An Overview: BRAC Enterprises & Investments
An Overview: BRAC Enterprises & Investments
An Overview: BRAC Enterprises & Investments
An Overview
What is Social Enterprise
A Social Enterprise is a business venture that aims
to achieve financial returns while fulfilling social,
environmental and/or other developmental goals. Social
enterprises can be non-profit, low-profit or for-profit
organisations as long as their social and environmental
missions are fulfilled. Typically, social enterprises serve
as a means to provide financial solvency to the low
income populations while ensuring that the social
obligations such as alleviation of poverty, illiteracy,
diseases, environmental impact etc. are met. That is why
social enterprises are considered alternative business
models with a double or triple bottom line, i.e. they have
the obligation to combine financial sustainability with
social and/or environmental missions.
Low Local
Social Enterprise
Income Suppliers
Social Enterprise
Untrapped
Market
Limited
Market Limited
Access Capacity
Greater Increased
Market Access Social Enterprise Income
BRAC Enterprises:
creating surplus with an alternative
mission
In 1978, BRAC’s flagship social enterprise, Aarong, was
created as a support mechanism to BRAC’s existing
sericulture programme. BRAC’s sericulture initiatives had
proven an effective way to engage poor, rural women
in productive income generating activity. However, the
livelihoods of these women could not be sustained on
a continual basis, unless the hand-spun silk they were
creating could be successfully marketed at a larger
scale. So Aarong was established as a retail distribution
outlet that offered a fair price to the rural suppliers while
introducing the products to urban markets where both
demand and consumers’ willingness to pay were the
highest. Today, Aarong has transformed into a high
surplus generating enterprise, operating as one of the
largest retailers in Bangladesh with 11 domestic outlets
while supporting over 65,000 Bangladeshi artisans
across more than 2000 villages – proving that an
enterprise can be profitable while maintain its social and
environmental commitments.
BRAC Enterprise
● Surplus generating
businesses
● provides greater
Programmes Support market access and
generates large scale
Enterprise
surplus
● Support Programme
● Increases BRAC’s
● Provides market
capacity to support
access and exit
the programmme and
mechanism to goods
enterprises
produced through
BRAC Programmes BRAC programmes
● Non-profit
● Aims to alleviate
poverty
Where is
THE RIGHT BALANCE
SUSTAINABLE
People
Planet Profit
Create inclusivity,
Create synergy access to
Generate Develop in conjunction financing, reduce
surplus Sustainable with donor dependency
Enterprises Development and hedge against
Create Interventions liquidity crisis
jobs/livelihood
• Microfinance
• Education
• Skills Training
Health Retail
BRAC
Livestock & Fisheries Green Enterprises
Enterprises
Agriculture & Food Printing & Packaging
50% of enterprise
surplus is
reinvestad and
cross-subsidizad
across the
Returns on investments enterprises
provide hedge against themselves
future liquidity crisis THE BRAC ADVANTAGE
Cross Collaboration:
BRAC enterprises maximise synergy, impact and value
by their targeted outreach and integrative products
and services across multiple enterprises. For example,
BRAC’s microfinance or Targeted Ultra Poor (TUP)
programme may allow a poor villager to own a cow and
produce/sell the milk. BRAC Feed Mills can offer the
nutrition required to tend for the cow while BRAC Dairy
can ensure that the villager can supply milk sustainably
and receive fair market price. Additionally, BRAC Artificial
Insemination Programme can step in to train the villager
to breed more cows and thus produce more milk and
cattle and move further ahead in the path to financial
solvency.
2
operations. a fair price for their
mills that produce
efforts.
balanced feed
+
takes out with the loan from a BRAC milk and for the
to BRAC
loan ‘feed seller’ meat milk
New
2
She breeds generation
the cow of cows
with hybrid produce more
cow semen milk and meat
= An
enterpreneur
takes artificial
insemination
He buys
hi-quality
bull semen
from
He sells
insemination
services
courses from
5
BRAC BRAC
Cross Subsidy:
Although BRAC enterprises aim for financial returns
while fulfilling the social and environmental missions,
not all enterprises are equally profitable. Aarong, for
example, is one of BRAC’s most profitable enterprises.
