Auto Express 31 January 2018
Auto Express 31 January 2018
Representative *Atandthefairendwear
of the agreement there are three options: i) pay the optional final payment and own the vehicle; ii) return the vehicle: subject to excess mileage
and tear, charges may apply; or iii) replace: part exchange the vehicle. With Solutions Personal Contract Plan. 18s+. Subject to availability
5.3% APR
and status. T&Cs apply. Offer available when ordered by 2nd April 2018 from participating Retailers. Indemnities may be required. Offers are not available
in conjunction with Scrappage upgrade scheme or any other offer and may be varied or withdrawn at any time. Accurate at time of publication. Freepost
Volkswagen Financial Services. Standard EU Test figures for comparative purposes and may not reflect real driving results. Model shown £33,325 RRP.
Official fuel consumption in mpg (litres/100km) for the Volkswagen Tiguan range in mpg (litres/100km): urban 31.0 (9.1)
– 49.6 (5.7); extra urban 44.1 (6.4) – 67.3 (4.2); combined 38.2 (7.4) – 60.1 (4.7). Combined CO2 emissions 170 – 123g/km.
Information correct at time of print.
CONTENTS
News | New Cars | Features | Tests | Products | Buying cars | Sport
Newsweek
COVER Mégane RS driven 8
Has Renaultsport created the new hot hatch king? We reveal all
COVER SEAT’s electric hatch 12
Exclusive images of EV. Plus more details as Cupra goes it alone
COVER Peugeot 4008 14
Coupé version of 3008 is coming, and we have the details
Ford’s self-driving pledge 16
New boss claims firm will be a leader in autonomous cars
Major MoT overhaul 18
New rules explained – and what they mean for you
Features
Record-breaking roads 22
The most amazing routes you could ever hope to drive
New cars
COVER Honda Jazz Sport 26
8 It looks sensational, but what’s the new Mégane RS like to drive? We find out Range-topping version of revised supermini driven
Honda Civic diesel 28
Family hatch gets 1.6 engine from CR-V and HR-V
Ford EcoSport 31
Is updated diesel a match for crossover class leaders?
Subaru WRX STi 33
Final Edition special takes rally-bred legend out in style
Nissan e-NV200 Combi 35
New 40kWh battery boost for electric seven-seater
Road tests
COVER Small SUV shoot-out 36
36 Kona faces C3 Aircross and CX-3 12 New SEAT electric hatch for 2020 New Hyundai Kona faces Citroen C3 Aircross and Mazda CX-3
Q7 e-tron vs XC90 T8 46
Audi tackles Volvo in plug-in hybrid battle
Our cars 52
Updates on Nissan Micra, Merc-AMG E 63 S and Peugeot 3008
Products
Hot kit 59
Smart battery chargers from Ring, plus your questions answered
New on the shelves 60
‘Virtual reality’ remote control car leads our kit round-up
26 First drive verdict on new Jazz... 28 ...plus new 1.6 Civic diesel rated DAB adaptors rated 62
Which is the best solution to get digital radio in your car?
Camera locators 64
Online thisweek
Our pick of the devices and apps that will keep you safe
Buying cars
E-Class buyer’s guide 68
Previous-generation Merc is now a bargain used from £7,000
Great estates 70
We take our pick from Kia, Volkswagen and Skoda wagons
New car prices 72
46 Plug-in Q7 and XC90 battle it out All the info you need before you head to the showroom
NEW
BIGGEST-S
10-16 January
2018 BRITAIN’S
| £3.20
No. 1,506
NE O
Senior reviewer: Sam Naylor
Special Issue
LO
ES
No. 1,507 | £3.70
IMAG GES
W K
EXCLUSIVE leads
Electric e-troncars...
Senior staff writers: Lawrence Allan, Andy Pringle blitz of new
CONTACT
SPECIAL ISSUE
UE
THE CAR NEWS WEEKLY We test the best petrol family hatches
0118
OFFICIAL
New 20 MI
M EST-S
8 BIGG SUV boomELLING WEEK
LY CAR MAG
HOT VWBuyingRolla s
2018
24 Jan-30 Jan£3.20
No. 1,508 |
flag with fresh EXCLUSIVE
Brit baby flies
DRIVEN
Living the dream e Phantom
G-Wagen of 4x4
we create a
alue big SUVs
bespok
www.autoe
xpress.co.u
k
Production
PLUS We go magic
it recreate the £14k?
PLUS
LC vs Merc SLCan
RIVALS
for
TESTED Lexus of original GTI
7 more small
NISSA
NISSAN’S
NEW XC40 vs
WEEKLY
www.autoexpress.co.uk
.autoexpress.co.uk
17 Jan-6 Feb Special Issue
Sub-editor: Paul Alton
facebook.com/autoexpress
ess
‘World’s up road next
ready to rip EXCLUSIVE
IMAGE
We dr
steering, which Renault calls 4CONTROL. a shame the paddles don’t operate
It’s designed to increase agility at low with a satisfying click, though; instead
speeds and stability at high speeds. they’re a bit soft and mushy.
But it also adds about 30kg of weight; The steering isn’t brimming with feel,
the RS tips the scales at 1,430kg, which but it’s sharp, and combined with the
makes it heavier than the Type R. Mégane’s four-wheel steering, it gives
As before, two chassis set-ups are this hot hatch gymnast levels of agility. PRACTICALITY Bucket seats feature
available: Sport and Cup. You can spec Below 62mph in Race mode, the rear as standard up front, but they eat into
either with a manual or auto gearbox.
The Sport chassis is the standard set-up
wheels turn in the opposite direction
from the fronts to boost turn-in; you can
legroom in the back. You’ll also struggle
to seat three grown-ups across the rear
FIRST VERDICT
RIDE
Renault Sport badges
hint at potential, but
hatch is impressively
refined on the road
STYLING
There’s an array of
RS touches inside and out,
plus powerful Brembo brakes
Automedia
Lawrence Allan
Lawrence_Allan@dennis.co.uk
@LobAllan
would be “other things” to come from platform. However, engineers are
PEUGEOT is looking to build on the its SUV range. “Remember when we said aiming to make the 4008 more
strong success of its 2008, 3008 two years ago we would launch five new engaging to drive than its siblings
and 5008 SUVs with a sportier, sleeker SUVs in the coming two years? We did it: with a unique suspension set-up.
fourth model. Likely to be named 4008, three in Europe and two more in China,” The engine range will kick off with
it’ll offer a more coupé-like design to he told us. “It’s time to come back to the three-cylinder PureTech turbo
take on cars such as the Toyota C-HR,
and will arrive early in 2020.
our DNA, and then we will maintain the
growth of our SUV range in the future
petrol engine, plus 1.6 and 2.0-litre
four cylinder BlueHDi diesels. The DS’s new Audi Q2
The new Peugeot, previewed by our
exclusive images, will be inspired by the
because the market is strong.”
Imparato also insisted that all
1.6-litre THP engine from the DS 7
Crossback will also transfer over.
rival caught cold
success premium German brands such Peugeot models would feature the Two plug-in hybrid variants will OUR spies have caught the sister
as BMW have enjoyed in the coupé- company’s innovative i-Cockpit, with support the range, too. Both will use car to the DS 7 Crossback on test
SUV sector and will be based on the high-set digital instruments and a the 1.6-litre THP engine, with one (above). We published exclusive
existing 3008. As a result, we small steering wheel. The 4008 would using a single front-mounted electric images of the SUV, set to be called
can expect the ‘3008 coupé’ therefore adapt the 3008’s cabin with motor to make around 240bhp. The DS 3 Crossback, in Issue 1,498,
to have a curvier exterior, a lower, sportier driving position. second, likely to be dubbed GT instead and now the Audi Q2 and MINI
with a sloping roofline and Despite the roofline, the 4008 is set of GTi, will feature electric motors on Countryman rival has hit the road.
reduced side glass area. to be offered in full five-seat form. As both axles for four-wheel drive, and When it arrives early next year,
It’s set to feature a number with the 3008 and 5008, the car will could produce up to 300bhp. it’ll be one of the first cars to use
of unique styling details, sit on PSA’s latest EMP2 modular P57: Latest on our Peugeot 3008 PSA’s new CMP platform, and looks
including blade-shaped set to mix DS 3 design cues with
LED running lights, a more the DS 7 Crossback’s newer look.
aggressive grille and a
distinctive single-piece
light bar at the rear. The
Variable limit cams
more elegant profile “always working”
would allow the 4008
to offer an edge over less DRIVERS breaking 70mph speed
style-focused mainstream limits on smart motorways when
SUVs, while competing no variable limit is in place can
with high-end crossovers. still be ticketed by speed cameras,
Speaking exclusively to an investigation has found.
Auto Express, Peugeot CEO Derbyshire Police told the
Jean-Phillipe Imparato said there Derby Telegraph cameras on the
M1 between Junction 29A and
Sloping roofline will give 4008 a more Tibshelf services are always on,
sporty profile than other Peugeot SUVs adjusting to limits and catching
speeders even when no variable
limit is in place. The cameras
caught 8,382 drivers in 2017.
(From left) I.D. Buzz microbus,
I.D. hatch, I.D. Crozz all on way Revived 8 Series
looks back on form
THE first official, unmasked
image of the new 8 Series has
been issued by BMW, although
the teaser (below) gives only a
shadowy glimpse of the Mercedes
OFFICIAL
tough on diesels
Latest emissions tests still
have their flaws, says Merc
James
Batchelor
James_Batchelor@dennis.
James_
Jam co.uk
es Batchelor@dennis.co.u
.ukk
@JRRBatche
@JRRBatc
tche
helor
helo
@JRRBatchelor
Videowatch
AT youtube.com/Autoexpress
this week, we drive the all-new
Nissan Leaf, as well as Toyota’s
208bhp Yaris GRMN hot hatch.
Alison’s Toyota
was still in good
condition, apart
from rust she
had arranged to
have repaired
Martin
Saarinen
Connected cars are nearly
here, but who will control
the data they generate?
HOW much do you think
your car knows about you?
An odd question, but you might
be surprised to learn that there
won’t be much you can keep
secret from it in the future.
The term ‘connected car’ is used a
lot, but what motorists need to start
understanding is that a connected
car isn’t just one that speaks to the
next set of traffic lights to determine
whether to slow down or speed up;
respray. But it returned with obvious were unacceptable” properly. That’s being taken up with Martin_Saarinen@dennis.co.uk
flaws, including a misaligned bootlid, the dealer and the bodyshop involved.” @AE_Consumer
mismatched paint, patches of bare The dealer offered to trade in Alison’s
metal, some overspray and misplaced came back with even more paint car for a new one. But that would have
decals. She said: “I was staggered it problems. A third attempt by BodyKraft’s involved her taking out fresh debt, which “There are hundreds
had actually got through the garage’s Dudley branch made matters worse. she wasn’t keen on. The spokesman
own quality assurance checks!” Alison said the car came back with confirmed: “We’re now trying to find her of different bits of data
After an inspection by a field a broken demister, a mix of matt and a much newer, 16-plate replacement your connected car can
engineer, Toyota agreed the repairs gloss paint and dirt chips in the finish. Yaris, which is not affected by the same
were “unacceptable” and the car went She added: “The car now needs a full rusting issues, and has similar mileage send out to the world”
back to BodyKraft. But Alison told us it respray.” Alison decided enough was and a matched or improved spec.”
