ATC Case Solution
ATC Case Solution
ATC Case Solution
ACC, a larger provider of cable, high speed internet and VoIP was planning to add on new business to
their existing portfolio, and ATC was one such option. ATC is one of the largest regional wireless firms
and due to the potential synergies in the business they are in, ACC is considering to add them to their
business to provide bundled services to attract more customers. Once merged, it is believed that they
are likely to have an increased revenue and reduced expenses. ACC now needs to consider aspects of
valuation before they can make a final bid.
Questions
1. Find out the terminal value. How many inputs are required to estimate this terminal value and
how are the growth rates calculated? Mention all the assumptions
2. How can be estimate the assets that are non-operating? Approximate the value of non-
operating assets for the firm?
3. How can we find the tentative value of synergy, clearly state the estimation? How much
payment could be made for acquisition?
Solution:
1. Find out the terminal value. How many inputs are required to estimate this terminal value and
how are the growth rates calculated?
The absence of any comparable in the industry and unique nature of the firms, vouches for a
discounted cash flow approach. Also, we can infer that the capital structure of the firm keeps on
changing considerably for the years. This implies that we cannot use WACC, as it requires a
stable D&E structure. So, now to estimate the values for next 5 years, we will value the firm in 2
parts. First assuming it as fully unlevered (no debt) firm and then add on the benefits and costs
of Debt on to it.
Hence, the LBO valuation using APV method, adjusted present value valuation is used here.
Further analysis and calculations given in the excel.
Growth rate is given by, g = (Capital Expenditure + Change in Working Capital - Depreciation) /
(D+E)
All the calculations are included in the Excel
2. How many assets can be tagged as non-operating? Approximate the value of non-operating
assets for the firm?
We have Cash & cash equivalents, marketable securities, marketable equity securities and
investments in affiliate entity can be considered as Non- operating assets
The bid should be made after doing the valuation of the firm, including value of both operating
and non-operating assets. Calculations shown in Excel