BRAC Sericulture on the other hand is running at or
below cost, creating low or no surplus. The cumulative
surplus from BRAC enterprises combined are used
to re-invest in the BRAC enterprises and support the
development programmes, on an as needed basis,
not on a pro-rata basis across enterprises. This allows
a highly beneficial cross-subsidy model where the
profitable enterprises are able to support the non/less
profitable enterprises. Moreover, closing of an enterprise
due to lack of profitability and subsequent job losses can
be prevented while the different social and environmental
missions across the enterprises continue to be fulfilled.
For example, in 2009, BRAC Dairy was faced with the
need to in order to remain a viable enterprise and had
considered mechanising some of its production lines.
But that would end up in considerable number of job
losses and close down of unprofitable milk-chilling
stations in ultra poor areas. So instead, BRAC invested
in 16 of these chilling stations and increased their
capacity by 5%-15%. Because of BRAC’s integrative
network support and operational model, such measures
were possible.
Continuous Innovation:
BRAC’s extensive network of enterprises with the
capacity to address major social needs allows BRAC to
continually identify needs and create innovative solution
to fulfill that need and create necessary market linkages.
For example, in response to the severe iodine deficiency
observed among the members of BRAC’s health
programmes and concurrent lack of hygienic iodised
salt in the market, BRAC created a salt enterprise,
BRAC Salt, in order to help fulfill the need for iodised salt
throughout the country. In the subsequent years though,
primarily due to increased number of new entrants to
the market, BRAC Salt started to lag behind in terms
of creating surplus, and termination of the enterprise
became a possibility. Instead, BRAC focused on an
innovative way to utilise its surplus salt production by
producing a salt-based, high-nutrient cattle feed called
Minamix. This product innovation not only proved
financially profitable but also allowed BRAC to retain its
employees and entrepreneurs and redirect their skills
and resources toward a sustainable enterprise.
Holistic Support:
Because of its integrated network and unique model,
BRAC has the advantage, ability and capacity to
provide holistic support and truly take care of its
stakeholders, i.e. the entrepreneurs involved with the
BRAC enterprises. For example, in 2011 due to market
infeasibility, BRAC was compelled to shut down its
Sanitary Napkin and Delivery Kit operations in Chinmari,
an area that comprised of ultra poor members with very
little or no entrepreneurial skills. Instead of terminating
these people and leaving them in abject poverty, or
providing them with cash severance that they had no
knowledge of how to invest or protect, BRAC enrolled
these people under BRAC’s Targeted Ultra Poor (TUP)
programme. Under TUP, each of these people were
given Taka 10,000 worth of assets such as cows
and chicken, were provided education, training and
resources to take care of their animals and were even
provided training under BRAC’s artificial insemination
programme. As a result, each of these BRAC members
was given the opportunity to remain on track for financial
solvency and increase their capital and skills in the
process, instead of getting lost in abject poverty and
unemployment.
BRAC Enterprises at a glance:
BRAC
Enterprises
Sanitary Napkin
Aarong Poultry Rearing Cold Storage Sericulture Printers
And Delivery Kit
(1978) (1978) (1980) (1978) (1977)
(1999)
Recycled
Dairy
Handmade Paper
(1998)
(2000)
Biogas (Pilot)
Feed Mills
(2009)
(1999)
Artificial
Insemination
(2000)
Chicken
(2001)
Are Social Enterprises same as
non-profits?
No. Social enterprises can be non-profit, low-profit or
for-profit organisations as long as their underlying social
and environmental missions are fulfilled and as long as
the social/environmental goals are just as instrumental (if
not more) for the business as its financial goals.
Are BRAC Enterprises non-
profit?