Useful
THE following provide help Legal Used car inspections Car registration/history Problems with dealers Problems with makers
with motoring problems. AA: 0345 850 1130 (m) AA: 0800 056 8040 HPI: 01722 422422 The Motor Ombudsman: The Motor Ombudsman:
RAC: 0330 159 1446 (m) RAC: 0330 159 0720 AA: 0800 316 3564 0345 241 3008 0345 241 3008
Some services are free, Consumer Ombudsman:
Contacts
Which?: 01992 878329 Technical advice DVLA: 0300 790 6802 Financial problems
others charge a fee or RAC: 0330 159 0364 www.consumer- Financial Ombudsman:
Citizens Advice Consumer AA: 0370 142 0002 (m) ombudsman.org
operate on premium-rate helpline: 03454 040506 Traffic information RMIF: 0845 305 4230
0800 023 4567
lines (p), while some offer Driving licences AA: 0906 888 4322 Safety concerns/recalls
Local Trading Standards Scottish Motor Trade
Local Citizens Advice Bureau DVLA: 0300 790 6801 RAC: 09003 444999 (p) Assoc. 0131 331 5510 DVSA: 0300 123 9000
advice for members only (m)
Jam
James Wilson
James
James_Wilson@dennis.co.uk
Highway 1, Australia
Key fact: It’s an incredible 9,000 miles long
RECO
Most southerly road
Between McMurdo
Station and Amundsen-
BREA
Scott Station, South Pole
Key fact: The road is unpaved,
and made from graded ice
ROAD
THERE is a route between the McMurdo Station and
Amundsen-Scott Station at the South Pole that’s made
Tallest road bridge of flattened, graded ice, and stretches for 900 miles. No
road goes further south, and it takes a fully prepared
Millau Viaduct, France snow truck 40 days to pull its sleds of fuel and supplies
from end to end. While this could be reduced in smaller
Key fact: At its tallest, the viaduct vehicles, it goes to show the harsh conditions at the
From the longest bridge in
stands 244.96m (803.67ft) high South Pole – a place where plane trips are often tricky.
twistiest road, as well as the
THE Millau Viaduct crosses France’s Tarn Valley, and is
the world’s tallest bridge, standing 244.96m (803.67ft)
“It takes a fully prepared out the amazing stretches
from the ground at its maximum. Designed by UK firm snow truck 40 days to made it into the Guinness
Foster and Partners, the 2,460m-long bridge is part of
the motorway connecting Paris with the Mediterranean
pull sleds of fuel and
region. The £272million project took 11 years to finish. supplies end to end”
22 31 January 2018 www.autoexpress.co.uk
Record-breaking roads INSIDE STORY
CONCRETE CITY
Huge 33.5 miles of road Longest road bridge
bridge make up the Hang
Na Expressway in Bangkok Hang Na Expressway, Bangkok
Key fact: Complex construction is 33.5 miles long
RD-
KING
S
the world to the
Widest road
Monumental Axis, Brasilia
Key fact: 12-lane expressway is 250m wide
Oldest road
Via Appia, Italy
Key fact: Some parts date back to 312 BC
highest, we check MONUMENTAL Axis takes the ‘widest road’ prize. POTHOLES, faded markings and overgrown hedges
Found in the capital of Brazil, Brasilia, the 12-lane are all signs of a dilapidated road which may, at some
of tarmac that have road is 250m (820ft) wide, runs for 1.8 miles and point, have been a glorious stretch of tarmac. There
Book of Records joins together two Plazas. Many Government buildings are old roads and then there is the Via Appia, in south
are situated on the stretch. The road is defined by a east Italy. Parts of it can be dated back to 312 BC and
huge central reservation that separates the two six- are still in use today. The road was originally made by
lane sections, home to a park and a radio tower. the then Roman Censor, Appius Claudius Caecus.
Steepest road
Baldwin Street,
Dunedin, New Zealand
Key fact: It has a max gradient of 1:2.86
35,000+
Customer Reviews on Trustpilot
T&Cs Apply
Named Best Online Tyre Retailer 2016 and 2017 by Auto Express, Blackcircles.com is the simple way to buy new tyres. Purchase your next set of tyres today to enjoy low prices, a tyre fitting appointment that suits you
and first class customer care. *Offer applies to Avon, Kumho, Michelin and Yokohama tyres only and valid until 28/02/2018. Code cannot be used in conjunction with any other Blackcircles.com promotion. Discount on
cost of tyres only and excludes fitting, balancing, valves and disposal on fully fitted orders and excludes cost of delivery on mail order orders.
NEWCARS
Visit autoexpress.co.uk for the latest new cars and drives
28 NEW CIVIC DIESEL
We try out the diesel
version of one of our
favourite hatchbacks.
Essentials
Honda Jazz 1.5
i-VTEC Sport
Price: £17,155
Engine: 1.5-litre 4cyl petrol
Power/torque: 128bhp/155Nm
Transmission: Six-speed manual,
front-wheel drive
0-60mph: 8.7 seconds
Top speed: 118mph PRACTICALITY The Jazz has always STYLING Hot hatch looks spice up the
been among the best in class for space Honda’s humble image. Black 16-inch
Economy: 47.9mpg
and practicality, with lots of headroom alloy wheels are standard, alongside
CO2: 133g/km
and a 354-litre boot with seats in place sporty, Civic Type R-inspired bodykit
ONSALE Now
Otis Clay
and light steering, means it’s actually revs at a fast cruise and making a fair
quite good fun around town. old din. As a result, a long journey
It even has a suitably rorty and sporty could well end up being pretty tiring.
note to its exhaust when you accelerate The Jazz can entertain on the right
hard. The one downside is that the ride roads, then, but there are more
is a little firmer than on other versions complete warm superminis available
of the Jazz, but it’s never unbearable. that are more engaging to drive.
Once you get out of town, however, At least you don’t lose what is
that relative lack of torque low down most appealing about the Jazz in the
in the rev range is more obvious. You
soon instinctively start dropping down
Sport: its space and practicality. This is
a surprisingly big small car, with more
Verdict
a gear to keep the revs up, which is space inside than many models from
when the engine is working at its best the class above; you could happily carry THERE’S a certain endearing
and responds most keenly. This four adults inside, and even five at a quality to the new Jazz Sport,
trait could both entertain and frustrate, push. Excellent visibility also makes with its willing and rev-hungry
depending on your preference. it easy to park and place in town. petrol engine on top of the
To make matters worse, once the However, all of those advantages sporty new look. However, it
initial exhaust rortiness subsides, it are also available in cheaper versions all comes at a relatively high
begins to sound quite coarse. You might of the Jazz, and we can’t help thinking price. For us, it makes more
expect to be able to escape the noise on that those models will continue to sense to buy one of the cheaper
the motorway, but thanks to the short make rather more sense for more versions, all of which still
gearing, the engine is still pulling high people than the Sport does. come with the qualities that
are sure to appeal most to
“What Sport lacks in outright performance the Jazz’s target market:
its space and practicality.
it makes up for with a willingness to rev”
★★★★★
www.autoexpress.co.uk 31 January 2018 27
NEWCARS Honda Civic diesel
Essentials
Honda Civic
1.6 i-DTEC
Price: £20,120
Engine: 1.6-litre 4cyl
turbodiesel
Power/torque: 118bhp/300Nm
Transmission: Six-speed manual,
front-wheel drive
0-62mph: 10.5 seconds EQUIPMENT Diesel model is hi-tech RIDE Civic remains a composed drive
Top speed: 125mph and features touchscreen infotainment. in i-DTEC form, with good handling and
The system is a little dated, however, a mature ride. Our European-spec test
Economy: 80.7mpg
and some menus aren’t that easy to use model was fitted with black alloys
CO2: 93g/km
ONSALE Now
Otis Clay
With 300Nm of torque available, diesel-engined Civic provides plenty of pulling power from low down in the rev range
Hond
FIRST DRIVE We lov
Andy Pringle commands a sizeable premium of welcome lack of vibration through the
Andy_Pringle@dennis.co.uk £1,300 over the 1.0-litre petrol. controls at all times, while the added
@AndyMoshPringle NEED
But if you’re buying through Honda’s diesel torque means that the engine TO KNOW
UNTIL now the latest Honda Civic finance, prices start at £249 per month pulls strongly from low revs. It’s smooth, Six-speed manual
has been a petrol-only affair, but on a three-year deal with 5.9 per cent predictable and easy to drive. is only choice right
that’s about to change. A heavily revised APR representative. That’s about £50 Overtaking in the diesel is a breeze, now, but a nine-
version of the 1.6-litre diesel engine that more than the equivalent 1.0-litre petrol too. Admittedly, the engine does get a speed auto arrives
currently features in the CR-V and HR-V car, which may be easier to square with little noisy towards the upper end of in the summer.
Claimed 80.7mpg
SUVs arrives under the bonnet for 2018. the potential fuel savings. Furthermore, the rev range, but the pull is so strong
means diesel has
With tweaks to the pistons and the the lower CO2 emissions will mean that at low revs that you never really need to a theoretical range
exhaust system, the end result is a it won’t cost company car users much go that far in most everyday situations. of 800-plus miles
claimed 80.7mpg and CO2 emissions of more in Benefit-in-Kind (BiK) tax. What was clear from our time with on a tank of fuel
93g/km. Those figures are up with the The other advantage over the petrol, it was that the way the Civic drives
best in the class, and better than the and many of its direct rivals, is its higher hasn’t suffered from having a diesel
equivalent engines in the Volkswagen torque output. Whereas the 1.6-litre engine under the bonnet. It remains
Golf, SEAT Leon and Renault Mégane. diesel in the Golf and Leon puts 250Nm balanced and composed, combining
What’s more, the engine achieves all at the disposal of its driver’s right foot, assured handling with excellent high-
this without any external help; there’s the Civic’s engine produces 300Nm. speed stability and a mature ride.
no need to use an AdBlue urea additive. Our time behind the wheel of a Inside, there’s no change to the
The 118bhp developed by the unit European-spec model revealed a Civic’s basic recipe, and in every other
is average, but it’s the least powerful
engine in the Civic range, sitting below
the two existing petrol options, the
“The way the Civic drives hasn’t suffered
127bhp 1.0 litre and the 180bhp from having a diesel under the bonnet”
1.5-litre. True to diesel form, though, it
ve the petrol Civic, so how will the new diesel model compare?
Running costs
80.7mpg (official)
£63 fill-up
ONSALE Now
Chris Knapman
SINCE arriving in 2014, the Ford
EcoSport hasn’t matched the success
of the brand’s bread-and-butter Fiesta
and Focus. As a result, this 2018
facelift is an extensive one. Alongside
the obvious styling tweaks, the marque
claims that 2,300 parts are new.
The highly acclaimed 1.0-litre
EcoBoost turbo three-cylinder petrol
engine will account for the vast majority
of sales, but diesel isn’t off the menu.
