Feminism in Streetcar Named Desire
Feminism in Streetcar Named Desire
Feminism in Streetcar Named Desire
com
ABSTRACT
Objectification theory, sexual objectification of women, and female self-objectification are new
trends in gender studies. When a woman is observed only through her body parts, i.e. as an instrument,
she is believed to be sexually objectified. Likewise, when a woman exploits her sexuality, either
through wearing revealing clothing or displaying lustful behavior, she is engaged in self-
objectification. This paper focuses its attention on the female characters in Tennessee Williams’ A
Streetcar Named Desire based on the female objectification theory. It examines Blanche’s past and
present behavior and argues that Blanche has undergone sexual objectification and consequently self-
objectification. She unconsciously suffers from psychological repercussions resulting from her
objectification, namely, her drinking problem and her immersion in a false sense of reality.
Furthermore, this paper narrows its scope of analysis down to Stanley’s character as an agent of
violence and women subordination and examines his relationship with women objectification.
1. INTRODUCTION
-230-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
2. DISCUSSION
-231-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
is jealous of her sister’s married life and cannot relate to her. Thus she becomes maladjusted
through the experience of living with Stella, herself a maladjusted person. Gulshan Rai
Kataria attributes Blanche’s loneliness to be “the beginning of her search for distraction in
eros, the opposite of thanatos” (as cited in Bloom, 2009, p. 23). Williams (1947) gives her
account thus:
Williams’s comparing Blanche to a moth symbolically accounts for her fragility and
purity. Nonetheless, her clothing or her long baths serve as a disguise for her shameful past.
Her preoccupation with her physical appearance makes her an object of desire for men as well
as women. “Now, then, let me look at you. But don't you look at me, Stella, no, no, no, not till
later, not till I've bathed and rested! And turn that over-light off! Turn that off! I won't be
looked at in this merciless glare!” (p. 16). In opposition to Blanche is her younger sister,
Stella. She is described as “a gentle young woman, about twenty-five, and of a background
obviously quite different from her husband's” (p. 10). She is from the same aristocratic
heritage as Blanche; however, she left Mississippi when she was a teen and married the
lower-class Stanley. Blanche’s wild sexuality is balanced against the healthy mild sexuality of
Stella. Stella subordinates herself to Stanley’s way of life although she is superior to him in
background. It is difficult for Blanche to fathom out how her sister can put up with her
husband and when she asks Stella about it, she responds "there are things that happen between
a man and a woman in the dark- that sort of make everything else seem-unimportant" (p. 7).
One of those ‘things’ Stella alludes to, is having sex or a sexual partner. In other words,
sexuality is the main reason for Stella’s tolerating her domineering husband. From Susan C.
W. Abbotson’s (2005) viewpoint, Stella’s allowing Blanche to be taken to the asylum at the
close of the play is to prevent her marital relationship from falling apart and therefore she
chooses ignorance over truth.
The most common type of objectification is female self-objectification or what Kroon
& Perez (2013) define as “regular exposure to objectifying experiences that socialize girls and
women to engage in self-objectification” (p. 16). When a woman objectifies herself, she
observes herself as an object or a set of body parts. Blanche objectifies herself through her
obsession in her baths, and physical appearance. An example of self-objectification is
observed through her encounter with Stanly: “Hello, Stanley! Here I am, all freshly bathed
and scented, and feeling like a brand new human being!” (p. 38).
In another scene, when Blanche and Mitch discuss what happened between them the
other night, Blanche says “I liked the kiss very much. It was the other little familiarity that I
felt obliged to discourage... I didn't resent it! Not a bit in the world! In fact, I was somewhat
flattered that you desired me!” (p. 98). Here, Blanche clearly sees herself as an object to be
desired and it is a sign of her self-objectification.
-232-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
STELLA: It's a drive that he has. You're standing in the light, Blanche!
BLANCHE: Oh, am I!
[She moves out of the yellow streak of light. Stella has removed her dress and
put on a light blue satin kimona.] (p. 54)
Most of the consequences that are associated with self-objectification are related to the
mental aspect of this issue. Not surprisingly, this problem may have some effects on the body
as well, since it is the body on which they put the most pressure and this masquerade of
feelings are veiled by the mask of their physique. On one hand, women strive to hide their
feeling of hopelessness and dejection by the male gaze behind their appearance, and on the
other hand, they tend to evade any social encounter which might endanger their new made
outward identity. In fact, these effects are the result of some efforts done by women to
alleviate the impact of the distress they experience in their social encounters. An example is
observed in Stanley’s behavior toward Blanche who both stares at her and harasses her
mentally and physically.
MITCH: Why did you try if you didn't feel like it, Blanche?
BLANCHE: I was just obeying the law of nature.
MITCH: Which law is that?
BLANCHE: The one that says the lady must entertain the gentleman--or no
dice! (p. 97)
This example vividly presents the idea that Blanche naturally believes in her
objectification as if her role is to “entertain the gentleman.” Accordingly, men as the
dominant force in such societies tend to keep things in accordance with what may be in
service of their benefits and therefore they are “conditioned to find women’s subordination
sexy, and women have been conditioned to find a particular male version of female sexuality
as erotic — one in which they are defined from a male point of view” (MacKinnon, 1989, p.