No. BRAC is a non-government organisation (NGO)
that runs Development Programmes, Enterprises
and Investment programmes. BRAC Development
Programmes are purely non-profit and run with
BRAC’s internal funds or external donor funds. BRAC
Enterprises are all incepted as interventions in order
address an existing social need and are dedicated
toward alleviation of poverty; however, they are run as
businesses with profit maximising potential. Some of
the enterprises are run at/below cost, such as BRAC
Sericulture, whereas other enterprises such as Aarong
have evolved into highly surplus generating ventures by
fulfilling greater urban market needs. However, BRAC,
the NGO, does not distribute any part of the profit to
any shareholders. Instead, BRAC aims to serve its
stakeholders, i.e. the targeted low-income population,
and therefore, reinvests 50% of the financial profits
from BRAC’s enterprises in the non-profit development
programmes such as education and healthcare. The
remaining 50% of the enterprise profits are reinvested
in the BRAC enterprises themselves on an as-needed
basis. The profitability of a commercially successful
enterprise therefore cross-subsidises the less or not
profitable enterprises. BRAC Investments consist
of surplus generating, strategic investments seeking
financial returns while fulfilling underlying social/
philanthropic missions. For example, BRAC Bank
operates as a conventional bank but provides loans to
small and medium enterprises, BRAC-Delta Housing
Finance Corporation provides financing for low-income
housing.
Are BRAC Enterprises Social
Enterprises?
BRAC can be best described as a surplus generating
social entrepreneur that combines surplus with
sustainability in order to alleviate poverty. Through
each of its enterprises, BRAC aims to fulfill three
criteria, referred to as the “3Ps”: serving the people,
benefiting the planet and also making profit. All BRAC
enterprises are driven by social and/or environmental
causes with ultimate goal to alleviate poverty. However,
BRAC also strives to make its enterprises as financially
viable as possible without deviating from the respective
social missions and without depriving the low-income
entrepreneurs that the BRAC enterprises aim to serve.
Does BRAC make money off the
poor?
No. BRAC enterprises ensure that the local suppliers
(mostly poor villagers) receive skills, training and
resources, produce their products efficiently and sell
them in larger markets where demand and consumers’
willingness to pay are the greatest. As a result, these
fragmented suppliers become small entrepreneurs
and advance on their path to financial solvency
through BRAC’s enterprises. Through its retail outlets
and distribution channels, BRAC re-sells some of
the commercially viable products however, always
ensuring that the suppliers receive fair price and that the
underlying social cause has been served.
What is BRAC Enterprises’
bottom line?
Although all of the BRAC enterprises are committed
toward achieving financial, social and environmental
returns, BRAC takes a unique approach in defining its
triple bottom line by focusing on three ethoses: people,
profit and the planet (the “3Ps”). A BRAC enterprise
must meet three criteria in order to be considered a
successful and sustainable business:
● It must serve the needs of poor people
● It must be environmentally friendly, and
● It must make profit to help keep BRAC’s
development works sustainable
How can BRAC enterprises be
for-profit yet remain true to the
social/environmental missions?
Through its collaborative network of enterprises,
development programmes and investments, BRAC has
pioneered a unique model that advocates for business
sustainability as “doing well by doing good”. BRAC
Enterprises strive to strike the right balance between
financial profits and social returns in order to achieve
the targeted double/triple bottom lines. By operating
as a for-profit organisation that aims to alleviate poverty
through its business operations and supply chain, BRAC
succeeds in implementing its vision to serve the society
in a profitable manner.
What factors influence the
development plan and strategy
of a BRAC Enterprise?
BRAC takes a holistic approach in conceptualising and
developing each of its enterprises. As BRAC enterprises
have expanded from development programme support
mechanisms to profitable enterprises with financial
and social missions, each enterprise has ensured that
it complies with the four fundamental objectives of a
BRAC enterprise:
Why is it important to reduce
donor dependency?
Donor funds can be subject to limitations including
finite availability and even scarcity during global financial
crises and liquidity crunches. Moreover, reliance on
donor funds can sometimes restrict an organisation’s
ability to utilise the funds according to its original
missions and visions. BRAC captures the financial gains
from its profitable enterprises and reinvests the money,
and as a result currently finances 73% of its annual
expenditure across its enterprises and development
programmes, with only 27% coming from donor funds.