In the summer you’ll be able to buy
an EcoSport with Ford’s new 1.5-litre
EcoBlue four-cylinder diesel, delivering
123bhp and 300Nm of torque via a new
NEED
four-wheel-drive system – another first TO KNOW
for Ford’s previously front-wheel-drive- Upgraded cabin
only baby SUV. Until then, those after a is much improved
diesel EcoSport must choose an older, over old model
less powerful four-cylinder unit. and gets SYNC 3 EQUIPMENT The new EcoSport
With 99bhp and 215Nm of torque, infotainment gains contrasting roof colours for
this 1.5-litre Duratorq motor offers only Titanium and ST-Line models, as well
leisurely performance, as indicated by a as the option of 18-inch alloy wheels.
Interior gets soft-touch materials
0-62mph time of 14 seconds. It’s three
seconds slower than the EcoBlue unit,
and more than a second behind the
(almost £1,000 cheaper) 1.0-litre petrol. Verdict
A claimed 68.8mpg should, in theory,
mean the Duratorq engine is at least amount when you corner quickly. Still, the seat in front. What’s more, the 334- THE updated EcoSport is closer
cheap to run, but we managed no more the EcoSport’s steering is both well litre boot is on the small side for the to the rest of the crossover pack
than 50mpg as you have to work the weighted and pleasingly direct, and class, and it retains its awkward side- than before, but it still doesn’t
engine harder than you’d expect. On the upgraded interior is much better hinged door and a parcel shelf that pose much of a threat to the
the motorway, where diesels should than before. There are more soft-touch you have to lift and drop manually. class leaders. This 99bhp
excel thanks to their mid-range torque, materials, a neat TFT display for the trip Ultimately, it’s these small details TDCi model is too sluggish
you’ll often find yourself needing to computer sits between the dials and that leave the EcoSport lagging behind to recommend. If you’re dead-
drop from sixth gear to fifth just to Ford’s new SYNC 3 touchscreen with established crossovers such as the set on an EcoSport, wait for the
keep up with the flow of traffic. its crisp graphics and slick interface. Renault Captur, not to mention impressive new EcoBlue diesel, or go for the
There’s a lot of wind noise above What hasn’t changed is the cramped new contenders in the form of Citroen’s 1.0-litre EcoBoost petrol version.
60mph, the ride on 17-inch wheels
is fussy and the body leans a fair
rear that’ll see any passenger close to
six-foot tall with their knees pressed into
C3 Aircross (tested on Page 36), which
is over £1,000 cheaper spec for spec. ★★★★★
www.autoexpress.co.uk 31 January 2018 31
Advertising promotion
Hyundai
will make you
a
VIP reporter!
A JOINT
PROMOTION
WITH
ONSALE Now
Otis Clay
SubaruWRX
Performance
0-60mph/top speed EQUIPMENT Multitude of modes
5.2 seconds/158mph make driving experience adaptable.
Pete Gibson
Honda Jazz facelift early 2018 Jeep Grand Wagoneer 2020
MINI facelift spring 2018 Lamborghini Urus spring 2018
Peugeot 208 early 2019 Land Rover Defender 2019
Renault Clio late 2018 Lexus RX L 2018
SEAT Mii X-Perience 2018 Mercedes G-Class late 2018
Nissane-NV200
Vauxhall Corsa 2019 Mercedes GLA 2019
Volkswagen up! GTI early 2018 Mercedes GLB 2019
FAMILY CARS
Mercedes GLE late 2018
Alfa Romeo large saloon late 2018 Mercedes GLS 2019
Audi A3 2019 Mercedes-Maybach SUV 2019
Audi A6 spring 2018 MINI small SUV 2021
Audi A6 Avant summer 2018 Mitsubishi Eclipse Cross early 2018
FIRST DRIVE Boost in range for van-turned-MPV Audi A6 Allroad
BMW 1 Series
late 2018
late 2019
Mitsubishi Outlander
Mitsubishi Shogun Sport
2020
early 2018
BMW 3 Series late 2018 Nissan Juke 2018
Ford Focus spring 2018 Peugeot 2008 2018
Porsche Cayenne early 2018
Steve Fowler Kia Pro_cee’d Shooting Brake 2019
Porsche Cayenne Coupé 2019
Steve_Fowler@dennis.co.uk Mazda 6 facelift 2018
Mercedes A-Class 2018 Porsche Macan facelift 2018
@stevefowler Range Rover Evoque late 2018
Mercedes CLA 2018
Mercedes CLS summer 2018 Range Rover two-door 2019
IF you’re ready to take the plunge Peugeot 508 summer 2018 Rolls-Royce Cullinan 2018
SEAT Ateca Cupra 2018
into the world of EVs, but your family SEAT Leon 2020
SEAT large SUV 2018
Skoda Rapid Spaceback 2019
circumstances mean seven seats are a VolkswagenArteonshootingbrake 2018 Skoda coupé-SUV late 2018
Skoda Karoq vRS 2019
must, your choice is rather limited. It’s Volkswagen Golf Mk8 2019
Skoda Kodiaq vRS mid 2018
Volvo S60 mid 2018
either a Nissan e-NV200 Combi or, apart Volvo V40 2019
Skoda small SUV late 2019
from a pricey Tesla Model X, that’s it. SsangYong XAV 2019
SPORTS CARS Subaru XV early 2018
The good news is that, as with the Alfa Romeo Giulia Coupé 2019 Volkswagen T-Roc R 2018
Alpine A110 early 2018 Volkswagen Polo SUV late 2018
brilliant new Nissan Leaf (driven in Issue Aston Martin DB11 Volante 2018 Volkswagen Touareg mid 2018
1,508), this van-based MPV has just been Aston Martin V8 Vantage summer 2018 Volvo XC40 spring 2018
updated with Nissan’s 40kWh battery Aston Martin Vanquish summer 2018
PICK-UPS
Aston Martin Valkyrie 2019
pack. That means a handy 60 per cent Renault Alaskan spring 2018
Aston Martin 488 GTB rival 2020
Audi A9 2019 CABRIOLETS
increase in range; judged by the new,
Audi RS4 Avant early 2018 Bentley Continental GTC 2018
more realistic WLTP testing procedure Audi TT facelift mid 2018 BMW Z4 2018
Nissan claims an average of 125 miles, Audi TT Sportback 2018 BMW 8 Series Convertible late 2018
Audi TTQ 2019 TVR Griffith convertible 2020
which could rise to as much as 188 Bentley Continental GT early 2018 McLaren 720SSpider late 2018
miles in the city. Plenty for a week’s Bentley Barnato 2019 LUXURY CARS
BMW M3 2019 Audi A7 early 2018
worth of school drop-offs and pick-ups. BMW M5 early 2018 BMW 8 Series 2019
It’s not the most sophisticated MPV, BMW M8 2018 BMW 8 Series Gran Coupé 2019
Honda S2000 2019 Infiniti Q80 2018
though. The driving position is typically
van-like and very upright. And although Nissan e-NV200 Hyundai i20 N
Jaguar XE SVR
2019
2018
Lexus LF FC
Lexus LS
2020
early 2018
the rear doors slide, there’s not a huge Combi Lambo Aventador Performante
Lexus LC F
2018
2018
Rolls-Royce Ghost 2019
amount of space in row two and only Price: £25,000 (est) Maserati Alfieri 2020 ELECTRIC/PLUG-IN/FUEL CELL
McLaren 570 LT mid 2018 Audi e-tron 2018
small sliding windows, while row three Battery: 40kWh Bentley EV 2019
McLaren BP23 late 2018
chairs are awkward to fold and get to. Power: 108bhp Mercedes-AMG GT four-door 2018 BMW i5 2021
Mercedes-AMG Project 1 2018 BMW i8 Roadster 2018
The ride gets bumpier the further Transmission: Single-speed auto, BMW X3 EV 2019
Polestar 1 2019
back you go, too; there’s no hiding the front-wheel drive Dacia EV 2020
Porsche 911 2019
0-62mph: 14.0 seconds Ford Mustang hybrid 2020
fact the e-NV200 works best as a van. Renault Mégane RS early 2018
Honda Clarity 2022
Toyota Supra 2018
However, it is in a class of one and NEED TO Top speed: 76mph
TVR Griffith late 2018 Honda Urban EV 2019
you can still enjoy the silent (if not so KNOW Range: 125 miles (WLTP) Vauxhall Insignia GSi early 2018
Jaguar I-Pace
Kia Stonic hybrid
2018
2019
swift in this model) driving, while you As a van, the CO2: 0g/km SUVS Lexus EV 2020
e-NV200 gets Alfa Romeo large SUV 2019 Mercedes-EQ SUV 2019
can get a decent smattering of luxury
a 4,191-litre load
ONSALE Spring Aston Martin DBX 2019 MINI EV 2019
kit, too. The dash is appealingly car- Audi Q3 2018 McLaren EV 2023
bay that will Audi Q4 2019 Nissan Leaf early 2018
like and although plush plastics are
swallow two Audi Q8 2018 Nissan Leaf Nismo 2019
nowhere to be seen, build quality is
Verdict
Audi SQ2 2018 Porsche Mission E 2019
Euro pallets Audi SQ8 late 2018
good and if Leaf owners are anything Skoda Vision E 2020
Audi RS Q5 2018 Range Rover PHEV early 2018
to go by, the chances of you having anyy Bentley Bentayga Speed 2018 Range Rover Sport PHEV early 2018
reliability problems are slim. NISSAN might just have pulled
NISSA BMW X2 early 2018 Tesla Model 3 2019
BMW X3 M 2019 Tesla Pick-up 2019
More goodood news is that, off a bi
bit of a masterstroke with BMW X4 2018 Tesla Model Y late 2019
although prices and specs the new
ne e-NV200 Combi. It’ll BMW X5 late 2018 Volkswagen I.D. hatchback 2020
BMW X7 2018 Volkswagen I.D. Crozz SUV 2020
have yet to be confirmed, prove popular with parents who Citroen C5 Aircross late 2018 Volkswagen I.D. Scirocco 2020
-NV200 may
the new e-NV200 are wanting
wa to go electric and Dacia Duster mid 2018 Volkswagen I.D. Microbus 2022
DS 3 SUV 2018 Volkswagen Phaeton EV 2019
not cost much more than taxi firms
firm for short journeys. It’s
the old one, which not the best MPV to be driven
ll-electric
makes this all-electric in, but iit is the only EV MPV. Have your say: What
van-cum-MPV PV look like
something of a bargain. ★★★★★
★★ is your car like to own?
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driver-power
www.autoexpress.co.uk
express.co.uk 31 January 2018 35
ROADTESTS
Visit autoexpress.co.uk for the latest new cars and drives
46 HYBRID SUVS
New diesel plug-in Audi
Q7 e-tron meets petrol-
electric Volvo XC90 T8.
Best of both
Hyundai
d i iis th
worlds
the llatest
t tb brand
d tto offer
ff SUV appeall iin a supermini-
sized package.We test its Kona against Citroen and Mazda rivals
WITH SUV sales booming and superminis
continuing to be best-sellers in Britain, it’s no
wonder car makers are bringing the two together.
Hyundai is the latest brand to join the fray, with
its new Kona, and thanks to its outlandish looks,
this car is bound to draw attention. Yet the real
battle it’ll need to win will be fought on equipment,
price, the practicality of its interior, and comfort.