140). This claim is bolstered when Blanche irritates Stanley fishing for a compliment about
her looks:
Stanley: Compliments to women about their looks. I never met a woman that
didn't know if she was good-looking or not without being told, and some of
them give themselves credit for more than they've got. I once went out with a
doll who said to me, "I am the glamorous type, I am the glamorous type!" I
said, "So what? (p. 40)
Stanley is, in fact, an emblem of force and oppression men impose on women. He is
depicted as a brutal force over the course of the play; the very character in the play who
deprives Blanche of the slightest compliment in spite of her constant efforts to make herself
beautiful. Williams gives his account thus:
-233-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
Since earliest manhood the center of his life has been pleasure with women,
the giving and taking of it, not with weak indulgence, dependently, but with
the power and pride of a richly feathered male bird among hens… He sizes
women up at a glance, with sexual classifications, crude images flashing into
his mind and determining the way he smiles at them. (p. 28)
He subordinates her wife, Stella, to the point that his absence is associated with longing
and loving on her part.
Diminished
Internal Disordered
Awareness Eating
Body Depression
Self-objectification Shame
Sexual
Anxiety Dysfunction
about
Physical
safety
S
afety
-234-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
as one perpetual part. Age talk is the typical conversation and discourse of women about the
topic of age. Assuredly, age is not to be dismissed as a banal issue and, therefore, it does not
do justice to its tremendous effects on the psychology of women. Arroyo et al. (2014)
consider age as something that “carries with it specific anxieties that go beyond concerns
about appearance” (p. 466). They further claim that “aging is associated with the fear of death,
fear of loss and bereavement, and as people age, they also develop fears concerning mental
function and decline” (p. 477).
Dealing with the caustic effects of feeling old, women usually tend to pretend to be
younger than what they really are. In general, many women prefer to misrepresent how old
they really are than dealing with what they consider as the harsh side of life called aging.
“Aging is also associated with more existential anxieties, as people attempt to come to terms
with the meaning of their lives, their accomplishments, and their relationships; such concerns
are often manifested in communication (Coupland et al. 1988, p. 477). In what looks like a
desperate move to make herself look better, Blanche states: “Stella is my precious little sister.
I call her little in spite of the fact she's somewhat older than I. Just slightly. Less than a year”
(p. 60). The sense of loss that the feeling of the end of life would convey to someone leads to
every kind of endeavor to stick to life evermore. It looks as if Blanche, in her efforts to make
an undying image of herself, is ready to take up any kind of tactic to be young again: “I'd
much rather forget it--when you--reach twenty-seven! Well--age is a subject that you'd prefer
to--ignore!” (p. 127). Apparently, her obvious fondness for men, extremely younger than
herself, is to prove herself that she can also be attractive to them like “A seventeen-year-old
boy--she'd gotten mixed up with!” (p. 115). Experiencing her sexual life in a retroactive
direction, she clings to the smallest opportunities to make younger men desire her again, e.g.,
the scene she talks to the Young Man:
Well, you do, honey lamb! Come here. I want to kiss you, just once, softly
and sweetly on your mouth! [Without waiting for him to accept, she crosses
quickly to him and presses her lips to his.] (p. 95)
The anxiety of aging becomes more problematic considering the fact that it is
somewhat inevitable, i.e. it is enforced. The ineluctability of aging on one hand, and the
dissatisfaction caused from the body-image, on the other hand, leads to women’s indulgence
in self-criticism which the only way out of it is through a deep process of self-objectification.
Not being able to maintain their consistency in coping with the assumed demands of society,
women usually go into fundamental periods of self-objectification which eventually has
destructive effects on their experiences.
Furthermore, the risks such women may encounter include eating disorder, depression,
and sexual malfunction. Likewise, this kind of anger and depression in individuals “may then
lead to coping via using alcohol or other substances to manage these feelings” (Szymanski et
al, 2011, p. 18). In the play, the number of times we see Blanche drinking is quite frequent
although most of the times she tries to deny her drinking problem:
I'm not accustomed to having more than one drink. Two is the limit--and
three!
[She laughs]
Tonight I had three (p. 59).
-235-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
Dealing with the anxiety of becoming the object of male gaze would surely be hard to
cope with and many women find no better way than nulling their perception. Notoriously
desperate, Blanche tries to escape the sad reality of her life by taking refuge in inebriating
substances: “The music is in her mind; she is drinking to escape it and the sense of disaster
closing in on her, and she seems to whisper the words of the song” (p. 130). Given that, it
could be realized that “using and/or abusing substances may be one way that women choose
to cope with the excess stress associated with SO and other experiences of sexism”
(Szymanski et al, 2011, p. 18). This behavior will most probably take on a progressive course,
in other words, the number and quantity of using such substances will increase in the course
of time. Not surprisingly, then, Blanche undertakes her habit of drinking whenever she feels
depressed.
