanities
Ekaterina Sharkova and Ekaterina Stolyarova

Special Collections
53 Deterioration and Preservation of Blaschka Glasses
Astrid van Giffen, Katherine Eremin, Susanna Kirk, Jim Tate, and Richard Newman

63 Classification and Preservation of Ancient Glass Beads from Ile-Ife,

Southwestern Nigeria
O. Akin Ige

75 The Museum of Ancient Glass in Zadar (Croatia)

Šime Perović

82 The Production of Pottery Vessels from Peqi’in

Elisheva Kamaisky

Treatments
93 Reattaching Paper Labels to Ceramics and Glass
Juanita Navarro

100 An Assessment of Polymers Used in Conservation Treatments

at The Corning Museum of Glass
Norman H. Tennent and Stephen P. Koob

110 18 Tons of Roman Glass under the Sea: A Complex Conservation Puzzle
Paul Mardikian and Pascale Girard
119 In Situ Mosaic Preservation of Three Glass and Marble Opus Sectile Panels
at the Roman Villa of Faragola (Ascoli Satriano, Italy)
Maria Concetta Laurenti, Elisabeth Huber, and Antonella Martinelli

128 An Experimental Treatment for Severely Crizzled Glasses

Stephen P. Koob

Science and Technology

137 Archaeological Glass: The Surface and Beyond
Paul Bellendorf , Hannelore Roemich, Sandra Gerlach, Peter Mottner,
Esmeralda López, and Katrin Wittstadt

145 Characterization of Japanese Raku Ceramics Using XRF and FTIR

Raina Chao, Blythe McCarthy, and Gail Yano

156 Mercury Emissions from Historical Tin Amalgam Mirrors

Manfred Torge, Sonja Krug, Michael Buecker, Ines Feldmann, Holger Scharf,
Heike Witthuhn, Christoph Sander, and Kerstin Fraenkler-Balhorn

164 Composition, Stability, and Storage of Imperial Qing-Dynasty Glass

Abigail Hykin, Katherine Eremin, Michele Derrick, Richard Newman, Hao Sheng ,
Kimberley Simpson, and Sarah Fearn

174 When Glass and Metal Corrode Together, II: A Black Forest Schäppel
and Further Occurrences of Socoformacite
Gerhard Eggert, Anne Bührer, Bruno Barbier, and Harald Euler

Architectural Glass, Ceramic Tiles, and Terra Cotta

185 Keeping Out the Wind: Repair and Restoration History in Stained Glass Windows
Diane Roberts Rousseau

194 The Use of Glass Bricks in Architecture in the 19th and 20th Centuries: A Case Study
K. De Vis, P. Jacobs, J. Caen, and K. Janssens

202 An Investigation and Assessment of Tile-Work on Nila Gumbad

Maninder S. Gill

210 Italian Renaissance Polychrome Terra-Cotta Sculpture

in the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum
Jessica Chloros, Valentine Talland, Holly Salmon, and Craig Uram

219 Hatching a Theory of Attribution: A 15th-Century Madonna and Child

at the National Gallery of Art
Simona Cristanetti

229 Posters
The papers in this publication
are dedicated to
Dr. Robert H. Brill
Research Scientist Emeritus
The Corning Museum of Glass
 Dr. Robert H. Brill. (Photo: Frank J. Borkowski)