That’s because the Kona is taking on our class
leader, the Citroen C3 Aircross. Like so many Citroens,
it’s quirky, but it doesn’t compromise, and that has
really impressed us since it arrived late last year.
Then there’s the Mazda CX-3. Despite being the
oldest car here, it makes a strong case
with its sharp styling and handling.
This is a tough class, so if you
want a small SUV read on to
find out which of these
makes the most
compelling
case.
Testers’ notes
“All three cars make a style statement. The Kona’s distinctive Hyundai Kona
design is unusual among the brand’s otherwise plain-looking 1.0 T-GDi Premium
range, while the Aircross fits in with Citroen’s brand image. Price: £18,795
The Mazda is the oldest car here, but it still looks good.” Engine: 1.0-litre 3cyl petrol, 118bhp
0-60mph: 10.1 seconds
Se
Sean Carson Chief reviewer Test economy: 42.0mpg/9.2mpl
CO2: 125g/km Annual road tax: £140
THE Hyundai Kona we’re testing uses a 1.2-litre three-cylinder, nor as responsive and fun
downsized 1.0-litre turbo petrol engine to rev as the Mazda’s 2.0-litre petrol engine. It has a
with 118bhp, which is designed for economy, sweeter manual gearshift than the Citroen, although
as well as good performance around town. It both are way behind the Mazda’s shift.
costs from £18,795 in Premium trim (the car The Kona performed well in our tests, accelerating
in our pictures is an SE), which makes it the from 0-60mph in 10.1 seconds despite heavy rain.
most expensive model in this test, although That was quicker than the more powerful C3, which
4L
only by £100 over the Mazda CX-3. struggled for traction off the line. The Hyundai was
also a match for the naturally-aspirated Mazda
in-gear, despite having half its engine capacity,
Design & score
4L
thanks to that wide spread of turbocharged torque.
engineering 3.7
IT’S a little late to the small SUV Practicality score
party, but the Kona certainly makes
an impression with its bold styling. The split THE Kona’s 334-litre boot is a good size
3.7
headlight design is similar to that of the Citroen and shape, but isn’t as useful as the C3’s
C3 Aircross, but the bonnet scoop and heavy plastic minimum 410-litre capacity, especially as
cladding give the Hyundai a more rugged image. the Aircross’ rear seat slides forward to create extra
Unlike many cars in this class, including the space. The Hyundai isn’t as spacious as the 350-litre
C3 Aircross and CX-3, the Kona is not based on CX-3, but its wider aperture makes it easier to load.
its supermini sibling, in this case the i20. Instead Raised-up seats in the Korean car mean it’s easy to
it uses a new platform that’s engineered to allow get in and out of, and there’s a good level of leg and
four-wheel drive on higher-spec diesels, although headroom in the rear. The Citroen is more spacious,
Hyunda
our 1.0-litre petrol is front-wheel drive only. but the Hyundai is comfortable enough for four
The four-wheel-drive models also get a multi- adults, which is still better than the cramped Mazda.
link rear suspension set-up, but the front-wheel- Roof rails are standard on the Kona in Premium
drive car we’re testing here features a less complex spec, which could be useful for bikes or a roof box,
4L
and cheaper torsion beam system. All models feature but they’re mainly meant as a style add-on.
MacPherson struts at the front. Similarly, petrol
versions use a six-speed manual only, while the
It’s got some catching up to
diesel gets a seven-speed dual-clutch box instead. Ownership score and turbo power help new
The Kona sits in between its rivals in terms
of overall size; it’s 4,165mm long and 1,565mm HYUNDAI finished a respectable 10th
4.0
!
high. It’s the widest of the three models here, in both the manufacturer and dealer
which helps with shoulder room inside. categories in our Driver Power 2017
For £18,795 the Kona Premium comes with satisfaction survey. That beat Citroen in both
18-inch alloys, sat-nav, Apple CarPlay and Android areas, but Mazda came fifth in the makers’ chart.
Auto, DAB radio, rear parking sensors and a All Konas get plenty of safety kit, including six Braking Running costs
reversing camera, so is very well equipped. airbags, downhill brake control, driver attention 70-0/60-0/30-0mph 42.0mpg (on test)
There’s good scope for personalisation, too, with alert, hill-start assist and lane-keep assist. You can 63.7/39.7/10.5m £61 fill-up/£140 or 24% tax
coloured accents around the cabin. These spruce also opt for a £235 Safety Pack that adds autonomous
things up, because the standard grey finish looks emergency braking to that list. The Korean crossover
4L
plain. Yet the quality of the materials isn’t as good as scored a full five stars in Euro NCAP’s crash test.
in either rival. Plus, the Mazda feels better built, and
4L
the Citroen has a much more interesting design.
Running costs score
3.8
Driving score THE Kona returned respectable fuel
On the road
Steering is well weighted and
Kona resists body roll well, but it’s
not as much fun to drive as Mazda
ai Kona
o do, so can dramatic looks
baby shake up the market?
Performance Practicality
0-60mph/30-70mph Boot (seats up/down)
10.1/9.5 seconds 334/1,116 litres
Our choice:
Kona 1.0 T-GDi SE
Grey finish in our car looked a bit plain; colour accents are available. But material quality trails other models here NEXT CAR
CITROEN’S C3 Aircross is partly a successor to seconds. This torque is also useful because it means
the old C3 Picasso model. But it’s also partly a you don’t have to work the six-speed manual gearbox
replacement for the C4 Cactus, which has recently as hard. That’s a bonus because it’s by far the least
been updated and repositioned as more of conventional enjoyable transmission of our three contenders.
hatchback than an SUV. The C3 Aircross definitely It’s vague and feels oddly heavy, and is particularly
4L
occupies the small SUV space, and our PureTech 130 unpleasant after hopping out of the precise Mazda.
4L
model costs from £18,490 in Flair trim.
Practicality score
Design & score 4.2
engineering 4.1 THE Citroen’s cabin is much more
spacious than either rival’s, thanks
THE C3 Aircross might be an all-new to a clever design that prioritises a
Citroen, but unlike the Kona, it’s not feeling of space and light inside.
based on a fresh platform. Instead it sits on the firm’s The C3 Aircross doesn’t just feel bigger, it also
PF1 architecture, used for many years to underpin has the most rear legroom, as well as the most boot
lots of different models, including the C4 Cactus. space thanks to a sliding rear bench seat that folds
With its chunky styling and focus on practicality, 60:40, too. Even with the seats all the way back,
the C3 Aircross has the least sporty design of the three there’s 410 litres of boot space; and getting items
cars here, but the body cladding does at least mean it in and out is easy as well, thanks to a low loading lip.
looks like an SUV. Although it’s noticeably taller than Moving the seats forward improves space up to
its rivals, it’s the same width as the Mazda; both are 520 litres, which is way more than in either rival.
narrower than the Kona. The C3’s longer wheelbase Despite this gain in capacity, comfort in the back is
boosts interior space, but short overhangs mean acceptable, because there’s still enough legroom.
the Hyundai and Mazda are both longer overall. Fold down the seats completely and there is a total
Here we’re testing the 128bhp 1.2-litre petrol, which of 1,289 litres of space, which is also the most of all
comes with a six-speed manual transmission; the three models here. The Kona has 1,116 litres available
L4 Citroen C
108bhp version of the same engine has a five-speed in two-seat mode, and the Mazda offers 1,260 litres.
box instead. The C3 Aircross uses a similar suspension
set-up to the Kona and CX-3, with MacPherson
struts at the front and a rear torsion beam. Ownership score
Unlike with the Hyundai, the French crossover
isn’t available with four-wheel drive at all. However, STANDARD safety equipment
3.8
Citroen’s £400 optional Grip Control changes the in Flair trim includes six airbags,
drivetrain settings to better cope with conditions. lane-departure warning, speed-limit Our current champ is a fine
There are Snow, Sand and All-Road modes available, recognition, a tiredness warning system
while hill descent assist is added to match the Kona. and autonomous emergency braking.
Not only can you have a more powerful engine in Shelling out £600 on the Park Assist Pack
the C3 for similar money to its rivals, you can also get adds blind spot monitoring, park assist, front Running costs Performance
a top-spec Flair car featuring standard sat-nav, DAB, parking sensors and a reversing camera. 40.3mpg (on test) 0-60mph/30-70mph
£55 fill-up/£140 or 22% tax 10.6/9.8 seconds
4L
Bluetooth, climate control and parking sensors. Citroen didn’t fare too well in our Driver Power
2017 survey, coming in a disappointing 26th in the
makers’ chart. That was second from bottom and
Driving score
4L
well behind its rivals here for customer satisfaction.
C3 Aircross
all-rounder. We see if it can stay on top
Practicality Braking
Boot (seats up/down)
410-520/1,289 litres
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
51.6/40.6/10.7m
!
THROUGH THE RANGE
Which trim level might suit you?
Our choice:
C3 Aircross PureTech 130 Flair
Dashboard design is interesting and quality of materials is better than Hyundai’s, but not up to CX-3’s standard NEXT CAR
WE’RE testing the 118bhp 2.0-litre petrol you might expect as well. There’s less body
version of Mazda’s CX-3 crossover, which costs roll than in either rival, and the Mazda feels
£18,695 in entry-level SE Nav trim (although our composed even when cornering aggressively.
images show an SE-L Nav) with a six-speed manual It’s certainly the enthusiast’s choice here, but it
box. It’s the only car here with four-cylinder engine doesn’t exclude itself from a wider range of buyers,
and it’s twice the capacity of the Kona’s, despite because the chassis remains comfortable over most
4L
having the same power output. Is it still a good choice? road surfaces. It doesn’t thump into potholes like the
Kona does, so while it’s not as soft as the Citroen, the
4L
Mazda still beats its Korean rival for ride comfort.
Design & score
engineering 4.1
Practicality score
THE CX-3’s 2.0-litre engine is
unusual in this company, as it doesn’t THE Mazda’s 350-litre boot is a little
3.6
use a turbocharger. Instead, Mazda larger than the Hyundai’s, but it feels
has focused on weight saving and clever engine smaller in the real world because the CX-3’s
tech to reduce emissions and improve fuel economy. sportier shape restricts access. It’s also nearly as
At 1,155kg it’s the lightest car of the three, which big as the Citroen inside with the seats folded
has big benefits to handling and performance, too. down, at 1,260 litres, but the load bay is a more
It uses MacPherson strut front and torsion beam even shape, so it’s more versatile overall.
rear suspension just like its rivals here, but Mazda’s The roofline in the Mazda also means that rear-
engineers have tuned the set-up to deliver a more seat headroom is limited and it feels much more
engaging driving experience than the other models. cramped in the back than in either of its rivals here.
Part of that tuning includes the subtle G-Vectoring There’s also not much legroom if you’re sitting
Control system. This is a clever set-up that can limit behind a tall driver, so if you’re using the rear
engine torque to the front wheels to improve seats often then the Citroen will be a better pick.
4L
handling response and driver comfort by
reducing the steering effort required.