Why does BRAC continue
to exist and expand its
enterprises?
Although most of the BRAC enterprises were
initially developed to support BRAC’s development
programmes, majority of them currently operate as
surplus generating ventures while maintaining their
ongoing commitment toward alleviation of poverty
via empowerment of the poor. BRAC enterprises no
longer just serve the immediate purpose of creating
market access – they maximise and monetise market
opportunities, making significant contribution to local
economy through development of market linkages,
entrepreneurs and employment opportunities. The
current surplus generating model of BRAC’s enterprises
concurrently achieves scalability, greater outreach and
maximum impact. By targeting profitable and scalable
businesses, BRAC enterprises are able to fulfill their
social missions at a much greater scale while increasing
financial surplus that reduce the organisation’s donor
dependency and support BRAC’s developmental
programmes and other innovations at a greater level.
Upon ensuring fair price to local suppliers and fostering
entrepreneurship and employment at the grass root
level, BRAC enterprises focus on successful marketing
and distribution in the urban and rural markets and
generate the maximum surplus that consumer demand
would allow. In most cases, BRAC enterprises end
up creating new opportunities in an un-served/under-
served market, which creates space for new entrants
to the market and fosters healthy competition. That is
why BRAC enterprises continue to exist, expand and
innovate through across multiple sectors.
How does BRAC Enterprises
take care of its people?
In addition to ensuring fair market wage, healthy work
environment, reasonable working hours and increasing
awareness, BRAC . For example, in 2009, BRAC Dairy
was faced with the need to in order to remain a viable
enterprise and had considered mechanising some of
its production lines. But that would have ended up in
considerable number of job losses and close down of
unprofitable milk-chilling stations in ultra poor areas. So
instead, BRAC invested in 16 of these chilling stations
and increased their capacity by 5%-15%. On another
instance, due to market infeasibility when BRAC was
compelled to shut down its Sanitary Napkin and Delivery
Kit operations in an area with ultra poor members
with very little or no entrepreneurial skills, instead of
terminating these people and leaving them in abject
poverty, or providing them with cash severance that they
had no knowledge of how to invest or protect, BRAC
enrolled these people under BRAC’s Targeted Ultra Poor
(TUP) programme. Under TUP, each of these people
were given Taka 10,000 worth of assets such as cows
and chicken, were provided education, training and
resources to take care of their animals and were even
provided training under BRAC’s artificial insemination .
As a result, each of these BRAC members was given the
opportunity to remain on track for financial solvency and
increase their capital and skills in the process, instead of
getting lost in abject poverty and unemployment.
What are the primary challenges
of the “BRAC Model”?
As BRAC and its enterprises continue to grow and
expand their outreach of social and financial benefits,
the challenge remains to continue to maintain social
impact while generating surplus without drifting away
from BRAC’s mission and vision, i.e. to alleviate poverty
and benefit the people, the planet and create surplus in
the process that can help BRAC become self-sustaining
and continue to grow. Since BRAC is not a commercial
or profit-driven institution, the returns from BRAC’s
investments and enterprises aim to beget social as well
as financial returns. In nominal terms, these returns are
not at par with strictly commercial, profit-driven players
in the market.
What are the “next steps” for
BRAC enterprises?
The next step for BRAC enterprises is to continue
capturing new opportunities in existing and new
sectors that will further the mission and vision of BRAC.
Through continuous identification of new opportunities
and innovation of new products BRAC will continue to
create interventions that address social needs, fosters
social equality and justice and alleviates poverty. In that
light, the immediate next focus of BRAC enterprises
is toward environmentally sustainable sectors such
as carbon emissions, nursery, clean energy and clean
water. Concurrently, BRAC Investments is also focusing
its efforts toward creating financially sustainability
through impact investing, equity sponsorship of small to
medium sized companies, financing of innovative social
entrepreneurial ventures etc. which further enhances
the potential of new enterprise creation and sustainable
development.