8 interim meeting of the icom-cc working group

Dr. Robert H. Brill is research scientist emeritus at The program at Cooperstown, Oberlin College, The Henry
Corning Museum of Glass, an institution with which he Francis du Pont Winterthur Museum, and the Fogg Mu-
has been affiliated for 50 years. seum.
He earned a B.S. in chemistry from Upsala College in Dr. Brill’s research and advances in the scientific analy-
East Orange, New Jersey, and a Ph.D. in physical chem­ sis of glass have resulted in several major awards. In 2004,
istry from Rutgers University in New Brunswick, New he received the William E. S. Turner Award for contri­
Jersey. He was an associate professor of chemistry at Up- butions to the work of the Technical Committees of the
sala College for six years before he joined the Corning International Commission on Glass. He was the found-
Museum in 1960 as administrator of the Scientific Re- ing chairman of the Commission’s Technical Committee
search Department. on the Archaeometry of Glass (TC-17) in 1982, and he
From 1972 to 1975, he served as the museum’s direc- was chairman until 2004. He continues to serve as vice
tor, and he supervised its extensive recovery efforts fol- chairman.
lowing a devastating flood in 1972. The 11th annual Pomerance Award for Scientific Con-
Dr. Brill is the author of more than 150 publications on tributions to Archaeology was awarded to Dr. Brill in
the scientific investigation of early glasses and related ma- 1990. It is one of the two highest honors of the Archaeo-
terials, and on conservation studies. The most significant logical Institute of America. The award stated: “Robert H.
of these publications is Chemical Analyses of Early Glasses, Brill has spent an enviable life as a productive scientist
the first two volumes of which appeared in 1999. These and administrator. He has been a pioneer in the appli­
books detail Dr. Brill’s chemical analyses of some 3,600 cation of many scientific techniques to the study and un-
examples of historical glasses. Volume 1 presents a catalog derstanding of artifacts and the technologies behind their
of the samples, volume 2 consists of tables of analyses, and manufacture. His research, his field projects, his lectures,
volume 3 will contain site reports and essays interpreting and his impact have extended throughout Europe, the
the data. Most of the glasses are fragments from archae­ Middle East, Africa, Central Asia, and the Far East.” Among
ological excavations, although some are from objects in Dr. Brill’s accomplishments, the award noted his use of
museum collections. These samples, which date from be- lead-isotope analysis to determine the provenance of an-
tween 1500 B.C. and A.D. 1800, were provided by institu­ cient glass, his production of a 30-minute film document-
tions in more than 40 countries. They come from Egypt ing a one-room glass factory in Afghanistan, and his re-
and Mesopotamia, the Roman and Islamic worlds, Eu- search on the origin and development of Chinese glass.
rope, and the Americas. There are also large groups of In 1987, Dr. Brill received the American Chemical
medieval stained glass windows and Asian glasses, as well Society’s Eugene C. Sullivan Award. As a Distinguished
as raw materials of the kind used in antiquity. Scholar sponsored by the Committee on Scholarly Com-
Dr. Brill was a founding member of the American Insti­ munication with the People’s Republic of China, he lec-
tute for Conservation, and he is a member of numerous tured in China in 1982, 1984, 1990, and 1995.
scientific and archaeological organizations. During the
25th annual meeting of the Association of North Ameri-
can Graduate Programs in the Conservation of Cultural
Property in 1999, he received a certificate of apprecia­-
tion for convening the first such meeting of faculty and
students from graduate programs in conservation. That
meeting, titled “Conservation Seminar on Glass and Li-
brary Materials,” was held in November 1974 at the Cor-
ning Museum, and it was attended by 70 students from
New York University, the State University of New York