The CX-3’s sharp exterior styling was updated to Ownership score On the road
keep it fresh last year, and it’s the sportiest-looking
model of the three here, while also having a more SAFETY equipment on the SE Nav
4.1 CX-3 suffers less body roll than
either rival here, and even when
conventional design than the Hyundai or Citroen. model includes six airbags, hill hold pushing hard, it feels composed
The interior has a different feel to the French assist and emergency brake assist, but as
crossover’s airy cabin, because it’s fairly dark inside, it’s an entry-level car some kit is missing.
Mazda C
but the driving position is much more comfortable, Higher-spec models are available with lane-
visibility is still good and the material quality is departure warning, AEB, LED lights, a blind spot
better. It feels more solidly built than its rivals, too. monitor with rear-cross traffic alert and traffic sign
At this price point you’ll be looking at an entry- recognition. But this kit isn’t offered on SE Nav,
level SE Nav version, but there’s still plenty of kit. which is disappointing and means the CX-3 lags
You get sat-nav, Bluetooth, DAB, cruise control behind its rivals despite having achieved a five-
CX-3 is still the driver’s choice,
4L
and a seven-inch display screen as standard. star Euro NCAP rating when it was tested in 2015.
However, Mazda did well in our Driver Power
2017 satisfaction poll, finishing fifth overall in the
Driving score
4L
makers’ chart, the highest of these three brands.
!
Braking
Brakin Practicality
70-0/60-0/30-0mph Boot (seats up/down)
53.5/40.9/9.4m 350/1,260 litres
CX-3
but can it see off challenge of new rivals?
Our choice:
CX-3 2.0 SkyActiv-G SE-L Nav
Mazda’s interior is dark, but there’s no faulting the higher-grade materials used compared with its rivals’ NEXT CAR
Hyundai
Kona
8-inch touchscreen sat-nav Standard
Key features: Sat-nav, phone connectivity
score
4.1
4L Citroen
C3 Aircross
Citroen Connect Nav Standard
Key features: Nav, smartphone link
score
3.9
4L Mazda
CX-3
7-inch Colour touchscreen Standard
Key features: Sat-nav, control wheel
score
3.8
4L
WHILE the SE model uses a seven-inch display EVERY C3 Aircross powered by this engine has a MAZDA’S seven-inch display is technically a
screen, the Premium-spec car we’re testing here seven-inch touchscreen display as standard, and in touchscreen, and using it as such is easy enough,
comes with an eight-inch unit that includes Flair trim you also get sat-nav. The screen impresses apart from the fact it’s a significant reach over
sat-nav as well as other standard features fitted. at first, because it looks sleek and the unit is big. from a natural driving position.
That system shares its design and menu layout Dig deeper and it’s disappointing, though, because However, you never actually need to touch the
with the smaller unit, including the standard Apple the interface can be annoying to navigate through, screen, because there is a rotary dial on the centre
CarPlay and Android Auto functionality. It works and the sometimes unresponsive screen makes using console that can be used for everything. That means
very well on the screen, and while the display looks it on the move much more difficult than it needs to be. it’s much easier to operate on the move than either
tacked on to the dash and the buttons around it feel The best way to control it is through Android Auto rival’s set-up, and the interface is more intuitive than
cheap, the touchscreen is responsive and easy to or Apple CarPlay, with their simpler, cleaner interfaces the Citroen’s and about on par with the Hyundai’s.
use, particularly with a smartphone plugged in. and useful voice control functions. You still have to There is no smartphone connectivity, though,
The graphics are clear and the on-screen icons are use the screen to adjust the car’s climate controls, so you have to rely on Mazda’s own sat-nav. That’s
big enough that they don’t feel fiddly. It’s not as easy though, which is always a frustrating experience. not a problem as it’s generally very good. There’s
to use on the move as the Mazda’s rotary dial-based At least you get plenty of features: there’s also also an app for Internet radio, along with the
system, but it’s snappier and more intuitive than the DAB radio and Citroen’s Connect Box Emergency standard Bluetooth, DAB radio and USB media
Citroen’s frustrating screen, and the menus are easy and Assistance System that can automatically options. Plus, on higher-spec models you get a Bose
to understand. Wireless charging is also included. contact the emergency services after a crash. sound system, but it’s not available on SE Nav cars.
Display Graphics are clear and the screen Screen Citroen’s infotainment looks Connection There’s no Apple CarPlay or
is responsive. DAB radio is included, as are good, but is let down by a display that can Android Auto, so you must use the built-in
Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, so the be unresponsive. Phone connectivity, DAB nav. Bluetooth and DAB radio are standard,
unit will link up well with your smartphone radio and sat-nav help make up for it and there are various USB media options
Cheap-feeling buttons, not that Sometimes illogical menus, No smartphone connectivity, hard-to-
well integrated into dashboard unresponsive screen reach touchscreen, low-res graphics
Results CITROEN
THE Citroen brings
together all the elements
that are really important
1st MAZDA
IT’S by far the most
entertaining car to drive,
2nd
but that’s not the only reason the
HYUNDAI
COMPARED with its
rivals, the Kona is
3rd
ultimately lacking a clear direction.
for a small SUV like this. It’s distinctive, CX-3 scores well. The car also rides It’s not as comfy as the Citroen, but
comfortable and incredibly practical, smoothly, offers enough usability and not as good to drive as the CX-3, and
which means it’ll fit in with buyers’ is also tempting on Mazda’s attractive rides more harshly than either. It has
everyday lives best. It’s not hugely PCP deals. While it’s not practical or the best infotainment system here
fun to drive, but it delivers good in- efficient enough to win this test, the and gets plenty of standard kit, but its
ROADTEST gear performance and the long list of CX-3 is still reasonably spacious and drab interior and driving experience
standard kit means the C3 Aircross suffers the least from depreciation, so count against it, while the smallest
★★★★✩ is the best-value car in this test. running costs should be acceptable. boot seals its fate in third place.
CITROEN
AEB = autonomous emergency braking. *Part of option pack. In red = equipment fitted to our test car. Insurance quotes from AA (Tel 0800 107 0680
or www.theAA.com) for a 42-year-old living in Banbury, Oxon, with three penalty points. Residual values provided by CDL VIP Data.
price THE SEAT Arona FR is a little le pricier than its three rivals
oice. The sporty
here, but it’s still a fine choice.
tainment
looks and top-notch infotainment
IF you’re prepared to buy used, you could get into a nearly
ne
sam
yman for around the
new MINI Countryman
same price as the cars in this test.
help it stand out, and it’s also The MINI rivals the CX-3
X-3 for
Other options for good to drive, practical and d dri
driving enjoyment, boasts
similar money... economical. Look out for goo
good residual values and
the decent PCP deals. a chic, upmarket image.
mage.
www.autoexpress.co.uk 31 January
ry 201
2018
8 45
ROAD TESTS Audi Q7 e-tron vs Volvo XC90 T8
Q7 vs
XC90 Audi and Volvo slug it out to be our
luxury plug-in hybrid SUV champ
ELECTRIFICATION is a trend sweeping the
industry, and in a bid to boost the efficiency
of their bigger models, such as SUVs, car makers
are turning to batteries and electric motors; these
supplement combustion engines and help cut CO2.
Audi’s Q7 e-tron plug-in hybrid bucks the trend
by teaming its electric motor with a diesel engine,
but the question is, has the brand backed the right
horse here? In some ways it’s incidental, because
the Q7 isn’t offered with a petrol choice in the
UK to electrify – unlike the Volvo XC90.
The XC90 T8 Twin Engine plug-in uses a petrol
engine assisted by an electric motor and battery
set-up, and is a different solution to the same
problem. Which best combines its two methods of
propulsion as our favourite big plug-in hybrid SUV?
46 31 January 2018
Audi Q7 e-tron vs Volvo XC90 T8 ROAD TESTS
Ag
Against: ortable as
Droning engine note, not as comfortable
he move
Q7, infotainment can be difficult to use on the
ROAD TESTS Audi Q7 e-tron vs Volvo XC90 T8
L4
JAN 2018
L4
Yet with both power sources delivering drive
on twistier roads, the XC90’s engine drones
more than the Q7’s smoother V6 TDI. RUNNING
The gearbox is adept at picking the right ratio score COSTS
and managing changes smoothly, but unlike the
Q7, it doesn’t respond as well in manual mode.
4.0 According to our experts, the
XC90 will retain 54.5 per cent
On top of that, the ride isn’t as good as the of its list price (£36,000). The
Audi’s. The Volvo’s air-suspended chassis (a Q7 will hold on to only 48.8
£2,150 option on Inscription trim) feels firmer per cent (£32,990), so it’ll lose
and harsher, plus doesn’t offer the plush control £4,515 more over three years.
over the body and wheels’ vertical movements,
meaning over rough surfaces it jars a little.
Still, the firmer-feeling set-up and 189kg SERVICING The electric
weight saving ensure the XC90 is marginally elements of these cars
more agile. It resists roll better and doesn’t feel shouldn’t need attention,
quite as heavy or cumbersome as the e-tron. so servicing won’t be too
Despite this sportier side, comfort is more of different to a regular XC90
a priority, while efficiency also plays a big part in or Q7. Insurance will be
what a plug-in hybrid should deliver. At £66,055 similar, too; they’ll be
– a premium price tag by any standard – so does costly to run as a result.
L4
equipment, and the Volvo scores well.
You get a nine-inch touchscreen sat-nav,
climate control in all three rows, keyless entry PRACTICALITY
and go, adaptive cruise with semi-autonomous score Even in seven-seat form the
driving for motorways, heated leather seats and
safety tech, including Volvo’s City Safety system
4.3 Volvo offers a useful 397
litres of boot space. If you
with autonomous braking. Oncoming Lane intend to tow, you can pull
Mitigation helps you swerve to avoid a head-on up to 2,400kg, although the
crash and there’s a device that prepares the car Q7’s 3,500kg limit (the same
for an impact if it senses you straying off road. as the diesel’s) trumps this.
The XC90 set the template for Volvo’s
current-era cabin design, and while everything
is nicely integrated and the ergonomics are VERSATILITY The T8
good, material quality isn’t quite as classy Twin Engine’s battery pack
as in the Audi. Still, it’s really not far behind. is mounted in the spine
of the chassis, unlike the
Q7’s, which sits underneath
the boot floor. This means
VERDICT ★★★★★ the car doesn’t lose the
standard XC90’s third row
THE XC90 T8 has fewer drawbacks and of seats, giving it an edge
delivers far better economy. It’s not as over the Audi when it
comfortable as the Q7 and trails in terms comes to usability. It’s easy
of quality inside, but it’s as good to drive, enough to get into the
even more practical and will be much back, because the two
cheaper to buy and run. It’s a hybrid that outer seats in the middle
doesn’t demand much compromise. row slide and fold forwards
for respectable access.
Transmission Materials
Eight-speed box is smooth in auto Lots of leather and metal give a
mode, picking the right ratio, but it premium feel to the XC90; it’s just
trails the Q7 for response as a manual not quite as classy as the Audi’s cabin
Running costs
57.6mpg
£61 fill-up/£440 or 9% tax
score
4.1
4L INTERIOR &
TECHNOLOGY
XC90’s cabin is more versatile, but it’s
not quite as nicely crafted here. While
material quality is good, it lacks the
Q7’s air of luxury. There’s lots of leather
and metal details, and plenty of tech.