Alcohol has long been associated with the aggression of men against the manipulation
of women. When the men are playing cards and Stella tries to send them away, she encounters
Stanley’s reaction: “She backs out of sight. He advances and disappears. There is the sound of
a blow. Stella cries out” (p. 63). That being said, using of substance is quite noticeable on two
different aspects. One is on the side of women themselves related to their getting away from
immediate reality. The other one is on the side of men, mostly related to the issue of their
violence against women. Whether or not it is done by men or women, the problem of drinking
alcohol and other abusing substances leads to some serious social interaction issues and
particularly the terms in which they are defined. Accordingly, Szymanski et al. (2011) quoted
that “Alcohol has long been linked to men’s SO of women and has been suggested to be both
a precipitant of and an excuse for sexually aggressive behavior by men” (p. 24).
Despite her drinking issues, Blanche’s grief also drives her to nymphomania and
hysteria. The role of these psychological issues coming from her sordid past is to assuage her
pain and grief. Her sexual intercourse with one of her students as well as strangers defamed
her character in the town and led to her dismissal from school and expulsion from her town,
Mississippi.
Another consequence of female objectification is creating a false reality or fantasy for
oneself. Reality is a quite unfixed domain and cannot be looked at in absolute terms. What is
meant by reality is the notion that one has of their surroundings and the dimension they have
made for themselves to live in. Drawing on the theories of Jacque Lacan, one can assert that
our reality “consists of symbols and the process of signification. Therefore, what we call
reality is associated with the symbolic order or ‘social reality’” (Homer 81). Our daily
experiences are actually shaped in the limits of this process of signification. In other words,
the reality is constituted by the relationship one makes between their own identity (their part
in the chain of signification) and the bigger system (e.g., society, law, and most significantly
our language). Understandably, this could be the case of many self-objectified women who
cannot bear the kind of reality they are living in. The moment they internalize the process of
objectification is the starting point they participate in building a new reality for themselves. It
is often quoted that “women to varying degrees internalize this outsider view and begin to
self-objectify by treating themselves as an object to be looked at and evaluated on the basis of
appearance” (Szymanski et al., 2011, p. 8). Eventually, women alter their view of themselves
and their surrounding world to such an extent that they will finally come up with a new
version of reality that is more agreeable to them.
-236-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
Avoiding realism, craving for magic, misrepresenting the truth etc. are all strategies
taken up by Blanche in order to get to a new version of herself defined in totally new terms.
Not surprisingly, she avoids any kind of encounter which might expose the reality of her body
to others. Gradually, realism as the realism of the social interactions gives its place to another
reality which has been wholly modified by the internalized implementations done on
Blanche’s perception of reality. Ultimately, we find Blanche totally entangled in her dreams
of a better life; that kind of life going in the same direction as her thinking of herself as a
woman desired by men. She is objectified by men around her and hides behind a mask no
more appealing than her immoral, dissipated past. Her self-objectification leads her to
numerous mentioned psychological issues which at the end of the play puts her in the
madhouse.
3. CONCLUSION
References
-237-
World Scientific News 56 (2016) 229-238
[4] Coupland, N., Coupland, J., Giles, H., Henwood, K., & Wiemann, J. (1988). Elderly
self-disclosure: Interactional and intergroup issues, Language & Communication, 8,
109-133.
[5] Devlin, A. J. (1986). Conversations with Tennessee Williams. Jackson, MS: University
Press of Mississippi.
[6] Fang, W. (2008). Blanche’s Destruction: Feminist Analysis on A Streetcar Named
Desire, Canadian Social Science, 4(3), 102-108.
[7] Haskell, M. (1987). From Reverence to Rape: The Treatment of Women in the Movies.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
[8] Homer, S. (2005). Routledge Critical Thinkers: Jacques Lacan: New York, NY:
Routledge.
[9] Koprince, S. (1996). Domestic Violence in A Streetcar Named Desire, Southern Studies
7(2), 4355.
[10] Kroon, V. D. A. M., & Perez. M. (2013). Exploring the integration of thin-ideal
internalizationand self-objectification in the prevention of eating disorders. Body Image,
10, 16-25.
[11] Leverich, L. (1995). Tom: The Unknown Tennessee Williams. New York: W. W.
Norton.
[12] Mackinnon, C. (1989). Toward a Feminist Theory of State, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard
University Press.
[13] Miller, J. B. (1986). Toward a new psychology of women (2nd ed.). Boston, MA:
Beacon Press.
[14] Paller, M. (2003). A Room Which Isn’t Empty: A Streetcar Named Desire and the
Question of Homophobia, The Tennessee Williams Literary Journal, 5 (1), 23-37.
[15] Saddik, J. A. (2007). Contemporary American Drama. Edinburgh: Edinburgh UP.
[16] Szymanski, D. M., Moffitt. L. B, & Carr. E. R. (2011). Sexual Objectification of
Women: Advances to Theory and Research. The Counseling Psychologist, 39 (1), 6-38.
[17] Williams, T. (1947). A Streetcar Named Desire. New York, NY: A New Directions
Book.
-238-