glass and ceramics conservation 2010 9

Introduction

What a wonderful meeting we had in Slovenia in 2007! of glass conservators. It was written by Stephen P. Koob,
It left lasting memories of the unmatched hospitality of the Corning Museum’s chief conservator, and it presents
Jana Šubic Prislan from the Goriški Muzej Kromberk in invaluable hints and tips that are based on his decades of
Nova Gorica and all of her colleagues in the country. All experience with the subject. In our continuing search for
participants remember the three exciting days with pre- more stable conservation materials, such as glass and ce-
sentations of current conservation projects and research, ramic adhesives, all of us are following his tested route.
excursions to other places in the vibrant cultural melting Meeting both of these outstanding scholars and prac­
pot of Slovenia, the tour to Murano, and the, h’m, let’s say titioners in the lectures and social activities in Corning
avant-garde venue of a hotel casino. Last but not least, be- will be a highlight for all participants. More information
cause of Lisa Pilosi’s tireless efforts, a well-edited and on both of them will be found in the paper by Agnès Gall-
-produced preprints volume1 made the content of the Ortlik and Pau Maynés on pages 15–21 of this volume.
con­ference available also to all those in the conservation Because of the considerable interest in the interim
community who could not make it to Slovenia, as well as meeting displayed by our colleagues in the working group
to future generations. and beyond, as well as the submission of papers, the 2010
As always, success raises expectations. Our working meeting will cover all aspects of glass and ceramics con-
group2 was delighted, at its meeting during the ICOM-CC servation (as will be seen in the table of contents). Indi-
triennial conference in New Delhi in 2008, to receive the vidual sessions will be devoted to history, technology, and
invitation of The Corning Museum of Glass to host the training; special collections; treatments; science and tech-
group’s next interim meeting in 2010. The museum, with nology; and architectural glass, ceramic tiles, and terra
its internationally renowned collection and its special ex- cotta. The contributions will lead us all around the world,
hibitions, will be the ideal locale for our international con- affording our somewhat Eurocentric group (most of our
ference “Glass and Ceramics Conservation 2010.” And it members are Europeans) a truly international perspective.
is not just the institution that is the attraction here. The All of the papers were selected and reviewed by members
Corning Museum has several highly regarded experts in its of the program committee, led by our editorial coordi­
ranks, and two of them are of particular significance to us: nator, Hannelore Roemich of New York City. The other
•  What glass conservator will not have come across the members of the committee are Stephen P. Koob of Cor-
papers of Dr. Robert H. Brill on crizzling? When trying to ning and Gerhard Eggert of Stuttgart, along with assistant
make sense of a glass analysis, who will not make compar-
isons with the data found in the (so far) two volumes of
his Chemical Analyses of Early Glasses (Corning: The Cor-
ning Museum of Glass, 1999), the scholarly achievement
of a lifetime and an indispensable reference work? It is in 1. Glass and Ceramics Conservation 2007, preprints of the interim
gratitude for these publications and for other contribu- meet­ing of the ICOM-CC Working Group, Nova Gorica, Slovenia, Au-
gust 27–30, 2007, ed. Lisa Pilosi, Nova Gorica: Goriški Muzej Kromberk,
tions by Dr. Brill, research scientist emeritus at the Cor- 2007.
ning Museum, that we dedicate this volume to him. 2. Glass and Ceramics is one of the working groups (WG) of the Com-
•  Conservation and Care of Glass Objects (London: Ar- mittee for Conservation (CC) of the International Council of Museums
(ICOM). Its members are interested conservators, conservation scien-
chetype Publications in association with The Corning Mu- tists, and curators. More information about the working group will be
seum of Glass, 2006) is an essential book in the education found on our Web site, www.icom-cc.org.

10 introduction
coordinators Kate van Lookeren Campagne of Amster- to achieve this goal is through “improved communication
dam, Agnès Gall-Ortlik of Barcelona, Laurianne Robinet between experts . . . on current conservation research,
of Gif-sur-Yvette (France), Renske Dooijes of Leiden, and practice, and education.” We hope that “Glass and Ceram-
Isabelle Garachon of Amsterdam. ics Conservation 2010” and this volume of preprints will
We also thank the staff members of The Corning Mu- be milestones in this pursuit!
seum of Glass who made this publication possible: Rich-
ard W. Price, head of the Publications Department, who
edited the papers; Jacolyn S. Saunders, publications spe- Hannelore Roemich
cialist, who designed the volume and prepared the layouts Institute of Fine Arts, New York University
of the papers; and Dr. David Whitehouse, the museum’s Editorial Coordinator
executive director, who served as editorial adviser.
In its triennial program of 2008–2011, the ICOM-CC Gerhard Eggert
Glass and Ceramics Working Group aims to foster the State Academy of Art and Design Stuttgart
conservation of the world’s cultural heritage made of glass, Coordinator, ICOM-CC Glass
ceramics, and related materials. We believe that the way and Ceramics Working Group

Editor’s Note: In the bylines of papers and posters with more than
one author, the name of the corresponding author is followed by
an asterisk, and that author’s e-mail address appears at the end of
the byline.

introduction 11