THROUGH
THE RANGE
Which trim level suits you?
4L
and adds a 12.3-inch dash display,
sports seats and 20-inch alloys, but
Practicality
Boot (7/5/2 seats)
OWNERSHIP score
these do affect the ride quality.
The top-of-the-range Inscription
397/775/1,951 litres Both cars have a three-
year/60,000-mile overall
4.3 version we’ve tested here will cost
£804 per month and features all of
!
warranty, while the battery the equipment we’ve previously
packs are also covered for eight listed, highlighting it’s still good
years or 100,000 miles. Audi claims value compared with the Q7.
a 10 to 30 per cent decrease in battery However, the much cheaper
Braking capacity over this period is normal. Momentum model is the one
70-0/60-0/30-0mph to go for at this price.
45.3/31.6/10.7m
SAFETY XC90 has more standard
safety kit, and you can add blind spot Our choice:
monitoring, cross traffic alert and XC90 T8 Momentum
AEB that works in reverse for £500. NEXT CAR
4L
LIKE any plug-in hybrid worth its asking DRIVING
price, the Q7 e-tron’s greatest trick is
score Q7’s blend of performance
making what is an incredibly complex and 4.0 and refinement is good, but
detailed engineering set-up simple to use. the battery is depleted too
Under the bonnet there’s a 3.0-litre V6 TDI quickly; we didn’t get the
engine driving an eight-speed automatic claimed 34-mile EV range. It
transmission that sends power to all four manages the switch between
wheels as part of Audi’s famous quattro package. power sources well, though.
Integrated into this transmission is an electric
motor that can drive the gearbox with the
engine off for all-electric running, while a MODES e-tron has a
clutch separates it, so the combustion engine Hybrid auto mode, which
can power the car exclusively if needed, too. manages the powertrain,
This all sounds very complicated, because it an EV mode and a Hybrid
is, but what you need to know is, with a fully hold mode. This reserves
charged battery, there’s a total of 369bhp and battery charge for when
600Nm of torque. This meant at our test track it’s needed most, such as
the Q7 sprinted from 0-60mph in a swift 6.4 in a low-emissions zone.
4L
seconds, despite its significant 2,445kg bulk,
which is partly due to its lithium-ion battery.
The big benefit is the 126bhp electric motor’s RUNNING
significant 350Nm of torque, which is 10Nm score COSTS
more than you get from an Audi A3 2.0 TDI
and is available instantly, filling in for the
3.8 Both models are in the lowest
nine per cent Benefit-in-Kind
diesel unit while it gets into its stride. (BiK) business tax bracket;
However, even with the combustion higher-rate taxpayers shell
engine off, there’s still plenty of performance. out £2,430 per year to run the
Audi claims the e-tron will hit 83mph in Q7. XC90 buyers pay £2,376.
electric mode, which we can vouch for, and
acceleration around town is brisk enough,
with only a faint whine from the motor. ECONOMY Heavier
On the road the e-tron is smooth and hushed, Audi also wasn’t as
cruising serenely in comfort due to the smooth economical on test. The
damping from the optional air suspension set- Q7 returned 47.2mpg
up – fitted as part of the Tour Pack Advanced compared with the XC90’s
or as a £2,000 standalone extra – which soaks 57.6mpg. As a result you’ll
up most imperfections a road can throw at it. pay £284 more per year
That weight means it’s not the most dynamic in fuel, at £1,433 in total.
4L
vehicle, but the Audi still steers sweetly and in
the sportier driving modes can be hustled along
at a respectable pace. Yet that’s not in keeping PRACTICALITY
with the hybrid ethos, so you’re better revelling score Q7’s battery means you lose
in the Q7’s comfort and cosseting refinement.
Standard kit on the e-tron includes LED
3.8 third-row seats. In five-seat
mode the 650-litre boot is
headlights, three-zone climate control and a still smaller than the XC90’s
sat-nav with connected services. A 12.3-inch 775 litres. This remains with
digital dial pack, keyless entry and go, cruise all seats folded, as Audi offers
control, DAB, leather trim, Bluetooth, Android 1,835 litres to Volvo’s 1,951.
Auto and Apple CarPlay also feature.
The drawback is the battery pack is under
the boot floor, which means, unlike the standard CHARGING The Q7’s
seven-seat Q7, the e-tron only has room for five. 17.3kWh lithium-ion
The XC90 T8 is a full seven-seater, however. battery takes eight hours
to fully charge using a
three-pin socket; this
drops to two and a half
VERDICT ★★★★★ hours with a wallbox and
will cost around £2.15 to
THE Q7 e-tron isn’t as versatile as the charge at home. The Volvo
XC90 T8. It’s smooth, refined and has a uses a smaller 10.4kWh
great mix of pace and comfort, but trails battery and will be around
the Volvo on efficiency, which counts 85p cheaper to charge.
double for a car of this type. It’s more A three-pin socket will
expensive and does without a third row recharge its battery in
of seats, even if it has a high-quality cabin. four hours; a wallbox
charge takes three hours.
Transmission Materials
Eight-speed auto box has an Fit and finish is superb in the
electric motor built in, which Q7, making for a comfy cabin.
allows for all-electric running Equipment is also generous
Running costs
47.2 mpg
£93 fill-up/£440 or 9% tax
score
4.3
4L INTERIOR &
TECHNOLOGY
The Q7’s cabin is reserved, but quality,
ergonomics and tech are first rate. You
get an 8.3-inch infotainment set-up and
the 12.3-inch Virtual Cockpit gives info on
how the hybrid is deploying its energy.
THROUGH
THE RANGE
What options are available?
4L
deposit contribution from Audi.
There are a number of extras
Practicality
Boot (7/5/2 seats)
OWNERSHIP score
you can specify, including the Tour
Pack to boost safety levels, which
N/A/650/1,835 litres Audi finished 11 places 4.1 will add peace of mind if this will
behind Volvo in our be a family vehicle. There are also
!
Driver Power 2017 makers’ adaptive dampers (£2,000) to
survey, in 18th place. Yet the Q7 further improve the ride, while
is a high-quality car and the e-tron the £995 Entertainment Mobile
tech has been thoroughly developed. adds two 10.1-inch touchscreens
Braking in the rear. You can team this
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
with a £1,100 digital TV set-up.
44.8/32.9/7.9m
SAFETY Q7 gets AEB
with pedestrian detection.
You can upgrade safety with Our choice:
£1,695 Tour Pack, which includes Q7 3.0 TDI quattro e-tron
adaptive cruise and lane assist.
Nissan Micra
FINAL REPORT Our time with supermini has shown how quickly the class moves on
Lawrence Allan when the Micra joined our fleet in its grown-up road manners and solid, grate after a long day in the office. A
Lawrence_Allan@dennis.co.uk April, I settled into it with a real respect attractively designed interior. But problem with the gearbox alignment
@LobAllan
for how far Nissan’s supermini had as 2017 rolled on, new superminis also made third tricky to select for a few
APART from the tech industry, the come over the years. The design also including the Ford Fiesta and SEAT Ibiza weeks, although after Nissan took it in
automotive sector has to be one of struck a chord with friends and family, arrived; and thanks to those cars the for a fix, changing cogs proved a much
the fastest-moving product markets who more often than not commented Micra has dropped down the rankings. sweeter experience. Given the stop-
around. As we often find at Auto Express, on the styling or overt colour scheme. Driving the excellent Ford and start traffic around our office in central
a brand new car can be up among the Yet by the time of the Micra’s first SEAT back to back with my Micra London and how hard the Micra needs
class leaders at the start of the year, yet group test a few weeks later, the initial really illustrated the Nissan’s flaws: to be worked, a final economy figure
will be merely an also-ran by Christmas. shine was clearly starting to wear off. namely its tight, claustrophobic of just over 43mpg is pretty good, too.
Our Nissan Micra, unfortunately, is The supermini faced the ever-popular rear seats, dated infotainment It’s a pity the engine didn’t deliver,
one of those cars. It made a splash at the Volkswagen Polo and the funky new and disappointing performance. because despite newer rivals showing
2016 Paris Motor Show, taking over from Citroen C3 in the shoot-out, and finished The latter has been my biggest gripe. it up, I’ve enjoyed the Micra’s overall
its woefully dated predecessor with a close, but disappointing, third. The Renault-sourced 0.9-litre turbo blend of ride comfort and handling.
a sharp new look. And when we first Its appeal hadn’t diminished as much petrol engine offers decent pace once My commute takes in motorways and
drove it in early 2017 it impressed. Then in my eyes, though; I was still enjoying higher in the rev band, but a lack of country roads, where its high-speed
torque means it feels a bit wheezy refinement and accurate steering
“Driving the Micra back to back with next to other turbo superminis. made the daily grind less of a chore.
It doesn’t excel around town, Other, more minor gripes have
rivals has highlighted some of its flaws” either, where its boosty nature and come from rear-seat passengers,
inconsistent throttle response could particularly those who are as tall as
Performance Small-capacity 898cc turbo petrol means Micra struggles to keep pace, but the handling is sprightly
Sa
Sam Naylor Senior reviewer
Calls to 03 numbers will be charged at your standard local rate. Gifts are limited to first 200 orders. Please allow 28 days for delivery. UK only. This offer is limited to one per household. Alternative gift may be supplied.
OUR CARS
Essentials
Otis Clay
Mercedes-AMG E 63 S
4MATIC+ Estate
On fleet since: December 2017
Price new: £91,290
Engine: 4.0-litre twin-
turbo V8, 604bhp
CO2/tax: 214g/km/£450
Options: Designo metallic paint
(£895), Premium package (£2,595),
Driving Assistance Plus package (£1,695),
ceramic composite brakes (£6,995),
AMG Night package (£795), AMG
performance exhaust (£1,000),
20-inch alloy wheels (£1,295)
Insurance*: Group: 47 Quote: £1,798
Mileage/mpg: 6,250/23.4mpg
Any problems? None so far
*Insurance quote from AA (0800 107 0680) for a
42-year-old in Banbury, Oxon, with three points.
Mercedes-AMG E 63 S
FIRST REPORT One of the world’s fastest family cars joins our fleet
John McIlroy Performance Running costs
John_McIlroy@dennis.co.uk 0-62mph/top speed 23.4mpg (on test)
@johnmcilroy 3.4 seconds/186mph £80 fill-up
IT seems odd to say it, but in this up 604bhp and a walloping 850Nm of you quite a lot of play before it scoops
era of environmental concerns and torque between 2,500rpm and 4,500rpm. you up and reins things back in.
financial instability, one of the biggest Add a nine-speed automatic gearbox This is especially evident in
success stories in the car industry is and four-wheel drive, and you have anything other than Comfort mode, WE LIKE There aren’t many
AMG. The brand has been enjoying the recipe for a two-tonne estate to because the more focused settings estates out there that are faster
record sales, thanks to an expanding go from 0-62mph in just 3.4 seconds. ramp up the gearshifts and firm than the E 63 S. Performance is
line-up that includes everything from The top speed is ‘limited’ to 186mph up the car’s standard air suspension, stunning thanks to four-wheel-
hot hatches (A 45 AMG) to sports cars because the E 63 S also gets the AMG giving it a more capable, but drive traction and a 604bhp
(AMG GT). It also has a hypercar on the Driver’s package as standard. slightly less tolerant character. V8 engine under the bonnet
way in the shape of the Project One. It is supercar fast. Such is the Cold winter mornings have also
AMG is known for its V8s, though; level of performance, in fact, that exposed the fact that the car’s high-
and even when faced with demands each E 63 S comes with a free driver performance Michelin rubber isn’t
for greater fuel efficiency, the firm’s training session at Mercedes’ at its best until it has warmed up;
engine wizards have found ways of impressive ‘experience’ and dealer that’s another reason why learning
keeping the legendary layout relevant. facility at Brooklands in Surrey. how to cope with slip, in controlled
And now we’re planning to see how When we arrived for our photoshoot, conditions on the track, is a good idea.
this science works out in everyday life, staff were preparing for half a dozen It’ll be interesting to see how the
because we’ve just taken delivery of an new AMG owners to get a briefing Mercedes-AMG E 63 S behaves in
E 63 S Estate for the next six months. and then some useful instruction. clogged-up traffic on my commute;
Under the bonnet lies AMG’s latest It makes perfect sense to us, because but we’ll also try to get a bit of track
twin-turbocharged 4.0-litre V8, a motor our early experience of the car is that time, or even do a cross-continent WE DON’T Adaptive dampers
closely linked to that in the AMG GT. it is shatteringly rapid; and that, even journey, amid the everyday humdrum. let you choose how stiff you want
In our ‘S’ version the engine serves with four-wheel drive, it will allow This car deserves nothing less. the suspension. Even in Comfort
mode the E 63 S’ ride is too hard,
partly due to 20-inch wheels
Verdict
OUR first few hundred miles in the
Mercedes-AMG E 63 S have been
all about the performance. The
4.0-litre V8 is characterful and
delivers stunning acceleration,
with a bellow to match from the
sports exhaust. The next six
Infotainment Controller gives you months are sure to go by fast.
access to COMAND infotainment on
Mercedes’ 12.3-inch central display ★★★★★
www.autoexpress.co.uk 55 31 January 2018
Living with a 3008 OUR CARS
Fleetwatch
Hot stuff
Ability to heat up the
cabin is great, and another
MINI joined ours at charge bay
MINI Countryman
SPECIAL contributor Tom Barnard was reminded of one of
the MINI Countryman PHEV’s most endearing features – its
preheating – during the recent cold weather. You can use the
Peugeot 3008 on-board computer to set a departure time, and the car will be
toasty inside as your neighbours work with their ice scrapers.
Warming the MINI while you’re plugged into the mains
electricity also means you’re not eating up the battery power,
saving it for propulsion rather than heating. But it only really
Update It’s time for our crossover’s first service works if you leave at the same time every day. If you need to
make a quick unplanned getaway the PHEV takes an age to
defrost and the battery-only range plummets. On a few frosty
Pete Gibson
Pete_Gibson@dennis.co.uk
Essentials mornings we’ve actually found the doors have been frozen shut!
The Countryman’s fuel savings have received a warm
welcome, though: it’s been doing fewer long trips recently,
OUR Peugeot 3008 does more miles Peugeot 3008 1.6 BlueHDi which has massively improved economy. We’re seeing over
than most cars on the fleet, because 120 S&S GTLine 70mpg thanks to the electric-only mode used on shorter hops.
I drive it all over the country to and from On fleet since: April 2017
our road tests, as well as in and out of Price new: £28,295
London to the Auto Express office. Engine: 1.6-litre 4cyl diesel, 118bhp
Ourfleet
INDEX
So while many models leave us before CO2/tax: 104g/km/£140
they need servicing, the 3008 has already Mileage/mpg: 17,508/56.5mpg
been in for its 16,000-mile maintenance.
I went to my local dealer, Robins & Day in Check-up Dash Audi RS3
Chelmsford, Essex, with the mileage reading flagged up service Issue 1,507
16,343, although an icon on the i-Cockpit indicator, while Citroen C3
display had been reminding me to take dealer was great Issues 1,483, 1,497, 1,504
it in for a little while before that. Ford Fiesta
Issue 1,508
I booked the car in a week in advance,
which was too short notice for a courtesy
car to be available. So instead of leaving the
Audi RS3 Honda Civic
Issues 1,485, 1,500
Land Rover Discovery
3008 there, I opted to go for an early drop-off THE regret knows no bounds in the Issue 1,506
and waited until everything was finished. seconds after you’ve just skimmed Mazda CX-5
That turned out to be a fine choice, because the rim of an otherwise immaculate Issue 1,503
the free WiFi and coffee in the waiting area alloy wheel – as special contributor Mercedes-AMGE63S
meant I could get on with some photo editing Steve Sutcliffe recently found out. New arrival
in comfort while the work was carried out. Trying to avoid a pothole, our man MINICountrymanPHEV
I paid £247.62 for the service, including a accidentally scuffed our Audi RS3’s Issues 1,497, 1,503, 1,507
pollen filter change (£35.70). That seems like thanks to a free interior clean. The engine 19-inch front right alloy on a kerb Mitsubishi L200
acceptable value; the work was carried out seems to be freeing up with miles, and – although the damage wasn’t Issues1,452,1,461,1,482,1,504
quickly, and the staff were friendly and helpful. we’re now averaging 56.5mpg after the as bad as he’d initially feared. Nissan Micra
The tyres were checked, and I’m happy to service was carried out. That’s a big increase It looks as if someone has taken Issues 1,476, 1,494
report that the all-weather mud and snow over the 44.9mpg we were returning a few an industrial sander to the outer Peugeot 3008
rubber fitted to our GT Line 3008 is holding thousand miles ago. Lots of motorway trips edge of the mega hatch’s wheel, Issue 1,489, 1,506
up well. Plus, the car came back looking fresh, have no doubt helped improve this figure. and Steve is naturally gutted about Renault Grand Scenic
it. But luckily there are now loads Issue 1,508
★★★★★
Waiting room Comfortable space with What is your car like to own? Issues 1,488, 1,503
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driver-power
WiFi and free coffee allowed Pete to work
A
AUTOGLYM won our 2015 test of these
TINY CHARGERS GIVE treatments, but its product is now called the
Convertible Soft Top Clean & Protect Complete
Kit. It comprises a cleaner and a proofer that
NEW PRODUCT
Ring smart battery chargers Must I change all four tyres?
Prices: From £39.99 Contact: 0113 213 2000, www.ringautomotive.co.uk
Q MY garage says I need to change four tyres
on my xDrive BMW even though it is only
IS your battery struggling this winter? Ring may the fronts that need replacing. Staff say it is
have the answer with its new smart charger range. Smart to do with the 4WD system. Are they right?
Long gone are linear chargers the size of toasters; RSC704 is James Willis, E-mail
these new products work around twice as fast, but the mid-range
A
have the dimensions of a chunky smartphone. model in new ALL BMWs with xDrive and some other 4WD
There are three new models plus a monitor, line of smart models have this problem because the
and all the units are compatible with the kind of chargers. The system can’t cope with more than a 2mm
batteries found on today’s cars: lead acid, gel, 4A unit works difference in tread depth between front and
AGM (absorbent glass mat), EFB (enhanced with engines rear. Replace all four tyres then make sure
flooded battery) and calcium. They also work up to a capacity you swap front to back on the same side
with the increasing number of stop/start cars. of 2.0 litres after a few thousand miles to even up wear.
Kicking off the range is the £39.99 RSC701 1A
Smart Maintenance charger, designed to be put
on rarely used cars to keep the battery topped up.
Assessing driving ability
Next is the more versatile RS704 4A smart
charger, at £44.99. It’s a one-touch device to Q I’M aged over 70 and am still driving, but
switch between slow and fast charging, and its Charger my family is urging me to stop. I think my
electronics automatically adapt to battery type Entry-level driving is fine. Is there somewhere that
and size. It’s good for engines up to 2.0 litres. RSC701 model I can go to settle the argument?
Top of the range is the more powerful £59.99 kicks off the Terry Walker, E-mail
RSC706 6A Advanced Smart Battery Charger. This smart charger
A
has a cold weather mode, plus an eight-stage range and costs IAM RoadSmart runs Mature Driver Review
charging and reconditioning cycle. It can work £39.99. It can courses (£49, www.iamroadsmart.com)
with lithium batteries and up to 3.5-litre cars. be used to top which assess your driving. You do it in your
The £14.99 RSCBM monitor works with all up batteries on own car on roads near you and you can take
three of the new units and provides a handy rarely used cars a friend or relative along. A qualified expert
traffic light-style indication of battery level. will assess your driving and give advice on
any areas that may need improvement.
Locators
Road Angel Pure
CAMERA LO
We nam
name the devices – and apps –
Price: £249.99 (pre-orders taken now for March delivery)
y)
Subscription: £99 (one year)
Contact: 0330 123 9479, www.roadangelpure.co.uk PRODUC
PRODUCTGROUP TEST
Rating: ★★★★★
31|1|2018
31|1|2
BEST BUY THE new Pure is the
priciest locator here, but it more than Every week, we extensively test all the latest
justifies the cost. It has the biggest and car kit from tyres
tyre to trim cleaners.
best display and was the most accurate Log on to www.autoexpress.co.uk
www. to look
at spotting cameras. We like the way it through ourr hug
huge online test archive
shows the current limit and warns you if you exceed
eed
it. Camera alerts were accurate, and it impressedd by
ignoring cameras on the opposite side of the road. It can
recognise average speed cameras and work out your average, too. The Road Angel app
(iOS and Android) enabled us to change settings quickly and easily, and the built-in WiFi allows
over-the-air updates. While the subscription is pricey, you get real-time alerts from other users.
Radarbot
Available on: iOS, Android Price: Free (Pro £4.99)
Rating: ★★★★★
36th Hugo
YOUR VIEWS ON YOUR CARS PLACE
Griffiths
Got any car queries?
Hugo_Griffiths@dennis.co.uk
@AE_Consumer
A
BIG bills caused by the failure of small,
inexpensive parts do happen on occasion. In
this case, the labour associated with accessing
Toyota Prius Mk4 and stripping down the pump explains the
final bill. You could pay for an independent
inspection of the O-ring and pump, but there’s
no guarantee this would find in your favour.
YOU TELL US Big-selling hybrid is cheap to run, but trails on infotainment
GOOD NOT SO GOOD
Is cambelt a lifetime part?
2017 Results “IT is smooth to drive, “SAT-nav is hard to Q MY Skoda Citigo is due for its five-year
Prius Factfile both when accelerating
and cruising.”
programme and route
guidance is unclear.”
service, which Skoda UK says should include
a cambelt change. But I’ve read elsewhere
that this is a lifetime part. Should I change it?
Years: 2016 to present CO2: 70g/km “I regularly see 70mpg, “The rear is squashed Mike Lynn, E-mail
Fuel economy: 94.1mpg (Active) which is exceptional when the front seat is
A
Best options: Keyless go, heated seats, for a car of this size.” set up for a tall driver.” WE’D recommend following your dealer’s
blind spot warning, head-up display advice and changing the cambelt. Skoda’s
“I really like the “The infotainment fixed-price servicing deals mean this should
Used prices: From £17,000 cutting-edge styling.” system won’t connect cost £389. Although it’s a big bill, if the belt
to my new phone.” snaps you could have to fork out thousands
“Insurance, road tax, in repairs for a new engine. Any extended
OVERALL SCORE Bars show where model petrol and servicing “I don’t like the white warranty wouldn’t cover the repairs, either.
finished out of 75 vehicles costs are super-low.” dashboard plastic.”
89.76% in our 2017 new car survey.
The longer the bar the better
“The build quality “The central storage Sponsored by Warrantywise
inside is impressive.” bin only opens on
Engine and gearbox
75 1
the driver’s side.” Insight from the industry
“It has all the latest
Exterior safety tech, like “Base of the back
Interior and comfort
Q
radar cruise control.” seats is too firm.” I HAVE had to replace my battery twice in
Practicality and space the past six months. On both occasions the
Ride and handling “Our dog loves looking “To me, it has less car was slow to start before totally failing.
out of the lower-glazed interior storage Could I have bought a faulty battery, or is
Safety features portion of the boot.” than the old Prius.” there a more serious underlying problem?
MPG and running costs
Reliability and build quality
A
IT is far more likely you have a problem
Have your say: What with your alternator. Take your car to the
Infotainment, connectivity is your car like to own?
and electrics garage, explain the issue and ask staff to
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driver-power
investigate. A battery should last for four
or five years before needing replacement.
BUYER’SGUIDE: Mercedes E-
FROM £7,000 Heavy depreciation makes previous executive model a strong choice as
Richard Dredge estate in January 2010, with the same parking sensors front and rear, trims, superb build quality, strong image
EVER since Mercedes started engines as the saloon. A cabriolet model Bluetooth, heated front seats and relatively high purchase prices.
making cars, it has been a pioneer. was launched in March 2010. and climate control, as well as a
With a focus on build quality, luxury The E300 Bluetec hybrid was unveiled multifunction steering wheel, artificial Verdict
and performance, the brand’s values are in November 2012, four months ahead leather trim and 16-inch alloy wheels. EXEC cars are costly to buy new and tend
typified by the E-Class executive saloon of a facelifted E-Class with significantly Avantgarde specification adds to be dear to run, so often depreciate at
and estate, first seen in 1985 when the revised exterior styling, extra equipment 17-inch wheels, real leather and a greater rate than smaller alternatives.
now-classic W124 was launched. – including lots of new driver assistance bi-xenon headlights. The Sport has The E-Class is no exception, which is
Since then the bar has been raised tech and a DAB radio – cleaner engines 18-inch wheels, a styling kit, quicker why it’s so easy to recommend second-
ever further, with more technology, and SE or AMG Sport trims in place of steering and upgraded front brakes. hand: it can represent tremendous value
safety and comfort features crammed the previous SE, Avantgarde and Sport. and it’s one of the most desirable
into each successive generation. An all-new, fifth-generation E-Class Alternatives family cars available at any price.
The fourth take on the E-Class came range was introduced in 2016. IF you’re buying an estate, the Volvo Yet electronics problems can crop up
in 2009 and it was more accomplished V70 offers lots of space for relatively and can be tricky to fix, so before buying
than ever, with a great range of petrol Which one? little cash, combined with decent build make sure everything works correctly.
and diesel engines. Later there was the IF you buy a rare manual E-Class, you’ll quality and excellent safety. However, Also pin down exactly what options
E300 Bluetec diesel-electric hybrid, too. struggle to sell it on. It’s the same with running costs tend to be high. are fitted, because some cars are much
petrol cars, apart from AMG V8s, but as The Jaguar XF secured an impressive more highly specified than others, with
History buyers desert diesel, this might change. third-place finish in our Driver Power items such as upgraded multimedia,
THE Mk4 E-Class arrived in saloon and Each trim level has a different chassis 2017 used car satisfaction survey, posher trim and a panoramic roof all
coupé forms in June 2009. There were set-up. The SE majors on comfort, the and comes in saloon or estate adding to the Mercedes’ desirability.
E200, E250, E350 and E500 CGI petrol Sport is stiffer, but the best balance is forms, so it’s a fine all-rounder. Be careful when buying, because
saloons, and E200, E220, E250 and offered by the high-spec Avantgarde. Yet it’s the BMW 5 Series and Audi A6 abused cars aren’t uncommon. Prices
E350 CDI diesels. The 525bhp E63 AMG All E-Classes are well equipped as that are the Mercedes’ closest rivals, also vary, but if you can travel for the
arrived in August 2009 and a spacious standard; the entry-level SE comes with offering a wide range of engines and right model, you might bag a bargain.
-Class
ALL facelifted Cabin space is generous for five, and the estate has a seven-
automatics have seat option. Boot capacity is great at 540 litres for the saloon EXPECT to pay at least £7,000 for a Mk4 E-Class. This
seven speeds; and a class-leading 1,950 litres for the estate. The dash may nets an early E220 CDI with around 150,000 miles; an
before this, look button-heavy, but some people will find that easier to use. equivalent E350 CDI costs an extra £1,000. Cap the
four-cylinder mileage at 70,000 and you can buy a 2009 E220 CDI
auto E-Classes
Tom Wood
saloon for £9,000, or an estate for £10,000.
got five speeds.
Virtually all available cars are automatic diesels. A
few petrol E-Classes have four or six-cylinder engines,
but most are V8s, especially the AMGs, which are
priced from £18,000 for a 100,000-mile example.
There’s a reasonable number of hybrids to choose
from; E300s start at £13,000 for a 100,000-mile car.
Running costs
Fuel CO2 Annual
economy emissions road tax
Insurance group
Model
E200 petrol 32-36 39mpg 165-172g/km £190-£220
E350 petrol 40-43 32-41mpg 161-205g/km £190-£305
E200 diesel 29 54-55mpg 143-145g/km £135-£150
E220 diesel 32-38 53-56mpg 116-144g/km £30-£135
E250 diesel 37-43 53-56mpg 128-144g/km £115-£150
E350 diesel 40-43 40-47mpg 154-186g/km £190-£280
Partwatch
2017 used car satisfaction survey shows
Expert’s how talented the E-Class is, and first for
safety is no surprise. It achieved top 10
verdict rankings virtually all the way across the Dealer price Independent price
poll, scoring impressively in every area
from trade insider Part
aside from a surprisingly low 11th for
Quentin Willson practicality, plus 45th for running costs.
Front brake pads (axle set) £71.99 £43.99
Front brake discs (pair) £140 £103.98
Door mirror glass (electric) £81.60 £8.99
THE E-Class combines lots of practicality YOUR VIEW Front wiper set £40 £29.49
with a high-quality interior, equipped CALLUM Rainsford, from Bridgnorth,
Prices for a 2013 E220 CDI. Dealer prices supplied by Mercedes-
with plenty of technology. It may be Shropshire, owns an E250 CDI. “It’s an Benz Cheltenham, Glos (mercedes-benzofgloucester.co.uk).
built for comfort rather than outright impressive car with comfort, space and Independent prices from Euro Car Parts (www.eurocarparts.com).
driving pleasure, but if you’re in the efficiency, and feels like it’ll last forever,” *Price from www.carwingmirrors.co.uk.
market for an executive saloon, the he told us. “High-speed refinement is
Mercedes is well worth considering. excellent and so is boot space. While the
running costs are high and there’s been
Recalls
Common faults a recurring electrical fault, I still love it.” SIXTEEN recalls so far is hardly cause for celebration.
ELECTRICS pose the biggest area of The first came in October 2010 for possible leaks from
concern with the E-Class, and repair the power-steering system. The most recent was in
bills typically range from £500-£1,000.
Contacts March 2017 due to potential electrical short circuits.
Official
Warranty price: £33 www.mercedes-benz.co.uk In between were campaigns for airbag and power-
Prices start from £33 per month with Warrantywise
steering failures, the engine stalling or failing, fuel
Forums
and oil leaks, the front seats working free and the
www.mercedesforum.com
www.benzworld.org self-levelling rear suspension not working properly.
Sponsored by www.mercedesclub.org.uk
31 January 2018 69
BUYING CARS Used triple test
Kia Optima Sportswagon Volkswagen Passat Estate Skoda Superb Estate Verdict
1 VW Passat
★★★★★
IT’S hard to look past the
value the Passat Estate
offers on the second-hand
market. It’s the most
expensive car new, but it’s
Sportswagon comes loaded with kit Top-quality interior sets Passat apart Superb is our reigning Best Estate Car easy to find as a high-mile
bargain in the classifieds.
Optima SW Passat Estate Superb Estate
2 ★★★★★
GT-Line S 1.7 CRDi SE Business 2.0 TDI SE L Exec 2.0 TDI Skoda Superb
Years: 2016 to date Engine: 1.7-litre 4cyl, 139bhp Years: 2015 to date Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 148bhp Years: 2015 to date Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 148bhp
Ins group: 20 Official econ/CO2: 61.4mpg/120g/km Ins group: 19 Official econ/CO2: 62.8mpg/119g/km Ins group: 19 Official econ/CO2: 60.1mpg/122g/km
Why? Sharp looks mean the Optima Sportswagon Why? VW is the high-quality choice here, and with Why? The most practical buy and also named best THE Superb Estate was
stands out in a rather conservative class. many available used, it’s the cheapest to buy, too. car to own in our Driver Power satisfaction poll. the overall winner when
we tested these cars new,
Prices from: £15,000 Prices from: £10,790 Prices from: £12,600 serving up Passat-like
THE Kia Optima Sportswagon is newer VOLKSWAGEN’S Passat Estate is the THE Passat’s closest relative is the capability for less. On
than both the Passat and Superb Estate, most expensive car to buy new out of Skoda Superb Estate. While the Czech the used market, this
so second-hand prices for the Korean this trio, but it’s a bit of a bargain on the model isn’t quite as polished in terms is no longer the case.
station wagon are still relatively high. used market, with lots of high-mileage of cabin quality and how it feels to drive,
Looks are a subjective matter, but it’s
arguably one of the most eye-catching
estates on sale today. Sadly, the rakish
examples advertised from low prices.
From behind the wheel, the Passat
is a strong all-rounder; its versatile
it is the most practical option of these
three, offering a large 660-litre boot.
It’s not as sharp as the Passat, but it
3 ★★★★★Kia Optima
design comes at a cost; the Optima characteristics make it better to drive is marginally more comfy with a more IT’S sharp-looking and well
Sportswagon only has a 552-litre boot. than the Optima and Superb. On paper, forgiving ride. According to owners, you equipped, but the Optima
Still, Kia customers are a happy bunch it’s the most economical choice, too. won’t find anything better on the road: it SW is still expensive on the
with the South Korean brand finishing The Passat came 32nd in our Driver was the overall winner in our Driver Power second-hand market. It’s
third in the manufacturers’ chart of our Power 2017 new car survey, with VW new car survey last year. And Skoda was also not as good to drive
Driver Power 2017 satisfaction survey. 14th in the manufacturer standings. the second best performing brand. as either VW Group car.
DAWN
RAID
Stunning Mount
Panorama track
promises close
racing for the
Bathurst event